How Israel STOLE Palestine
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 тра 2021
- We often hear that Israel and Palestine is a complicated issue. It's actually not, and here's why.
We take it back to the beginning and find out the history of how Israel got it wrong from the very start when it comes to Palestine.
Since the occupation of Gaza , over 20,000 people have been killed.
If you enjoy OnePath content, please consider supporting us to grow! ►onepathnetwork.com/dollar-a-d...
Download the OnePath Network App for access to the latest and exclusive videos:
onepath.onelink.me/mJxr/3de973bd
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @onepathnetwork
Facebook ►: / onepathnetwork
Instagram ►: / onepathnetwork
Patreon ►: / onepathnetwork
I’ve been trying to figure this conflict out. The problem is every video has a different narrative.
Just learn history, Israel lost its land thousands years ago, this info alone is enough to understand it should not exist and It would creatw conflic if suddenly to they take the land. It is like if my country suddenly claim our land from 1000 years ago, taking over parts of 5 different current countries.
@@michalviktorin6758 The problem is Palestine was never a country. It was always a territory or nation under someones occupation. The same moment the British were to recognize the Palestine as an independent state they recognized Israel instead for to them known reasons.
Later on (only after Israel!) Palestine was recognized and started (for the first time!) to exist as a country.
And of course it was raising tensions as nation of Palestine was significant and was properly feeling forsaken and decieved.
The problem is that it was all the time Palestinians starting conflicts - even if after ruthless and unlawful acts of discrimination done by Israelis - and it always was loosing.
And each time it was loosing more and more, even though Israel was the part that was stopping itself, turning back its' forces.
Yet the problem is not that Palestinians were waging war - that was to be expected, even if not fully proper - the problem is that Palestine was and still is (!) ruled by terrorist organizations, that not only doesn't recognize Israel as a country, but also are exicitly telling they will use terror and kill Israelis indiscriminately.
So it do is complicated - you in general should never trust someone who claims otherwise...
It is so as oppressed Palestinian nation is trying to reach for more they could be possibly able to get, with claims for it that are not really well justified although rational... and it's doing so by any means without any will for peace or being satisfied with what they were given - which was not much, but much more than they ever had.
On the other hand we have Israel, which is protecting what they are really able to protect with easy - but also overusing the power they have to seize what shouldn't be theirs after each such defence - in counter attack. Even if not attacking as first - often provoking the other side quite heavily...
And even more importantly - breaking human laws of Palestines by having discriminative policies, trials and being responsible for driving Palestinian population out of their homes when Israel was created.
Yet on the other hand it's not strange they wanted to build a wall around nation that is leading an active terrorist attacks and not even willing to recognize them as a nation...
@michalviktorin6758 it's sounds evil to take people's lands like that.super evil devil like work.
It’s very simple. Jewish Zionists have tried to force Palestinians out of their homeland for decades. Israel has been supplied with high-tech militia by the West, whilst the Palestinians have had barely anything to defend themselves with. Yet to this day, Israel has not managed to fully take Palestine. It’s practically a miracle that Palestine is still standing their ground. It was never a conflict. Israel was holding a sword to Palestine’s neck. But the media is owned by Zionists, so all that is shown in mainstream news is propaganda. Now , that Palestine has made an attempt to retaliate against the heinous crimes of Israel, they have been painted as the terrorists. Israel is the terrorist. Even real Orthodox Jews stand against Israel with us. As Muslims, we have been told by Allah that Palestine will be free, and we will do our very best to help our brothers and sisters 🇵🇸
@@michalviktorin6758but it is their land and they won it back… it’s a success story which you Muslim can’t accept, history have show everything you Muslim have touched turned into shyt.
There’s an old Indian proverb:
If you see 2 fish in a pond fighting...a British just walked by.
British colonism ends in a planned conflict amongst colonised races. Deepest pain they gave to India of partition
Perfectly said
So true that the British also gave this conflict to my country china and your country. The McMahon line which is conceived by the very same guy who deceived the Arabians.
Can't agree more
By this point though, you can't really blame the British anymore. It's externalizing the blame.
Don’t trust a Chanel that doesn’t cover everything. They pick what will help their cause.
Lol, you've said it all
oh yeah ? give proof what can help the israelis cause please tell me im listening
"hey don't trust the Muslims because they're biased... trust the Israelis instead"
@@theglowingmaster he didn’t cover other parts of history, that’s why I said that. If you didn’t notice what else he missed then you need to do some research.
@@War-lock47 i mean if we thinked about it we need evidence that supports palestine and evidence that supports israel right ?
me personaly i see that everything is full loud and clear in the video please tell me if something is missing ?
Yes it is complicated. And it seems you left out a lot of details, including the Balfour Declaration, the San Remo Conference, and the Paris Peace Conference, to name a few.
And Hamas using civilians as meat shields, and the fact Israel owned the land long before Palestine, etc
Israel is evil state
@@thedomainofsealteamaqua israhell is the one doing that. More people died from israhellish gunfire than Hamas Resistance Army on october the 7th
@@thedomainofsealteamaquathat doesn't matter
@@mamo7636 using people as meat shields doesn’t matter? Your comp,aiming about civilian casualties and it doesn’t matter? Wow,hypocrites.
Teacher: "What is the cause for all problems in the world?"
Me, An Intellectual : THE BRITISH!!!
As someone who lives in Britan I can confirm this is true.
It is undoubtedly unequivocally true!!!
true.. period
A bit simplistic for an intellectual, but than again you are probably a muslim...
You mean British politicians. Not the actual british
Lol “Let’s go back to the beginning 1916” 😂😂 oh yea that’s totally the beginning
Hahaha. Agreed man. Story changes depends when the "beginning" is.
They are here to spread propaganda. Don't expect much truth from this channel.😑😑
How come he didn't mention that the land he calls Palestine was originally called Judeah and that the name "Palestini" now Palestine, was given to it by the Romans.
@@HHHGeorge what’s also interesting is the word Palestine evolved from ancient word of few languages: Egyptian, Hebrew, Greek, Latin. It meant either wanderer or invader. So it’s ironic that Jews are branded as the colonizers when the very meaning of the word Palestine suggests otherwise.
@@hanh3000you better delete this comment or hamas apologist will start commenting nonsense.
Best part of the video was when they said for unknown reasons Jewish peolle felt a need to migrate in the 1930s and 1940s
What could have been happening in the world to drive the need for this?
😂
"For some bizarre reason the 2 superpowers that spent the last few years fighting a country hell bent on erasing the Jewish people from existence recognised a country set up to be a place where Jews will always be safe"
It’s a mystery that will never be solved🙄
Thanks for that. You just saved me a load of nerve-wrecking.
Ironically, Arab leaders like Al-Husseyni foolishly supported the Nazi persecution of Jews in Europe, thus encouraging Jewish migration to Palestine, in defiance of British efforts to limit such immigration. In Haifa one finds a museum honoring these "illegal immigrants",
"Let's start from the beginning."
- Starts in post WW1
- Completely ignores the 3000+ years of history prior
What else happened before
Loool omg yes, “the beginning” even though the history pre dates the Bible
@@jalalelsakka3560 Literally all of human history.
yep, i read the title over again and instantly laughed
@@freethehostages1 explain to me how he’s incorrect please
The fails to mention the Balfour Declaration where the British promised Jewish leaders could return to their homeland if they supported the British in WW1. Also, when the video mentions most Jews arrived just a few years before 1947. It leaves out the fact that they had just survived the Holocaust.
To created other Holocaust!
Now they inflict a genocide on poor Palestinians
Also fails to mention that the land is holy for the Jews (and Christians), also that the Muslims took the land from Christians before that, and they from the Jews, and many others had it over the history of the region too, and lastly that even before ww1 and Zionism, and everything else, there where ALWAYS Islamic pogroms against the local Jews... But, you know, just 'unimportant details' when you want to paint the picture in one color.
@@mkzhero this isn't a fire hydrant and who ever peed on it first is the owner lol 🤣.
They had no Homeland
The problem in understanding Israel and Palestine issue is historical amnesia. You can begin at certain time period and suddenly the villain changes. And funny thing is it holds for both the parties.
You are right but the only scenario that can’t never be true is that God give the land to the Jews. Also the Bible study about Jews going into exile can’t be accepted as European people who simply adopted of converted to the religion claiming that they are the biblical Jews.
Noone in the west thinks they are Jews, we do however understand that white westernets all come from the Jewish bloodlines and are infact Israelis not Jews. Don't break your head trying to understand, buy a bible and read it
How could Palestinians in any point be at fault
@@janjakdesalin4236 Thank You! Somebody finally said it.
No. The Jews were slaves in Egypt.
2:05 it wasnt out of nowhere, the jews and brits were fighting together in the war, and were into a point where they were allies, and for that balfur the brit gave 100% support in a letter he wrote for the jews to establish a jewish national land for the jewish population in what was called palestine.
historians dont debate it, its proven fact that the jews and brits were fighting together at that time, and that why.
Blame the Ottoman Empire of losing world war 1. And blame the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and the decline of Islam. Ataturk might have some role in it. Blame the British in 1948. And blame the Arabs for walking away from a two state solution.
Might is right. Winner rewrite history. That's a fact of life.
Winner by what, ethnic cleansing and genocide. The Arabs liberated the land, so it was rightfully theirs. They have also lived there since 2000 years ago, when the Jews left after the Romans invaded
The winners always make promises they can't keep to win these wars.
Blame the violence, breakdown and civil war in the mandate, Jews being forced to draw guns all on the Arabs.
If the Ottomans kept it there would be no Jews and no Arabs they would "disappear" as did the Armenians, Greeks and Assyrians.
@@_UA-cam-User_ this is pure bullshit. The ottomans controlled the Balkans for over 550 years and all ethnicities that were there are still there.
The situation isn’t complicated, speaking about it without getting cancelled is complicated. (For the west)
Very well said . I’m going to use this statement 👍🏽
It gets complicated when the question is raised whether Israel should be allowed to defend themself. The Iron Dome is not good enough. A good offense is a good defense. A good offense prevents future attacks or deters. Or it exhausts the enemies military equipment to the point of defenselessness. Whether Israel should exist or not, they still have a right to defend themselves, they don't have to let innocent civilians in Israel.get killed by Hamas rockets. And you're crazy if you think innocent Israeli civilians should die. Simply them being there illegally and occupying that land is not a sufficient reason to attack them.
