Guftagoo with Naseeruddin Shah

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2018
  • Naseeruddin Shah born 20 July 1950, is an Indian film and stage actor and director, and a prominent figure in Indian parallel cinema. He has won numerous awards in his career, including three National Film Awards, three Filmfare Awards and an award at the Venice Film Festival. The Government of India has honoured him with the Padma Shri and the Padma Bhushan awards for his contributions to Indian cinema. Shah has also acted in Pakistani films.
    Shah was born into a Muslim family in Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh, India, as one of the three sons of Aley Mohammed Shah and his wife Farrukh Sultan. He is a descendant of a 19th-century Sayyid Afghan warlord Jan-Fishan Khan (Sayyid Muhammad Shah), who participated in the First Anglo-Afghan War and helped the British in the subsequent Indian Rebellion of 1857.
    Shah did his schooling at St. Anselm's Ajmer and St Joseph's College, Nainital. He graduated in arts from Aligarh Muslim University in 1971 and attended National School of Drama in Delhi.
    Anchor- Irfan
    00:15 Intro/Clips from few Films and TV serials
    03:02 Gulzar on Naseer’s acting prowess & versatility/Mirza Ghalib
    04:33 Glimpses of theatre/Motley theatre/Benjamin Gilani/Tom Alter/ His Autobiography-And then one day/ Padma Bhushan award/Regional language Films/Pakistani & Hollywood Films/National & International Awards
    07:24 Why acting & what motivates him continuing with it?/ In pursuit of achieving excellence & perfection in acting / childhood reminiscences & formative years /Exposure to Hollywood films in childhood
    12:49 Art is nothing but a constant search for truth / Art cannot be classified / how classicism ruins spontaneity in terms of artistic expressions/ how classicism diverts art from intellectualism or from the truth of the art/ Realism is not the only way in acting/ An actor just conveys the truth of the writing or an idea or belief or a propaganda
    16:22 Stanislavsky, Bresson and Method acting / Fetishization of character/How he understood Brecht after many years post NSD and the need to manifest a character objectively/ Difference between becoming a character (Method) and consciously doing a character (Brecht) and how he transformed his style from being a Methodical to Brechtian style
    19:56 How his character in Paar was manifested via relating with old memories, consciously being empathetic & imaginative & without taking resort to method acting (i.e. to become a character Psychologically)/ /Mirch Masala was accomplished remembering his maternal grandfather
    22:32 Memoirs of family and early days / His autobiography and how much he has included and excluded stories or people/ his relationship with father
    25:24 Hindi & Hollywood films & difference in execution / Dilip Kumar / Udan Khatola & Wizard of Oz / Influence of Hollywood due to its excellence in execution / Learning Urdu at this age
    28:40 Why is there a constant tussle between an actor and a director? Role of an actor from the perspective of objectivity/ An actor is a ‘coolie of communication’ in reference to Dr. Shreeram Lagoo’s autobiography ‘Lamaan’/ How this realisation gave him a sense of satisfaction & understood the reason of being an actor
    35:35 On failing in 8/9 class & middle class view on failure & assessment in education system / how theatre at the age of 14 helped in self-motivation and realising the importance of observing human behaviour/Grandfather- a Nawab, his other relative who pulled rickshaw and one who did begging/ Cricket & Acting / NSD training in learning the skills/ Bathroom actor-self observation/ Pulling memories from real life characters to enact Sparsh, Bhavni Bhavai
    44:20 Result of no planning for tomorrow by the Nawabs/ Film stars
    46:02 Ebrahim Alkazi, Satyadev Dubey & Habib Tanveer / western theatre vs indigenous theatre / Flaws in NSD’s approach and failure in developing an indigenous theatre which is rooted in India like Satyadev Dubey & Habib Tanveer/ Alkazi stressed on discipline and finesse of an urban or western theatre but lacked knowledge on Mahabharat , Dastangoi, Ramayan- the indigenous stories & styles
    56:24 How Popular cinema & Television is shaping a subversive & regressive thoughts at subconscious level / Mohan Agashe/ An audience or actor’s role in shaping this process
    58:31 Why act in Blueberry Hunt kind of films?
    1:01:36 Pursuing passion of story reading for taking literature to society/Audio books (reading text aloud), Zia Moyeddin, Dr Jameel Gulrays , Rajendra Gupta / Chaupal , Atul Tiwari, Shyam Benegal ,Satyajit Ray ,Mrinal Sen Khwaza Ahmad Abbas / songless movies, V Shantaram/70s film movement, Ketan Mehta, Govind Nihlaani, Anurag Kashyap, Vikram Aditya Motwane,
    1:04:18 Why I act in commercial cinema if I hate it so much?/Joginder/Shammi Kapoor/Rajshree Films/ Dirty Picures/Tridev/Karma/Chamatkar/Bachchan/Balraj Shahani/Dilip Kumar/Role of entertainment
    1:10:36 Thanking note by anchor Irfan and a collage of photos & feedback on Guftagoo

КОМЕНТАРІ • 810

  • @princeworld2014
    @princeworld2014 5 років тому +107

    Finally....what a class conversation...mature.... amazing

  • @Shez_C
    @Shez_C 4 роки тому +89

    The class and intellect of the man is exemplary. In a world where greed and selfishness is paraded as being great, the humility and honesty of Naseer saab is touching and warming. Many can learn from him

    • @brodyjeremiah9848
      @brodyjeremiah9848 2 роки тому +1

      you probably dont care but does someone know a trick to log back into an instagram account..?
      I stupidly forgot my account password. I appreciate any tips you can give me

    • @VVS167
      @VVS167 Рік тому

      Shez_C ROGER that🌹

    • @SHANKARKUMAR-cq8wn
      @SHANKARKUMAR-cq8wn 10 місяців тому

      ​@@VVS167vxvvxv
      Bbbvvb
      Nfvxxv
      Ffffvffffxfff
      Vffý3313the

  • @iragrover2676
    @iragrover2676 5 років тому +43

    Irfan Sir brings out a certain kind of honesty in his guests and with such ease that it sounds so beautiful

  • @deepaksaxena7417
    @deepaksaxena7417 5 років тому +22

    It wasn't an interview. It was a conversation par excellence among two legends.

