Peter Dutton can expect a 'fight' over nuclear energy: Peta Credlin
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Sky News host Peta Credlin says if Opposition Leader Peter Dutton wanted a fight over nuclear energy, it "looks like he's going to get it".
"And that's no bad thing for an Opposition," she said.
"You certainly can't beat an incumbent by just agreeing with them - as the Victorian Liberal Party needs to learn, and fast.
"Yesterday, the Prime Minister said that nuclear energy was fine for others but not for Australia."
She said today, Treasurer Jim Chalmers "really unleashed on the Opposition".
"I can't speak for the Opposition Leader, but I reckon you can drive a truck through the government's position.
Put this to a referendum and the PEOPLE vote to decide, NOT POLITICIANS!
Dunce.
@@EL_Duderino68 Why Dunce? If you don't know, vote NO.
@@psidot Because, dunce, referendums are for changing the Australian Constitution. Look it up. You didn't know that. Hence you are a dunce. Do you get it now?
Which will be quickly followed by the circus over who pays for its construction and who operates it. Government won't because it requires tax increases which are unpopular. The other is looking at a 6-8 billion dollar or so initial investment with no income for around 6 years and investors who want to see the balance sheet go up each year. This is even before you account for the numbers of nuclear power stations built.
no more bloody referendums!!!
Dim Jim has more than enough hot wind to blow those turbines.
Chalmers must think most Australians are suckers, electricity has gone up by 30% & rising !!
Yes it has. That's due to 2 factors. 1 the LNP doing very little towards the transition beforehand with zero planning, and 2 price gouging by retailers from the capital cost of renewables. The wholesale price has actually fallen.
@@yggdrasil9039 Trouble with your Argument is, Your Mate Albozzo is Supposed to be In Charge......Remember He Had a PLAN ?
@@yggdrasil9039 Tell me another one silly, I worked in renewables for 10 years & you don`t know what you`re talking about !! You on the other hand probably sit around smoking bongs all day !!! The Liberals started renewables !
@@KT-bb1tb No trouble at all KT. Let the market decide. Remember, people were only too happy to vote for state governments that sold off their electricity companies. People are now reaping what they sowed. What did people honestly expect was going to happy when natural monopolies were sold off?
Well your obviously a sucker because nuclear will drive prices up a lot higher than 30%
Charmers is a waste
Most people recognise that trying to rely on renewables is an unreliable and expensive road to disaster.
labor are economic vandals leading Aus to poverty
The baseload aspect of nuclear is a good point, but baseload also comes from battery and heat capacitor firming, hydro, future deep geothermal, and some gas peakers.
It's a road to destruction of our country.
Albanese and the greens ,teals are selling us out to the CCP!! The CCP is building 500 new thermal power plants to add to the 1000 they already use. To make windmills and EVs and a power source to power the EVs. What a bunch of sellouts the left is. All need to be investigated for links to the CCP.
@@yggdrasil9039😂😂😂 and all of that could be combined into nuclear for a lot less cost than those environmental damaging problems
Renewables is a joke
But we are the punchline.
All options should be on the table. Lift the bans on nuclear power.
Stick to ya guns Mr Dutton.
Mashed potato head is out of ammo.
@@countyorga764 and so are you by your comment!! What is your claim to fame that you are able to make such a comment. Be positive like the LNP - not negative like the majority of the ALP. We are supposed to be a country united - not divided by stupid talk and dumb comments!!
OK DUTTON STICK WITH IT AS WE WILL STICK WITH YOU
Mr Dutton needs to make it official LNP policy to withdraw Australia from the Paris Accord, repeal the renewable energy targets legislation and use the most economical energy resources available.
Well Jimbo and Bowen, why have you not fully disclosed the true cost of these renewables? The rot has to stop 🇦🇺
The rot has stopped. It stopped on May 21, 2022.
There is no such thing as renewables, wind turbines are subject to weather conditions, storms, hail, last about 10 years and then they are junk. So then does it cost us all over again to replace them
@@Aussie-Nan Indeed. So where do you propose the nuclear waste be buried? In your backyard? And if not your backyard, than whose backyard? It has to go somewhere you know.
