What Minecraft Dungeons SHOULD Look like!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
- What Minecraft Dungeons SHOULD Look like! dungeons in minecraft have stayed the same for over TEN years. Villages were updated in 1.14, so when is it time for the humble minecraft dungeon? Time to transform...
- Ігри
05:25 wandering trader: "It's been 30 YEARS..."
Joshua Andrea
Waiting for a someone to say, “Minecraft is only ~11 years old”.
@@Aqib2 but minecatfs still very young its only 11 years
And tecknickly wandering trades only exist since 2 years
A Friday in Villach
Bruh
@@they_call_me_lenz_3549 teck nick
Grian commited many crimes in this video.
1. Wore golden armour.
2. Mined diamond with lava right next to it.
3. Killed a spider with a pickaxe.
4. Dug straight down.
Minecraft FBI: *FBI OPEN UP!!!!!*
XD
He also ate uncooked chicken and rotten flesh
And he dug with a sword
He mined sand with a diamond pickaxe
5:29
“Wandering trader not included”
Rip I was gonna spend 5 emeralds for a cactus
In the desert.
In your cactus farm
yay cactus :D
@@cactus2 ironic
Rip i wanted to spend 13 emeralds on a flower.
This should be in the new caves and cliffs update, as it would fit nicely with the new caves!
Go give them the idea then
@@sashaabdulrahman9654 ✉️ I’ll give them the envelope
Yeah that is cool they should add this
Yes definitely they rlly need an update but how will Mojang hear about it?
Utah. Hope they are doing something like this
Grian: "Dungeeeeoooons"
Mojang: "But bees" ;~;
Mojang does have a point though
Players:cave update
Grian:dungeons
Competitive pvpetd:combat update
Mojang:bees
Minecraft: do you want to update dungeons, or have giant bees
Mojang: *sweats*
@ObzPotato it was also a bug in the bug fix update
When he said "simple" at 4:23 I've expected a supercomputer behind that wall
I've been watching mumbo too much...
Same
4:19
Its surprisingly simple
@@aser3951
This is grian.
@@aser3951 It's unsurprisingly simple
Mojang: Adds this to minecraft
Speedrunners: free arrows
You got the point bro!
They dont even use arrows they bed cycle the end fight lol
@@copyandpaste2052 they would use the bow to fight the enderdragon and any monster they see
@@amandarockhold8390 Fighting mobs is a time loss. Most runners just ignore them. They don't need a bow to fight the dragon. You can kill it with beds. Go watch couriway or smth.
@@copyandpaste2052 lots of speed runners use the bow
The Spider Dungeon is definitely a favourite imo, it's the most unique out of all instead of the Cookie Cutter Undead Dungeons because of the Ceiling Scenario.
Same
Same
if there are monster egg bricks in the walls of the reward room then people probably won't mine around and skip the rest of the dungeon
I like that idea!
I would put more chambers and you have to break it all to get loot
@@Mild_autism hes trying to make it simplistic to match the rest of Mojang's structures
08DarkTiger08 They have it in the stronghold so why not
That one guy ! Because a dungeon isn’t a stronghold.
Grian: *makes an amazing suggestion*
Mojang: “I’m just going to pretend I didn’t hear that.”
@Maarten ten Velden agreed
Maarten ten Velden You’re completely right development is really hard the way that Minecraft works probably takes months and months to get one type of thing into the game and I really like the way you broke it down just simply by saying how it would really work and how hard it is to do this kind of stuff and I like this comment a lot ;)
Thats the worst suggestion ive ever heard of
@Maarten ten Velden + making 2 new games, both including dungeon related topics lol
Grian: *ur profile pic*
He shouldve used slowness arrows for the stray spawner
and if there are hunger arrows, use em with the husks
Ikr
That's what I thought !
@@MiScusi69 aw man
Sorry I had to do it
111 Likes
Everyone: we want upgraded dungeons!
Mojang: heh that’s a funny way to say BEE
that was their vacation update, when you want longer vacations, just code something smol and call it a day.
“The Redstone is actually very simple!”
Grian - the red stone leads into these pistons and opens the door!
Mumbo: This multi tiered monostable circuit activates the double piston extender which triggers this flying machine that flys and activates the observer to open the door!
