Celestion Speakers: Greenback vs Alnico Blue vs Vintage 30 vs Creamback
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
- In this video we are going to: listen to a song of mine with a rhythm part and a lead part listening to 4 different Celestion Speakers, than we will build together a 4 speakers cabinet with a Celestion Greenback, a Celestion AlnicoBlue, a Celestion Vintage 30 and a Celestion CreamBack and then we will hear a detailed comparison between them, both with clean tones and distorted tones, listening each after the others and also each against all the others....Please let me know in the comment below which speaker you prefer and if you want me to compare other speakers...hope you enjoy and please subscribe to my channel and hit the notification bell!
▶💽 Link to a playlist of my songs: • Leo Gibson Songs
▶🎸🔉 If you are interested in my IRs, please follow this link: www.leogibsong...
▶🎸🔉 If you are interested in my Kemper Profiles, please follow this link: www.leogibsong...
Link to DistroKid with 7% discount for you: distrokid.com/v...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OTHER VIDEOS:
▶ Pedalboards demo review:
Neural DSP Quad Cortex Unleashed: • Quad Cortex Unleashed:...
NUX MG 30 demo review: • NUX MG 30: Demo and Re...
Pedalboards Latency: • The most extensive amp...
Fractal FM3 demo review: • Fractal Audio FM3: Dem...
Kemper Stage demo review: • Kemper Profiler Stage ...
POD GO demo review: • LINE 6 POD GO: Demo & ...
Zoom G11 demo review: • Zoom G11: Demo and Rev...
Zoom G6 demo review: • ZOOM G6: Demo & Review...
Valeton GP 100 demo review: • Valeton GP 100: demo a...
NUX MG 300 demo review: • NUX MG 300: Demo & Rev...
Mooer GE 300 lite demo review: • Mooer GE 300 Lite: Dem...
Mooer GE 250 demo review: • Mooer GE 250: Demo & R...
Mooer GE 150 demo review: • Mooer GE 150: Demo / R...
▶ Modeling pedalboards comparison videos:
Quad Cortex vs Fractal FM3: • Neural DSP Quad Cortex...
Quad Cortex vs Kemper: • Neural DSP Quad Cortex...
NUX MG30 vs Mooer GE 200 vs Ampero One: • NUX MG 30 vs Ampero On...
FM3 vs Kemper vs Helix vs Pod GO vs NUX vs Valeton vs Mooer vs Soldano: • FM3 vs Kemper vs POD G...
NUX MG 300 vs Valeton GP100 vs Mooer GE 150 vs Harley Benton DNA: • NUX MG 300 vs Valeton ...
BOSS GT 1000 core vs HX Stomp: • BOSS GT 1000 core vs L...
Zoom G11 vs Mooer GE 300: • Zoom G11 vs Mooer GE 3...
Fractal FM 3 vs Kemper Stage: • Fractal audio FM 3 vs ...
POD GO vs GE 250: • Line 6 POD GO vs MOOER...
GT 1000 vs Line 6 Helix: • BOSS GT 1000 vs LINE 6...
Line 6 Helix vs Headrush: • Line 6 HELIX vs Headru...
GT 1000 vs GT 1000 core: • BOSS GT 1000 vs GT 100...
GT 1000 vs FM 3: • Fractal FM3 vs BOSS GT...
GT 1000 vs HEADRUSH: • BOSS GT 1000 vs HEADRU...
GT 1000 vs GE 300 vs HELIX vs HEADRUSH vs PLEXI: • GT 1000 VS GE 300 VS H...
GE 200 vs GE 250 vs GE 300 vs GE 150: • MOOER GE 150 vs GE 200...
GE 250 vs Hotone Ampero: • Mooer GE250 vs Hotone ...
GE 250 vs HX Stomp: • Mooer GE 250 vs Line 6...
GE 250 vs Gigboard: • MOOER GE 250 vs HEADRU...
GE 200 vs Ampero One: • Mooer GE 200 vs Ampero...
HX STOMP vs GIGBOARD: • LINE 6 HX STOMP vs HEA...
