Someone from india said on some social media video that during the movie most of the cheers were on the scenes when female characters were treated by ranvijay more than the action scenes.. most females felt bad and uncomfortable watching it .. what else is glorification when people are defending the problematic themes.
That experience of watching the movie (being surrounded by people who have intrinsic misogynist values) might have justified the negative reaction of the people who do not have those values, however Amna watched it by herself and does not have the misogynistic values within her, which is why she did not find those scenes unacceptable.
@@Sana-t5z5gexcept that animals are a million times better they show inter species compassion too, we as humans are often capable of much evil!Look at the violent zionist committing genocide with our western governments and other country’s leaders supporting it, and the ordinary folks against the genocide are demonised! Our endless wars, how we traffic children and women, how we destroy countries by illegal bombings! So the animal title is actually an offence, However, that being said humans too are animals of the mammal variety, so we are the most evil of all animals, and we cannot be compared to other animals !
I am glad you two reviewed animal. I 100% agree with Amna. My respect for her as a journalist has increased all the more . I am so glad that I didn’t see the movie in a theatre. According to me , it was the director’s / maker’s sick mentality which was portrayed. All the points which Amna pointed out , I agree with her. Just bullet pointing .-Too much violence ;unnecessary violence without redemption of any kind .- Glamorising toxic masculinity - betrayal/ infidelity without any consequences -far fetched imagination ( he got badly injured & then recovered fully, got a heart transplant & even then fighting like a super hero ; come on . Spare us please Single handedly killed 100s of people - showing him nude though blurred was unnecessary. Had it been shown in a way that he was disturbed mentally , it would have made sense , but I didn’t get that feeling .I felt it was glorified -Then his opinion about his frequency of being intimate with his wife was very disturbing. How Can someone boast about something so natural or beautiful .again toxic masculinity - rolls Royce matching …plus shaving off his body hair …. - it was too much & unnecessary The director sorry to say is not normal . Ranbir kapoor is a superstar . I am disappointed that he did this movie . He could have argued regarding the end . Why didn’t law enforcing forces didn’t take any action . At least they should have shown that AK & RK used their powers to save themselves . I can go on & on but one last point: The fact that it’s a mega hit , in itself is disturbing. People loved it . I am sure esp men . I agree had RK been shown to be killed or committed suicide or ending in an asylum or some kind of redemption maybe my views about the director’s intentions would have been different. Sorry for a long feedback.
Flm ki story flm k action k sath jaa hi nahi rahi ek bnda jis k andr koi prt b baki nahi bacha..wo 300 bnda maar de raha hai ap Ambani k bety b ho schl gun le ja k chala de or koi b poch nahi raha itni maar dhaar khoon or police hai hi nahi film may Yan in k city may
So just cuz their wasn’t a redemption arc for the character its glorified 😂? And at least they showed how injured he was after the interval fight, unlike all the other action movies where the main character fights and doesn’t even get one scratch lol
Childhood trauma from broken families. Thes flawed characters and film animal teach us how we behave with children and not turn abusive. Mold them well so they flourish with good upbringing.
Aamna.... I have never commented before here.... But EACH AND EVERY WORD of yours was worth a 1000 hugs from me to you. You made fully sense to me ... Hasan.... Thank you for being humble
Guys 12th fail is not larger than life ,the reality of UPSE exam and IITJEE in India itself is much much large. The coaching industries contribute highly in GDP . The competition is for real.There are infinite stories in city of Kota , Mukherjee nagar and old rajendra nagar.
Haha ..almost every time they mention 12th fail I comment watch Aspirations..As Rajender Nagar ke 3 saal personally dekhne ke baad Sandeep Bhaiya is far more real than 12th
Made this comment a month ago in one other review in which you guys briefly discussed Animal. The basic difference between people accepting GOT and not accepting Animal is that GOT is based in a nonfiction world. They have creatures like dragons and whatnot. In that world, everything is allowed. With Animal, it is based in our world, in our reality. The main lead is a human, no matter how demented he is in the head. You can say that he is a bad guy, but there’s no denying that he hasn’t been glamorized or glorified in the movie. When he says shit like “lick my shoes”, and at the end of the movie still survives and stands tall. He is being glamorized. He is shown to be the alpha male with his pack of wolves standing behind his every move. When he kills 200 men with that big gun, the scene is supposed to make the audience go “Wow”! And all of that is clear from the background music that plays whenever he does something like this. The music tells you what the director feels about the character he’s putting on screen. When he cheats on his wife and comes back and tells her to not marry someone else if he dies, the sad arijit Singh song plays, why? Because the intention is to make the viewer sympathize with him. He has been glamorized and glorified. And this does play in the heads of the young teenage boys. They will be influenced by this. Not to forget that our culture already considers “aurat ko joti ki nok pay rakhna”, when your male leads treat their significant others like this and still win in the end, that is glorification. Even if his wife leaves him in the end, Knowing his character he’ll be with another woman pretty soon. I’m so glad that Amna feels so much like this!
Hasan realistically it’s a dangerous situation for any girl if on her engagement a boy comes and talk the way he did in front of her family. No girl in real life will go to such a rude mouth boy,assisted by her brother. It gives the boys very wrong impression about reality and girls. Aamna is right. Also, Hassan, boys like you like this crap is because you guys go together to watch, do halla gulla, have fun with your homies and think wah Kia maza aaya. You stop thinking about the real life repercussions of this. Extremely problematic film!!
Such a sensible review! I think Amna voiced all the viewers who had issues with animal. Hassan liking Animal and have no issues with it says a lot about Pakistani men. Hassan is one of the most educated and exposed man. Honestly my respect for Amna as a journalist has increased after watching this
There was a scene in the movie where Ranbir tells his son I am the director to which his son says, "Papa, aap hero ho". So I feel the direction was clear that he is a macho hero vs Bobby who was shown to be even more evil to ensure that Ranvijay is seen as the "hero" of the movie. Even portraying women as statutes in a movie is anti feminist. Last, even if I leave feminism aside, tell me the screenplay of the film? What is the story? What is the logic? Where is the flow? It was shot well and they had the money for sets. Even the interval action scene was like an English movie Old Boy. Animal was a movie that is only useful for memes.
