'PM Has Never Been a Student Himself, His Contempt For Them is Not Surprising': Naseeruddin Shah
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2024
- In a detailed interview with The Wire's Sidharth Bhatia, actor Naseeruddin Shah comments on the ongoing anti-CAA-NRC-NPR protests happening in several parts of the country. He says that the rise of India's young against the current dispensation is amazing. 'Even in Bollywood, the young actors and directors have risen against this law', he adds. On the silence of the older and established stars, Shah says that he understands their silence but also wonders how long can they keep their silence going.
Actor Naseeruddin Shah's family has been in the ranks of the Army and served as diplomats and administrators to the Indian government. He tells Sidharth Bhatia that ever since the flaring up of religious politics by the current government, he has become more aware of his Muslim identity and that he thinks is deeply worrying.
On the use of force against students in universities across the country, Shah says that he isn't surprised why the PM has absolute contempt for students' dissent. He says that because the PM has never been a student in a university himself, the lack of compassion or empathy towards them and their cause isn't quite surprising.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/support
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewire.in
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewire.in/
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
It's so good to see people are expressing themselves openly
Ya it's after Modi..
@@murugen1981 🤣🙏
its good that snakes have come out. 😂😂
Sale mar gya
@@bs12984 IT Cell member snakes are coming out IT Cell hole. Above ID is a IT cell id👆
I am a hindu but i am not an andhbhakt. Hats off to you n your thoughts. U are way much better than opportunistic ppl like andhbhakt mr.kher . Hats off to you Mr Nasruddin Shah sir. & the Wire.
You don't have say you are a hindu you are not andhbhakt a majority of hindus are not
Iam a muslim if anybody wants to know. And I agree with Kibe and Kiran K. WE must work hand in hand for the collective progress.
I am hindu shaiv and oppose this kind of idiotic behaviour of nasseruddin...
Andhbhakts are not hindus, brother. They are bloody hindutvavadis. A real hindu will never hate a non-hindu. I, being a proud hindu, stand with my muslim brothers/sisters.
@@clown3055 real who are real hindus and who the hell who says hindu never hate anyone... Ofcourse if any race or religion continously indulge in mrdering and raping of innocent lives it must be hated....what kind of idiotic behaviour is that..
What kinda interview is this? Didn’t ask serious questions like, if he eats Mangos nd how he likes to eat it😂😂
Aman Virk because he is not the pm.😜😜😜
Mr. Sir haha, yeah mean while PM rubbing his own sweat to make his face glow🙈🙈🙈....... hum aise hi fair nd lovely ragedte rahe😂😂😂
@@amanvirk1808 Gawd! You chamchas can't even get a joke.
😅
Harami nassseyydidin to bahot paddha-likkha hai then why he didnt become PM?? Iskki aukkat hi nai hai..!!
“Art is not a mirror to show reality, but art is a hammer to change a soicety.” 👌👌👌
@Kaala Manyar bro..
Plzz scratch ur mind n
Realized... After partition muslim goes to Pakistan ...n those r left, which r lived here ... about 800 years.... Don't be optimistic...n yes V reject CAA on the basis of religion... Because preamble of India says about secularism on the basis of sovereignty of country
....
@Kaala Manyar NO HUMAN ON THIS EARTH IS "ILLEGAL". IT TAKES HUMANITY TO UNDESTAND THIS SIMPLE FACT.
IF a person rejects CAB then the person is against minorities from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan who were people who got stuck during partition. The partition idea maker Iqbal created this new nation basis of religion that is Islam. Most of the Hindus, sikhs and other minorities were the hostage population. Trains stopped around 1950s.
That means present muslims and few hindus dont want the perscuted Minorities.
Preamble of securalism came after 1975 after emergency. This was anti- constitional then.Articles 14 to 21 cannot diminish CAB. refer some of the imminent Advocates
Say for example for you understanding once u remove minorites and put people in CAB. IT becomes persecuted people in islamic countries in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afganistan.
Minorities cannot be challenged.
But others can be challenged example Balouchis are tortured in Pakistan, then it means India is getting in internal matters of Muslim Country. Balochi guys are trying to get assslum but they are been refrained by Indian Government. If you check their history, Maulana Azad refrained Balauchis to be part of India, as he did not consider them that pacca muslims and it seems they very far.
Second people like Taslima Nasreen who can be persecuted in Bangladesh because of her writing - her famous book "Lazza.". India gave her assylum, Muslims organisation gave her fatwah in India. She stays in India but she is Swedish citizen.
So you still think. Persecuted Muslims should be added in Act. Balocuhi and people like Taslima Nazreen. Can the Indian muslims stop giving fatwas.
People from Pakistan origin can still come to India like Adnan Sami, to settle in India it takes 15 to 18 years. U think people like Fawad the actor wants to settle in India. There was a terrorist attack , they do not wanted to even condemn it.
Well Indian and Pakistan meet outside very cordially. That is a fact. And believe me its always food.
This is political ploy. Well the problem is Muslims in India rejects CAB today and in 1940s gave 90% to Muslim league ( in a separate electorate ) to form a separate country.
It is ironic, the muslims who weent to Pakistan now wants to come back. They won't. IF we give assylum to Balouchi, entire the strategy changes.
And if balouchis would be allowed in huge numbers that it means it is war with Pakistan. Refer 1971 East pakistan.
I do not think India wants a full fledged war. But I think India will have to take balochis if iran does not take them.
Remember Tibetan. They have a passport and each year they will renew their stay in India. There is lot to foreign affairs. Balouchi was a Independent country before 1947. Pakistan took it away from them. Only difference after 1962 defence strategy has changed. Pakistan will hit back if balouchis are given assylum.
Full fledged War become evident.
