Did Ayesha Cheat on Prophet Muhammad?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лип 2024
- Join our social media networking
networking.harrissultan.com
You can also support my work by donating either via Paypal or by becoming a patron.
Patreon
/ exmuslim
Paypal
paypal.me/harrissultan
You can also follow me on following social media platforms.
Twitter: @TheHarrisSultan
Instagram: TheHarrisSultan
Follow me on Telegram
t.me/harrissultanSpeaks - Розваги
Reference Ibn Ishaq pages 493-499
Thank you
My question would be, shouldn’t she have some female maids accompany her? I think it’s stupid to think a wife of Muhammad was accompanied by male servants alone. Hence, why didn’t the female servants made sure she got into her ‘howder’ or whatever before taking off?
@Hisham Malik Bro, there is Ijmah on this story. There is no disagreement in the scholars about the accusation of adultery on Ayesha
@@HarrisSultanAtheist
Fact: The Self-Deceiving Atheists Problematic Issue
Can someone like you (Harris Sultan), a self-deceiving Atheist really afford to answer this quite a very simple '2 in 1' question, properly, correctly and perfectly? Or just pretend or divert as a pretext to avoid from answering the so-called truth?
Q1: If there's a chair, there must be a chair-maker (the maker of the chair), mustn't there? 'Yes' or 'No'?
and,
Q2. If there's the sun, there must be the sun-Creator (the Creator of the sun), mustn't there? 'Yes' or 'No'?
Note: The dumbest human on earth is the one who simply deceives his/her own-self’s natural innate. That’s pretty fact!
@@HarrisSultanAtheist
@ FACT: THE PROBLEMS WITH IBN ISHAQ | HOW AUTHENTIC IS THE WORK OF IBN ISHAQ
"Something old doesn't mean authentic"
Why Ibn Ishaq work isn't reliable?
"The Life of Muhammad" by Ibn Ishaq has been quoted by many critics of Islam. They get excited when Ibn Ishaq paints a bad picture of Prophet Muhammad and use it in their writings to attack Islam. Although Ibn Ishaq was the earliest of the traditionalists to write a biography of the events that pertained to the time of Muhammad there are several severe problems with his writings. Bassam Zawadi a Muslim missionary says" Just because something is early doesn't mean it is true". He has a good point. Not everyone back then was reliable and honest. Ibn Ishaq was known to be careless in him collecting stories about the Prophet, etc.
Several respected Muslim theologians rightly reject his (Ibn Ishaq's) authority for several reasons:
(A) That he was a Shiite favouring Ali over all the other contenders to the Khalifa.
(B) His Isnads (chains of transmissions) were defective, i.e not 'iron' tight by naming all the reporters, which is important because this determines whether the transmitter of the story is trustworthy or not. Ibn Ishaq was not an eye witness to any of the events of Prophet Muhammad's life. Ibn Ishaq was writing about 150 years after the Prophet's death so this is very important. In Islamic sciences in order for a report of the Prophet (peace be on him) to be true is if the isnad is solid or not.
(D) He used reports of traditions gathered from Jewish sources. Jews made up a lot of false stories/legends of Prophet Muhammad (just like the early Christians living outside of Palestine made up a lot of myths and legends of Jesus and put them in the Gospels). Making up stories and legends about the Prophet are unacceptable in the eyes of many Islamic scholars.
(E) Ibn Ishaq was (for lack of better term) a "suck up" to the Jews of Arabia. He said several complimentary reports of the Jews of Arabia, despite the fact that the Jews of Arabia were constantly fighting with the Arabs and were charging interest when loaning money. The Jews of Madinah were constantly plotting against the Prophet Muhammad. They were always trying to undermine his authority. In fact they sided with the Makkans in order to assassinate the Prophet.
(F) Most important of all, his report about Laylat al Qadr (the first revelation), contradicts all the hadith versions. The hadith collectors Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawud, etc were more careful in collecting their hadith (their chains of transmission).
(G) There are several stories in Ibn Ishaq which are never found in the hadith. The reason why is because several hadith collectors such as Bukhari - did not trust Ibn Ishaq.