GE 250 vs GE 300: • MOOER GE 250 vs GE 300...
GE 150 vs ZOOM G1X Four: x • Mooer GE 150 vs Zoom G...
GE 250 vs Ampero vs HX stomp vs GigBoard vs JCM 800: • GE 250 vs AMPERO vs HX...
BIAS AMP 2 VS AMPLITUBE 4 VS SOFTUBE VS FORTIN vs PLEXI: • BIAS AMP 2 VS AMPLITUB...
GE250 vs HX STOMP vs GIGBOARD vs IRIDIUM vs Fender DLX Reverb: • GE250 vs HX STOMP vs G...
#CelestionSpeakers #Vintage30 #Greenback #Creamback #AlnicoBlue
The best comparative video! Congratulations!
Thank you Fernando, appreciated!
They all sound great and I would be happy with any one or combination of them. You can't lose!
Thank you for sharing!
You always have the best comparison videos Leo. Thanks!
Thank you for such an amazing compliment! Really super appreciated!!!
This is the best guitar speaker comparison I've yet seen. Excellent work. Thank you very much indeed. I hear things in each speaker that I like, and I know a lot of this is personal taste. The Alnico always sounds the most present to me, like it's speaking right into my ear, but it also sounds rounder than all the rest. It makes me want a speaker with all the body and presence of the Alnico but with the more extended high-end response of the Creamback or Vintage 30 - which also sounded a bit more distant and small to me but had a lovely top definition.
I wonder how much different each speaker would sound with a Sennheiser 421 or a condenser? I also reckon a lot of this would change just by moving the mic an inch or so towards or away from the center, or by moving it back a couple of inches . . . so many variables! But as a comparison to show the basic overall inherent characteristics of each speaker, this is top work. Thank you again!
You are welcome, I'm super happy that you like the video!!!
Thank you also for sharing your findings! Yes, I do agree...mic positioning is very important and also a 421 would have an impact in the tone...but at least I hope (as you said) that this video provide a general idea of the character of each speaker.
Thank you so much!!!
This is the best comparison video I’ve ever seen. Great job!
Hi, thank you for this great compliment that really makes me happy!!!
Incredibly well done video, thanks, subscribed!
You are welcome and thank you so much for becoming part of our community!!! It means a lot to me and to us!!!
Beauty is in the ear of the beholder. Very well done my ear preferred the cream and the green
Thank you, really appreciated! Thank you also for sharing your opinion!
Thanks!
The best comparison!
Very very informative!
Thank you soooo much, I'm really happy that you appreciate the video!!!!
What a great comparison job, man! Pretty organized. Thanks for do it for us.
Thank you Thiago!!!
Thanks a lot Leo for helping your subscribers choose their speakers. Very important and helpful.
You are welcome and I'm super happy to have been of some help!!!
This was great, Leo. Excellent. Thank you.
Thank you Bobby, I'm happy you like the video!!!
Best speaker shootout on youtube hands down! Celestion Blue is the best Celestion speaker in my opinion. The GreenBack sounds like the ceramic version of the Blue speaker.
Thank you, really appreciated!
Thank you also for sharing your opinion!!!
Surprisingly the blue and green complement each other nicely combined
Incredibly helpful video. Thank you!
You are welcome, I'm happy to have been of some help!
Great comparison! Thank you for this.
You are welcome, I'm happy that you like it!
Amazing review, Leo! Unfortunately my favorites, (gold and cream) were not reviewed... Thanks a lot, i loved this review
Thank you so much, I'm super happy that you like the video!!!
Awesome! Extensive comparative and with great audio quality. Thanks a lot!
Thank you Luis!!!
Thanks so much for doing this. Instantly removes the vintage, which I was about to buy, from contention and leaves me torn between the blue and green. The clearest comparison video I've seen.
Thank you, I'm super happy that you like the video!
Great video Leo. I especially like how you did each speaker against each of the others. This was really helpful. For my own situation, I have typically been using greenbacks. I want a cab with blues so I have both options. This solidified that I will proceed to get blues (but still hold onto my greenback cabs). Thank you.