Why is it so true?
Its funny cuz its true
I would like but I don't want to ruin the 69
m8 u cracked me up ty
Cruel but true.
I swear to god I actually gasped when he broke the diamond but didn’t drain the lava first and then lost one of them. It physically hurts
James Lodge lol
It legit hurts so bad
It really be like that sometimes
*9 yeara olds cringing*
Yeah it does
Grian: makes dungeon
Wandering trader: I’m gonna end this mans whole career
Of Korse
that makes no sense
@Rathana Perez
It does make sense just watch the video
SMH🤔
@VGamer45C Pro
Why is Course spelt With A K?
Wow I got 39 likes that’s the most I’ve got ever lol 😂. Insert insult here....
I feel like the treasure should be in the middle of a box, surrounded by traps. If someone is mining or just happens to mine in the side then they could just skip the traps
I don't think mining is that big a deal. The most valuable thing in the structure is the spawner
I'm going LIVE soon
@@walmarp don’t care + didn’t ask + L + ratio’d
@@shrug1250 1:1 ratio lol
@@thunderboltpoplays1177 damn
Imagine mining in a cave, not knowing you were near a dungeon, only to find some random redstone contraption connecting to dispensers
I liked the idea of a redesign, but this is the one thing that gets me.
He says the old dungeons were like that, but this design is still really funky if you enter it from any other side.
Robert Cline...I know, right?
нє υѕє∂ α тяιρωιяє σи тнє ∂єѕρєиѕєяѕ.
they should be programmed to have the entrance facing into a cave.
They should box all of it in and make the walls indestructible until u flip the switch in the treasure room
4:22 Grian: The redstone behind this is very very simple
Mumbo: I'm gonna end this man's whole career
seeing this meme everywhere is getting a little old. ever heard of moderation?
I don't know that Mumbo really does simple redstone. If I wanted complicated redstone then I'd certainly go to him though. :P
ツTheRealDevron Look at my name
@@rami0184 burn in hell
Oh God no
These are very good remakes! I suggest making the loot in the chests related/themed with the dungeon itself, example if the chest if in a drowned dungeon, the loot would contain things you can find underwater as of the 1.13 update, and another suggestion would be to make the arrows in the stray dungeons be slowness arrows. Also I also suggest making the chests from the zombie dungeon to be inside of the zombie cages as that kind of makes more sense, and they can have rotten flesh/themed items, other than that your dungeons are great!
but these are dungeons dungeons were removed from the game for supporting sutcha law
Grian: Makes new dungeons
Mojang: And I'll take that
I wish
I hope
Grian: minecraft dungeons should look different.
Mojang: Lets create a game called minecraft dungeons
hahahaha
Pół
@@BSFan123 trzy czwarte
That game is already made LOL
@@yadiramatos5917 no it is not, that release is in 2020 April
It actually isn't a very bad idea to dig straight down. Mumbo did the math.
But he ended it with saying you should never dig down and to just play the game like the rest of us
And if you actually have ears you can hear it
You have an 8% chance to hit lava. Thats almost every 1 in 10, seeing as you're gonna go mining a lot more than 10 times, it's a bad idea. A really bad idea. 8% is a really big percentage when it's done frequently.
I wouldn't say that. While you've got favourable odds for each individual go, there's still a fairly significant chance for it to go wrong, especially after a few tunnels.
It only takes once to die and loose your stuff. Not worth it. ;)
'Husk is just a desert zombie, other than it doesn't burn in light'
Hunger status effect: am I a joke to you?
lol I legit thought those exact words as he said that
I just saw that in time while reading the comment
The funny part is that the hunger status effect IS a joke to me
What about depends on the dungeon the loot is diffirent, at least like a spiser has more chances of getting string loot
Yes, actually, if you have more than 3 steaks it’s barely an inconvenience.
I really like this. So many mods and so many suggestions take things way past what vanilla feels like. These are small, simple, and aren't like those ridiculous megadungeon mods. This improves on the structure without really changing what it is
Grian: "This is how MC dungeons should look like"
Mojang: *1.15 update - the Dungeon and temple update!*
Since 1.15 seems like it going to be a new combat update a better name for would be
1.15
*Dungeons and Combat Update*
A.G _empire i though 1.15 was the combat update
I would be the cave update but its gonna be the combat update
Helen has confirmed 1.15 will have nothing to do with the underground
What about the dungeoneering update?