  • @saquib2949
    @saquib2949 5 років тому +71

    Its a meditation in itself to watch Irfan sb. interviewing the great actors with such a beautiful peace..

  • @mylifemyrule4580
    @mylifemyrule4580 2 роки тому +3

    Kitna kuchh Jan neko mila...
    Thank you both

  • @shobhanajoshi7186
    @shobhanajoshi7186 5 років тому +15

    इरफ़ान साहब शुक्रिया नसीर साहब से अनमोल मुलाका़त का। शानदार प्रस्तुति ।

  • @anshumansharma6334
    @anshumansharma6334 5 років тому +43

    If I can get 1 percent of Naseer sahab's voice, I'll consider myself blessed. Who wouldn't sit and listen to this voice?

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 4 роки тому

      Everything about MohMadism is fake. Your and my names are Yahood/Jew bit Bedouinized but MohMadism ask us to hate Jews/Yahood & kill them. Your & my DNA is native Dharmik one but MohMadism asks us to hate everything native including our ancestors who gave that Dharmik DNA. Today there are more fake Khans in LaWhore than real Khans ever existed in Mongolia where Khans come from. Similarly there are more fake Qureshis in Karachi than the real ones ever existed in Saudi Barbaria.

    • @ashokaal-hadrami8477
      @ashokaal-hadrami8477 4 роки тому +5

      @@salimalvi5178 what this has to do with interview?

  • @SushilKumar-mp4tg
    @SushilKumar-mp4tg 5 років тому +47

    Reality is Itself exaggeration of Perception ......... Acting Can be exaggeration of Reality no Doubt
    Very Knowledgeable Anchor

    • @shahfenil08
      @shahfenil08 5 років тому +2

      I disagree with you, sorry. Perception is how you infer reality based on your limited intelligence. Acting is a way to represent perception based on writer's and actor's intelligence.

    • @SushilKumar-mp4tg
      @SushilKumar-mp4tg 5 років тому +2

      @@shahfenil08
      Mind comes before Matter . What we call common Reality of all is Very Subjective fragile and Relative . I mean I put you on Drug in a Room show you film could you ever tell me was it a Dream or Reality . Reality is there but is it ultimate reality God know what . Only Thing I know is I don't know
      I think Therefore I am
      - ( Rene Descartes)

    • @rohansharma8302
      @rohansharma8302 5 років тому +1

      Kya baatein kar rahe ho tum dono.
      Sab bouncer jaa raha hai.
      Humein din-raat ki daal roti mil jaati hai hum to usme hi khush ho jate hai. Bas hume yeh pata hai

  • @saurabhbhatia2401
    @saurabhbhatia2401 5 років тому +165

    What an enlightened man with such clarity of thoughts.....Compare this with the ones who are dancing at Isha ambani's wedding......

    • @aravindkumar6631
      @aravindkumar6631 5 років тому +6

      That does not mean they are low on thoughts depends on prespective

    • @krishanrathi9119
      @krishanrathi9119 4 роки тому +7

      @@aravindkumar6631 not low on thoughts but daulat ke aage mazboor hain bechare.

    • @sauravdagaSDaga1984
      @sauravdagaSDaga1984 4 роки тому +4

      @@krishanrathi9119 Paisa khuda to nahi, par khuda ki kasam khuda se kam bhi nahi

    • @nirajbasnet2000
      @nirajbasnet2000 3 роки тому

      6

    • @utkarshtiwari5549
      @utkarshtiwari5549 3 роки тому

      @@gm679 1ll1

  • @vipin01202758191
    @vipin01202758191 3 роки тому +30

    Only Irfan sir can bring smile to nasseruddin shah in an interview...

  • @tarunaggarwal3917
    @tarunaggarwal3917 5 років тому +21

    When NASEER SIR speaks........ Even ENCYCLOPEDIA and GOOGLE sits back and listens........ The LEGEND.....

  • @shoaib3219
    @shoaib3219 5 років тому +279

    Master of the interview - Irfan sir is the best interviewer of India.

    • @poojapal4431
      @poojapal4431 5 років тому +5

      The Irfan sir is the Best!

    • @_The_Alchemist_
      @_The_Alchemist_ 3 роки тому +1

      @Abhi R He just spoke about the interviewer like many others in the comments section. You assumed the rest yourself.
      By the way, who is the best interviewer, best singer, best actor, best musician, according to you?

    • @gurudeepranjan
      @gurudeepranjan 3 роки тому +1

      @Abhi R I wonder why would you say something like that. Please try and get yourself out of these communal shackles. It will never let you grow.

    • @gurudeepranjan
      @gurudeepranjan 3 роки тому +1

      @Abhi R and the commonality between all these people that you've mentioned is that they're all indians .