Your are welcome!!! Thank you for you comment and your interest in my channel!
Thanks for this. I'm wondering how much the tones would change once the speakers were broken in. I keep reading how that is vital. I was most surprised by two things here: The blue sounded best dirty (always thought the green would), but I'm not sure if my brain is equating what seemed like more volume on the distorted tones which we can sometimes equate that to 'better' sound, or if the perceived higher volume was just the more pronounced mid push of the speaker. Also, I didn't expect the greens to sound as good as the blues on clean. I always thought that's the blue's domain. Vintage sounded like I thought it would, and the creambacks were slightly more disappointing than anticipated
You are welcome and thank you so much for sharing your findings!!!
Thank You for the comparisons between each speaker, I am in the market for a speaker for a small cab I'm building. I've been all over youtube listening to speakers and until now I was undecided, though now the clear choice for me and my budget is the greenback, Thank You for your effort in bringing this to light.
Hi Dennis, you are welcome, and I'm happy to have been of some help!
Wow! Great work here! You just made me decide to build a 2X12 cabinet with one Greenback and one Alnico Blues speaker in it. :)
Thank you, I'm happy to have been of some help!
Great video - well done guys. I'm loving that Alnico...
Thank you Joe, really appreciated!!!
Expensive taste.
Great job! Thanks for that comparison!
Thank you Maciek! Really appreciated!
The Blue and M greenback is one of my favourite mixes of speaker in the same cab. Great video
Thank you!
Such a useful video, thank you!
Thank you sooooo much, I'm really happy that you appreciate the video!!!
Very well executed comparison! Greenback is my favourite here, with Creamback as 2:nd.
Thank you Mats!!! Thank you also for sharing your opinion!
The best video comparision, excellent and thanks
you are welcome, I’m super happy that you like the video!!!
best comparison video ever
Thank you sooo much, really appreciated!!!
Well done sir, thank you.
You are welcome and I'm happy that you appreciate the video!!!
Cream is sweet and a good mix of Blue and Green in a way. It sings more like a blue at louder settings but all this is vague and subjective to hearing, amp and guitar as we all know. The real joy comes from mixing them for me. Two speakers I don’t like as much V30 and g75t actually sound great together but not as much on their own.
Hi Frank, I do agree...when you mix these speakers you can obtain pretty great tones!
Thank you for your message!!!
Hi, you made such a great video! Thanks man! you're great!
Thank you so much! really appreciated!!!
I came here wanting a good comparison and I was blown away! No need to waste money on the blue when greens and v30s are perfect. I know there are plenty of play styles but I just can't get over that perfect sound of the v30s. Cheers!
Thank you!
This is as good as a comparison video gets.
Thank you John, really appreciated!
I love the green back and creamback :-)
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion!!!
This is an amazing comparison. Thanks for making this.
Thank you Paul, really appreciated!
Excellent video Leo!!! Listening to this comparison I preferred the Creamback.
Thank you, really appreciated!
Don't know if already done, but I'd like to hear a comparison with the G12H 30 anniversary ;)
What an amazing demo. Thank you for spending the time to do such great work. The blue and green sounded best to my old ears.
Thank you, your appreciation is really important for me! Thank you also for sharing you preferences with us!!!
Really excellent, would love to hear the G12EVH vs Greenback vs M65 Creamback vs H65 Creamback
Thank you, I'm really happy that you like the video.
Thank you also for sharing your suggestions!
Excellent work! Thank you!
Thank you Paul! really appreciated!
Amazing comparison! Here's what I thought:
Distorted:
1. Greenback - Full, with clear top end
2. Blue - Full, but somewhat lacking in the top end with a "hollow" sound
3. Cream - Full, but muddled top end
4. Vintage 30 - Very thin, bleh.
Clean:
1. Blue - Full in mid range, a bit of a hollow sound, super clear top end and bottom! Awesome!
2. Greenback - Top end is there but it lacks fullness
3. Cream - Full-ish, but missing some of the "hollowness" and character of the blue
4. Vintage 30 - Thin again. Also bleh
Thank you and thank you also for sharing your opinion with us!!! your description is very cleaver! Actually I also would use the Green for overdriven tones and the Blue for clean...
