I think your numbering is spot on. Interesting that the SS Carnage is a bit under scaled. Wonder how the new XM Carnage will compare? Appreciate the comparison
Custom axe and the XM Studios Carnage I like the best out of this group. If I had to keep one it would be the custom axe one. I wish Prime 1 Studios would have made one and had it be similar to what the anti-venom look like I think that would have been cool
I really like the Sideshow, especially when paired with their Venom and Black Suit Spidey, like they had at SDCC. Just overall a really great value for what you get. I appreciate how Sideshow has been limiting or eliminating the switch outs and keeping the bases smaller, all while coming up with great poses and great execution, to keep the prices down and more accessible for a lot more people who want to collect statues.
I have to give the win to sideshow, the pose is really on point for me and i love the cell 316 base and the fact he is not on a church tower. They did miss a beat by not adding a switch out for the weapon from scythe to axe. Xm is second but that custom definitely comes close. Cool idea for a video, i would love to see which spiderman, venom, carnage trio you would put together to make a diorama of sorts.
Agh good ole Cletus Kasady. He's up there in my top favorite villains. I really like the Carnage USA and Sideshow's Carnage. Awesome Carnage collection Mr.X!
Sideshow takes top spot for me. It’s cool having the lower edition sizes of the customs, but Daniel Bel’s sculpt on this one is too good. I have one on the way and can’t wait to see it in person!
Always liked the XM but agree the symbiote looks messy. If I were looking for a Carnage I would probably choose the SS or the custom with movie style teeth
I have to be the oddball and choose American Carnage. I know it's tall but I like the way he is squatting down. The flag gives it that unique touch. The fact that it seems fragile doesn't excite me any. The "axe" statue is solid second, I would darken that puppy up myself
Sideshow and XM are the best ones there, but would be better with tweaks as you mentioned... darker "blood" reds and that XM base is too plain(plus would be good to have the steeple vertical). I like the axe, and the symbiote tendrils should be a mix of glossy blood red and glossy black. I like him more scrawny/lithe than Venom, with parallels to hyenas vs lions. I also want to see the pose as more aggressive such as lunging and hunched forward like a hybrid of the left custom and XM.
I don't own the piece but just from what I've seen, I think the sideshow is my favorite. Just based on what I picture when I think of carnage and the amazing paint job and scythe. Would've been cool if it had a head swap out though.
I think SS is my favorite even though I'm not getting it. I have a 1/6 fine art from Kotobukiya that I think is awesome but sadly the companion Venom statue is 💩.
The new SSC one is the clear winner for me. The rest are a bit tougher to rank. I like the idea of the museum custom, but I don't like the portrait. I like the XM one, but there's too much base/steeple and the engineering sounds annoying.
This was cool to watch, comparing the other Carnage’s you have in your collection to the new SS one. I do agree with the top two you picked but in reverse, for me 1st is the SS then the custom. Cool video
I would agree with 3, 4 and 5... as for the other two, I would probably see them on the same place (would have to see them in person in order to decide which one is actually better).
I was looking to buy the sideshow one and didn't even realize there are so many different statues to choose from. This video is gonna help me make a better decision.
XM studios peice is definetly supreme carnage does not need all the tendrils and self forged weapons due to the cheer mindset of serial killer Cassidy. look says it all.
Love this ranking video. My top 2 are actually American carnage and then sideshow. I like the American carnage a lot without the flag! Looking forward to seeing what you price him at.
This is one of the best videos real good information I also like side show The price is good and it looks good I think I speak for most of us this is the best statue channel
Mr X, maybe you can help me. I’m still a fairly new collector but like you, I love custom pieces. While looking on eBay (custom or not) I noticed some of the prices are WILDLY different. I mean, in some cases, $1000s apart from one another for the same exact piece. Any advice?
I personally think sideshows does pretty damn good against the others. Ain’t the best, yet it is fairly decent specially against other companies like XM and customs
I'm gonna tell you why that Axe Carnage is not number 1. Really simple, you ready? It's not number 1 because if you liked it the most, you wouldn't have put a book in front of it. Unless that base is not part of the statue, I couldn't see you covering up something you like the most. The book would have went in front of your number 5 statue. Also, it looks like a gargoyle base, and I like gargoyles. Other than that, I'm not surprised by your rankings, they all made sense. My question, how would you change the XM one to be more interesting? My problem with that is the base overshadows the figure- I find myself looking at the base than the details on the statue, and that shouldn't be. Also, I thought the Sideshow one looked way too small when I saw it in other collector videos, but stacked up next to theee others, he looks like a descent size. I think Sideshow tries to be mindful of displayability with design, so they underscale their figures a bit. But it doesn't look to be so here. My main issue is the claw on the left hand looks smaller than the prototype claw displayed at Sideshow con last year. This is off-topic, but Sideshow and the axe custom give me Terminator T-1000 vibes. I would love to see them face off with all these different blades they can form! Or maybe Carnage vs. another shape shifter- but there aren't too many that can shift the way Carnage can. Maybe the new Ms. Marvel? With so many possibilities, I think true shape-shifting is the most under represented super power, not many mutants can form any shape with different parts of the body.