Grian: The redstone behind this is very simple...
Mumbo: Hey, that's my line!
Tracer: Hey,thats my line!
Ceave: ⭐️(*w*)☄️
But you KNOW it's simple because it's Grian, where-as with Mumbo, things tend to go wrong with that line...
0:52
I didn't think this was a cursed video.
Is that dimond upside down
maybe maybe not
*flipped diamonds intensifies*
hopefully the caves and cliffs update will do something about the spawner dungeons
Ya after all they did say there was going to be more then what they told us
@@PremiumRogue I’m hyped 👁👄👁🤘
No.
Sadly they didnt do anything
This didn’t age well
Grian: *builds trap*
Also grian: Who put that trap there!?
Me though. Except (sorry to say if you don't like this game) this would also happen to me in fortnite if you could die from your own trap
Scarlett Panther irrelevant topic
Zacoman222 it’s just a comment!
vas happenin
@@zacoman2225 How is that irrelevant? he was talking about the same thing as the original comment.
Grian: Makes new Dungeon models
Mojang: **FURIOUSLY TAKING NOTES**
Joseph Thibodeau I wish
Mojang: Write that down! Write that down!
This better be part of the cave update or I'm gonna be pissed
I think we ALL wish that
@@scarlettpanther6892 yeah
They should really add this. They did say they made the dungeons more "exciting", but to be honest, I don't even remember what they changed. Would be perfect for the wild update
source? they never said that they jusr added new ones blud dungeons dont exist it is a ploy
Honestly I really like this! The changes aren’t too drastic, they still have mostly the same content, but they are just re-arranged and modernized for today. Maybe if Mojang were to actually do this they could add multiple new layouts for each type of dungeon. Idk but this is just great, it updates everything for the modern times, and keeps what players know and use these for. Btw I think the spider one is honestly really cool, prolly my favorite.
8:15 you should have put slowness arrows in the dispenser for the stray dungeon.
Sheila Armenti but when strays hit you, you get slowness
...you dont get poison...
@@strike-impulse6133 Are you dumb?...
You get slowness.
ItsBlazeCraft yeah he’s dumb
And for the Husks you get hunger
We need a cave update or a nether update
New structures
New ores
New blocks
New mobs
Fixed bugs
Removed herobrine
Herobrine will never be removed
I think they've tried that last one once before
YA MOJANG IM TALKING ABOUT YOU
Edit: HoLy MoLeY that's a lot of likes!
Serpent31 Gaming he hasn’t been in the game for about 6 years
@@jordansykes4298 shhhhhhh he dont need to knowwwwwwww
@@jordansykes4298 ooohhhh that's what you think he is always online he is always in your game stalking you he is always here he even hears this conversation
These dungeons would go really well in minecraft for an extra challenge
After going in the stray dungeon
"Someone stole the loot from the dungeon!"
"Really??"
"It's flooding in here!!"
0:51 G R I A N did you just mine that diamond *into lava*
Yes, yes he did. Sad, isn't it?
i was a bit triggered
Yes. he did :'(:'(
Yep
Rip diamond 2019-2019
Grian: The skeleton one is probably the most difficult
Shield: Am I a joke to you?
Even if you didn’t have a shield you still have strays
Shield only works if you're facing the mob
Problem is...I live in a minecraft world without Shields.....
the arrows would come from both sides
@@russianbot5302 noob
You forgot the Mesa dungeon. Looks like the desert one (except all the blocks are red sand variants I stead of regular sand)and for the treasure room there’s be red sand falling and cave spiders would be spawning (because of the surface mineshafts)(works the same way as the regular spider spawner. It’s on top of the roof)
Underwater dungeons
ocean monuments: am i a joke to you?
I like how the dungeons that he created had cobwebs so that there was another way to find naturally spawned cobwebs since you can’t craft them.
U can 9 string
Atom Gaming if you play on server with plug-in (like 99,999% of the non-moded server) you maybe can craft some by dropping string or something, or if you play with mobs but in vanilla minecraft nope, there is no way (and i don’t think there will be one, how humans suppose de make a cobweb???)
