Is Minecraft REALLY getting WORSE?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- ddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
Sry for all my voice changes, i recorded at day and sometimes at night so thats the reason. I know also that its really complicated topic but I hope I exhausted it a little bit. Last changes in minecraft are not that bad so we will see what future will bring for us. see ya ヾ(•ω•`)o
Music used:
Toby Fox:
Uwa!! So Temperate♫
NCS:
• Mortals x Royalty Mash...
S'Hill:
• S'Hill - Awake [Chills...
Scott Buckley:
'Ashes of a Fallen Year' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.au
'Icarus' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.au
Funnily enough, when I play this game I end up going for much longer than most people apparently do. I think part of that is that I always enjoyed the game for being a sandbox rather than the progression? I've killed the ender dragon maybe 4 times throughout my probably tens of thousands of hours in the game. It's not really that fun of a fight imo. It's mechanically complex but simultaneously fairly boring and tedious with failure potentially sending you into the void and losing everything.
I think you touched on a really good point that people notice proportional changes more than absolute changes in games. For me, I enjoy 1.21 purely for the tuff bricks and expanded copper block options. That said, the update doesn't fundamentally change anything about the way I approach the game. The mace is probably pretty neat but I haven't had time to mess around with one yet.
It's worth consideration whether the game would be freshened up by changing core mechanics. Imagine an Inventory Overhaul update! Adding ways to invest XP into your character's directly instead of gear? Adding area protection mechanics to the base game? Adding meaningful minigame UIs to blocks we already use? Enchanting is rather boring and could benefit from something like that last one. A lot of the best updates did this on accident and were left in (on Java edition, at least): being able to fit in 1 block spaces with trapdoors, and being able to put anything in your off-hand to name two (on Bedrock the offhand can only hold like 5 things; they didn't intend for it to be so useful but it was very popular so kept it on Java).
Also phantoms need to be removed from the game, or encountering them needs to be the result of intentional player action rather than just forgetting to right click a specific block once every three days.
Not that Phantoms are not annoying. But you can build easily a light sensor that rings a bell once you can sleep that is precise to the milisecond. Reminds you every night then.
I dont think phantoms should be removed but changed rather. Like from today’s 3 nights to 10? 10 nights without sleep maybe
@@hedone13xyeah 10 days without sleep would make more sense
While I understand the feel of early Minecraft I would never build without deepslate again, early Minecraft wasn't really interesting to me as a builder so I just mined for ores most of the time
hey great video, pretty good for only 50 subs, keep up the work.
I like to talk about this through the lens of things like design and balance moreso than overall quality. Modern Minecraft is far more polished, looks much nicer, and has way more content. However, a few very impactful changes, like health regen, stackable food, sprinting, and shields have significantly changed both how the game plays out and how you approach it.
In pre-Adventure Update Minecraft, it was structured and paced almost like a survival horror game. There were hard limits to how much food you could process, store and carry, and as a result you were basically capped on how much healing you could take with you on an expedition. Every arrow and spider bite and 5-block fall you took would slowly whittle that supply down, and you'd also constantly be asking "is it worth using this whole cooked porkchop to heal this two-heart injury?"
In post-Adventure Minecraft, the gameplay loop is closer to "grab your 150 cooked steaks, sprint through the cave, stuff your face every time your hunger gets low enough that HP stops regenerating, and survive effortlessly until a stray hit from behind knocks you into lava." It's not that the progression is worse, or that the enemies are easier, or that not every new feature is some amazing multi-purpose omnitool that you don't know how you ever lived without, it's that the core gameplay just isn't as engaging as it used to be. It's the kind of unnecessary and poorly planned rebalance that'd completely kill a lot of games, Minecraft is just fortunate enough to be the one game where "core gameplay loop" is a small enough fraction of the appeal that people still love it anyway.
Also the playerbase changed, before it was like 20 episodes of survival Minecraft but now day 3 and they are already in another dimension
No, i wished about these updates 9 years ago(still waiting for end update)
Good video but please don't use background music with lyrics. Makes you very hard to understand.
Very appreciate the advise, especially that im not familiar yet with editing and others
Wojack usage is getting worse
im sorry
I don't care what anyone says, an update is always good
thats true, i didnt say not adding another updates would be better
Well thats just untrue. There are plenty of updates that have taken features people enjoyed. Updates that fucked netcode, assest loading, load times, ect ect.
Stop being a corpo-simp.