(H) Ibn Ishaq live among the Shiite Muslims and Jews and was heavily inspired by Jewish and Shi'i traditions
(I) Ibn Ishaq is refer to as one of the early scholar for the development of Shia. Some of his work is even criticize by Shiite scholar. His works contains false stories regarding Prophet Muhammad and contradicts the hadith.
(J) Many prominent scholars such as Imam Hanbal had rejected his narrations, others hardly use his narrations in their works.
(K) Ibn Ishaq original biography (Sirah) did not survive. The modern day biography has been mixed and revised with the work of Ibn Hisham.
That always bothered me when I was a muslim. Thanks Harris Sultan
@jameel kuthubdeen Okay Lets say, all these people you named are Bad peoples, but yours so called Best human being ever lived Prophet, why did he married a Child.. ?
@@Abhnv1337Respected mother Ayesha raziallaahu taala unha was 16 years of age at the time of her marriage.
What is your problem?
@naman vohra You don't know anything Naman vohra. It seems you are just obsessed with hatred without no reason. Don't ever abuse our mother.
Otherwise in return you will get the same thing. So let's just respect each others religious beliefs. We don't abuse other's religious icons. You also shouldn't.
Then first change your name. Don't be a hypocrite.
@jameel kuthubdeen not you bro.
I told this to that Al mir or what.
This sounds like a haram relationship 😆😆
@UCmDQ3dAyb68GdObV9lkAUVw
Nope.
She was a virgin
Pure according to Quran and Bible
@abc
God
@abc
Father is the Creator
He have no father
@abc 😂
@@RoarT19 why not create without womb of a women
It would seem to me that lots of Muslim Women have affairs when they can get away with it. It's not about sex, it's about revenge for being treated badly and as second class citizens.
That's maybe true but Ayesha wouldn't cheat because the Prophet loved her.
@@mugzA21 Probably not. From what I have read about her it seems she was pretty smart.
That's a risky move when you can get stoned to death for it.
@@mugzA21 may be Muhammad did but I don't think a lady would love a man who once molested her. Many times she disagreed with him and complained about that Allah always fulfill every desire of him. She was smart and it is even believed that she poisoned Muhammad.
@@alliedatheistalliance6776 That's why she was very smart with Mohammed & muslims. No way Mohammad would harm Abu Bakr's daughter. Mohammad feared Abu Bakr & Umar who knew about him they were all accomplice to establish this religion (as it would give them all power, status, class, wealth, lands, armies, women etc). Mohammad was kept at front as to develop this religion since he originally planned it. So no way would Mohammed fuck up with Ayesha as she knew him well & his fraudulent things. She agreed to stick with it bcz she wanted to be most powerful Islamic lady & wanted her father to take over Caliphate
Then, according to Hadith, it was not enough that the witnesses had seen her lying naked on a man. Now compare that with How easy it is to convict a woman in an Islamist country for sexual infidelity. in Iran, the claim that the woman showed a smile to a man could suffice. or that she had been staying alone but with a man in a house
Roses are Red 🌹
Sky is blue 🔵
Ayesha was 9 🧕
Mohammed was 52 👴
Muhammad 53-aisha6
Muhammad56-aisha9.
Violets are blue .... sugar is sweet ...😃😃😃
Before Aisha married the Prophet, he was engaged.
@CHEANG HAN BIN Moe
Mary 12 e90 Joseph
Your sick Christianity
@@sajeevtb8415
Fuckoff who 50 55 53 57 fuckogf
I'm really glad that i came to know the truth about all these nonsense things and so called "prophet" ......and you always keep us aware about those things , thankyou @harrissultan
Damn gurl.Your hotter than Salsa Valentina
what about ali who married his bhatijee. short little perv.
Poor Aisha became widow at the age of 15 only poor girl 😢😢😢
If she had marry Muhammad follower it would have been better
I read it in scripture.
Muhammad touched her sexually when she was 6 years old only
At age 9 sexual intercourse.
Muhammad loves his youngest wife it seems he loves to sleep with Aisha more than any wife it seems.
That shows his lustful nature.
With these basis I will consider him as a false prophet simple
Wow this is crazy. Keep up the good work Harris!
