Both countries are proud to speak English but not willing to speak their own language. Especially in India, boys who speak English will have better chance of winning a girl's heart.
@@infoworld7706 such a shame... I am not saying speaking English is not good, it is the world's most speak language, but people should not be proud on being able to speak a foreign language, especially when India is considered to be one of the older civilization on earth
so basically Singaporian speak broken English and broken Chinese, lol Edit: Ey bros chill, I meant no offense to Singaporean homies, just find it funny
grayisagirl c what i wanna know is, was he really rappin? what was he sayin!? also, i was waitin for the sunglasses & the music ”tara-rara-ra” & the text ”thuglife”...
Bangga sebagai rakyat Malaysia !!! Kerana kami fasih dalam sekurang kurangnya 3 bahasa. Proud to be a Malaysian! Because we are fluent in at least 3 languages. 我为我自己是马来西亚人感到骄傲!!! 因为我们能够说一口流利的至少3种语言
which part of Malaysia? I know I shouldn't be saying this cause I am too a Singaporean, but........... ... how did they even pass their Chinese? I know I did. and I'm still in primary school
im proud of those malaysian chinese. We raised our people well as they should not forget their mother tongue. 🤣🤣🤣 Im malay and just learned chinese. I wish to be good in chinese language 🥲
I'm a Malaysian and I'm 12 years old I know how to speak Chinese fluently and I'm an Indian. I didn't go to a Chinese school but I learned it my self cause I found that speaking in Chinese is so interesting
I'm so proud of Malaysian Chinese! I know what they have done to keep the Chinese language and culture in Malaysia society! Best Chinese group abroad! 真的为马来西亚的华人朋友感到骄傲. 我知道他们曾经为了华语和华人文化所做过的努力! 最棒的海外华人!
Pretty much all of my friends from Malaysia can speak Chinese fluently. I have been wondering how do ya people manage to learn three languages, Chinese, Malay and English(if I recall it correctly) at the same time in Malaysia? It is so impressive.
@@evilproducer9647 they speak mandarin with their families at home, speak Malay with Malay friends/teacher at school and English is pretty common bcs it's the 2nd language in Malaysia, you can get a better job if you're fluent in English (sometimes Mandarin too). My dad and sister(malay) are fluent in mandarin too
I don’t agree with not being able to speak their mother tongue HOWEVER, people it is easy to just say things like what you said because you weren’t put in a spot to answer a question in front of camera. Not everybody can do well like that. But then again, I could never understand people who thought only English was important so 🤷🏻♀️
@Gwi 93 No Mandarin is simply a common dialect for all Chinese around the world so that they are able to understand each other better, there are other dialects too like Cantonese and Hokkien, they are all dialects of the Chinese language
blissxful _ my father has been living in singapore for almost 10 years now, and we also went there for a vacation, we had chinese singaporean friends and they speak a bit of mandarin and lots of singaporean english.
blissxful _ i know some singaporeans who are fluent in chinese, but there are also some who aren't that fluent with the language. i guess it depends on the family??? i can't really speak for them since i'm not sgean, this is just based on my personal experience and observation from singaporean chinese people that i know of and have already met 😊
@SomeoneYDK 餘實恩 That's true, but American, British, Australian, and Canadian accents are considered the standard accents to learn from. OP is talking about what we know as a foreign accent. Think about how even in China, Mandarin speakers will have different accents. Those accents are all acceptable to learn from, but if foreigners like myself learn Mandarin, we will have a non-native accent to all Mandarin speakers. There's nothing wrong with having a foreign accent. It's just a fact of learning languages.
because Singapore abolished vernacular schools, using fully English education other than mothertongue class, so English became the mainstream language.
Bcos of the racial suppression they very fight for their right to learn chinese. In singapore it was propagated to learn english bcos lky deem it as a common gound n good for global economy. With increasing west influence due to sg's successful global economy, the emphasis for mother tongue deminishes through each generation.
Singaporean Chinese are usually able to understand it, but because our accent is too "flat", other chinese speakers from outside Singapore/Malaysia find it hard to understand what we say. (Experience from living abroad with other chinese speaking internationals)
Ohh I’m Japanese, and even I don’t have much knowledge of Chinese language, I can understand what you’re saying! And 以上 同感, it’s completely same how to use in Japanese!!!
hahah... "speaking chinese" "too much Chinese for translation" "speaking higher chinese" "rapping in chinese" OMG! 🤣🤣 I like the kid at the end saying what you talking about and then BOMB! rapping in Chinese... 🤣🤣
Bro you should actually translate what those people who can actually speak Mandarin fluently so we viewers can actually understand what they're explaining as well, instead of just dissing those people who can't really speak Mandarin well
For Sg Chinese language education, the aim is to just verbally communicate kinda, for business rapport with other Chinese, same with English but except better because they also read in English. I happen to know that Sg is already outsourcing their English copyrighting work to the Philippines
I am korean and we have a number of ppl who are good at Chinese like a native. I thought majority of Singaporeans are able to speak Chinese. This is kinda shocking to me.
They’re mainly speaking English and slightly Chinese even though they’re Chinese. But in Malaysia there’s of course Malay, but the 2nd majority in the country is Chinese so most Chinese in Malaysia know decent Chinese maybe not as good as Native China-Chinese kind but they most probably can understand some questions here lol
It really depends on who you run into. People from Chinese-speaking families will be able to speak Chinese fluently enough, on the other hand, not so much if they are from English-speaking families. But the latter's mastery of the English language is likely to be better.
Singaporeans are bilingual and are good in Mandarin. Just that this guy chose wrong venue. He also chose Thai, malaysians (very obvious by their chinese accent) and he never ascertain the nationality of the rest. FAIL! He should have gone to HDB neighbourhood and you will see old aunties and uncles correcting his intonation and pronunciation of Chinese words. Hahaha 一杆子打翻一船人
I'm malaysian chinese. Apparently in our country the government are emphasise citizen to speak malay. The level of our chinese much more better than them we could write and speak fluent as well as the poem. But undeniable some of chinese don't know how to speak chinese due to their families background. Although my english is not strong as Singaporean but it's enough for daily use.
Although chinese in malaysia only got about 20% population(maybe lease by now), they still trying very hard to emphasise chinese education for chinese these days, im malysian chinese n im proud of n respect malaysian chinese!!
yup as a malaysian malay i respected the chinese race here. they can speak with their mother tongue language so fluently. same goes to the indians and malays as well
Ahh really ?? 40% of malaysian chinese cant even speak their own ethnic language . Go to KL many chinese hokkien cantonese and other only speak china national language @ mandarin . I didn't know mandarin is a race/ethnic language . As i know mandarin is a standardized language of china national language
Depends which part of Malaysia you from though, Penang can speak Hokkien and Mandarin, in KL we speak Cantonese and Mandarin. Some speak Hakka and Mandarin. My grandma in Singapore speaks Hokkien no problem but its different to the Hokkien in Penang lol.
@@leonidaslazos6828 it's like saying americans should be 100% fluent in german just because they ethnically the same with germans, not all overseas chinese have the opportunity to learn or speak it because the older generation probably never teach it in the first place
You know there are times where like you know some words in Mandarin, but don't know them in English and then there are times you know the word in English but don't know it in Mandarin.
Learning other languages , it opens another part of your soul that your didn't discover. You speak the language for people to understand but speaking the mother tongue , you talk to their souls.
This is really depressing.. Im literally gobsmacked by the responses given by those adolescences. I wonder how they even passed their O level Mother tongue. Constantly shaking my head in despair. Furthermore, Chinese is not a language. Chinese, per se, is a race or ethnicity group. We, Chinese, speak Mandarin and Mandarin is a form of Chinese Language. Chinese Language consists of Mandarin and other forms of dialects. Just like the Indian dont speak Indian. They speak Tamil or other dialects. I even questioned your proficiency in "Jiak Kang Tang".
i got As for both O level Mother Tongue and Higher Mother Tongue (Mandarin Chinese) but even I would struggle to find the words to answer the questions simply because it isn’t a language that I’ve been using every day. If the people around me don’t converse and don’t wish to converse w me in Mandarin(which they all don’t), I don’t have much use of it. Not to mention the fact that I was exempted from it in JC and hence completely stopped my reading and writing of the language after secondary school. Sure I speak it at home sometimes but words for daily use are different from words required for such questions in the interview, and the fact of the matter is that Singaporeans are just not using the language enough and when practice goes down, fluency does too. It becomes harder to comprehend sentences and form sentences from the very language that we in fact know.