U didn't find story or logic in film? Then I don't see it properly. Coz we got the story. Also the movie is called animal not hero. And physcho do think they are hero in film. The are making part 2 and they want to show that how father's or family environment influence children same way and make them go wrong way
Thank Goddddd that Amna reviewed the movie!!!!!! I 100% AGREE WITH AMNA! I couldn't watch this movie in one go. I watched it in 3 parts and that too on Netflix and I'm so glad I didn't go to theater to watch this. Amna has pretty much said what I wanted to say! Also, I ALSO AGREE that he should've died in the end to have that good over bad msg - just how SRK has done his negative roles. And you know HASAN why you didn't like dunki and just had negative things to say about it? And I'm not shocked that you liked animal LOL a typical man who enjoyed nudity and violence. 🙄
Young boys are getting influenced by these toxic characters!! Hitting in love is not ok! Extreme love doesn’t mean that you start hitting each other and being disrespectful to each other
Who hit who in animal? And I don’t think a negative character can influence an adult who has their own brain and know the difference between right and wrong
If hassan is so fascinated by the film being so educated and having a good perspective on most things and having been exposed to so much and him overlooking so many things when he watched it in the cinema or even at home then imagine how an ordinary person in South asia with not so much exposure or education feels when they watch danish taimoor or toxic men in dramas maybe they go into that realm of fascination too,i mean that is enough to appeal to their kinks and that is why this is so scary and such toxic garbage stuff shouldn’t be made
Over the past decade or so, the average urban Indian woman has been able to have her voice heard to quite an extent. With the increase of women's education and with economic independence, urban Indian women have come to realize that the men who dominated their lives for centuries are not particularly stronger or better than them. The changing of many of India's laws in favor of women has also helped them. Urban Indian men have had no choice but to accept these changes and pretend to be okay with it. But secretly they are not happy about it. There is a lot of internalized bitterness at their losing what they see as their birthright and their natural place in society. This internalized bitterness and resentment was clearly visible in theaters as urban Indian men thoroughly cheered at scenes where women were being hurt and humiliated by the male stars of the movie.
@@Sana-t5z5g 'Animal' as an adjective means "relating to the physical or sentient as contrasted with the intellectual or rational". This character is exactly that. And yet a very large number of guys felt the need to defend and validate his hateful actions and celebrated the mistreatment of women in the film. It felt like they desperately wished to be like him. That is the problem - when one half of the population celebrates and defends the humiliation and mistreatment of the other half of the population.
It's because most women in india misuse the laws and avoid accountability and responsibility in the name of equality while men still continue to do their part that's the reason why misogyny exists and is growing
Omg I can’t believe it you spoke my heart every thing you said about animal is on point. To be honest this movie is not worth review . I was shocked when I saw Amna is doing the review But I am glad she proved herself as a mature and intelligent critique.❤
I disagree with Amna's perspective that "he should've died." In my opinion, for a character like him, death isn't a punishment. Because we all have to die one day, Instead, living without the love he desperately wanted throughout his life, and causing so much chaos, but still being left with nothing in the end, that’s a bigger punishment.
This review tells you why being well read and experienced is so important. Nailed it Aamna! Hassan who was raving about the film got your point with your first statement. I lost respect for Shahid after I watched Kabir Singh, same with Ranbir Kapoor after this movie, not that I respected him earlier anyway.
Amana, I am so so proud of you and after your analysis of animal my respect for you as a journalist has grown immensely. As for Hasan, I am extremely disappointed in you for liking animal, let alone being obsessed with it. It’s dangerous for people to glorify animal in any shape or form. It is outrageous and Ranveer’s character is a psychopath. It’s extremely problematic to glamorize and glorify such characters because they are disease that you are unleashing in the society. Hasan, defending the movie makes me really uncomfortable because it doesn’t send across a good picture of you Hasan. I would have hoped better from you. I have been watching you since you guys started doing something haute. I hope, Hasan, would reevaluate his thoughts and look deep down in himself and see why he loved animal. For anyone who loves animal, there is something very wrong with them.
Well, everybody seems to have their own take on the story of this movie, and the opinions are quite polarized. But I guess one thing that most of us may agree on is that the music album of this movie is pretty good.
Thank you Amna apa for speaking my mind. Honestly after hearing the first few reviews that came after its release, my anxiety kicked in so hard that I almost skip watching any song or scene that are there on insta or yt because I can't deal with how it will effect my mind after. Not that I am so immature that I can't differentiate between fantasy and real but I can't put myself into a situation where I have to see so much negativity and misogyny and gore in the name of entertainment. And thank god I didn't watch your review I just heard it as an audio because I just can't see the few scenes you shared within this review because I can't compromise on my mental state. Having said that I feel it's sequel will only normalize this and it may not impact people in urban society but it is gonna impact people who are not as intellectually sound just because the selling point of this insane story is a superstar like Ranbir Kapoor who has huge following even in the states of India where such crimes are very normal.
I was asking my husband to leave our kids with my in laws and go to watch this. Unfortunately our local cinema in Oxford wasn’t showing it so I was really disappointed. But after watching it I’m super super glad I didn’t go
@@aali9778 well then u missed a great movie u don't need to influence ur decision just becoz ome women tell some bullshit becoz she didn't like it movie characters based on real life animals characters that's why the movie name got animal not any hero type name
Omg omg amnaaaaa your example in start took my heart 😂❤movie is fascinating but it's impact on people ,society is 👎n most important they are just normalizing cheating on partner..personally I don't like..it has just over hyped movie..yes you can say Bobby deol's acting is good n songs ...
Why does a youtube channel called desitv repost all your videos? If they are licensing your videos, then it makes sense. But if its some other channel stealing your content - interviews / shorts etc., then you should report them.
Totally totally agreed with amna She is fantastic in reviewing she gave great example referring not only to film but also to hasan (why he liked this movie) And movie also got many good scenes but there is no connection with the story
Hello i am from India. I completely agree with Amna❤and i watched Animal recently and i must say it is one of the worst movies ever made...totally misogynist i didn't like at all. The reason why it became superhit is because majority of the middle-class audience likes this kind of stuff...larger than life things.... Personally i couldn't digest the storyline...
more respect for Aamna , the way she review this piece of “art”. It took me 3 days to finish and yes about the 12th fail, which I just found out in in your discussion, I finished in one go and I throughly enjoyed.
My husband and I both hated it , kept hitting forward , the story was ridiculous , the look alikes , the stupid hotel scene , the bad humour , hated it
I am a bit aware of some of the Hollywood movies which have a lot of violence. The difference in my opinion is that there violence or gruesome acts are not glorified. It’s shown as it occurs in the society. In Bollywood it’s different. In the indo pak , masses / public adore the Bollywood heroes& idolise them. Somehow they want to relate themselves to the heroes shown on screen . This is my personal opinion. If someone likes watching violence, it’s their choice. I can’t tolerate it. Especially at these times, when there is already so much lawlessness in the society. Why show stories where the protagonist gets away with killing so many people , even if in self defence with no consequences or intervention by the police. Pehle hi boht decline hy agar Acha message nahin de sakty tou burra kyon diya jaye . Ya tou message hi na do , sIRF entertainment dikayo . Again that’s my personal opinion .