I hope she did, I hope she had a better life than being married to a pedo and having her puppy taken away plus all the other shit
Poor aisha.. treated so badly
So much gasslighting and stonewalling in this story.
A man who supposedly loves the woman, his wife but is unable to honestly communicate with her and believe her and eventually even forgive her or ignore her sin if she ever had committed adultery.
He just fueled up the evil gossip spreading and allowed people to sin in their thoughts and speach, allowed them to grow in their ego pride and contempt toward someone who should be sacred and haraam to them to even think of.
Completly sick and twisted when it comes to relationship patterns and when it comes to the setting example of the spiritual standards.
I mean how the hell can you rely on spiritistic channelling to get a truthful reliable information about whether your wife cheated on you or not. And wait for it for one month as well... Lol whilst your beloved wife suffered humiliation and possibly has been feeling threatened by severe consequences like stoning to death, whilst she was completly innocent. There's so much going so wrong in this story of a "role model".
unfortunately hes the example many men follow in the muslim world today
Fucked up stupidins
If Ayesha was wearing a full face veil, how was she recognized!!!???
ur able to recognise people from their eyes and height and how they are lol it’s easy
@@mmmelbs810 you are more clever than Muhammad!
Because at that time no hijab nikab was there it's all man made policy to control women
safwan must've had a heck of a time with aisha.
it must have been really tough to commit adultery in the time of the Prophet.
Ayesha was not cheating she just wanted to get rid of this bastard.
😑
Imagine a grown mad upset his 13 yo wife could have cheated
I just watched a documentary on Pakistan's blasphemy law and I realised that you're extremely brave, though you are not in the country. But at the same time, take precautions aplenty
Big point here that in Islam there is no punishment for rape in the Quran and second its difficult to prove rape cus u need 4 witness...
Is there anything in the list of evilness that the so called prophet live out and did not act upon?
Lool the title was dope 😂😂👌
That is absolutely horrible.
Isme kya sawal hee aayesha 25 sal ki hote ye 75 ka huva to performance kaha se dega?
The romans had the legion in a camp. Only military. Prostitutes, Slaves, merchandise etc. Was in the tross (german word- dont know the english).
Please share the page, so we can clarify it our own.
👏🙂
Interesting
12:50 good point
What is the source of what you are saying? Thank you!
It's Hadiths..
What is the hadith reference?
@@fishersofmen0419 I have heard this before as well but not rememring...Any ways all of hadiths are shit...what's use exploring Shit ..
We muslim only believe 100% on quraan, we take guideline from hadith but we know its man written thing, non muslims actually maligned through hadith, few illiterate people believe on fake hadith but we dont. See quraan (words of Allah), in this context.
@@Mahi-dq3fk when it's convenient it's sahi when not its daif or even sahi is not convenient they tell it's daif.
Shayad yahi se 'Char log kya kahenge' muhawara bana hoga.
Yes good point, you might be onto something!
Probably..
And don't forget , not only did they need 4witnesise Whatever ) they had to actually see the little pinky enter the tunnel of love. Rock n Roll !
Aysha was his favorite wife. Did not the revelations only come to him while he was with her?
As for his restraint, did Aysha not lament at some point in a hadith that he had struck her on her chest which caused her pain?
Revelation came when he was with her? Wrong.
The revelation came when he was crossdressed with Ayesha's clothes.
@@Sunil-wi4yw whaaaat lemme see that hadith lol
@@mireya_libre “Do not hurt me with Aisha, for the inspiration did not come upon me when I was in a women's garment except that of Aisha.” Sahih Bukhari 2393
@@mireya_libre you are still in doubt ? Then read about it many times everywhere in history.
Yes revelations only comes,when muhammad is in Aysha's clothes....
Aisha was a babe !
Ayesha got one on Momo this time.
the documentary wer can i find it ?
I wonder what would happen if someone makes a biopic on Hazarat Ayesha! 😏
@Brian Baker yeah I do watch his videos sometimes.
May be 18+ videos
its already there in prontub ..
what book is he reading/referencing, i'd like to read it. i see its called the life of muhammed, but by whom?
Ibn ishaq ,he wrote the first biography of muhammad
@@ggtheog7610 ty
I'm glad she did. That man was sick.
