This. This is what arguments about religion should look like. Hold firm to whichever beliefs you can, if that is important to you, but acknowledge that others can hold different or no belief just as firmly, and just as you know they are absolutely wrong, you must accept they too know YOU are absolutely wrong. That way, no matter what, you are able to sit and drink and laugh as brothers and sisters, as humans, and not become monsters to one another.
AnonEyeMouse Sadly, people have been slaughtering each other over their imaginary friends; throughout human history. No matter how advanced we get this will never change.
@@anyohoww Everything we KNOW is just thinking something with a great deal of conviction. I KNOW you are a human being. (But you might not be). I use the word KNOW because many, many people know things that just isn't so. I've met too many people who reject the idea that they 'think' something. They will respond with 'no, I KNOW it!'. Rather than but heads with that entrenched point, better to embrace it. Ok. You know it. I know different. Rather than fortified retreat of a position, you now get to talk about how you each know what you know. But yeah... I'm on the same page as you.
It’s highly disturbing how they say they are pro Trump and then just make excuses for how he is exempt from the moral code that they have literally dedicated their lives to
Jim picked out three non-fundamentalists though, try the same experiment with a Salafist Muslim preacher, ultra-Orthodox rabbi and fundamentalist Christian and see how long it remains civil? It probably couldn't take place in a pub for starters!
You don't appreciate how much work he puts into his pieces. It may sound off the cuff, but his best one-hour shows are meticulously planned. He talks about it in some interviews. Even in this discussion, I think he came with a couple of prepared lines and laid out traps. I think the real difference is between stuff Jim does on his own, and stuff he delivers but a whole team worked on.
He can give away Quebec instead. They keep complaining they don't wanna be canadians anyway. It solves two conflicts at once! I'd miss Quebec, sure, but if they really wanna go might as well make the best of a bad situation, right? (Plus Middle Eastern food is awesome, hopefully we'd get an influx of Middle Easteners in Alberta as a sideffect ;D )
Brilliant video ... but I'm defending Tasmania from any Jim inspired mass infiltration. This fellow Aussie should have sacrificed the Gold Coast for the benefit of our species ... or taken out Canberra.
Canberra is not a real city! I’ve been there, it’s the weirdest place I have ever seen. I guess Israelis and Palestinians can have it! It’s much better than Israel though.
I love how simple he makes everything. It's so refreshing to have a comedian, who is Atheist, talk to religious leaders about complex belief systems. All the while simplifying it so much that you can come to a ridiculous conclusions. And then laugh that they can't come up with an appropriate answer to your simplified question...... Comic genius.
Honesty, the feast the muslims have at the end of Ramadan has got to be better than christimas or hannukah. After a month of fasting, a feast must taste SOOOO much better.
The year was 2004. In a small sleepy college town called Moscow, Idaho. We all learned about Ramadan. Because we had the munchies and the only thing that could sate us was a Shawarma. Every establishment we knew we could get one of the said delicacy was closed for Ramadan. A cultural punch to the solar plexus.
4 people sitting at a table being PAID to do so. Ya actually think these people would have done this if they were not being paid? Good luck witht that (OK, Jim would do it. He actually likes to make people laugh)
Nah if you're really religious its basically supposed to stay on at close to all times of the day besides sleeping, iírc. Something about clothing needing to be between you and the gaze of god or smth, i dont quite remember anymore.
Zahbär Schmuni I guess...but isn't that what the Tzitzit is for? Apart from on shabbat/chaggim on the way to shul or in shiurs etc, I find it a little odd to see someone, even a rabbi, wear it at such a meeting as this.
