I thought it was interesting that when he called Marzia and then his mom later, he didn't recognize their voices. But when Oliver called, he knew it was him right away. Small detail, but huge meaning.
I can't even allow myself to get fully immersed into the story, cause the ending is so sad, and I'm too sensitive (+ depressed).. I heard a sequel is coming, but I can't really imagine it being/ending any happier than this one... I really do wonder what the sequel is gonna be about tho.
@@weaouw it's apparently based in Paris. It follows Elio and Oliver but there is a back story following Elio's father and his past ~lovers~ aka I think we are seeing his father's almost lover gay boyfriend.
@@corinnacarlotti3141 oh woah really..? I took the father's words in the movie as that he was just close to having that intimate of a relationship with someone. Didn't realize he was talking about an actual gay relationship.. But yeah, when it comes to Elio and Oliver I figured it would look into their lives too, but what I've been wondering is if it's just gonna be about them separately. I mean I can't imagine the author bringing them back together again... Even if that would be great.
someone the book is called “find me” and I think it comes out in October or September (?) this year. And I think Andre Aciman is going to bring them back together
One thing I didn't realize until the second time I watched this movie was with Elio and him answering the phone. He's only on the phone 3 times during the movie: the first it's Marzia and he doesn't recognize her voice, the second time he can't tell if it's his mom or Mafalda who picks up, but the third time he IMMEDIATELY knows it's Oliver on the other line, no question. 🥺
Y'all really obsessed with the fact that he's a straight man enjoying a gay movie, and totally missing all his film analysis. Like those were some well-noticed points and I didn't even take the hints myself, makes me appreciate the filmmaking and art of the movie even more. 💞
@@BlueHat1 Because we're not used to it. Like, maybe you live in West Hollywood, maybe you're only on the part of the Internet where everyone is super liberal anyway, but I'm from a small rural town in Europe and I'm just happy. The people in the comments are happy about his reaction, they're not thanking him, they're expressing their joy at this open and peaceful environment here. Yes, the ideal would be that everybody is treated exactly the same and you don't even have to come out because nobody cares, but we're just not there yet. The legislation that allowed me to marry another woman was passed only two years ago in my country, and you should have heard some of those politicians! How they lower their voices when they say words like "gays and lesbians", how uncomfortable they are with the topic. So no, I'm not gonna pretend that's so normal it's not worth mentioning. It should be, you're right, but it isn't and denying that isn't helping our cause one bit.
Elene Kaldani I’m from South Georgia and I can’t even talk about the lgbtq+ community without distorted looks and judgement so graciously thanking someone for acceptance is so important to make others feel comfortable accepting I think it’s wonderful and you should show you enjoy his acceptance not just ignore it
Michael Stulhberg is an amazing actor in everything that he has been in. I highly recommend the HBO show 'Boardwalk Empire' where he plays gangster Arnold Rothstein. Easily one of my favorite characters. Also he starred in the Coen Brother's 'A Serious Man', so if you want a stand alone film with him there is that.
@@neszellI think elio is talking about if mom knows about his dad not loving her (when the father says I may have come close, but I never had what you two had)
I can't believe you guys are this blind. He was talking about HIMSELF! Elio's father is obviously gay too and that's what made Elio ask him if mom knows. He asked him if she knows that he's bisexual too Notice the way the father looks at photos of greek gods, he adores them! And even Oliver noticed that
As a bi dude who recently started watching this channel, it made me really happy to see a straight guy getting so hyped over a gay movie. Not being weird about at all and just treating it like any other couple. Not just enjoying the movie but actually being excited about the characters. I dunno, just seeing stuff like this makes it feel more normalised in an environment where I feel alienated at times. Thanks for that, this made me smile.
I am surprised that you are happy about this. I love the content of the movie as well. I feel like a lot of people love a good love story, regardless of gender. Possibly I just surround myself with good people so it is shocking when faced with an ugly point of view.
Like this isn’t what I meant. I guess a more appropriate word would be impressed, shocked, grateful, surprised, thankful... I don’t know. I’m talking out of my ass now.