@@psidot Australia has the perfect conditions for waste storage.
@@psidot. There's plenty of room in this country to dispose of it safely and well away from population.
Chalmers projecting again. What a clown.
The ALP have a ring master who directs the circus, and he has many clowns and monkeys providing the entertainment. The biggest clown is Chalmers (though many come close to him), but the funniest monkey is Bowen. When he gets going he is really good to watch. Oh what fun it is to watch the ALP Circus provide entertainment for the people of Australia!
I live by my self and my electricity bill to day Nelly 12 hundred,bring on nuclear and get this useless government vote d out
Nuclear will drive prices up goose, go do some reading on the subject instead of talking garbage
@@jettstream2886. I suppose you think green energy will save us all money hey goose!
@@jettstream2886 What is your claim to fame that you are able to make such a comment. Be positive like the LNP - not negative like the majority of the ALP. We are supposed to be a country united - not divided by stupid talk and dumb comments!!
@@lesblack413 no claim to fame goose I've been doing some reading on the matter and and merely repeating what I read on a number of sites including the CSIRO
Cant run a country 100% on renewables, could certainly run it 100% without Chris Bowen tho.
Why is Albozo & his mates so for nuclear subs but can't accept nuclear into our power mix? Do they hate Australia so much ?😮
Yes!! The majority of ALP supporters are socialist communists hell bent on ruining Australia. You can bet that once they are voted out it will take more than nine (9) years to get back in to power again after this current debacle!!
🤔 $400 billion to go nuclear to fully go renewables will cost australia over $1.2 trillion
Wrong again, where do you fools get this rubbish
The “renewables” last 15 to 20 years and a well built nuclear or coal fired power plant lasts for over 50 years.
We are currently burdened with a large cohort of dishonest duplicitous politicians who are colluding with ridiculous and economically destructive popular delusions. They are acting contrary to the national interest and need to be voted out ASAP.
Perfect point. Plus the environmental devestation from wind and solar
Japan’s Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant Unit 6 took only 39 months for completion.
Nuclear power brings down electricity prices by 75% in Finland.
: Japan’s Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant Unit 6 took only 39 months for completion.
Nuclear power brings down electricity prices by 75% in Finland.
I stand with Petter Dutton
Labor give us pain, nothing else.
Lnp gave us robodebt, make and break submarine deal, Dutton handed 400 million to a security firm to guard a family of 4, 30 million to fox, sports rorts, etc etc so stop talking crap
I vote peter Dutton
You are in his electorate?
@@EL_Duderino68 the only one impressed with your supposed witty comeback is you, my vote will be liberal in kingston electorate thats a vote for dutton
Why can't we stick with coal and gas?
Until there is a viable replacement ...ABSOLUTELY!
Climate
Albosleaze wants to save the planet even though no one asked for it !!!
When Krakatoa blew its top 1883, it emitted more carbon fossils fuel into the atmosphere, than the whole commencement of industrial world. We are still here. Why didn't we all die. Shows you climate change global warming is just shizenhousen. The planet is intelligent knows how to adapt, pity the humans on it are stupid.
@@info88w11 the reason the LNP lost is because they had no emissions policy
The only reason that Nuclear Power would be too expensive is if Labor was in charge of the project, and if it's in Victoria it would also take alot longer than it should. Cannot remember a major project in Victoria that has been on time, on budget and run by Labor.
Yeah, because the corrupt unions would want control of the build and then the maintenance contracts.
I hope Australians vote for Peter Dutton as their PM next time around... It would be great for Australia to have Dutton as PM when Trump becomes President in 2024... It would benefit both nations greatly...
Mr Trump correctly rejects the economically destructive delusional insanity of Net Zero.
The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels are largely beneficial. Benefits include increased agricultural yields (main effect) reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum.
can chalmers hear himself, it is their party that brings divisive polices, James Paterson sounds like a good fit he articulates himself very well and is usually across the detail.