There is danger with a single story.
In short writing a act of a muslim being persecuted in indian act will take a lot of time. Defence strategy will have to be in place to do such thing.
Harami nassseyydidin to bahot paddha-likkga hai then why he didnt become PM?? Iskki aukkat hi nai hai..!!
Arcticle 19 - Abuse of freedom of speech and expression- 1951. THe first amendment of constitution created by Nehru. Nasseruddin shah can taken out with law. These were changes to our fundamental right. When Nehru banned Romesh thaper his journal cross road when nehru was critized in Crossroads. Romesh Thapar went to SC and won the case.
But in a year. Abuse of freedom of speech and expression had been got in our fundamental right as the first amendment in a constitution. 1975 secularism was place in Constitution.
Nasseruddin Shah is an Art , Art for Art for sake
What a knowledgeable person Nashiruddin shah is !!!! Had our PM been as intelligent as he is it could have been really really good .
That would have been great to see.
Mr. Ujjal, you are right, that's why we haven't seen Dr.Manmohan Singh following haters on Twitter or making big claims out of nothing.
@@navreetdhillon6914 I am amazed such good indians really exist who understand what is going on and more than 75% indians are pro CAA.
@@ironheart8690 Because quality education is still very much a privilege. Most people are simply not aware.
@@iemon7722 Basic social education comes from home. If the parents themselves teach hate and bias, no level of education or schooling can change that. And that hate has been cultivated in the minds of parents by the RSS, so that they pass on to their children. They've been constantly working on this for years and years together.
Naseer saheb, as much as a brilliant actor he is, he is equally a beautiful Patriot. And that's unquestionable!
This is a beautiful platform where there's such an amazing conversation of people with conscious ✌️✌️
*Meanwhile on the other side of screen*
Anupam Kher : Bas. Dosti bani rahe.
😂
like leader like chamcha dont you know this ?
What a pleasure to watch this interview! Such intelligence and wonderful mastery of language. The current leaders dont have even half his ability to converse on global platforms. Thanks for giving voice to our concerns fearlessly.
Hi please contact me please. +601151709463 Malaysia
Beautiful, interesting, captivating and intellectual reply by Nasaruddin Sir. My respect for him.
Its nice to see Mr.Naseeruddin Shah coming forward and speaking his mind....we need idols like u.
its nice that snakes have come out 😂
@@bs12984 IT Cell member snakes are coming out IT Cell hole. Above ID is a IT cell id👆
@@bs12984 2 rupayee kama liye tune....desh ko bech ke
@@gurmitsingh8735 invite aa gaya hoga isis ka apne mail par. go and check 😅😅
@@bs12984 tu bhi jayga?
"I am not anxious, I am angry".. what a thought..
Harami nassseyydidin to bahot paddha-likkga hai then why he didnt become PM?? Iskki aukkat hi nai hai..!!
@@tvaits802 kyunki unhone ek khaum ke against kisiko bhadkake dange nai karwaye islie
@@MD-mi3nl dange kis ne karvaye??
He watches tooo much congress paid media
His tongue has become taller then his height
Great
human , artiste, intellectual, & brave Personality.
India needs more of such individuals.
I am glad that people like Mr. Naseeruddin is speaking up. More should do that.
And I'm glad our elder generations are acknowledging us ♥️✊🏻
i am glad that snakes are coming out. remaining ones should too 😀😃😂
@@bs12984 Snakes are better than y'all tho.
@@mohammadkamilakbar9605 y'all?? 😂😂😂 jihadis are improvising 😛😜🤪😂😂
Mohammad Kamil Akbar comprehend, douchebag, blot???
Ye sab school se sikha ya madrase mein? 🤣
Sirji thanks for speaking up front and open.
"Perfectly voiced", the way in which the whole scenario has been summarised by you Naseer sir is commendable. Really appreciate your comment on being angry but not scared. We stand with you!
Interview in English
No BJP goons commenting
Ever wonder why🤔
Angrezi smjh nhi aati na unko.... 😉
Might be BJP is not as frustrated like him
BECAUSE U R HALALA PRODUCT
Comment from BJP goon.
Nasoor Ud Din is a DRUG ADDICT.
I give 100% Discount for whatever he excretes from his mouth.
The Poor chap is so frustrated. I feel pity for him.
Tumhara Baap hai Modi...Ab Bhagwa hi Bhawga hai. ... Tan air man mein! Jai Hind!
Can a person who never pursued ever any intellectual pursuits or has been a regular student, teach students how to write exams, without ever caring for unemployed or educationists
I saw that in near kirna store and both shopkeeper and me telling each kya fekta hai...i was laughing laudly.. 1st time in last 3 year i saw godi media
Yes he is a kind of a clown with fascist tendencies.....
Govt put the students on road and remind the exams if the govt is keen for the students why not withdrawn the act very simple
8
Amar Pahuja. how about Asad uddin owaisi?
I certainly agree with Mr nasaruddinji who is quite educated wise respectable personalities.
😂😂
@@bs12984 IT Cell member snakes are coming out IT Cell hole. Above ID is a IT cell id👆
@@TheClinchMagazine my foot
@@kadarsakarwala4473 IT Cell member snakes are coming out IT Cell hole. Above ID is a IT cell id👆
@CHANDER CHOORAN UNCLE
Mr. Shah is really intelligent. High respect for a legend like him. Salute to you sir. Jai Hind.
Which shah u r talking about is it our chikara bhai amit Shah or naseer sir🤣🤣🤣
@@shilpamaharshi383 of course Naseer Sir.. I am not a fool to find intellect in goons.. hahaha..
No chance...! Chronology samajh gaye h....
@@shilpamaharshi383 wo chronology samjhaanewala khud hi confused hai.. Shilpa.. don't know aage Kya hoga.. our country is going through very tough time these days..