Oh and Catalie Mew idk why you’re saying that, you can’t collect cobwebs, even with a silk touch shear...
@@ReeversUhHuh yes you can
Buke was you can what? Having cobwebs with silk touch shears?
5:27
Grian: Treasure is in this room
Trader: it’s free real estate
lol
Dang that's a lot of likes
DrPulseOver I’ve seen people get 1k likes in 7 minutes 😳
You should hire someone to make this in a datapack.
It would also be nice in the new wild update since they want to enhance the adventuring experience
Minecraft structures: Exist
Grian: I’m about to *improve* this man’s whole career
A lot of people do that. q:
Ok YES
Pikachew Likes Waffles nice
Genius
Whole man
Watching him let that diamond burn in lava gave me depression
Belgum Dire I don’t care if diamonds burn I to good I can catch them
And he ate raw chicken smh
Not to mention wearing gold armor
Dig sand with the diamond sword
what the hell
Imagine these dungeons with wireless red stone coming in the 1.17 update! That would be so cool!
Who’s rewatching this AFTER THE NEW CAVE UPDATE WAS ANNOUNCED?!?! I can’t wait!
I've still never found a fossil in my life
Agreed
Only once 4 me
Cam same
i didn't even know they existed
Same
When a creative builder plays survival :
1. He uses gold armour
2. He eats raw chicken
And breaks diamond ore into lava
3. Is paranoid of mobs
(Unless that’s just me)
Yea, it triggers me.
Nah. I’m mainly creative but have a hard survival world going for about 100 -150 days
and he mines sand and ground with diamond pickaxe
I hadn't thought about going around and getting the loot that easily all this while...
The ice dungeons would be great with the new powder snow as a trap in the entrance. I'd love to see dungeons and other structures get improved proper some day
Imagine if Grian was a designer (at Mojang) for Minecraft. I would end up mining nothing because I’d be amazed by literally everything!
Add Mumbo to the mix and it would become a marvel of just endlessness
Honestly, Minecraft should hire Scar for the terrain and Grian for the buildings lol.
@@onyxflame they should also hire sethbling for the coding lmao
They wouldnt be able to keep updating the game seeing how fast he comes up with ideas xD
But some ideas they present is not too minecraft like as grian addressed in another generated structures video and so their builds might be too complex to still be in minecraft and doesn't iniciate the player to build? Just imagine walking into a villege made by Grian and having a super computer in it made by mumbo, it would take away the fun of upgrading a crappy villege yourself
Grian: “You can get redsto-“
Mumbo: “I have been summoned.”
*WHOMV'ST HAD SUMMONED THE ANCIENT ONE*
jaxon. ITS THE MESSIAH
Lol
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
lol
0:50
Grian: Calmly discussing and introducing the video's topic
The diamond: NOOOOOO-
Wow! This is really cool. I love the ocean dungeon! Keep up the good work!
When I read the title, I didn’t know if he was talking about the new game “Minecraft: Dungeons” or the naturally generated dungeons.
Same thoughts
@@jester3654 have you seriously not seen the new currently indev Minecraft dungeons game
Same haha
u silly
@@alex.g7317 goose
C'mon, say it with me
*CAVE UPDATE! CAVE UPDATE!*
Come on everyone say it with me we're going to lego super droid's house and kill him/she
@@Co-ordinator 😂
@@dynasty4444 it would be him/her not him/she
@@m4teo573 any problem if you have tell it to me
C A V E S A N D D U N G E O N S U P D A T E ? ?
A suggestion you could use powder snow as the trap in the stray dungeon
The spider spawner remembered me the magma cube spawner in bastions, good work
I swear to god this guy will redesing the fountains you find in the desert biome
come at me brah
Pretty sure he has
redesign?*
@@MetanoiaRose yeah thanks english is not my first language
That's a well right?
“you should change the dungeons”
*makes entirely new game*
Lol
lol
LOL
Eat my chakra
Hormejsudjdns
i love your ideas so much Grian, PERFECT!!!