I’m not surprised at your picks…and I would be torn between 1 and 2…the red paint is the key IMO. Question though what would be your fave black spider suit (non venom) to pair with the carnage statue?
I think the new XM carnage coming out will be able to compete with the others. The photos so far look really good. Not a fan of the new sideshow piece, they gave him a beak. Where are all the crazy sharp teeth? And what’s up with the BBC? It just looks weird blacking out his crotch.
I really like sideshows products. They really did a fantastic job bringing one of my favorite comic serial killers to life. It is really difficult to make the symbiote look right.
@@TheXtremeChannelMrX thanks for replying. You like giving a background of the character you will be reviewing, make it feel more personal. Best if all you are 100% honest.
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I like the new SS Daniel Bel Carnage. I’m not a huge fan of the character, so I don’t own any Carnage statues. But if I did, it would be that one.
Cell 361 is an awesome Easter egg/reference to Carnage's first appearance in comics-> Amazing Spider-Man 361🕷I love that Sideshow most!
Dan Bell did a great job on the SS Carnage, I would give my top pick to this one.
If I did not know anything about the price or the company I am pretty sure I would still have easily picked the Sideshow Carnage. That thing pops!
I LIKE THE CUSTOM WITH THE AX, AND THE SIDESHOW LOOKS GREAT TOO
I think your numbering is spot on. Interesting that the SS Carnage is a bit under scaled. Wonder how the new XM Carnage will compare?
Appreciate the comparison
I love that custom carnage that you chose as #1 to me that's carnage. The red tendrils set it off for me. Great video👍
Custom axe and the XM Studios Carnage I like the best out of this group. If I had to keep one it would be the custom axe one. I wish Prime 1 Studios would have made one and had it be similar to what the anti-venom look like I think that would have been cool
I want this statue so bad I want to pair it with my og xm venom u think it's going to look sick can't wait
custom 1 is my favv hands down. shut your mouth when u talk 2 me
I really like the Sideshow, especially when paired with their Venom and Black Suit Spidey, like they had at SDCC. Just overall a really great value for what you get. I appreciate how Sideshow has been limiting or eliminating the switch outs and keeping the bases smaller, all while coming up with great poses and great execution, to keep the prices down and more accessible for a lot more people who want to collect statues.
Sideshow is easily my favorite of these. Just love the sculpt.
XM probably comes in second.
I have to give the win to sideshow, the pose is really on point for me and i love the cell 316 base and the fact he is not on a church tower. They did miss a beat by not adding a switch out for the weapon from scythe to axe. Xm is second but that custom definitely comes close. Cool idea for a video, i would love to see which spiderman, venom, carnage trio you would put together to make a diorama of sorts.
I think overall that new Sideshow actually lands in 1st place for me. Colors look great, and I love the gigantic scythe!
Agh good ole Cletus Kasady. He's up there in my top favorite villains. I really like the Carnage USA and Sideshow's Carnage. Awesome Carnage collection Mr.X!
Sideshow takes top spot for me. It’s cool having the lower edition sizes of the customs, but Daniel Bel’s sculpt on this one is too good. I have one on the way and can’t wait to see it in person!
Sideshow carnage is the best only because I also have it. The one I like the least is the custom one standing up. I think its a stupid pose.
Nice Video.
I'm going with Sideshow Carnage for my display for the size mainly. But waiting for a sale since sideshow seconds is a thing now.
The new Sideshow Daniel Bel Carnage is my favourite to be honest. It really captures the character and his abilities very well.
