Why the UK is in the EU | Yes, Minister | American Reacts

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 46

  • @irreverend_
    @irreverend_ Місяць тому +12

    You really should watch these series fully, they're timeless classics

  • @timg5011
    @timg5011 Місяць тому +7

    This is from Yes Minister s01e05.
    Glad you like the show. Its the crowning glory of British political satire.

  • @iainsan
    @iainsan Місяць тому +17

    The UK is still one of the few European countries where it is legal not to carry any personal identification.

    • @irreverend_
      @irreverend_ Місяць тому +4

      I wouldn't be comfortable at all having that a legal requirement

    • @TheCornishCockney
      @TheCornishCockney Місяць тому

      I was always against ID cards,but now,I’d welcome it.
      For reasons including voting in a general election and all the aliens now amongst us.
      And no,I’m NOT a rabid far right lunatic,just a very concerned British citizen.

    • @iainsan
      @iainsan Місяць тому +4

      @@irreverend_ Nor would I.

    • @irreverend_
      @irreverend_ Місяць тому +1

      @@iainsan I know a lot of people will argue (and I feel a bit stupidly), that if you're innocent you have nothing to fear. That kind of statement anyway. Except, in a state where you're REQUIRED to always have ID, well you can just be vaguely forgetful one morning and you've broken the law. Even the requirement of having ID but not always carrying it, is overkill to me. It's not on me to prove my identity to even the police, I've never lied to the police about who I am, but it's their job to verify that. I can give them my national insurance number etc, but photo ID? Never had that until I was 36 and got a provisional licence for a motorcycle. Which took 6 months, because I had to get a passport first, and my GP was no longer allowed to attest to my identity. Previously that would've been ok, but I guess with so many non British born medical practitioners, they've stopped that. So I needed to find a professional, not related to me, who had known me for over 10 years to confirm I'm me. Which was surprisingly difficult because most people who know me are elderly neighbours and didn't meet the criteria. I also had to get copies of my birth certificate, my mother's birth certificate, my mother's marriage certificate, and this was all during lockdowns so I had it pay for expedited ones, since most were in Scotland, and it may have taken 3 months otherwise for each document. In short, it cost me £400 to get a passport, and a further £200 to get the provisional licence. And 6 months.

    • @sunseeker9581
      @sunseeker9581 Місяць тому

      ​@@iainsan what about when youre stopped from voting?

  • @vincentsaia6545
    @vincentsaia6545 25 днів тому

    This is Yes, Minister.

  • @seijika46
    @seijika46 Місяць тому +1

    The strategy worked very well indeed - up until some lunatics threw proper decision-making out of the window in favour off letting people who often knew little or nothing about what was at stake to decide on membership...and unsurprisingly chose poorly. Now, in the face of vast new transatlantic tariffs and the possible demise of NATO, we're obliged to go begging for help from people who we openly dislike and thus are unlikely to be over-generous. Key lesson: leave diplomacy to the FCO, not stupid voting.

    • @paulgovan3507
      @paulgovan3507 Місяць тому

      @@seijika46 Demise of the US-NATO-Israel trifecta can't come soon enough, mate. As for your "people we openly dislike" - if you're still swallowing the mainstream media's US-servile Koolaid + Baloney you probably mean BRICS countries and other countries that defiantly refuse to become US vassals like Britain.
      Paul G

  • @irreverend_
    @irreverend_ Місяць тому +1

    Incidentally on more than one occasion the idea of compulsory identity cards was floated in the UK as a result of the EEC and then the EU, and we really didn't want them. EDIT: it's also not illegal to drive without your licence on you. Illegal to if you don't have a licence of course, but you don't have to have it with you at all times, "The Police are entitled to ask to see your licence at any time and if you do not have it immediately, you will be ordered to produce it to a Police Station within 7 days."

    • @irreverend_
      @irreverend_ Місяць тому

      For example, I had never had any form of identification until I was 36 (and only then because I wanted a motorcycle licence). Been arrested multiple times over the years, never been an issue. Got convicted once, still never had any form of ID.