@violet 9968 My precise consensus. Our proficiency in Mother Tongue decreases at an exponential rate ever since we graduated from Secondary School. Our tertiary education don't promote the usage of Mother Tongue and even in our workplace, we mostly converse in English or colloquial form of Singlish. But what is really shocking to me is that, in that video, a couple of teenagers who looks like freshly graduated from Secondary school/JC, couldn't even form a proper dialogue in Mandarin. This makes me ponder, do we even take Mandarin in during Secondary school? Or maybe most student just opted to get "Basic" Chinese language instead as they deem it as a hassle. During my years of pursuing education, I knew students who were struggling in their Mother Tongue, could actually opted for Basic Mother Tongue but this only cater towards a very special minority group of students. Somehow, I just got this bad spider-sense tingling feeling, that the majority of the current generation just simply opted for Basic Mother Tongue just to get the "easy way" out. If that is the case, I'm utterly gutted at our education system. Instead of moving forward, we are actually moving backwards. Most of Us our mother tongue proficiency stops until secondary school. I honestly think, it sets up a good foundation for us moving forward in speaking our Mother Tongue, but it is also up to us as individual, to choose whether we want to hone it and let it incorporated in our lives or just simply brush away and blame the society that it is the environment causes us to neglect our mother tongue. Sadly, we chose the latter. We got no excuse to complain,whine or sulk that "Oh it is so hard to watch Chinese Movie without English Subtitles or to read a Chinese Novel " because our education system has already equipped us the fundamental tools to sufficiently cope with such difficulties. Ultimately, it is up to us to apply them or not.
Are you Han Chinese? Yes, you are right. Many Han people in Malaysia like to called by Malaysia-chinese, it is too funny to me, I am Indonesian-tionghuaness(Han people in Indonesia language). And always said to me " YOU ARE CHINESE, must speak Chinese language,,,lol,,,I thought I must speak my nationality language and Han-Hokkien dialect...and the Malaysia-Han people didn't know how to separate Mandarin and Standard-Chinese language...
@@dollylin262 Tionghoa is also mean Chinese nationalty in China. The name of People Republic of China in Hokkien Chinese start with word Tionghoa, the Indonesian translation to "Republik Rakyat Tiongkok" is actually not linguistically accurate, it's should translated as "Republik Rakyat Tiong Hoa" (mean Tionghoa isn't just Han, but also include other 56 minorities ethnic groups). Here is name of. People Republic of China if written in Hanzi: 中华人民共和国, and the letter 中华 is read as Tionghoa in Hokkien or Zhong Hua in Mandarin. So, if you said Tionghoa and Han are the same thing, it's indicate you don't know the name of People Republic of China in any Han Chinese dialect and how it written in Hanzi. Han and Tionghoa are actually completely different thing and not synonymous.
@@faustinuskaryadi6610 No, Tionghoaness is mean to Han's people only in Indonesia after independent at 1945 year, where there is no Republic of China country yet. Chinese is means to China netizen, where Han the most people and including 55 ethnic. The 55 ethnic is not tionghoaness, cause they have their culture. 中华人民不代表是中华族。Sorry for my personally thinking. Thanks.
@@dollylin262 Republic of China中华民国 was formed in 1912, before Indonesia independent. If 中华 equal to Han, so minority etchic groups will not happy to become citizen of either People Republic of China (中华人民共和国), or Republic of China (中华民国). The one that formed in 1949 is Communist People Republic of China. IMO Han Chinese in Indonesia should call themselves Han instead Tionghoa, but they can also call themselves Tionghoa if they have non-Han diaspora in their community. And Hokkien word Tionghoa is never be adapted to English language, so you should still refer Han Chinese in Indonesia as Han Chinese while speaking English, not Tionghoaness. For me Tionghoa is translation for Chinese, Tiongkok is translation for China, and Han should be translated as Han.
@@faustinuskaryadi6610 RT is not same RRC, RT is republic tiongkok only Han's people in 1912, But after 55 ethnic joined to RT with autonomy each area, RT changed to RRC. Yes, you right, Han- Mandarin can't be International language. But that is not mean Han's people can't speak their mother languages, like as Taiwan. If you go to Taiwan, and ask Taiwanese "Are you Chinese? Must of them answer "No", But if you ask "Are you Han-Hokkien?, Most of them answer "Yes". And are you Indonesian?
Good to be multilingual. I am Chinese & was brought up in Malaya & left for a public school in England 56 years ago & have settled in both England & now Turkey in my retirement. Good to listen to Chinglish. English accents in the UK also vary a lot & many English cannot understand heavy provincial accents. Standard received English i.e. BBC English is the standard but, unfortunately, there is also a Class difference in accents. I am fortunate that I can speak four different Chinese dialects or languages because my father was a Hakka, my mother Hokkien , the servants Cantonese & I picked up Mandarin at school. I also had to learn Malay at School & communicated in Malay with our Chauffeur. Then I moved on to picking up Italian, Czech & Polish owing to my different girlfriends. OK lah! sorry to bore you.
To be honest，as a Chinese，I can't even understand the host's Chinese without reading the subtitles！ that was not Chinese which can make people understanding
Sarawakian/Sabahan fluent in more than 3 language . Such as Malay,English,Chinese,Dusun,Iban,Murut,Lunbawang,Lundayeh & more. Some of us even speak Korean. Walaoo ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@chinmungkuan8551 English is the international lingua franca. I speak Spanish fluently, but it isn't widely used outside of its area and among immigrants.
As I'm living in Malaysia(20years), Singapore(5years)and China(maybe the rest of my life) for a longtime, I think I have to said that, Malaysian entire Chinese level are much higher than Singapore ,indeed there's always a joke for the billboards or road signs spelling wrongly in Chinese at the public tourist places for many times due to the Malay official using the google Translator and become a laughing stock as a headline on the newspaper , but I have to said its just rarely individual case, if u traveling furthermore on others places of Malaysia (other than Cameron), u will find out they are not only speak fluently in Chinese, but also Malay and English and their own's mother tongue (Hokien, Hakka etc). Malaysia national language is melayu as Malaysia Also a multi-racial nation, so they should have a common medium language to united them, but besides that, the chinese ancestor still insists that the Chinese language as a fundamental stone of their culture should be inherits and preserves , languages is the medium of ur very own culture to passing down n inherit, if u lose ur language, then ur culture will most probably be twisted ,fading n bury in the history. So under the local Chinese spiritual leaders such as 林連玉，陳六使 etc, struggling n fighting for the right of learning Chinese, so Nowaday the Chinese-malaysian not only can speak melayu n English, but communicate with their family members in their own dialects n Chinese as well. For the Indonesian, some says they are same as singaporean,but that's truely a sad case ,as their previous pm Suhato strongly against Chinese, because of the domestic political conflicts with the communist party, so he intended to eliminated the language, deprived it from the local Chinese, they don't even have a right to celebrate the Spring Festival there, except recently the policies been started to loosen. But in Singapore, despite of the vast majority is Chinese, but out of the political demanding n certain context at that time, liguangyao have to converted the medium teaching language from Chinese into English in nanyang technology university (before reformed the medium language is Chinese) etc, pulling the Relationships closer to the western countries for ports business and economic development . However, what I wanted to point out is, there are surely many profound reasons n complexities of politic behind the context, but learning Chinese is a privilege through the efforts of generations keep passing down. I'm not put the blame or looking down on anyone, but since there's an opportunity offers by ur school for free, then u should grab the chances n learn it well, either for the career advancement or self-improving, don't just simply take it for granted.
Most Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when ever there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment . 大多数新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化， 他们中的大多数都讨厌自己的母语， 甚至讨厌他们祖先的国家， 这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对来自中国的中国人. 大多数新加坡华人真的讨厌自己的种族， 这是一个如此巨大的失望 ................................................
Somehow I feel that a lot people find being able to speak proper Chinese not a very proud thing as English is perceived as a "branded" or "higher class" language.. Its a sad thing..
In Switzerland, each race speak theirs own mother tongue as a first language and also can speak Swiss . French Swiss speak French and be taught in French at school. German Swiss speak German and be taught in German at school.
4:28 proud malaysian here ! i think all of malaysian chinese can speak their own language but they also good at english. but some of the other malaysian that who is not chinese also know how to speak chinese #NOHATEHERE i just say about my opinion about my own people.