About time 😊 great news
If Mr Duttons up for the fight then hes got millions of Australians behind him charlmers is a jughead and Bowens a crook theyl never be remembered for anything good only the mess they made of everything they touched.
Senator James Patterson is a fine politician and one that I am proud to support. Thanks Peter Dutton for making this change. You can always judge a good leader by the people they hire; the people they fire; the people they promote; the people they demote.
Talk about fantasy, the Labor & Greens mistaken belief that "renewables" are the best thing for Australia freightens me beyond belief. I have seen the size of solar "farms" which reduce the amount of arable land available for food production concerns me because I believe tjat the idea is driven by city based people who have no concept of the importance of rural production to the food they consume. For some reason, they think that imported foodstuffs (which are not produced in the sustainable way Australian food is produced) can replace the healthy food to which Australians have become accustomed.
On top of that, our balance of trade will (not might) be adversely affected!
Tell that to the private power providers who are the ones building it. Every house could have roof top solar to drastically cut power from the grid during the day and rely on barely any draw from fixed sites during the night. But we all know what happens if you dare to use less power, the costs just go up to compensate the loss.
Just like all those power saving items you have, they ended up doing nothing in the end.
Who is going to get the contract to maintain and clean all the solar panels on a regular basis as any RV and caravan owner knows, you've got to keep them clean in order to get maximum return out of them, and maximum return is around six (6) hours per day at best. When is most power used? Generally in the evening from 6.00pm up 'till about 10.00PM and guess what... no solar panels are working then and the battery capacity, if fitted to store the power, lasts for maybe two (2) hours if lucky!!
Just heard Tim Pallas Vic Treasurer bailing out after May budget, ffs, realised state is f@#ked ! 😢
passing the grenade after pulling the pin
Chalmers reading that well from script which means nothing but words
About time this was discussed, nuclear is a tried and tested form of energy. Lets get it on!
There is nothing renewable about wind & solar.
Renewable because they have to be maintained and replaced at regular intervals...
1 wind turbine has to work 24/7 for three years before its classed as green, like EVs, 5 years or 90,000km before its classed as green, not to mention solar panels on the manufacture of each one. Billions spent on renewable`s each 15-20 years, and nuclear power plants lasting up to 5 times longer giving cheap power. Labor and greens have totally lost it.
A bunch of BS
Solar lasts 30 years some even have 40 year warranty. The 30 year overhaul of a European reactor costs as much as installing solar. Nuclear is financially unviable
Please explain your BS to the French government.
@@johngeier8692 you explain your BS to the world nuclear association, they say the same thing
@@johngeier8692 Spends 5 mins and research the French owned nuclear power corporation EDF and tell me how much debt they are in. Hint €65 billion
You can recycle nuclear waste to generate power also.The technology is now available for that. So Australia don’t need to worry about storing nuclear waste
Yep, labor look nervous when they argue against nuclear. They debate the issue like a primary school debating class. Dutton only needs (probably already done) experts from overseas that have developed, operated, run, modular nuke plants, how they operate, how they connect the grid, how much they cost and what power bills will be like. Get all the know how, and answers then confront Labor, here you go, I bet they will all be red faced.
Nuclear will drive the price of electricity through the roof, go do some reading on it before talking garbage
Dutton just needs to tell everyone how it's going to be funded and who is going to operate it. That will make him really fight for answers.
Very clearly elucidated. You are right on the topic here and you have nailed them to the wall with your honesty.
Lame
I'm sure many farmers in LNP seats will embrace nuclear power stations on their properties, and also accept nuclear waste on their farms. Dutton needs to explain exactly how it works, and not just grandstand.
Problems with policies like this are for Labor to pick up later on of course.
Steve Nuclear fusion is being tested in Korea right now its product waste is hydrogen and farmers would love to have that in close proximity. You really should forget your fears its not even driven by uranium.
Labor aren't just taking on the opposition but also a majority of Australians.
They have form though because they're slipping in a Voice via the back door completely disregarding the referendum vote.
Are we still a democracy?