Aamna is spot on about how those who liked the movie it subconsciously played to their inner kinks. It was titillating to the senses! And as Hassan pointed out kinks could be anything like violence, power play, etc.
Oh my God i love and respect Aamna, her review for this movie is just super. I havent watched this movie thank God, never will. She is so right that the man is a savage beast. And hassan enjoyed this movie just because it is larger than life and action packed. Men in him didnt think beyond, although i didnt expect this from him. But aamna you are a brilliant journalist..
Finally, someone who agrees with me! Amna, you nailed it. I cannot agree more. What a garbage and senseless psychopathic movie. Want to add one more thing Ranbhir Kapoor ka ilaaj ussi genius doctor ne Kiya tha jis ne Amar Akbar Anthony main maa ko direct beton ka khoon laga kar Theek kar deeya tha. Otherwise, that miraculous “heart transplant” and that supernatural recovery were impossible!
Oh my gosh... It's hard to overlook the fact that Animal has no story for anyone who identifies as a critic. I've found Hassan to be biased from the beginning, which is why his opinions on dramas and art, in general, lack credibility for me. He just is in love with the Cringe of Bollywood. I'm only watching for Aamna's insightful views. Besides, this whole concept of 'alpha' male is going to attract pseudo alphas. Please watch Anupama Chopra review. One would know how a credible citric sounds like. I hope you don't mind my perspective. If someone can watch Animal twice and express love for it, I too can share my reaction to that. 😅
Such a stupid film!! The hotel scene was so bad!! Made no sense. And Ranbir’s character also made no sense! If he loved and wanted to impress his father, why was he so rude and unhinged!! Why didn’t he have any manners and talked inappropriately around people about sex. And didn’t even like his acting. Cringe fest 🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮
If a man only cared about his alpha male ego trying to impress and revenge just his father but totally ignored feelings of his wife mother and children. He should have rather be a loving Dad to his kids than to shoot a gun in front of his own kids. Vijay was just obsessed trying to prove himself. And there are lots of kids or sons in real world trying to get love from parents but doesn't justify violence to do so. Most people were impressed by the shooting of hundreds of people😮
Guys, I don't think the wife left! The kid came back and she came out of the car! She had sex with him after figuring out that he cheated... i don't know what made you guys think that she left!
Most viewed doesn't mean that people like it... it's just the controversy they built for the film and the discussions which lead to increased intrigue value for people to go and watch it.... there was no story in the film only a son protecting his father ... waste of time.. makers just cashed " BADNAAM HONGAY TO KIA NAAM NA HOGA"
Not only this movie promoted masculine toxicity at its highest but it was also very stupid and illogical. It is baffling to me how a person with even a little logic would or could like a movie like this. It is a kind of movie that if I had even liked, I would have been too ashamed to admit I did. So, my question is how Hassan is able to support this movie so openly? Is he so tone deaf? The only circumstance, in which I think someone can only enjoy this movie is just to laugh at its buffoonery and absurdity.
If you remove the excellent fight scenes and Production values, all you have left with some star plus drama story, body doubles, plastic surgeries, I mean come on! There was everything in movie but story, basic premises was father son relationship, and there was very little exploration of that.
Loved the review. Had the opportunity to see it in the cinemas and honestly, Amna you are spot on! And having seen 12th fail and all back story and bts, waiting for its review too. Loved the parallels you drew with the it throughout and also how you so prominently pointed out in 12th fail it was the story that had the magic.
@28:00 Hassan Ishq Murshid is a feel good romance whereas with Animal there is nothing feel good giddy sort of feelings. Both polar opposites of each other . Also, Game of Thrones was very much criticized for glamorizing rape & violence towards women. ppl actual boycotted the show after certain rape scenes.
It’s name should be PAPA , PAPA . I totally agree with Amna . I don’t know why it is super hit . How can a man with heart transplant become so powerful 😂😂😂 .
There s a guy who has commented why he liked the film and watched it twice. And i actually think thats a perfect explanation. I hope hassan you find that comment. My husband too liked the movie and i have mixed reviews like Amna
Yess. I loved it how honest hassan is. And yaa ppl have enjoyed animal and its finee. Their discussion was so so good. The way they go unfiltered and real. No doubt something haute never disappoints!
100% agree with amna . We ( me and my husband) couldn’t watch in one go too. We both didn’t like the movie , what I feel ranbeer had a plaster face through out the movie .
In India also, Some liberals always have problem about fireworks, playing water during Holi.Ok somewhat I agree about fireworks affects environment or affect animals.Does eating various animals or beef helps environment?
I agree with Amna I didn't find Ranbir's character a good character in animal. It was a bakwas and violent film. Not a good example for generation, from Mumbai, India
I am 💯 agree with Amina's review. I didn't enjoy the movies, but yeah I get fascinated by the movie, but yes I can't watch this movie in the cinema, true this is a good movie, but this is not everyone's cup of tea.
Amna first of all u just nailed it with ur example I totally agree with u ..watch something haute only becoz of u ....my admiration for u increasing day by day
Please don't give importance to indian movies. First of all it's a horrendous film but most importantly they will never give our films and movies any important and never forget how our artists were treated.
I felt like I was watching a cartoon movie. It’s like kids play video games, killing people without any consequences, its ridiculous, very disturbing. Do we want our kids to give the message that you should kill for the love ? Treatment of women is bad in most of the movies anyway.
The movie targeted exactly those people who make sure movie should do stupendous business and by that means i mean men. I was really enjoying the movie when i was watching it. Of course afterwards you know how absurd some of the things were but the emotion i felt was brilliant. I feel there is an animal in all of us especially in men and it exactly tapped into that. It hit that parts of us which Sandeep wanted. Some of the things were actually relate able. I have seen women falling for bad guys and it exactly showed that.
I felt disgusted watching animal to an extent that I started puking because of the bloodshed in the movie, couldn't handle it being faint at heart. I regret watching it
Killing anyone, even be “evil vs evil” is fair? LOL what a justification. Speechless! Totally boycotted this movie way before its release because of the Director. Some people enjoy it, well no comment to them but 100 points to people who get why there are people who can’t even tolerate a glimpse of this horribly made movie. I’m not the target audience of Vanga, never will.