So sorry to Singaporean, I am Malaysian Chinese and I can speak English, Malay, Chinese, Cantonese and Japanese. Thanks to my country most of the Chinese here speak fluently in mother tongue and sometimes dialects. PROUD TO BE MALAYSIAN
I am a Chinese college student and I am capable of speaking Chinese mandarin,Sichuan dialect and fluent English. Frankly speaking I think these guys interviewed are kind of weird in pronunciation both in Chinese and English😂
I kinda agree with you. However, note that singaporeans with excellent performance like how you are in China are way better than these few people which are not even sufficient to be a considerable sample. 不能以偏概全，是吧
Wow,I am from Sichuan as well,so the two languages and one dialect I could speak are totally same with you,no communication barrier between us at all,哥老馆儿，要得哈，说啥子英语嘛，四川话讲起巴适得板
Cause they are not from China and obviously their Mandarin and English is not going to be of native standard. Their English is Singlish the accent used in Singapore don't call someone's English weird if you don't know the local slang.
@@xiranhuang8213 Indeed, probably it is different now. I remember Singapore Government encouraged Chinese Singaporeans to speak Chinese (推行講華語) when I was there.
lol we are actually not pretty good, we are excellent, considering that we are the minority of only 20++% in a non chinese country and we speak it at a native level.
Proud to be MALAYSIAN we as students also need to learn other language in universities and even mandarin we have to learn and get pass if want to continue next semester. 😬 Im also happy to learn mandarin cause it will help me to communicate with chinese people. ❤️🙏
@@Alex-nk3mt no answer after 3 years. So i am going to answer this. Universiti of Malaya (the sister school to Singapore’s NUS) use both languanges Bahasa Melayu and English in its lecture and tutorial. There are only 2 universities which use English as medium of instruction and learning, that is Universiti of Malaya and Universiti Teknologi Mara (100% English). Both are public universities with UiTM heavily funded by our government. Other public varsities use Bahasa Melayu and private universities and colleges use English. Hope this helps
A lot of young chinese in sg actually master chinese language pretty well but they just pretend they are bad at it due to peer pressure and some other factors, it is kinda disgusting to see them so proud of being banana, being good at chinese seems to be a shameful thing to them lol
oontur- mench I’m not sure what u think it means but I think it means yellow in the inside (Asian genes) but white on the outside (westernised and mainly speaks English) xD
Most Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when ever there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment . 大多数新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化， 他们中的大多数都讨厌自己的母语， 甚至讨厌他们祖先的国家， 这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对来自中国的中国人. 大多数新加坡华人真的讨厌自己的种族， 这是一个如此巨大的失望 .....................................
Lol it's so difficult to develop mandarin in Sg cuz all our documents r in English. I work in a chinese speaking company and my contract is in mandarin, and I can't even submit my contract to apply for anything official cuz other companies cant read mandarin. Even if you study Traditional Chinese Medicine (in mandarin) and apply to take the license exam, you have to submit a translation of your chinese graduation documents. Which is pretty hilarious to me.
Most younger Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment .大多数年轻的新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化，他们大多数都讨厌自己的母语，甚至讨厌祖先的国家，这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对中国人民。 大多数新加坡华人实际上都讨厌自己的种族，这是一个巨大的失望...............................................
As a Singaporean, I am always proud of our multilingual culture but sadly, the youngsters nowadays are not doing their best to speak their mother tongue.
Singapore consists of Singa Chinese, Singa Malay and Singa Indian. its hard to truly define ones "mother tongue" when your core society are divided into 3 classes. The equalizer the govt just settles is to be good in english and everything follows eventually
The parents should be blamed for this phenomenon. I see a lot of Singaporean parents speak English with their children and encourage speaking at home amongst the siblings. I always wonder why they do that, since their children have plenty of opportunities speaking English at school l, at work and in the street. What are they afraid of or simply because they feel superiority of English and inferiority of Chinese language? My Children are very fortunate because we speak Mandarin at home and they master English and Malay languages as well.
Another thing I want to point out is, some low educated parents who speak broken English (haha, not the Singlish accent) definitely influence their Children. No matter how good the education system that is in Singapore, more or less the Singaporeans speak in funny accent so-called Singlish and sometimes grammatically wrong sentences.
我觉得新加坡人尤其是年轻人不会说很好的中文也是可以理解的。他们平时用的最多的就是英文，学校教的也是以英文为主，这当中也涉及到一些历史的原因。而且也不是说缺少中文就对他们交流沟通影响很大，属于可有可无的吧，当然能掌握好的中文会更有优势！就像很多华人去了欧美国家，他们的后代不会说中文的也是大有人在的。有很多外国人到了中国，也有后代也只会说中文的！所以，无所谓啦！这是他们自己的选择！from China .
Most younger Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment .大多数年轻的新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化，他们大多数都讨厌自己的母语，甚至讨厌祖先的国家，这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对中国人民。 大多数新加坡华人实际上都讨厌自己的种族，这是一个巨大的失望.....................
The Thai guy Chinese is way better than our local Chinese students.
yea lo...
Which is kinda sad...
He is obviously Thai- Chinese, most Thais in Bangkok have some Chinese heritage
Singapore's next generation of children will mist likely.....
....
....
.....
FAIL THEIR CHINESE!
-My mother
在瑞士，每个种族都以自己的母语为第一语言，也会瑞士语。法裔瑞士人讲法语，用法语教学。德裔瑞士人讲德语，用德语教学。
To be honest... Singapore English is literally becoming another language, like Indian English 😂
The accent is so strong
faaaact
And their Chinese either
Both countries are proud to speak English but not willing to speak their own language. Especially in India, boys who speak English will have better chance of winning a girl's heart.
@@infoworld7706 such a shame... I am not saying speaking English is not good, it is the world's most speak language, but people should not be proud on being able to speak a foreign language, especially when India is considered to be one of the older civilization on earth
Definitely yes 😂
The host: this is a Chinese program.
The program: too much Chinese for translation
Chinese: am I a joke to you? 😂
Lol
KMS M Ridho Firman R lmao
KMS M Ridho Firman R 笑死
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHA I LAUGH
哈哈哈哈
so basically Singaporian speak broken English and broken Chinese, lol
Edit: Ey bros chill, I meant no offense to Singaporean homies, just find it funny
U really be talking like your English was too good for this world
Hong kong too
At least they can speak 3 languages
Its all mikey fault
@@ratarium not fluently lol
I die laughing at the kid rapping part
grayisagirl c what i wanna know is, was he really rappin? what was he sayin!? also, i was waitin for the sunglasses & the music ”tara-rara-ra” & the text ”thuglife”...
His awnser was the best.
hawthornroot he wasn’t actually rapping lah 😂
이엘렌 he wasnt? loool. what was he saying? tnx :)
@@hawthornroot He was just giving a regular reply about his thoughts on it. Pretty similar answer to everyone else but with a lot of filler words.
Bangga sebagai rakyat Malaysia !!! Kerana kami fasih dalam sekurang kurangnya 3 bahasa.
Proud to be a Malaysian! Because we are fluent in at least 3 languages.
我为我自己是马来西亚人感到骄傲!!! 因为我们能够说一口流利的至少3种语言
Jia Ming Khe not really in English for some ...(sry no offense )
Yes lancau punda...bahasa melayu cina india kami boleh
which part of Malaysia?
I know I shouldn't be saying this cause I am too a Singaporean, but...........
...
how did they even pass their Chinese? I know I did. and I'm still in primary school
Really ? Fluent ?
what do you want Rahman
'too much chinese for translation'
im proud of those malaysian chinese. We raised our people well as they should not forget their mother tongue. 🤣🤣🤣 Im malay and just learned chinese. I wish to be good in chinese language 🥲
全世界的华人唯一会说多种语言的应该是马来西亚华人了。。
多到让我惊呆的程度，我一个朋友会说普通话，英语，马来语，广东话，不知道是不是马来西亚华人都这样
@@newyorkglassking3591 马来西亚华人基本上都是这样，普通话，英文和马来语是在华族学校里的必修课，认真学习的话从华校毕业的马来西亚华人都会。 至于广东话，闽南语，客家语就是在家族背景耳濡目染下学会的。
@@leongkokwei2122 总之就是很佩服
@Darren Gao 法英中三语记着不累么
@@林北北-g3e 都是从小培养的 不需记
I'm a Malaysian and I'm 12 years old I know how to speak Chinese fluently and I'm an Indian. I didn't go to a Chinese school but I learned it my self cause I found that speaking in Chinese is so interesting
Any tipsss ?
yes..any tip
@@firdausmedli2458 open book n learn lol
The tips get a chinese friend , read book etc
@@Rosewan1234 yeah all you need is .. A chinese lover or friend..you soon can speak fluent Chinese language
我是学过中文的泰国人。其实你问 ”教授们在校内要付停车费是否公平吗？“我觉得 ”是否” 就表达是疑问句了，没必要在句终加上这个 ”吗” 字了。
对
你是对的，这个主持人准备的问题里面充满语法错误
天哪，华人让非华人的来指错误，真是醉了
阳阳 谢谢
苏冠奇 谢谢！
I'm so proud of Malaysian Chinese! I know what they have done to keep the Chinese language and culture in Malaysia society! Best Chinese group abroad!