I know this was done for comic effect but even choosing three people with a sense of humour didn't cover their hypocrisy and refusal to deal with each other's BS.
lol the baptist dude "i love bacon!" "The pig is also unclean, you are not to eat their meat." -Deuteronomy 14:8 why is it that us atheists no more about the bible than the people who believe it? XD
Jesus said it's not what you put into your body/mouth that makes you unclean it's what comes out of your mouth that makes you unclean. Because it's a direct reflection of your heart. Ie what you speak and such
Edwin, jesus said that the old laws will be valid until heaven and earth have faded away (matthew 5;17), not eating pork because it is unclean is one of those laws. (Deuteronomy 14;8)
SoTotallyEpic Ironic when you just looked past the original comment and said something completely irrelevant. And just saying hope doesn’t mean anything anyway. It’s just bland platitudinous drivel.
Why is it that you atheists never try to understand the theological background of us Christians eating pork? Have you ever read St. Paul's epistles, or the Acts of the Apostles? It's in there mate. XD
Great to see religion being treated like the bad joke that it is. We need much more mockery like this until one day we might hopefully grow out of this insanity.
Those religious guys just show how deeply hypocritical they are. As long as sth. furthers their interests they are willing to throw morals out of the window. Because religion is not about morals but self-interest.
@@raprometheus3051 actualy there is historical proove that jesus did exist and most historians agree but they dont agree on what he was(i cant find the words to discribe this)
If all religous people, of any religion, would act to other beliefs or atheists like this, i would at least respect the people and their beliefs as well as their religion as a whole...
Fun thing is: for Christians, you need to believe that Jesus is the son of God. He is our savoir and only thru him can we enter Paradise. For Jews and Muslims, believe in Jesus is believing in another God and prevents you from entering Paradise.
I'm pretty sure Muslims view Jesus as one of the prophets but they disagree that he is the final and most important prophet because Muhammed was also very important as a prophet.
@Memento Mori faith is useless? What do you think drives people to do things? I'm not religious or even believe in god but you can't deny that what first brought people together is faith
Rather an arrogant assumption don'cha think? People are driven by any number of things such as self preservation, greed, hunger, lust, curiosity, boredom, etc. What first brought people together was a desire to survive. Ancient predators were very hungry and primitive humans were very tasty, I assume. Faith is largely wishful thinking and self deception, don't just assume everyone is like that.
If you go to Muslim majority area during daytime in Ramadan you won't get anything but go there when it's around sunset and the street would be filled with all sorts of food plus you can get free food sometimes
"two negatives make a positive"
That comment was hilarious by the Muslim. Everyone should be more like that with the small things in the world.
This. This is what arguments about religion should look like. Hold firm to whichever beliefs you can, if that is important to you, but acknowledge that others can hold different or no belief just as firmly, and just as you know they are absolutely wrong, you must accept they too know YOU are absolutely wrong. That way, no matter what, you are able to sit and drink and laugh as brothers and sisters, as humans, and not become monsters to one another.
AnonEyeMouse Sadly, people have been slaughtering each other over their imaginary friends; throughout human history.
No matter how advanced we get this will never change.
This statement would be perfect if we change the word "know" to "think" XD
I actually think that "know" has more meaning here, and might be intentional.
YES YES YES. Can I get an amen.....(I am an atheist.....)
@@anyohoww Everything we KNOW is just thinking something with a great deal of conviction. I KNOW you are a human being. (But you might not be). I use the word KNOW because many, many people know things that just isn't so. I've met too many people who reject the idea that they 'think' something. They will respond with 'no, I KNOW it!'. Rather than but heads with that entrenched point, better to embrace it. Ok. You know it. I know different. Rather than fortified retreat of a position, you now get to talk about how you each know what you know. But yeah... I'm on the same page as you.
This should be a regular segment with the same panel each time.
YES!!!!
3:30 😂 what Sacha Baron Cohen does with tons of Makeup, Jim does with a couple of beers.. 🤣😂😆
The Muslim guy treated the whole thing like a big joke😂😂😂
They all did !
Errrr it was on a comedy show lol.