Never really liked V30's but it took me decades to figure that out.
Hearing celestions in a comparison like this makes me realize I put up with not liking my sound and blaming the guitar all this time.
What happens when you assume kids ?!?!
@@decimusrex92 I agree! Blue and green were so much better than the v30. I want to mix the blue with green in 2 x 12 wish the db's were the same
@@RG-yz8ov you just have to put a little more into the V30. I think it has the most neutral sound, which means the amp, guitar and yourself make the tone. I used an Englad made V30 in 1x12, and it works great with all 3 of my small tube amps VOX, Blackstar and Ampeg. Just my opinion
@@decimusrex92 Slash only uses V 30 for what’s it’s worth…
Great test Leo, I always follow your channel, undoubtedly one of the best on UA-cam today, when it comes to guitar equipment!
Thank you Lucas, this is really a great compliment! thank you once more!
This is the best speaker comparison i have ever seen, and i've been watching alot lately, because im looking for some upgrade to celestion seventy 80 in my Ibanez TSA15 combo. Im torn between greenback, vintage 30 and v-type, i want a nie strat quack on clean and the least fizz possible with drives.
Hi, thank you so much, I'm happy that you like the video!
Finally, I'm typically using the Greenback for clean or comping parts and the V30 for soloing...but the speakers are the things I have changed a lot over the years...It's an ever ending research... :)
Thank you!
Superb comparison! Thanks! All elements have their strenghts. Maybe Greenback is the best compromise.
Thank you, really appreciated!!! Thank you also for sharing your opinion!
Great comparative Leo. Congratulations
Thank you Javier, I'm happy that you enjoyed the video!!!
great comparison and some really great playing. P.S. Vintage 30's for me.
Thank you, really appreciated!
Amazing work, thank you very much for sharing that!
Thank you! Appreciated!!
You’re a great player and this is a great video brother!!!
These are great compliments!!! Thank you so much!
Excellent comparison. I thought for me the Alnico Blue had slightly more bloom to the overall sound than the Greenback on the clean but not enough to justify the price difference. Overall both clean and distorted they all sound good. My preference if I am paying for them would be 1. Green 2. Cream 3. Vintage 30 4. Blue(Simply for its cost). If I had a Great 30 watt or smaller wattage amp that I loved, then I would spring for the Blue.
Thank you James, I'm happy you like the video!!!
Thank you also for sharing your opinion!
Amazing job! And everything you did made it easier to compare.
I never thought that the drive tunes would be where I'd notice the better the differences.
Than you, I'm happy that you like the video!
Thank you also for sharing your findings!
Just subscribed! Great job on the video!
Thank you Dennis, really appreciated!
Wonderful job - thanks so much. A question: did you burn in the speakers before doing these comparisons? Also just a note to point out that these speakers will sound different in an open back or ported cab and different depending on whether they are wired in series or parallel (damping). Would be cool if you could do a video highlighting these differences too. That would be a ton of work though!
Hi Gerry, thank you, I'm happy that you like the video!
May I ask you what you mean with "burn in" the speakers?
Yes, the comparison you are suggesting is cool! As you said...it would take a lot of time...
Thank you once more!
@@LeoGibsonGtr Hi Leo - yeah I was referring to the break or burn in of new speakers. Basically speakers change their tonal properties with time - mechanical wear on the “flange” where cone meets the surround, makes the speaker less “stiff”. In practice this can remove shrillness and harshness from the top end and also boost bass extension. It may also lessen a speaker’s tendency to sound nasal. I guess there’s a general consensus that speakers sound more musical with playing time. The amount of time required is the subject of much debate: some speakers reportedly require a long time (months, years), but many people say that hard playing for a few hours (or letting amplified music or loops blast the speaker whilst one goes elsewhere), is enough to make an audible change for the better. Cheers, gerry
Great video. I honestly imagined the difference between speakers would be bigger - not sure I would be able to tell the difference in a blind test..