真的为马来西亚的华人朋友感到骄傲. 我知道他们曾经为了华语和华人文化所做过的努力! 最棒的海外华人!
Pretty much all of my friends from Malaysia can speak Chinese fluently. I have been wondering how do ya people manage to learn three languages, Chinese, Malay and English(if I recall it correctly) at the same time in Malaysia? It is so impressive.
说的真好
@@evilproducer9647 they speak mandarin with their families at home, speak Malay with Malay friends/teacher at school and English is pretty common bcs it's the 2nd language in Malaysia, you can get a better job if you're fluent in English (sometimes Mandarin too). My dad and sister(malay) are fluent in mandarin too
但不是个个词汇都记得... 很少用的词汇根本记不起来 lol.
I mean, Malays in Singapore cannot speak bahasa as well, even the simple phrases 😅, kinda made me sad a lil😶
(speaking in higher chinese)
(rapping in chinese)
HAHAHAHA i can’t
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😱😱
😂😂😂😂
Is there such a thing as higher Chinese?
@@Killabeethev It's normal to mainland chinese like me, but probably higher for the subtitle maker though.
I hate how young Singaporeans thinks being bad at their Mother tongue is funny.
walao eh yes 😑
Thanks, been saying this since forever. They think it’s cool but it isn’t. Lmao they look like losers.
Nah not all singaporean mt is bad
exactly, all trying to be hypebeast and think that not being able to speak their MT is funny...how embarrassing
oh shit true some actually take it as a joke
this is why i am proud to be Malaysian. studied in SJKC.. speaks mandarin.. and at the same time still speaks in Malay which is my native language.. 😊
same here, non-chinese malaysian who can speak chinese as well, learning many languages definitely is one of the greatest advantages
At least you guys still can speak your native language, any other extras is definitely an advantage.
Really don't understand them.
好羡慕你们大马人会多种语言，而且还是不同语系的语言。我是中国人，只会中文跟一般般的英文。
I don’t agree with not being able to speak their mother tongue HOWEVER, people it is easy to just say things like what you said because you weren’t put in a spot to answer a question in front of camera. Not everybody can do well like that. But then again, I could never understand people who thought only English was important so 🤷🏻♀️
@@makkaucbkia9640 pssssst~~~white wash~~~
Everyone :All Chinese people can speak Chinese fluently right?
Singaporeans:imma prove that this is wrong 🙃
@Gwi 93 No Mandarin is simply a common dialect for all Chinese around the world so that they are able to understand each other better, there are other dialects too like Cantonese and Hokkien, they are all dialects of the Chinese language
blissxful _ my father has been living in singapore for almost 10 years now, and we also went there for a vacation, we had chinese singaporean friends and they speak a bit of mandarin and lots of singaporean english.
blissxful _ i know some singaporeans who are fluent in chinese, but there are also some who aren't that fluent with the language. i guess it depends on the family??? i can't really speak for them since i'm not sgean, this is just based on my personal experience and observation from singaporean chinese people that i know of and have already met 😊
blissxful _ yeah i'm confused too cuz i know a lot of singaporean who are fluent in chinese 😂
blissxful _ in sg usually english i can speak chinese but not write well lmao
你问的问题也不通顺
他就说他中文也不厉害了嘛 应该是翻译过来的
Shallow Stream you hungry ah?
Haha li哈哈哈哈哈哈
HAHAHAHAHA
and someday Chinese becomes the international language.... only then these tards will know 😄
@@winnsheng9897 obviously?
当然！
飲水思源都不會，華人都不會講華語，驕傲我是馬來西亞華人
我妹妹在新加坡工作，他说现在年轻的一辈已经会讲华语了
华人当中属马来西亚华人最值得我们骄傲！
Bi Kau Ren 現在年輕的一輩更不會說華語吧，老一輩的還好，就算不懂華語也會講方言，你是不是少到一個"不"字
buli a 對啊，proud to be malaysian，bangga jadi rakyat malaysia
@@bikauren4468 重點是，一見面就說英文。
when your english is not very english bc its singlish and your chinese is not really chinese bc u speak english HAHA JIALAT
Why
Lost of identity..
What's their official language? Cause they were speaking English in this video
Have to agree with you.
YOU SPOKE THE TRUTH.
To be honestly, your English accent is a little strong. And your Chinese accent is even stronger.
hahaha
To be honest, ...not to be honestly
@SomeoneYDK 餘實恩 That's true, but American, British, Australian, and Canadian accents are considered the standard accents to learn from. OP is talking about what we know as a foreign accent. Think about how even in China, Mandarin speakers will have different accents. Those accents are all acceptable to learn from, but if foreigners like myself learn Mandarin, we will have a non-native accent to all Mandarin speakers. There's nothing wrong with having a foreign accent. It's just a fact of learning languages.
I speak both languages better than those people in the video....
@@harry9790 gucc cc
Vbzvnvbgdcjvdg Bhalo Bhalo
不懂說中文不要緊，但他們的面對中文的態度好像有點輕浮，感覺自己説中英夾雜的比較優越。作為華人，大概也該專重下 自己。
elizabeth poon 位置好，躺着赚钱太容易了
确实是中文不太好~~~
确实，有很矫揉造作的感觉。作为一个在新加坡工作过的人，我想说之前在的公司里很多华人都是可以直接讲中文，有夹杂英文或是发音奇怪，但是绝对是很自然地可以讲。
人家高等华人额
elizabeth poon 殖民地人民的优越感呗diss
How come singaporeans cannot speak Chinese?! Malaysians speak Mandarin, Cantonese very fluently. 😱
Malaysia Boleh lah! We need to buck up on Chinese X)
👍🏻
Cause we speak different language to different people depends on their race or understanding hahaa
because Singapore abolished vernacular schools, using fully English education other than mothertongue class, so English became the mainstream language.
Bcos of the racial suppression they very fight for their right to learn chinese.
In singapore it was propagated to learn english bcos lky deem it as a common gound n good for global economy. With increasing west influence due to sg's successful global economy, the emphasis for mother tongue deminishes through each generation.
Actually your tone of speaking Chinese is hard for Chinese people to understand it at the first time as well.
First place***
Singaporean Chinese are usually able to understand it, but because our accent is too "flat", other chinese speakers from outside Singapore/Malaysia find it hard to understand what we say. (Experience from living abroad with other chinese speaking internationals)
agree +1
Southern Mainland Chinese have the similar accent, though.
口音有点别扭啦
深深感到華文教育的重要性，過去150年的國力衰弱讓大家背井離鄉。不管是在哪裡，什麼體制，什麼生活水準，文化傳承是我們保持民族延續性的最大保障。馬來西亞華人堅持華文教育，秉承文化的傳承非常的了不起。以上
同感
Ohh I’m Japanese, and even I don’t have much knowledge of Chinese language, I can understand what you’re saying!
And 以上 同感, it’s completely same how to use in Japanese!!!
@@mokar638 あなたは日本人ですか?
太佩服马来华人了，佩服你们的坚持
@@thanaphumooimaster1134 そうです
我是一个巴基斯坦人， 说中文比他们好
Yahya Shaikh 哈哈
我在加拿大温哥华，这边很多出租车司机是巴基斯坦的，人都很nice
@@seanchiu721 雞巴多大？
Salam Alekum 朋友！
Christina Plywood 你想说什么哈哈哈
我是新加坡华裔。有很多年轻人不像他们那样的。那些对中文认真的，从小中文水准会自然提高。我会说流利的中文啊。
棒棒哒
你真幸运呢 我觉得小时候学中文是最好的。。 我是马来西亚人因为从小我们常搬家所以我学会很多语言我的邻居们是我学语言最好的老师 ：）
Jay Chow 没错，我在新加坡也有见到很多很小的孩子都在讲中文。但是就怕他们经过多年的学校纯英文训练，反而荒废了中文。
哈哈，看你写的内容，水平也是勉强可以，读起来怪怪的。不过，加油。。
新加坡華人的華文真的非常初級，就連主持人提出的第二個問題都有一個低級的語病，疑問句中「是否」跟「嗎」只能用其中一個，兩個同時使用就是重複的語病了。
他的第一个问题也有低级语病“获得奥运金牌将为。。。。”问成了“获得奥运金牌奖为。。。。”
的确是，发音就更不提了！
@@王一一-r1v 不仅仅是发音问题，是他完全没看懂那句话，也不知道奥运金牌 是全语，无需后面加个 奖，一看就属于连基本语境都不懂的人
David Chan 第一个问题看了两三遍才明白他究竟要表达什么
主持人应该是用翻译软件把英文翻译成中文拿去提问的。
hahah... "speaking chinese" "too much Chinese for translation" "speaking higher chinese" "rapping in chinese" OMG! 🤣🤣 I like the kid at the end saying what you talking about and then BOMB! rapping in Chinese... 🤣🤣
Stage 1: Speaking in Chinese
Stage 2: Too much Chinese to translate
Stage 3: Speaking in higher Chinese
Stage 4: Rapping in chinese
Bro you should actually translate what those people who can actually speak Mandarin fluently so we viewers can actually understand what they're explaining as well, instead of just dissing those people who can't really speak Mandarin well
Probably they didn't understand too what the people (who fluently spoke Mandarin in this video) said, so they didn't translate it hahahahahah
Agree
He said he is not good in chinese too..
