Thi Hills Music Isn't this video inaccurate? Mariah has hit several higher notes in head voice also. Take her E6 from AIWFCIY remix high note for example.. She's also supported down to at least B2..
Cash Cow it's actually not, in the description it says it includes ALL of mariahs live lucky moments yet he didn't even include the clip of her supporting a B2
Honestly for her lower register G3 is when her voice really becomes audible lol. Eb3 sometimes it comes out but it's mostly breathy.D3s are not her strongest respectfully ofc.
@@whitneyhouston1122 It is not a well developed instrument anyway. I wouldn’t say that she has been a very solid belter. Inconsistent and fragile. Her head voice is weak.
These are pretty fun to watch! I'm glad you didn't include those awful lowered-larynx bits for her lower register. This was my first time seeing some of these clips. Actually, I thought her technique was generally unhealthy in the lower register, but these were pretty nice for her. Is it a mix of studio and live?
Señor Loco What's your opinion of her technique in the Music Box era please? See, I always thought MB was her strongest era vocally cause she finally mastered her technique (she was fantastic during Debut and Emotions but she had strain (minimal, but was there) in her upper belts around E5 and up.
Señor Loco I believe her Music box era technique was better. Daydream her breathe support wasnt very good and she had a lot of rhasp (hard to hear but you can hear it by the end of the era and in the studio) and daydreams mix was too heady. Music box had the power of emotions and debut but resonance of daydram
She has a G5 with vibrato (briefly) in Anytime you need a friend, when she sings "don't you EVER be lonely"! Where is all her whistle register?! She sings them with vibrato meaning that she supports them!
Frankie NS "Whistle register" is a disconnected vocal register and it is impossible for them to be resonant & since they aren't connected to the model register, they technically can't be supported either.
RyderC Daniels there's a lot of controversy about this because in opera they only sing well supported notes and there's a lot of parts in opera that requires whistles! Queen of the night (Dramatic Coloratura Soprano) being the most famous!!!
Well In Some Live Performances, Early On, Her Bb6, B6, C7, & C#7 Whistles Are Very Resonant & With Vibrato Yes... I Believe She Can Support Up There But It Is Taxing On The Lungs So She Doesn't Do it Any More...
@@ilovetati91those notes are pretty questionable tbh. there was a time on youtube when anyone believed a note to be supported just because some ppl say so lol
@@ilovetati91 her headvoice is always thin, squeezed, air-leaked, aspirate and hollow. she was never consistent with her headvoice (shed rather use falsetto) until in daydream era that she was consistent up to G#5.
Mariah will get 19 #1s That is true, however the creator of this video is only counting the "connected" supported registers which only include chest voice/mixed voice & head-voice. Disconnected registers like falsetto/whistle's are excluded because of that.
Yeah.. I was wondering about that too. Mariah's whistles are very stable and well supported. Her actual supported range is precisely 5 octaves (B2 - B7)
I think her supported range is definitely D3 to F6... Her lower notes than D3 may have Vibrato but I feel it's just a comfort thing with her... Easier when it's comfortable... But The E6 note for Mariah was a staple after 2004... That note kinda became supported over time. The F6 as well because despite what people say if it wasn't supported the 2nd high note after the bridge in IWTKWLI wasn't a whistle it was head voice... She has a high head voice... Higher than most assume... I think alot of the other notes passed either end are more comfortable and can be produced as easy as the supported ones...
Lam Do keyword: RARELY This video isn't about consistency, it's about her total supported range, just because she only did it on a few albums doesn't mean she didn't support F6
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN BUT I FEEL VOCALLY HER BEST ALBUM WAS TEOM... ONLY BECAUSE THE FACT THAT THE STIGMA OF HER LOSING HER VOICE WAS SO PREVALENT THAT THE PROOF WAS ON THE PUDDING... SHE EVEN DID THINGS VOCALLY THAT SHE DIDN'T DO IN ANY OTHER ALBUM...