@@789mannu1 yes, unfortunately....! But people like u,me and all others young generation are much more sincere mature and SUPPORTIVE then some influence people... That's what our country required in the current scenario..... We gotta do with a collective support and for long🙏🙏🙏💪💪💪💪UNITED WE STAND DIVIDED WE FALL💪💪
When he speaks, I listen. It's worth it...
His tongue has become taller then his height
Congress Was Formed by British District Magistrate, Allan Octavian Hume on 28-12-1885, the pupose to form congress party was To Stop Anti British Moments, So That 1 More Revolution Like 1857 Shall No Repeat. Congress Had No Agenda to FREE INDIA all the letters between congress and British were for dominion status only. When Subash chandra bose talked about fighting the British both Nehru and Gandhi fired Subash chandra bose from the president position of congress party and dismissed him from the party. Congress party is full of british loyalist maharajas like Maharaja of Scindhiya .... Also after that British done one more step in 1906 they created the Muslim league its charter was loyalty to the british crown. So dont teach us British history and provide us British political agenda.
Just like in India Congress party is attacking BJP using urban naxals and JNU in USA, the Democrats Hillary Clinton group is attacking Republican and trump. This is new age of intolerant opposition who use organiZed groups for street rioting. By the way Hillary Clinton - Sonia - Pakistani army/ISI - arabs-global media-ndtv are one team.
When ISIS raises one finger they mean all muslims are one, when you talk about RSS it means all hindus without exception.
No muslims ever mentioned till date what good congress did for muslims but they always ask Modi what he done for muslims. They ask Modi for accountability for Gujarat riots but why the same muslims dont ask Lieutenant General Zameer Uddin Shah accountability for Gujarat riots when he was directly responsible for law and order during the riots. He is same man who was incharge of army to control 2002 gujarat riots ...he never said anything against modi for gujarat riots.
Tell me why muslims dont call General Zameer Uddin Shah butcher of Gujarat.
Kyu ki fake media ki post karne ki aadat hai real fact explore karna nahi hai.
@@rjhaveri8bh good job you earned your 8 rupees for your 4 comment mr BJP IT cell troll. keep up the good work modi ne kuch logon ko toh employment diya hai bhale woh 2 crores per jobs na diye hon tumhe toh nafrat phaylaane ka job milgaya tum dil laga ke karo jam ke karo jab tak tumhaari pichwaade pe laat na padhe.
Naseer is a gutsy, courageous person. A prominent citizen who has excelled in his professional life and has his heart in the right place.
Its rare to hear the celebrity speak out so candidly, frankly and openly. Hats of to the great artist and a fine human being Mr Naseeruddin Shah for being so fearless and truthful. Wish others in Bollywood show one tenth of the courage as Naseer does.
He is lieng and spreading fake news.........
It's rare for a celebrity to lie so much in a drunken tone in one single video. That much I'll give u.
@@sr-gu8bt and he is spreading fake news aswell
Abey ye jehadi suar hai
I like the style of the interviewer, who is letting the guest speak not like others who cuts them and talk themselves. Brave
@Vigilant Mind Like Modi and Shah's interviews right?
That's Arnab Goswami lol 😂
When a person speaks truth it is not digestible and acceptable to everyone and then they shout, rest people knows.salute to Naseer saheb
Very candid and fearless discourse. Kudos to him.
Wish others in the film industry who have got every thing they wanted and have spent most part of life should have spoken instead of keep selling oil and cement and building toilets.
Thank you Naseer Saab for expressing your thoughts. Strangely it felt warm , in this hostile environment , to see such a heartfelt interview
I could listen to him speak all day. His voice is incredible.
Listen to Sonu nigam instead.
GENTLEMAN WITH CLEAR SIMPLE MIND!,
Nassuridin is reflecting very truely and candidly.
Mughals were very good rulers they were great rulers
They were very good bcoz they killed 10crore Hindus $ destroyed lakhs of temples $ kulbir Singh's ancestors were burnt alive, so he is having that fear even today
@@bhattatewar9590 gau mutra kum piya kar, saste nashe mein Modi ki tarah behki behki baat kar raha hai? La de link is figure ka jo tune diya hai?
10 crore Hindus?
@Subrata Shil if India can have a Chai wala as a PM and Tadipaar as a fucking Home Minister then yes anyone can be a PM. If India can have a Muslim President then yes it can have a Muslim PM too. Do no assume with your tiny shitty brain just because your world runs with WhatsApp.
What kind of a name is Subrata? Your name sounds like a low life, scumbag blood😂😂😂
@Subrata Shil modi is leading India towards further partition...
Hindu will go to Nepal....
It's not fair to through you in Sea.....
I too share the anger. Evil laws must be opposed, evil governments must be toppled.
It's very Nice of Mr Nassurddin sha speak in openly and clearly against in depth reality of the present situation of the country..
I personaly want to Thank him such good interview.
Tu rohingya se apni behan ka nikah kara de aur jija bana le rohingya ko apne ghar pe rakh le rohingya ko
Given every govt. to rule India has been evil, disastrous, murdererous and failing to bring peace and or progress. Amazing how stupid hope keeps the generations going ... Who's next? Which bad leader with bad ideas are you going to choose India?
RAVI KUMAR Women have a right to make their own choices. I will not dignify your cheap comment.
Audio Pervert Making sweeping generalizations does not solve any issue. All governments have done some good deeds and failed in many. However, this one government has systematically worked on failing the economy, destroying the PSUs, creating unemployment and dividing the social fabric. Which leader? Nature hates a vacuum, leadership will emerge.