Hi Peter, thank you for sharing your opinion with us and for your message!
Audio gear is often like that - the differences are subtle and people get very passionate about comparitivly small differences in tone! I try not to get sucked in to it all, but as my ears get better, the difference become more noticeable...
Absolut great job, thank you
Thank you for your comment and your interest in my channel!!!
Excellent work! My intitial impressions: No surprises, usual issues. Blue has very pleasing crystal chimey highs, mids won’t be scoop friendly. Cream has some nice low-mid extension, interesting, yet it also sounds a bit colored/phasey. V30 sounds round with some nice highs, presence. Green compresses the right ‘hard rock’ way, but very slightly dull (smoother?) relative to others. I find you can always subtract specific frequencies with a precise eq post-mic to get to a specific desired sound, but harder to add frequencies/dynamics it’s lacking to begin with, unless your that person who uses sim amps and speakers. Tho they can sound good and are very convenient, I’ve yet to hear a sim speaker IR that sounded like a real celestion, including celestion ones, which is great news for celestion. A guitarist (who’s achieved proficiency) really does need several different real speakers pushing as much air as the gf or neighbors will tolerate imho.
~Hey Celestion: make an alnico blue that retains the beautiful 3d clarity, but compresses in the mids just like a low watt green when pushed, with some 9-16k presence hair on top and a little low chunk from the v30; since this is a wish list also add a dial to tune resonance 50-80hz. I suggest you make the speakers lower wattage and more pick dynamic above 5k, use lighter cones. Lower wattage, sensitive speakers ‘usually’ sound more alive; plus if people blow them you will sell more.
Hi David, first of all thank you for your really interesting message! Well, actually I agree with you. Each speaker has different quality and characteristics...in fact at end I prefer to mix different speakers then record the same speaker with different mics ... actually my favorite couple is the Alnico with the Greenback...I have to find the time to make a part 2 of this video...mixing speakers...thank you once more!
Great playing and nice song man. Great comparison. I love the greenbacks the most.
Thank you Andrei, really appreciated!!!!
Thank you Leo, nice video like always....Alnico for me
Thank you for the compliments and for sharing your opinion!
Thanks by excellent video
You are welcome!!! I'm super happy that you like the video!!
Leo, has fet una fantástica feina. Et felicito!
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the video!!!
Here’s an idea, put one mic on a blue for cleans, and a mic on the ceramic for distorted, and an a/b/y for both!
👍
Amazing video!
I'm a V30 and Alnico Blue guy. I can't seem to like greenbacks as they sound dull to me.
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the video!
Thank you also for sharing your findings!!!
An amazing job wow. Lots of work! The question needs to be which speaker sounds best in a mix? Your music and guitar playing is beautiful.
Thank you Normand... you are right, in fact I'm thinking about other videos comparing the speakers in a fully produced song or combining them... for instance a greenback with a vintage 30 or a greenback with an Alnico Blue..
Thank you once more...I've really put a lot of energy and passion into this video...and I enjoyed it!
Appreciate the work you put into this. Unfortunately critical listening over mobile devices just gives you somewhat of an idea of what being heard. Between my phone, phone with earbuds, and then my desktop system with Focal over-ears, each one I have a different favorite amongst the 4 speakers. In real life I prefer Alnico Blues. Thanks again for the hard work.
Thank you for the compliments and for sharing your opinion!!!
Great comparison, but they all sound pretty much the same to me. I’d buy anyone a drink or two who could tell which is which with your eyes closed
Very well done.
Thank you Evan, really appreciated!
I love how detailed your videos are #science
Thank you, really appreciated!!!
Lovely video, Leo. This solidifies it, there really is no need to upgrade the good old Greenback.
Thank you Al, both for your message and your interest in my channel!!!
Extremely well done video.
Thank you John, really appreciated!
Very good comparison video. Clear, detailed, technical.
Could be good, to have the comparison double track left and right. And in a mix with bass and drums, as it changes a lot the sound.
Thank you, really appreciated! Actually, I had in mind to do a second part of this video doing basically what you are saying, trying the speaker in a real mixed song and also paring two different cabs together, but I never found the time to do it...hope in the future I will... thank you for your message and your interest in my channel!!!!