@R35 none of that should result in Hamas firing at Israel though.
@R35 innocent civilians are not being targeted unless you mean the protests and evictions, but the missiles were specifically targeted for Hamas militants and bases.
Sup Saim S.
I always see you in comments of many videos, nice seeing u bud
Historical fact; The Romans changed the name of Judea to Syria Palaestinia in 135 AD after the Bar Kokhva Revolt, which is sometimes called the Third Jewish-Roman War. At the same time, the Romans expelled most Jews from the province. The purpose was to destroy the cultural identity of the province, and spread the Jews throughout the empire in order to prevent another revolt.
exactly right thank you for saying this
Fact: doesn't justify genocide and ethnic cleansing.
Yes, it does not justify what the HAMAS terrorist did and have been doing.@@mahalebdeh3153
@@mahalebdeh3153 what ethnic cleansing is happening here?? are you on of those historical facts deniers who rely on useless terms to make a point?? if truly palestinians are being ethnically cleansed then why are they still alive?? i bet you won't answer that.
@@mahalebdeh3153 Maybe don't take land thats not yours then
Whenever people attempt to explain this conflict and start in 1800..1900... they miss it. It starts with Abraham.
Well if you start anywhere it still favors Israel lol. There were very few people living in the area and the Jews literally created all of the communities in most of that area. Most “Palestinians” are actually Arab settlers who came after the Jews built everything from basically ruins. This is a fact by the way. This whole narrative is all made up, and most of the reason the Muslims wanted to invent this history is because their true goals were to not have Jews living nearby. The Jews didn’t take any land ever except after they were almost genocided and they mostly just wanted buffer land to prevent attacks. Now, the land where Israel was partitioned was nothing special and was basically ruins. When Israel was partitioned, it was when there was an overall Muslim majority and their current leader was a Nazi Supporter. He actually send letters to Hitler begging him to help genocide the Jews in Palestine. Israel wasn’t just given land for no reason, it was because there was no other choice. If the Palestinians were openly genocidal then it could have worked out. But the “Palestinians” by that point they were not really any of the natives who lived there before the 1900s. So there you have it, that’s why things happened how they did. I can explain more to you if you’d like :). I’m also open for evidence against what I am saying as well as historical counts or things. But the fact is Israel did not settle anywhere where there were many people.
Abraham Lincoln? Lmfao
Explain??
No that’s wrong, the myths of the Bible have almost nothing to do with this conflict. It’s just mostly used to deflect and obfuscate about Israel’s false claims.
BS. - Nothing justifies what you’ve done to the Palestinians. Who cares if you were there during ancient times? This is modern times. You forced those people out of their homes and into prison camps.
Absolutely wrote his own history of this situation please people do your research and make your own decisions
Just shut your western mouth up I am begging 🙏🏻
Exactly! Israel was way way way here before Palestine. Makes me sick how much he’s deceiving the young generation
If Video clips isnt enough then I don't know what is @@ItsJustSherirea
Why is he even telling this ridiculous, distorted, deliberately biased version of history? Even he must know this is rubbish.
Yes. If you go to Israel and actually see what’s happening ( i havn’t but know people who have) you stop being pro-Hamas (not that i ever was)
skipped:
1921 Jaffa riots
1929 Hebron massacre
1936 The Bloody Day in Jaffa
1938 Tiberias massacre
1939 Arab revolt in Palestine
1948 Arab-Israeli War
1950 Palestinian Fedayeen insurgency
1956 Suez Crisis
1967 Six-Day War
1970 War of Attrition
1973 Yom Kippur War
1980 Palestinian insurgency in South Lebanon
1982 1982 Lebanon War
1985 South Lebanon conflict
1987 First Intifada
2005 Second Intifada
2006 Lebanon War
2008 Gaza War
2012 Israeli operation in the Gaza Strip
2014 Gaza War
2021 Israel-Palestine crisis
2023 Hamas Massacres (Newly Added to the uncomplicated situation, 😭)
but its not complicated... trust me
and even before that when the ottomans sold land back to jewish people
@@AbdillahibnYusha but... the muslims were the ones that took it by force in the first place. im sure the israelis just switched to islam on their own and built the al aqsa mosque without any conquest :)
@@AbdillahibnYusha please tell me this is bait, “the jews originate in iraq” what is the etymology of judaism please tell me? and i’m sure the first temple was also in mesopotamia right? and king solomon, he was also from mesopotamia right?
@@AbdillahibnYusha the jews believed in abraham, but there is no evidence that he was ever a person. and who abraham was varies from who you actually ask, sure islam, christianity and judaism all believe in abraham, but different versions of him. Ibrahim pbuh was believed to have constructed the kaaba in islam, but in christianity he was never believed to have even stepped foot in modern day arabia, going from harran to caanan. the torah does speak of altars built by abraham but all of them were in caanan and not in mecca.
and even if abraham was from babylon, that doesn’t mean the religion itself was founded in iraq.
@@Slinkaiur dumb
You left out the part where 2/3 of the area was given to create Jordan.
That's another dumpster fire
Can you explain? Was it given to create jordans for Palestinians?
@hosseinafshari3947 For all Arabs. They protested it all becoming Isreal so Churchill, before he was Prime Minister, drew a line at the Jordan river and earmarked that area to be Arab. Then the same for Syria, then for southern Lebanon, then for the Sinai pennesula to satisfy Egypt. Then, after the holocaust, half of the small area remaining was made Isreal. The rest was designated as international. The fay after Isreal was established every surrounding area declared war on the Jews. A tiny sliver of the area once called palestine became Isreal. The rest was used to establish new Arab states and expand others. But even a tiny Jewish presence was impossible for Arabs to tolerate. So from then until today they have been determined to extinguish the Jewish people. The whole thing, "from the river to the sea" has been to kill Jews. It's never been about creating nations in the region (occupier, colonist) and it's never been about Arab displacement (genocide, aparthide) it is and always has been about Jew hatred. Same as those German Nationals of 1938.
@@hosseinafshari3947 NO. Jordan will not let any Palestinians in
@@stephenbaughman3006 True. The Arabs that align with the label 'Palestinian' are rejected by all Arab nations, Muslim or not. Their culture of violence as the answer to their problems has them unwelcome.
"The beginning" he says and goes back to ww1.
Palestinians were not told about Sykes Picot agreement or the Balfour Declaration until years later. They were also not involved in discussions on the partition in 1948
That's what happens when you forget to declare independence like a civilized nation.
Why should Palestine exist? They were nazi supporters.
Nonsense. The Balfour declaration was published in the British press roughly a week after it was issued.
I'm still wondering why the Palestinians deserve a country. They sided with Germany and lost.
which Palestinians - was there a land called Palestine back in 1948?? It is news to me
Your leaving out a great many details. First the people in this region did not start calling themselves Palestinian until much later, they referred to themselves as Arabs. The Peel Commission of 1937 was going to give the Jews 20% of the land and the other 80% to the Arabs. The Arabs refused. In 1947 the British government asked the UN to divide the land and again the Jews accepted but the Arabs said no. It was shortly after this that Egypt, Jordan, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon launched a war which Israelis won but what is known today as the West Bank was still controlled by Jordon.
20 yrs later Egypt, Jordan and Syria launched the 6 Days War which Israel won. It was at this point in time that the Arabs of the area started calling themselves Palestinians. Israel offered Egypt the Gaza region back and the West Bank region back to Jordan in exchange for peace. This was refused. A few months later the Arab League came out with their "3 No's" No recognition of Israel, No Peace with Israel and No negotiation with Israel.
In 200 Bill Clinton at Camp David tried to broker a deal, Israel PM Barak offered Arafat all of Gaza, 94% of the West Bank and East Jerusalem for the Palestinian Capital. Arafat said NO. In 2008, another peace deal was tried and Israel PM Olmert offered all of Gaza, 94% of the West Bank and East Jerusalem as Captial along with other lands and Palestinian leader Abbas said NO.
They have been offered a 2 state solution for decades and each time the Palestinian leaders have refused.
Yup. This is some weak propaganda. I find it offensive that he makes no mention of the Holocaust, which was a major reason for the approval of the creation of a Jewish state. Excluding a world event as important as the Holocaust feels passively antisemitic, which makes sense given that the Palestinian leaders are all Holocaust deniers.
You sont want to go down this path. The 1911 Brittanica Encyclopedia includes Palestine but doesnt include Israel.
@@luckieolp So you get to genocide and replace a people of the same happened to you before? Does that mean I can steal from you if someone stole from me? Are you a child?
It’s irrelevant what Arabs called themselves. They were still expelled to create Israel. They still existed.
Israel should have only occupied the West Bank instead of putting in settlements. It’s dumb to put up a wall to separate yourself from another people you have problems with and simultaneously create communities in the middle of those same people. If I have problems with John then I stay away from John. I don’t move next door to John.
Of course, Israel is trying to squeeze the Palestinians out through harassment and violence. Anything more overt would create to much of a backlash.
Somewhat baffling that people have the audacity to say that 'oh we Jews (who came from all around Europe, mostly) wanted to only take 20% of the land but they refused and we were promised 56% of the land (even though we were only a third of the population) but they still said no, we were willing to give them back a portion of their previous land (just not the whole piece of land) but they still said no, we have been a peaceful bunch'. They had every single right to say no to any of the proposals because it was their country their land so do you think it's valid if I told you that my great great great great grandparents used to live in your house, pointing a gun at your head, saying that I only wanted a small portion of your house, I wanted to live peacefully with you here, would you think I was lunatic to suggest something like that?
Yeah the whole world felt sorry and still do feel sorry for the Holocaust survivors and other Jews who went through hell during that period of time but it does not make it alright to not only settle in another group of people's land but declare it their own
A crash course on history of PALESTINIAN STATE:
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, NOT a Palestinian state!
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, NOT a Palestinian state!
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, NOT a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, NOT a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, NOT a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, NOT a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, NOT a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, NOT a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, NOT a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, NOT a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, NOT a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, NOT a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, NOT a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, NOT a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
What exactly are you saying? I want to make sure I follow you correctly
TRUTH@@ChristopherVPepe
@@ChristopherVPepehe saying there is more to the story then this video
@@stephenhoward7454 so I think I mean do you favor a Palestinian state?