How you know?
yeah, he had syphillis which he had passed on to all his wives...that's why they were all barren!
Truth is very difficult to digest for d fanactics
Lesson learnt for girls: do not cheat on your spouse, you never knows if he ends up to be a prophet and makes verses that screw all women.
What, that makes no sense. If the verses come from "god, " they should not ruin everyone else because of one person's actions. Also, if Muhammad is the last prophet, no one would have to worry about that, because no one else would become a prophet.
It’s all washed up, down the line. Her missing from the convoy on their return and reappearing a day along with the youthful stranger is quite obvious of the cheat that happened. Mohammad downplayed it but not Ali. It in fact one of the reasons why Ali and Ayesha fell apart!!
I does not proves that she cheated. She was innocent.
@@faisalkhalil1625 doesn't matter if she did, he married a bunch of women, had sex with what his right hand possessed and then had the nerve to force himself on Maria, the slave girl of Hafsa and cheated on ALL wives.
"You could need a wife at any moment"
There were 3 witnesses ...so Mo chamged the rules and made it 4
Short answer- Yes.
When a non Arab muslims comes up me to talk about the beauty of Islam, I'll tell to read Quran 41.44 in front of me and walk away from them. The most effective way to leave them in cliff hanger
any credible source about the story? i'd like to do some reasearch
Life of Muhammad by Ibn Ishaq.
I wont blame aisha if she did cheat 🤪
Especially after he died. Poor girl was 18 and couldn't have a man for the rest of her life!
Feel sorry for this poor 9 year old.
In this instance how old was she?
35 kg.. probably 9 or 10 according to Harris.
Your opinion is silly
Prophet Wife was mature all hadiths
@I
📚 read
@@koza3350 Nope
what a load of bs adding your own lying details. if you can't even be honest about islam when criticising Islam what you're criticising is some fantasy juju land in your own head.
Was it 'morning sickness'
Is insident ke Baad 10 ayat nazil hue thi. Is ke Baad law bna. Agar ye waqia na hota to quranic law na bnta.
CSI and CMI together
Why 6 yr was matured to marry while 19 yr Fatima was too Yong for marriage?
The waited for her period and the disclose the ayat of non guilty. Harri Sugar coating for Safwan incident .
an expected plot twist :P
Harris bhai please make a cartoon and you write script for it and then explain it in the back ground. That will be much more interesting.
Missing the point. Actually, muhammad had to keep ayesha because he said once, that he got majority of allah’s revelations when he was on her cloths. Thus, if muhammad needed allah’s words, he must be on ayesha’s cloths.
Thanks for another great video. You are a true blessing to all mankind. I’ve learned so much about Islam from you. Both books agree that Jesus is the greatest miracle by God as the only virgin birthed blameless sinless messiah or savior and the Lord Jesus is now alive in Paradise having successfully accomplished his mission as the lamb sacrifice of God for the sins of the world. . Both books agree that Jesus is returning to Jerusalem to Judge and rule and reign as king of kings and Lord of Lords. Both books agree that we are all sinners Sura 14:34 and we all need a savior Sura 24:21.and Jesus is God’s mercy and provision for all mankind. Call on Jesus right now and have eternal life in Paradise
I don't know what all the FUSS is about MUHAMMAD & AYESHA
HE & She were BORN like any other HUMAN being
So THEY are Prone to Human FEELINGS & WEAKNESSES
Harris. Pl cite the chapter and verses of the book from you are speaking about.
Ibn Ishaq p 429-435
ala laanat ullah i alaeka ayuhal khabees ul fahaash ul badee.
Wow something ..that girl.
Shut upp
Muslims, ex Muslims and their logic !
Quran forbade the remarriages of prophets widow even 18 year old Aisha. Allah being cruel.
Mohamed made the rules 😂
Bsing objective here, if you read the story carefully, there were no “witnesses.” No one saw what happened between them. The three “witnesses” you refer to were simply ones who were spreading the news.