    • @rupakdey4616
      @rupakdey4616 3 роки тому +1

      G yg ggggyuyftfgygyguuffffgyffuuguygyyftfffgyuggyufgfugtygyfyuffguyggyygugtyfyftgf7ft77ftgfGFgggfuuuftuuguftggGft7Ffff77687t8788ttggugu7ygfu tugu yutyygft8667778t888ffggggyuygufufytufft78766t685Tt77t8t7Tfffggygyggfgygguufuuggtgytt787768688t8t7t7t8tffffgggggugffggyuFgF tutti-frutti yuufgGgffFy8t7t67tt8t8t8877tytffffyttgyggftyyygfgfuftuGygff68ttt6tttttt6f5tt78685tttf7fugggfyggyuggg6ff tutti-frutti 55t576ttTT7tt58t6y77t6t65tt55ftt6rt rightist 8tr5rtt5tttttttrttt rutir rutir and 6t to tttrrtt tuturor tutur 66 yg 6t tuturor tar te it would help t5575rtttttt tuturor tourist 65t7666r5rttt66t555555558ji

  • @akbarattar5910
    @akbarattar5910 4 роки тому +22

    BEST Actor in India, Hasn’t got his due respect from film Industry.

  • @dukhtarafghan7289
    @dukhtarafghan7289 5 років тому +80

    One of the rare actor jo fake nahi hai

    • @budhrajarahul3
      @budhrajarahul3 5 років тому +4

      bhai fake stars hote hai ...guftguu me sab underrated or non commercial log ate hain..agr vo khud star hote to vo bhi fake hote..unfortunately naseerudin shah sir is a great actor but not that commercial..

    • @suryashekharbiswas7229
      @suryashekharbiswas7229 5 років тому

      @@budhrajarahul3 correct

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 5 років тому +3

      You and me are fake. We got Bedouinized Yahoodi names but we are made to hate Yahoodis. We live off of Hanood land but hate everything native/Hanood. This makes us rootless parasite, who bites the hand which feeds us. This is why China does not allow Islam & Christianity in its land. It does not allow its citizen take non native names, especially AbraHarami Bedouinized or Romanized Yahoodi/Jewish names.

    • @rohansharma8302
      @rohansharma8302 5 років тому

      @@salimalvi5178
      Kya bol rahe ho bhai?

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 5 років тому

      @@rohansharma8302 ban Islam like China

  • @kartoosonuchagoku
    @kartoosonuchagoku 3 роки тому +18

    Wow what a interview! Such a knowledgeable person in industry.

  • @samratroy7600
    @samratroy7600 4 роки тому +23

    Naseeruddin Shah is One Of The Greatest Actors Of All-time Of World Cinema 🙏❤️
    My Two Favourite Actors Are Naseeruddin Shah Sir and Irrfan Khan Sir,Two Incomparable Actors❤️🙏

    • @namansrivastava9076
      @namansrivastava9076 2 роки тому +2

      India needs more people like you whose favourite actors are these people and not shahrukh salman

  • @amaanhasan803
    @amaanhasan803 3 роки тому +76

    Jis safai se Naseer Sahab ne sab bataya, ye interview apne aap me ek film school hai

    • @user-cd4nb6wz3d
      @user-cd4nb6wz3d 2 роки тому +6

      यह बात अगर आप देवनागरी लिपि में लिखते तो बहुत ही उत्कृष्ट होता।।👍

    • @saarthakcoachingclasses1092
      @saarthakcoachingclasses1092 8 годин тому

      True❤

  • @rozbey2504
    @rozbey2504 5 років тому +25

    Tridev,Vishwatma,Mohra all directed by Rajiv Rai changed the destiny of Naseeruddin Shah's movie career. He later also did Asambhav again directed by Rajiv Rai. He had great collaboration with Rajiv Rai Trimurti films.

  • @vivekmishra-xw9hu
    @vivekmishra-xw9hu 5 років тому +118

    "Excellence Versus Excellence", it was more soothing & complementary as a Jugalbandi amongst. The questions were well crafted - positioned - prioritized. 300th Step manifested its height. Also the birth of new word "Classiquiyana", which will remain forever.

    • @NavinGulia
      @NavinGulia 5 років тому +3

      Exactly

    • @FunjollyWood
      @FunjollyWood 5 років тому +4

      well said but Classiqiyana, classikiyat, classiki is already being used in urdu.

    • @obliquequanta7320
      @obliquequanta7320 5 років тому +3

      OhO! No! Classiquiyana or Classiciana is the word first used by Rabindranath Tagore. Irfan sab has also said that in the interview if you have carefully listen you will get it may be it just passed by. Doesn't matter if you listen again you'll get it. Tagore said " classiquiyana r moho" meaning the 'sticking too much to classicism ' is not good and does not do any good to creativity. Creativity should flow with spontaneity which Nassir sab has mentioned but said it also has its root in truth but difference is Tagore said that creativity should not commit in totality to the rigor that classicism seems to dictate. Tagore himself was trained classics and its ways and means as far as creativity is concerned. He also knew that yes that it also has its root in truth otherwise it could not have become classics in the first place. But actually here Nassir sab and Tagore are saying about the different aspects of the same thing and Irfan sab has raised the point which concerns with the methods of approaching. However it was great to hear Nassir Sab with somuch energy and passion about his art and how he came to be what he has become. It's always invigorating to listen to Nassir Sab especially when interview is conducted by someone like Irfan Sab. Splendid!

