I think flower would be quite important as when you think about it: when someone talks about first boots, flower immediately get's acknowledged. Also is it REALLY bfdi without flower?
If spongy was the first boot I don't think anything would have changed. Also, tpot is working fine without flower (there was that weird thing with robot flower but tpot was fine even before that)
yes, bfdi is very easily bfdi without flower, infact it may actually be better off without her because in season one she was an awful 1 dimensional antagonist whos only personality trait was violence.
@@ThrarmClipsok but like think about BFDI 25, she destroyed all the recovery centers and started killing everybody off. This also builds onto her redemption story (which ends in her winning BFB) personally I think she’s at least quite important if not very important
this is a really cool unique idea this was done well albeit slightly biased (emphasis on slightly) I’m only at 6:28 atm but I’d argue Golf ball would be slightly important for the few episodes she is in she has quite in impact on how well her team does in challenges and having interactions with a variety of characters
Some I disagree with: Pin-She was a team leader so she kinda created some interactions through that Flower-She did a slight amount of important stuff (Destroying recovery centers so Bubble didnt compete in BFDIA) Announcer-Blud was the face of BFDI. Nobody could pull off hosting season 1 like he could Rocky-(This one is bias so dont listen to it as much), he was the only source of comic relief in later episodes
I think announcer’s most relevancy is in the season 4 finale where he causes the whole side plot with all the contestants fighting for the bfdi and also nearly ending the show. It’s kinda surprising to think about how little he did in the original season of bfdi besides be sassy sometimes, but then again it makes sense as he’s probably the most mysterious bfdi character.
I disagree, David was detrimental because his debut prevented a character who could have actually been a character and not a joke from joining. Had Bomby debuted, or Nickel, or Ruby, or any of the others, the season may have had more interesting plotlines develop, but that didnt happen, we got David. His inclusion alone wasn't a detriment, but the knowledge of what we missed out on absolutely was.
flower is at least quite important solely because of the finale. she destroyed the recovery centers, permanently killing off multiple characters until, if memory serves, bfdia 5? (except bubble, who came back earlier with the bubble blower) this also literally prevented multiple characters from competing entirely in bfdia. you could argue this makes her important to the plot of BDFIA, rather than BFDI, because even though what she did was in BFDI, i guess it did effect BFDIA more.
15:14 i kinda see what ur saying but i also kinda disagree bc i love announcer as a host. he’s iconic and i love the sarcasm. plus he did have the whole “budget cuts” gag
yeah but he could be replaced by anyone else and it wouldn't change anything, he's just the giy they picked, like you say he's iconic but so would purple face if he was the host right
@@ThrarmClips purple face is also annoying tho. i feel like if he did the budget cuts thing with his character it would somehow be less funny. maybe i’m jus trippin but i feel like the ai voice makes the lines funnier than if they had four or two say them since they’re properly voice acted. i respect that tho!
I'll say icecube is more important than blocky even if she's not as funny or interesting as him she did have a small alliance plot line and revenge plot which show up in later seasons. blocky is similar to needle to just being comic relief
"just there" is a very wide category, I personally don't think Ice Cube made much of a difference to the overall show, it was relatively the same before and after her elimination and that shows considering how they chose to eliminate her.
Blocky was much more relevant than Needle tho. Blocky literally had his own ads which were actually funny. Needle's whole Needy gag got old very quickly and was pretty forgettable throughout BFDI. And Ice Cube literally just floated her way to the final 6 or 7.
@@Randomguywhoishere8783 She didn't really do much tho, just was part of a few arcs and recycled lines. I just think she was a boring character who didn't contribute that much to the show.
wait a minute without eraser, nobody would be there to notice announcer there and eraser would never be there to tell everyone else about the show which starts the show. eraser could be replaced by someone else but it makes sense for it to be him so that eraser’s just a nobody.
yes, announcer should be very important, and i knew you'd make the argument that he could be replaced easily, lol. but thats not the question being asked. its, "how important is this character to the plot?" and like you said with the finalists, there is no story without them. well, without announcer, there is no competition. no alliances. no teams. no eliminations. no challenges. nothing. yes, he had no personality. yes, any other host of a future season could replace him - but, while we're on this, let me make another point. those hosts wouldn't have hosted the future seasons either if announcer had never started this. - back to the original point, yes, all the stuff you said, but without him. there is literally no show.