Great job naseerji.....hope that big b and all other superstars portray a fraction of their reel heroism in REAL LIFE
Eye opening.... rightly said..
Very well said by Nasrudin shah
Wish the elected PM understood 10% of what he spoke.
@@sumasuma5572 very true. And PM very well understands what is the current situation of India due to his reforms and bill but his ego forcing people to adopt his bullshit ideology and trying to prove he is right.
If a person is unaware we can make him understand but one who pretends to be unaware then its impossible. The same is going on in India what has drastically damaged Indian economy.......
Beauty of Indian democracy is people can express openly.
Hahahahah joke of the day 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@Pichkalu Pappita Please Allah.. give him some knowledge.. May Allah bless you....
@Pichkalu Pappita is it really possible or u just say?
@Pichkalu Pappita have u ever read any book on Muhammad (p.b.u.h)? Atleast read something about his life and then comment...
A big salute to you, can’t believe the goid media has picked up only one word “Clown” from this 30 mts interview
@Kaala Manyar Priorities are what need to be sorted. Education, healthcare, economy and access to basic living conditions should be the prime target of the govt. After all those needs are met, then we could move onto such agendas.
@Kaala Manyar They've been here since 50 60 years. What's soo urgent all of a sudden that overlooking the more important topics became so necessary? Fix schools hospitals economic downfalls and then make statues temples CAA NRC and everything that you fantasize about under constitutional bounds.
@Kaala Manyar There are illegal Hindus as well for your kind information as the Assam NRC showed. Anyway, illegal migration should be stopped at the borders, it's almost impossible to identify after migration as getting fake papers is very easy in India..so NRC is a futile exercise right now.
@Kaala Manyar Lol keep telling yourself that if that's what turns you on
@Kaala Manyar 👌
Thank you. You’ve also spoken for us who have been drowned by strident voices.
I admire Nasirudheen for he is so clear and fact exposer. I salute him. Dare to say what is wrong activities applied by the ruling party.
No muslims ever mentioned till date what good congress did for muslims but they always ask Modi what he done for muslims. They ask Modi for accountability for Gujarat riots but why the same muslims dont ask Lieutenant General Zameer Uddin Shah accountability for Gujarat riots when he was directly responsible for law and order during the riots. He is same man who was incharge of army to control 2002 gujarat riots ...he never said anything against modi for gujarat riots.
Tell me why muslims dont call General Zameer Uddin Shah butcher of Gujarat.
Kyu ki fake media ki post karne ki aadat hai real fact explore karna nahi hai.
When he looked at the camera and addressed the minister, it just hit me that he could fit well in the Indian version of House of Cards
Nasseruddin shah is a MORON, FRUSTRATED and a DISGUSTING HUMAN BEING.... One must read his autobiography, he did sex with a girl who was just 14 years old... He himself mentions in his book....And he is jealous of all super successful celebrities in india.... Actually, Anupam kher has put it very rightly that Nasseruddin shah is a deeply FRUSTRATED person...
nitish goyal you people can’t digest truth at all. Anti national.
nitish goyal Miss call please. 😂
@@intheair5434 you kattar insan you no need to tell who is who just oppose caa nrc npr
We Indian Muslims demand now separate country...hum lekar rahengyh azadi InshaAllah, Hindustan Murdabad Murdabad
Salute to you Nasiruddin sir. Loved your movies. Now love you more for your thoughts.
He just spoke my heart out !
Are you also senile and frustrated?
Abhishek arora khatna karwa liya kya mulle
@@ramangarg4619 You seem another brainwashed person.
@@suptaguin3229 and you seem to be another converted person
@@yushpi Sounds like you are !
My respects to the great Naseeruddin Shah
Well said Mr Shah is Knowledgeable person 🇮🇳👍🇮🇳
🔔🔔
Great sir, we all are with you.
Respect Mr Shah....
Mr Nasiruddin shah is absolutely right.
I am with Nasir Sir . God bless you and people like you. 🙏😂
God and Allah both will bless
I got no problem with this video, but then I found another video which in a very factual manner proved N. Shah's claims false .
ua-cam.com/video/hb_Ulasq1V8/v-deo.html
@@MonkeyDLuffy-zw4cd okay Let me share with you 100 videos in which all of Modi's claims have been proven false and that too with facts
@@raghavkaushal7561 Mind you, the video I shared was also supportive of facts .Yeah, I agree a lot of political figures haven't clarified and not stuck to stronger claims and need to be held accountable, it's our responsibility to do so .But that's not the point I'm making. I'm saying that as much as we've the right to point out the falsifications of others it doesn't allow us to put out a fake narrative like this one .This also needs to be condemned .
@@raghavkaushal7561 And the worst part is, judging from the likes and comments on this video , we haven't condemned this and that too when it's false on a factual basis . That's all I'm saying .
Students!!! What happened in JNU,?? Do we need students who study on tax payers money and talk against own country!!
20:52 m here to hear those magic words💓💓
Kanishq sharma thanx for the time stamp 😂
thanks
First give me answers to :
why all letters/ agreements between nehru and british only talk about dominion status not independence.
why sikhs did not participate in 1987 revolt, why they had concerns against leadership of baba bahadur shah zafar.
Why British created the muslim league in 1906 i.e after 1857 revolution. why the charter of muslim league was loyalty tot he british crown
why nehru was not honest to say he had muslim ancestors,
why gandhiji did not allow sardar patel to become prime minister of India
When gandhiji said to Nehru let Jinnah become PM so that nation is not divided by Nehru never allowed this , instead said in his speech Jinnah is not fit to become chaprassi of my cabinet. The real reason is both Jinnah and nehru were British proxy agents.