Johnathan Yes TEOM was vocally beast. But she belted on Merry Christmas album with chest dominant mix and it's so hard for me. She mix properly on TEOM and it's amazing because she didn't do it during her prime and only started in Charmbracelet album. Both vocally demanding album tho 💕
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN She Did In Her Prime Just Wasn't Noticeable At The Time... Like In To Be Around You... It Was A Quick A5 Mixed Belt... But Yea I Personally Like The Stuff No One's Heard Or Rarely Gets Of Hers...
@@uditsahu4537 they don’t need to be pushed. There’s plenty of vocalists that can support up to B5 without pushing their head voice. Pushing IS straining.
@@mesmereizedwell there is pushing and PUSHING Bb5 is a demanding note depending on your voice type so ofc for mariah it requires more effort. the note is still crisp edit : i wss referring to the Bb5 in dreamlover my bad
It was, but it wasn't what was being showcased. It was referring to the higher of the three notes. Which was indeed an F by the way, but that's not important. Lol
Menawo Rigg On The Extended Version Of TGTBAW She Belts G#5 Supported Well... She Just Doesn't Do It Alot... And In The Song With Eric Benet, The Way I Believe It's Called, She Hits A Very Resonant G#5 In The Background... But Again She Just Doesn't Do It Alot...
7:35 That C6 is not supported at all. You could have also included her Rendition's G5 performance instead of the ones from Anytime you need a friend studio.
Kaley Q. F3: yes, that's one more try. D5: It's from one of her 2014 beacon theatre emotions performances. This note is flat though, I don't think Mariah ever actually sang that D5 (when she still sang it) perfectly even if it was supported occasionally. TECS D5s seem to be more in tune but those are all strained I think.
'Cause whistle register isn't connected to vocal chords, supported range only includes notes you can sing producing resonance and with full connection to the vocal chords. Fry, falsetto and whistle register aren't connected registers, so that's why I didn't include them here, even if they're supported.
Alchris John Balita in falsetto and whistle register, the vocal chords are in an open shape with the air fluttering over their edges. In chest and head voice, the folds "zip up," which is why, when used properly, they don't have airiness.
Edgar Cárdenas just curious then what would Christina's highest supported falsetto be??? I only count connected registers but I want to know why falsetto can't be supported???
No, her supported range at her BEST is D3-G5-Bb5. Her BEST consistent supported range is like E3/F3-F5/F#5-A5 (from late 1994 til mid-1996). Her Nowdays's supported range is only like F3-B4/C5-A5.
the 5th octave is the most beautiful for singing, the 6th is a whistle register so I can imagine how tiresome Mariah was to sings for many years on that range, a range where people could die trying to reach it.
Jhanna Augustina CP Jhanna Augustina CP No even in the studio Mariah's resonance and breath support is usually only present up to G5. For the most part, almost all of her studio G#5s & A5s are unsupported, chesty, & squeezed. She has one A5 that was hit with a neutral larynx though in her song called "The one". But for the most part she is mostly consistent up to G5.
Amit Agmon I don't think this video is of a consistent supported range. I think it's of the whole range of notes she supported. I can't recall a single C#3 or G#5 or Eb6 she sang perfectly.
Cassie Jones The supported Eb6 was a lucky moment since she literally strained in all Eb6 except these Also she has 1 supported B2 in You And I Also he forgotted a lot of notes Like Eb6 in Inseparable E6 in I Still Believe F6 in Angels Interlude
3 octaves of supported range, while some singers has 3 octaves of straining range.
Christina Strainulera XD
Strangulera
CaptianSkinder well I think she has a wide range maybe 4? but yeah she doesn't use it properly
Thi Hills Music Isn't this video inaccurate? Mariah has hit several higher notes in head voice also. Take her E6 from AIWFCIY remix high note for example.. She's also supported down to at least B2..
Christina and Ariana 😂❤️
Resonances. Lots of resonances!
Now THIS new video is very accurate for her supported range well done
Cash Cow it's actually not, in the description it says it includes ALL of mariahs live lucky moments yet he didn't even include the clip of her supporting a B2
lilsheep when did she support a B2?