Most appreciated effort.
Thank you Chris!!!
bravo eccellente come sempre, ho fatto anche io un test simile ma con coni diversi , il century , il century vintage , in leo cream back , and in neo vtype ... su una 4x12 engl...
Graze! Interessante e grazie per aver condiviso!!!
Very inspiring video! I will build a Frankenstein cab with 10" speakers. Celestion is launching a 10" Creamback soon!
Thank you Marco!!! Let us know about your Frankenstein cab!
Great video gentlemen, really compared the character of each speaker very well. For me in order of most preferred to least preferred it would be 1. Alnico Blue 2. Greenback 3. Creamback and 4. Vintage 30. I think the Alnico gives the best overall sound, best for cleaner tones and retains that "chime" tone with a good strat. The Greenback comes in a close 2nd, ideal for a crunchier 412 cab tone. Creamback had a good tonal response. The Vintage 30 had the least expressive tone for me.
Hi, thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the video!!! Really appreciated!
Thank you also for sharing your findings!!
Green for Distortion
Blue for Clean
Thank you for sharing! The way you orchestrated the "each speaker against the others" is brilliant! Which speaker did you prefer in the room? Cheers!
PS Subbed!
Hi Chris, thank you very much for your interest in my channel and for subs!!! In the room I prefer the greenback, if I had to choose only 1.
Well done and very informative video!
Thank you!
I'm amazed how much the GB sounds like the Blue for clean tones. The Blue was the most "open" sounding, almost like there was more depth and space in the sound spectrum. The GB was very much like the Blue but less "airy" or slightly more "damped". I'm not sure how much that slight difference would translate in a live situation, so I'm wondering if I can get away with the cheaper GB and get the sound of a Blue that I like. The distorted tones are where the GB sounds different from the Blue. The Blue remained open with slightly more bass and slightly crispier highs. Since I already have a G12EVH (Heritage Greenback), I'm thinking I'll try the Blue next. Thanks for the great video!
Thank you! Well, I'm currently gravitating towards a solution that combines two different speakers: for comping (clean or distorted) I'm combining Blue and Green (mixed left and right) and for soloing it depends...I'm still not sure...once I finish evaluating I'm gonna posting a video... Nevertheless, nowadays everybody combines different mics with the same speaker: in order to obtain a more original tone, I would like to combine different speakers in different situations (lead or comping)..because I think that they are complementing each other pretty amazingly... It's just an idea...and I've used this approach in this video: ua-cam.com/video/hLjuVqix1nw/v-deo.html. I would like to know your opinion also ... if you will... thank you once more!!!
@@LeoGibsonGtr So, I've been mixing two speaker types in my 2x12 cabinets for the past year now. I'm doing this for live situations and I'm going for what sounds best to my ears. I'm transitioning over to the Vox MV50 amps because they fit on my pedal board. One amp for clean/overdrive and another amp for overdrive/distorted tones, each with its own 2x12 (easier to carry than 4x12). I mixed a G12EVH with a Peavey Scorpion, and that combination was nice with the Vox "Rock" amp. I mixed a G12H Anniversary with a Peavey Scorpion for the Vox "AC" amp, and that combination worked well also, but I'm still trying different things. When mixing speakers, I noticed that to my ear the ones that sounded nice for clean didn't sound nice for distortion and vice versa. I saw that they were selling certain combinations online, and I decided to try what they did. Right now I've combined the G12EVH and G12H Anniversary (recommended mix for blues/overdrive) with the Vox "Rock" amp, and it's much louder (100dB SPL) and a good combo. I also have combined the G12T75 and G12V30 (recommended mix for hard rock/distortion) with the Vox "AC" amp, and it's also much louder (100dB SPL) and nice for clean tones. I'm considering the Alnico Blue to replace the V30 because it's always seemed a bit harsh in the mid-range. I'm hoping the Blue will be smoother in the mid-range while also staying loud (100dB SPL). So far, the most versatile and pleasing in most situations has been the G12EVH. The V30 only sounds good in recordings. The G12T75 has been versatile also, it can do anything acceptably, but not excel, even in my 4x12. That's one thing people say also, that nothing compares to a 4x12, no matter what speaker it is. What is your opinion of V30 vs. Blue in live a situation? Thanks for the great video!
great video but which celestion greeback was exactely used? there are different ones.