Did I get entertained by the film? Absolutely. Did I agree with what’s being shown? Heck, No! My views on this film are somewhere between Amna’s and Hassan’s - I agree with Hassan that I was completely sunk in the Animal world for those 3.50 hours when was watching it in Cinema, and then again on Netflix. I was mesmerized by the great visuals they created - the larger-than-life scope of the film, and how all hell broke loose - complete disconnection with reality , and bang for buck for cinema-watchers, especially. But, I also agree with Amna - fireworks example - spot on! Glamorized - yes, it was! Glorified? Not at all. He should’ve died in the end; but actually usky father ko cancer/death ka dikhaa ker unhune Ranvijay ko zindaa houtay huay bhi Maar hee diaaa! Also that one iconic scene (from the Trailor) where they swap roles for a mo, I felt like we’ve relived childhood trauma in that one scene - how many of us relate to being ignored, neglected, beaten up (physically), suppressed (emotionally) at the hands of our violent parent (mostly, fathers). That was a real trigger for someone like me, who has not had a very rosy, fairytalish childhood or relationship with her father. I don't mind such stories being told, especially at the level that Vanga created the Animal-verse, but I also feel we as an audience are not ready to take this in its stride, unless we're able to draw a VERY fine line between "entertainment" and "undue influence". I hope no-one gets even a slight hunch that they can actually DO what Ranjvijay did, in their own context and lives - For this scary thought to be coming in my mind, I don't think we're ready yet, to watch this without being influenced! Peace to the world! 💚🟢💚
Loved the review. Totally agree with amna's review. Animal was a movie with no story but a brilliantly executed movie. Please do rocky or rani ki prem kahani review.
36:52 You are saying about "Arjun Vally". My small suggestion is please read or go through the real history of "Arjun Vally" Song which is related to Arjun Singh Nalwa. Kudos to Sandeep Reddy Wanga the way he uses regional songs and various terminologies according to situation.
Given the current political realities in the world, I can't even think about this movie, without drawing some sort of parallels. The protagonist could've been a soldier with an unhealthy obsession with an idea, designing and coming up with new machinery to cause maximum damage. I can't think of this as fantasy. It's reality in some places.
You guys are the only reason I know anything about Pakistani and Indian cinema. Especially sessions like this, where you talk transparently and relentlessly about an absolutely ridiculous piece of shit which became ridiculously famous, restores my faith that some sanity still prevails in the world of digital content consumption.
Love the review but i have a small problem about it both Hassan and Amna are biased towards ranbir and they have watched this movie and didn't had actual problem with the story but they didn't enjoyed srk's jawan , i feel it was far much better than animal.. weather its story line, srk's acting or his cause to society about elections... Afterall jawan was also fantasy type of movie...
Really Loved your conversation about Animal.aap dono nay itna animal animal bola k mein nay movie dekna chahi,Meray bacho nay bar bar bola yay aap k type k movie nahi hai,but Hassan Tu obsessed tha,so mein nay dekhnee thee.buhat mushkil say may nay half say zeyada dekhee.pher Meri bs ho gaii.amana nay 💯 teek review keya.aur Hassan is like my kids.i think yay generational gap hai.
Hi Amna and Hassan, I have been noticing your audio output in volume is generally low, ads in between have higher audio frequency. Can you please increase it in your future uploads. I need to keep it 50+ volume in laptop not sure its the same for everyone else?
Am I the ONLY one who watches cinema PURELY as cinema, and not get so influenced by it? Animal, for me, was an entertaining watch therefore I enjoyed the film. Do I like Ranvijay or want a man like him in my life? No. Will I go out killing people because Ranvijay did so> No. It was just a good film. Why are we intellectualizing films so much? If someone watches a violent film and gets inspired from it to an extent that he/she starts embodying the negative aspects of the fictional characters in the movie, problem lies WITH THE PERSON and not the film.
Hassan is hell bent on taking out each and every positive point of the film from aamna just to satisfy himself. Dude even a kachra film has some positive points in it (which animal is btw)
Someone from india said on some social media video that during the movie most of the cheers were on the scenes when female characters were treated by ranvijay more than the action scenes.. most females felt bad and uncomfortable watching it .. what else is glorification when people are defending the problematic themes.
That experience of watching the movie (being surrounded by people who have intrinsic misogynist values) might have justified the negative reaction of the people who do not have those values, however Amna watched it by herself and does not have the misogynistic values within her, which is why she did not find those scenes unacceptable.
@@Sana-t5z5gexcept that animals are a million times better they show inter species compassion too, we as humans are often capable of much evil!Look at the violent zionist committing genocide with our western governments and other country’s leaders supporting it, and the ordinary folks against the genocide are demonised! Our endless wars, how we traffic children and women, how we destroy countries by illegal bombings! So the animal title is actually an offence, However, that being said humans too are animals of the mammal variety, so we are the most evil of all animals, and we cannot be compared to other animals !
১
১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১১
Rubbish the whole movie was enjoyed and cheered just like all movies coz people are going for entertainment. Learn diff between reel and real
Aamna restored my faith in the first few mins ❤
This was such a good conversation. Great questions and bang on answers.
I am glad you two reviewed animal. I 100% agree with Amna. My respect for her as a journalist has increased all the more .
I am so glad that I didn’t see the movie in a theatre. According to me , it was the director’s / maker’s sick mentality which was portrayed. All the points which Amna pointed out , I agree with her.
Just bullet pointing
.-Too much violence ;unnecessary violence without redemption of any kind
.- Glamorising toxic masculinity
- betrayal/ infidelity without any consequences
-far fetched imagination ( he got badly injured & then recovered fully, got a heart transplant & even then fighting like a super hero ; come on . Spare us please
Single handedly killed 100s of people
- showing him nude though blurred was unnecessary.
Had it been shown in a way that he was disturbed mentally , it would have made sense , but I didn’t get that feeling .I felt it was glorified
-Then his opinion about his frequency of being intimate with his wife was very disturbing. How
Can someone boast about something so natural or beautiful .again toxic masculinity
- rolls Royce matching …plus shaving off his body hair ….
- it was too much & unnecessary
The director sorry to say is not normal .
Ranbir kapoor is a superstar . I am disappointed that he did this movie . He could have argued regarding the end .
Why didn’t law enforcing forces didn’t take any action . At least they should have shown that AK & RK used their powers to save themselves . I can go on & on but one last point:
The fact that it’s a mega hit , in itself is disturbing. People loved it . I am sure esp men . I agree had RK been shown to be killed or committed suicide or ending in an asylum or some kind of redemption maybe my views about the director’s intentions would have been different. Sorry for a long feedback.
Absolutely agree 👍 with you 💯. You summarized it perfectly.
Very well written, completely agree with you.