*(TOO MUCH CHINESE FOR TRANSLATION )*
🤣🤣🤣
So ur racist to chineese poeple
4:00 that Malaysian Chinese accent
(Speaking in Chinese)
(Too much Chinese to translate)
(Speaking higher Chinese)
(Rapping in Chinese)
ROFL
Lol
我是印尼人 我觉得我的普通话程度比视频中访问的新加坡人还好。
Aryo Seno 印尼哪里
厲害
你太棒了
🤣🤣🤣
托了印共的福
很心痛。新加坡的中文水准依旧这么低。十多年前，梁智强的电影就已讽刺了新加坡的中文水准。现在还是没改进
R Ratchett 如果心已不在，就很难再回头了。
根本没在改好不？
华文不行，英文也马马虎虎。
没问题啊，他们又不是中国人。。。
zingiau Tan 哈哈就是嘛
我遇到过一个马来西亚华人，中文好的让我以为是福建人，直到他管老挝叫辽国我才意识到他是大马的
sjejncuks xuwbj 怎么让你知道的
@@Fishball0423 翻译问题啊。
@@Fishball0423 Laos的马来西亚翻译是寮国， 中国翻译是老挝
@@mteng5764 老挝应该也是很后来的翻译了，好像近代史相关的老地图上还是寮国
马来西亚华人当中有很多都是福建人
The last guy n the kid were relatively eloquent compared to the rest..
The child's awnser was better than the rest.
mvcity Was he rapping or actually answering the questions? I heard him say teachers a lot
I mean... even the question itself is grammatically flawed......
No wonder why they can’t speak Chinese lol
Yep that's a sad story in SG..
😂😂😂😂😂
from the one hosting, filming, video editor, doing subs, etc etc. this is just so fucking painful to watch.. jesus christ 🤦♂️
Tbh, the way they phrased/translated the first question is very weird.
For Sg Chinese language education, the aim is to just verbally communicate kinda, for business rapport with other Chinese, same with English but except better because they also read in English. I happen to know that Sg is already outsourcing their English copyrighting work to the Philippines
I am korean and we have a number of ppl who are good at Chinese like a native.
I thought majority of Singaporeans are able to speak Chinese. This is kinda shocking to me.
They’re mainly speaking English and slightly Chinese even though they’re Chinese.
But in Malaysia there’s of course Malay, but the 2nd majority in the country is Chinese so most Chinese in Malaysia know decent Chinese maybe not as good as Native China-Chinese kind but they most probably can understand some questions here lol
It really depends on who you run into. People from Chinese-speaking families will be able to speak Chinese fluently enough, on the other hand, not so much if they are from English-speaking families. But the latter's mastery of the English language is likely to be better.
Singaporeans are bilingual and are good in Mandarin. Just that this guy chose wrong venue. He also chose Thai, malaysians (very obvious by their chinese accent) and he never ascertain the nationality of the rest. FAIL!
He should have gone to HDB neighbourhood and you will see old aunties and uncles correcting his intonation and pronunciation of Chinese words. Hahaha
一杆子打翻一船人
다룬 사람들이.... 다른 유창한 수질있는데.
I'm malaysian chinese. Apparently in our country the government are emphasise citizen to speak malay. The level of our chinese much more better than them we could write and speak fluent as well as the poem. But undeniable some of chinese don't know how to speak chinese due to their families background. Although my english is not strong as Singaporean but it's enough for daily use.
Although chinese in malaysia only got about 20% population(maybe lease by now), they still trying very hard to emphasise chinese education for chinese these days, im malysian chinese n im proud of n respect malaysian chinese!!
yup as a malaysian malay i respected the chinese race here. they can speak with their mother tongue language so fluently. same goes to the indians and malays as well
Ahh really ?? 40% of malaysian chinese cant even speak their own ethnic language . Go to KL many chinese hokkien cantonese and other only speak china national language @ mandarin . I didn't know mandarin is a race/ethnic language . As i know mandarin is a standardized language of china national language
I am a Korean but i Speak well better chinese than singaporeans
안녕하세요 i have a korean friend who can speak Chinese very well too
i want to learn korean too. Lol
@@louroaloysius1922 I have learn Korean, Japanese,Chinese, English and Cantonese
That’s great
The Korean Chinese of old generation are able to speak Korean,Chinese and Japanese(they didnt learn English)
Those who can speak Chinese in Singapore is definitely from Malaysia. Definitely.
谁说的?
Who says so? Maybe you have not encountered ppl who actually speak in Chinese in SG (like myself lol)
Xue Ling 好事好事。加油
Malaysia boleh!
Xue Ling
我也是。我虽然是本地人，但我在日常生活中比较习惯使用中文，朋友圈也因此比较小。。。
身为新加坡华人，我自豪的说我双语能力强，能听，说，读，写。感恩父母在家中与我用华语沟通，在学校又学会了英语。现今年轻人都很少有机会用华语沟通。他们的中文水平不理想，也不足为奇吧！但是身为华夏子民，不懂华文还真的该面璧思过。真切希望他们能认真的学习华文 😁
面壁思过
甜蜜咪Atlantis 当年李光耀先生提倡新加坡国民学习各自的母语，就是为了避免国人将来陷入自我认知模糊的尴尬境地，因为“我是谁，我是什么人，我来自哪里，我的文化是什么”对一个人来讲很重要。
关键英文水平也不高 邯郸学步
@@tomtom-jx6nd 英文水平很高了好不好。。是母語水平
@@ysy5472 他们英语很好了可能没错 但母语水平 你真的是聋子吗
Malaysian chinese should win some award for able to speak Chinese, English, Malay, Cantonese and Hokkien lol
Depends which part of Malaysia you from though, Penang can speak Hokkien and Mandarin, in KL we speak Cantonese and Mandarin. Some speak Hakka and Mandarin. My grandma in Singapore speaks Hokkien no problem but its different to the Hokkien in Penang lol.
alot malaysian chinese still act atas class, they can speak and read but when comes to any conversation they refuse to use it.
I am Singaporean I can speak English Chinese and Hokkien no problem. Malays I can understand very basic. But my English still best.
our chinese may not sound good, but our currency is better than yours, that's your award. hahaha take that low blow.
我是吗来人,但可以讲华语,因为读在华校。
您們的華語不錯，本人很感動的
快点笑他cina tak tahu cina
bestnya...nak blajar jugak la
@@mingchunwan1723 sedih lah cina tak tahu cina.
@@alecrosewell6959 ya super sad but its funny 柑你拿 哈哈哈哈
*(Rapping in chinese)*
I WHEEZEDDD LMAOO
作为中国人，我觉得主持人讲的中文很难听懂。
是啊
Imnothat 我甚至有点不理解他的问题 语病爆炸多
Catherine 对呀，就算他问我，我也没办法流利回答
这是腔调的问题和一些当地才使用的词，虽然语病真的很严重
他自己都讲不顺
I was surprised to know that some Chinese Singaporean cannot speak Chinese because I thought all Chinese Singaporean can speak Chinese very well.
Same here
@Yu Kay cuz their ethnically Chinese
Even Malaysian Chinese can speak better Chinese..
Indonesian Chinese : Are you guys allowed to speak Chinese?
@@leonidaslazos6828 it's like saying americans should be 100% fluent in german just because they ethnically the same with germans, not all overseas chinese have the opportunity to learn or speak it because the older generation probably never teach it in the first place
The interviewer is sort of a jerk himself.
You know there are times where like you know some words in Mandarin, but don't know them in English and then there are times you know the word in English but don't know it in Mandarin.