Hi, thank you, it's a Celestion G12M-25 Greenback 16 Ohm
Always employ G12T-75s from Ipswich. Can’t go wrong with ‘em.
I'm looking for an IRs for a Fender Twin Reverb amp for clean and crystal clear tones, which one would you recommend among these or maybe some other Celestion?
For clean tone (jazzy style) I would recommend a Jensen speaker IR (there is one in my IR packet here: www.leogibsonguitar.com/shop-online/p/leo-essential-irs
Thank you!
excellent... looks like there are a few amps there to choose from :) noticed the Marshall head was on @ 8:10. Is that what was used? Also I may have missed it, did you wire them up in a conventional series-parallel configuration?
Hi Albert, the amp I'm using is a Marshall SC20 (basically a JCM 800), I've not change the wiring of the original Blackstar cab, I've just changed the speakers. Thank you for your question!
Hard to tell from my side but from ur side wonder witch one u found more versatile or the one with most midrange?
Maybe the more versatile and mid raingy is the Greenback. I tipically use greenbacks for comping and V30 for solo...
Thank you for your message!
@@LeoGibsonGtr thanks brother ✌
You are welcome!
So who wins ?
The one you like the most...😀
Loved the video. Thanks. This reaffirmed my love for Greenbacks. It is also the cheapest of the whole bunch! The voice of Rock n'Roll.
I can hear the "sound" of the cab, minimising the differences between speakers. Is the cab birch ply?
Which creamback?
My takeaway? Get a quality Celestion and you’ll be in good shape. Nice video!
Thank you! Appreciated!!!
Great video
Thank you Chad, really appreciated!
I wanted to hear them all together! And why did you choose to place each speaker where you did?
Hi Mark, there is not a specific reason why I put each speacker in each position...you can place where you want. Yes...I should do a part 2 with combination of speacker... I need to find the time...thank you for your message!
What's the best colour for playing early Metallica songs ?
Hi, among the 4 of this video, I would say V30...but I'm not sure
Thank you for your question!
I really don t like the V30s.....Like all the others. I wanted to buy a orange ppc212 cabinet, but they come with v30s.....Shit mannnnn. We should be able to specify the speakers we want when buying a cabinet from them. No way i m getting V30s. Great test as usual Leo. Thanks mate !
You are welcome! I'm happy to have been of some help!
Cream back sounded the worse to me, followed by the vintage 30. The greenback sounded the most balanced but I thought the alnico blue had the best clean tone out of all, awesome video man! I’m going green back!
Thank you Killian! Another option is to combine them...for instance an Alnico Blue with a Greenback... I'm currently experimenting with different combinations... with a lot of fun...😊
I am interested to hear what they all sounded like together! could you gig with a cab like that?
Hi... well, you can gig...but in my opinion all 4 together are not the best solution: for instance I like the Greenback pared with the Alnico, but other combination does not sound so good in my opinion. On the other hand this cab is.a valuable solution for recording...still in my opinion. Thank you for your message!!!
@@LeoGibsonGtr no, thank you for the very well thought out video and your reply! If you were building a 2x12 would you mix speakers or stick to one?
Hi Dave, I would mix...also in a 4x12 cab, but at max with two speakers types, for instance two Alnico and two Greenback.
I have all celestion speakers the blue 15ohm is the best
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion and experience!
Green back for me
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion!
Is it me or V30 and blue are very close?
Hi, in my opinion the difference is not night to day, but subtle
Thank you for your message!
The V30 was designed to behave like an alnico speaker apparently? I notice results vary.