@@irisalan3018 he was joking about eating pork and wine. Calm your horses
Eagle 367 🤣🤣🤣 that makes more sense !
you could say he had a blast
It’s highly disturbing how they say they are pro Trump and then just make excuses for how he is exempt from the moral code that they have literally dedicated their lives to
Didn't expect anything else from professional liars. 😂
Jim picked out three non-fundamentalists though, try the same experiment with a Salafist Muslim preacher, ultra-Orthodox rabbi and fundamentalist Christian and see how long it remains civil? It probably couldn't take place in a pub for starters!
Lol bloodbath probably
yeah, but you never want the extremists if youre just looking to accurately represent the majority of a community.
@@jenshep1720 exactly my thoughts
Jim is the hero we need, AND deserve.
And want
Off the cuff Jim is pure gold compared to scripted Jim 👍🏼
You don't appreciate how much work he puts into his pieces. It may sound off the cuff, but his best one-hour shows are meticulously planned. He talks about it in some interviews. Even in this discussion, I think he came with a couple of prepared lines and laid out traps.
I think the real difference is between stuff Jim does on his own, and stuff he delivers but a whole team worked on.
Daneelro, agree.
hey, I live in Tasmania!! Don't start giving away my real estate, Jim!
He can give away Quebec instead. They keep complaining they don't wanna be canadians anyway. It solves two conflicts at once! I'd miss Quebec, sure, but if they really wanna go might as well make the best of a bad situation, right? (Plus Middle Eastern food is awesome, hopefully we'd get an influx of Middle Easteners in Alberta as a sideffect ;D )
now u know palestinians felt when britain give away their land to the jews.
Tasmania! That's real! WOW . I thought that was from Lord of the Rings. Look's like it on Google images.
Brilliant video ... but I'm defending Tasmania from any Jim inspired mass infiltration. This fellow Aussie should have sacrificed the Gold Coast for the benefit of our species ... or taken out Canberra.
Definitely Canberra! :-p
Canberra is not a real city! I’ve been there, it’s the weirdest place I have ever seen. I guess Israelis and Palestinians can have it! It’s much better than Israel though.
Christmas islands should be enough. You don't want them on the mainland. They have a knack for encroaching on other peoples territory.
Take canberra and the pollys
HELLS YES, spot on Matthew
Having been to Tasmania, it is the forgotten jewel of the earth and may it remains undiscovered.
I love how simple he makes everything. It's so refreshing to have a comedian, who is Atheist, talk to religious leaders about complex belief systems. All the while simplifying it so much that you can come to a ridiculous conclusions. And then laugh that they can't come up with an appropriate answer to your simplified question......
Comic genius.
2 negatives makes it a positive >
I was like "what the fudge?!!"
Lol, two sins make a good deed, I guess if a lot of people explain themselves like this, it says a lot
Trump's new policy?
Seems like most of the world works like this lol so he may have a point
It was a good joke but his delivery was of course not so well and i believed him for a second bht he was droning water
Wow these people are horrible. I wasn't expecting that at first.
Honesty, the feast the muslims have at the end of Ramadan has got to be better than christimas or hannukah. After a month of fasting, a feast must taste SOOOO much better.
muslims eat after sunset, a 30 days feast is what ramadan is, trust me I live among them
Mike, it is really good!
Ramadan is the best time of the year :) the gates of heaven opens and your prayers have double good deeds and devils get chained up ^^
This was awesome!
This episode should go for an hour!!!!!
This looks like a fun hangout
"You can have Tasmania", As an Australian, I have a problem with that Jim. A big problem.
The year was 2004. In a small sleepy college town called Moscow, Idaho. We all learned about Ramadan. Because we had the munchies and the only thing that could sate us was a Shawarma. Every establishment we knew we could get one of the said delicacy was closed for Ramadan. A cultural punch to the solar plexus.
Masterclass Jim! ... I hope Jared Kushner was watching.
I love this..4 people with different beliefs on the same table and having fun
until the cameras go away
4 people sitting at a table being PAID to do so. Ya actually think these people would have done this if they were not being paid? Good luck witht that (OK, Jim would do it. He actually likes to make people laugh)
@@jamesjpak getting paid is part of their Jobs!