Why Nehru did not allow the army to advance to POK to take back kashmir when our army and airforce was much stronger then Pakistan.
why nehru was not openly sharing that he ate beef
Why nehru did not allow to implement the directive principal of cow slaughter ban
why nehru only controlled hindu population via hindu code bill but did not stop muslims from marrying again
why nehru added in constitution that majority don't have same rights as minority to teach own religion in schools.
Why nehru imposed IAS control of temples but not for mosque and churches
why nehru give up chabahar port rights when oman offered them to India
why Nehru did not take permission from parliament majority to introduce article 370, 35A
why nehru closed all arms and ammunition factories in India.
why nehru was saying he will resign if constitution directive principle on beef ban is implemented but same time he promised gandhi that he would implement beef ban
Despite Punjab being a sikh country, Why 80% of votes from punjab in the provisional elections went to Muslim league which resulted in 80% of land punjab going to Pakistan. Why only 2 states, punjab and Bengal voted for muslim league in large majority.
why Nehru never asked for independence in any document with british, between 1925 to 1947, all his letters to British only seek dominion status under british empire.
By 1752 the Mughals were completely kicked out of India by the Marasthas but still British offered the most precious historic hindu and pious sikhs land to make Pakistan. Why Nehru could not say you took from the muslims you have to give full India back to the hindus.
If muslims were only 8-9 percent population then why did British reserve 30% of the provinces for Muslims during the provisional elections of 1946. This means only muslims or muslim league candidates could win in the 30% reserved provinces. Isnt this the reason for 30% land of India being given to Pakistan cause Muslims won 30% reserved seats. Wasnt this a conspiracy against the hindus.
When India was offered UN security council seat why did he refuse and instead offered it to china.
Why Nehru was unhappy about operation polo by sardar patel
Why the 1st corruption scandal started against Nehru govt in purchase of army jeeps.
Why indira added the word secular in the constitution during emergency without consensus of parliament, when the country was created a hindu country at the time of creation by the british.
When the partition was to make pakistan for muslims and India for hindus then why the hindu state was made into a secular state who authorized Nehru family to do this,
Imran khan claims he want to make pakistan tolerant, then why even after his govt came to power sikhs in Pakistan are being forced to convert to Islam.
why congress spied on subhash chandra bose family for 2 decades even after independence.
In the provisional elections NWFP voted against Muslim league why did Nehru ignore Abdul Ghaffar khan who wanted to join India, why for NWFP repeat referendum was required and NWFP made part of Pakistan with rigged elections.And why after partition Abdul ghaffar khan was jailed 10 years in Pakistan.
Why CIA supported the Khalistan movement, why all Khalistanis found refuge in UK, Canada and USA.
Why Nehru lied to India that constitution of India was written by Baba Saheb Ambedkar, when in fact it was given by the British to Nehru who then modified the article 27-32 and given to Ambedkar for review. This is why Majority hindus till date dont have same rights as Minority Indians to teach own religion is schools, and manage own religious places like the minorities, why IAS officers are in control of majority temples in India. Why funds of temples can be taken by govt for taken for minority development
Why congress party workers who were involved in 1984 sikh riots were not jailed until Modi came to power. Why Kamal nath was made CM of Madhya Pradesh by congress party despite being responsible for sikh killings.
Why Jinnah was offered Knight hood in 1925 by the British empire.
Why Jinnah was exchanging secret letters with winston churchill with regard planning of the partition. Which were kept classified in UK until recently.
Why are you denying when all the possibilities point out that Nehru, Jinnah were British agents.
Why the Cripps commission, the Nehru act, the independence act of India are only saying dominion status under the British. Are we still funding the British queens expenses. Why is India part of the common wealth., what is the implications of this membership. Why did many of the news papers in 1947 state two dominions are born.
Why did british give away the birth place of Hinduism , Birth place of Sikh religion to the muslims.
Why even after 10 years of independence all the army generals in pakistan army were British. Were these army generals involved in attacks on India.
Why after death of Lal Bahadur shastri all the defence contracts went to Russians.
Why communist party of India did not allow air force to attack china. Why the members of communist party of India refused to give blood to the soldiers of India in 1962 war with china.
Why congress party wants to prove saffron terrorism, why is Lt Purohit in Jail for last 10 years. Is there a congress conspiracy in his being jailed for so long.
Why abdul ghaffar khan told Nehru you fed us to the dogs when the pashtoons stood shoulder to shoulder with the congress and hindus to for a united hindustan. Why Nehru back stabbed the Khudai Khitmadaars
Lot of these things need answers.
Correct what he says. Tukde tukde gang is the ruling party n No one else.
Exactly.
I got no problem with this video, but then I found another video which in a very factual manner proved N. Shah's claims false .
ua-cam.com/video/hb_Ulasq1V8/v-deo.html
Ye Jinnah ki nazayaz aulade hi tukde tukde gang wali hai
U mean the people that voted bjp.. u mean the majority of india... may be ur dad is one among them
in.yahoo.com/news/we-ruled-india-for-800-years-wont-show-papers-akbaruddin-owaisi-052947259.html
Explain this?
4:35 Here, Mr. Shah is referring to his brother Lt. Gen. Zameer Uddin Shah.
Yes Bro 😉
My great-grandfather served as DIG of police and now we have to prove our citizenship... Wah Modi ji wah
Usko bolo...jao pehle us aadmi ka kagaz lekar aao ..jiska Naam Damodar hai...tab mein tumhe kagaz kya sab kuch doonga...
P.s Haan mein bhi Hindu hoon...asli wala
Who insulted the war veteran? When ?
@@nv2929 ua-cam.com/video/4Pmk4LNfiqQ/v-deo.html
Its one of the best interview I have seen.Shah is speaking like a normal sports person.