@@ChristopherVPepethe full history before 1900 lol
Who founded Judea. In the 934BC?
Why would that matter? Are you saying the romans own everything in the world now? Are you saying the people in Mexico should be able to take over the U.S.? We are talking about modern day history. No one cares what the cave men did.
antiquities history and event logic almost nothing Judea not that important or big + jews just random Tribes who lost their true language by time that They spread across the land
Torah never mentioned Palestine
Bible never mentioned Palestine
Quran never mentioned Palestine
From when Palestine exist?
Lol, they are delusional my brother
hm from where every country got its name ?
from the bible ?
from the torah ?
from the quran ?
no my friend they get their name from their minds and your country applies to that its an idea a name and there was many mentions like in Genesis 15, Exodus 23, Numbers 34 and Ezekiel 47.
@@theglowingmaster the bible mention Israel, Egypt, India, Ethopia, Turkey, Iran, Roman Empire, Greece, Espagne, Cannan, There other kingdom who gone in present
The Romans Empire was collapse but the still have they word in Latin
@@MathelyHelliga umm really to be honest i dont care about whats this new muslims state is gonna be named palestine ect ... but the most important is that the natives have the full right to claim their land without any occupation
Palestine exists and people who don't want to accept it have to deal with it.
only Palestine exists.
Before 1947 even a palestinians didnt call themselvs palestinians. This is a name of region gived by by roman imperator Adrian in 9th century BCE
Golda Meir did though..... had a "Palestinian Passport" in her own words.
@@geoffreyselvage1673 Yes. A british passport issued by Britannia. And also who was president in palestine before 48?
@@Stefan86g Excuse me??? What kind of passport was it again? Issued by the British like the Balfour Declaration.
@@geoffreyselvage1673 Not the same thing. It was because when the British took control, there was mandated Arab Palestine and Jewish Palestine, but the Arab people were not called Palestinians. In fact, they rejected being called that until 1964 when it became a political designation.
@@gmh471 What do the maps call the area btw prior to 1947? Golda Meir said that she had a Palestinian passport? Whatever was she talking about?
when you’re so filled with hate and ignorance you rewrite history
Ikr, this video is a load of BS, it excludes a TON of very important facts. The history videos from pragerU, Ben Shapiro (yes, even Ben Shapiro) and travellingisrael are so, so much better. This video is only fueling the idiots who don’t know history, by teaching them history that’d been picked and chosen from.
Finally SOMEONE who does not get their Information from Starbucks!
@@blennboy1025 Pretty sure you are gen Z knowing nothing abt history
Wow, just wow.
@@theglobalist9059it doesn't matter when you were born it only matters if you have common sense, in this scenario he has.
Did you graduate from taco bell
Does the truth make you feel some sort of way?
@@amandahugenkissbro acted confused as to why superpowers recognised a Jewish state less than a decade after the biggest war in history with one of the main reasons being to kill all Jews, if ignoring the holocaust counts as history I know what kind of man you are
@@amandahugenkiss The Kingdom of Israel existed roughly from around 1020 BCE to 922 BCE, following the United Monarchy under King Saul, King David, and King Solomon. After Solomon's death, the kingdom split into the northern Kingdom of Israel and the southern Kingdom of Judah.Meanwhile,Islam began in the early 7th century CE, specifically in 610 CE when the prophet Muhammad received the first revelation from God, according to Islamic tradition.this event marked the beginning of Islam as religious and social movement
@@amandahugenkiss "Palestine" word originates from Latin language used by Romans to describe the region around that time kingdom of Israel and The Kingdom of Israel predates the use of the Latin word "Palestine" by several centuries. The Kingdom of Israel emerged around the 11th century BCE, while the term "Palestine" originated from the Roman province of Judea, which was established much later, during Roman rule in the region, around the 1st century BCE.
@@amandahugenkiss he’s neglecting to share historical facts on purpose. He’s being very bias. I want whatever you’re smoking lady.
"They got 55% of the land" yeah Swamps and a massive desert in the South. Forgot to mention that
Remember kids!
Bias is a huge part of historical reports.
If it’s biased you can assume it’s not 100% accurate due to the party presenting the issue naturally showing favour to a side. Therefore only reporting on incident supporting their argument.
Remember this when looking into any historical information.
Accurate information is presented with total neutrality to accurately reflect both sides and get to the facts while avoiding emotional manipulation.
Critical thinking, a tool taught in schools but so rarely used.
@@maidaayah2580 Infact he wrote a book called Mein Kampf that he used to convince people that he knew the best way to get Germany out of their ww1 debt. Which included the idea that a superior race existed which lead to the systematic murder of minority religious groups and ethnic groups in his country. Other wise known as the holocaust. Maybe you’ve heard of it?
Yeah, Hitlers bias lead to the mass murder of innocent people.
Thank you for helping me prove my point with a good example of the dangers behind a biased source of information.
@@maidaayah2580 can give a parallel with ukrainians, who where fighting with Germany against USSR in WW2. (im a ukrainian so know these things as well). Everything is pretty subjectively, USSR (Russia) had a rural policy to Ukraine with narative that we dont have our own culture, language, religion (those all things they saying even now). And for some ppl in Ukraine in that time USSR was a better choice with common mentality, principles etc. But other part of ppl were pissed of cuz they where trying to identify as only own ukrainian nation. So Hitler proposed that Ukraine is gonna be as a part of German Empire in the near future with "guarantees" that we are save own culture. So ofc after WW2 a lot bad things showed up about "Hitler policy" in Europe: tortures etc. But after WW2 over USSR started a "big company" of russinization in ukrainian territories: ukrainian writters were sent to Siberia and tortured ( most of em were killed in a couple years), ukrainian music was prohibited as a ukrainian language and a lot of things. So nowadays ukrainians have some big problems as corruption, mentality of ppl: "are you fighting for your country or "just" working in job and "donating to the army?", separating of ppl who talks in ukranian or russian languages (historically that happened for a lot of reasons). And the main quastion is: If Hitler won maybe Ukraine would have another "european" life from now? And were those "ukranian nationalist", who been a part of Hitlers army in Ukraine, right about ideology or we can call em "nazists"? Everything is super subjectively
wat
critical thinking is not taught in american schools, at least not directly
It’s funny you say critical thinking is taught in school when education deliberately teaches you to not question authority and history is written by the victors correct ? According to history books 9/11 is going to go down as a terrorist attack but I know this not to be true and I didn’t need a education to come to that conclusion I used my eyes and common sense. Everything must be questioned the media never tells the truth there is always and underlying agenda. So take your “education” and stick up your big fat booty hole
If this guy told me my name I’d check my birth certificate
😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣👍
😂😂😂😂😂😂
No doubts that palestinians have suffered from the exodus. However, keeping fighting and claiming the destruction of Israel (see Hamas..) is unrealistic and irresponsible at this point. Negotiate with Israel to get recognized as an independent State, with the commitment to stop the Hamas/Hezbollah guerrillas looks the only reasonable possibility
Now the situation is far more worse but Arab countries leader are silent and failure to their basic job.
not all Arab countries are like this.
you did forget to address the Jordanian occupation of the west bank and the Egyptian occupation of the Gaza strip until 1967, on both cases no Independence was given by them to the local Arabs.
It’s not occupation if Muslims or Arabs rule the land. It’s why they say the British occupied but the Ottomans ruled.
@@edwinlucianofrias1643 true. the basic misconception is that Jordanian = Egyptian = Palestinian. it is like saying Japanese = Chinese. those are different groups with a different agendas, I fail to see why an occupation of a Muslim over other Muslim is OK while the other options are not. if the basic concept is that occupation in general is wrong it is about time to point a finger at the Jordanian kingdom which treat its local Palestinian like second class citizens and preventing them from being a part of this country. why no one is talking about this matter?
Hahaha here is the lie on black and white it's all about religion wars with Muslims lol!! No such thing palestine never was and never will be
@@chenkarp arabs are arabs chinese are not japanese
@@samer.a nope.
You lost me at “just trust me” 😂
That is what religious people say. Just follow me blindly and you will get to paradise. Anyone that disagrees is the devil testing your faith.
Youd almost feel bad for all these babies that got indoctrinated sinse birth
never trust a muslim
Where was he wrong?
he also said "out of nowhere" 😂
Sure but there are proofs to back why isreal is in the wrong
Today I’ll make pasta with chicken and cheese sauce
I was playing this one game for the summer, so I ended up getting real cool with these two guys, we play everyday & talk everyday anyways one of them was Jewish he was born & raised in Israel, anyways one day towards the end of summer he was telling us how that was he’s last week playing, cause he was about to join the army which I didn’t know was mandatory,so ofc I got all sad man!! I won’t play with my friend no more anyways I’m telling him dude don’t go & he told me how he didn’t want to I ask why & he said tbh It doesn’t feel right I don’t agree with what my country is doing.I was 16 I didn’t know about the whole Palestine & Israel conflict so he told me about it & yeah he pretty much told me how he didn’t agree with what his country was doing & how the Palestinian people are pretty much treat it like ish, thanks to that conversation I started doing my research & I educated myself.
I think you forgot to mention some historical facts on purpose, when five Arab nations invaded territory immediately following the announcement of the independence of the state of Israel on May 14, 1948.
On October 6, 1973, Egypt and Syria launched a coordinated surprise attack on Israeli forces in the Sinai and the Golan Heights.
and the most important one there was no Palestine country to start with, it was a ؛Ottoman Empire" that collapsed and before that, all three religions (Islam, Judaism, Christianity ) owned that part at different times in the past.
There were a lot of unmentioned historical facts in this video.
Owned by different people at different times in the past yes but let's admit who built up that land. The ORIGINAL land owners came home.
That's exactly right my friend-- Palestine was not a nation-- but Israel 🇮🇱 was!
Thank you Siavash!
And I think you forgot to mention the massacres carried out by Zionist forces prior to the intervention of those Arab nations, including the infamous Deir Yassin massacre of April 1948 which resulted in the deaths of over 100 Palestinians.
