How Do Indonesian Muslims Feel About ISIS? | ASIAN BOSS
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- Indonesia is the country with the largest muslim population in the world. In light of the recent New York terror attack, ASIAN BOSS interviewed ordinary Indonesians to find out how they feel about ISIS.
The opinions expressed in this video are those of individual interviewees alone and do not reflect the views of ASIAN BOSS or the general Indonesian population.
Reach out to Steve (presenter) on Instagram ► / theasianboss
ASIAN BOSS Instagram ►
/ asianbossmedia
Send us a message via our Facebook page if you have any questions or topic suggestions ► / asianboss
Are you curious about real people's perspectives from Asia on various cultural and social issues? Subscribe to ASIAN BOSS for more informative videos ► goo.gl/TRcSbE
![What's It Like Being A Muslim In The Philippines? [STREET INTERVIEW] | ASIAN BOSS](/img/n.gif)
Special thanks to Vesa from Indonesia for guest reporting.
From time to time, we get criticized for making "easy money" off our volunteer reporters who "do all the hard work while we sit in our office doing nothing". While our volunteer reporters do a great job of getting people's answers, there is a lot that goes on behind the scenes from selecting the right set of questions to editing and subtitling, which are all done at the headquarter. First and foremost, we care about storytelling and it takes a lot of work converting all the raw interview footage into one coherent story.
Second, most of our videos get demonetized by UA-cam due to the sensitive nature of the topics we deal with. This video got demonetized even before it went public. Does that stop us from making videos on relevant and important topics? No, it's important and necessary, now more than ever, that we try to understand others' views, especially of those from different cultures and backgrounds.
As a media startup, our vision is to bring you the most authentic perspectives on the latest news and cultural trends from Asia. We are not going to let a lack of resources and sponsorships stop us from executing that vision. All of our volunteer reporters will be taken care of one way or another in due course. We hope that the rest of you can join our grassroots movement to fundamentally transform news media. - Steve
Asian Boss Ey Boss, I rarely ever do this but I need to thank you for doing this work. I've shown some of your videos to my university advisor because the content is closely related to my field of study. I'm a criminal justice major focusing on sex crimes. The north Korea and Indian rape videos where very insightful of what they have to deal with on the other side of the planet and how similar it is to what we have to combat in the western world. She really enjoyed them and will likely be including them in her future lesson plans.
Keep fighting the good fight. You know your fans will have your back no matter the strife you must endure.
Thanks for your work hopefully your network getting bigger and bigger
I have been really looking forward to guest reporting from other Asian countries as well,
i hope i get to see something from pakistan one day.
These videos are so important, thank you so much for making them.
thanks for the videos and the noble vision. keep it up!
I'm Indonesian, and Christian. I wanna say: Muslims here are mainly religious yet peaceful, but there are those who aren't. Christians here are mainly religious yet peaceful, but there are those who aren't. So, yeah...
*ahem* aceh and brunei
@@everettduncan7543 brunei implements sharia law but no one had ever got killed or punished because of sharia law in brunei. Sharia law in brunei and saudi are different. Saudi's law is extreme and it was obviously to maintain the royal and riches' status as they themselves are breaking the rules.
@@Sarah-yg8kt yeah brunei doesn't kill for sharia but it still uses corporal like aceh
Mouth Eater brunei is not indonesia???? aceh is one of indonesia’s province???
Bener banget mas, i believe that religion doesn’t fully shape our personality. Agama adalah pedoman hidup, kita mau percaya atau engganya, kembali ke kita :)
Indonesia is a lovely country and Indonesians are super friendly and nice. Greetings from Thailand
luckystriker, hai greet from Indonesia
Hope you have a wonderful life.
luckystriker Respect Same Asia
Thank you, My neighbour.
Sawadee krab, i love thai
That's sweet of you guys to see you contribute in making the world a better place with this type of content
Long live Indonesia from kazakh.muslim in Central Asia. Your country is so wonderful. I wanna visit it
Azizbek Abatov We will welcome you bro...
Thank you! Greetings for Muslim Kazakhstan from Muslim Indonesia !
Alhamdulillah thanks so much brother. We are open for everyone no matter what their religion is, as long as they're good person with good purpose to visit our country. Peace✌️
I know so little about countries in central asia, and it makes me curious about you guys. salam
I've been to many Muslim countries such as UAE, Kuwait, Qatar, and Jordan. The people in those countries treated me with great respect.
AZ Wallbreaker How would they treat you if you were openly gay 🤔
Umar Tanveer Well, it's illegal to be homosexual in these Muslim countries. I would image at least prison time if a gay prison was caught.
Well I’m a muslim in Saudi also Indonesian. When you visit Indonesian, say, market or shopping malls, the people there treat you like a king or queen. With extreme politeness. Meanwhile in Saudi, people here treated you like a friend
Hatsuharu Akimoto Pakistan world represent the image of all Muslims???
Siria
I am Indonesian but not Moeslem, I can say this to you.
Our Moeslems are very different from those out there... for better or for worse.
Basicly we are very friendly with anybody here except for a very little group of peope.
The younger generations are starting to be a melting pot in a major city at least.