Always liked the XM but agree the symbiote looks messy. If I were looking for a Carnage I would probably choose the SS or the custom with movie style teeth
I have to be the oddball and choose American Carnage. I know it's tall but I like the way he is squatting down. The flag gives it that unique touch. The fact that it seems fragile doesn't excite me any. The "axe" statue is solid second, I would darken that puppy up myself
Sideshow and XM are the best ones there, but would be better with tweaks as you mentioned... darker "blood" reds and that XM base is too plain(plus would be good to have the steeple vertical). I like the axe, and the symbiote tendrils should be a mix of glossy blood red and glossy black. I like him more scrawny/lithe than Venom, with parallels to hyenas vs lions. I also want to see the pose as more aggressive such as lunging and hunched forward like a hybrid of the left custom and XM.
I’m Biggest carnage fan love these brother. They really dropped the ball on the carnage movie😢
I don't own the piece but just from what I've seen, I think the sideshow is my favorite. Just based on what I picture when I think of carnage and the amazing paint job and scythe. Would've been cool if it had a head swap out though.
I mostly agree with your rankings, except I would give Sideshow’s Carnage a slight edge for the #1 spot.
I really love that SS Carnage. Definitely gonna pick him up. The custom Axe Carnage is a close second for me.
I think SS is my favorite even though I'm not getting it. I have a 1/6 fine art from Kotobukiya that I think is awesome but sadly the companion Venom statue is 💩.
1. Most recent custom
2. Sideshow.
3. Custom with axe
4. XM
5. The big one lol
Holy shit, those two custom pieces you didnt get, (prisoner/captive carnage and the bust carnage) are insane!!!!
My goodness that is an awesome and terrifying display!! I agree the darker color is nicer, but that Sideshow version is the top on the table for me.
The new SSC one is the clear winner for me. The rest are a bit tougher to rank. I like the idea of the museum custom, but I don't like the portrait. I like the XM one, but there's too much base/steeple and the engineering sounds annoying.
As they all amazing in their own right, just acquired the sideshow carnage and it looks amazing next to my venom and spider-man.
Happy to be one of the owners of axe man carnage. Your list validâtes my tastes! Ps. Hair is looking good mr. X
This was cool to watch, comparing the other Carnage’s you have in your collection to the new SS one. I do agree with the top two you picked but in reverse, for me 1st is the SS then the custom. Cool video
Im really liking the Sideshow might need to wait for that Black Friday lol, although the diorama you showed was amazing.
I would agree with 3, 4 and 5... as for the other two, I would probably see them on the same place (would have to see them in person in order to decide which one is actually better).
If only the one on the left had more Black on his face. It would be the perfect Carnage. Definitely still number 1 though compared to these others.
American Carnage is my favorite you had/have a matching slab comic so pretty cool :)
I have the older PF from Carnage and i like it! :D But i would prefer (just a little bit) to have the new PF :D
Wooooooow😱. Is perfect Collections Carnage statue.👍👍🤩🤩❤
I really like sideshows carnage but I'm not really a fan of the character. So I didn't buy it. So its hard to say witch is better.
All stretches there can fill up my whole room and I love that bronco jersey You’re a bronco fan are you have old bronco collection
I agree with your #'s 1 & 2. For me, they are interchangeable. Both are great for different reasons.
I was looking to buy the sideshow one and didn't even realize there are so many different statues to choose from. This video is gonna help me make a better decision.
"How much carnage do you need in your life?"
Mr. X: "Yes!"
I never paid beyond 150 bucks for a statue but for that ss carnage i will
Haven't seen the movie completely but if they would have done it in the style of the joker I think it would have been way better.
XM studios peice is definetly supreme carnage does not need all the tendrils and self forged weapons due to the cheer mindset of serial killer Cassidy. look says it all.
Sideshow piece is def better than the rest imo I just bought one looks absolutely sick
I better f#ckin win one of those Alien Queen statues. But Jesus at this rate your going to need to do a giveaway at every 500 subs😝
carnage is cool, not sure if I'm a fan of the new one you got though. I like the one with the ax hand better
Custom axe is the best. I also think your list is right on. I would have put them in the same number positions u did
Excelente colección lo mejor de lo mejor felicidades 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟👍
Personally love the atf if only the paint was better.
Right on point regarding the 3 enemies…especially #1. 😂
I would go 3usa carnage
2nd the mostly red custom
1 the new carnage
Love this ranking video. My top 2 are actually American carnage and then sideshow. I like the American carnage a lot without the flag!
Looking forward to seeing what you price him at.
On rewatch, that custom has me super tempted. Although also considering holding out for the new PCS maximum carnage diorama bust.
This is one of the best videos real good information I also like side show The price is good and it looks good I think I speak for most of us this is the best statue channel
Xm is still my favorite. Least favorite is the one where he's just standing there
This is an Xtreme collection of Carnage. This statement could also be made at a serial killers residence
Carnage is one of 2 of my fav villains, these are absolutely amazing!