You seem a little forgetful
Wait what? You said let’s start from the beginning but then start at 1916?!?! That’s NOT the beginning my friend.
exactly bro
Bravo🎉 you caught him lying😂
thats what all muslims do to keep other muslims stupid.
What's your point?
he might not realize how much land lost russia recently too, or basically dozens of countries prior and after ww2, a conveys like they are only country in world , when there are tens to hundreds
Funny how you didn't talk about Ottoman muslims overtaking Jerusalem in the 7th century by force.
Why would that? Do you think Mexico should be able to take over the U.S. because they used to own part of it centuries ago and there's currently some Mexicans here? Do you think Putin should be able to take over Ukraine for the same reason?
@@amandahugenkiss I never said that 😂just his claim that Muslims have always claimed Palestine as theirs is stupid when Jews were there first
@@user-du3pl4nb6i Saying your people were there first is stupid when your people have just migrated there from Europe in the past 70 years.
@@roofdogblues7400 My people 💀I'm not Jewish, and being honest I don't care about the Israel Palestine conflict. Its just he needs to mention how Jews were there first, and then Muslims took over.
@@user-du3pl4nb6i Why? Even the Jewish bible says that other people lived there when God "gave" it to them, and they killed them to take the land. Lots of people took the land before the Ottoman Empire took it, Jews weren't there first, and most Jews weren't there when the Ottomans took it, they were already in Europe. You wouldn't care if someone claimed that your people took your land from them and wanted it back, so why the double standard? Christians also lived in Gaza and are being systematically killed by Jews right now.
"However, in the cities of the nations the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, do not leave alive anything that breathes. Completely destroy them-the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites-as the Lord your God has commanded you." ~Deuteronomy 20:16-17
Doesn't even mention the Amalekites, who they also slaughtered out of existence.
So why American support Irael instead of the french and British?
Up until 4:00 , his complaint would be with the British and the UN.
Immediately after that, there is no mention of Arab nations attacking Israel.
So are all of the other historical sources wrong, or is he merely choosing to omit any facts that might support Israel?
It also falsely presumes the existence of a national Palestinian movement back in 1917, which wasn’t the case. Arabs occupying the Palestinian region saw themselves as Arabs first and had primary allegiance to their tribes and families, not some unified front. This is important, because the establishment of Jordan was dedicated to the Arabs we refer to *now* as making up the nation of Palestine.
This video presumes that Palestines weren’t given anything when the land was split between Jews and Arabs, and that’s historically false.
What do you think? People look for an exuse to hate Jews publicly. If the bs he said was true then jorden stole most of the palastinian land but non of the people that created his lie mention it (despite using the mandate claiming there was such a nation).
There is no mention of the Holocaust, the pogroms, anti-Semitism, and the Jewish struggle for independence against the British, the roots of Zionism and the Jews' attachment to the land, the Jews who were in Israel before 1948, the Arab attacks and wars with Arab countries 56,67,73,..the Oslo process, and much more
Arab nations attacked israel cause it came in there and stole Palestine. Kinda makes sense. The Islamic nations will support their neighbour
Maybe he’s giving a side u didn’t hear by brainwashed people
Very informative, but you missed out the bit where the surrounding Arab countries jointly began a war against Israel in 1948, a day after Israel’s independence, which was what resulted in the Palestinians having to flee. Israel didn’t arbitrarily decide to drive the Palestinians out of their land.
Or was that not a deliberate omission… 🤔
And you missed the bit where the Zionists had carried out at least 16 massacres of Palestinians prior to the intervention of the Arab nations. Included in that list is the infamous Deir Yassin massacre where over 100 Palestinian men, women and children were killed.
Try telling the whole story-not just half the story-next time.
Zionist stole Israel, they have been patiently rubbing their shnozzles and throwing shmeckles at this for years. Couldn’t have done it without zionist loving politicians. Seems like every politician is zionist or loves them. Politicians love anybody with power and/or deep pockets.
Yeah it's funny. When it's Palestine is peaceful protest. When it's Israel defending itself from multiple countries it's Zionist enforced cleansing. Interesting
ofcourse
Historically Palestinians have never been the owner of this land, the ruler of this land is Canaan, Israeli, Roman Empire, Ottoman Empire and British Empire. Legally both Israeli and Palestinians can live here
During the rule of Ottoman and British rule, Greedy Arab landlords sold their land to Jews at high prices (which was much more profitable than renting it to the poor Arabian), making the poor Arabs unemployed in large numbers, causing dissatisfaction among the Muslim political and religious nobility headed by the Grand Mufti family and attacking Jewish kibbutz farms everywhere.
It was the Hebron Massacre by Arabs against Jews in 1929 that gave birth to the Irgun, a Jewish extremist group. The Arabs also cooperated with Nazi Germany during World War II - Grand Mufti of Palestine - the SS Arab Legion, aiming to eliminate Israelis
Palestinians could have built their own country accrording to 1937 Peel Plan(Britain Peel Commission), 1947 UN 181 Resolution ，2000 Camp David Israeli-Palestinian Summit and 2008‘Land for peace' Program
However they believed they could eliminate Israeli and took all land. So they rejected all proposals and waged 5 times of wars at 2rd day of Israel establiment and numerous terrorist attacks on Israeli bus, cafe etc. They got defeated, started to play victims. That is the history
He only talks about the history starting from ww1 the history starts more then 10,000 years before ww1
What about the immigration of Jews to Palestine?
@@iq1540 well that was done by England and America not the Jews
@@iq1540 plus historically it is both your land mainly the Jews since the Arabs kept invading
@@iq1540Jews lived on this land long before Islam existed. The Arabs invaded and took it with force.
Either we accept, that Israel owns most of the land now, or we stay in this conflict, that the Palestinean people will lose. Make your choice!
No it wasn't jews who lived on this land it was Palestinian people contain arabs , christian, jews if you are talking about before that form thousand of years it was canaan people
A 2017 study of five Canaanite skeletons found that approximately half of the skeletons’ genes originated from agricultural settlers in the Levant around 10,000 years ago. The other half was from a population tied to Iran, which researchers estimate arrived in the Levant approximately 5000 years ago.[96]
Hajjej (2018) revealed that when using HLA genes, Levantine Arabs, such as Palestinians, Syrians, Lebanese and Jordanians, were closely related populations with common Canaanite ancestry. They shared a common geographic territory, which was later disrupted by 19th century British and French colonization. Their Canaanite ancestors came from Africa or the Arabian peninsula via Egypt in 3300 BC and settled in the Levant lowlands after the Ghassulian collapse in 3800-3350 BC. The Levantine Arabs were also related to East Mediterranean populations, such as Turks, Greeks and Cretans, Egyptians and Iranians, which can be explained by high migratory flow between Levantine sub-regions. However, Levantine Arabs were genetically distant from Arabian Peninsula populations such as Saudis, Kuwaitis and Yeminis before the 7th century Islamic conquests.[97]
Agranat-Tamir et al. (2020) stated that Canaanites from the Intermediate Bronze Age (c. 2500- 2000 BC) to late Iron Age I (c. 1000 BC) were genetically similar to each other. They lived in modern Israel, Jordan and Lebanon and could be modeled as "a mixture of local earlier Neolithic populations and populations from the northeastern part of the Near East (i.e. Zagros Mountains, Caucasians/Armenians and possibly, Hurrians)". Exceptions include the 2nd millennium BC inhabitants of Sidon, Abel Beth Maacah and Ashkelon, who were relatively heterogenous due to inflow from the eastern Mediterranean basin. The inhabitants of Ba'qah in Jordan also have probable admixture from "eastern desert groups". Following the Bronze Age, there was an addition of European-related and East African-related components, which were represented by Late Neolithic and Bronze Age Europeans and Somalis, from a north-south and south-north gradient respectively. The majority of modern Jewish and Levantine Arabic-speaking groups have 50% or more ancestry from peoples who were related to Bronze Age Levantines and Chalcolithic Zagros groups. But they have other ancestries that cannot be modeled by the available ancient DNA data.[98]
I don't stand to defend Israel or Palestine, but I have read a lot about the historical background of this conflict, including everything being said in this video. And I can tell you most of the things he is saying are different from the original story. Take the 1948 Arab-Israel war for instance, where he spoke about, how Israel captured many Palestinians leaving them homeless and landless... In the original story, the Arab states including Jordan, Syria, and Iraq among others, all launched a military attack on the Israelites for the sole reason that they had declared themselves as a sovereign state and they also retaliated.
Arabs were right to cause these devastations to help their brothers in Palestine
Why where they in someone else’s land in the first place ?
Oh I forgot because their special book told them!
Arabs launched these attacks because they were betrayed by the British and French. They declared Israel a sovereign state. Despite all this, Israel was annexing the land. An Israeli born author Ilan Pappe depicts the horrific sketch of that time in his book THE ETHNIC CLEANSING OF PALESTINE. And Kindly share your source too?
That's got the sequence out of order. Israel started to take villages along transport routes in Palestinian territory after their supply trucks were attacked. This was called Plan Dalet. While IDF were taking villages, Irgun decided that they would help, leading to the Deir Yassin massacre. The expansion of Israeli territory and the massacre led Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon to declare war. So he was correct about Al Nakbar, but he left out the reason Israelis were taking control of villages.
@user-bn3sv8lh4f
Ok if Jews were "invaders" please answer the following:
1. State the connection between Arabs and Philistiens (who were form Crete)
2. If Palestine was a country with palerinians as nationality what was their flag?
3. What was the Anthem of these "Palestinians"?
4. Who was the first palestinian king?
5. Which ARAB named Palestine
6. Which ARAB king build Jerusalem that they claimed to be their capital (in 1988 lol)
I can answer those questions about Israel but let me spare you the time and say you cannot answer those questions about Palestinians because they are not a real nation. Made up nonsense in the 60's by PLO and the KGB because Russia lost the proxy war over the Sinai peninsula. Learn history before you come on here.
Every map EVER that has the word Palestine written on it you will notice that most cities are named by the Israelites and those names predate the word Palestine by centuries!