So... selamat datang di Indonesia.
plukdim nah u mending lulusin TOEFL dulu dah, u cuman translate kasar, Pakai Comprehension yg bener.
Sederhananya Muslim Indonesia itu beda kultur sama muslim lainnya.
Muslim kita lebih bebas dibandingkan dengan Muslim Arab sana yang masih kental hukum Syariah.
Tergantung orang yg lihat bisa dipandang hal yang positif dan negatif.
Ada sedikit kelompok fanatik Islam di dalamny
plukdim Dan kalau u mau tau Ajaran Islam bisa beda, antara Muhammadiah dan NU, ada perbedaan sedikit. Seperti perbedaan Katolik dan Protestan.
Satu akar dua metode.
plukdim Nah... Penjahat itu beragama tapi gak beriman.
plukdim except for a very little group of people? (Sorry for the typo, but I won't edit for it won't affect the context)
Kalau u translate tanpa comprehension u bakal dpt arti salah
KevinMulia Please, don't try to compare NU and Muhammadiyah as protestant and catholic, you know nothing.
wahh, gini yah rasanya nonton tanpa baca subtitle
AHAHAHAHAHAHA NGAKAK ANJING
Calon Suamimu tapi orang Barat masih aja percaya kalau ISIS itu Islam.
Kurang akurat ya subtitlenya hahaha. Berasa ga?
Hahahahahahha
wkwkwkwkwwk sumpah ge ngakak baca comment u yg ini
Proud of myself as a malaysian to be able to watch this without reading the subtitles lol
Me too,
I understand Indonesian because of television .
Malaysian ppl probably could understand indonesian language but for me as an indonesian i still need subtitle when i'm watching upin ipin 😂.
Bahasa malaysia and indonesia like central java and east java.. Similiar.. But still television give subtitle for ipin upin.. Haha
Saya tau bahasa malaysia dr upin ipin
I've watched that series since I was in elementary school, now I'm in college and I don't need any subtitle to understand them wkwk @@An-iy9ct
Indonesians are such calm people
@@li6135 are you okay, pal?
@@li6135 are you human
@@li6135 are you ccp propaganda
Doubt
@@jonatankrisna4124 toxic best friends and bocah-bocah warnet when they are playing PB.
Great to hear their perspective
You guys are awesome for this one. Thanks. These people explained it perfectly.
bishplis why you need to hear from the bomber? Dont you think that they will biased too?
It's same like, i want to hear from kkk members, because american people seem biased. (Just for example, dont want to offend American people).
Ooh yeah.. you can go ask the bomber by youself.if you want to know their opinion.
U guys are SERIOUSLY the best!!! Always telling it like it is cuz it's ALWAYS straight from the actual people. Unfortunately so many of us in America are so blinded by the bullshit spewed out from the media. Why can't our media do what u all do?? Total lack of respect... that's why
they did not ask the most important questions as in granting equal rights to non Muslims, tolerating others religious /cultural practices and having non Muslim political leadership.
shadow mode you can ask me for that. lets start your question 😊
@@shadowmod3 Do they don't provide equal rights to non-Muslims? I didn't knew that. I thought Indonesia is fairly tolerant nation unlike all Muslim countries where they treat non-Muslims as trash.
@@d-katsu8931 Indonesia tolerates them but it discriminates against atheists. State IDs have religion printed on them and atheists are often charged with anti blasphemy laws.
its media my guy it's totally controled by goverment
try to ask muslim people in middle east, the result may be different, indonesian muslim is similar with malaysian muslim, but I think muslim in middle east has stronger rules and more extreme
Muslims in asean so different
It's because middle east is a hard place, so that it breeds hard people with hard culture. If you have an ethnic tension for centuries and you add religious extrimism into the mix, the result is Iraq.
Middle East is a religiously dangerous area actually ; where almost no one can be fully trusted
All middle east people are not extremists
Jordan Egypt even Iran better visit it people are very nice
Hi, I'm Buddhism from Indonesia.
True, each people in indonesia have so many differences from the ethnic, religion, skin color, traditions, and more, but we respect each other and we are still one, one indonesia.
AND PLEASE, just because INDONESIA has a lot Muslims "DOESNT MEAN IT WAS A MUSLIM COUNTRY."
Our country teaches us to respect each other.
"BHINNEKA TUNGGAL IKA"
Means "Different from each other but We are still ONE."
True. Bhinneka tunggal Ika!
BHINNEKA TUNGGAL IKA DONT LET IT GO
"unity in diversity" kali. Ribet amat
@@Ismail-bi2sk ampun bang jago
@@JoannaFuater iya neng jago
Judging by the comment section, videos like these are still supremely important to make. Ordinary people need to hear from other ordinary people from around the world so they can see each other, past all the fear-mongering and into the core of what unites us all.
Hear! Hear!!
Indonesian people are so kind and down to earth. ❤️❤️
This is so important for westerners to know. Thank you so much for sharing. “A few bad apples don’t spoil the whole bunch”.
for a moment I thought they were speaking filipino visayan, but then I remembered.. ay bahasa indonesian pala! lol
Kevin 080592 can visayan understand indonesian?