I think Marzia only forgives him because she realized that Elio had a thing with Oliver. And that he was struggling with his sexuality. Again, just a very subtle thing. Elio and Oliver started spending all of their time together and stopped spending time with the two girls. I'm sure they picked up on what was going on.....and that's why Marzia didn't have to ask why Elio was so sad in their last scene together. She knew why.
Actually, I think the two girls get to fully know it when (after Elio and Oliver go on the bus) Elio's mother invites them both to have lunch with her and Elio's father. I think that is the point when they get to realize everything and kinda learn to be ok with that from his mom... Just another example of the full parent's suport... A little detail that made me like the hole situation even more! It may not be the case tho, just my interpretation of that part :) but I totally agree with the reason why Marzia forgives him!
i think marzia knew the whole time. after the dance scene when marzia and elio when swimming marzia says “are you only with me because you’re mad at chiara?” and elio says “why would i be mad at chiara?” and she says something like “because she likes oliver”
Honestly Marzia was such a team player. I wanted to dislike her for getting in the way of Oliver and Elio but I couldn’t bring myself to. She was so sweet and wanted to still be friends with Elio even after everything that happened between them. She deserved love, even if it wasn’t Elio’s.
Virginia Lane Oh she knew somewhat but liked him a lot. Marzia has been close friends with Elio for a long time so she knew him well enough to guess at what was going on. She ended up forgiving him because she realized that he just didn’t like her that way, and she accepted it. She’s still his friend, always will be.
Not trying to be a bit*h, but the movie takes place in Rome or Italy I think. America and Canada are not the end all and be all of The Law. Pretty sure in Japan it’s different as well.
@@amara1884 right everyone’s just forgetting that or acting like it’s okay and it’s just weird…the film tricks them into thinking it’s such a beautiful thing but no
@@lanceelliott2504 wdym? Sexuality has nothing to do with acting. Skill is what you need to cast someone. It’s an actors job to become the role. There are queer actors in the Industry but I don’t think their sexuality has anything to do with their job
Diabolical Butler they said REVOLVING around not wholly ABOUT ie the movie *centers on* somebody who is bisexual not that there is nothing to the movie but ‘oh, a bisexual’
Also, if you remember Elio’s dad talking about the statues, he says that they are almost made to be desired. Oliver DESIRES Elio, it’s plain simple. He just holds back.
When Elio asks his dad, "Does mom know?" He means, "Does mom know [about you]?" His dad had just confided in him that he almost had what Elio and Oliver had, and never found anything like it again. That would include his marriage. Personally, however, I think the mom definitely knew. She was just that strong and gracious and loving of a woman, that she accepted and loved both her men---her husband and her son---for who they were, and cherished them for it.
no he meant does she know ab oliver and elio and the dad was heterosexual but he was talking about a time when he was with a girl he couldve loved but he held back
HickoryDickory86, I agree with your interpretation. It just wouldn't make make sense that the director needs the audience to know what dad knows about mom's perception of Elio and Oliver. 1) We as the audience already know mom knows. 2) What difference does it make for us to know whether dad knows mom knows (or not).
Just to reiterate, mom definitely knew. Her body language later on in the movie shows: when Oliver leaves the breakfast table first, her eyes instinctively peers at Elio. Furthermore, she explicitly asked Elio whether he liked Oliver.
@@avanorby love is love. They arent suggesting the dad is gay but that he never had such a relationship with so much love and connection like Elio and Oliver. Not even with his wife. "Does mom know this." Elio askes about his dads feelings. Yes, because she is a smart strong woman.
The three minutes at the end of Elio crying into the fire just killed me. So powerful yet underplayed at the same time. Had my heart in my throat the last 10 minutes. I can see why Timothee got the Oscar nomination. Can't wait to see him in DUNE.
broooo yes. i read somewhere that timothee had earphones in listening to the scene's song, vision of gideon , while he filmed. checks out. that song makes me feel a type of WAY!
I think he got the wrong meaning from that one, it's supposed to be a question about the mom knowing that his dad used to close to a man or maybe not....