It’s not complicated if you are biased. But for those who want peace, it is extremely complicated.
no
give half abraham's land to isaac/israel n half to ishmael/palestine - dam simple
@@bobevans9996it’s hard to give half to one and half to the other when one side wants the other side to be eradicated
@flipperdip4009
19 minutes ago
@bobevans9996 it’s hard to give half to one and half to the other when one side wants the other side to be eradicated
----------------
true
so
since
the story/history
sarah gave abraham her egyptian servant hagar to bear him an heir n after hagar had a son ishmael then sarah herself had isaac then she drove hagar n ishmael into the forest - so evil so cruel she meant for them to disappear go extinct - they could be kill rob rape sold eaten ...😭
gaza is now a concentration camp n israel is still attacking it - it'll be extinction of palestianian
from the start israel want palastinean extinct not the other way around
so
what is going to happen is
indonesia the largest muslim country
egypt hagar's country
the many rich muslim countries
n
god said he'll protect ishmael n give him lots of seeds
n
god said israel will not have a home country they'll be forever wandering jew
so
maybe biblical fortelling will come true n israel will be extinct - help - yea i love muslim food but i also can't live without lox cream cheese on fresh fresh warm warm bagel 😭
not a good time to be alive - sigh
----------------
i think maybe god will give everything to palestinean n israeli will be forever wandering jew - which is good - at least neither go extinct 😭
-----------------
i don't think evil colonist criminal uk usa care - all they want is wars - war criminal peloci obama trump bush clinton ... will starve without wars - it's always they power profit we die debt
remember peloci - so brave go to taiwan against china warning - she wasn't brave - she change dates n routes many times🤣
usa stole china forest n call it vietnam
usa stole china island n call it taiwan
they hatecrime chinese/asians n war china/asia nonstop
they want ussr to become russia then for russia to go extinct
usa n gang forced lone russia to fight n is forcing lone china
u have to fight u have to die if usa wants it
so
china will reset world to pre colonial order
natives tribals aboriginese redindians in americas australia newzealand n all islands r from china so all these/whole pacific n half atlantic belongs to china so return all to china with reparation n without a shot like british hongkong n portuguese macau (they ate fried chinese - like japanese ate live humans) n all racist thieves 600mil total immigrate back home to europe africa india ... china ordered blinken to take eviction notice to biden - look at their faces🤣
@@flipperdip4009 that is exactly what I was thinking, apparently Jews have been trying to make peace but Hamas dont want to. anyone got prove that Palestine has tried to make peace? - i'm just a latino
Perfectly stated David.
Why people dont talk about Palestinians voted for Hamas, a terrorist group that attacked Israel before Israel fought back?
Jews in Israel: 700 BCE
Muslims in Israel : 600-1000AD
Wrong. Canaanites on the land 6000 BCE (that's archaeology). Sea Peoples/Philistines/Palestinians 1300 BCE and ever-after. Israelites 1200 BCE for all of 200 years before their conquest.
Why do we even need to go to biblical times for this? You can’t stake a 2,000+ year old claim on a piece of land just cause you’re prophets and god say so!
And to say Muslims in Israel 600 ad and on is not quite right. We get caught in a trap of religious identity being a race or specific group of people when it’s a religion and…. THAT’S IT. Jews can be multiple races, Christian, Buddhists, but not Muslims. A lot of the people that were native to the area converted to Islam, Islam didn’t move into the area or anything.
@@danielhaving3411 Nonsense. Muslims too can be of any race.
That doesn't matter if they decided to leave after the Romans invaded
Wow... I especially like how selective with history and facts this narrative is. I'm hardly an expert on this but even the most desultory effort of research can see the colossal omissions made in favor of Palestine.
@osawagedk
He starts with "there were arabs in Palestine" ... so Philista not an Arabic word, it's greek.
Philistiens were from Crete.
"But look at the map, it says Palestine" well most of the cities on that map are Israelites built and have names that predate those maps.
The flag is made up by the PLO in the 60's.
Who ruled before the Brits? The Turks, and before that? How many empires ruled it ? There never was a kingdom of Palestine they didn't have currently, borders, passports, Anthem, flag NOTHING until the PLO with the KGB made this nonsense up
@@johnconnor2931You rn: 🤓☝️
Welcome to the israeli frustration
Palestine was never a State, it is Jordan. Jordan never recolonized any Palestine claims. Jordan controls the east (Palestine - Not a real State BTW) and Egypt controls the South (Gaza - also not a real State). No Islamic State want refugees from either of these places because they don't want radical Jihadist in there State. Israel has always offered and accepted less land but everytime Palestine declines. A Muslim Coalition (Egypt, Syria, Iran, Jordan, Iraq) tried to wipe out Israel, they had over 650,000 dead but Israel won! Do not let anyone tell you anything other than it is a continued Genocide of the Jewish people, anything else is a lie.
You are entitled to your opinion but not your own facts.
@@osawagedk lmao seriously? dude doesn't even mention that the "nakhba" was a result of Israel being attacked by all its neighbors, fighting back and then gaining territory. He doesn't mention that jewish migration had started decades before the british got involved and would have happened with or without the balfour declaration. He makes it sound like the brits entirely sided with the jews when in fact they tried to entirely stop jewish immigration during ww2, which resulted in thousands being unable to escape europe. Dude talks about palestinian land being "seized" pre-1948, when in fact every inch of land was purchased up until the UN partition. After the partition, there was ethnic cleansing on both sides. Jewish settlements that were in the arab partition were ousted, it wasn't just arabs being forced out from the jewish side, it happened on both sides, just like when pakistan/india was partitioned. also, even though it's true that israel's partition was larger, if you know anything about the geography there you'd know that they also got the worst land - the negev desert and the swamp land in the north (before israel figured out how to drain them and make them productive.) The Arab partition was much better land. So yes, the story actually is complicated, unlike the muppet who made this video would like you to believe.
Him:“Let’s start From the Beginning” also him:skips 3000 years of history
why not 6000 years then ? History certainly didn't start with judaism ? why not start with dinosaurs? he's start with contemporary history not with ancient history that has no relevance by this point. if you want to displace people all over the world based on their 3000 years old ancestry then i'd agree but if u only want to do it for the sake of Israel... then whatever.... what a pointless argument
@@realityzoner actually it is not pointless... lets start as far as possible, as long as we do not miss details and tell the story as it was. the big issue here is that accuracy is still in favor of Israel, exept one thing: Israel is strong and there are many muslims around the world that cannot accept its existence.
@@realityzoner
Much if the region known as Palestine was sparse or not densely populated. This changes largely after the 1940's when mass immigration happens on both sides.
Pretending there was this huge portion of ancient and native "Palestinian" people is disingenuous also. Many Arabs immigrated when the standard of living went up and the British found petroleum / oil in the region also.
@@jammin1881 no these talking points are disingenuous ...pretending like Arabs started leaving their lives in their countries to counter populate Palestine is a stupid talking point, noone in their right mind would move to a conflict zone just for the sake of spiting... and trying to shape the reality for your narrative .... these people are native to that land whether you like or not, this whole pretend non=facts are facts and try to push an alternate history that is the peak if disingenuousness... in fact if what you said is true the people displaced by isreal wouldn't be refugees they would return to their homelands, there's over 7 Million refugees that have been in refuge for 75 years ... they are not playing pretend
@@user-sn3uo8vq8u if it is not pointless then anyone with a Canaanite ancestry has claim to the land not the jews specifically... and i bet you can even go beyond the Canaanite ancestry or even further... secondly many jews that used to live in that land converted to Christianity and many of their descendent converted to islam ... the fact that Judaism was the first religion chronologically doesn't mean that only jews have exclusive "genetic claim" to the land if i follow ur logic of "Claim to a land by ancestry" ... speaking of genetic many of the Isreali citizens have a European ancestry yet they can claim the land as their own.... and your second claim is that jews are strong so they can take the land ... then you are also justifying that when romans were strong they had the right to kick jews out ... anyway your logic is just a bunch of logical fallacies that weave together to make a point... but it's just a bunch of contradictions that want to believe makes you right to justify what you have been brought up to accept is right...
I love when people condemn Britain for colonialism and then condemn decolonisation as Britain handing over their problem to someone else. Also I found this video very informative and fascinating. Particularly with regards to the selection of facts
Agreed. This is the most honest video I've ever seen on the subject.
Ok but happened before that war. Who's land was it then?
Imagine living there 1K years before your enemy even existed and then they said you stole it 😂😂
History did not start in 1900s. This guy is biased asf. At least touch on the entirety of history even if you are biased.
@@IAmThe_RAoh really? when do you think he should start?
answer me Jewbot
@@tshooehe talks about stuff 500 years ago…more than 2000 years ago Jerusalem belonged to the Jews, that’s also a reason they chose the land surrounding Jerusalem as their home. But if you and this UA-camr talk about losing parts of their territory and giving them the right to slaughter people due to this fact, every European should do this aswell? Most of the world belonged to any European state in the past and many of these colonies were destroyed after…people should realize that things can change…especially, if you don’t even know, that an independent Palestine never existed…
@@tshooe Imperial Rome.
Anyway, I am no Jew. I am the D. 👹
@@IAmThe_RAyour a demon??? Stfu your not a badass
A good friend of mine is Palestinian and he told me how his family came home to find a fence constructed around their house and armed Israelis stopped them from returning to their home they just took it and the Israeli government allows this.
There was also that family a few years back that went viral, who had come home to find a settler occupying most of it (iirc they still had ownership of part of the groundfloor). The guy literally just moved from the USA.
Every other day on the Balkans in 19th and first half of the 20th century. And just like the Balkans, the Middle East is not simply Arab and Muslim.
@@KarlSnarks and as I understand it many of the companies hired to fence off Palestinians from their own homes were American companies hired by Israelis to do so
@@o6ina I understand I know that things are rarely so black-and-white or simple as some media would portray them to be
I also have a Palestinian friend who absolutely hates what Hamas has done to Palestine and the Palestinian people. Hamas is driven by power and have one goal that have have publicly announced for years: The destruction of Israel and death to all Jews.
People go back in history only so far until it suits their narrative. The entire world as we see today has been shaped by countless number of conquests, invasions and settlements. And people generally associate this with the British and the Europeans which is more recent in comparison, but Islam has committed far worse genocides and conquests before that. Afghanistan and Iran are examples of the then existing communities being completely driven out to form pure Islamic countries. Thankfully India was able to drive out the Mughals at some point, only to be taken over by the British later, which ended with yet another division in the form of Pakistan(something similar to what they did with Israel and Palestine). One of the most developed nation in the world - US itself exists on the history of a mass genocide of native Americans. There are so many examples like this.