I'm a malay.... As malaysian yang belajar kat sekolah cina... 我会说华语！
Kawan saya ramai bangsa malayu pandai cakap bahasa cina sbb depa semua belajar kat SMJK.. :)
@@aftereffects00 nanti hantaq anak hg p sekolah cina haha... Best belajaq dengan org cina ni
Aarule Veyyltone , saya orang cina yg belajar kat SMK. 但是我小学读华小，所以我会讲华语和写华语字
@@诗曼-b9p 一样的！我也SJKC和SMK
Aarule Veyyltone gw chinese indonesia tak bisa bahasa chinese or mandarin wkwkw
"如果他们没有skill，then他们不能赢what...." im dead..😂
身为一个马来西亚人华人，我为他们感到汗颜
@lolololol lol 馬來西亞讀華校的華人來說，華語基本可以達一個中等偏上的水平，有些中文专业的學生可以達到相當高得程度。
@lolololol lol 呵呵，不懂就闭嘴吧
马来西亚华人是全世界华人的榜样👍
大马华人我见过中文最好了，我新加坡老教授也比不上
马来西亚华人最多英文是不多好 不过我不觉得英文会差得去哪里
Learning other languages , it opens another part of your soul that your didn't discover. You speak the language for people to understand but speaking the mother tongue , you talk to their souls.
i am a jawa people but i can chinese 雖然我是爪哇人但是我對華文也是很有興趣,所以我一直努力學中文
我也是爪哇人 会讲中文的。
我也是爪哇人 会讲华语的
加油哦
没错因很多印尼人会说中文特别siantar的人
我是华人，我在学jawa语，muleh piro mas 🤣
Me as an Indonesian-Chinese: "i'm in danger"
This is really depressing.. Im literally gobsmacked by the responses given by those adolescences. I wonder how they even passed their O level Mother tongue. Constantly shaking my head in despair. Furthermore, Chinese is not a language. Chinese, per se, is a race or ethnicity group. We, Chinese, speak Mandarin and Mandarin is a form of Chinese Language. Chinese Language consists of Mandarin and other forms of dialects. Just like the Indian dont speak Indian. They speak Tamil or other dialects. I even questioned your proficiency in "Jiak Kang Tang".
Are you singaporean ?
i got As for both O level Mother Tongue and Higher Mother Tongue (Mandarin Chinese) but even I would struggle to find the words to answer the questions simply because it isn’t a language that I’ve been using every day. If the people around me don’t converse and don’t wish to converse w me in Mandarin(which they all don’t), I don’t have much use of it. Not to mention the fact that I was exempted from it in JC and hence completely stopped my reading and writing of the language after secondary school. Sure I speak it at home sometimes but words for daily use are different from words required for such questions in the interview, and the fact of the matter is that Singaporeans are just not using the language enough and when practice goes down, fluency does too. It becomes harder to comprehend sentences and form sentences from the very language that we in fact know.
but it is true that their responses are quite atrocious 😂
@violet 9968 My precise consensus. Our proficiency in Mother Tongue decreases at an exponential rate ever since we graduated from Secondary School. Our tertiary education don't promote the usage of Mother Tongue and even in our workplace, we mostly converse in English or colloquial form of Singlish. But what is really shocking to me is that, in that video, a couple of teenagers who looks like freshly graduated from Secondary school/JC, couldn't even form a proper dialogue in Mandarin. This makes me ponder, do we even take Mandarin in during Secondary school? Or maybe most student just opted to get "Basic" Chinese language instead as they deem it as a hassle. During my years of pursuing education, I knew students who were struggling in their Mother Tongue, could actually opted for Basic Mother Tongue but this only cater towards a very special minority group of students. Somehow, I just got this bad spider-sense tingling feeling, that the majority of the current generation just simply opted for Basic Mother Tongue just to get the "easy way" out. If that is the case, I'm utterly gutted at our education system. Instead of moving forward, we are actually moving backwards.
Most of Us our mother tongue proficiency stops until secondary school. I honestly think, it sets up a good foundation for us moving forward in speaking our Mother Tongue, but it is also up to us as individual, to choose whether we want to hone it and let it incorporated in our lives or just simply brush away and blame the society that it is the environment causes us to neglect our mother tongue. Sadly, we chose the latter. We got no excuse to complain,whine or sulk that "Oh it is so hard to watch Chinese Movie without English Subtitles or to read a Chinese Novel " because our education system has already equipped us the fundamental tools to sufficiently cope with such difficulties. Ultimately, it is up to us to apply them or not.
Aimer Ang can you express your reply similarly in Chinese?
I think Chinese is a nationality. Ethnicity is Han. The language is actually Mandarin. But basically, Han Chinese speaks 10 types of languages.
Are you Han Chinese? Yes, you are right. Many Han people in Malaysia like to called by Malaysia-chinese, it is too funny to me, I am Indonesian-tionghuaness(Han people in Indonesia language). And always said to me " YOU ARE CHINESE, must speak Chinese language,,,lol,,,I thought I must speak my nationality language and Han-Hokkien dialect...and the Malaysia-Han people didn't know how to separate Mandarin and Standard-Chinese language...
@@dollylin262 Tionghoa is also mean Chinese nationalty in China. The name of People Republic of China in Hokkien Chinese start with word Tionghoa, the Indonesian translation to "Republik Rakyat Tiongkok" is actually not linguistically accurate, it's should translated as "Republik Rakyat Tiong Hoa" (mean Tionghoa isn't just Han, but also include other 56 minorities ethnic groups). Here is name of. People Republic of China if written in Hanzi: 中华人民共和国, and the letter 中华 is read as Tionghoa in Hokkien or Zhong Hua in Mandarin. So, if you said Tionghoa and Han are the same thing, it's indicate you don't know the name of People Republic of China in any Han Chinese dialect and how it written in Hanzi.
Han and Tionghoa are actually completely different thing and not synonymous.
@@faustinuskaryadi6610 No, Tionghoaness is mean to Han's people only in Indonesia after independent at 1945 year, where there is no Republic of China country yet. Chinese is means to China netizen, where Han the most people and including 55 ethnic. The 55 ethnic is not tionghoaness, cause they have their culture. 中华人民不代表是中华族。Sorry for my personally thinking. Thanks.
@@dollylin262 Republic of China中华民国 was formed in 1912, before Indonesia independent.
If 中华 equal to Han, so minority etchic groups will not happy to become citizen of either People Republic of China (中华人民共和国), or Republic of China (中华民国). The one that formed in 1949 is Communist People Republic of China.
IMO Han Chinese in Indonesia should call themselves Han instead Tionghoa, but they can also call themselves Tionghoa if they have non-Han diaspora in their community.
And Hokkien word Tionghoa is never be adapted to English language, so you should still refer Han Chinese in Indonesia as Han Chinese while speaking English, not Tionghoaness.
For me Tionghoa is translation for Chinese, Tiongkok is translation for China, and Han should be translated as Han.
@@faustinuskaryadi6610 RT is not same RRC, RT is republic tiongkok only Han's people in 1912, But after 55 ethnic joined to RT with autonomy each area, RT changed to RRC. Yes, you right, Han- Mandarin can't be International language. But that is not mean Han's people can't speak their mother languages, like as Taiwan. If you go to Taiwan, and ask Taiwanese "Are you Chinese? Must of them answer "No", But if you ask "Are you Han-Hokkien?, Most of them answer "Yes". And are you Indonesian?
Good to be multilingual. I am Chinese & was brought up in Malaya & left for a public school in England 56 years ago & have settled in both England & now Turkey in my retirement. Good to listen to Chinglish. English accents in the UK also vary a lot & many English cannot understand heavy provincial accents. Standard received English i.e. BBC English is the standard but, unfortunately, there is also a Class difference in accents. I am fortunate that I can speak four different Chinese dialects or languages because my father was a Hakka, my mother Hokkien , the servants Cantonese & I picked up Mandarin at school. I also had to learn Malay at School & communicated in Malay with our Chauffeur. Then I moved on to picking up Italian, Czech & Polish owing to my different girlfriends.
OK lah! sorry to bore you.
To be honest，as a Chinese，I can't even understand the host's Chinese without reading the subtitles！ that was not Chinese which can make people understanding
so simple, malaysian chinese is easy to understand it
It’s his accent and pronunciation. It was really flawed.