Rene nope, if you have read the book then you’ll remember how the dad continued the sentence with “but even if she knew i think her reaction would be pretty much the same” (referring to his reaction to the topic) which already gives away the fact that they were speaking about Elio. They cut that out, i don’t know why tho
When they're talking about mum knowing I think they mean about the dad not being fully in love with the mother and the father possibly being gay.. that's what I thought when I watched the film awhile ago
@@lifetheslowway huh?? the word "gay" is not a dirty word. using the words "gay" or "bi" or "queer" to describe these characters would not indicate any lack of "class" or anything else.
@@laurapersilva1882 dylan is simply not putting labels and that means class. It's beyond disrespectful to put a label on someone's sexuality if they haven't explicitly said that they're straight, gay, bi, pan, trans etc. They never said that gay was a bad word, they simply said that they were happy that dylan didn't mention the word, since the characters never mention their sexuality or labels.
@@itsmemiaa738 thisss!! Yes. Thank u! I personally don't like labels, but beyond that, I don't like it when people say its a "gay movie", its not because I think its a bad word or something like that, its because they never said that! Even the actors when promoting the movie *always* said its a love story and that love is love. I like both men and women but don't consider myself bisexual or any label, I don't like them, and I wouldn't allow someone to label me and saying it like that's the truth.
Nihal Nihal He means that if you choose to feel nothing instead of feeling anything (hurt, pain, loss) then it’s a waste. Like why would someone choose not to feel? Even if it’s painful.☺️
@@daisypieropan And also that closing yourself off like that leaves a mark on you. His speech resonates so hard with me because that's what I've been doing my entire life. You eventually stop being able to open yourself up to people. I could share my entire life with a stranger and never feel closer to them because I've cut myself off emotionally to protect myself. It's no way to live.
I feel like he edited this in purpose like this. He used to have another channel in which he reacted to music or music videos and the editing was like it is now
@@sushibunnn hello!! May you tell me what is in the Second book? I don’t have enough money for the book currently and I really want to know what happens! Because I’ve been waiting a while for call me by your name 2 comes out haha!
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 to make it short 2/4 of the book shows elios father falling in love with a much younger woman( they have a child in the end if i remember correctly). Then we see elio starting a new relationship with another man but he soon realized that no one can replace Oliver (ofc lmao) and the last bit is about Oliver who understand that he loves elio more then his wife and in the end they return back together Actually I didn't really like it just because I wish it focused more on elio and Oliver but in the end I kinda enjoyed following elios father love story Sorry for any grammatical errors english is not my fist language, also i read it almost a year ago so i don't remember every little bits of the book. I think you can also find it online to read btw^^
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 if you didn't knos btw after the events of the film elio became a very famous pianist and Oliver marries a woman (like it's said in the last scene of the moovie) and they have two sons
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 oh yeah I really recommend to read the first book because it's wrote by elios prospective and you are literally in his mind which btw is a low dirtier then how it's shown in the film and you get much more information about their last trip ^^
This guy was way overreacting to the Dad. If you notice when Elio asks his Dad whether Mum knows, it's unclear whether he's asking about himself or about his Dad. It's a subtle and beautiful touch.
Fun fact: they filmed the movie in chronological time so they could feel everything so real,and at the end timothee had a little like AirPod (¿) and he was listening to visions of Gideon
I feel that when Elio asks: "Does mom know?", he means the deep love he and Oliver felt for each other, something that the dad has picked up on, displayed by his deep monologue, but the mom, throughout the entire movie, views the relationship as a summer fling/ teenage crush rather than fully realizing the extent of her son’s feelings and experiences, so I thought that was a really nice aspect of the movie when the dad says "I don’t think she does."
I honestly thought the dad was telling Elio he was gay too, and that's why he was asking if his mom knew. Like I've only watched it once and that's what I thought and I'm here shocked that no one thinks that too lol
@@eneswk same, I thought his dad was saying how he was in love with another man once and so Ellio was asking if the mom knew that the dad had those feelings
Some stuff in the movie I don’t understand, or at least I didn’t as much the first time, I’m catching on to things more and more when I watch the movie, but that part of him asking if mom knows is the many little stuff I hear throughout the movie that don’t fully understand but I questioned it and thought a lot about it afterwards trying to comprehend, the mom seems aware and accepting of Elio and Oliver but like u said in that summer fling/crush type of way, she’s doesn’t know the full extent of what they’re actually r to each other but the dad seems very aware, the dads iconic talk with his son he’s sounds like he even had sort of the same thing Elio and Oliver had, this movie makes me feel and think so many things it’s crazy
@@eneswk Your interpretation is correct. ELIO asked his dad if his mom knows this heretofore-unknown story of his father's gay past. This revelation shatters the seemingly perfect and open family life they have. But yes, some things are better left unsaid.