The point is instead of trying to justify who has complete right to the entire land, which basically no one has, and wishing that either side just ceases tk exist or drive them out completely to "anywhere", a two state solution with peaceful co-existence is the only solution. But its not just the two regions suffering who are in conflict, now the entire world are adding fuel to the fire by taking sides and even worse there are some who want the conflict to continue for their personal gains.
Sir why not start 3000 years ago? Study history, archeological history, read your Quran, Tanakh & Bible. Then tell me again who originally owned the land. Please don't be biased. This is the reason why a lot of young people right now don't know the truth because they only listen to a random people Instead of studying the history.
Ancient history is irrelevant
Losing a war doesn’t automatically make you the good guy
50 50 support
What would you know
war. what kind of war? you are cutting everything on these people robbing them taking their land with the support of the western ki...ng children and somen you cowards what waaar you are talking about
but winning a war and continuously taking more land and resources does, right? 😂 😂
@@huda_19 I didn’t say that you did
When history starts in 1916, it's called HIS-STORY.
I agree. Because many people are acting of though His-story began on October 7th, 2023. And those victims where the first causalities.
@@BKthoroughbred
Right? People don't know that this conflict began way before Oct 7, 2023 when followers of "The Religion of Peace" were constantly killing, bombing and kidnapping Jews before this day. Albeit Oct 7, 2023 was one of the worse massacres yet.
But if you are think like that so, give life to all people who died in Palestine. Then I could accept your point.
Yes, this guy has a complete knowledge of the known ancient history, and he also has a complete knowledge of the holy texts regardless of his religion. He knows what this very long running conflict is all about. So why does he choose to start 'his-story' from 1916?
Don't go to thousands of years ago
Give back the indians their land you freak
I wish someone who was intimately knowledgeable about this would make some graphs with important data points, that can give a sense of who is more in the rite. Because both sides want to minimize a lot of what they’ve done.
How to rewrite history for a propoganda
While I appreciate this information, I also think it’s important to realize that this conflict goes back WAY further than WWI, or even the Ottoman Empire. I will pray for humanity to prevail.
the peoples who inhabited the land are the Canaanite 3500 BC who known now as Arabs, this was long before Jewish exist and the land was called Palestine, and for your knowledge Israel is a tribe Palestine is a land
@@PSYKSY_ Weird, because the Canaanite's language is most similar to Hebrew. Also the Canaanite's didn't believe in the Muslim religion or Jewish religion. They became Jewish before they ever became Muslim.
@@K0rium This has nothing to do with religion, Muslim mean one who submits to God therefore all prophets of God were Muslim,. Arabs and Jewish are semitic they speak semitic language and there are a lot of similarity between them adapted from Sumerian, the birth of Semitism was in Mesopotamia or Babylon (Modern Iraq)
@@K0rium Prophet Abraham was Iraqi, Jesus was Palestinian Jewish
@@PSYKSY_ False. They were originally Judean. Judah predates Palestina by nearly 1000 years.
2:17 calling them european is wrong. Genetically they are not European. They are a lot closer related to Arabs and Turks than Europeans.
Bruh exactly. I agree with everything else but denying Jewish history is so annoying. Even European Jews are 50% Levantine in orgin, with the rest being mostly Southern European
@@LostTumbs Half of them came from Arab countries!
This is one of the biggest problem in that there's a confusion/mixing of religion and ethnicity. You can very well become a jew without having anyone of your ancestry coming from the region. Many Palestinians are also probably jews who converted to Islam (which was common in the Ottoman Empire).
European ? Stupido locco
Labels are the racist way of viewing politics. It should be based on humanity and justice. Israel is racist and unsustainable.
The music is inappropriate.
I like how these videos only start in the early 1900’s. The kingdom of Israel and Judah existed long before the invasions by Muslim caliphates in the 7th century and the Ottoman Empire in the 14th century.
“Let’s go back to the beginning…after WW2” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Exactly! Haha
Palestinians don’t want to take it before 1900 because they know that part of the history is indefensible.
😂😂
yes very ancient
I guess after WW2 history was born 🤣
He means the beginning of the conflict
May I be so bold as to point out the Palestinians rejected the two state solution on 5 separate occasions. Too, when one group calls for the extermination of the other group, peace is not possible.
do you think Israel is allowing tow States
they are refusing that
@@kamal5341since when
@@Funknwanker from the first day they are saying there is only one state it is Israel... please look history
It doesn’t matter if they rejected it or not. If someone took your house and said you take this half and I take the other, are you gonna be like “oh sure honey” ?
I've otherwise never heard of refugees being gifted a state rather than just a home in an existing one.
published 3 years ago?
He says it all started in 1916 because if he would go further back, he’d realise history ain’t on his side
yeah, just like these kids that spam everywhere "free palestin"
Lol actually if he goes earlier, there's even less of Jewish immigration lol
He mentions 1916 because it predates the belfour convention which where we can consider every immigration after as a plan for a zionist project that lead to the creation of an occupational state
that's what I'm saying. Palestinian speak Arabic, Arabic language started in 512bc in Syria, so Palestinians were in Syria in 512 bc, meanwhile in Israel it's occupied by Persian invaders from 539bc-323bc... besides, Hebrews first settled in Israel in 3500 bc
i'm libyan and i speak arabic
i'm arabic only by spoken language my ancestors are not actually from saudi arabia
it's mixed between north african and turkish
spoken language isn't an evidence
especially even with the born of islam there were jewish tribes in the arab peninsula that spoke arabic fully
which leads us to the point palestinians / syrians / lebanon / iraqis / and even some egyptians have strong blood ties to the ancient jews, especially that huge chunk of jews that stayed in the area converted to islam
@@caseherc5991
How much further? I would really like to know what you mean by this.
What about the 3000 years before the first world war? And you failed to mention the Balfour agreement.
According to what you said, we must expel all people of European origin from America and Australia
What about the immigration of Jews to Palestine?
The j turned their backs on God the land was no longer theirs.
@@LarryBonson God promised them the land forever. The Jews just have to live up to their part of the covenant. God has restored them to the land as per Ezekiel 37. Now they just have to go through the process of recognising Jesus was the messiah.
@@jeffreyjohnston2445THE TRUE STORY regarding PALESTINE
-Palestine is the land of the Prophets.
-Jews have no rights in Palestine
-Palestine is for Palestinians
-Jerusalem is the capital of Palestine
-There is no country of Israel
Some of the Prophets who lived in Palestine are:
Ibrahim (Abraham)
Lot
Ishmael
Ishaq (Isaac)
Ya'qoob (Jacob)
Yusuf (Joseph)
Daud (David)
Solomon
Zakariyyah (Zachariah)
Yahya (John)
{May the peace and blessing of Allah be upon them)
Ibrahim(Abraham) has two sons:
1. Ismael
2. Isaac
Isaac's son was Jacob(Ya'qoob) where most of the Prophets came from his lineage such as Yusuf(Joseph),Daud(David),Sulaiman(Solomon),Zakariyyah(Zacarias),Musa(Moses) and Yahya (John).
The second name of Prophet Ya'qoob(Jacob) is ISRAEL so his clans are called BANU ISRAEL(Son's of Israel). Also, accordingly, ISRAEL means Abdullah (servant of Allah).
But the tribe of Israel has been known for disobedience and stubbornness where they oppose and kill their own Prophets sent to them except for a small number them, this is how the Quran describes them.
Among their disobedience are:
-They disobeyed Prophet Solaiman (Solomon)
-They disobeyed Prophet Musa (Moses)
-They disobeyed Prophet Eisa (Jesus)
-They killed Prophet Yahya (John)
-They killed Prophet Zacariah (Zacarias).
THAT'S WHY ALLAH PUNISHED THEM. THEIR PUNISHMENT IS THAT, THEY WOULD HAVE NO LAND IN THIS WORLD EXCEPT THOSE WHO BELIEVE.
What happened to them for several centuries is that wherever they ended up in the middle east after the time of Prophet Eisa (Jesus), others went to Europe and America.
In World War II between the years 1941 and 1945 the Holocaust occurred where nearly 6 million Jews died in Europe at the hands of Adolf Hitler of Germany.
The reason for Adolf Hitler's great anger towards the Jews is about politics and religion where the Jews believe that people who do not belong to them are animals or the lowest creatures, because they believe that they are the chosen people who chosen by Allah, so Hitler did this to them.
They only got land in Palestine because GREAT BRITAIN took pity on them where it was recommended to the UNITED NATIONS and the UN immediately received it in the year 1947, because the Jews also served for a long time in Great Britain.
In the following year (1948) the Zionist Jews immediately declared their own country in Palestine which they called ISRAEL where it seemed as if they only arrived in Palestine as refugees until they gradually expanded their land to conquer in the lands of the Palestinians in a violent and forced way, at the same time they gathered all the Jews around the world where before they would have been scattered because of the punishment of Allah.
This is where the Arab countries intervened and there was a war that has not ended until now between the JEWS and the ARABS.
Apart from this conflict, the Jews also do not respect the Arabs because they believe that they are the only believers, so they did not believe in Prophet Muhammad SAW and it was easy for them to kill Arab Muslims. Why?
Prophet Ismael, the brother of Prophet Isaac, is the son of Hajar, the second wife of Prophet Ibrahim, who used to be the maid of Sarah, who was the mother of Prophet Isaac, the first wife of Prophet Ibrahim (according to their history).
And after the reign of the clans of Isaac in which the last Prophet among them was Prophet Eisa (Jesus), Allah gave this promise to the clan of Prophet Ismael where the last prophet and Messenger would come from his clan. Prophet Muhammad SAW.
Because the last Prophet did not come from the family of Isaac, the Jews did not believe, believing that Prophet Ismael was inferior compared to their ancestor, Prophet Isaac, the son of Prophet Ibrahim's first wife, besides that, they really are people who disobeys, even to the early Prophets.
In other words, the ongoing conflict between Jews and Arab Muslims is about religion and history.