Some things I would change 1 announcer should be in at least quite important as without him the show literally couldn’t exist 2 snow should be in slightly important due to winning 2 tiebreakers causing td to get out and bfdi 9 blocky should also be in quite important
Fair enough for Snowball, however I don't think those tie breakers caused enough of a ripple effect throughout the entire season, it just saved a few Grapes for a few more episodes. and like I said, announcer could be replaced by anyone else and it would not have changed
I don't like David really, and am sad he joined over someone else, but I'm glad he joined. For example, if Basketball joined, their personality would just be their audition tape thingy, so they would have a rivalry with specifically TB, so I'm glad nothing like that happened
can you do animatic big brother if you are still retaining interest in it? I already have some with 24 characters Z5MYbbhU this one has 3 randomly chosen characters from each team H7wCEmn1 this one i replaced 9 characters with some important ones (or some that i liked but didn't get in the first one) also click re-simulate so it's changed
my videos are largely light-hearted and non-serious, this one especially, i don't really hate him as much as i seem like i do in this video it's being played up for effect
I think flower would be quite important as when you think about it: when someone talks about first boots, flower immediately get's acknowledged. Also is it REALLY bfdi without flower?
If spongy was the first boot I don't think anything would have changed. Also, tpot is working fine without flower (there was that weird thing with robot flower but tpot was fine even before that)
yes, bfdi is very easily bfdi without flower, infact it may actually be better off without her because in season one she was an awful 1 dimensional antagonist whos only personality trait was violence.
@@ThrarmClips She was kinda important in the sense that she destroyed every Recovery Center
@@ThrarmClipsok but like think about BFDI 25, she destroyed all the recovery centers and started killing everybody off. This also builds onto her redemption story (which ends in her winning BFB) personally I think she’s at least quite important if not very important
@@riftrishereWhat redemption arc? She just started to become nice with no reasoning. I hope they actually go into this in IDFB.
this is a really cool unique idea this was done well albeit slightly biased (emphasis on slightly)
I’m only at 6:28 atm but I’d argue Golf ball would be slightly important for the few episodes she is in she has quite in impact on how well her team does in challenges and having interactions with a variety of characters
Some I disagree with:
Pin-She was a team leader so she kinda created some interactions through that
Flower-She did a slight amount of important stuff (Destroying recovery centers so Bubble didnt compete in BFDIA)
Announcer-Blud was the face of BFDI. Nobody could pull off hosting season 1 like he could
Rocky-(This one is bias so dont listen to it as much), he was the only source of comic relief in later episodes
flower destroying the recovery centers affected bfdia, not bfdi
I would've kept Pin in slightly important imo, she did have that alliance with Leafy. Wouldn't put her down with all those irrelevant characters.
I think announcer’s most relevancy is in the season 4 finale where he causes the whole side plot with all the contestants fighting for the bfdi and also nearly ending the show. It’s kinda surprising to think about how little he did in the original season of bfdi besides be sassy sometimes, but then again it makes sense as he’s probably the most mysterious bfdi character.
this video is talking about BFDI season 1, so yes he does become important later on but in season 1, no dice
@@ThrarmClips yeah ig in season one they wanted to focus on the competitors more
Actually W tierlist (except David, he never did anything to worsen the plot because he wasn't involved in the plot. Just there is the best tier)
I disagree, David was detrimental because his debut prevented a character who could have actually been a character and not a joke from joining. Had Bomby debuted, or Nickel, or Ruby, or any of the others, the season may have had more interesting plotlines develop, but that didnt happen, we got David. His inclusion alone wasn't a detriment, but the knowledge of what we missed out on absolutely was.
@@ThrarmClips Even Roboty would've been more interesting than David...
@@cooperc69420ok maybe not thaaaat low
@@ThrarmClipscan you really blame david for that tho?
@@the_random12345 I’m not blaming David, I’m just stating the facts, and the fact is, his inclusion was detrimental.
flower is at least quite important solely because of the finale. she destroyed the recovery centers, permanently killing off multiple characters until, if memory serves, bfdia 5? (except bubble, who came back earlier with the bubble blower)
this also literally prevented multiple characters from competing entirely in bfdia.
you could argue this makes her important to the plot of BDFIA, rather than BFDI, because even though what she did was in BFDI, i guess it did effect BFDIA more.
that bfdia
15:14 i kinda see what ur saying but i also kinda disagree bc i love announcer as a host. he’s iconic and i love the sarcasm. plus he did have the whole “budget cuts” gag
yeah but he could be replaced by anyone else and it wouldn't change anything, he's just the giy they picked, like you say he's iconic but so would purple face if he was the host right
@@ThrarmClips purple face is also annoying tho. i feel like if he did the budget cuts thing with his character it would somehow be less funny. maybe i’m jus trippin but i feel like the ai voice makes the lines funnier than if they had four or two say them since they’re properly voice acted. i respect that tho!
okie finished it very epic love to see more of the other seasons
Oooooh I like this idea
I'll say icecube is more important than blocky even if she's not as funny or interesting as him she did have a small alliance plot line and revenge plot which show up in later seasons. blocky is similar to needle to just being comic relief
"just there" is a very wide category, I personally don't think Ice Cube made much of a difference to the overall show, it was relatively the same before and after her elimination and that shows considering how they chose to eliminate her.