@@dynaa4168 Visayans were descendants of Srivijayan soldiers that settled im Pinoy Archipelago
It's Bahasa Indonesia with Javanese accent
Native Filipino languages are related to Indonesian and Malaysian
More Indonesia videos please, Subbed :-) 😊
Good one bro. Factual video.
Craptastic" Horse shit religion are still spray cancer around the world
บุญทวี ทวีบุรุษ True
Great job! So happy you did this video. I love the Indonesian people.
I really appreciate getting perspectives on so many things from so many people throughout your videos, thank you all for what you do. As cliche and cheesy as it is, the world needs to come together as one and accept we're all in the same family, and I believe your videos really help with that.
Indonesia is a peaceful nation
They deserve to live in a peace and not have to go through what the middle east or other muslims nations had to go through
Long live Indonesia
Love from 🇸🇴🇸🇴❤❤🇮🇩🇮🇩
thank Allah, i was born in Indonesia hehe
@@rah164 wkwkwkwk
Aww ;)
Thank You Indonesia
P/s:I'm From Malysia
Hello nice to meet you !👋
you're welcome, mate ;)
Hello Malaysia!!! :D
Hello brother
Kkkkk
Love from the Philippines...
I visited Indonesia last year and made many friends there =) Terima kasih to all of my Indonesian friends out there =)
Terrorism is not Islam teaching. Islam doesn't teach killing innocents. In fact Islam is strict towards murderers. If a person accidentally killed another person, there's qishas punishment, means that person either be killed or pay large sum of money to the victim's family as a punishment. And Islam doesn't allow suicide. Suicide is a big sin in Islam.
ISIS doesn't obey Islam teaching. So rather than addresing it as a religious group, it's more proper to call it a group of people move with politic interest and borrowing God's name for their wrongdoings.
Nope, Isis just followed exactly what their prophet did!! Either you are a liar or know nothing about islam!!😒
@@Whoami1988_ Where do you learn Islam? Is it from CNN and BBC? I learn Islam from quran. You can read quran yourself to see whether I'm lying or not.
@@corocororo1724 wow your ignorance is something beyond me!! I'm pretty I know islam more than you! Quran have violence ayat in there!! Wow your ignorance is unbelievable!!😒
@@Whoami1988_ which verses teach people to be violent?
@@Whoami1988_ LMAO you said you know Islam more than me, you said I'm ignorant yet you can't even name one verse from quran. I've met many people who are proficient in arabic, quran and hadith but none of them claim to be the most knowledgable about Islam, they're all humble. You're either a troll or Islamphobic.
I'm American and I appreciate this video ,it helps ,it shows us what REAL Muslims believe,and feel about ISIS
Personal Opinion: In the end, I end up being more open to Indonesian, Malaysian, & Filipino Muslims than the Muslims in the Middle East :)
- Christian from Laguna, Philippines. Peace ✌️
try to ask middle east muslim, i think the answer is different most middleeast moslem more extreme than indonesian, because moslem indonesia or nusantara which is southeast asia is taught by turkey and before the wahabism and shia spread in middle east and india. in here everybody have to tolerant or if you dont you end up in jail lol
Unfortunately wahabi Islam is gaining foothold in Indonesia. :(
You should visit Jordan Egypt and such Arab countries they are very welcoming people.
Anecdotally, there seem to be a lot of moderate Indonesian Muslims. I have met numerous Indonesians throughout Asia, although I only visited Bali in Indonesia. The Muslims in Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore generally seem to be moderate.
Here, islam spread by sufi muslim, not wahhabist muslim like in arab, thats why
@@zalmhendry 😆😆😆😅😅😅
Beautiful people with beautiful views. You people must represent your beautiful religion to the world rather than letting some psychopaths do it for you. As a practitioner of Buddhism, I try and see things as they are and what I see here in the interview are people genuinely in love with their religion and it's advocacy of peace.
Please ask indonesian think about malaysian?and also malaysian think about indonesian? Do they hate each other or naturally love each other..?
I think Indonesia and Malaysia are fine with each other its just some people(not all) from both countries are fighting over the culture.
Indonesia and Malaysia are such as a brother with different father. Thet love eanch other, but also hate eanch other.
Like what actually happened to anny step-brother in real life. They like to fight but also like to help eanch other.
Brother relation is complicated ~ Lol.
@@meong9078 kadang mreka ngebully kita abis2an tapi tiba kita nuntut malah bilang Kyt4 s0dARa seroEMpun
I don't think they will be posting this kind of content. Many people, both from Indonesia and Malaysia are still too immature which make them unable to move on from the past. People who commented about their hatred just because of numbers of retaliation are the perfect example of this foolish childlishness which hinder us to achieve a better future
As a people study in international law, and sometimes do several events overseas which is bilateral events, in the internet or worldwideweb we really2 hate each other but when it comes to real life, we are very friendly
As a Muslim living in the US, and seeing all the hate towards Muslims in the west, I really appreciate you for covering this topic to show people that we are just normal humans with normal lives. Thank you!