Palestine is a place of Arab Muslims, and the believers in the clans of Israel, it does not include those who disobey, they are not among in the promise of Allah.
There are three existing religions in Palestine:
1. Judaism
2. Christianity
3. Islam
WHY ARE THE CHRISTIANS IN PALESTINE NOT INCLUDED IN THE ENEMY OF THE PALESTINIAN MUSLIMS?
Christians are not like Jews, where Jews are worse but they are the same race, Jews also consider Christians as enemies because they did not really believe in Prophet Eisa (Jesus), they are the ones who accused Mary committing adultery (Zina) and Prophet Eisa (Jesus) was a child of zina (adultery), so a great miracle happened from Allah where Prophet Eisa spoke when he was a baby to refute what the Jews were saying and prove the innocence of his mother.
WHY DO THEY WANT TO TAKE JERUSALEM WHERE MASJID AL-AQSA IS LOCATED?
They believe that here is the very temple of Prophet Solaiman that was destroyed and replaced by masjeds, so this is what they want to restore from its original, but if you go back to history and the books you will not find any solid evidence about the temple that they claim.
Rather, the Masjid Al-aqsa is the one that was built by Prophet Adam and rebuilt by Prophet Solaiman.
And they have no right to it because they also disobeyed Prophet Solaiman as we mentioned.
Canaan people was exist
Nakba is what happened when you lost the war you started.
Balfour of Declaration, Sykes and Picot agreement.
Palestinians voted for Hamas in a free democracy, despite knowing the turmoil they would be engaged in.
Let that sink in!
no one cares about truth.. it’s all about hating the fact that the Jews have a right to their land
The Palestinians must be desperate! What would drive them to do such a thing?
People we call Hamas form a government just as Likud forms one. Why is it that when it comes to self defense, only Israel is given that right but not Palestinians.
@@thunderboy678 if I steal something from you and you come to me and try to take it back by force, I could certainly attack you back and claim self defence, but focusing on my claim would be missing the point wouldn't it?
Israel funded Hamas. Occupation and ethic cleansing existed will before Hamas became in 1986.
I doubt all these people with the “ I stand with Ukraine” stickers will be doing the same thing for Palestine. It’s sad what the Palestinian people have gone through
Well that's wrong. I support Ukraine and Palestine, you're just creating fake opposition.
Be sure they stand with the native American, stand with people killed in Tiananmen Square, The Shia-Sunni etc. Heck We have conflicts inside nation between one group to another.
"What causes fights and quarrels among you? Don't they come from your desires that battle within you?"
Well, Ukrainians didn’t kidnap, rape and kill innocents.
Ukrainians aren't murdering, raping, torturing and parading with dead bodies of Russian citizens. Slight difference.
It's sad that choose to continue to go through it. Accept the loss and move on. At this rate Israel is going to occupy all of their land.
By Israel’s logic, Mongolia has rights to most of Asia and half of Europe lol
This conflict has been going on since it was Canaan.
The picture 5:43 is actually yemnite jews fleeing yemen to there ancestral homeland israel you can tell there jews by the head covering of men and side curls the man is holding a torah scroll wrapped in a talit jewish garb for prayer
Yep. These are Jews who made aliyah to Eretz Israel. 😊🕎
Correct! it's a very famous picture of jewish yemenite refugees. He claims to speak the truth but he can't even tell the difference between jewish arabs and palestinians. this is actually hilarious!
@@area51xi I left Elad a comment I think he erased it..so I'll tell you what scripture says about all of this..the bible mentions Past Present and future...In Genesis God showed Abraham the promised land...and told Abraham he could have it because Abraham forsook his Idol worshipping family to worship the Lord ..and he also told Abraham that he would bless his Nation...he would make him a father of nations... especially the Jews and Arab's...through Isaac(Hebrews) and Ishmael(Arab descent)...Isaac the one with the birthright..his other son...was banished... according to scripture..those who call themselves Palistinians...Are ancient Philistines....Many DNA experts today..say they are closely related to the Jews..but they don't seem to know where the Palistinians descendants come from...I don't want to add a bunch of scriptures... people can do their own research like I did..but...the bible calls them ,,"Edomites."...or Descendants of the "Mount of Seir"...either way the bible say they are descendants of Esau who are the philistines if Old... The Palistinians descendants are indeed closely related to Israel's.. However, they are not Israeli ...they are the brother of Israel...In fact they are Israel's twin brother..Jacob and Esau were twins..Jacob had 12 son's..that went on to be the 12 tribes of Israel..God changed Jacobs name to "ISRAEL"...Esau originally had the birthright...because he was the eldest... but he sold it to Jacob for s bowl of lentils.... Nevertheless, history tells us that God made his covenants With the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and not with...Pagans(Abraham's ancestry), Ishmael (Isaacs half bro) or Esau (Jacob's twin)..it's amazing that these people claim this land belongs to them..it's like a modern prophecy that's been projected into this future... Originally Jacob obtained the birthright through dishonesty...his name means "Disceet." Jacob took advantage of Esau when he was tired and hungry..and he obtained the birthright through trickery...yet into today's future..when ISRAEL is scattered during 70 AD... THE DESCENDANTS OF Esau sneak in and try to claim the promised Land as their own...However...God always keeps his promises...and he made his Covenant with Jacob rather than his older brother...It say's in Ezekiel 35 and 36 that God remembers the past when the philistines shed the blood of Israel... Calamity was brought upon the servants of God in the past with these people... Samson would be one example...God is angry with Palistine..he tells them they will be desolate...because of their greed ..He mentions two nations...I believe he's mentioning the regions that were split up in 1948 from the English Ottoman in verse 9 and 10...God insinuates that The Palistinians were greedy...they didn't want one half of the region that was offered...they insisted that the entire region of Israel Belonged to them when he clearly gave it to Israel.from the gate.......the Lord says for this ..they will be a nation that will remain DESOLATE.. Because they also bear the shame of the Heathen...I think he's talking about Them adopting the religion of ISLAM...CLEARLY THEY ARE MUSLIM..IT DOES NOT SET WELL WITH GOD ... God tells them in Chapt 36...that they will be a possession of the residue of the heathen..I surmise he's talking about the Arabs of that region..THE MUSLIM ARABS ..who bear their shame ...HE CALLS THEM IDOLATARS ...HES SAYING THAT THEIR NATION WILL STAY DESOLATE..They pretty much have right? . You have to remember..this was the past... because it talks about how the promised land was desolate to these descendants of Esau but when Israel...began inhabiting it again..it began flourishing.in the regions that Israel lived ... God explains that ISRAEL was invaded by the ROMANS because the House of Israel shed innocent blood...I believe hes talking about those Apostles that the Jews killed in the early church.. and it says because of their "Idolatry." ... Israel's apostasy of Christ equals IDOLATRY..that's why he scattered them...They profaned his name in those heathen countries that they ended up in.. ..he told them that he would remove them from the heathen countries and bring them back into their own land.. he states that he's going to clean them up and will save them from their filth.(I have a feeling that hasn't happened yet.) .He said that he would build Jerusalem back up ..and that it would flourish with vegetation...people and buildings...cities ..and that those around Israel would say..'Israel has become like the Garden of Eden."... Ezekiel 37 God's telling the European Jews... those from the Holocaust... that he would put flesh back on their bodies, cover them back with skin and being life back to them again...that they will stand back on their feet again and become like an army....he said their hope was lost and they felt like they were cut off but..he would bring them out of their graves and back into their land again...he states that he will make them into a great nation and will gather them together out from the heathen... He says David his servant will be their king...He's speaking about JESUS.....those are past events...the future...what's going on right now Ezekiel 38 and 39 says that ISRAEL wiill be invaded and the invader's..it's not just Palistinians . but it's other Nations as well...will be demolished by the hand of the Lord....So listen up Palistinians...This is what God says about y'all in 38 and 39... of Ezekiel..all of you that are being hateful...(These Jews will no longer be slaughtered like they were in times past) God is saying when y'all invade it... God will put ideas in the Russia'ns apostate mind...they will be one of the invader's in your band...and they will have their entire army with them ...Iran, Libya and also Ethiopia will make up that band of soldiers.... Palestine and also others from the region of the Mediterranean ...will be a part of that army...sounds like a gigantic army ... For days you will be visited and you will return back into the country that was taken from Israel by the sword ..This Army will come upon Israel like a big storm....this Army will cover the land of Israel...as it's all happening..y'all will start thinking evil murderous thoughts ...and your thoughts will to prey upon Israel and to steal their possessions...I assume that the land itself...is part of that...Many of the influencers that join hands with you will encourage you to steal from Israel....their excuse will be that the Army is great and powerful..and u all will be able to not only steal land but plunder Israel....Many from the North will be with you.. I'm assuming Russia....You all will plot together and go against ISRAEL....God says that the moment that this fearful thing comes upon Israel...God's rage and fury will be against you ... and there will be a big shaking in Israel...the shaking will be so large..that mountains will be thrown down and the inhabitants in other parts of the world will feel the shaking.. Earthquake,? Bomb? ..
God says he will bring pestilence, hailstorm, fire and brimstone down upon you....verse 39 says ...those from the North....Namely Russia..will be killed and thrown upon the mountains of Israel..,he will give all your bodies to the scavengers of the fields (birds and beasts) he will burn Russia with fire...he says that those around will know that he is God....I guess he wants Israel to burn the enemies weapons....However, God tells Israel to help themselves to all other possessions that are left ...It say's in verse 39 that it will take 7 months for ISRAEL to bury all the bodies and anyone who passes through their land searching for their lost relatives or friends will be slaughtered and buried with the other bodies. Sounds like God isn't playing this time...He will feed Israel from the fat of the lamb and will give them horses and much inheritance... Including horses and everything... because in the next chapters they begin building the temple .. .they will then know that they their Lord was him who led them into captivity...He goes to never hide his face from them again...
Palestine isn’t their ancestral homeland. Their ancestors lived in Yemen.
@@odaenathus7825 there ancestors were deported from Judea
In 1937, 1948, 1993 & 2000 viable proposals for a Palestinian/Arab State were on the table. Each time rejected by the Arab leaderships for the folly of "all this land is ours from the river to the Sea." Still the refrain at the recent demonstrations.