The age of consent in Italy is 14. Serenityq26 - what you said is disgusting and derisive, apart from the fact that it’s factually wrong. Did you not watch this film? Elio (the 17yr old) pushed for a physical relationship, Oliver tried repeatedly to prevent it.
serenityq26 “White” so you think that if someone is “supporting” that that’s automatically a white thing? What do white people do today that is pedophile? In Afrika a 13 ist married to a 26 so is that not pedophile. That happens really often in Afrika but I don’t say supporting Pedophile is a African thing? And he didn’t even supported Pedophiles. you’re so mad about 1 Year till he’s “legal” (in America but they are in Italia”) but his parents where fine with him and he also was Oliver never forced him to do something and didn’t try anything it was always Elio. So yeah watch the movie before you talk about stuff you don’t know nothing about
Wait, what implies that dad is talking about his sexuality? From what he said I get that he found someone who could be what oliver was to elio but he didnt go for it and settled with elios mom. Dad could have a love story just as powerful as elio and Oliver's. Not necessarily with a man. But I have seen so many people say that, and I'm genuinely curious what gives it away?
12:53 he missed a cool factor in the movie. Elio had been on the phone 2 times prior to this. First with Marzia and then with his mother. Both times he was unable to recognize them; two people whom he had known his whole life. But he was able to recognize Oliver instantly.
Richell R. i think oliver said “do you mind?” hoping that elio would stop him. of elio had said “yes, i do mind.” then oliver wouldn’t have married her. it’s a shame that elio didn’t say anything
I'm glad you picked up on the little things that make this movie incredible. Everyone who worked on this is an amazing job. Hope you do more videos like this in the future!
caro when I read it two or so years ago, I understood this as Elio finally being able to feel love of some sort. Before he really didn’t love himself en hearing Oliver say his own name (Elio) back to him in a loving way they made that love connection. I don’t know if I really understood it as how the writer wanted it to be interpreted but I found it a sort of victory for Elio to finally feel some sort of love
@caro I thought it was a reference to marriage/union. When a couple marries, the wife usually takes her husband's last name. Since they are both men I guess they would take eachother's last name. So the "Call me by your name, and I'll call you by mine" line, implies that they are life long lovers in a sense that are taking eachother's identity for their own. They form one bond.
That speech from his dad changed my life. Like, literally it changed my way of handling relationships. This book and movie are so touching and I cry even watching just your video lol. There are rumours that there's gonna be a sequel and I hope Luca (the director) gives them a good resolution because the book doesn't and that left a hole in my soul. I love everything about this story ;;___;;
Another thing I really enjoyed about cmbyn is that the same sex attraction was never a source of conflict or despair, which is so unique. Even if it is realistic that thats what happens, it nice to see lgbt people in movies who can just exist and be happy, not have to suffer for their arc.
12:40 It's funny, I never interpreted the "does Mum know?" as Elio asking about him and Oliver, but about that Dad has come close to true love once, and it wasn't with her.
Same, I was so confused when Dylan mentioned Oliver and Elio, like "wait, isn't he talking about his dad never giving himself completely away to another person?"
True, I'm sure he wasn't... Surprised no one told Dylan like higher up, I thought the dad had something with someone he shouldn't have had feelings for.
@@danielag.medrano8987 He came back around at the end of the vid and mentioned that he realized it I believe. Or rather caught his drift later on when he mentioned how much he loved the dads monologue
You didn't pick up the dad part. The dad once had his own Call Me By Your Name story but never came close to being with that person.. he kinda meant he settled for the relationship with Elio's mother.. that's what he meant when he asked "does Mom know?" (About that relationship)
Love seeing a more masculine "presumably straight" guy watch a movie like this instead of a superhero movie or action film. The way he delved into the story and analyzed is so refreshing to see from a younger straight guy. Love the video!! Can't wait to see the movie!!!!