Macuahuitl copie ton commentaire et mes le normalement pour qu il soit mieu vu
I wish people would separate the ideology from the people. The book is not deeply studied by most adherents. So, they don't realize how shocking the content is. The same is true of the bible. Besides, wars are never fully participated in by any supporting group. When a nation declares war, how many actually participate? Anyway, no one can be objective about their own religion, unless they start to have serious doubts and questions. Even then, initially it is very difficult to stop believing due to indoctrination, group pressure and subsequent feelings of guilt.
Baby, it's not hate. When places like America and Europe are getting terror attacks in the name of their religion.
//Macuahuitl
-if a muslim woman marries a non muslim man thats against her belief, so when you say "they don't seem to fit": you want them to do things against their belief to fit?
-these percentages are so wrong and only imagination based, and only a terrorist would think terror is sometimes needed.
-yes, you are (at least) overreacting.
but in Indonesia, The Largest Muslim Population in one country in the world undoubtly where Indonesia itself is not a muslim country but 85 percent of them are muslim and the most number of muslims in the world live here, we still have other religions here in a big number too like christian, catholic, buddhist, hinduist, and confuciasist that live here happily and treated equally although there issues still of course but that’s only a small number of group. I mean if u want to blame don’t blame the religion because we muslim in Indonesia and also christian in Indonesia are just happy with each other. U want to judge someone? judge from where they come from. Don’t generalize muslim because we Indonesian muslim are the largest muslim people living on Earth not middle east. So blame the middle eastern because they have cruel identity start before muhammad even born. Muhammad spread islam so that the arabs are not like that. But turns out they’re still like that same like moses and the jewish. We are the one who should u judge not them we have the biggest number of muslims living here so judge us come here if u want to and see how friendly we are, even in Bali, they’re still maintaining their hindu religion and tradition and we love to be friends with them also other indonesian which is predominantly muslim and also in the east of indonesia, most of them are christian and we’re still okay with it we’re still friends and hang out together. U judge muslim like that because muslim coming to ur country are from countries that have a lot of conflicts and terror and they are not that civilized maybe. Come here u wouldn’t even think that we are muslim haha because we look a lot different than the middle eastern but we’re still muslim. Islam is just faith man the ones that describe a person is where they come from not what religion they believe. Even us Indonesian we really hate terrorist and we always send our troops inside or outside our country to stop terrorism. So u still think we are terrorist when we always send troops to stop those kind of dumb actions the terrorist do? They are just practically dumb and we’re not so stop generalizing u can judge muslim from ur country which comes from middle eastern country that is quite cruel but stop generalizing islam because we are muslim and we never do those kind of dumb things we even fight alongside with western and eastern people to stop terrorism
I'm Indonesian and I'm Muslim, but I'm not a terrorist.
@Surajit Biswas oh its simple!!! If you hear people read Quran in their home, in the Mosque or everywhere then thats it!!! But most importantly Indonesian people cant translate it
@Surajit Biswas uhhg Mosque leader or Imam/Ustadz isn't that Evil!!! We dont need English version Quran cause not all people understand it!!! Most Indonesian have Phone so they can search Quran Translation in Google. Meanwhile who doesn't have it well they can learn Arabic (even though is not that very hard)
@ZebraZ actually my name is Ramdhani it taken from Quran word : "Ramadhan", coz I was born in the month of Ramadhan an Islam holy month.
@ZebraZ please do some research about Indonesian history before judging our name meanings
@ZebraZ you shouldn't be surprised. Sanskrit names are often used as names for Indonesians, regardless of religion. Fyi, many Muslims but their names are Vishnu, Bayu, Dewi, Saraswati etc
Islamic state isn't, very smart people in Indonesia. Good work!
Come go to Indonesia! we will welcome you very well.
have a good day mr. mark.
because they're democratic not islamic state THOUGH almost all the population were muslim
@Indonesia Javanese Crazy mah gila arti nya , yg bener cracy
@@kyledevin4512 mungkin maksudnya gila demokrasi
Suka demokrasi
I am a muslim from Morocco Islam is what makes me a good person and a good version of my self Islam is the reason why me and many other muslims are doing good deeds and avoid the bad deeds ❤️✨
Definitely Isis is not aligned with most of muslim people in the world, as the big majority of them are normal people who want to enjoy their lives, have a job and take care of their families, as the majority of western and christian people.
Still I ask myself what these people in the video think about atheists.
In other words, they see us the same way Christians in the West see us. They accept we have the right, but they wouldn't protest us being fined, jailed, or worse.
I would have liked to have heard questions like, "What do you think about gay people?" "What do you think about feminism?" "What would you do if your child renounced islam and became an apostate?" "Do you want to live in a secular country?" I'm guessing that most of them would answer in reasonable ways, but a large minority would answer in ways that would not make an atheist liberal like me feel good.
Fsilone im sorry but, i think your situation still better, compare how people see islam and moeslims. Not all people but alot. Alot of people hate islam and moeslims, they want to get rid of us. That hurts actualy..
L Galicki Band im indonesian and im muslim..Most Muslims don’t really care if you’re an atheist. They'll likely think you’re just uninformed and accept you for who you are. Some may even try to convert you in the most loving respectful way. More than likely if some Muslim finds out you're atheist, they might just see it as an opportunity to enlighten you.