Don't see why they should have to give 1% of their land to Zionists in the first place.
@@abelbalbo5134 It's not their land
@@fafolaw tell me why it's not their land 🙂
@@abelbalbo5134 Same reason your house is not mine
@@fafolaw So you can't answer it. You agree that Zionists stole the land from the natives then. Thank you and good night 😉
Whoops, there goes the neighborhood.
"Palestine" word originates from Latin language used by Romans to describe the region around that time kingdom of Israel and The Kingdom of Israel predates the use of the Latin word "Palestine" by several centuries. The Kingdom of Israel emerged around the 11th century BCE, while the term "Palestine" originated from the Roman province of Judea, which was established much later, during Roman rule in the region, around the 1st century BCE.
Beautiful 👏👏
There is definitely things being left out of the story. One thing I know for sure though is that the people who carried out the TERRORIST attacks and the people cheering over the bodies of innocent kids are animals and have no business breathing the same air that everyone else does.
I feel like Israel is the animals they murdered over 800 kids now it's always been pretty one-sided Israel has killed five times as many people as Palestine have that's not complicated at all. Stray animals
What about the israelis cheering the hospital attack that killed 1000 innocent civilians
I love how he starts his story at the end of WW1 as if he actually knows what he’s talking about 0:21. The world didn’t start in the early 20th century.
Balfor Declaration 1917, the Khazars stole Palestine from Saudi Arabia. I hope you know who the Khazars are.
@@Boomhauersdad The story did though (if you think like a critical thinker)
I am Christian and was raised and taught to support Israel. I have to say this side of the story was never told to me. Many of us in the west are completely unaware of what our government has done or is doing in other countries. I respect the Palestinian people for standing for their way of life. I wish things were don’t fairly and the killings on both sides would stop.
The middle east will forever be at war... blame whatever- the track record beckons we toss it to the wind. Not our problem
@@boman9208Unfortunately many Christians get deceived by misleading information like this, that land was always Israel's
@@gamingassassin115no it wasn't, isreal never existed before the 1940s
@@boman9208no because God doesn't exist and cannot just give land away when people are already there
@@sharktenko267Nor did Palestine.
Only blind and deaf is not clear what is happening in that land
People want whole history in 6.5 minutes 😂.
The video already explained an important part of history
The way he emphasizes the 27% when speaking about the Jewish population rising really says it all.
If anyone ever tells you this situation is NOT complicated, you can be sure they are lying through their teeth.
shut up jew
@@Supraem downright anti semitism lmao
@@jowandean ok buddy
Yes, its not. Palestine and the arab states tried to annihalte israel. Israel defended itself. Now the losers are crying oppression.
Lol it’s not complicated, it’s not their land, Israel should not and doesn’t exist in my mind. End of story
There never was a plstn.
Thank you my brother
That's not true. Up until the invasion in 1948, it was referred to as the British Mandate of Palestine.
What is so baffling about giving land to people who have constantly had no where and just been reduced by 6 million.
I look at this from a military history perspective. Yes, in 1948 the Arabs fought to get the land back. The problem is that they LOST THE WAR in 1948. They also LOST THE WAR in 1967. Then in 1973 they fought another war, and guess what…. once again they LOST THE WAR. The Arabs (who choose to be called Palestinians) are a CONQUERED people. As a Muslim, you should know better than anyone else, how the sword can be used to conquer people and take their land. (the Muslim Caliphate conquered many lands and reached all the way to Spain and Vienna) Unfortunately now it is YOU who are the conquered ones. The opportunity for a “conquered people” to try and negotiate for land is long passed. Each time you launch a war, your situation gets worse. This war is going to be even worse than the previous wars. You have no one to blame but yourselves. You allow the leaders of Hamas to get rich while you finance another useless, deadly war.
The people of Gaza and the West Bank are basically whiny sore losers.
ABSOLUTELY AGREE with you sir! Thank you. I can only hope everyone reads your comment to obtain the actual FACTS.
free Palestine soon
my only problem is who supported them in each of the wars. was it Israel vs all the arab states or Israel and USA vs Arabs
Hamas
It is not known how many Gazans genuinely support Hamas. It is possible most of them support it, in which case hoping for any internal revolution is insanity. A much more optimistic scenario, which is also quite realistic, is that most Gazans do not support Hamas and do realize it is the principal cause of their misery. In that scenario an internal revolution is about as difficult as the job of the White Rose movement.
Hamas isn’t a political party, it’s not running a state and it’s not a religious cult either. Hamas is an organized crime ring, anchored in Islamic fundamentalism, that is also performing the duties of a state in Gaza. In other words, it is an unholy alliance between mafia and religious wackos. As such it has complete control over the distribution of goods in Gaza. Those who do not work for Hamas live in abject squalor, being a member is basically a prerequesite to hold a job, with very few exceptions. Those who oppose Hamas die a violent death. The result is most people either work for or with Hamas and no one is willing to oppose them, it’s too dangerous and spies are everywhere.
There isn’t any way an internal resistance might organize either. People might not like Hamas, but they all know what happens to those who defy it. Religious organizations are all agents of Hamas and there isn’t a whole lot other ways for people down there to organize. Besides, if there are 10% genuine supporters any organization of three members or more will likely be infilitrated or spotted by an informant. The larger it gets the easier and quicker it becomes to notice.
Gazans cannot be counted upon to revolt. Even if they earnest desire is to overthrow Hamas and finally have a chance to live a life worth living, they genuinely can’t do it. Hamas has all the guns and plenty of thugs to enforce their will. Protests, riots, peaceful demonstrations just get you raped, mutilated and killed - not necessarily in that order, but you’ll get all three, don’t worry.
The only way Hamas can be defeated is if the international community finally starts treating it for what it is: a crime syndicate with religious backing, cosplaying a state. But it is a crime syndicate first and foremost, it always has been. Their leaders aren’t beyond our reach. They live in Qatar in a five star hotel and watch the conflict from a distance, sipping cocktails and enjoying the fruits of their labor.
As long as people can't establish a universal law that includes everyone regardless their faith or ethnicity, these conflicts will not cease.
America established this in 1791
@@euphegenia"America" doesn't even respect a country if they catalog them as "comunists" and steals natural resources such as oil and minerals. That so established law is a lie.
You mean a one world government
Are you suggesting a 1 world government because thats the only way.
@@COYS_593 "universal law that includes EVERYONE regardless their faith or ethnicity" would only happen if there was a one world government.
As someone who is English and born in England, curious as to the real truth about this conflict, I’m finding it impossible to really get to the facts, as whatever video’s I watch are heavily biased towards the side the narrator represents. Like in this video you can clearly feel the bias towards the Palestinians as if they’ve never done anything wrong when I know from other videos that they most certainly have. So it’s really tough knowing what to believe as Palestinians claim Israel stole their land and the Israeli side claims that fought off the Arab League that was trying to wipe them off the map, and as a result of that gained the West Bank and Gaza…
I don’t blame anyone for not understanding clearly who’s at fault here.
I understand, but it's very telling when (videos like this one) have to omit blatant facts to prop up their narrative.
I watched one from keerthi history called isrea vs palestine explained. Best one i could find
Don't watch UA-cam videos by random people. Read historical books instead :)
This perspective only works if you limit your history lesson to the past 100 years.
Exactly
We need to remember that Muslims dont like to accept facts & live in their own little world
King David, Solomon... first temple and even farther back
Modern history has to have limits though, does it not? Lest we would have to agree that the United States is still native land....Yet it's not. Modern history would show that land 1000% belongs to the Palestinians and if not for foreign intervention, it's still would. Israel is propped up by MY tax dollars
So true.
The weird thing is that there are plenty of ancient artifacts like coins which link the Jews to the Israel region. I have not found information about anything mentioning Palestine was there before Romans named the land itself Palestine.
There was never a Palestine state, that is a new term. Arabs living I the region prior to the creation of Israel considered themselves Syrians, Jordanians and Egyptians.
For curiosity, Palestinians, today they speaking the same language, same beliefs with the Arabs . so why they don’t marge with arabs ?
Palestinians are Canaanites who lived there before the jews
The Palestinians are Arabs. They are jordanians. They are not indigenous to Israel. They moved in in the 7th century AD. The Jews had already been there for 3,000 years. Genetics proves this.
@@jimbatsis7949Because they are culturally different🤦♂️ Stay in school please and pay attention
They've put their trust in the wrong book. The wrong ideology. The wrong approach
Yeah. Sad that Islam takes Christianity and corrupts it to make it more believable.
These should never have happened 😢
When did Palestine become its own State as an independently recognized self-governing nation?
Probably before you were born...
1988 but never act as one.
@@journeybug3050
That would make sense as it became an issue only after Israel became a country. I sympathize with the citizens of the Gaza Strip as their homeland is torn asunder in the search for Hamas soldiers. Israel is in a difficult position trying to resolve a problem it didn't directly create.
@@journeybug3050
It would be nice to see the Palestinians elect a more responsible government. The Palestinians wanting their own state did not become an issue until Israel was formed.
@journeybug3050 Palestine doesn't exist. It never has. it's just land that Israel gives in exchange for peace. They never get the peace and every time the Muslims attack, they lose more land
Interesting video. Now you know what it was like to be a Christian in Turkey from the fall of Constantinople in 1453 to the present day.
Constantinople change his name Jesus Christ. He is false image. We is worshipping Constantinople.
What does this have to do with anything?
it was before the "modern rule based world" born from the WW2.
The land known as Palestine was once a part of Phoenicia.
Before then it was known as Canaan...
PP don't have money for food, but they have money for rockets...
You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame: I shot a rocket back."
-Noam Chomsky
@@Unpopularity Which god are you talking about? And if ur talking about the palestine people just remember the fact that they all are going to heaven as all of them are "Shaheed❤". They are in a better place now❤❤
ua-cam.com/video/-7a6tDnziJw/v-deo.html .. .
.... .
@@user-wh7ce5sl5i inshallah
Onepath network is a lying network. Israel did NOT steal the land. Israelites were there when Moses brought them out of Egypt 4000 years ago. Where was Palestine? It didn't exist.
@@hegagi839 "If I don't *steal* your house someone else will" - yakub the honest Israeli settler, don't debate with us when the Israelis are the one refuting you