Scrolling the comments looking for angry Tassies defending Tasmania 😂 wasn't dissapointed.
I actually prefer Jim to have a longer cut, this could be an interesting conversation!
More of this!!!
I absolutely love this
After a couple cuts the audience got what they wanted.👏😂
3:31 and 4:26 cracks me up every time.
Why is the Rabbi wearing his talit in a bar?! Isn't it more for praying and not regular wear?
Nah if you're really religious its basically supposed to stay on at close to all times of the day besides sleeping, iírc. Something about clothing needing to be between you and the gaze of god or smth, i dont quite remember anymore.
Zahbär Schmuni I guess...but isn't that what the Tzitzit is for?
Apart from on shabbat/chaggim on the way to shul or in shiurs etc, I find it a little odd to see someone, even a rabbi, wear it at such a meeting as this.
millerhxc his bald spot, his choice xD
What has that got to do with it?? I'm talking about the talit, not the kippah/yarmulke.
@@millerhxc you're right. The guy was probably a reform or conservative rabbi
Jim Jefferies is the most sensible and most belligerent person In modern history
That's quite a title to give to a late night host
why cut the answers you are given ?
This is the best
That was the best thing I have ever seen!
I have to see this fill interview! Hey, Comedy Central! Release the tapes! ;)
I know this was done for comic effect but even choosing three people with a sense of humour didn't cover their hypocrisy and refusal to deal with each other's BS.
Two negatives make a positive 🤣🤣🤣
We need a lot more of these, with different people doing the same kinda thing
We got Ramadan everyone 😂😂
I wish we all could actually get along like this in the real world and make jokes about each others beliefs and laugh and not get offended
This was surprisingly wholesome...
This was a lot of fun.
lol the baptist dude "i love bacon!"
"The pig is also unclean, you are not to eat their meat." -Deuteronomy 14:8
why is it that us atheists no more about the bible than the people who believe it? XD
Although Paul in the New Testament explicitly denounces many of the laws of the Torah, both in dietary terms and abandoning mandatory circumcision.
Jesus said it's not what you put into your body/mouth that makes you unclean it's what comes out of your mouth that makes you unclean. Because it's a direct reflection of your heart. Ie what you speak and such
Edwin, jesus said that the old laws will be valid until heaven and earth have faded away (matthew 5;17),
not eating pork because it is unclean is one of those laws.
(Deuteronomy 14;8)
SoTotallyEpic
Ironic when you just looked past the original comment and said something completely irrelevant.
And just saying hope doesn’t mean anything anyway. It’s just bland platitudinous drivel.
Why is it that you atheists never try to understand the theological background of us Christians eating pork? Have you ever read St. Paul's epistles, or the Acts of the Apostles? It's in there mate. XD
That was brilliant!
Great to see religion being treated like the bad joke that it is. We need much more mockery like this until one day we might hopefully grow out of this insanity.
I love these 3...they look chill compared to the usual religious nuts..
This was awesome. Religious or not how cool are these guys?! Good on them for having a great sense of humour 😁
Those religious guys just show how deeply hypocritical they are. As long as sth. furthers their interests they are willing to throw morals out of the window. Because religion is not about morals but self-interest.
there he is, Jims back
That was hilarious!!!!
I actually loved this
As Hitchens said, genital mutilation is not a joke.
Anant 1 irrespective of your moral arguments circumcision is ultimately a net positive for the individual & society at large.
hundreds of healthy kids -dying- BEING MURDERED each year because a cult tells you to mutilate their genitals
oh yeah that sure is a positive...
@@katrinamichlik9410 You mean, a net negative.
Lol. Anti-circumcision loonies.
@@DroZzhat Loonies? Excuuuuse me, Mr. Blind enough to not see that circumcision is a bad thing.
That was beautiful
Can't watch youtube without zomato ad just change ads pls
"Never _ever_ make fun of Muslims, Simon ..only Christians. And Jews a _little_ bit." - Alan Partridge
Only an Australian could pull this off
i can argue about anything and stay civil as long as you buy the first round
Cant get better then this ... XD
OMG yes Tasmania is amazing, I live there
How is everyone circumcised?
