The New Worst British Tank in War Thunder - Scimitar

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 81

  • @Философ
    @Философ 17 годин тому +46

    should've given it thermals like it had on dev

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому

      I dont think that would be enough to save it

    • @TakenWithout
      @TakenWithout 12 годин тому +10

      If it had got its rangefinder & thermals from the dev server it would’ve made for a pretty fun fox alternative trading speed for situational awareness & gun control. Instead now we literally just get a slower tracked fox with worse turret traverse. Really nothing you incentivise playing the scimitar once you have the fox. Not sure why they couldn’t be foldered

    • @thombrick
      @thombrick 9 годин тому +1

      That would be another version of the vehicle, the ones that were in service didn't have thermals or a laser rangefinder untill they were almost decommissioned.

  • @blacksmith0808
    @blacksmith0808 15 годин тому +17

    Give it thermals and the correct engine and you may be able to actually play it as intended

  • @r1zmy
    @r1zmy 16 годин тому +14

    with T-55s, the layer of floor armor right below the side of the hull is around 20mm so if you fire a round inbetween the roadwheels, you could one shot the tank with the Scimitar's APHE round.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  16 годин тому +7

      Yea thats where you aim with like the Falcon or the 35mm on the gepard with regular APHE, Just the Scimitar cannon fires so slowly if you miss the shot you are dead.

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому

      @@DawgIVLifeat 7.7 you are fighting the T-54s, so you have about an hour and a half before they stop and try to shoot back

  • @leesinclair9651
    @leesinclair9651 10 годин тому +5

    ive crewed this IRL and can say its not suppose to be used for face on fighting..its a medium recce asset. 6 round mag but if you fired the 4th + round youd have to recock the rade. Aluminium armour to keep it air portable. its used for parking up and eyeballing stuff for a chally to bounce forward and slap. its crap for fighting other tanks head on, i think its crapness in WoT is accurate, xx

    • @MrCimik
      @MrCimik 8 годин тому

      Hey, I always wanted to ask someone who's been around these vehicles - what is their role IRL really?

    • @sirdiesalot2975
      @sirdiesalot2975 5 годин тому +2

      @@MrCimik He says he's crewed them (can't be around them much more unless you repaired them constantly) and spelled out their usage quite clearly I thought: it's primarily a reconnaissance vehicle. It rolls around finding things for other people to blow up, while offering support with its own gun.
      They're a part of a class of vehicles Britain have been making/using since the 60s called Combat Reconnaissance Vehicles. Although that doesn't mean much, they're functionally very similar to earlier armoured cars but with progressively more modern doodads attached to them over the decades.

  • @hudsondeweerd3910
    @hudsondeweerd3910 17 годин тому +15

    Sad British main noises.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  17 годин тому +5

      I know Maybe when the FV101 comes it will be decent.

    • @thatonelocalauthority2809
      @thatonelocalauthority2809 14 годин тому +6

      @@DawgIVLifeit won’t, gaijin despise Britain too much.

  • @mattdriesenga4770
    @mattdriesenga4770 17 годин тому +4

    I am wondering if they are planning to bump the Fox up in BR, but brought thin in first before doing so to hold its spot at 7.7.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  17 годин тому +2

      They said something about a 30mm APDS nerf so that's why they kept it at 7.7.

    • @mattdriesenga4770
      @mattdriesenga4770 16 годин тому +6

      @@DawgIVLife If they nerf the 30mm APDS, the Scimitar becomes COMPLETELY useless at 7.7. They could give it a stabilizer and thermals, but to what end? I'm thinking about the US M551(76mm) and its seems better than this tank in every aspect and its at 7.0.

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому +1

      @@mattdriesenga4770fire rate

    • @michaeldoyle841
      @michaeldoyle841 10 годин тому

      they can't, it'd just be the same as when it was first released except it'd be at a higher br.

  • @valorandrews190
    @valorandrews190 11 годин тому +1

    The fox has to be my favorite vehicle in the game and its not even close. But if it gets its apds nerfed that would be unfair to the warrior and this new peice of crap. The only way to punish the fox would be to move it up to like 8.7 or something insane. I bring it with the 8.3 SPAA lineup and it does just fine since you should be side/rear shotting everything anyway.

  • @willdelapradera
    @willdelapradera 13 годин тому +2

    without the fox speed, must be at 4.7

  • @konna6130
    @konna6130 8 годин тому

    its just a worse fox, but no means a bad vehicle. once you get the mobility upgrades it goes at a decent enough speed to get to good spots on most maps.
    also fox should be 8.0. it was really funny when it came at 7.0, i got like 3 site caps every match with it and dropped nukes left and right.

  • @ixb1
    @ixb1 12 годин тому +2

    scimitar in reality is really fast vehicle

  • @Matrixrupture-productions
    @Matrixrupture-productions 15 годин тому +6

    It’s mid but just like many British vehicles it’s not even close to its irl performance. In the real world it’s governed to 50mph it’s literally the fastest tank in the world it can do 70mph without the governor. And have image intensification sights. Not to mention the harriers not having the flight performance they should have. And many other issues the scimitar should be almost able to keep up with the fox but it can’t even out accelerate mbts.