    • @syedmuhammad2144
      @syedmuhammad2144 5 років тому +3

      Mishra Ji, you are absolutely right but the world "classiqiana" is neither derived from English, Hindi, Urdu or Persian. It is totally wrong.
      The right word is classiki in Urdu. However, no doubt this interview is excellent.
      Tashfeen Syed, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

    • @bahadursk9151
      @bahadursk9151 5 років тому +2

      Nasiruddin

  • @dr.balgovindsingh9268
    @dr.balgovindsingh9268 3 роки тому

    नसीरुद्दीन के साथ यह संवाद एक अभिनेता और साथ ही एक व्यक्ति के समग्र को समझने का इरफान साहब का बहुत उम्दा प्रयास है।विशेष रूप अभिनय से जुड़े उच्च स्तरीय एवं वैधानिक प्रश्न और वैसे ही बढ़िया उत्तर। पूरी बात चीत(गुफ्तगू)को रंगमंच तथा सिनेमा की दुनिया का एक आधिकारिक प्रपत्र (दस्तावेज) बनाते हैं।इस पूरे कार्यक्रम में इरफ़ान साहब ने अपना बेहतर देने का सफल प्रयास किया है। इसी क्रम में नसीर साहब को समझने में मुझ जैसे छोटे लोगों को बड़ी कामयाबी मिली है,इसके पहले मैं इन्हें हल्के... ।यदि कोई चाहे तो उनके विवादित बयानों को एक आम भारतीय नागरिक का बयान मान ले तो उनका बचाव हो सकता है।धन्यवाद !

  • @navjiwanhira3888
    @navjiwanhira3888 3 роки тому +19

    These interviews of Guftagoo are so so Real... So organic... So natural... And even the silences of conversationalists are magical.... Even their pauses don't boar you... You are still glued to the show!!

  • @am_ac
    @am_ac 5 років тому +18

    Irfan ji is by far the best host ..the questions he asks the mildness he has in his tone and even his knowledge is too good..
    Thank you Rajya Sabha
    More power to you guys.

  • @koul09876
    @koul09876 5 років тому +88

    Bollywood can not handle him..i think we seen 10% of his talent only

    • @karamjitsingh-im9rx
      @karamjitsingh-im9rx 5 років тому +1

      Yes it is true

    • @rudrankpatel379
      @rudrankpatel379 4 роки тому +5

      Bollywood spends time making shitty movies. How it can fully utilize naseer sahab. Wish web series were on his time

    • @jayantkumarbasu5378
      @jayantkumarbasu5378 4 роки тому

      Naseer chootiye ko lega kaun, har ek ko gyan deta phirta hai

    • @apratimbordoloi4056
      @apratimbordoloi4056 3 роки тому +4

      @@jayantkumarbasu5378 Chup saale chutiye....tum bhisdiwalon ko uski film samjh bhi nhi ayegi

    • @sanjeevchauhan522
      @sanjeevchauhan522 2 роки тому

      Nonsense, he has given a lot to indian cienema.

  • @manutrivedi1891
    @manutrivedi1891 5 років тому +11

    Interviewing Shah is a challenge. The interviewer is clearly up to it. Amongst the most fullfilling interviews I've seen. Brilliant. This is old world classy television programming.

  • @ad84_71
    @ad84_71 5 років тому +13

    long time coming for mr shah...बहुत ही बढ़िया साक्षात्कार लिया आपने इरफ़ान साहब। बहुत बहुत बधाई।

  • @SaurabhPathak23
    @SaurabhPathak23 5 років тому +11

    इरफ़ान साहब आपका बहोत बहोत शुक्रिया...

  • @zulfizulfiqar9377
    @zulfizulfiqar9377 4 роки тому +6

    He is my " Asadullah Khan Ghalib". What a great artist Naseer sahab is.

  • @moinkhan3744
    @moinkhan3744 5 років тому +72

    When you hear Naseer Saab voice it's sets in your brain and settles there permanently.

    • @krishanrathi9119
      @krishanrathi9119 4 роки тому +5

      @@thalatarani do not stress, pea sized brain will not understand Nasser, you could watch mithun chakraverty son !!

    • @thalatarani
      @thalatarani 4 роки тому

      @@krishanrathi9119 mam hats off to you, you're judging my IQ based on a youtube comment. That's very smart indeed!
      BTW, Mithun da atleast does not shit and eat in the same plate

  • @ravi9320
    @ravi9320 5 років тому +37

    Great interview Irfan sir...highest order of intellectual conversation great to listen and learn simultaneously...truthful reflection of a flawless actor Nasser Sir..thanks for the interview.

  • @personaldata1270
    @personaldata1270 Рік тому +1

    Naseer ji has inspired so many actors that came later and became really good actors... Actor like irfan khan is one grt example

  • @SKarthikeyan75
    @SKarthikeyan75 2 роки тому +1

    What a great interviewer! Rajya Sabha TV interviews are among the best. Such thoughtful engaging questions. Naseeruddin Shah does not suffer fools. I am sure he positively delighted in the interviewers questions - they were smart and provocative without being personal. Amazing! I miss this level of unabashed unpretentious intellectualism on other Indian TV programs.

  • @shyamnarayantiwari4336
    @shyamnarayantiwari4336 Рік тому +1

    नसीर साहब को देखना खुशकिस्मत है,शानदार इंटरव्यू

  • @firojhasami5072
    @firojhasami5072 5 років тому +21

    thanks rstv for such a great programme i like too much the presenting style of anchor irfan sir & his voice.