I totally agreed..ye sabi points hum sab ko nazar aty hain to jo log is flm k fns hain wo kya dekh k khush hain is flm may
Flm ki story flm k action k sath jaa hi nahi rahi ek bnda jis k andr koi prt b baki nahi bacha..wo 300 bnda maar de raha hai ap Ambani k bety b ho schl gun le ja k chala de or koi b poch nahi raha itni maar dhaar khoon or police hai hi nahi film may Yan in k city may
So just cuz their wasn’t a redemption arc for the character its glorified 😂? And at least they showed how injured he was after the interval fight, unlike all the other action movies where the main character fights and doesn’t even get one scratch lol
Mentally unstable for Ranvijay is an understatement. I think Ranvijay and Abrar are psychopaths.
Or we can say they are literally animals
Yes the title of the movies is for them.
Childhood trauma from broken families. Thes flawed characters and film animal teach us how we behave with children and not turn abusive. Mold them well so they flourish with good upbringing.
That's y the movie name is Animal 🤦
Aamna.... I have never commented before here.... But EACH AND EVERY WORD of yours was worth a 1000 hugs from me to you. You made fully sense to me ...
Hasan.... Thank you for being humble
Guys 12th fail is not larger than life ,the reality of UPSE exam and IITJEE in India itself is much much large. The coaching industries contribute highly in GDP . The competition is for real.There are infinite stories in city of Kota , Mukherjee nagar and old rajendra nagar.
Haha ..almost every time they mention 12th fail I comment watch Aspirations..As Rajender Nagar ke 3 saal personally dekhne ke baad Sandeep Bhaiya is far more real than 12th
@@fashionstationindia I think it's aspirants
@@ArunKumar-vd9kw sorry ..Typo..indeed the entire universe ..Kota Factory included ..
Yes it’s actually true! Lakhs of aspirants take the exam and the success % is very low !! People invest years of their life to become a civil servant
Amna nailed it. Nevertheless Hassan too is so humble and honest about his own views. You two make a great pair.
Yes you are absolutely right. Hasan is so honest about his experience and at same time he is agreeing with amna... so nice to see that
Made this comment a month ago in one other review in which you guys briefly discussed Animal. The basic difference between people accepting GOT and not accepting Animal is that GOT is based in a nonfiction world. They have creatures like dragons and whatnot. In that world, everything is allowed.
With Animal, it is based in our world, in our reality. The main lead is a human, no matter how demented he is in the head. You can say that he is a bad guy, but there’s no denying that he hasn’t been glamorized or glorified in the movie. When he says shit like “lick my shoes”, and at the end of the movie still survives and stands tall. He is being glamorized. He is shown to be the alpha male with his pack of wolves standing behind his every move. When he kills 200 men with that big gun, the scene is supposed to make the audience go “Wow”! And all of that is clear from the background music that plays whenever he does something like this. The music tells you what the director feels about the character he’s putting on screen. When he cheats on his wife and comes back and tells her to not marry someone else if he dies, the sad arijit Singh song plays, why? Because the intention is to make the viewer sympathize with him. He has been glamorized and glorified. And this does play in the heads of the young teenage boys. They will be influenced by this. Not to forget that our culture already considers “aurat ko joti ki nok pay rakhna”, when your male leads treat their significant others like this and still win in the end, that is glorification. Even if his wife leaves him in the end, Knowing his character he’ll be with another woman pretty soon. I’m so glad that Amna feels so much like this!
💯💯💯
I was waiting for Aamna's review and SHE SPOKE MY MIND! 🙌
the portrayal of women in animal is just so unrealistic and annoying 🤦
For india it is not unrealistic it's not Pakistan
Hasan realistically it’s a dangerous situation for any girl if on her engagement a boy comes and talk the way he did in front of her family. No girl in real life will go to such a rude mouth boy,assisted by her brother. It gives the boys very wrong impression about reality and girls. Aamna is right. Also, Hassan, boys like you like this crap is because you guys go together to watch, do halla gulla, have fun with your homies and think wah Kia maza aaya. You stop thinking about the real life repercussions of this. Extremely problematic film!!
That's y she leaves him at the end .. don't know y u guys gettin offended with the Film
Such a sensible review! I think Amna voiced all the viewers who had issues with animal. Hassan liking Animal and have no issues with it says a lot about Pakistani men. Hassan is one of the most educated and exposed man. Honestly my respect for Amna as a journalist has increased after watching this
Are you deaf or something?
Look at Hassan jisse Pak dramas k toxic hero k naam pe feminism yaad aata hai woh Ranvijay ko justify kr rha hai such double standards
Agreed
Becoz Pakistani dramas gloryify it and call them hero. While in this film they are called animal, criminal Gunda not hero
Love Amna’s take on the movie. Poor Hasan was just sitting there agreeing with her and doubting his own like for the movie…
U guys are the best
I like Hasan's honesty
This movie does not deserve to be reviewed or even viewed.
it was pure garbage
Take movies as movies man, and if you don’t want to watch it then don’t, no one is forcing you
💯 agreed
Totally!!
EXACTLY
There was a scene in the movie where Ranbir tells his son I am the director to which his son says, "Papa, aap hero ho". So I feel the direction was clear that he is a macho hero vs Bobby who was shown to be even more evil to ensure that Ranvijay is seen as the "hero" of the movie. Even portraying women as statutes in a movie is anti feminist. Last, even if I leave feminism aside, tell me the screenplay of the film? What is the story? What is the logic? Where is the flow? It was shot well and they had the money for sets. Even the interval action scene was like an English movie Old Boy. Animal was a movie that is only useful for memes.
U didn't find story or logic in film? Then I don't see it properly. Coz we got the story. Also the movie is called animal not hero. And physcho do think they are hero in film. The are making part 2 and they want to show that how father's or family environment influence children same way and make them go wrong way
Why is Hassan so amazed with Ranvijay's name reveal? This was in so many Telugu Tamil films we saw 15 years ago. Lol
Thank Goddddd that Amna reviewed the movie!!!!!! I 100% AGREE WITH AMNA! I couldn't watch this movie in one go. I watched it in 3 parts and that too on Netflix and I'm so glad I didn't go to theater to watch this. Amna has pretty much said what I wanted to say! Also, I ALSO AGREE that he should've died in the end to have that good over bad msg - just how SRK has done his negative roles.
And you know HASAN why you didn't like dunki and just had negative things to say about it? And I'm not shocked that you liked animal LOL a typical man who enjoyed nudity and violence. 🙄
They're planning for a squeal, there's no way they'd have killed him
Calling out hassan 😂🤝
If you didn't find it interesting enough then you wouldn't even have completed. Animal was gigantic hit for a reason.