Joel Parkinson on a live radio interview
lilsheep ohh that one, i don’t think that note was supported at all, to me if sounded like she had a super low larynx and it was breathy
Joel Parkinson it was supported
Most of her low notes in the YOU AND I performance is well supported, its just that she pushes down her larynx when she hits Bb2
Her Eb5 are so good !
Best Vocalist Ever
I love the Bb3s you added!
*Disconnected notes can definitely be supported...*
Great video btw!
By definition, disconnected notes can never be supported.
@@ingropetinal3915 Kindly explain support...
People use "disconnected" as a blanket statement for whistle register which isn't the case.
Supreme Songbird!
Honestly for her lower register G3 is when her voice really becomes audible lol. Eb3 sometimes it comes out but it's mostly breathy.D3s are not her strongest respectfully ofc.
I'd give her F3, that's when she starts being audible.
@@joemelcruz6556 Sometimes they are like breathy tho that means her larynx is low.
True. It is like whispering.
@@marieljackman1850 Yes, like I don't mean to be mean but her lower register was always her weakest part of her voice.
@@whitneyhouston1122
It is not a well developed instrument anyway. I wouldn’t say that she has been a very solid belter. Inconsistent and fragile.
Her head voice is weak.
These are pretty fun to watch! I'm glad you didn't include those awful lowered-larynx bits for her lower register. This was my first time seeing some of these clips. Actually, I thought her technique was generally unhealthy in the lower register, but these were pretty nice for her. Is it a mix of studio and live?
Out of curiosity, what do you think of prime Mariah's technique during the Daydream era?
chimanruler15 mostly flawless she always sang with a neutral larynx and amazing ease on high notes!
Señor Loco What's your opinion of her technique in the Music Box era please? See, I always thought MB was her strongest era vocally cause she finally mastered her technique (she was fantastic during Debut and Emotions but she had strain (minimal, but was there) in her upper belts around E5 and up.
Señor Loco I believe her Music box era technique was better. Daydream her breathe support wasnt very good and she had a lot of rhasp (hard to hear but you can hear it by the end of the era and in the studio) and daydreams mix was too heady. Music box had the power of emotions and debut but resonance of daydram
She has a G5 with vibrato (briefly) in Anytime you need a friend, when she sings "don't you EVER be lonely"! Where is all her whistle register?! She sings them with vibrato meaning that she supports them!
Frankie NS "Whistle register" is a disconnected vocal register and it is impossible for them to be resonant & since they aren't connected to the model register, they technically can't be supported either.
RyderC Daniels there's a lot of controversy about this because in opera they only sing well supported notes and there's a lot of parts in opera that requires whistles! Queen of the night (Dramatic Coloratura Soprano) being the most famous!!!
KevOnIt 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well In Some Live Performances, Early On, Her Bb6, B6, C7, & C#7 Whistles Are Very Resonant & With Vibrato Yes... I Believe She Can Support Up There But It Is Taxing On The Lungs So She Doesn't Do it Any More...
Whistle register is considered "incorrect" in the opera world. Stop.
5:34 sounded like Whitney
yeah she loves those sharp descending runs
I love how there's tons of recent vocals here
I just came upon your vids and am loving them! gained a new subscriber right here
Shes a beast wtf
did she ever support above G5 (mixed reg) in studio? i've seen some people mention that she had A5, i'm assuming if ever that would be in the studio
Avatarkyungsoo - yeah she did have very nice placed note up A5 with some tension Ofc in studio
I guess there are Bb5's in Triumphant... You can hear it in the climax... But it was auto-tuned (I guess)...
Therre are also A5's from My All - Stay a While remix, Fly Like A Bird and Circles... and a sharp A5 in Honey (So So Def Radio remix)...
+Alchris John Balita but, yeah... perhaps those aren't supported...
Avatarkyungsoo - yes an A5 in the one
D3-G5-D6 is her supported range at her best.
No, at her BEST live it's D3-G5-Bb5.
@@ingropetinal3915 she supported C6/C#6 live. I believe a D6 in an ISB performance as well
@@ilovetati91those notes are pretty questionable tbh. there was a time on youtube when anyone believed a note to be supported just because some ppl say so lol
@@whoevr those are not questionable at all.