The Sideshow Carnage statue is wearing a Symbiote speedo.
Not really digging the SS. That custom really is no 1 imo also.
would you call this maximum carnage ...............ba dum tiss
Man those looks wicked awesome 😎👍 👍👍👍👍👍
hey look, a crowd you can blend in with. LOL jk. dont ban me.
Wow! "Bro", they all have such "Presence"! 🤣
Keep all the ones with the axes. They're amazing!
They are all fire.but I think Sideshows is the best.
#1 looks like a 10 year old molded clay. Horrible customs
Sideshow's looks best, no competition imho...
I'd have to agree with you, I just wish it was a darker red...
Mr X, maybe you can help me. I’m still a fairly new collector but like you, I love custom pieces. While looking on eBay (custom or not) I noticed some of the prices are WILDLY different. I mean, in some cases, $1000s apart from one another for the same exact piece. Any advice?
Never buy custom from Ebay. Most are recasts/knockoffs
Cool video. The movie is NOT doing grace with him
I personally think sideshows does pretty damn good against the others. Ain’t the best, yet it is fairly decent specially against other companies like XM and customs
ATF and Sideshow Carnage for me.
I'm gonna tell you why that Axe Carnage is not number 1. Really simple, you ready? It's not number 1 because if you liked it the most, you wouldn't have put a book in front of it. Unless that base is not part of the statue, I couldn't see you covering up something you like the most. The book would have went in front of your number 5 statue. Also, it looks like a gargoyle base, and I like gargoyles. Other than that, I'm not surprised by your rankings, they all made sense. My question, how would you change the XM one to be more interesting? My problem with that is the base overshadows the figure- I find myself looking at the base than the details on the statue, and that shouldn't be. Also, I thought the Sideshow one looked way too small when I saw it in other collector videos, but stacked up next to theee others, he looks like a descent size. I think Sideshow tries to be mindful of displayability with design, so they underscale their figures a bit. But it doesn't look to be so here. My main issue is the claw on the left hand looks smaller than the prototype claw displayed at Sideshow con last year.
This is off-topic, but Sideshow and the axe custom give me Terminator T-1000 vibes. I would love to see them face off with all these different blades they can form! Or maybe Carnage vs. another shape shifter- but there aren't too many that can shift the way Carnage can. Maybe the new Ms. Marvel? With so many possibilities, I think true shape-shifting is the most under represented super power, not many mutants can form any shape with different parts of the body.
It's #1 because I like it the most. The book is in front of the base so no carnage statues are blocked.
I want the SideShow one. I think that one looks the best in my opinion
I’m not surprised at your picks…and I would be torn between 1 and 2…the red paint is the key IMO. Question though what would be your fave black spider suit (non venom) to pair with the carnage statue?
I’ve only owned two. The most recent SS one looks great. I have a transformation one coming next month
I think the new XM carnage coming out will be able to compete with the others. The photos so far look really good. Not a fan of the new sideshow piece, they gave him a beak. Where are all the crazy sharp teeth? And what’s up with the BBC? It just looks weird blacking out his crotch.
I do like the new XM Carnage. I think it's the only actual statue from Absolute Carnage
If I need a Carnage in my collection I would pick Sideshow's for affordability and sculpt. It's just very hard to beat the combination.
#truth
I wish they didn't make so many from sideshow
I really like sideshows products. They really did a fantastic job bringing one of my favorite comic serial killers to life. It is really difficult to make the symbiote look right.
Favorite serial killers lol
I love the American Carnage piece.
SS is the best, the edition size sucks though.
You make me want to buy Carnage statues!
I like the sideshow piece just cuz lol
Damn those are some badass Carnage statues
Came to subscribe again. I think your content is great! Best statue review channel out here!!!
Thank you!
Agreed on the #1 choice! I regret not getting it
I like the side show Carnage
Custom Axe Carnage is bad ass
I agree ..1 threw 5
I’ve been contemplating on getting the sideshow one, but seeing your vid makes me want it even more
It's done very well
great video, as usual!
I appreciate that you are a collector that knows the comics. I have seen collectors that have no idea about the characters they buy
I’ve been guilty of that
@@TheXtremeChannelMrX thanks for replying. You like giving a background of the character you will be reviewing, make it feel more personal.
Best if all you are 100% honest.
Sideshow easy...
Love that sideshow statue
Friggin' AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!
Great video brother!