Same question for you,what do atheists think about islam?
try to catch me, little ghost I can only talk for myself, and I think that which I already said I'm my original comment: the majority of muslims seem to be regular people who want to enjoy life, have a normal job and take care of their families and friends.
Thank you for your insight.
Indonesian people are friendly and super nice. LIKE REALLY NICE
Thanks for the vid :D
김지호
I😍u
These are very urban, worldly Indonesians and young at that too. It might be a different if you ask older, rural, from different areas.
You're right, sometimes when I talk to elderly their replies was like outworldly, in a bad or good sense nowadays
al4sake i asked my grandmom, she replied "are u insane or backward ?". she is almost 80.
Why u asking an older people? they're living in the past!, in several years they will dead and replaced by these awesome generation, if you want to see the Future, look at them, they have really good perspective in mind.
Elder people in my experience are more syncretic they believe in weird Kejawen beliefs and such
hahaha,,, damn, dude. Lol to this (In several years they will dead and replaced by these awesome generation). xaxaxaxa
I'm from France. Thank you so much for this video
Before Islam became majority in Indonesia, Indonesia is a Hindu & Buddha country for many centuries.
So Islam in Indonesia its different, more softer, caused by fusion with Hinduism & Buddhism values & culture.
Became...why not... was forced to become Islamic.
Regarder des films avec Jean-Paul Belmondo please learn about Indonesia history.
Regarder des films avec Jean-Paul Belmondo
seems you have your own nice world filled with your own thought.....nice..lol
Regarder des films avec Jean-Paul Belmondo you do know that on that era is where many traveling merchant around the world reach the islands in indonesia, trade with em, make a family, spread religion. thats why we got many mixed and pure race of malayu, arabic,and chinese too xD.
white drone
yeah agree. even japanese and dutch
and thats what u called insanely colorfull (in a good way) lol XD
Good job on sharing the views of ordinary people in different places of the world, I think it really brings us all closer together in understanding each other!
every ignorant person in the west has to see this video!
thanks for your real journalism Asian Boss.
Now you're the world's foremost authority on Islam 'cos you seen this video? Real journalism? When was the last time you got off your lazy behind and bothered to read credible material......c'mon, who's being ignorant now Georg??
Too bad it's not going to go too far with the CNN fake news. But I completely agree with your statement.
Thank you for the hardwork you guys do along with your reporting team. Its really good to hear directly from the people and their religion who are indirectly get a misconception from others based on someone's action against the belief in an religion.
Thank you for raising this issue. And by scrolling throughout the comment section, i realized that there are still people think bad about islam at general. That makes me sad. Because religion never taught people to harm others
well yeah, Islam is not a pacifistic religion if someone slaps you have the right to slap them back with the same amount of force if someone tries to kill you your allowed to protect yourself by killing them if it is reasonable in that scenario so it is MAINLY about self-defence and with a really compelling reason such as wars, protecting your home and families etc..
There will always be atleast 2 sides, for better or worse.
Your songs ❤ yeah it does stated in quran ,but doesnt mean every muslim stated jews and christian was a lowest creature
Amazing vid as always, looking forward for more Indonesian videos :D
A friendly reminder that everytime you discriminate or you harm a Muslim, your'e helping ISIS' ideological warfare
"As I travel around the world over the next years, I will be saying to people: if you want to know whether Islam, democracy, modernity and women's rights can co-exist, go to Indonesia"
~ Hillary Clinton
Shes right!
Can u give me the source of clinton said that?
Im an indonesian muslim, and when i go overseas to western areas, the people are actually really friendly
Thanks Steve for making this video about Indonesian content. The subtitle is on point. 👌🏻
Asian Boss, I really appreciate this channel and its message. People need to slow down and get to know one another. I'm learning so much from the people you're interviewing. It's really quite humbling.
Tau2 ngerti bhs indo, tapi ttp aja gue baca sub english nya.. tolol gue
relatable lol
kebiasaan haha
Tapi emang lebih bagus susunan kata di subtitlenya, lebih internasional
Gue baca sub cuma ngecek takut malu2in buat org luar baca, tpi trnyata bagus
Gelar Novian sama,, 😂,ngecek doang takutnya malu2in
The young lady in the yellow hijab is simply lovely.
Seeing this really restores my faith in my own country. The amount of people who are succumbing into extremism in Indonesia is increasing at an alarming rate.
Also, it's worth notifying that not even all female Muslim Indonesians wear headscarves. One time, there was a policy that requires it and the Congress shut it down almost immediately.
Kamu nak pakai tudung atau hijab lantak kamu, ibarat solat, solat itu wajib tapi terpulang pada kamu mahu tunai atau tidak. Dosa tetap dosa cuma bila kamu mati nanti jangan pula salahkan org lain itu sahaja.
@@zmc2585 Bacot dek
Interesting! I never thought that Asian Boss has reached out of my country! Look forward to seeing your other topics in Indonesia!