@@ilovetati91 her headvoice is always thin, squeezed, air-leaked, aspirate and hollow. she was never consistent with her headvoice (shed rather use falsetto) until in daydream era that she was consistent up to G#5.
Mariah has supported Bb2's in the You And I performance in 2002.....
That's true!
No, sorry.
Hi Roos
Ross.White98 they are actually breathy and lack projection so no but her larynx might have been neutral but I'm not sure
Rashaad Perry isn't Emotions's C#3 in Daydream WT Tokyo Dome supported?
Beautiful F#5s! It’s like an angel singing her praise to God. Oh Mariah Carey. 😍😍😍
@2:54 that bb4 sounds higher than what it actually is omg her resonance is incredible
Never Forget You Bb3 at 2:24 or Bb4 at 2:44
Uncontained Chaos lol omg i meant @2:54
Never Forget You ok bcuz I was confused for second
Non-resonant =/= unsupported.
oTheGalacZo actually a note can be supported but not resonant
Xtina biggestfan that's what they're saying. Just because a note isn't resonant doesn't mean it's not supported lol
MikeJMCarey93 lol 😂
Disconnected=/=Unsupported.
Mariah will get 19 #1s That is true, however the creator of this video is only counting the "connected" supported registers which only include chest voice/mixed voice & head-voice. Disconnected registers like falsetto/whistle's are excluded because of that.
Yeah.. I was wondering about that too. Mariah's whistles are very stable and well supported. Her actual supported range is precisely 5 octaves (B2 - B7)
disconnected can't be supported but can be relax and has ease
mariah doesn't even support C3's, i think this video is very correct.
Rizki Pawitra really?! I didn’t know
Finally the vidoe is up again!!!! I used to go to thay Chinese website to watch it 😂
ouuu when was it taken down
i was wondering if i had ever watched it 😭 i probably have lol idk
@@whoevr Many years ago, I can't remember, before COVID lol 😂
I think her supported range is definitely D3 to F6... Her lower notes than D3 may have Vibrato but I feel it's just a comfort thing with her... Easier when it's comfortable... But The E6 note for Mariah was a staple after 2004... That note kinda became supported over time. The F6 as well because despite what people say if it wasn't supported the 2nd high note after the bridge in IWTKWLI wasn't a whistle it was head voice... She has a high head voice... Higher than most assume... I think alot of the other notes passed either end are more comfortable and can be produced as easy as the supported ones...
Johnathan in your dream Mariah support the F6. She rarely use head voice that high
Lam Do keyword: RARELY
This video isn't about consistency, it's about her total supported range, just because she only did it on a few albums doesn't mean she didn't support F6
*I think her best album vocally was her Merry Christmas album. She hitted some supported lows there below D3 tho so...*
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN YES THE B2 IN GOD REST YE MERRY GENTLEMEN... CLEAR EXAMPLE
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN BUT I FEEL VOCALLY HER BEST ALBUM WAS TEOM... ONLY BECAUSE THE FACT THAT THE STIGMA OF HER LOSING HER VOICE WAS SO PREVALENT THAT THE PROOF WAS ON THE PUDDING... SHE EVEN DID THINGS VOCALLY THAT SHE DIDN'T DO IN ANY OTHER ALBUM...
Johnathan Hi in that particular song her B2 there was supported? Thanks! :)
Johnathan Yes TEOM was vocally beast. But she belted on Merry Christmas album with chest dominant mix and it's so hard for me. She mix properly on TEOM and it's amazing because she didn't do it during her prime and only started in Charmbracelet album. Both vocally demanding album tho 💕
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN She Did In Her Prime Just Wasn't Noticeable At The Time... Like In To Be Around You... It Was A Quick A5 Mixed Belt... But Yea I Personally Like The Stuff No One's Heard Or Rarely Gets Of Hers...
my queen
The C#6 and D6 are def not supported. Those are falsetto/super head voice ... not head voice
I LOVE YOU❤
awww thank you!