Stanley Tucci is EVERYWHERE!
4:11 - if you believe in jesus, you'll have eternal life.... he lived, so i do believe in jesus, it's god i don't believe in
But Jesus is dead tho
There is no proof that Jesus existed.
@@raprometheus3051 actualy there is historical proove that jesus did exist and most historians agree
but they dont agree on what he was(i cant find the words to discribe this)
Love it!
Hey...whoa.........leave Tasmania alone.
Had to make it longer.
Love the man
What kind of off-brand Muslim did they get?
A normal one
He must have bought muslim light cause he couldn't handle the full one
Leave tassie out of this Jim!
They all treat it like a joke, comedy show or not, makes sense, Religion & Trump are the biggest jokes on this planet xD
I bet Gunther was crossed after that joke
Not bad. Quite hilarious at times.
Seems like the Muslim has the best common sense after him himself
3:30 is how we all feel about Trump.
Great we are made in gods image but then decide he got it wrong so we haver to chop bits off
Why is this reposted? Taken down? Easily offended religious people crying like babies about the truth? Surely not!
Right, because atheists NEVER complain, or claim to be offended, or try to have things removed. Sure. You keep telling yourself that, Sparky.
The irony never get old
this is so genius.
Rabbi is such a hypocrite
How can anyone approve the barbaric act of cutting parts of children... Disgusting. They should be in jail.
* YAWN * While you approve all kinds of barbarity because you're used to it.
3:32 🤐 Jewish guy. 😂
"You can have Tasmania". Same old story Europeans offering out land that isn't theirs to give.
He's an Australian
@@shadowlord1418 He does not look Aboriginal, Samoan or Maori. Im certain a DNA test will say he is 95-99% European
@@francisnwokedi581 wow that's a bit racist your saying cause he's white he can't be Australian?
Only an Aussie!!!😂😂😂
Jim should interview the pope
... the bar is called “Bar in Hebrew”
At least they were good sports about it
If all religous people, of any religion, would act to other beliefs or atheists like this, i would at least respect the people and their beliefs as well as their religion as a whole...
Evangelicals are as Christian as Mormons and JWs and not a good judge of the religion. But I do like see all sides having a peaceful discussion.
Fun thing is: for Christians, you need to believe that Jesus is the son of God. He is our savoir and only thru him can we enter Paradise. For Jews and Muslims, believe in Jesus is believing in another God and prevents you from entering Paradise.
I'm pretty sure Muslims view Jesus as one of the prophets but they disagree that he is the final and most important prophet because Muhammed was also very important as a prophet.
Oh man do I love science 😀
is coca cola kosher ?
tell that muslim that we aren't even allowed to sit down with people who drinks
I tuned out after the muslim said i drink bear and eat pork ...
Let's jew it up😂😂😂😂😂
Practice faith not religion
Yes, practice making good and wise descissions
Ah, the little word games people love to play to convince themselves they're right and everyone else is wrong.
@Memento Mori faith is useless? What do you think drives people to do things? I'm not religious or even believe in god but you can't deny that what first brought people together is faith
Rather an arrogant assumption don'cha think? People are driven by any number of things such as self preservation, greed, hunger, lust, curiosity, boredom, etc. What first brought people together was a desire to survive. Ancient predators were very hungry and primitive humans were very tasty, I assume. Faith is largely wishful thinking and self deception, don't just assume everyone is like that.
If you go to Muslim majority area during daytime in Ramadan you won't get anything but go there when it's around sunset and the street would be filled with all sorts of food plus you can get free food sometimes
i still quite like it, when Jim gets pub lairy. Who else could get round that table? for round 2
A Buddist.
The probability of "or it could be made up" is 1.
Yeah tassie
I always thought how to get a Jew a Muslim a christen in one room and what would happen
Lets jew it up! Hahhaa 😂