WE LOVE YOU SIR (Naseeruddin Shah) THANK YOU FOR THE HELP AND SUPPORT FOR POOR AND NEEDY AND WE EXPECT MORE AND MORE SUPPORT FROM THE INTELLECTUALS AND FROM PM WE EXPECT WE SHOULD BE TREATED EQUALLY REST WE WILL EARN OUR LIVELIHOOD BY DOING HARDWORK
Naseeruddinji, you are a towering and inspiring citizen. I've always been in awe of you time and again standing out and expressing your thoughts on various social and political issues in spite of the awareness of the forces that are he'll bent on stifling sane voices. I'm sure you will continue to inspire and the students and young coming out on the streets will take a clue from you to March on to their betterment. Salute to you.
Real hero of India -Sh. Nassiruddin Shah.
My respect Naseer Saab grows manifold.Big admirer Sir.
Excellent expressions and thought !
Nasruddin shah was great
But lets take a moment and appreciate the work of interviewer he did an amazing job of getting out the most from Nasruddin shah
Keep it up sir !
Kejriwal is highly educated and very well mannered person. ONLY he deserves to be PM among all opposition parties.
Certainly it will happen one day but i would not be that lucky to see that happening i m already 70+
Imran Khan of pak, oweisi , hafeez, etc etc are also qualified to be PM of India...
I agree
Yashpal Mhaskar well said sir 👍Kejriwal @pm
@@mukeshaggarwal5004 may be possible
hello people, i am going to make a fan page for this brilliant person on instagram because i saw there is none.he deserves so much more attention.
During 2002 I still remember when I was studying in Sardar Patel high school in Nadiad, Gujarat, there was a curfew for months and when I returned to the school the female teacher said in a class “who enjoyed in bashing Muslims” “raise your hands and majority” of students raised their hands and we muslims students were just shocked and angry. Our hindu friends became our enemies that time. RSS, Bajrang Dal and BJP were brain washing of Hindus for so many years in Gujarat through anti-Muslim speeches in small gatherings in various parts of Gujarat. Sardar Patel High School, Nadiad, Gujarat is the school where Sardar Patel used to study.
💔😢🙏💜
That teacher is a hate preacher, she’s spilling poison and teaching the students how to spill poison at your own country men, she shouldn’t be teaching at all.
So sad to see bjp is turning friends and neighbors into enemies.
@Pradeep B let's ask this question to Sadhwi pragya who appealed to modi to repeat Godhra again.
The meaning is clear and everyone of us know that it was modi who did godhra in order to win Gujarat election in the same way he did pulwama.
I am a Brahmin and was RSS sanghatak but I have left RSS because I can't be with one who kills Hindus in godhra and pulwama to win election
@Pradeep B you shut it bro. Someone who turns a blind eye to reality; who can't think for themselves n make assumptions by listening to bigots n haters and not having the brains to find facts for themselves; how can we expect an andha aadmi like you to understand another insaan's pain, suffering n feelings!
All you guys do is just make stupid comments rather than working towards making your country a better place for all the people of your unique country whose for fathers and mothers of all backgrounds fought for.
You cannot blame innocents of any background who had or have anything to do with some awful things that others have done.
This goes for people of all faiths and backgrounds ... whether they believe in any religion, God or not.
Religion or faith accha ya bura nahi hota ... Insaan acche ya bure hotel hai! Especially jo dharm aur nationalism ki choli pahen kar, doosron ko behka kar, apne agenda ke liye istamaal karte hai!
why so many uppercaste join rss
Thanks for confirming the truth about Anupar Kher as well, among other things.. Someone needed to say that out loud
Haha yes, and if i remember, anupam taklu came up with some response video to Naseeruddin, and it was so lame. I think ultimately, Anupam must have seen both the videos, and realized what a great fool he must have looked compared to Naseer, i think he has mellowed down a bit recently. Doesnt bark as much as he used to.
Dear nasuruddinji you need not emphasise on your being. Everyone knows about you. You do not need any certificate either PM or hm
@Alamani hossain what do you mean
Yaar thoda angrezi seekh lo... Nahin toh hindi mein hi likho.... Btw tumhare naam ka Stadium bana tha kya..?
The fact this grammar got 79 likes shows the structure of our education system and brain cells behind it
@@absarahmed5695 illiterate hona problem nahin hai.... Illiterates ko bewakoof aur islamohobic banana dangerous hai... Jiska result 80 likes hai... Thanks to Republic zee news and so on.... Btw aaj kaal literate hoke bhi bewakoof bante log..... Jab tak galat dikhaya jayega tab tak hum galat seekhte rahenge...
Yeah for Goondas don't need certificate.
He has talked many nice and meaningful things but modia picked only anupam kher section and highlighting that only.
They play this game always and what else can be expected from these leeches.
Muslims who are opposing Pakistan today, their generations will have to prove their loyalty to India for rest of their lives.
(Mohammad Ali Jinnah)
Who stopped them to move Pakistan. By the way UP , Bihari , Bangali , Hydrabadi , TN , Kerla Muslims were frontrunner to create Pakistan , so they owe Pakistan.
@@gayatri956 shut up you antinational....people like you are in minority ....majority hindu would never support hindu rashtra we wont let hindu pakistan agenda
@@theeconomicslab82 U shut up. Majority are in favour that's why BJP won 300 plus seat. I challenge anti-national like you to demand referendum on the matter of Hindu Rashtra, if u believe what u r saying.
@@theeconomicslab82 Who are u stop it , we already given mandate & will give again in 2024. We are on right path to convert India into Hindu Rashtra. U people tried every propgenda to stop CAA & NRC. CAA implemented , NRC will also come.