Blocky was much more relevant than Needle tho. Blocky literally had his own ads which were actually funny. Needle's whole Needy gag got old very quickly and was pretty forgettable throughout BFDI. And Ice Cube literally just floated her way to the final 6 or 7.
Ice cube is useless
@@Randomguywhoishere8783 She didn't really do much tho, just was part of a few arcs and recycled lines. I just think she was a boring character who didn't contribute that much to the show.
@@cooperc69420 oh crab I meant to say she is useless
wait a minute
without eraser, nobody would be there to notice announcer there and eraser would never be there to tell everyone else about the show which starts the show. eraser could be replaced by someone else but it makes sense for it to be him so that eraser’s just a nobody.
that would have happened either way, announcer was there to host the show and it would have started somehow
yes, announcer should be very important, and i knew you'd make the argument that he could be replaced easily, lol. but thats not the question being asked. its, "how important is this character to the plot?" and like you said with the finalists, there is no story without them. well, without announcer, there is no competition. no alliances. no teams. no eliminations. no challenges. nothing. yes, he had no personality. yes, any other host of a future season could replace him - but, while we're on this, let me make another point. those hosts wouldn't have hosted the future seasons either if announcer had never started this. - back to the original point, yes, all the stuff you said, but without him. there is literally no show.
fair, however, shuttit
@@ThrarmClips 🤐
Some things I would change 1 announcer should be in at least quite important as without him the show literally couldn’t exist 2 snow should be in slightly important due to winning 2 tiebreakers causing td to get out and bfdi 9 blocky should also be in quite important
Fair enough for Snowball, however I don't think those tie breakers caused enough of a ripple effect throughout the entire season, it just saved a few Grapes for a few more episodes.
and like I said, announcer could be replaced by anyone else and it would not have changed
Firey Speaker Box and Flower Speaker Box are in BFDI (including like every other speaker box except PSB but they are not that important)
they weren't on the tierlist
Imagine this but in BFB
I'm the most important character
W ranking but I would change ice cube and announcer speaker box to slightly important
I dont like the detrimental category because i like rocky
Didn’t flower literally melt all of the recovery centers, causing bubble and others to be unpreseny in the next season?
that didn’t affect this season
Ah alright
3:36 there’s also no season two
Ya know, im starting to think you may not like David, crazy, i know.
I don't like David really, and am sad he joined over someone else, but I'm glad he joined. For example, if Basketball joined, their personality would just be their audition tape thingy, so they would have a rivalry with specifically TB, so I'm glad nothing like that happened
TB got eliminated before David debuted in canon anyway, so BB and TB wouldn't have been able to have that rivalry to begin with.
@@cooperc69420 yeah, but I mean in like BFDIA and stuff
@@cooperc69420they would honestly just write Leafy out for this
can you do animatic big brother if you are still retaining interest in it? I already have some with 24 characters
Z5MYbbhU this one has 3 randomly chosen characters from each team
H7wCEmn1 this one i replaced 9 characters with some important ones (or some that i liked but didn't get in the first one)
also click re-simulate so it's changed
David would like to know your address
What tier list is this
Flower kind off cheated in bfb the writers clearly wanted flower to win even tho most people had the feeling gelatine was supposed to win
they wanted flower to win and she did, it’s not that big of a deal to me
@ThrarmClips What if every seaso after that is rigged what if David wins
@ThrarmClips what if pen wins
david cant win
I hope needle gets in the final 5 of bfdia but doesn’t win like Coiny or tb or even pencil or even nickel should win
Blocky has more relevance than Coiny in BFDi
3:13 TBH as much as David's debut was kinda a waste, there's no need to hate him so much like that man, chill out.
my videos are largely light-hearted and non-serious, this one especially, i don't really hate him as much as i seem like i do in this video it's being played up for effect
Oh alright then my mistake
Hello
nonexisty better be top rank
he is in every rank
He is, you just can't see him there.
Yay I’m first!
Just like Firey was in BFDI!
@@cooperc69420well said