Lol judging men for their preferences that's why animal is hit liberals feminists cry about it
Young boys are getting influenced by these toxic characters!! Hitting in love is not ok! Extreme love doesn’t mean that you start hitting each other and being disrespectful to each other
Who hit who in animal? And I don’t think a negative character can influence an adult who has their own brain and know the difference between right and wrong
Are movie is called animal not hero to be inspired
If hassan is so fascinated by the film being so educated and having a good perspective on most things and having been exposed to so much and him overlooking so many things when he watched it in the cinema or even at home then imagine how an ordinary person in South asia with not so much exposure or education feels when they watch danish taimoor or toxic men in dramas maybe they go into that realm of fascination too,i mean that is enough to appeal to their kinks and that is why this is so scary and such toxic garbage stuff shouldn’t be made
Pakistani dramas gloryify it and call them hero. While in this film they are called animal, criminal Gunda not hero
@@IceCube-zb5mmranvijay was heavily glorified too
@@AmyP-zn9dzso what when toxic women characters are celebrated in the name of feminism why not the other way around
As you're doing Beyond Borders - Abdullahpur ka Devdas is releasing on 26 Feb 2024 on Zee5/Zindagi
Is it really with Bilal?
@@anuvaid6457 yes
@@anuvaid6457 yes, Bilal has shared snippets on Instagram
Over the past decade or so, the average urban Indian woman has been able to have her voice heard to quite an extent. With the increase of women's education and with economic independence, urban Indian women have come to realize that the men who dominated their lives for centuries are not particularly stronger or better than them. The changing of many of India's laws in favor of women has also helped them.
Urban Indian men have had no choice but to accept these changes and pretend to be okay with it. But secretly they are not happy about it. There is a lot of internalized bitterness at their losing what they see as their birthright and their natural place in society. This internalized bitterness and resentment was clearly visible in theaters as urban Indian men thoroughly cheered at scenes where women were being hurt and humiliated by the male stars of the movie.
@@Sana-t5z5g 'Animal' as an adjective means "relating to the physical or sentient as contrasted with the intellectual or rational". This character is exactly that. And yet a very large number of guys felt the need to defend and validate his hateful actions and celebrated the mistreatment of women in the film. It felt like they desperately wished to be like him. That is the problem - when one half of the population celebrates and defends the humiliation and mistreatment of the other half of the population.
It's because most women in india misuse the laws and avoid accountability and responsibility in the name of equality while men still continue to do their part that's the reason why misogyny exists and is growing
Omg I can’t believe it you spoke my heart every thing you said about animal is on point. To be honest this movie is not worth review . I was shocked when I saw Amna is doing the review But I am glad she proved herself as a mature and intelligent critique.❤
I disagree with Amna's perspective that "he should've died." In my opinion, for a character like him, death isn't a punishment. Because we all have to die one day, Instead, living without the love he desperately wanted throughout his life, and causing so much chaos, but still being left with nothing in the end, that’s a bigger punishment.
This review tells you why being well read and experienced is so important. Nailed it Aamna! Hassan who was raving about the film got your point with your first statement. I lost respect for Shahid after I watched Kabir Singh, same with Ranbir Kapoor after this movie, not that I respected him earlier anyway.
And I lost respect for feminism
Oh, I just loved Amna"s review 💯👍🙏, 🌹 superb review once again, ... you read my thoughts ❤
I don't like to watch any Hassan's review without Amna....
Me too
Amana, I am so so proud of you and after your analysis of animal my respect for you as a journalist has grown immensely. As for Hasan, I am extremely disappointed in you for liking animal, let alone being obsessed with it. It’s dangerous for people to glorify animal in any shape or form. It is outrageous and Ranveer’s character is a psychopath. It’s extremely problematic to glamorize and glorify such characters because they are disease that you are unleashing in the society. Hasan, defending the movie makes me really uncomfortable because it doesn’t send across a good picture of you Hasan. I would have hoped better from you. I have been watching you since you guys started doing something haute. I hope, Hasan, would reevaluate his thoughts and look deep down in himself and see why he loved animal. For anyone who loves animal, there is something very wrong with them.
Totally agreed
Well, everybody seems to have their own take on the story of this movie, and the opinions are quite polarized. But I guess one thing that most of us may agree on is that the music album of this movie is pretty good.
Hy have u seen it? If Ya Whats yr opinion ?!
@@nusalam8171 I saw it at the theater, and sitting through it for over 3 hrs was tough. Performances were good, and that's about it.
Finally! Someone said it.. Animal is heavily influenced by Kill Bill. Thank you Amna ❤
Thank you Amna apa for speaking my mind. Honestly after hearing the first few reviews that came after its release, my anxiety kicked in so hard that I almost skip watching any song or scene that are there on insta or yt because I can't deal with how it will effect my mind after. Not that I am so immature that I can't differentiate between fantasy and real but I can't put myself into a situation where I have to see so much negativity and misogyny and gore in the name of entertainment. And thank god I didn't watch your review I just heard it as an audio because I just can't see the few scenes you shared within this review because I can't compromise on my mental state. Having said that I feel it's sequel will only normalize this and it may not impact people in urban society but it is gonna impact people who are not as intellectually sound just because the selling point of this insane story is a superstar like Ranbir Kapoor who has huge following even in the states of India where such crimes are very normal.
I was asking my husband to leave our kids with my in laws and go to watch this. Unfortunately our local cinema in Oxford wasn’t showing it so I was really disappointed. But after watching it I’m super super glad I didn’t go
@@aali9778 well then u missed a great movie u don't need to influence ur decision just becoz ome women tell some bullshit becoz she didn't like it movie characters based on real life animals characters that's why the movie name got animal not any hero type name
@@gameruleworld.1889 no I meant I watched it on Netflix but I was not worth the hype at all.
Oh boy sanity prevails!!! Thanks Amna.
Omg omg amnaaaaa your example in start took my heart 😂❤movie is fascinating but it's impact on people ,society is 👎n most important they are just normalizing cheating on partner..personally I don't like..it has just over hyped movie..yes you can say Bobby deol's acting is good n songs ...
Why does a youtube channel called desitv repost all your videos? If they are licensing your videos, then it makes sense. But if its some other channel stealing your content - interviews / shorts etc., then you should report them.
it's their channel only I think
Totally totally agreed with amna
She is fantastic in reviewing she gave great example referring not only to film but also to hasan (why he liked this movie)
And movie also got many good scenes but there is no connection with the story
Hello i am from India. I completely agree with Amna❤and i watched Animal recently and i must say it is one of the worst movies ever made...totally misogynist i didn't like at all. The reason why it became superhit is because majority of the middle-class audience likes this kind of stuff...larger than life things.... Personally i couldn't digest the storyline...
more respect for Aamna , the way she review this piece of “art”. It took me 3 days to finish and yes about the 12th fail, which I just found out in in your discussion, I finished in one go and I throughly enjoyed.