OMG! I LOVE YOUR IDEAS! I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE THESE DUNGEONS IN MINECRAFT! Even though they are harder to deal with and I suck at fighting, BUT STILL!
“As if I’m a new player.”
*also holding a diamond pickaxe and sword*
You can literally get iron and go strip after little bit o playing
@@markdream6813 but a new player won't know how to do that
New players might wear gold armour
Ploper Dung pewdiepie did that and he’s new
Also alot others
@@solaris2523 you are right when i was a noob i thought that the gold armor was better than the iron
Grian: *Does redstone*
Me: wait that’s illegal
this has already happened... alot
this foes not make sense at all lmao
The guy literally messed up a gravity door in the real world situation
The redstone: doesn’t work
I actually love this remake you made it feel like an actual dungeon
These are really cool dungeons.
I normally sneak around the spawner areas to get the loot. Actually, In one of my survival games my spawn area was near a pillager area and a witch hut. And because I actually have a bad habit of dying (because I don't pay attention to my heart levels when in battle...heh...), I wanted to figure out a way to, well, not die.
So, for the witch hut I snuck underneath and used my axe to take out some of the floor then use dirt to stand on.
The pillager tower I used my pickaxe through the side (actually another time, I somehow made it up to the roof and used the pickax down from there).
Once I got the loot, I ran like hell.
I feel so dumb for wanting to see what is in the chests every time
Me too but it's just instinct
Me: Why
My brain: just do it
Me: I'm not lucky though-
My brain: *O P E N T H E B O X , M O R T A L*
@@pileofcrap-w-8309 You: But you're basically me
@@pileofcrap-w-8309 13:03 5 bones and 25 string is what you need in there
I think i would cry
@@pileofcrap-w-8309 got 2 spawners combined got 2goleden and 1 enchanted golden apple
"im just a regular player"
*Is wearing gold armour*
@@aurescentgamez_5900
>spams random letters and asks for subscribers
>"please don't hate me"
@@aurescentgamez_5900 shut up
@sananiquilatorXD wat did he say??
@@aurescentgamez_5900 shut up
Yeah shut up even though I didn’t see your comment
grian buddy you just perfectly demonstrated the dangers of an enemy who breaks up and strategically places their forces with the skeleton and stray dungeons. Kudos for showing the challenges of good tactics!
Thanks Grian! more ideas for decorating my exp farms
Grian: the chests are the loot
Me: yay Skeleton xp farm
i was thinking this too. I was like "I would leave the torches in mah inventory and wait for them to spawn
Yeah Grian doesn’t do red stone so making a mob farm doesn’t even come to mind (though you can make mob farms without redstone)
My first thought was that a drowned spawner would make farming tridents 10x easier on Java, where converted drowned don't give you tridents.
Skeleton XP farms are nice, but ever since I made a zombie pigman farm I only visit it when I need bonemeal.
@@Virgil6440 what about arrows?
Grian: *mines diamond under lava and doesn't get it even though he could have blocked the lava first*
Me: *deletes life*
Lol I felt the same thing
@@floofysnoopy2487 nice.
I would say the drowned one is the most deadliest dungeon because
1. The magma blocks could drag you down and possibly kill you
2. The iron bars and other blocks you need to break are hard because you are underwater
3. You can drown If you dont get the loot in time unless you have a potion
4. Its kinda hard to disable the spawner because you cant place torches underwater
For the desert one it would be cool for the first room to be a cactus maze then the second room with the spawner will also have a bunch cactus in it so not only will you have to fight the husk you also have to avoid the cacti, for the snow one it would be cool for the first room to have a floor of snow and you have to guess which block is normal snow and which on is powdered snow and in the spawner room there will also be some powdered snow on the floor so not only will you have to fight the stray you also have to avoid the powdered snow and not get sucked in
A solution to the mining around problem: Use silverfish blocks
Bruh...
U mean infested blocks?
Yes
Use silverfish blocks AND obsidian
Literally use bedrock
The real reason Grian didn't open the chest in the Drowned Dungeon demo:
He wasn't lazy, he just knew the chest would be full of NOTHING
Just like the real dungeons!