Very Well Made Video. This is Personal and although I think the Greenback, the blues and the V30 each have something special to give the CreambackM has some kind of Congestioned Mids through MY ears. Maybe a H magnet either a Greenback 30h or the CreamBack75h (that I actually prefer to the GreenbackH30) would have something different to the others (very open sounding, tight bass, pristine highs. Slightly less mids buts gives great fullness to the sound. Others that I have curiosity to hear someday compared is the Original Creamback the g12 65 (www.thomann.de/pt/celestion_g12_65_8_ohm.htm)
Great comparison. Lots of work went into this! But just one advice, as I hope it’s not too late already:
I became nervous as you screwed in the new speakers with the power drill!
Man, that’s done by hand and with a small screwdriver! The force you can bring up with two fingers is enough. Just screw them in until they touch the chassis and then tighten them in an X-pattern a maximum 3/4 turn from there! The gasket sealing will build up enough pressure to secure them from there or if you’re afraid of them becoming loose, use drop of nailpolish on the screw and let it dry for 15min.
If you tighten them with a powerdrill you have very likely deformed the chassis already which leads to an oval or other way uneven speaker movement. This can cause frequencies to peak, other frequencies to die almost completely.
I had a 4x12 1960A with Vintage 30 in it which were tightened to the point where the steel chassis touched the wood. The cab sounded harsh an very ice-picky. I then de-mounted all four speakers, bend the chassis back straight in about two hours of concentrated work and screwed them back in with just the right amount of force. Was a Night and day change, the harshness went away almost completely and the bottom end increased. As if the speakers were free to travel where they wanted now.
Hi Kevin, first of all thank you for your post, these are great advices! I was pretty careful not to tighten the screws too much and the screw driver I'm using is very sensitive, I mean you can run it pretty slow just not pressing too much. I will check out once more, as I did it many months ago, but I'm using this cab all the time and I'm pretty happy with the result. Thank you once more for you comment and your interest in my channel: your post is very useful for other guitarists who maybe want to built something similar!
Hey:) Good That you take it as an advice, and not critical:)
If you’re happy everything will be fine:) have fun and keep up the great work on this channel!
Sure Kevin, I appreciate good advices well written and with good intentions like yours! It's actually a very good advice for all the guitarists who are watching the video! Thank you once more!
BLUES EVERY TIME!
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion!
Great video, a hard work well done!
I have a 50 watts Gurus Cicognani monoclean head, with Preamp tubes 2x12AX7/ECC83 and
Power tubes 2x5881/6L6GC; I would like to match it with a 2x12 open back cabinet for more airy sound.
I play in a band with another guitarist, a bassist, a drummer, a singer, and our music genre goes from rock-pop to mid-gain rock.
I'm so undecided among 2 Vintage 30, 2 Greenbacks G12M 25 or 2 Creambacks M65, and I have only the possibility to purchase them online without trying them first: I'd like a good sound that cut through the mix without being too trebly or harsh in a band sound.
In your experience, and taking in consideration all the particulars written above, which speakers do you suggest among those three?
P.s. At the moment I can't do a mix of different speakers in the same cab, maybe in the future
Hi, thank you for your message and your interest in my channel! This is a pretty hard question to answer. I've changed mind and opinions many times: there was a time when I was all in for Vintage 30, then Greenbacks, than vintage 30 again....I can tell you that currently I've come to this set up: Greenbacks for distorted sounds and Jensen for clean tones. And I think that the Vintage 30 is a good compromise between the two if you cannot bring with you two different types of cabs...so tipically for live use. Please take into consideration that I can change my mind in future...as I already did many times...:) even becaouse it also dipends by the amp you I'm using.
Thank you once more for your question and please, if you want, let me know you final choiche!
@@LeoGibsonGtr Thanks for the kind and detailed answer! Maybe there is only one thing to do: the famous German site allows to try music gear and return them if you are not satisfied, I should take a cab with Greenbacks and a cab with V30, and then decide. For Creambacks of mixing speakers, I will give them a try in the future...
That's a good idea...I'm pretty curious to know your final decision...so, if you want, please share it with us! Thank you once more!
Creambackkkk
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion!
Great playing bro
Thank you, when you like my playing...I'm happy!!!