This movie has sooo many amazing things to appreciate, but something I personally really enjoyed is that it never felt slow in a bad way. Like, the movie as you said didn't have thaaat much dialogue, there were long scenes just based on body language, yet they were made in a way that they felt so necessary and the acting just was great. All this moments without dialogue could've slowed down the movie but they didn't, it flows perfectly. Like the scene in the end of Elio crying infront of the fire place, at that point one could just stop the movie and skip that crying scene, you technicaly wouldn't miss anything "important" yet in my opinion is one of the most important scenes in the movie and it's just perfect.
I agree that the story jumped too quickly to the winter scene. It would have been intense if we had been given one or two scenes showing Elio normalizing and adjusting to life without Oliver during the fall, autumn colors fading in, beginning to get over the heartbreak... and then to get that phone call and have to relive it all over again. All the same, an outstanding movie, and this was one of the best review and reaction videos for it. Great job.
The problem with that is the family leaves and goes back to the US for the school year and only comes back for Christmas season. The book skips straight to winter, and I don’t think they wanted to establish him at an American school and a whole new location just for a montage.
We rip out so much of ourselves to be cured of things faster , that we go bankrupt by the age of thirty. And have less to offer , each time we start with someone new. But to make yourself feel nothing , so as not feel anything. What a waste. 💔 ugh
Ok in the scene where his dad is comforting him in the end, I think he didn't realise the dad was coming out to his son in a very subtle way. And Elio was asking if mum knew he was gay not Elio himself. Or at least that's what I got from it
I was really drunk when I watched this movie and I was expecting it to be a nice summer romance so I sobbed relentlessly through the end of the movie and then got incredibly angry because the ending made me sad. Also when Oliver said he was getting married I literally shrieked
the guy with the white blazer who watches elio play the piano is the author of the novel YOU SHOULD READ IT you will hear what elio is thinking when he’s not talking in the scenes in the movies ITS THAT GOOD OF A BOOK i read it before watching and you will hear him in the movie because you know what he’s thinking
agree agree agree. I watched the movie after reading the book and i could hear Elio’s thoughts throughout the movie even if there weren’t any words involved in the scenes
By the way Dylan, the “I don’t think mom knows” was talking about the father’s homosexual relationship when he was younger, which is what he had just confessed to elio. That’s what elio was asking about
I think he was saying that he'd come close to have a love like oliver and elio did (or do), not that it's with a man (well, could be) but more of like the feels, like this intense first love, it's just what I think tho
No. "Does Mom know? I don't think she does" is about Elio/Oliver relationship. Dad lies to Elio in that moment. Luca didn't like the line because clearly she did know but the author insisted it be in there for some reason. Plus, I know it's a bit confusing but Dad didn't confess to almost having a gay relationship. He confessed to not being courageous enough to love as deeply and with as much abandon as Elio did.
I like to think that the pause Professor Perlman takes as he looks in his wife's direction before he says to Elio "I don't think she does" means he doesn't want to speak for her. So, he tells a white lie until Elio can talk to her himself. I also read somewhere that a scene was cut in the Perlman's bedroom that makes it clear that they overhear the boys. I love that idea. They are so cool. His mom's gorgeous.
As a gay man I appreciate your reactions on both channels to the LGBT content. I was wondering in your reaction you commented when Oliver ran his finger around Elios. Mouth if you missed the fact it was exactly as Oliver first touched the face of the statue? Your action as filmed was how I felt till I watched the second time.
I cried on and off for three days straight after I finished watching. Truly it is one of the most beautiful movies I have ever seen. Everything is just freaking AMAZING
His mother actually didn’t know until later, her line “he likes you” was actually taken from a book character Vimini (she figured them out) she was a 10 year old genius with terminal leukaemia, in the book she had a whole side plot going. since the line of great importance with Elio figuring Oliver out they gave the line to the mother.