This is what I expected. Isis is to Islam what the kkk is to Christianity.
i heard somewhere correct me if im wrong that the prophet knew that the world will change in the future drastically so he wanted islam to adapt to modern societies as some rules were not needed in the new world. such as having more than one wife because in those times there were lots of widows because of war and no one to look after the women. whereas nowadays it is more peaceful and not really needed. i think islam needs to adapt not reform!
You are riight xx
kiki kiki i am not sure if you understood my comment?
This is what I believe
another sheep i dont know, i'm muslim but i'm not religius at all ..
Most funniest line :- Islam is all about to pease.😂😂😂😂
i am Crying 🤡😂
Islam is peaceful apart from the backward jihad parts.
go build some toilets in your country😂🤣🤣🤣
My roommate is Muslim. At first, I was a little worried, but after knowing more about him and his religion culture, I think he's definitely a good guy.
So, according to people in the comment section here, as a muslim i'm not left with many options. I'm supposed to be a terrorist killing peple or practicing the taqia if I look like a normal person leading a normal life, and if I don't fit in any of those two categories, then I'm a person who don't know well my religion and they are here to enligh me and teach me about my religion :D
Exactly. If you don't follow the Quran strictly, waging Jihad on infidels, you are considered an infidel, and as such the Quran commands that infidels must be killed. Got it?
Isis follows the Quran and the Hadith correctly.
@@RogerRamos1993 Your view is dangerous and it's utter nonsense. only 2-3% of Islamic teachings prescribe violence. A muslim can have sufficient moral or spiritual guidance in Islam without including violence.
5 pillars of Islam and 6 articles of faith doesn't mention any violent acts.
This is some prescription for us to be a good muslim: salat (prayer), dhikr (rememberring god), zakat (alms), hajj (pilgrimage), shawm (fasting), sadaqoh (alms), free a slave, go to school, conduct mannerism etc.
These are obligatory: belive in god, obedience to parents, speak honestly etc.
These are forbidden: killing, adultery, dringking alcohol, using drugs and tobacco, lying, eating pork and dogs and other animal with claws and fangs, cheating, hating etc.
These are some inner quality we must have: faith, honesty, sincerity, humility, tolerance, etc.
It's a small presentage of Islam I mention here. I am personally not a 100% muslim not because I'm not terrorist. In fact the game is not to become 100% but to have your good deeds outweight you bad deeds the best you can in life.
what's taqqiah?
Thank you so much for talking about this topic which is important to clear the name of Islam from territories. And to make people know that Islam means peace not terror.
Indonesian must unite as "one motherland" not "one belief". by any means, all people from all background shall not repressed from their own right to speak by any majority. we indonesians are different from all countries, and by that, we must show them our strength and "Great Indonesia" vision. Pancasila doesn't recognize single religion, and we indonesian must follow our way of life, not by "My Belief" but as "Our Belief".
Thank you so much for making this video
Thank you so much for bringing up this issue. We are Indonesian love peace and ISIS has nothing to do with Islam at all. Bombing and killing civilian in the name of Allah is not Islam...it is moronic.
I have just begun watching this channel and when i saw this video i've been so happy:)Thank you so much for interwieving this kind of questioning topics to rest of the world.Thank you sooooooooo muucchh😊😊
This was a great video, showing insight into the views of everyday ordinary people yet I feel like an opportunity was missed to ask deeper questions i.e. Can they see how one might misinterpret the religion to the extent of extremism? Or why they think there aren't extremists terrorists from other religions?
Jika mereka salah dalam menerjemahkan kitab suci mereka,, mereka akan tersesat dan akan keluar dari ajaran kitab suci ..!! Bukan hanya di agama Islam di agama lain juga begitu,, ,
Jadi penting bagi orang yang baru belajar agama, jangan sampai belajar ke orang yang salah, tapi mereka harus belajar kepada orang yang paham agama dan ahli kitab suci mereka... Biar mereka tidak salah jalan.. .
I love asian country in our region (southeast Asia) and in East Asia. And we are actually lot of similarity than difference. Politeness, manners, morals, respect parents and ancesstor is important in our culture. Peace✌️🙏♥️☮️👍💪
finally, something about Indonesia
Gezzz Asian Boss always interview idk people from no where...
1:51 wait what 😂😂
Thank you for sharing. I keep trying to tell people in America that Islam is a religion not an ethnicity. Don't let fear keep you from being a healthy, positive member of your community. Live life to the fullest and with joy.
Islamic leaders and all public people in Islam . . . stand up and speak out against the violence! We all need to condemn the terrorist and tell them clearly this is not what Islam wants, every day!
If this happened more louder, more western people will understand your intention and your life is peace. There is no space for terrorist extremist among us, regardless in religion, politics or else.
Thank you for the (too short) video.
We shouldn't have to be more loader...there should be smart enough to think rationally themselves, they caused the problem they have to think it through and solve it :)
i was sooo waiting for this topic......really appreciate your efforts for this video!
If ISIS is not already in Indonesia, they will be at some point, and making there presence known in a big way.