@@mk-qk3xd 😞
Lane Robertson dungeons have god tier loot wtf u talking about
@@mk-qk3xd Exactly! I don't exactly need two more bread, three more string, and yet another copy of the "cat" music disc.
moosa kazim I never have gotten just rotten flesh so maybe I’m just lucky
Honestly this is the only structure upgrade I've seen that blends really well into the normal game. I'd love to see these added
The redstone door is another great way to introduce structures that can teach the player basic redstone mechanics
ibxtoycat slowly goes more insane while waiting for a cave updade, and Grian has gone as far as recreating a cave structure. MOJANG, CAN YOU HEAR OUR CRY FOR HELP!?!?! WE NEED A CAVE UPDATE!
Toycat & Grian are yes
Yes
Toycat is yes
*THIS NEEDS MORE LIKES*
Update*
Don’t worry! It will probably be changed in the cave update!
*oh right*
Your name basically explains the comment
@@bettercetacean lol ikr
Just wait for it to be called the mining and divine if update and it to be the same thing
@Panda4Life "It acutally explains ur self" I don't think he's alone.
Really Sad Idiot Look at my name Look at my name Look at my name Look at my name Look at my name
0:23 The structure of dungeons has stayed the same since Infdev, but the loot in the chests has had tweaks to it, such as when enchanted books were added, and also when Minecraft 1.9 added several new items to dungeon chest loot as well as tweaking many item weights.
Also, prior to Minecraft 1.3, breaking spawners didn't reward experience orbs like it now does.
The first minecraft dungeon didn't even have a spawned at all, it was just a white cube in the air will a hell of a lot of wool
"Cobwebs to stop you from the loot"
Security 100
Marcus Acaba it’s Not an infestation,it’s my home defenses!
grian: *exists
the diamond from 0:51 :OH HELL NO
Grian: "I'm about to end this man's whole career"
@@gearandalthefirst7027 tbh thats better
LuXe FTW I can’t believe people can be so critical about meme formats.
Cliché the Cat he’s not being “so critical” you snowflake
@@baldmartin1355 you're the snowflake here, dude.
I swear the wandering trader is EVERYWHERE. I found one in a hecking stronghold!
Agreed! Even a fraction of this would be a huge improvement, just a box with a spawner in the center is pretty lackluster.
"I haven't thought this through. At all."
- Grian, 2019
And 2018 and 2017 and...
UA-cam thinks that this is actually Minecraft dungeons
Look in the description
*plays a game before it comes out*
*like a boss*
lol
Released in 2020...
*My brain cells:*
Hahaha
@@georgecota1720 Braincells lost 100
I love them all
POV Grian make a resource pack
Nice job! =) BTW my favorite is spider dungeon
0:53 u just gonna causally mine diamonds right next to lava
he lost one to the lava too. F.
@@juan3141 that hurt
You and Mumbo should do: “What Strong Holds should look like”
strong holds arent that bad
The Gaming Brit or “What the nether castle should look like”
@@soviety4613He's already done that. Look up "Let's Transform a Nether Fortress".
Why Mumbo?
Imaging if minecraft added full on proper dungeons. Like, huge structures that are dark and require puzzles to open doors and have a mini boss in the inner sanctum. That'd be amazing
Minecraft community: Update the dungeons from Minecraft
Mojang: Did you say to make a new game?
me: enters the wrong side of the dungeon
dungeon: am i a joke to you
Thijmen van Keulen yeah that’s what I thought. What if you enter the wrong side? Mojang isn’t gonna add this because of that reason
@@roon8356 I was thinking the same thing; this setup is not too likely, but there are other pathway structures. I agree though.
What's a joke is how I can't go on a single video without someone commenting this meme.
Thijmen van Keulen couldn't you just place the treasures somewhere else and add the corridors on all corners? this way it doesn't matter which way you come from
@@lucca3113 wouldn't that be too much loot?
I don't think Mumbo would like to raid the Stray dungeon because of the ice :P
Rumbo Jumbo it is pretty useless
What if he carries tnt with him
Yeah he wouldn't much care for it.
He WOULD like to burn it ;)
Rumbo huh, ok
I love the spider one! Even though the drowned one doesn’t really work, it’s better than the ol’ box of cobblestone.
Love the idea. I hope this pitch flies on in to Minecraft. Keep doing what you do best grian.