I love your reaction and how you point out the silence and how it speaks volumes. I remember when first watching this I thought that they said something to each other at the train station but when I rewatched it I realized that they don’t actually speak to each other. Their connection and emotions are so palpable it just seems like they’re speaking to each other.
When Elio was crying at the end during the credits, I couldn’t look away. If I didn’t cry before then I did during the credits. THE CREDITS. he just conveyed so much without any words.
"Timothee Chalamet, that's the genre."
can someone make this a tshirt and actual netflix genre
OMG ME
@@katiee4396 I would buy that shirt
Infinity Lover love the cover of Harold 🌹
leah your fricking profile pic I love it. I love hazza to death omg. 😌💕
“Timothee Chalamet, that’s the genre” me
honestly tho
i almost choke
Same 😂😂
that’s the genre of my entire life
I still quote this 6 years later😂
“he put his head in oliver’s shorts..like that was weird”
me: *P E A C H S C E N E*
tiffany woolworth I KNOW I KEPT LOOKING FOR WHEN HE WAS GOING TO MENTION IT
Peach scene 🍑: Am I a joke to you?
I can never look at another peach again...
Oh yeah. My friend thought the shorts was weird and then the peach she said :O
We just filmed us watching it too, lol
I like ur profile picture Fiona Gallagher
I thought it was interesting that when he called Marzia and then his mom later, he didn't recognize their voices. But when Oliver called, he knew it was him right away. Small detail, but huge meaning.
Claire Frey agreed
Wow I didn't notice that before
@@chelsea7609 bruh was the movie supposed to have subtitles? I felt like i was missing something watching it
@@deja5477 yes some parts do have subtitles.
Chelsea Thomas omg no wonder i was so confused. i guess that’s what i get for watching it on 123movies lol
dylan: _ohh, please, don't make this sad._
me: this movie is the definition of sad
it's got a lot of heartache, but also sweet, adorable moments
I can't even allow myself to get fully immersed into the story, cause the ending is so sad, and I'm too sensitive (+ depressed)..
I heard a sequel is coming, but I can't really imagine it being/ending any happier than this one...
I really do wonder what the sequel is gonna be about tho.
@@weaouw it's apparently based in Paris. It follows Elio and Oliver but there is a back story following Elio's father and his past ~lovers~ aka I think we are seeing his father's almost lover gay boyfriend.
@@corinnacarlotti3141 oh woah really..? I took the father's words in the movie as that he was just close to having that intimate of a relationship with someone. Didn't realize he was talking about an actual gay relationship..
But yeah, when it comes to Elio and Oliver I figured it would look into their lives too, but what I've been wondering is if it's just gonna be about them separately. I mean I can't imagine the author bringing them back together again... Even if that would be great.
someone the book is called “find me” and I think it comes out in October or September (?) this year. And I think Andre Aciman is going to bring them back together
One thing I didn't realize until the second time I watched this movie was with Elio and him answering the phone. He's only on the phone 3 times during the movie: the first it's Marzia and he doesn't recognize her voice, the second time he can't tell if it's his mom or Mafalda who picks up, but the third time he IMMEDIATELY knows it's Oliver on the other line, no question. 🥺
omg that hit me😭
Dude you just wrecked me
OMG YESSSS
I..
OMGGGGGGGGG I AM : DEPRESSION
When i first watched this movie it made me question my life.
Now I want a slightly awkward summer romance in Italy
It's like mood after I watched the movie.
fucking same
SAME
Relatable, have a nice day.
Glad i wasnt the only one. I literally stared at nothing for a moment. Long moment. It made ME question everything. Leaves a huge impression.
Y'all really obsessed with the fact that he's a straight man enjoying a gay movie, and totally missing all his film analysis. Like those were some well-noticed points and I didn't even take the hints myself, makes me appreciate the filmmaking and art of the movie even more. 💞
Nobody missed the analysis. There are just a lot people who aren't used to seeing people have positive reactions to LGBT things.