There have been several bombings from members of ISIS... as well as kidnappings...
yeah, media never said anything if we (moslems) were in harmful conditions
Sam P ISIS is ALREADY in Indonesia and we've ALREADY STARTED those TERRORIST
They are here. And they even try to make us one of them 😭😭😭 creepy people.
They ARE already here. We just try to stop the spread continue. If the spread does got worse, the government will put a national emergency and full out war by deploying a lot of soldier
Loved every single second of this. Thank you.
Im a Christian and im Thankful for this channel shedding some light on islam and its difference from ISIS.
I'm Indonesian, and I'm a Christian. But I can tell you that not all Muslim are bad people. Well, some of them are, but most of them are actually nice and kind. And not all people who are Muslim is in ISIS.
Apa cuma aku yg baca translate nya juga meskipun udah paham, gara2 penasaran nerjemahinnya?
Yeah me too! Takut aja gitu klo terjemahan inggris nya ngawur.
Kan kadang ada toh berita di tempat lain, narasumbernya ngomong ini, terjemahannya ngomong malah lain.
come visit us here, and you'll be surprised by how much diversity and how peaceful for you to believe in what you want to belief.
our largest mosque and cathedral is standing face to face (literally)
You guys should interview FPI instead
Ah no. Those idiots (FPI) are too dumb to be interviewed
i think the answer is "ISLAM SEDANG DISAKITI, AYO JIHAD!" terus demo berjilid jilid di monas lol, huuh wahabii wahabii
Please dont do that..cauze it will hurt my eyes..😂
Interview Brunei too. Basically a country ruled by a pro-FPI sultan
hachi roku Nah. Most of their acts are contradictive to the Islam teachings. And by their acts i mean, rebelling and mocking the government, blocking the streets with groundless protests. All of these acts are considered extremist and are prohibited in Islam. They ignore the real teachings of Islam and embarassing us muslims by being ignorant on the streets and mass media, let alone represent muslim in interviews. However i do understand why you have such prejudice towards Islam because the Islam that the media potrays is FPI, but if you learn Islam from the authenticity you will never find any of the FPI acts was justified in Islam.
Proud of indonesians..
*Out of context Comment*
YOOOOOOOO UNIVERSITY OF BRAWIJAYA
emg ada? menit k brp?
banana boy semuanya
Tempat adek gue kuliah. Mantaps. Salam dari alumni Unpad! :)
Busett, tempat emak gw kerja dong
Tadi juga ada museum Brawijaya, Ijen. Pas cfd kayanya
good job on making this vid. westerners need to see or even come visit how indonesians and malaysians muslims live together with chinese buddhists, chinese christians, indian hindus, indian muslims, natives of borneo, foreigners from various faiths, not just living but actually going to school together, work together in various fields, having multi cultured holidays etc. this two countries are what the westerners have been sleeping on regarding Islam as they only Muslims are Arabian middle-east who greeds on oil amongst themselves, and they also sleeping on Pakistan and India and Bangladesh which has large Muslim populations. geography and demographics is not something the common westerners good at especially Americans.
You know what would be interesting? If you ask these muslims the following:
Do they believe if homosexuality is a sin that is punishable by death.
Whether or not they would report a terror plot or a fellow muslim to the authorities if they know they are joining ISIS.
Whether or not death for apostates is acceptable.
Whether or not it is acceptable for a husband to beat their wife
Whether or not it is acceptable for a woman to inherit half of what a man inherits.
Whether or not they believe non-muslims should have to pay the jizya & be 2nd class citizens in Indonesia
& Whether or not they support worldwide sharia law
yes that will be interesting
1. no, Indonesian is already accustomed to having waria [men that behave and identified as a woman and liking man]. they don't care about your sexuality but the country marriage registration is handled by religion department, they don't think they need to meddle with people's intimate relationship and they can get married elsewhere, there's no tax break for a married couple either so they generally has no concern about the difference between gay and normal unmarried people, you can't even see the differences.
2. no, many isis arrests happen because fellow Indonesian told authority that they don't mingle and insist on their own way in performing pray, we did a lot of arrests but ofc none get translated,
3. no, your religion is mine and mine is mine but the one who judge is not us but god in the after life, the story you heard is based on hadith for treason, people who sell their man, country and religion based on court, and court that based on sharia death law should be 100% sure, 99% can't do it so people already accepted that no man can do sharia court, therefore the death penalty should never happen but that's a reminder about hoe big a punishment is for treason,
4. if a husband raise his arm above his shoulder, you can ask for a divorce so that's not acceptable
5. The law of inheritance comes fair cause woman didn't have to divide everything she gets but man need to divide it to his wife and children and the law will abide if the father never said anything but they can get compromised depends on the before death and the children agreement.
6. Jizya ix tax because they didn't pay zakat and it's lower than zakaat [what every capable muslim has to pay], it's not making you 2nd class citizen, actually jizya used for their own court in country where Islam law is implemented so they don't have to go to muslim court when their deeds and things [like sex before marriage or what they want to reform] that has nothing to do with muslim to be done, everyone pay tax and non-muslilm tax is called jizya which can be talked and didn't abide by all the muslilm tax law, in this matter, what muslim pay for their country is actually jizya by definition beause they still pay zakat that has nothing to do with their country, if non-muslim wants to be fair, we don't need to pay tax cause we have our own tax already but that's a ridicolous agreement.
