Why is the Mainstream Media Journalism Failing? - Arifa Noor -
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- Arifa Noor is a Journalist, Writer and the host of Newswise on Dawn News.
Arifa comes on The Pakistan Experience to discuss Electoral Politics, Constituency Politics, Election Analysis, Journalism, TV, Mainstream Media, Social Media and Data.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:30 Electoral Politics and Punjab-centric Analysis
10:05 Constituency Politics and Imran Khan
19:30 Control on Media and Social Media
26:20 Failures of Mainstream TV
44:30 Audience Questions - Розваги
Arifa Noor, The unsung and underrated Female Journalist of Pakistan , TPE's choice is commendable.
🙌
Calling the coverage of Punjab vis-a-vis electoral politics "biased" is an unfair characterization. The fact is whoever wins Punjab takes the center and despite this advantage, KP and Karachi both get considerable coverage. Media will cover contentious areas. Punjab, KP, Urban SIndh are all contentious areas. Interior Sindh and Balochistan aren't. And even in Punjab, most of the coverage is focused on Lahore. When have we seen stories on Faisalabad, Sialkot, Gujranwala etc? It's only natural. Commercial mass media is for the "masses". Call it commercial but not biased.
Also, TV is not a benchmark to assess the quality of journalism in Pakistan. There is a reason it's called an idiot's box. Judge our journalism from print which for me is pretty good (especially English newspapers i.e. Dawn, Profit).
11:00 wow she called it perfectly.
When coverage of Punjab’s electoral politics is characterized as biased, the inherent focus on controversial areas is overlooked, with mass commercial journalism catering to mass audiences rather than sleep discrimination
Thanks Shehzad for bringing important voices to the forum . Please keep up ❤
❤️
Very nice podcast. Ms. Noor is a great journalist
🙌
Bring her back @@ThePakistanExperience
One of favourite journalists and show hosts
🙌
I really admire Arifa Noor. Big fan of your podcasts as well Shahzad. Please also invite Hamid Mir to your podcast one day.
🙌
Such a humble woman. Used to love her show on DAWN which used to be inquisitorial instead of unproductively adversarial.
Listening to her for the 1st time. Enjoyed the podacst.
🙌
The reason behind Dawn removed comment section is because we Indians were writing true comments there how inaccurate their content specially on India news. Just kidding. :) 😄
I miss the Clown of the Comments section Dr Salaria .
He was a daily source of entertainment 😆
Because truth-seeking is legit to human existence, and people are coming awake.
The initial part about data & analytics used during elections is quite true about india. Parties are employing professional poll strategists like Prashant Kishor these days. Poll issues, campaign schedules, interview appearances, seat sharing, caste equations etc need experts.
Prashant kishor is retired 😊
Love arifa g
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience
Yes she is very competent. Although it doesn't make sense recording before election and uploading after. Strange logic...
TPE selection of guests is amazing.
Waiting for Cyril in this podcast.
🙌
Always great to see brilliat women on tpe
🙌
Wow what a clearing of though she had amazing journalist 🫶🏻🫶🏻
🙌
I don't think their are any electoral process, when you don't even respect the manded and say no to a major opposition party
I see the news anchors are always the ones who are most unaware of ground realities
great talk, nusrat javed also his job during the last caretaker government, apparently his name was not on the white list
He lost it during PTIs tenure no?
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou are correct, at the beginning of pit’s tenure, but it started during the caretaker govt and continued after elections
True Banana republic 🙃
Short podcast though.. should've been longer
Please bring ayaz latif palejo on your podcast. He is very great at speaking about rights. Sindhi nationalism, water resources in Pakistan, the feudalism politics in Sindhi. He is son of rasool bux palejo The great sindhi leader and intellectual. Ayaz latif palijo done a big jalsa along with pir pagara in which millions of sindhis participated to protest against election rigging. Ayaz latif palejo is the only Sindhi politician and speaker who is well educated and bears a genius intellect about history and politics. The podcast will be fun. And also it will be very good if you hear all the voices from the country. Also there have been less sindhi people who have came to your podcast. Being sindhi it's your responsibility to give voice and platfrom to your own people.
He contested from Hyderabad PS 60 in GDA party in which he lost to the PPP (jam khan shoro)
*Feudal Politics Bad*
*Doing jalsa with Pir Pagara*
@@muddi900 ?
bhai , sab pata hai is motay ko Iska adha khandan PPP main hai … yeh masoom si shakal bana kr sab ko banata Hai !!!
Tu please ap socho yeh kabhi usko nhe bulaega jo PPP k against bolta .. yeh MOTA BUHT HARAMI Hai 😊😂 ap sab ko bana rha Hai
28.14...
GOOD..REALLY GOOD
It's funny how our politicians still don't have any idea of KPK Politics. The people of KPK, have proven far again, that they are more intelligent voters, and they vote based on performance. I personally don't agree with the politics of Imran Khan, and PTI.
KPK has always been a lab for the Pakistani establishment. Musharaf handed us over to an incompetent governor in the form of Syed Iftikhar Hussain Shah. Then we were handed to two successive tenures of MMA and ANP. All three of these people took the province back in time by years. The corruption, and ill-governance increased multiple folds. PTI, with all its evils, performed a lot better in the province. And that is why, after 15 years of incompetence, the people saw someone that cared about development and social services, and hence the increasing majority of PTI in the province. Bombs, and terrorism, may have played a role, but the people of KPK do not have any sympathy for ANP or MMA, on any scale.
Dawn news was the pioneer in english news media . It had develop a niche following amongst English speakers. Then it went into capitalist mode and became another bhaand urdu channel. Pakistan refuses to promote English media because they are rational. India invests in english so thats why the world listens to them
45:06 today situation
Its been more than 2 weeks since elections are still airing pre election podcast. I know that u have done a lot in these days and done many podcats each day but a lot is missed on situation after elections. Bad timings. Nevertheless this one is good one also
Every problem can be traced to pak army
She is estonishing jurnlist the way she give her option on multiple topics is remarkable.
Election in Pakistan? It selection dude
PTI Changes Parlimetry Potlitcs tell me PTI members you which they win in Punjab
I tell you so many name which consider in "comba" in 2024 and they win
in the city of liya tell me name of PTI winning candidates and check their background.
PTI mouthpiece
Fake neeews 😂
شہزاد بھائی مجھے آپ کا کام بہت اچھا لگتا ہے مگر آپ کا بولنے کا انداز اچھا نہیں ہے۔۔ آپ ایک جملہ اردو میں بولتے ہیں پھر دو جملے انگلش میں ۔۔یہ کوئی اچھا انداز گفتگو نہیں ہے۔۔۔ آپ ایک زبان بول لیں ۔۔ یا اردو یا انگلش، مگر کھچڑی نہ پکایا کریں۔۔ خدا کا واسطہ ہے
39 40 ..?
The LADY SPEAKS OF CONFIDENCE NO CONFIDENCE..IN POLITICAL CIRCLES IE JURNOS..IRONIC ASTRUE OF GUARDIAN , SO FAKE IS RIFE..YA.