@@gayatri956 what stopped you from moving to sri Lanka or a ditch even? The nation doesn't belong to your baap. EVERY citizen has equal right to our nation irrespective of their religion
Well done Naseeruddin Shah
23:50 "I don't think anyone is communal by nature, it's fed"
Agree! Some religions preach it too - the seeds are sown there.
www.organiser.org/Encyc/2020/1/13/Jihadi-mob-attacks-Hindu-homes-in-Bhainsa-in-Telangana-.html
Explain this ?
in.yahoo.com/news/we-ruled-india-for-800-years-wont-show-papers-akbaruddin-owaisi-052947259.html
explain this ?
That's why education is important. Salute to you Nasir sir.
I love to hear him.very eloquent learned and fine person. I loved mostly all films he acted in .fearless soul like Lord Krishna wants us to be in BhagwadGita.we love you Nasrudinji.Many must be wanting to be like you but this really requires courage which perhaps they lack;even in your film world.. Lots of our best wishes and good luck dear.
Nasiruddin Shah is a brave gentle man. He have the guts to express his thinking.
Salute him for expressing his view regarding CAA.
Nassuridin is not a Muslim
He is only a great human being.
वह एकदम कट्टर मुस्लिम है
Mughals we're great, that's why they forgave guru gobind,, these RSS people r dangerous
@@dipakfarkade793 aur tu kya hai katad hindu
@@kelloggole5458 नसरुदधिन जेहादि सोच रखनेवाला है.
Salute to Mr. Naseeruddin Shah for speaking honestly and opening eyes of many. Society need guidance like this to understand the reality.
Naseeruddin shah is as great actor as Anupam kher. However great actor should not disrespect the other one saying he is clown, maniac etc. On the contrary I would admire mr. Kher's reaction on mr. Shah. Disclaimer: " I am not modi bhakta at all". Love n peace - I need justice
Anupam Kher was using all abusing word in front of ladies in public live and he was praising Modi at the same time. Now compare.
Nassuridin is a great man and a great actor.
BJP is a shameless party.
Isn't it Hamari Bhul Kamal ka Phool !
Kulbir Ji,
I do agree with you partly, he is a great intolerant and a political party is not a circus party, it is a political party!
Citizens get a government exactly what they deserve!
Get ez brainwashed ☺️
Nassuridin is a great man . Then what's happened. How can u judge ruling party is shameless
Probably a fake account by a disgusting Communist comrade
World will always Schindler , When God will ask for Scars, Naseerunddin Shah will show his courage that was worth fighting for.
नसीरुद्दीन साहब हमारे बुज़ुर्ग और मार्गदर्शक हैं। उन्हें सलाम।
Mr.Sidharth Bhatia, It rare to find such fine matured journalist taking interview. Please take an interview of Mr Lal Krishna Advani on CAA-NRC-NPR. That would be great service to nation.
Huge respect for Mr Shah!
Well spoken !
Jehadi
फसादी है
@@PyaraBHARAT007 he also cancer for india .
@@sanjaykumaryadav3428 नसीरुद्दीन शाह पे मैं वीडियो लाऊंगा देखिएगा। लिंक शेयर करेंगे यहाँ पर।
@@PyaraBHARAT007 jehadi cancer ko itna seriously mat lo
He is speaking for so many of us. I agree completely with him.
Naseer sir is my all time favourite actor and human being 🙏
Looks like Anupam Kher needs to listen to the whole interview . The amount of study Naseer Sab has on his country is much more than Anupam has ever done.
@Akshat yeah but we no gobar is as worth as kohinoor.
Anupap is a sarak path alow life.
A Muslim made him famous, before hè was a begger.
@Akshat So you are saying that you want to fight jihad with saffron terrorism?? Great, but remember civil war of Sri Lanka, and at present state of Myanmar. If you still want to support this goons then remember another riots and partition could happen.
@@suptaguin3229 Kaunsa saffron terrorism? Pakistan ki tarah kya minorities ko ghar se uthaake zabardast convert kar rahe ya unhe maar rahe? Sabse tezi se bad rahi muslim population India mein, karke dikhaade aisa baaki islamic nations mein.
@@Akash-vf3ru Growth rate check karna zara, bhalei muslim ki growth rate abhi bhi sabse zada hai, par sabhi census ko agar dekhe to abhi bhi 200-250 saal lagenge hindu muslim barabar hone me, agar isi tarah badte gaye to, joki asambhab hai. Aur rahi baat convertion or utpiran ka to Md.Ali Jinnah ne bhi ie kaha tha ki, Pakistan bhale Muslim rashtra bane par uha sabhi dharm ke log khusal rahenge. Iha tak ki Jogendranath Mondal bhi unke jhanse me aa gaye or Pakistan me rahna pasand kia. Asliyat to hamare samne he ki Pakistan me wakai me kya hua. Isiliye agar RSS ie kahti hai ki Hindurashtra me sabhi dharm ke log achhe se raha sakti he to usme kitna biswas karna chahiye ie to history dekhne ke bad bichar karna chahiye. Agar Hindurashtra ban bhi gaya to baki religions choro khud hindu bhi safe nahi hoga, aye din dalito aur advasi o par atyachar hote rahenge, jaisa Pakistan me Shia or Ahmadiyas ke sath hota hai. RSS or Muslim League me koi farak nahi hai, dono hi religious extremism ke idea ko mante hai.
When criminal himself sits on pm post what can one expect....
Biggest terrorist of India
*Criminal is full knowledge of criminology otherwise louts trying to stand on the feet of the we indian*
🤔 🤔
😢 😢
🙏 🙏
more than 70% of nasserudin shah's claims are factually incorrect..i get it he is dumb...he is so dumb that in 2015 he filed a mercy petition for yakub menon...but what about this journalist??..my problem is with this fucker....channels like the wire quint ndtv republic tv zee news are the real problem...they are all godi media the only difference is that they all sits on a different lap
Don't expect but we r expecting from our respected pm that soon he will remove the piece of shit like u
Explain how.. majority of india didnt vote him to office loke that. He is also ur pm..