Sarawakian/Sabahan fluent in more than 3 language . Such as Malay,English,Chinese,Dusun,Iban,Murut,Lunbawang,Lundayeh & more. Some of us even speak Korean. Walaoo ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
我终于明白为啥大马人爱说新加坡人是Banana了！特么都是Banana!，作为华人华语说成这屌样
doli99 sjyiao Banana 的意思是什么？
kelvin pang 就是说外表只像外国人（Angmor) 但本身是华人.Like they chinese right but behave like Angmor
新加坡大多数华人都是 福建人 不讲国语的
不能否认。可是，如果是你，在同样的教育或大环境下，你觉得你的语言能力会有多强? 他们差，是真的。不过，很大原因是环境因素。所以，别笑人吧。
아니야!!
interviewer: try your best to answer in chinese
interviewee: ok
interviewee: *answers in english*
Hahaha So embarrassing... Hua ren bu zhe dao huayi...
@@acreativename4391 so how to pronounce the correct pin yin??
@@acreativename4391 Haha you're right... Thank you
i think English is pretty important，but everyone shouldnt forget the mother tongue
English important? You just a idiot knew nothing at all, there more country and people in this world use Spanish as official language than English.
@@chinmungkuan8551 English is the international lingua franca. I speak Spanish fluently, but it isn't widely used outside of its area and among immigrants.
我认为教师支付停车费是不公平的，因为他们的工作最难。他们有其他的东西要花钱。抱歉不好的普通话
-来自菲律宾
而且他们挣得不多哈哈
C H I N O 我觉得最大的问题是教师是学校的员工，应该有一些优待才是啊😄
As I'm living in Malaysia(20years), Singapore(5years)and China(maybe the rest of my life) for a longtime, I think I have to said that, Malaysian entire Chinese level are much higher than Singapore ,indeed there's always a joke for the billboards or road signs spelling wrongly in Chinese at the public tourist places for many times due to the Malay official using the google Translator and become a laughing stock as a headline on the newspaper , but I have to said its just rarely individual case, if u traveling furthermore on others places of Malaysia (other than Cameron), u will find out they are not only speak fluently in Chinese, but also Malay and English and their own's mother tongue (Hokien, Hakka etc).
Malaysia national language is melayu as Malaysia Also a multi-racial nation, so they should have a common medium language to united them, but besides that, the chinese ancestor still insists that the Chinese language as a fundamental stone of their culture should be inherits and preserves , languages is the medium of ur very own culture to passing down n inherit, if u lose ur language, then ur culture will most probably be twisted ,fading n bury in the history. So under the local Chinese spiritual leaders such as 林連玉，陳六使 etc, struggling n fighting for the right of learning Chinese, so Nowaday the Chinese-malaysian not only can speak melayu n English, but communicate with their family members in their own dialects n Chinese as well.
For the Indonesian, some says they are same as singaporean,but that's truely a sad case ,as their previous pm Suhato strongly against Chinese, because of the domestic political conflicts with the communist party, so he intended to eliminated the language, deprived it from the local Chinese, they don't even have a right to celebrate the Spring Festival there, except recently the policies been started to loosen.
But in Singapore, despite of the vast majority is Chinese, but out of the political demanding n certain context at that time, liguangyao have to converted the medium teaching language from Chinese into English in nanyang technology university (before reformed the medium language is Chinese) etc, pulling the Relationships closer to the western countries for ports business and economic development .
However, what I wanted to point out is, there are surely many profound reasons n complexities of politic behind the context, but learning Chinese is a privilege through the efforts of generations keep passing down. I'm not put the blame or looking down on anyone, but since there's an opportunity offers by ur school for free, then u should grab the chances n learn it well, either for the career advancement or self-improving, don't just simply take it for granted.
Most Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when ever there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment . 大多数新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化， 他们中的大多数都讨厌自己的母语， 甚至讨厌他们祖先的国家， 这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对来自中国的中国人. 大多数新加坡华人真的讨厌自己的种族， 这是一个如此巨大的失望 ................................................
@Richard Yang Damn TRUEEE... Hate people who didn't embrace Their mother tongue languages.. boo to Singaporean
Lol I know Malaysians English standard very high,compare the o levels English to yours see which ones more difficult
Wah seh u write so long. I give u 3 star for effort k. Haha
Too long. Didnt bother to read ur rant tbh.
@@mankinds8685 too bad ur psychology tactics dont work on him.. Better luck next time pal
When a Thai people can speak better 中文 than most of them😂😂
Somehow I feel that a lot people find being able to speak proper Chinese not a very proud thing as English is perceived as a "branded" or "higher class" language.. Its a sad thing..
In Switzerland, each race speak theirs own mother tongue as a first language and also can speak Swiss . French Swiss speak French and be taught in French at school. German Swiss speak German and be taught in German at school.
4:28 proud malaysian here ! i think all of malaysian chinese can speak their own language but they also good at english. but some of the other malaysian that who is not chinese also know how to speak chinese #NOHATEHERE i just say about my opinion about my own people.
but the question is can they speak good malay
@@bella8145-d9z off course they do. Every Malaysian do but in different slang.
Throughout my career,i met so many malaysian who cant speak malay. Especially chinese.
@@ShoppeeHolic yes..malaysian chinese is really poor in malay..compare to malaysian indian really good in malay
@@bella8145-d9z yup true.
So sorry to Singaporean, I am Malaysian Chinese and I can speak English, Malay, Chinese, Cantonese and Japanese. Thanks to my country most of the Chinese here speak fluently in mother tongue and sometimes dialects. PROUD TO BE MALAYSIAN
I am a Chinese college student and I am capable of speaking Chinese mandarin,Sichuan dialect and fluent English. Frankly speaking I think these guys interviewed are kind of weird in pronunciation both in Chinese and English😂
I kinda agree with you. However, note that singaporeans with excellent performance like how you are in China are way better than these few people which are not even sufficient to be a considerable sample. 不能以偏概全，是吧
Wow,I am from Sichuan as well,so the two languages and one dialect I could speak are totally same with you,no communication barrier between us at all,哥老馆儿，要得哈，说啥子英语嘛，四川话讲起巴适得板
Cause they are not from China and obviously their Mandarin and English is not going to be of native standard. Their English is Singlish the accent used in Singapore don't call someone's English weird if you don't know the local slang.
@@lemon2524 So what language are they fluent in?
@@lynn6457 If you are talking about their English proficiency Singapore students have one of the highest scores according to PISA results.
我曾在新加坡工作七年,當時在公司內的新加坡華人都能説華語.2002年,我辭職回香港,我把新加坡永久居民(PR)也退回給新加坡政府,因為不打算再去了.
Eddie Lau it’s been a long time.
@@xiranhuang8213 Indeed, probably it is different now. I remember Singapore Government encouraged Chinese Singaporeans to speak Chinese (推行講華語) when I was there.
我是马来西亚人，华语是我生活上用的语言，英语是我很小的时候一直在看美国儿童节目学会的，马来语也是小时候一直在看电视节目学会的，福建话也是看电视节目慢慢学会的，所以学校教的什么动词在后什么宾语主语那些我都不是很懂哈哈哈哈哈
结论是看多一点电视节目。
i'm not even chinese,but i can speak mandarin so well!!! proud of myself 👏👏👏 and now I'm learning Korean.
You are a genius 😂 After learning Chinese and Korean, Japanese will be a bonus 🎉
@@mengxuanzhao2226 nani!! btw i'm already gave up on learning Korean🥺🤣 now I'm learn Cantonese.
@@peoplecomepeoplego9029 Already good enough. I speak Chinese my self, but I can’t imagine if I can learn it as a second language.😅
I like how the boy be like “what u talking about”to rapping in chinese
Wow! I never thought Singapore Mandarin is at this level now. As bad as Malaysian speaks not so perfect Mandarin I suddenly think we are pretty good.
lol we are actually not pretty good, we are excellent, considering that we are the minority of only 20++% in a non chinese country and we speak it at a native level.
Indonesia lebih buruk
The thing is... Many of the teenagers can't speak English properly as well...so the question would be, can singaporean young people even talk?