  • @CatWorld_101
    @CatWorld_101 5 років тому +83

    Started the interview with a bang as usually, with that first question itself makes the interviewee starts respecting you, one more elegant, thoughtful interview, thanks Irfan sir!

    • @vickkay6516
      @vickkay6516 5 років тому

      shut the fuck up, no one cares about your stupid opinion

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 4 роки тому

      @mohammad Basha
      Everything about MohMadism is fake. Your and my names are Yahood/Jew bit Bedouinized but MohMadism ask us to hate Jews/Yahood & kill them. Your & my DNA is native Dharmik one but MohMadism asks us to hate everything native including our ancestors who gave that Dharmik DNA. Today there are more fake Khans in LaWhore than real Khans ever existed in Mongolia where Khans come from. Similarly there are more fake Qureshis in Karachi than the real ones ever existed in Saudi Barbaria.

  • @pritishacharya9070
    @pritishacharya9070 3 роки тому +2

    bahut hi accha laga. Nasir ji ka interview. Irfan is a great interviewer. He is the master of interview.

  • @thespontaneousvlogger6168
    @thespontaneousvlogger6168 4 роки тому +7

    i wrote down almost 10 pages from this class today . thanks its epic .

  • @rajnishdham9091
    @rajnishdham9091 2 роки тому +1

    The Greatest actor India has ever produced along with Kamal Hasan sir.

  • @nitrand
    @nitrand 5 років тому +21

    Irfan speaks real Hindustani - a good mix of Hindi and Urdu.

  • @AzeemaFaizunnisa
    @AzeemaFaizunnisa 5 років тому +39

    Nasir is one of the best actors out there..

    • @KUNALKUMAR-en8nu
      @KUNALKUMAR-en8nu 3 роки тому +1

      According to manoj Bajpai..nasir saab adakari ke antim lafz hain.

  • @moviesplanet9482
    @moviesplanet9482 5 років тому +7

    Naseerudin shah sahb is more than an actor he is an inspiration himself

  • @haseebzahoor4770
    @haseebzahoor4770 Рік тому +1

    Naseeruddin_Shah is a (Pure Legend)❤😊

  • @sanjaykhan4454
    @sanjaykhan4454 3 роки тому +9

    52:15 see the attention of Learning of Irfan sir....What a Interviewer ? What a Listener Irfan Sir is ?
    Have any body notice that attention in Irfan Sir eyes ?
    👇🏻

  • @sachinmundhe9579
    @sachinmundhe9579 4 роки тому +7

    Legendary man😎👏🇮🇳
    kudos to the shriram Lagoo who is no more RIP 💐💐💐

    • @roshannagwanshi4524
      @roshannagwanshi4524 4 роки тому

      He's not dead bro

    • @dr.nandinik7780
      @dr.nandinik7780 3 роки тому

      @@roshannagwanshi4524 Dr Shriram lagu is no more he died in Dec 2019 he was an ENT surgeon and a gr8 actor

  • @ashish0808
    @ashish0808 3 роки тому +4

    Such deep and insightful questions from the interviewer...He is working in the wrong industry...He would have been a gem if he was in Hollywood unlike the shallow Rajeev Masand, Anupama Chopra & Co..

  • @noshulal
    @noshulal 5 років тому +7

    Naseer the genius ...Acting university... Great Actor

  • @chhhattisgarh
    @chhhattisgarh 5 років тому +8

    Congratulations on completing 300 inspiring episodes......

  • @satyengusain976
    @satyengusain976 3 роки тому +2

    Really A Good Human Being...

  • @vasdevhemnani7658
    @vasdevhemnani7658 5 років тому +8

    With all due respect to Naseer bhai, I have never seen an interviewer overshadowing his guest like this. Naseer bhai and only Naseer bhai could come close answering such questions. Irfan saahb is unmatchable. Lots of love from Pakistan.

  • @snr5950
    @snr5950 5 років тому +14

    Respected Irfan Sir, immensely grateful to you for uploading this video clip on Mr Naseeruddin Shah[ a long awated outstanding personality]..Happy Dushehra festival n warm greetings to you n your family. Thanx to RSTV n its team of Guftugu....

  • @sagar07wagh
    @sagar07wagh 4 роки тому +8

    He spoke about Dr Shriram Lagu - India's or worlds best theater actor 30:22

  • @sheezamunir9430
    @sheezamunir9430 3 роки тому +5

    I love the interviewer he made actor to reveal himself today we see lack of this kind of art form unfortunately 😞

  • @mayurnayudu3376
    @mayurnayudu3376 28 днів тому

    Naseer Sirji ka voice is very rare . Big fan of his unmistakable voice.

  • @986manav
    @986manav 5 років тому +3

    A much-awaited episode of guftagoo. Enjoyed it!

  • @sumankataria4964
    @sumankataria4964 3 роки тому +2

    34:10 कमाल है सर आप जो इतना सोचते हैं
    Kaas सारे एक्टर ऎसे सोचते तो कितना अच्छा होता Great है आप sir
    Nassir sir ❤️👌मजा आ गया

  • @user-cd4nb6wz3d
    @user-cd4nb6wz3d 2 роки тому

    हमें आपसे प्रेम है नसीरुद्दीन शाह जी क्योंकि आप पूर्णता (perfection) की तलाश ताउम्र करते रहे।।

  • @vishramacharya159
    @vishramacharya159 3 роки тому +1

    I'm very fortunate that I have seen his all types movies. He is a very grat actor & very honest. Very nice interview by Mr. Irfan.👍

  • @bansariparmar5620
    @bansariparmar5620 5 років тому +33

    Thanks RSTV
    I am big fan of your voice Irfaan sir

    • @napoleanthgrt
      @napoleanthgrt 5 років тому +2

      Haven't seen such an intellectual interview of an Indian Actor .Salute to both Greats .