Totally justified anger...agree with you sir...the person who has never been a student or been inside a school will understand the students
Tea
Look 1 sonia again come. Now we have 2 sonia 1 is from Italy 2nd is you 😂
Exactly ! And what about your dadi maa the great honorary BA degree holder Late Indira Gandhi ????
@@awakenkaafirex-muslim6627 no sir not mine but maybe urs u explain 🙏😂
We Indian Muslims demand now separate country...hum lekar rahengyh azadi InshaAllah, Hindustan Murdabad Murdabad
the way he is talking here reminds me of the movie Wednesday..... Also he has a vast resource of vocabulary...
0p
.0pp
Naseeruddin was a dull student according to his autobiography so i understand why he is unable to understand the CAA. This bill was passed to give
refuge to the "persecuted minorities" in the 3 Islamic countries. Muslims in these countries are neither minorities nor are they persecuted so logically
they cannot be included in the bill. The reason we need such a bill is bcoz minorities are being persecuted by muslims in these countries chruches
were bombed, women are abducted and forciably converted. Syria was Christian, Pakistan was Hindu, Iran was Zoarastrian, Afghanistan was Buddhist and
now all are Islamic states where the indigenious ppl are wiped out. Moderate muslims like him are actually helping the radicals instead of educating
certain members of his faith/community to be tolerant and respectful towards other faiths/communities.
Are wo fenku pariksha pe charcha kar raha hai 🤣🤣🤣
Loved the interview
Well Said Nasir Sir. Love you for you truth speaking.
A real "A WEDNESDAY"
Yep he was the hero
Underrated comment!
Thank you sir . Unity in diversity !
Best Actor, Best Human, Best thinker, Best ideas. I salute his ways.
Best in spreading fake news and best in kies with this interview i can completely underatand a muslim that what ever u five them they are muslim first and muslim last.......
Eloquently put in a very candid and emotive way.
This Interview Reminds Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah words "Those Muslims who are against Partition will Always Strive to prove Loyality to the Hindus" Thats a Vision of a Legendary Leader.. Proud to have Such a Leader..Thanks Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah..
Your favourite....
Nasruddin sir
Modi cmnt 😜
Respect You Sir
Why not ask questions on Triple Talaq, Article 370, Shah bano case. Was it right or wrong? I wanted to see the response of Mr Naseeruddin Shah on this. Also JNU campaign is lead by JNU students union who dont allow new students to register for courses. Is that democracy? They enter server room to cut cables so other students cannot apply. Is that fine with him? Anupam khair is right, he has no clue of what is wrong and what is right? Just harping on some issues based in his hatred for Modi and Amit Shah.
Naseeruddin shah sir has clearly hit the nail on the head. My Thankx to you that you spoke so openly about it. It’s sad what is happening nationwide. Hope better sense prevails amongst the powers that be eventually. This is a draconian law no two ways about it, laced with malicious intent and hellbent on ripping apart the core constitutional principles.
Anupam kher is a clown😂😂😂good one sir
Very true 😂😂😂
Anupam tho BJP ka bada dalla hai sab jaante hain
Anupam kher is palto kutta of Bjp ...
Anupam has always been a RSS pracharak and you know they always talk Golwalkar- I mean from Bunch of Thoughts." Limiting themselves of intellectuality.
@@mr.engineer3843 kya Anupam Kher Ji engineering bhi jaante? But acts much better than Nashah!
Irony is that Mr.Modi is doing Pariksha pe charcha with students after totally ignoring brutality beaten up Students of JNU, Jamia and AMU.
Mr Modi has entire countrys students. AMU, JNU and Jamia is not India ...
Supriyashashidhar Shashidhar how can u even say that without knowing anything please think before you make such absurd statements about children of poor who still want to pursue education despite of all the financial difficulties Dude there’s a whole lot of difference when your parents cannot afford certain things that is when u care about such changes
And with due respect Mind yourself before pointing a finger at someone’s Nationality 😡
Ha ha , I was a child labor myself . Worked hard and got where I am today . Doing decently well. I dint engage in fights , I those days nothing was available . But we did it. Despite of all the facilities there are fights. Don't like it.
Supriyashashidhar Shashidhar happy to hear dear but times have changed now today education is of much importance and the students raised their voices against fee hike which is their right and their duty as a responsible citizen the government and management should have solved this problems with discussions and dialects which never happened
Anyways the only point I got offended in your comment is you said they r not India but they are as Indians as you and I
Peace ✌️
@@safurawasgare4246 My point is , every one especial Muslims , where is the focus ? focus on fights ? Focus should be on education , upliftment not fights . If I would have fought and missed classes , I would not be a Sr. Manager earning in lakhs . Once you are uplifted , nothing matters ... remember . FOCUS on right things .
Before I start what I have to say let me tell I am a Muslim and I support CAA and have no qualms with NRC. If there are issues and concerns then there are ways to do it inside Parliament instead of rebelling on streets and burning our own property. Now, I respect Naseer Ji for what he has done in his life but certain pieces he said does not match his image. His five year old then Son was surprised to see Hindus married to a Hindu - Really? What kind of society did you expose him to? Was he surprised to see a Muslim married to a Muslim too or did he find that just natural? All the rest he said appeared to be personal hatred towards Modi Ji being a nationalist Hindu. Looking at the list of Prime Ministers this country has had, I am fairly comfortable with Modi as our PM, not so much with Naseer who seems spooked as if their hidden agendas have been exposed.
If they are students and not following law than they should treated the same