@@StopBanningMaStuffyou are saying it in general or with minecraft as an example
@@StopBanningMaStuff dooooooon't careeeeeeee
Nice recap of Minecraft, amazing vid my dude
Personally, I still use 1.16, cant stand how the game looks and feels now :)
ever since they stopped doing TU worlds on console they started dropping off
last good update was the nether update
I really liked your video in the sense that it explains how I feel about the game. When I finish the game I’m done with the world I’m not a builder I just can’t build my creativity is really bad and I agree with most of the topics.
As a builder I found the early Minecraft limiting so I just mined, today I can't imagine not building with deepslate, the block is a blessing for roofs
have you considered playing the older versions instead?
no, they need something to complain about
i mean I later clarified that minecraft is not getting worse because developers arent deleting content from the game, but they could for sure add more things and keep their promises made to community
If you want the old minecraft feeling but still want to experience some new things I recommend playing RL Craft. I started that recently and since it's on version 1.12 there's old textures and that old feel but also it's way more challenging with a ton more stuff.
No, Next question
It is absolute insanity how people are still making these types of videos. There is negative discussion to be had after the 50th "Minecraft is bad now" middle-school tier video essay; please move on to more interesting topics that demand creative thought. If not for us, then for your own benefit.
In fact minecraft is getting better but its direction might not be in good condition. With this video i want to add my thoughs to the "discussion" why many people might thinks so and why others might disagree cuz finally its subjective matter. And by the way, i wanted to refresh knowledge about earlier version. But thanks for all the advise, ill take it into consideration!!
@@PecoraPL maybe the interest in realismcraft can shift the focus of this trend of "early mc vs today's mc" topic, the fact some biomes are still the same for like a decade is just lame, by this time it should have been much better looking, we still don't have an autumn biome
Not even watching it. No, it hasn't gotten worse. This topic is beyond overdone. Get newer ideas.
Yes, it is worse. From feature creep alone.
it hasn't gotten worse because nothing was deleted. All updates were cool but their frequency and quality have decreased nowadays but of course it ultimately depends on who you ask. Mojang overpromised many things that are still waiting to be added. As i said the game is in good condition but it could surely be better. Whole 1.21 is based on underground structure which will be hard to find if you wont search for it using for example maps. And that is what i stated in my video 20:36 , but thank you for the advice
@@DragonlordN7 Funny, others say Mineraft has not enough features like in all videos showcasing mods.
@@DundGafter you try realismcraft you know vanilla Minecraft is a bit dated-looking, I get the feeling of early mc survival but when it comes to building and biomes it was lame, like a lot
no, btw
Commenting for the algorithm. Hoping you blow up.
I really hope that they're working on something big. I feel like mojang is just playing catch up with the earlier updates since the caves and cliffs updates and they are just naming it other things so they dont call it Caves and Cliffs PT 4. These updates are the equalvalant to a naruto filler episode. Think of the buzzy bees and, and the Frostburn update, They were straight ass, but good updates came afterwards. Theres something big coming if were getting these ahh boring updates
when 1.22 releases:
"Why 1.23 Will Save Minecraft"
lets hope so
buzzy bees isn't ass when you look what got done outside of content, aka. A LOT of code optimization and quality of life changes!
Buzzy bees was a decent small update but frostburn is just omg so bad, they could have at least added snow building blocks and made igloos built out of that rather than ordinary snow blocks, also icicles or snowlogging maybe even ice castle or something
17:57 Minecraft is a 3D game, a 3 Dimensions Game, there won't be a new Dimension, BUT, an overhaul of the End Dimension would be great to see in Game.
They said no new dimensions before existing ones get an update
no it isnt
Yes Minecraft is getting worse
Yes it is getting worse. Anyone that disagrees, please tell me what glow berries, cherry blossoms, glow squids and sniffers have added that meaningfully changes the way that I experience the game? It's all inventory clutter. That doesn't even cover the weird mechanics they keep trying to force, like sneaking in caves, transporting frogs to the nether etc. etc. Mojang need to start adding things that ACTUALLY change the game instead of filling my inventory. Shulkers and bundles aren't good enough at this rate, since every time they add a new "solution", they add 50 new items that stack awkwardly...