    • @rohansharma8302
      @rohansharma8302 5 років тому +1

      @@napoleanthgrt
      Bro she won't reply.

  • @asmrhealwav.5321
    @asmrhealwav.5321 3 місяці тому

    Irfan sir aapke baat karne me ek mehak si aati he...jo mujhe 24 saal piche le jaati he..jab me Agra me kisi tang gali me duphar ki garmi ke tale.. kisi puraane khoobsurat aur majboot patthar se bane ghar me....ek sahab ke saamne betha hu...aur mene nikkar, polo t shirt aur cap pehne hue haath me sharbat pakda he...mere Papa ji aur wo saahab baat kr rahe he...aur mujhse baat kr raha he wo kamra...aur fir unn sahab ne mujhe bulaa kr santre waali toffy di apne safed kurte se nikaal kr...aur unka sparsh bhot sukoonbhara tha...aur kuch Itra ki mahak mehsoos hui...jisse me aajtak nhi bhool saka...AUR WOHI MAHAK AAPKE INTERVIEWS ME AATI HE....SHUKRIYA🌹

  • @rsingh3453
    @rsingh3453 Рік тому +1

    What a complete man in all fields, salute Naseer sir

  • @mayankchoubey3197
    @mayankchoubey3197 5 років тому +31

    Thank you Irfan Sir..!! I respect and adore your style of conducting interviews..!! It's very good that you question the correct things to everyone considering their body of understanding of their art..!! Like everybody else, I was awaiting for this episode as he is one of my favorite actors and I also love the fact that Naseer sahab loves irrfan Khan's acting style..!! I am a huge admirer...!! Thank you again Irfan Sir for this wonderful experience..!!

  • @sushmasingh8008
    @sushmasingh8008 5 років тому +4

    Shandar! shukriya!

  • @ushatitikshuphoto
    @ushatitikshuphoto 5 років тому +3

    Waiting to watch film by you Dear Naseer which will satisfy you. It's lovely to hear and feel this conversation between Naseer and Dear Irfan. WOW.

  • @samarthnagarkar
    @samarthnagarkar Рік тому

    An interview is often as good as the interviewer. This anchor is brilliant.

  • @mithunchakrabortylove1106
    @mithunchakrabortylove1106 3 роки тому +5

    Excellent Program & Interview, Shri Naseeruddin Shah Ji is A Great Villan & My Favourite Actor in The World.

  • @Ajitinsidehit8586
    @Ajitinsidehit8586 Рік тому +1

    One of the greatest actor in Bollywood film industry..I don't want to compare but I think he is second greatest actor after Dilip Kumar

  • @anilchaudhari6231
    @anilchaudhari6231 5 років тому +3

    काफी अच्छा इंटरव्यू रहा सुन के देख के काफी कुछ समझने को मिला इसके लिए आप दोनों लोगों को बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद

  • @rohitkathuria1840
    @rohitkathuria1840 4 роки тому +1

    naseer sahib and irfan sahib both are gems..

  • @mukulsingh1141
    @mukulsingh1141 5 років тому +2

    Finally it came ...And I was waiting for him so long

  • @LIFE-CRICKET-TRAVELS
    @LIFE-CRICKET-TRAVELS 3 роки тому +2

    one of the best interviews I have ever heard.

  • @mking7325
    @mking7325 2 роки тому

    Itne dino ke baad itni shaista zuban sunni dil bagh bagh hogsya shukriya Rsjabahya TV 💯💯💥👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏

  • @nasheedguyasalways
    @nasheedguyasalways 5 років тому +5

    Learnt so much about film art and literature from this engaging conversation with Naseer sb. Thank you Irfan sb. Regards from Pakistan

  • @sanketkulkarni2390
    @sanketkulkarni2390 5 років тому +10

    Was waiting for this since long time

  • @pebblestones123
    @pebblestones123 5 років тому +6

    superb interview.. so much relevance he made about filmmaking and its process.. so many budding actors can learn so much from him.. terrific!!!!

  • @anish4555
    @anish4555 5 років тому +3

    Really engaging interview! Naseer Saab is an institute in himself. Every word of his is informative! Courtesy: A great interviewer!

  • @srinivaspillai4622
    @srinivaspillai4622 4 роки тому +11

    When we think of Mr Naseeruddin shah, brilliant actor of highest scale without doubt,not political correct kind, honest confession, man of immense sensitivity with frankness, not a pussy feet kind, man of substance, coming to the interview,very nice, actors actor was fantastic, thanks for the video.

  • @aslammohammad8568
    @aslammohammad8568 3 роки тому +2

    Greetings on 300th episode Irfan sb very perfectly questioned live long

  • @utv1999
    @utv1999 5 років тому +3

    excellent Urdu,English and voice.

  • @brilliantminds8497
    @brilliantminds8497 5 років тому +12

    Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you so much Irrfan sir. I was waiting for this like anything.