Put it this way; if aisha had cheated and Muhammad came in saying she’s innocent, she would have been the first ex Muslim. But she was clearly loyal to the prophet and believed in him as Islam was spread mainly through her teachings. That just doesn’t add up
Where do you do your business in a desert 🐪 😂
No, I don't think Ayesha cheated on Muhammad since Ayesha was really young when the alleged incident took place. It was actually the fault of Muslims to leave Aisha behind and the rumor spread. No wife of Muhammad cheated on him. It was Muhammad who cheated on Aisha and Hafsa when he was caught red handed hooking up with Mariyah Ibn Qibtiyah, the coptic slave he brought from a governer of Egypt.
Bingo
omggg really??? can i get the source on this please? ❤️❤️
@@trollmagnet8265 actually??? can i see the source please?
Oh Gosh! He was the Hue Haffener of his time.
Phew harris is so handsome!!!!!!!!!!! And thank god you’re an atheist. Haha
Were it is righting ali bet slav girl
Your life just Rumours
Why r u deleting the comments which are against u?
His saporter are reporting 😁
Your story telling is too verbose
Get to point
Urdu mei karo yar
Talibaan ke kisi amal ko aap Quran se nhi jor sakty.
Haris lets challenge, ,
If you accept that aisha did commit adultry ,you may be blind..
becoz who balmed her he became blind..
Do you accept that..??
@Patricia Hill
Hassan ibn Thabit was an Arabian poet and one of the Sahaba, or companions of Muhammad, hence he was best known for his poems in defense of the Islamic prophet Muhammad.
@Patricia Hill so you mean every man gets blind after 100? ..
@Patricia Hill
Narrated Masruq;
Hassan came to Aisha and said the following poetic Verse: 'A chaste pious woman who arouses no suspicion. She never talks against chaste heedless women behind their backs.' `Aisha said, "But you are not," I said (to `Aisha), "Why do you allow such a person to enter upon you after Allah has revealed: "surah 24:11: "For every person among them( accusers) is what [punishment] he has earned from the sin(of accuse)," (Surah 24.11).
She said, "What punishment is worse than blindness?" She added, "And he used to defend Allah's Apostle against the pagans (in his poetry).۔۔
Kyu na kare wo 6 sal ki aur popar Saab 62
Krishna married 166666
@@koza3350 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@koza3350 you must know the whole story behind it. It was a mark of respect to those kidnapped women that Krishna saved.
Yeeaaaaah I was the 100th to put a 👍🏼
This is a sign from allah
100 is 1 and 0 and 0
So 1 + 0 + 0 = 1 and 1 is the first number after 0
That's a miracle Harris
La la la la you are crazy
Ayesha did not commit any adultery'. Prophet should have known about it without mentally suffering for a month. However, what was the testimony of three accusers? Did they offer any eye-witness testimony ? Your research is incomplete. The Egyptian Generals during 1967 Arab-Israeli war in keeping with the Sunna of Prophet, took wives and family members to Sinai desert, staying in air-conditioned tents. They sent military helicopters to Cairo to bring ice cream. You know what happened to them. Keeping Sunna did not help one bit.
I'm jesus love you you believe my joke
But why would he mentally suffer for even a moment since being rasul and God's special one, he should have known of her innocence the moment she was accused🤷🏿♂️
@@samsonyusuf587 Gabriel was on vacation.
@@samsonyusuf587 Gabriel was on vacation. Everybody needs a time off.
@@Californiadesi 🤣
Travel Chanel
Islam: Duniya k pehle shaks Hazrate Adam alai salam hai aur yahi logic sahi hai.
Atheist: Atheist bolta hai kya ki pehle bahut chota sa tinka tha woh tinka bada hua aise karte karte insaan bana.
Islam: To woh chota sa tinka kaha se aaya.
@Bhai Patel ha ha ha ...exactly bro...
Kyunki Allah ko bananey wala Muhammed tha...
Uski sada hua dimag mai
Fir bata Allah kaha se ayaa
@Bhai Patel Allah tala ne hi uss chote se tinke ko banaya.
@@jaimimumbai Allah tala ne hi uss chote se tinke ko banaya.
@Bhai Patel 😁😁😁Hazrate Adam alai salam ka logic sahi maan raha hai
Lekin Allah tala ko nahi maan raha hai.
This guy is too good at lying hahaha
Can you specify what he's lying about?