    • @thatonelocalauthority2809
      @thatonelocalauthority2809 14 годин тому +5

      Yeah, British vehicles are the most nerfed in game easily. The only vehicles that are still somewhat similar to their actual performance are from 1.0-2.0, everything onwards is nerfed heavily. Gaijin just hates Britain man, and it’s sad.

    • @Matrixrupture-productions
      @Matrixrupture-productions 14 годин тому +2

      @ it’s annoying the FCS shouldn’t extra the fun is gas operated and the turret and laying drive are hydraulic assisted manual like you have to crank it yourself no electric stuff. I also made a bug report with lots of flight manuals and even the report from NASA with there studies of a TAV-8A trainer harrier and its turn performance was much better then what even the gr3 can match in game. Best part about it was the trainer harrier turns better without even going over the wing buffet onset.

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому +3

      I remember starting as the british and really feeling the suffer, then i changed to USSR and man, does the bias exist

    • @Matrixrupture-productions
      @Matrixrupture-productions 12 годин тому +1

      @ lol yeah but it’s also money based gaijin probably makes most there money off Russia and USA and as we know most prem players are trash and if they had a vehicle on par or worse then there opposition they wouldn’t want to play or buy. Now I’ve heard it said before the the UK is the best nation to play if you want to get good bc the only way to do good as a uk main is to be good lol. Imagine is you had uk mains that are good with good vehicles that are really good scary. I have a 56% win rate on the FA2 with a k/d ratio of around 1.2 and I very rarely shoot ai planes

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 12 годин тому +2

      @@Matrixrupture-productions dont forget germany, there is a scary number of Turm IIIs and the like

  • @edxcal84
    @edxcal84 9 годин тому

    The Luchs is outstanding, it's very similar to the XM-800T, only larger.

    • @konna6130
      @konna6130 8 годин тому

      no stab, but smokes are nice tho.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  6 годин тому

      but do I really want to play a worst XM-800T with APCR for a tier 4 APDS belt

  • @patriklenck1735
    @patriklenck1735 13 годин тому +1

    Jeah i kinda went over the statcard Yesterday and thought why would i ever want to bring it im my 7.7 Lineup? The whole point of The fox is beeing a fast lunatic but this thing isnt even fast. So if i want to chill scout i go aml 90 and otherwise just rock the Conq or Centurion. There is no reason to even research it.

  • @dootanator_
    @dootanator_ 9 годин тому

    its only 7.7 because the fox is 7.7 and they share a similar turret, it would be much more balanced if it was at 7.3 or 7.0

    • @AgonizedApricot
      @AgonizedApricot 9 годин тому

      it'd fight way more heavy tanks at 7.3 or 7.0

  • @thomasleonard2564
    @thomasleonard2564 6 годин тому

    Sad it didn't get its thermals but it is true this is the early scimitar and not it's late modernized brother with its Cummins engine and thermal scope they could bring it in but idk if it would serve a purpose at this point tho i still love to play this thing more than the fox because i think the fox is very ugly.

  • @frankbradley4487
    @frankbradley4487 16 годин тому +3

    Please play the Luchs A2. 😢

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  16 годин тому +6

      I think I will go insane trying to get the APDS Belt. I would 100% do it if it was a tier 1 mod like the AMX-10P Dm63 is.

    • @frankbradley4487
      @frankbradley4487 8 годин тому +1

      @@DawgIVLife But it is on wheels, has a faster RoF than the Raiden 30mm, has thermals, and is amphibious. It may be fun.

  • @OcelotSF
    @OcelotSF 15 годин тому +1

    what are u supposed to do with maus on btr82?

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  15 годин тому +2

      Get over penned by the 128mm and then get overpreasured by the 75mm HEAT.

  • @Kettleman1.0
    @Kettleman1.0 8 годин тому

    If this is not like the fox at all i dont want to get it. I really wanted to like the scimitar but im probaly keeping the eland 90 in my lineup over this.

  • @Hemimike426
    @Hemimike426 5 годин тому

    Britain can't get nice things, the devs make it clear every update

  • @whoslistening
    @whoslistening 11 годин тому

    I thought the Scimitar was supposed to be the fasted IFV in the world?

  • @Markty07
    @Markty07 9 годин тому

    I saw a guy that owned that tank irl lol

  • @redterror7242
    @redterror7242 9 годин тому

    Should of added the cvrt scorpion 90mm instead

  • @phantomklepht7675
    @phantomklepht7675 12 годин тому

    Does it get thermal, stabilizer and rangefinder irl?

    • @mirekspodmonopolowego9016
      @mirekspodmonopolowego9016 12 годин тому

      The upgraded version does get thermals and rangefinder but still no stab, also the current scimitar we have is the base version

  • @Gmann-q4r
    @Gmann-q4r 17 годин тому +2

    Hm, so it has worse armor, pen, damage, and speed than other tanks in the same br range? Why does it even exist???