6.shria is a way of life, 75 % of how you should pray, 20% is about what food is permissable, ofc they like the rule, the rule that would let them get a free time for pray and more holiday, what you thought of sharia law is punishment by court which is universally agreeable by muslim can't be done and you can use sharia as inspiration but you can't call it as sharia court, if it happens, it can't be implementd to non-muslim cause sharia only abide people who are in the religion and would be full of people who are stealing sandal at the mosque or get told that you can't eat during fasting.
that's an interesting question but also can be answer if you learn the religion with good mind
@@anastasyavie6236 agree 100%...plus,islam in indonesia is also affected a lot by cultural influence..cant compare it at all with the middle east
Thank you so much for making this video!!
Ini ketemu sama yg moderat kalau ketemu yg radikal ya beda lagi jawaban nya 😊
yaiyalah tololl. wkwkwk kok lucu.
Lebih spesifik lagi karna ini di Jawa Timur yg mana gudangnya Islam moderat.. beda lagi klo di jekardah gudangnya wahabro.. runyam sudah image indonesia.. 😱
@@maduratri02 sy suka Jawa Timur. Islamnya kebanyakan moderat. Jd gak rasis dan mencoreng nama agama lain.
Im indonesian. M a muslim, and trust me ISIS is not Islam at all.. Qur'an teach us to be a kind person, no crime, no kills, no hurting woman n kids, but ISIS did..
They spit so much fax yet people will say they r lying 🤷♂️
Very beautiful to see this video to help overseas frds to understand, and not to get scared by the Muslim belief.
The world is shaped in such a weird way that its okay to be Christian but not okay to be Muslim
Why would you need a religion to tell you how to be a good person, or nice? Just be a good person lmao damn
humans......just a complicated creature.........nothing to worry about
Generally, if you let someone do something bad, they would tend to repeat that action. e.g Bullying
Did your parents send you to school? Why bother to learn from your teacher instead of learn by yourself?
Because ITS our guidance of life
Love Indonesia from Pakistan 🇵🇰♥️🇮🇩
2:10 Islam is very open to other religions. Has she actually been studying?
best joke of the day.
Bro she is from indonesia they don't have riots over there it's literally a good nation
@@janmayswami I don’t know what your comment has to to with Islam being open or not. As for riots, 2022.10 football riot caused 100 deaths in Indonesia.
I hate how the guy at the beginning said that the whole thing is about isis vs the west but in reality its more like isis vs the local muslims or extrimist muslims vs normal muslims ,there r far more muslims died fighting isis than non muslims died fighting isis ,its true that a lot of muslims arent peaceful but compared to the peaceful one theyre like only 0,5 percents ,in fact muslim people suffered the most from isis atrocities than any other countries so blaming us for isis is so wrong
We will never forget what happened in Indonesia in the May of 1998.
ea3dfx *Jakarta
Are u indonesian chinese? Do you know that 98 is not religion issued?
Sparkling Dimond lol you're irrelevant. Also, go back to China.
MANTIS HERE owh, I'm sorry to hear that, so...you're chinese-Indonesian?
MANTIS HERE soalnya kan tragedi 1998 ada kejadian pembantaian etnis tionghoa, makanya saya tanya, masnya org tionghoa atau "pure Indonesian", soalnya saat itu mau ras apapun bisa jadi korban, soalnya rusuh banget, apalagi kejadiannya serentak di seluruh Indonesia, mau di kota ataupun di desa
Keluarga saya HAMPIR jadi korban, soalnya muka ortu sama tante saya mirip org tionghoa, padahal di keluarga saya tdk ada keturunan etnis tionghp aapi utung saja tdk terjadi apa2,
Sweet, mate!
Alot of muslims try to show a one side of islam, I tell you Islam is the most rational religion, not just a religion that teach kindness but teach you how to be strong, to stand for your rights, that what makes our life balanced. Islam is a very inspirational religion. But people dont like it simply cuz it goes against their desires not cuz it itself is bad :) open your eyes and read by yourself.
oh and where is that?
Patatas con panceta yh i have read it in arabic. I meant to ask where if it is everywhere sate 10 with the chapter and verse.
Patatas con panceta not even 10 make it 3 should be enough
Great video!
If you study Islam and Imams, you will see a reason for it; it's not just the NY attack, it's the general culture of MEWahabism.
Walked into this with an open mind wanting to know what they think, not to be lectured the same speil we get all the time "It's just the media". "We are just like you" is not "this is what we believe". Educate about what they DO believe, not them apologizing. This is crap.
Well we shouldn't have to explain ourselves if you think about it if we all thought the same than 1/4 of the world would be suicidal and we would really be in trouble just imagining it is scary enough /0.0/
Abdikadir ismail
Rational people don't think muslims all think alike, just that there are powerful fundamentalist and supremacist movements within islam which support violence and archaic law.
yeah, your right.
Sarahmint
Where are you man remove the VR from your head and see the world around you its more beautiful
Thank you so much for this video..love it! :D