  • @asifparkar31
    @asifparkar31 5 років тому +33

    According to me the greatest actors ever in India are Balraj Sahni, Pankaj Kapoor and Naseeruddin Shah...What a great institution in acting he is

    • @2sridhark
      @2sridhark 5 років тому +3

      I don't think you know anything about South Indian actors, do you?
      Shivaji Ganeshan is better than all of them put together!

    • @rajendrasoni4327
      @rajendrasoni4327 5 років тому +2

      @@2sridhark Maybe he didn't watch south movies and you haven't watched the artist's mentioned by him closely hence you have come with south and north which is very pertinent these days from most southies as if it's not part of India or Indian movie industry. Anyways, only actor's who are well known and greatest actor of all time in my opinion from south movies who happens to have worked in Hindi movies too are Kamal Hassan and Mohanlal. Don't be surprised if I haven't mentioned Rajni Sir's name as he is one of the greatest entertainer across.
      Asif, I guess you missed Dilip Kumar and Nana patekar in your list for greatest actor's of all time.

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 5 років тому +3

      Niloo Phule, SriRam Lagu, Kashinath Ghanekar

    • @synhope3746
      @synhope3746 5 років тому +3

      Let me ask you, can Bal Raj Sahni do the role of decoit of Ganga Jamuna or double Role of Ram Shyam or tragic role of Devadas and Shikast or romance of Madhumati or the Prince of Mughal e Azam or dashing role of AAN and others. The answer is NO. He was a good actor. No doubt. But, he is nowhere near Dilip Kumar. Nowhere. How many actors got inspired by Balraj Sahni. None. Amitabh rightly said, INDUSTRY WILL BE KNOWN BEFORE AND AFTER DILIP KUMAR. Yes, Naseer is a versatile actor. No doubt. His role of Ghalib was just stunning.

    • @ammarkhan5688
      @ammarkhan5688 5 років тому +1

      Asif Parkar and dialup kumar

  • @ranbirsinghraman1554
    @ranbirsinghraman1554 5 років тому +11

    वैसे तो इरफ़ान साहब आपका हर इंटरव्यू बेहतरीन और लाजवाब होता है। लेकिन इस खुसुसी इंटरव्यू को आपने इतने नैचुरल और बाकमाल ढंग से किया है कि यह एक बेशकीमती यादगार इंटरव्यू रहेगा। आपका बहुत बहुत शुक्रिया अदा करता हूं।
    . Ranbir Singh Raman.

    • @budhrajarahul3
      @budhrajarahul3 5 років тому

      bakamal shabd se aapne apni hindi ko uthane ka kya bakhoob prayatan kia hai jaanab..bemisal.

    • @siddhant3093
      @siddhant3093 5 років тому

      @@budhrajarahul3 lagta hai aapko urdu se koi gila hai janaab? ☺️

    • @budhrajarahul3
      @budhrajarahul3 5 років тому

      @@siddhant3093 aapko kitni urdu aati hai?? ya sirf khud ko cool dikhane ke lie ye farmaya..:P

    • @siddhant3093
      @siddhant3093 5 років тому

      @@budhrajarahul3 yeh bhi pehli martaba ilm hua ke cool lagne ke liye bhi urdu bolte hain log. Beherhaal rahi meri baat toh darasal baat yuun hai huzuur e waalaah ke humein urdu se mohabbat hai. Hum yeh toh nahi kahenge ke hum urdu ke maahir hain, bas yahi kahenge ke kaafi hadd tak samajh aur bol lete hain, aur jitna seekh sakein seekh letein hain. ☺️

    • @budhrajarahul3
      @budhrajarahul3 5 років тому

      @@siddhant3093 haha bhai kyu apna mazak banwa rha hai..itni urdu kisi ko bhi aati h..or jitna tu dikhane ki koshish kr raha hai ye saaf hai ki tu abhi nadaan hai..lol..or beta cool to hai hi urdu zabaan..kyuki sbke bas ki nhi bolna saaf urdu..or jis hisab se tu khud ko humble dikha rha hai phle utna urdu bolna to seekh bad me amitabh bachan ki tarah humble banna..:P

  • @kissekahaniyanbyatul3112
    @kissekahaniyanbyatul3112 5 років тому +25

    ३००वी प्रस्तुति पर बधाई. साक्षात्कार की उत्कृष्टता की पराकाष्ठा दर्शाती प्रस्तुति. न केवल साक्षात्कार कैसे करें सिखाते हैं आप बल्कि जीवन में अपने अपने क्षेत्रों की गहराईयों, उतार चढ़ावों और सफलताओं को कैसे 'हैंडल' करें, देखने वाले को यह भी सीखने का मौका मिलता है. आपको बधाई.

    • @salimalvi5178
      @salimalvi5178 4 роки тому

      Bhaiwood & Kirkit are opium fed to natives by anti-national (anti-nativity) crooks & criminals who were given reigns of power by BriShits while leaving India. This opium kept natives in stupor and their native roots were systematically cut. Repeat with me, " Bhaiwoody UrduShurdu ne Kiya nikamma warna hum bhi the kuch kaam ke aur kuch naam ke Chini ki tarah." Islam is Weapon of Mass Destruction & enslavement of natives. Today Anglos/BriShits have mastered its use by creating Khilafa like Khilafa E Lundoni Chiknah Jinah, Khilafa E Lootyani ConAngrez Mughal Bandit NehruGazi and recent Khilafa Al Baghdadi. China was smart to ban Islam & Christianity. Xinjiang was 99% MohMadden in 1949, today it is less than 20%. China is merely wearing Burkha of Marxism but in reality it is strengthening & spreading its native Han Chini roots.
      Everything about MohMadism is fake. Your and my names are Yahood/Jew bit Bedouinized but MohMadism ask us to hate Jews/Yahood & kill them. Your & my DNA is native Dharmik one but MohMadism asks us to hate everything native including our ancestors who gave that Dharmik DNA. Today there are more fake Khans in LaWhore than real Khans ever existed in Mongolia where Khans come from. Similarly there are more fake Qureshis in Karachi than the real ones ever existed in Saudi Barbaria.