    • @sunseeker9581
      @sunseeker9581 Місяць тому

      Might have made it easier to vote for all those adults that dont have id cos they dont have enough moneybto drive or travel.

    • @spodula
      @spodula Місяць тому

      The last time was Tony Bliar. It basically put the very few people who still supported him into the Libdem camp. (He had already lost most of the lefter leaning voters over Iraq, so he wasn't going to win any election anyway, so if your really an authoritarian arse, why not go full out?)

    • @Isleofskye
      @Isleofskye 27 днів тому

      The idea is still floating in THe North Sea,last I heard:)

  • @clemstevenson
    @clemstevenson Місяць тому +5

    Now we're on the outside, the French, Germans, Belgians, Dutch, Italians, and so-on, would have to screw things up themselves. It's much fairer to let them do it for themselves. Meanwhile, we're planning to move the island to the middle of the Atlantic.

  • @adrianhughes8143
    @adrianhughes8143 Місяць тому

    Why do you stop the video then actually say word for word what has just been said. A lot of people that watch your reaction's are British and as our language is English especially people like me who are English and born and bred English also it's our nation's language, we can understand everything that is being said in the video without you copying word for word what has been said in Yes Minister. 💂‍♂️🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇮🇪

    • @Isleofskye
      @Isleofskye 27 днів тому

      He is highlighting the salient points.

  • @paulgovan3507
    @paulgovan3507 Місяць тому +4

    The most important takeaway: TV, our media and Deep-State overlords would NEVER permit a subversive ugly truth-exposing series like this to be made today - and if it tried to mock or ridicule the whole warmongering US-NATO-Israel trifecta the script-writers and would-be producers would be blacklisted and possibly end up in Belmarsh prison.
    Paul G

    • @Whoami691
      @Whoami691 Місяць тому

      Found the wokie.

    • @paulgovan3507
      @paulgovan3507 Місяць тому

      @Whoami691 Wokeness is a well-deserved smear for people who claim to care about anything EXCEPT major geopolitical issues/truths. Do YOU give a damn about the forever warmongering now genocidal US-Israel psychopaths?
      Our mainstream media low-lifes would have you believe that the likes of Martin Luther King Jr and yer Jesus of Nazareth were virtue-signalling do-gooders. I suggest you stop parroting mainstream smears and get yerself some serious geopolitical research done. Get wide-awake - fruck wokeness.

    • @paulgovan3507
      @paulgovan3507 Місяць тому

      @Whoami691 You really need to try and understand the massive difference between sh!tlib small issue "woke-ness" and genuinely bold, fearless full-spectrum geopolitical wide-awakeness and truth-telling. If you think that those of us who condemn warmongering genocidal US-Israel psychopaths are woke clones you're just another geopolitically unresearched victim of a mainstream tamestream media who would have you believe that the likes of Martin Luther King Jr, JFK, Malcom X and the post-Beatles John Lennon("Gimme Some Truth") were fringe virtue-signalling left-wing crazies.
      I urge you to learn to differentiate between fearless ultra-informed geopolitical truth-tellers and woke phonies who don't do the geopolitcal research and cloak themselves with small-issue wokeness...
      (Paul G)

    • @paulgovan3507
      @paulgovan3507 Місяць тому

      @Whoami691 No - you found the geopolitically WIDE-AWAKE..
      PS. I wonder if this comment of mine will also be quickly disappeared like my other lengthier geopolitically subversive responses that I've posted here in response to this guy over the past 36 hours?
      Unseen anti-free-speech, anti-truth forces at work again?

    • @Whoami691
      @Whoami691 Місяць тому

      @@paulgovan3507 dawww! You're so cute, acting pro free speech while trying to cancel anyone who dares call you on your bull.
      Trans whamen arent whamen'
      Hislamists are violent and have caused an increase in violent crime
      Diversity is not our strength, merit is
      Not all cultures are equal.
      Wide awake my crack.