The Aboriginal Nation Delusion was voted down.
The electorate now needs to reject the Climate Delusion (The false and delusional belief that mans effects on the earth’s climate are significant and dangerous), the Energy Transition Delusion (The false and delusional belief that transitioning to non fossil fuel energy sources will be cheap and easy) and the Nuclear Power is Unsafe Delusion (The false and delusional belief that nuclear power plants are unsafe).
Popular delusions are dangerous and can lead to economic ruin war and genocide.
We should commit to staying at 1% of global emissions and use what we have
If Australia is going to go down the path of nuclear power, laws must be changed. If anyone uses lawfare to slow or blow out costs, they have to be held accountable for any losses incurred. Regulations need to be streamlined so that projects don't move at a snail's pace or go back over the same ground time and time again. It should never take 10 years for any project to be started because of red and green tape. If anyone tries last minute, last ditch attempts to halt projects, they and their lawyers need to be charged under security statutes and jailed. Once the decision has been made, it should be allowed to proceed. Create a new department to oversee if needed, but they should have full responsibility for getting the reactors built and operated, no matter who is in government.
Why is this government aloud to hide all details from us! Where is the Governor General?
Pets tell me why have they not told us the rice of these wind turnbines
Bring on Nuclear.
Of course They/Them are going to oppose.. i mean you don't think you'd want CHEAPER ELECTRICITY.. 🤔🤫🤣
ANOTHER. BIDEN
Labor won’t lift the moratorium, because it’s an easy and lazy place to sit.
I think they will have to as there will be too much backlash to enable them to be voted successfully in at the next election. The longer the election is set back, the worse the situation becomes for the ALP!
Sorry about that price of these wind turnbines
Any idea what is going on with crime spree in Melbourne ? can we have a honest report about it ?
immigration!
Cheap and reliable electridity is devisive?? Only in Labor world.
Nuclear ain't cheap
Aussie coal and gas is cheap
@@shellysmith3780 not as cheap as renewables. Coal is going broke
@@shellysmith3780 dirty, not cheap
Mr Morrison signed us up for the economically destructive delusional insanity of Net Zero. The ALP then doubled down upon it whilst we continue to export large amounts of coal, natural gas and uranium to other countries which utilise these resources for cheap reliable energy. This situation is ludicrous.
We need to withdraw from the Paris Accord forthwith and use the most economical energy resources available.
Delusional? Labour is delusional over their renewable policy.
They are colluding with ridiculous and economically destructive popular delusions (1) the false and delusional belief that mans effects on the earth’s climate are significant and dangerous (2) the false and delusional belief that transitioning to non fossil fuel energy sources will be cheap and easy and (3) the false and delusional belief that nuclear power plants are unsafe.
The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels are largely beneficial. Benefits include increased agricultural yields (main effect) reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum.
Yet Albos getting a few Nuclear subs.
How often do you fill them up ...?
Once only
Never heard so much BS from this Treasure
Net Zero is economically destructive delusional insanity.
We have energy policy based upon ridiculous and economically destructive popular delusions.
Wasn’t she Abbotts bit on the side
Rumour has it.
He has good taste hasn't he mate
there is one idiot born every day.
What a stupid comment from a clearly ignorant person.
You’re a simpleton 🤦♂️
She was just his chief of staff and nothing else.
Politicians with all these hig ideas yet no money.
If and when we get out of debt then we can decide ... but not before.
No it’s not reliable and how much has it cost us so far with no real results
James Paterson is the best coalition performer by a country mile. A future PM.
Nuclear makes sense just get it done sick of govt acting like children , didn’t care for politics once , but there policies are ruining this once great country🤔🧐
Dutton is history! Michael Kroger knows the truth. Dutton and Littleproud cannot dent the Labor machine.
Labour liars.
Crayge can't spell.
@jsuter2849 all good @jnutter.
@@GoldenWaveTitans you better go back to school.