My husband and I both hated it , kept hitting forward , the story was ridiculous , the look alikes , the stupid hotel scene , the bad humour , hated it
Well animal is not for feminist and kids😂
I am a bit aware of some of the Hollywood movies which have a lot of violence. The difference in my opinion is that there violence or gruesome acts are not glorified. It’s shown as it occurs in the society. In Bollywood it’s different. In the indo pak , masses / public adore the Bollywood heroes& idolise them. Somehow they want to relate themselves to the heroes shown on screen . This is my personal opinion. If someone likes watching violence, it’s their choice. I can’t tolerate it. Especially at these times, when there is already so much lawlessness in the society. Why show stories where the protagonist gets away with killing so many people , even if in self defence with no consequences or intervention by the police. Pehle hi boht decline hy agar Acha message nahin de sakty tou burra kyon diya jaye . Ya tou message hi na do , sIRF entertainment dikayo . Again that’s my personal opinion .
Aamna is spot on about how those who liked the movie it subconsciously played to their inner kinks. It was titillating to the senses! And as Hassan pointed out kinks could be anything like violence, power play, etc.
Oh my God i love and respect Aamna, her review for this movie is just super. I havent watched this movie thank God, never will. She is so right that the man is a savage beast. And hassan enjoyed this movie just because it is larger than life and action packed. Men in him didnt think beyond, although i didnt expect this from him. But aamna you are a brilliant journalist..
Finally, someone who agrees with me! Amna, you nailed it. I cannot agree more. What a garbage and senseless psychopathic movie.
Want to add one more thing Ranbhir Kapoor ka ilaaj ussi genius doctor ne Kiya tha jis ne Amar Akbar Anthony main maa ko direct beton ka khoon laga kar Theek kar deeya tha. Otherwise, that miraculous “heart transplant” and that supernatural recovery were impossible!
Oh my gosh...
It's hard to overlook the fact that Animal has no story for anyone who identifies as a critic. I've found Hassan to be biased from the beginning, which is why his opinions on dramas and art, in general, lack credibility for me. He just is in love with the Cringe of Bollywood.
I'm only watching for Aamna's insightful views. Besides, this whole concept of 'alpha' male is going to attract pseudo alphas.
Please watch Anupama Chopra review. One would know how a credible citric sounds like.
I hope you don't mind my perspective. If someone can watch Animal twice and express love for it, I too can share my reaction to that.
😅
Such a stupid film!! The hotel scene was so bad!! Made no sense. And Ranbir’s character also made no sense! If he loved and wanted to impress his father, why was he so rude and unhinged!! Why didn’t he have any manners and talked inappropriately around people about sex. And didn’t even like his acting. Cringe fest 🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮
Totally agree with amna. ❤
If a man only cared about his alpha male ego trying to impress and revenge just his father but totally ignored feelings of his wife mother and children. He should have rather be a loving Dad to his kids than to shoot a gun in front of his own kids. Vijay was just obsessed trying to prove himself. And there are lots of kids or sons in real world trying to get love from parents but doesn't justify violence to do so. Most people were impressed by the shooting of hundreds of people😮
Guys, I don't think the wife left! The kid came back and she came out of the car! She had sex with him after figuring out that he cheated... i don't know what made you guys think that she left!
Most viewed doesn't mean that people like it... it's just the controversy they built for the film and the discussions which lead to increased intrigue value for people to go and watch it.... there was no story in the film only a son protecting his father ... waste of time.. makers just cashed " BADNAAM HONGAY TO KIA NAAM NA HOGA"
Speak for yourself. Maybe in Pakistan they didn't enjoyed it.
Most of us loved it here in India 😂
Not only this movie promoted masculine toxicity at its highest but it was also very stupid and illogical. It is baffling to me how a person with even a little logic would or could like a movie like this. It is a kind of movie that if I had even liked, I would have been too ashamed to admit I did. So, my question is how Hassan is able to support this movie so openly? Is he so tone deaf? The only circumstance, in which I think someone can only enjoy this movie is just to laugh at its buffoonery and absurdity.
Hassan was really passive in this discussion. He should have asserted his views more.
If you remove the excellent fight scenes and Production values, all you have left with some star plus drama story, body doubles, plastic surgeries, I mean come on! There was everything in movie but story, basic premises was father son relationship, and there was very little exploration of that.
Animal was one of the worst movies ever Im honestly judging hassan for his taste
Thank you, Amna, for saying what you said.
Amna is just GOAT.
I really like the examples
aamna, darya ko koozay mein band kar dia aap ne. 😂
completely agree with your review.
I totally agree with Amna mam..she explained everything so well
Loved the review. Had the opportunity to see it in the cinemas and honestly, Amna you are spot on! And having seen 12th fail and all back story and bts, waiting for its review too. Loved the parallels you drew with the it throughout and also how you so prominently pointed out in 12th fail it was the story that had the magic.
@28:00 Hassan Ishq Murshid is a feel good romance whereas with Animal there is nothing feel good giddy sort of feelings. Both polar opposites of each other . Also, Game of Thrones was very much criticized for glamorizing rape & violence towards women. ppl actual boycotted the show after certain rape scenes.
Animal was not my cup of tea 😤 story was so horrible and it was all about to put down and insult a woman or human being 😡😡
It’s name should be PAPA , PAPA . I totally agree with Amna . I don’t know why it is super hit . How can a man with heart transplant become so powerful 😂😂😂 .
There s a guy who has commented why he liked the film and watched it twice. And i actually think thats a perfect explanation. I hope hassan you find that comment. My husband too liked the movie and i have mixed reviews like Amna
Yess. I loved it how honest hassan is. And yaa ppl have enjoyed animal and its finee. Their discussion was so so good. The way they go unfiltered and real. No doubt something haute never disappoints!
He went from Scotland to India in a bloodied state, how did he get through border force like that??
He was the richest man in india.so for him anything can be possible .
100% agree with amna . We ( me and my husband) couldn’t watch in one go too. We both didn’t like the movie , what I feel ranbeer had a plaster face through out the movie .
In India also, Some liberals always have problem about fireworks, playing water during Holi.Ok somewhat I agree about fireworks affects environment or affect animals.Does eating various animals or beef helps environment?
Exactly 💯
I agree with Amna I didn't find Ranbir's character a good character in animal. It was a bakwas and violent film. Not a good example for generation, from Mumbai, India
I am 💯 agree with Amina's review. I didn't enjoy the movies, but yeah I get fascinated by the movie, but yes I can't watch this movie in the cinema, true this is a good movie, but this is not everyone's cup of tea.
Amna first of all u just nailed it with ur example I totally agree with u ..watch something haute only becoz of u ....my admiration for u increasing day by day
Please don't give importance to indian movies. First of all it's a horrendous film but most importantly they will never give our films and movies any important and never forget how our artists were treated.