Edgar Cárdenas OK 👍👍👍👍
Unpopular opinion her mixed notes above F5 aren’t supported, just relaxed at best
Also not sure how I feel about her head voice. The Eb5/E5 seems passable but the rest seems unsupported. Bb5 and up seems pushed
@@mesmereizedobviously they need to be pushed it not like she is struggling and straining
@@uditsahu4537 they don’t need to be pushed. There’s plenty of vocalists that can support up to B5 without pushing their head voice. Pushing IS straining.
@@mesmereizedIt’s an unpopular for a reason. She has proven to support many F#5s during her prime.
@@mesmereizedwell there is pushing and PUSHING
Bb5 is a demanding note depending on your voice type so ofc for mariah it requires more effort. the note is still crisp
edit : i wss referring to the Bb5 in dreamlover my bad
B4 & C5 have always been her best notes for me
lovin' that kpop in the intro
Could you make one for lara fabian please?
Since you included the anytime you need a friend studio G5s, the the one A5 and honey remix Bb5 are also supported
Supercharged Hi
Lichy Guevara oh hi
1:16 sounds like Db, three semitones lower than the E in the video
It was, but it wasn't what was being showcased. It was referring to the higher of the three notes. Which was indeed an F by the way, but that's not important. Lol
i love the big hit and nct intro 😂
I think she can do a supported G#5 in studio
Menawo Rigg Nope. The highest notes when belting that she has ever had support/resonance on live and in the studio is a G5.
Menawo Rigg On The Extended Version Of TGTBAW She Belts G#5 Supported Well... She Just Doesn't Do It Alot... And In The Song With Eric Benet, The Way I Believe It's Called, She Hits A Very Resonant G#5 In The Background... But Again She Just Doesn't Do It Alot...
7:35 That C6 is not supported at all.
You could have also included her Rendition's G5 performance instead of the ones from Anytime you need a friend studio.
what rendition
what’s “Rendition’s”
Pretty sure the E6 in I still believe is also supported
Is the recent F3 from her George Michael tribute? Also where is the recent supported D5 from 4:07?
Kaley Q. F3: yes, that's one more try.
D5: It's from one of her 2014 beacon theatre emotions performances. This note is flat though, I don't think Mariah ever actually sang that D5 (when she still sang it) perfectly even if it was supported occasionally. TECS D5s seem to be more in tune but those are all strained I think.
Hating this video for not including any supported belts from music box era, charmbracelet era, and #1 to infinity era.
She can support B2 i think
KevOnIt She has supported a few B2s in the You and I performance, those might have been Bb2s idk
Cool Guy Ikr
Cool Guy They weren't supported though. They had low larynx & were pretty breathy and lacked tonality
7:49 SONG PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
the art of letting go
Lol the intro is T7S i thought i went to the wrong video lol
In the description, you mentioned about a supported range video of Gaga. Where is it?
oooh I uploaded it but I forgot some notes so I'll re-upload it on Wednesday
I think Bb2 is supported too!
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Wait, ahm, why didn't you include her whistles? Lol I'm just confused...
'Cause whistle register isn't connected to vocal chords, supported range only includes notes you can sing producing resonance and with full connection to the vocal chords. Fry, falsetto and whistle register aren't connected registers, so that's why I didn't include them here, even if they're supported.
+Edgar Cárdenas Oh... thanks so much 😊 Ahm, if you don't mind, I'll also ask how whistles aren't connected to the vocal chords... Thank you so much!
Alchris John Balita how about mariah head voice at cant let go when she did at the emancipation of mimi era tour 2006
Alchris John Balita in falsetto and whistle register, the vocal chords are in an open shape with the air fluttering over their edges. In chest and head voice, the folds "zip up," which is why, when used properly, they don't have airiness.
Edgar Cárdenas just curious then what would Christina's highest supported falsetto be??? I only count connected registers but I want to know why falsetto can't be supported???
bb2 at dont forget about us clear
💋💋💋💋💋💋💋
some of those notes are not supported tbh but it’s ok !!