Where we're going, we don't need rd's
#ALP GET OUT please 🙏 🎉
Yeah every year we are instaling solar and wind where are those discounts already i should be paing by now at least 100$ less
Vote 🗳 LABOR OUT forever and asap. 😢
Next time a nuclear powered vessel comes into port, plug it in to the grid hold a press conference and say tada we've got nuclear power now, see how long and how hard it was hahaha.
it is a better use of those useless subs than thinking they are going to scare China off.
The Governments power policy is built and maintained on coal generated power EVs are built and run on coal power to many people see the still surface but not the dangerous under curents.
Exactly ❤ 1:57
Nearly 50 billion to get 4 gigawatts. We would need 6 times that to replace coal. Also we still have the question of where to put the waste. Samsonvale or Lake Kurwongbah maybe. This will never happen.
Go well Peter Dutton.
Come on Pete, tell us the details. For example, how much is it going to cost, how long is it going to take to get all this up and running, and where is the waste going to be buried?
Relax bozo..... Take your anti depressants and go back to bed.
Before this is done I hope there is a referendum so the people have a say on unclear power
Unfortunately it's a technical issue. A referendum is a bad option.
"If you don't know, say no" lol. No referendum will ever pass again.
No point having a fight with incompetence of the Labor party who have no lie about nuclear. Stick to the facts and make it work and show the Labor party up for what they are not worthy of having and that is leading this country any longer.
Have data and all the material and out then in their place once and for all
True hun LOL. A Renuable energee truck. Road Train in fact hahaha.
Google, don't go evil
Before Peter Dutton makes a commitment to nuclear power to
replace coal powered stations, my suggestion to him is to do
in depth reading on the subject and to "watch your mouth".
Think of Chernobyl and Fukushima as being stark warnings.
The last thing Australia needs is politicians meddling in nuclear
power in order to fish for votes. Vote fishing can be disastrous.
Remember what happened when Labor tried to redefine what
an Australian aboriginal is.
When James Lovelock got out there and said that for the foreseeable future Nuclear should be considered for virtual emissions free power then that must have ruffled a few feathers. But it was like a revelation to me, as I had come to the same conclusion at that time. That was 20 years ago and the current ban is just one step away from burying your head in the sand. IMO most Ozzies would prefer not to have Nuclear, but I think we are slowly coming round to the notion that it’s in our national interest and more modern technology makes it much safer. Perhaps there are some benefits after all of being a Nuclear outlier.
who can sharpen a knife ?
Chalmers could not run a household budget for a week let lone a countries economy. Could not add 2+2 without a calculator. Nuclear is the only way to go for reliable power.
Yes nuclear
Bullshit Chalmers
AND YOU TO GREENS AS ON THE WAY OUT
So more misinformation and disinformation
the belief is nuclear is zero Co2 That is not the case, there is 15-50Grams of Co2 per kwh of power generated. Multiply that by 1 billion KwH of power. = 1 Gigawatt.
Dutton has to explain how the cost of $50 billion / reactor, plus maintenance, plus processed uranium, plus disposal of waste will generate cheaper electricity. Its not in Europe, the UK or the USA, all countries that build them. Check for yourself.
France generates 70% of its electricity from nuclear power plants and their electricity is currently cheaper than Australia’s.
Iran has the cheapest electricity of all major countries and Germany has the most expensive of all major countries.
Iran did not sign the Paris Accord and Germany has based it’s energy policy on the same popular delusions as the current Australian government.
Popular delusions are dangerous and can lead to economic ruin war and genocide.
@@johngeier8692 well what a pile if crap, have you actually done any research or do you just blindly believe this crap. Germany has reactors. UK has reactors. Do yourself a favour, look at the cost of building the Hinkley C Reactor in Bristol and double it. Then look at the population of France and size. 60 something million. Then figure out how a puny 25 million is going to fund at least 7 reactors at around 40 - 50 billion dollars if we are lucky, then add maintenance, waste management, cost of processed uranium. That's just the start, these reactors only last 50 years and cost billions to decommission, look at the Anglesea reactor owned by Hitachi. Even in the UK French built reactors (EDF) are experiencing major cost blowouts at £22 biilion same in USA. Then do the research on Nu Scale and SMR'S and see for yourself. Dutton and Sky have you fooled.