I was waiting to hear Aamna’s perspective, good conversation. I watched on Netflix, was wowed and disgusted at the same time.
In short Women hated this movie and Men loved this movie overall
Aamna, you articulated the progressive desi and female POV very well. ❤
Progressive and Pakistan
I felt like I was watching a cartoon movie. It’s like kids play video games, killing people without any consequences, its ridiculous, very disturbing. Do we want our kids to give the message that you should kill for the love ?
Treatment of women is bad in most of the movies anyway.
19:15 !! Hassan was so accurate and good here
The movie targeted exactly those people who make sure movie should do stupendous business and by that means i mean men. I was really enjoying the movie when i was watching it. Of course afterwards you know how absurd some of the things were but the emotion i felt was brilliant. I feel there is an animal in all of us especially in men and it exactly tapped into that. It hit that parts of us which Sandeep wanted. Some of the things were actually relate able. I have seen women falling for bad guys and it exactly showed that.
As long as people who see the animal in them realize that the animal needs to be suppressed.
Thats a good realization and very honest ,haven’t watched the garbage but ur honesty is refreshing
We all don’t have an animal in us. May be it’s just you.
film was just to give shock value. it was different scenes combined together. no connection between them
I always tell my cousin who too is an eminent journalist Amnaji should be in India too she is gem of a person
To tap the potential of the movies of this region first Pakistan and Bangladesh will have to lift ban on Indian movies.
agree with amna 💯%
I felt disgusted watching animal to an extent that I started puking because of the bloodshed in the movie, couldn't handle it being faint at heart. I regret watching it
hassan must recieve some kind of appreciation from RK for promoting the film💰
Killing anyone, even be “evil vs evil” is fair? LOL what a justification. Speechless! Totally boycotted this movie way before its release because of the Director. Some people enjoy it, well no comment to them but 100 points to people who get why there are people who can’t even tolerate a glimpse of this horribly made movie. I’m not the target audience of Vanga, never will.
Dear Aamna Baji Hassan bhai Abdullahpur ka devdas releasing on 27th Feb in Zee5 /Zindagi Tv. Hope you will review it. Thank you .
Check out Javed Akhthar’s comments on Animal. To the point.
Happy to know Amna's views. I do agree with her 100%.
Loved your review Amna! U were on point while stating the facts ❤❤❤❤
Did I get entertained by the film? Absolutely.
Did I agree with what’s being shown? Heck, No!
My views on this film are somewhere between Amna’s and Hassan’s -
I agree with Hassan that I was completely sunk in the Animal world for those 3.50 hours when was watching it in Cinema, and then again on Netflix.
I was mesmerized by the great visuals they created - the larger-than-life scope of the film, and how all hell broke loose - complete disconnection with reality , and bang for buck for cinema-watchers, especially.
But,
I also agree with Amna - fireworks example - spot on! Glamorized - yes, it was! Glorified? Not at all.
He should’ve died in the end; but actually usky father ko cancer/death ka dikhaa ker unhune Ranvijay ko zindaa houtay huay bhi Maar hee diaaa!
Also that one iconic scene (from the Trailor) where they swap roles for a mo, I felt like we’ve relived childhood trauma in that one scene - how many of us relate to being ignored, neglected, beaten up (physically), suppressed (emotionally) at the hands of our violent parent (mostly, fathers).
That was a real trigger for someone like me, who has not had a very rosy, fairytalish childhood or relationship with her father.
I don't mind such stories being told, especially at the level that Vanga created the Animal-verse, but I also feel we as an audience are not ready to take this in its stride, unless we're able to draw a VERY fine line between "entertainment" and "undue influence". I hope no-one gets even a slight hunch that they can actually DO what Ranjvijay did, in their own context and lives - For this scary thought to be coming in my mind, I don't think we're ready yet, to watch this without being influenced!
Peace to the world!
💚🟢💚
Loved the review. Totally agree with amna's review. Animal was a movie with no story but a brilliantly executed movie.
Please do rocky or rani ki prem kahani review.
36:52 You are saying about "Arjun Vally". My small suggestion is please read or go through the real history of "Arjun Vally" Song which is related to Arjun Singh Nalwa. Kudos to Sandeep Reddy Wanga the way he uses regional songs and various terminologies according to situation.
Given the current political realities in the world, I can't even think about this movie, without drawing some sort of parallels. The protagonist could've been a soldier with an unhealthy obsession with an idea, designing and coming up with new machinery to cause maximum damage. I can't think of this as fantasy. It's reality in some places.
Wonderful review by Aamna! 👏
You guys are the only reason I know anything about Pakistani and Indian cinema. Especially sessions like this, where you talk transparently and relentlessly about an absolutely ridiculous piece of shit which became ridiculously famous, restores my faith that some sanity still prevails in the world of digital content consumption.
Love the review but i have a small problem about it both Hassan and Amna are biased towards ranbir and they have watched this movie and didn't had actual problem with the story but they didn't enjoyed srk's jawan , i feel it was far much better than animal.. weather its story line, srk's acting or his cause to society about elections... Afterall jawan was also fantasy type of movie...
Really Loved your conversation about Animal.aap dono nay itna animal animal bola k mein nay movie dekna chahi,Meray bacho nay bar bar bola yay aap k type k movie nahi hai,but Hassan Tu obsessed tha,so mein nay dekhnee thee.buhat mushkil say may nay half say zeyada dekhee.pher Meri bs ho gaii.amana nay 💯 teek review keya.aur Hassan is like my kids.i think yay generational gap hai.
Thank you amna for your review..
Your points are well deserved.
100% agree with Amna - great production quality and great acting
The problem is story and that is the biggest problem .
Hi Amna and Hassan, I have been noticing your audio output in volume is generally low, ads in between have higher audio frequency. Can you please increase it in your future uploads. I need to keep it 50+ volume in laptop not sure its the same for everyone else?
Am I the ONLY one who watches cinema PURELY as cinema, and not get so influenced by it? Animal, for me, was an entertaining watch therefore I enjoyed the film. Do I like Ranvijay or want a man like him in my life? No. Will I go out killing people because Ranvijay did so> No. It was just a good film. Why are we intellectualizing films so much? If someone watches a violent film and gets inspired from it to an extent that he/she starts embodying the negative aspects of the fictional characters in the movie, problem lies WITH THE PERSON and not the film.
Respect for Amna! Thank you for giving a real review of the movie!
Hassan is hell bent on taking out each and every positive point of the film from aamna just to satisfy himself. Dude even a kachra film has some positive points in it (which animal is btw)
Guys, Abdullahpur ka Devdas series Feb mei aa rahi.. Ost aur teasers aye us par discussion karain aplog please❤