"please tell me what glow berries, cherry blossoms, glow squids and sniffer"
glow berries, cherry blossoms: Building? Like the main feature that is Minecraft since day 1, having more blooks to build. Plus the glow berry is nice to lighten up places in a different way than torches or lanterns, more magical feeling.
glow squids and sniffer: Those where the communities choices... But still, glow ink and two new plants for decoration plus mobs for more ambience in your world, like building a deep sea base or an dinosaur biome for Sniffers.
You strike me as the non creative type!
@@DundG I don't think you understand what I'm getting at. I know that blocks are for building. Sorry to burst your bubble, but you aren't the first to realise that...
Also, glow squids to not produce any light, they meerly ignore light levels in their texture. That isn't the same thing as being a light source like a torch is.
My main point is that each of these new features you encounter will fill your inventory with junk that just isn't needed. If you use silk touch on ores, you will now find that you are regularly gathering 16 different stacks of ore due to deepslates addition. You will also have your inventory filled by the 8 different stone varients as well.
You can pull the "muh building blocks" argument, but at a certain point, you need to consider the actual experience of inventory management in this game and how shockingly bad it is now. You can't even argue that you can simply just throw unwanted items away, since that gets tedious in and of itself.
When you have a total of 36 inventory slots, having 16 for ores, a minimum of 2 for tools, 1 stack of blocks, 1 stack of wood and 1 for a weapon, your inventory feels pretty worthless. That's 21/36 slots taken up immediately, and that isn't even counting torches, which you now need more of due to the larger caves...
@@Handles_AreStupid "Also, glow squids to not produce any light, they meerly ignore light levels in their texture." Where did I supposedly even claim that?! Quote the sentence.
"16 different stacks of ore" Really... you mean you mine from top to bottom in a single session AND find rarer variants like deepslate coal or deepslate emerald, or stone diamond and stone redstone while you're at? I really don't believe you.
Plus, if you REALLY don't want unwanted stones, ores or even any type of items, you can spread for example 5 slots iron, 3 slots gold, 1 slot diamond and the rest stone around to fill up your inventory and you're unable to pick up any items except which are already in your inventory.
Plus use redstone to order your inventory so you don't need to do it everytime manually. There are tutorials for those contraptions, which aren't difficult to build.
And any game that lives from gathering a lot of items with limited space will have this "issue". Inventory management is part of the game and always will be as a not so small part of the community wants more building blocks and natural blocks. Heck I just googled and found a mod with every stone variant being able to be every ore variant. So 64 different ore types, so I guess some don't mind what you hate.
"have added that meaningfully changes the way that I experience the game" Oh I misread. Don't know how YOU experience the game and those features probably don't. But who cares about the experience of one single player?! If it isn't for you, it isn't, will hardly affect the games popularity!
"Sorry to burst your bubble, but you aren't the first to realise that..." Oh the Sass. I give it a 3/10. Nice start, but you misreading me the very next sentence weakens it a lot!
@@Handles_AreStupid don't mine things you don't want, or just throw it away, although we could use at least another row in inventory
@@DundGexactly, also they can throw away something they don't want, I don't understand why are so many mc players so afraid of throwing away diorite for example if they had to mine it and now it is in their inventory, or why did they even mine it in the first place....
Because of their inventory mismanagement therefore a game about building should never again add new blocks or something. God forbid we get a new flower. It is all "needless clutter" apparently
Some players really want the building game to be just cobblestone and oak wood. They are the only ones who prefer current birch biome over the one we saw in concept art. I mean how can anyone be against more immersive and beautiful biomes like cherry blossom
nah, not really.
i only hate mob vote
Yeah they better quit with that shit now. How hard is it to just add 3 mobs??
They make us choose 3 mobs no one asked for but can't add vertical slabs, something we all wish for
@@oliver_editzz61they are completely illogical, like they want us to vote on some mobs no one asked for, and with a clear bias, but when we suggest something like basic furniture they are all like "it doesn't fit the VISION for the game WE have". So... If they have a vision then why bother aksing players anything? They wished for sniffer to win, like how it was presented and everything clearly shows that, they should have just said it will come to the game and that is it, no voting needed.
@@velvet3784 oh wow so even Mojang themselves are doing the “that’s not very Minecrafty 🤓” thing?
@@oliver_editzz61yeah in a way yes, they are not very consistent with it tho. Sniffer animation is almost like it is from different game compared to other animals, but furniture, even a simple table and chair , for which textures did exist in game files, is apparently not fitting in their view or something. They like to set themsleves some really weird rigid rules like "no vertical slabs, period"
No.