  • @dchoudhury3071
    @dchoudhury3071 4 роки тому +2

    One of the greatest actor ever (east or west)

  • @muslimkhan1566
    @muslimkhan1566 3 роки тому +1

    Lajawab actor mr nasiruddeen saahab verry nice

  • @vaibhavtaragi8021
    @vaibhavtaragi8021 3 роки тому +3

    You can listen to naseer sir for hours and hours without getting bored and with full curiosity,He is the institution of flawless acting we are lucky enough to witness an artist like him.

  • @pradeepsonee6436
    @pradeepsonee6436 5 років тому +176

    आज मैंने अभिनय कि गीता को सुन लिया ।

    • @cristykumar244
      @cristykumar244 5 років тому +3

      bhai agr bharatiya cinema me choti ke abhineta ki baat aayegi to naseer saheb ka asthan phle 10 me hoga

    • @punittiwari212
      @punittiwari212 5 років тому +5

      @@cristykumar244 shayad top pe hoga

    • @budhrajarahul3
      @budhrajarahul3 5 років тому +3

      pradeep sonee ke sathi pyar ka maine chun lia..chun lia..

    • @jayeshagrawal9472
      @jayeshagrawal9472 5 років тому

    • @shivkantverma8497
      @shivkantverma8497 5 років тому +2

      एक प्रश्न और बनता था कि - साथी अभिनेताओं की वे कौन सी भूमिकाएँ हैं जिन्हें अगर ये करते तो शायद बिगाड़ देते ?
      एक और - अभिनेता के तौर पर क्या कमियाँ अब भी हैं जो सालती हैं ?

  • @johnabraham9953
    @johnabraham9953 5 років тому +2

    Love from Kashmir --Naseer sahib 😍 Allah apko lambi umer dai ----

  • @Vikasgoodvibes
    @Vikasgoodvibes 3 роки тому +1

    Really enjoy the interviews.
    Naseer sahab was as usual Speaking without any hesitation.

  • @gatikrushna7973
    @gatikrushna7973 2 роки тому +1

    We just learned so much.

  • @sanjaykumartewary8497
    @sanjaykumartewary8497 3 роки тому +12

    Irrfaan Sahab,
    I sincerely thank you for this programme of yours. This is not an exaggeration to say that this is my most favorite programme. I often go into a sort of depression and feel quite listless and your Guftagoo available in UA-cam brings me back to my real self elevating my spirit . Your Guftagoo has a cathartic effect on me. Your interviews in some way resemble first rate serious movies pregnant with profound meanings.
    Thanks once again.
    A true admirer
    Sanjay Kumar Tewary

  • @shamshadhusain4737
    @shamshadhusain4737 2 роки тому +1

    Irfan Sb, You are really great interviewer with ocean of knowledge to bring the intervieng to talk very openly about thair personal life even..!!
    So hats of to you..!
    Thanks Rajya Sabha Tv for the wonderful program and wonder interviewer..!

  • @vikaramkumar4482
    @vikaramkumar4482 Рік тому +1

    Both the interviewee and the interviewer are extraordinary !
    Simply superb !
    The way Irfaan saab conducts this programme is to be seen to be believed.
    He doesn't put his words into the mouth of his guests but allows them to speak what is in their mind.
    He gives them full freedom to express their views. He doesn't interrupt in between.
    No doubt Irfaan saab is one of the best anchors one could ever wish to see.
    As far as Naseer saab is concerned, his honesty is reflected on his face and his voice.
    He is such a great actor and his contribution to Indian cinema is second to none.
    Its good to see two such learned, erudite and honest persons together.
    This interview is worth a watch.
    Love and respect to both of them.

  • @aarifboy
    @aarifboy 5 років тому +120

    He looks like Einstein in some photos of old age hehe

  • @mkmphysio9555
    @mkmphysio9555 Рік тому +1

    Both are Legend 👌🏼

  • @yogendrapratapsingh5803
    @yogendrapratapsingh5803 5 років тому +5

    love you Naseer sahab.....

  • @hitesh324
    @hitesh324 5 років тому +15

    Watched it once..will be watching again to understand and ingrain the good things from the Great Man..Thanks Irfan Ji...:)

  • @s.kartandentertainment9106
    @s.kartandentertainment9106 5 років тому +2

    Nasiruddin sir is my inspiration and my one of the favourite actor in the world.☺☺

  • @mbproduction2504
    @mbproduction2504 5 років тому

    Nasir saheb aap jaise log to hum jaise actor ke perception ko v change kar dete hain....thnku so much
    Irfan jee u r great

  • @LuckyYadav-nj6mt
    @LuckyYadav-nj6mt 4 роки тому +1

    शुक्रिया इरफ़ान साहब आज में 5 वी बार देखा

  • @sanjoybhattacharjee8261
    @sanjoybhattacharjee8261 5 років тому +2

    what an insightful discussion .... thanks for sharing