May ALLAH Guide you and show you the righteous way, Little knowledge is very dangarous. Why are you spoiling your Akhirah Bro I hope you know very well Qaum-e-loot, Qaum-e-samood.Where is Firaun? Where is Shaddad?
Aur ham ne kafirun Kay ley zanjeery Aur tuq banay Hai alquran
haris was the real name of satan.
secondly, this story was fabricated by narrator to show disgrace to the Prophet Muhammad and negates the prophet's knowledge of unseen(ilm e ghaib) and to claim the revelation of SURAH E NOOR in aisha's name. not a single word in this story is true. it's full of lies. if you want true Islam study the Quran, Nehj al balagha, sahifa e sajjadia, Musnad al-Imam al-Baqir, Ma'athiru'l-Baqir, super man in Islam.
As a Shia what do you think? Did wife of prophet Muhammad commit adultery according to shia believe
Pls criticise mohammed; not abuse.. it will only provoke islamists.. they will not THINK.. our purpose shud b to make islamists THINK...and make them leave religion..
Qayamat Ke din kafir Kahyga khas Ke me mitthe huta alquran
She was 9.
No... six
Consummation happened at 9 but marriage done at 6... Islamic Sources.
@@doyoureallycare5740
9
Isaac married Rebecca 3
@@koza3350 no 6
Kafir keley aakhirat mezalalat Aur roswai Ke elawa kuch nahe milygaa
Mohammad KO kya Mila
Allah ki laanat ho tum pe
Why
Allah pe meri lanat bhar bhar ke barsaye jayein 😉 Aur Muhammad lanatullah par vi😁
No No No reham karo Maafi de do Harris ko tauba karne ka mauka do 🙏🙏🙏🙏😎😅😎
Allah hai to lanat ho. Agree. Par allah hi nahi hai to kya karein?
Sach maan lo
Muhammad par kyun Hui
Sari jhooti bakwas kr rha hay. Bahot si cheezain apni traf se shamil kr rha hay.
Islam hi ek bada jhoot ha
@@humanityfirst1774 Mr kumar agar aap apni baat man sachy ho to daleel (proof) den.
@@ahsanmuhammad1653 bro ager Allah ha tho wo sirf mohammad ko hi q boltha sarii roles actually mohammad chutiya banaratha logoko Or log ban bhi rahe
@@humanityfirst1774 bhai aap agar aap ko aik example deta hun.
Corona virus aap ko nazar nhi ata magar aik scientists ko nazar ata hay q k us ke pas dekhny Wali aankh(eye), telescope hay. Agar kaho ke koe virus nhi agar scientist ko nazar aa sakta hay to Sari duniya ko q nazar nhi aa sakta. Bas logon ko chutiya bna rhy han. Lekan ye Sach bhi hay ke log Mar rhy han. Virus exist krta hay. Agar aik khas treeky ko follow kr ke test kia Jaye to wo dikh jata hay. Jab tak aap khud ventilation par nhi jao ge nhi mano ge. Lekan zahir ki aankh se nazar to nhi aata magar uski mara mari Uska pta deti hay. Aur virus ki mojudgi, presence, new varieties aur charectristics sirf aik khas admi ko pta lagti hay hum tum jeson ko nhi. Phir jisko pta lagta hay to wo rule bnata hay logon ko surakhshit rakhny k liye k bhai
2 meters distance rakho
Face cover kro
Senitizer pas rakho
20 seconds tak hath dho.
Naak aankh kan ko touch na kro
Etc
Bhai ab in Sari baton ko mazhab( Religion) ki zuban main badal do to tumhen pta LG Jaye ga ke Allah sirf Muhammad ko hi q nazar aya aur phir Muhammad ne q rules bnay.
Seerat ul nabwi kabhi parhi hay?
A kafiru jitnee mazy ura sakty Hu uralu Ek Din Allah Ke samne Jana Hai Aur jawab daina hai
There is no Allah but god. And that god too is nothing. Allah se dar kar na jee. Self pride or imandari se jee le. Kal Ho Na Ho.
Muhammad ne kya jawab diya hoga yeh sab kar ke
Harris, u committed the worst form of blasphemy and RIP in advance.
Haris one day you will again b a good Muslim....islam is a true only religion....