Colourful Banana
Singlish is enough for daily conversations
people*
前两天刚在今日头条上看到这个视频，今天刷UA-cam就看到这个视频。头条上的人对新加坡华人的负面评价太多了，对马来西亚华人正面评价很高。
👍👍👍
真的超爱马来华人，给他们点赞
中国人对马来西亚华人评价是真的算好的，新加坡大部分都是骂他们香蕉人
还不是马来西亚华人舔中国臭脚的多
@@tianlim1239 连自己的母语都不会说，还有脸在这里狡辩。丢不丢脸啊！还能写出你那个LIM的中文吗？那是你老爹给你的姓。
And I thought I’m the only Chinese guy who can’t speak Chinese in Singapore 😂😂😂
Proud to be MALAYSIAN we as students also need to learn other language in universities and even mandarin we have to learn and get pass if want to continue next semester. 😬 Im also happy to learn mandarin cause it will help me to communicate with chinese people. ❤️🙏
just a question, which is the medium language of malaysian universities? University of Malaysia more specifically
@@Alex-nk3mt no answer after 3 years. So i am going to answer this. Universiti of Malaya (the sister school to Singapore’s NUS) use both languanges Bahasa Melayu and English in its lecture and tutorial. There are only 2 universities which use English as medium of instruction and learning, that is Universiti of Malaya and Universiti Teknologi Mara (100% English). Both are public universities with UiTM heavily funded by our government. Other public varsities use Bahasa Melayu and private universities and colleges use English. Hope this helps
A lot of young chinese in sg actually master chinese language pretty well but they just pretend they are bad at it due to peer pressure and some other factors, it is kinda disgusting to see them so proud of being banana, being good at chinese seems to be a shameful thing to them lol
Agreed 100%, damn sohai act shuai like tat
Lmao does ‘banana’ mean what i think it means?? 😂
oontur- mench I’m not sure what u think it means but I think it means yellow in the inside (Asian genes) but white on the outside (westernised and mainly speaks English) xD
Bettie Shi That’s exactly what i thought 😂
Most Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when ever there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment . 大多数新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化， 他们中的大多数都讨厌自己的母语， 甚至讨厌他们祖先的国家， 这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对来自中国的中国人. 大多数新加坡华人真的讨厌自己的种族， 这是一个如此巨大的失望 .....................................
华语不会说，浓重的南洋腔英语说得连美国人都听不懂，尴尬得不行！
英國人聽了會説你的新加坡語講得很好聽，聽起來很像英文，儘管英國人不知道真正的新加坡語是什麼
哈哈哈，严重同意。这帮吊人还以为自己fluent in english and chinese.其实他妈的鬼都听不懂
确实很多年轻人会说华语，还不错
真心听不懂
Maxis Stan 真相了
Honestly I’m singaporean and his questions are the type of questions we get tested on our Chinese oral exam
Lol it's so difficult to develop mandarin in Sg cuz all our documents r in English. I work in a chinese speaking company and my contract is in mandarin, and I can't even submit my contract to apply for anything official cuz other companies cant read mandarin. Even if you study Traditional Chinese Medicine (in mandarin) and apply to take the license exam, you have to submit a translation of your chinese graduation documents. Which is pretty hilarious to me.
I agree with your comment.
Most younger Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment .大多数年轻的新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化，他们大多数都讨厌自己的母语，甚至讨厌祖先的国家，这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对中国人民。 大多数新加坡华人实际上都讨厌自己的种族，这是一个巨大的失望...............................................
Eleanor Robi But why Singaporean English is so poor？ because stupid right？even china people‘s english are much better than singaporean 😂
hahahahhaha the caption when they cant even translate them to chinese got me dying especially the one who speak higher chinese
Chinese people living in my country can speak Chinese pretty well, one of my friends is Chinese, he said his family always spoke Chinese at home.
As a Chinese from mainland, I have no idea about what he was saying if without the caption🙃真的难懂啦🤷♂️
And here is me thinking I have to improve my Mandarin fast because my company has got a new client in Singapore... Thanks for opening my eyes
Hey most of the Malaysian Chinese can answer that fluently lahhhh
这英文说的不英国也不美国的四不像，中文中文不会说。你到底是哪里人。
本地是新加坡，中英语言混杂说并是本地特语：新式语，新为新加坡
Edna K 新加坡自创语新语，到底怎么演变成这种奇怪的口音的，难道好听吗，正宗的难道不好听吗，真是奇怪
@@aquamarine6606 大多新加坡人都习惯所以仍不觉得奇怪。针对可怪声调，我认为有可能是因被新加坡多元文化文语而影响。应该是由马来语，隔国马来西亚的口音等，并造成了新式语的，呃，特别口音
Edna K 原来本地人不觉得奇怪呀😄想了一下，，中国北方语系听南方一些沿海地区的口音真的感觉奇怪，普通话又是以北方语言作基础的，所以把标准国语普通话当作标准来衡量方着言区的口音就会有这种落差感吧
说错了，以北方口音做基础
我是北京人，希望能看到更多说中文好的海外华人
Singlish is our national language lah Bodoh!
As a Singaporean, I am always proud of our multilingual culture but sadly, the youngsters nowadays are not doing their best to speak their mother tongue.
Singapore consists of Singa Chinese, Singa Malay and Singa Indian. its hard to truly define ones "mother tongue" when your core society are divided into 3 classes. The equalizer the govt just settles is to be good in english and everything follows eventually
The parents should be blamed for this phenomenon. I see a lot of Singaporean parents speak English with their children and encourage speaking at home amongst the siblings. I always wonder why they do that, since their children have plenty of opportunities speaking English at school l, at work and in the street. What are they afraid of or simply because they feel superiority of English and inferiority of Chinese language?
My Children are very fortunate because we speak Mandarin at home and they master English and Malay languages as well.
Another thing I want to point out is, some low educated parents who speak broken English (haha, not the Singlish accent) definitely influence their Children. No matter how good the education system that is in Singapore, more or less the Singaporeans speak in funny accent so-called Singlish and sometimes grammatically wrong sentences.
@@kenmalaysia7440 支持您的做法，永远不要忘记母语，而且中国现在很强大，孩子们学习中文也是多了一种机会。
I can' t speak chinese, but i really want to learn chinese because i think the sound of people speak chinese is very interesting for me.
So where are you from if I may ask?
*I LOST IT WHEN THE KID STARTED RAPPING 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣*
He was actually not rapping
@@gabilei3974 AcK- my life is a lie
They sound Nigerian when they speak English😭
Bro, as a Chinese national, I can not understand your questions...
0:35 The girl was panting badly already upon hearing the question.
0:54 Conceded already
5:02 The boy is god-like.
我觉得新加坡人尤其是年轻人不会说很好的中文也是可以理解的。他们平时用的最多的就是英文，学校教的也是以英文为主，这当中也涉及到一些历史的原因。而且也不是说缺少中文就对他们交流沟通影响很大，属于可有可无的吧，当然能掌握好的中文会更有优势！就像很多华人去了欧美国家，他们的后代不会说中文的也是大有人在的。有很多外国人到了中国，也有后代也只会说中文的！所以，无所谓啦！这是他们自己的选择！from China .
Most younger Singapore chinese people are a disgrace and are overly westernized, and most of them hate their own mother tongue , and even hate the country of their ancestors, and that is why when there is any conflicts between people from China and those of other races, you always see most of the Singapore Chinese people speaking up loudly against the Chinese people from China . Most Singapore Chinese people actually hate their own race, which is such a huge disappointment .大多数年轻的新加坡华人都是耻辱，过度西化，他们大多数都讨厌自己的母语，甚至讨厌祖先的国家，这就是为什么当中国人和其他种族的人发生冲突时 你总能看到大多数新加坡华人大声反对中国人民。 大多数新加坡华人实际上都讨厌自己的种族，这是一个巨大的失望.....................
认同！！！！
新加坡是世上最可悲的华人，中文不会说英文说不标准这叫“丢人现眼“ 另外这是我听过最可笑的借口就是什么 ”日常生活沟通用英文为主“ 学校都教英文课“之类的，这是主要的问题吗？为什么马来西亚华裔没这些问题？通通都会中英马文，还要美国/澳洲/加拿大华裔都会中英文好吗？说得都是标准的。
@@tharencetung3436 还不是因为马来西亚华人在国内是二等公民
Chwee Teo 我们对有些中国人没好感是因为他们把这里当成自己的地盘。你有在看新闻、报纸等等吗？你可知道他们有多过分？在大庭广众 - 地铁站附近拉屎，对老人家完全没礼貌，对服务生无理要求，得不到他们想要的就闹就打架。在街上拉拉扯扯，大声嚷嚷，在巴士上一点公德心也没有，自己迷路了，还拦下满满乘客的巴士，其他人不用回家了吗？我们对大部分的中国人没好感不是没原因的。当然也有例外，个人觉得年轻一代中国人和每分年龄层的男性中国人没问题。只是比较有年纪的女性有些真的比较野蛮。然后你们马来西亚华人批评我们这里的华人还不是一样是耻辱？我有几个好朋友都是马来西亚人，前同事也都是，都相处得很好。这里的却是那么骄傲自大。见缝插针，看到这里哪方面不好就批评，难道马来西亚没差劲的地方？我90后的，来说啊
Him: *asks me question I'm Chinese*
Me who knows nothing about anything: Nani?