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  17 годин тому +1

      Its the same cannon as the Warrior and fox, The APHE belt is stock on all of them but once you get the APDS belt you can kill tanks from the side.

  • @walsh5243
    @walsh5243 13 годин тому

    damn a average french 7.7 medium is faster than this thing

  • @MrFrancois101
    @MrFrancois101 11 годин тому

    Its a Fox with tracks

  • @slimrummy4616
    @slimrummy4616 4 години тому

    Uptire it to 8.7

  • @sharksammy
    @sharksammy 9 годин тому

    man it 6.7? mmm or sort out its speed it should be faster

  • @jvcardoso1997
    @jvcardoso1997 10 годин тому

    tf is this collors of teamates and squad?

  • @mr.lizard7285
    @mr.lizard7285 16 годин тому +1

    did you forget about the Archer (the worst tank in the game)

    • @thatonelocalauthority2809
      @thatonelocalauthority2809 14 годин тому +3

      It isn’t the worst tank in the game lmao

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому +1

      Archer is actually super good, 4.7 gun at 2.7 is insane, i have 73% winrate on that thing

    • @PNolandS
      @PNolandS 11 годин тому

      I'm pretty sure the worst tank (or at least tracked vehicle) in the game is the Type 60 ATM, though the Zachlam Tager is also pretty awful

    • @konna6130
      @konna6130 8 годин тому

      @@PNolandS Zachlam reaps huge benefits from the ammobox. 12 atgms instead of 6.

  • @araynortassadore3056
    @araynortassadore3056 8 годин тому

    Skill Issue

  • @TheRealKiRBEY
    @TheRealKiRBEY 10 годин тому

    9:32 skull issue ☠

  • @joeythegamer9519
    @joeythegamer9519 16 годин тому +1

    It’s pretty good
    It’s a more controllable fox
    Maybe you’re just not fit for the job

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  16 годин тому +2

      I don't think the fox ever had a issue with being controllable it did pretty well.

  • @FrantisekPicifuk
    @FrantisekPicifuk 17 годин тому +3

    Complaining that you can't pen the Maus with this thing just gives me brain rot. Of course there will be enemies you will struggle against, but that doesn't mean you cant be helpfull to your team in other ways. It's a light scout, fighting is it's secondary role.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  17 годин тому +6

      The point isn't that it can't pen the maus majority of the tanks it faces you can't pen from the front, which means you need to have good positioning which the Scimitar can't do. Meanwhile you have the fox at the same battle rating that can get into good positions scout very well and effect the match by actually killing targets.

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 12 годин тому +1

      Struggle against? Thats not a struggle, thats a pain

    • @exceptionalanimations1508
      @exceptionalanimations1508 12 годин тому +1

      @@DawgIVLife Scimitar is just an awful vehicle, it serves no purpose and was wanted by nobody

  • @b.c.2281
    @b.c.2281 15 годин тому +2

    The Scimitar isn't a bad vehicle, it's just actually balanced at 7.7 unlike the Fox. I don't know why they didn't move the Fox to 8.0 in the last BR changes rather than threaten some ambiguous "future apds change" to try and solve it.

    • @DawgIVLife
      @DawgIVLife  15 годин тому +2

      Comparing it to vehicles like the T114 AML-90 it does not feel balanced at all.

    • @7KYEARS
      @7KYEARS 13 годин тому

      "It's just ackshually balanced at 7.7" so it should be kinda dogwater to be balanced?

    • @filipbitala2624
      @filipbitala2624 13 годин тому +1

      Fox is balanced at 7.7, i remember seeing it with my IS-2, that was imbalanced

    • @b.c.2281
      @b.c.2281 12 годин тому

      @@7KYEARS Do you believe the Fox is balanced?

    • @b.c.2281
      @b.c.2281 12 годин тому

      @@DawgIVLife I think I should have explained what I meant because I came across a tad contrarian. Before the most recent BR changes Gaijin was using the Fox over performing at 7.7 as grounds to nerf the Rarden's APDS round sometime in the near future rather than just moving it up in BR like they did with the XM-800T. I wasn't making a blanket "Fox is OP" statement, because Gaijin has already said as much when it comes to statistics. I'm a mainly UK player myself and quite like the Fox after all. It's just that staying at that BR is going to be an excuse for Gaijin to nerf the other Rarden vehicles in the future, ie. the Warrior and now the Scimitar, which are going to suffer disproportionately because they don't have the insane mobility to compensate.
      The Scimitar has some serious issues with its driving model as it stands, it should be faster than it is and it has some odd oversteer characteristics when turning that I hope can be fixed.
      On a personal level, I can't speak to the T-114 but I would take the Scimitar over an AML-90 even in its current state, but that's just a subjective taste thing. lol

  • @followerofkek8808
    @followerofkek8808 11 годин тому

    skill issue not gonna lie cant agree with you on this one, im killing leo 2's with this thing