Everything you called ‘mixed register’ wasn’t mixed though, they were all belts (unless you consider her highest belts chesty mix bc of the tone)
7:45 song please
The Art of Letting Go
The second G5 is a F#5
kpoptastic no
kpoptastic no it's a G5 It kinda peaked G5 but it was still G5
What is the song at 5:40?
Hark The Herald Angels Sing, live in 1991!
where's dat intro from tho
One Dollar Bleach nct u 7th sense
Brandon Kadir hm? I don’t understand
One Dollar Bleach it’s the name of the song during the intro.
Brandon Kadir oh I meant the Mariah intro 😅
Her actual supported range is B2-A5(presuming all of the Bb5s are unsupported even though there are a couple that probably are supported)-F6.
No, her supported range at her BEST is D3-G5-Bb5.
Her BEST consistent supported range is like E3/F3-F5/F#5-A5 (from late 1994 til mid-1996).
Her Nowdays's supported range is only like F3-B4/C5-A5.
I hear NCT song
the 5th octave is the most beautiful for singing, the 6th is a whistle register so I can imagine how tiresome Mariah was to sings for many years on that range, a range where people could die trying to reach it.
I thought she supported G#5 and A5 belts??
She rarely touches those notes.
but she did in the studio, right? is this about consistent live notes?
+Jhanna Augustina CP I suppose that is the case.
Jhanna Augustina CP Jhanna Augustina CP No even in the studio Mariah's resonance and breath support is usually only present up to G5. For the most part, almost all of her studio G#5s & A5s are unsupported, chesty, & squeezed. She has one A5 that was hit with a neutral larynx though in her song called "The one". But for the most part she is mostly consistent up to G5.
oh thank you
where's the whitney vid tho
who has the widest supported range??
If I am right may be Sohyang for Soprano wih G3/G#3-C6-F6 and Beyonce for mezzo soprano with C3/C#3-F#5-D6
Alex Nguyen thank you
yes, Dongha maybe a tenor who has the widest supported range :)))
I see his vocal range and he can hit up to an A5(super shouty) but he really has ease up to Bb4
I think from B4 to A5 should be considered to be headvoice, although he can mix up to A5 but above B4 there is no support in his mix.
i thought disconnected registers could be supported too no?
No
Art Aspire they could but it's best to only count connected registers
kpop intro !!
shhh :P
what's her CONSISTENT supported range tho?
Currently? Something around F3-C5, but she's not too consistent nowadays, back in her vocal peak she was more like Eb3-F#5/G5, without head voice.
In her prime like E3/F3-F5/F#5-A5.
Nowdays like: F3-B4/C5-A5.
Mariahs supported range (lucky moments) B2-D6
were there any era were she suported lower notes than D3 consistently?
Amit Agmon I don't think this video is of a consistent supported range. I think it's of the whole range of notes she supported. I can't recall a single C#3 or G#5 or Eb6 she sang perfectly.
Amit Agmon no her consistentcy ends at D3. She has supported only 1 B2 before but it was only once in the studio.
Cash Cow how low did she support in the stevie tribute?
Amit Agmon I think Eb3
Though I was in love with one of her C#3s in that performance. Not sure it was supported though
Beautiful voice ... But her head voice ain't that strong
bako jeremiah her pitch perfect whistles cover for it.
swift 1989 naah it dose t
bako jeremiah 😂😂😂😂😂
Really wish you included her lucky supported moments like you did Beyonce :/ oh well this was made by a Beyonce fan lmfao
lilsheep Beyoncé doesn't have "lucky moments". Beyoncé's moments of support are accomplished through skill NOT luck.
Cassie Jones same with Mariah
Cassie Jones
The supported Eb6 was a lucky moment since she literally strained in all Eb6 except these
Also she has 1 supported B2 in You And I
Also he forgotted a lot of notes
Like
Eb6 in Inseparable
E6 in I Still Believe
F6 in Angels Interlude
A B thank you 💕
A B Beyoncé has never strained on Eb6.
The first 3 lows were sooo airy
Ms. Patricia Carey trained a VOCALIST