Credlin has a shameless regard for credlin but few people agree.
Are you saying that nuclear waste will
reach a stage where it doesn't exist ? Are there no risks ?
think carefully for future generations.
Even one mistake could eliminate all life on earth.
Renewables, ha ha
Ol Jimmy boy speaking with forked tongue yet again. Peta, do yourself a favour and go and look at Dr Simon Michauxs work. He lays it all down and even presented to Canberra and they were all dumbfounded.
I Hope Dutton has Grown Some Ka'hunna's ? Stick with it Peter !
Poor Dutts. Still smiting after Saturday's lose.
Abandon net 0 or get no vote from me
Riddle me this, What is the difference if a nuclear reactor provides electrical power to a submarine versus providing electrical power to residential and industry?
@piersculley6419 Size matters. My girl friend told me so.
I am amazed that the size answer didn't occur to you.
@@brianterence3211 got me on a technical issue 🤣
The good place to put one is in New South Wales the Huntervalley where Ridell power station used to be there is plenty of water you already have transmission wires there and it would be good for the area course it also creates jobs in the Hunter Valley and good on Peter Dutton to bring this up so wall people can start talking about it and yes we need cheaper power and yes nuclear-power would be good for Australia
Well said!!
Aah Labor … confounding ‘the bleeding obvious’ as usual.
❤
Now if we were attacked then invaded what is the difference between a bomb landing on a Nuclear power station verses the same on Solar Panels/Wind Turbines?
That isn’t how it works, it’s not going to be a nuclear explosion.
We should withdraw from the Paris Accord and the nuclear nonproliferation treaty and build nuclear power plants for reliable energy and nuclear weapons to defend ourselves. It is unwise to rely upon foreign powers for our defence.
i know you probably thought that was very clever....
you were wrong!
we all have something to contribute to this discussion, but from now on the only thing you should contribute is silence!
@@ThatGuy-ze5kk 🤭🤭🤭🤔🤔🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
@@johngeier8692 We are too small a country and need friends. Nuclear Power Stations would suffice as long as risk is minimised and the 4% non recyclable wastage is managed in a location that is fully agreed to by all parties. Renewables still have a place and need constant research and refinement for the future as resources are finite. In an event of war those nuclear power stations would be first hit.
No comparison at all about a submarine and domestic power. As more and more coal fired power stations close down the more power prices will drop, The last two years has seen a drop in power prices. Hydro is good power, half of Victoria runs on snowy power with another hydro to come. Coal does not do as much as people think.
The coal fired power stations that have already shut down have not been missed. The whole eastern States +SA +tas are all connected to the same grid. and controlled by AEMO. Pumped hydro has been there since the snowy hydro first started so no change. Ill informed persons think they know all when in fact it's all misinformation. France is not Australia More B/S
At the moment our energy policies are run by a small number of fringe zealots. Bring on the nuclear energy election and let the people have their say. I think we all want lower power bills like we had before the reliance on the so called renewables. I also think producing C02 is a good thing for the environment.
Agreed. The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels have the net beneficial effects of increased agricultural yields (main effect) reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum.
Nuclears isnt cheap and in the present state of the economy oh boy is it going to be expensive. Our debt is close to 2 trillion image adter 😮 3 trillion?
Strange thet Peta does not endorse nuclear energy! Perhaps she has a smidgeon of reality which does not usually show.
Only underachieving bogans are triggered by Dutton...
Here they come 😊
Only thing that triggers me is glitter so go change your dress
Bring it on!! Perer Dutton!!
We need nuclear power much better than covering our fram land with millions of solar panels and millions of wind turbines on our hills and beaches.
At least all the infrastructure is there at the coal-fired power station
6-8 years to build nulear look it up
Too late anyways. Should of had 4 Reactors 20 yrs ago....France, Germany, Russsia and America had and have them...
Bit too late fellas....
Lol "nuclear power now ... or maybe in 50 years!"