@@BlueHat1 Because we're not used to it. Like, maybe you live in West Hollywood, maybe you're only on the part of the Internet where everyone is super liberal anyway, but I'm from a small rural town in Europe and I'm just happy. The people in the comments are happy about his reaction, they're not thanking him, they're expressing their joy at this open and peaceful environment here. Yes, the ideal would be that everybody is treated exactly the same and you don't even have to come out because nobody cares, but we're just not there yet. The legislation that allowed me to marry another woman was passed only two years ago in my country, and you should have heard some of those politicians! How they lower their voices when they say words like "gays and lesbians", how uncomfortable they are with the topic.
So no, I'm not gonna pretend that's so normal it's not worth mentioning. It should be, you're right, but it isn't and denying that isn't helping our cause one bit.
i’m sorry i accidentally disliked your comment :(
Elene Kaldani I’m from South Georgia and I can’t even talk about the lgbtq+ community without distorted looks and judgement so graciously thanking someone for acceptance is so important to make others feel comfortable accepting I think it’s wonderful and you should show you enjoy his acceptance not just ignore it
Kingfckn Cole FACTSSS
The actor who played the dad was amazing with the role, he gave me serious robin Williams vibes tho
no wayyy i thought i was the only one who got those vibes
Michael Stuhlberg is amazing indeed.
Yeah in good will hunting
Michael Stulhberg is an amazing actor in everything that he has been in. I highly recommend the HBO show 'Boardwalk Empire' where he plays gangster Arnold Rothstein. Easily one of my favorite characters. Also he starred in the Coen Brother's 'A Serious Man', so if you want a stand alone film with him there is that.
666 likes
"Why is Elio having Sex with someone that is not Armie Hammer? This is WRONG! " Truth
😣😣😣
… this didn’t age well
i'm laughing so hard, sorry
@@Spingler_0 what's going on with him has nothing to do with the relationships in this movie, though, lol
Or, why is Elio having sex with Armie Hammer?! This is absolutely wrong!
Dylan : *is crying*
Elio : “does mom know ?”
Dylan : “pfft mom been knew”
Me : *chokes on water and falls off couch*
MEEEEEEE
@@neszellI think elio is talking about if mom knows about his dad not loving her (when the father says I may have come close, but I never had what you two had)
Enes Üzel well idk, spoiler alert they end up having a divorce
I can't believe you guys are this blind. He was talking about HIMSELF! Elio's father is obviously gay too and that's what made Elio ask him if mom knows. He asked him if she knows that he's bisexual too
Notice the way the father looks at photos of greek gods, he adores them! And even Oliver noticed that
Aseel Anza !! Yeah I agree
As a bi dude who recently started watching this channel, it made me really happy to see a straight guy getting so hyped over a gay movie. Not being weird about at all and just treating it like any other couple. Not just enjoying the movie but actually being excited about the characters. I dunno, just seeing stuff like this makes it feel more normalised in an environment where I feel alienated at times. Thanks for that, this made me smile.
James you’re one of the best things about this world to some of us 🦋
I am surprised that you are happy about this. I love the content of the movie as well. I feel like a lot of people love a good love story, regardless of gender. Possibly I just surround myself with good people so it is shocking when faced with an ugly point of view.
Like this isn’t what I meant. I guess a more appropriate word would be impressed, shocked, grateful, surprised, thankful... I don’t know. I’m talking out of my ass now.
Agreed! I love seeing this kinda shit. Dylan is a breath of fresh air and has a million dollar smile 😃
Can i follow ur Instagram james
I think Marzia only forgives him because she realized that Elio had a thing with Oliver. And that he was struggling with his sexuality. Again, just a very subtle thing. Elio and Oliver started spending all of their time together and stopped spending time with the two girls. I'm sure they picked up on what was going on.....and that's why Marzia didn't have to ask why Elio was so sad in their last scene together. She knew why.
Actually, I think the two girls get to fully know it when (after Elio and Oliver go on the bus) Elio's mother invites them both to have lunch with her and Elio's father. I think that is the point when they get to realize everything and kinda learn to be ok with that from his mom... Just another example of the full parent's suport... A little detail that made me like the hole situation even more!
It may not be the case tho, just my interpretation of that part :) but I totally agree with the reason why Marzia forgives him!
i think marzia knew the whole time. after the dance scene when marzia and elio when swimming marzia says “are you only with me because you’re mad at chiara?” and elio says “why would i be mad at chiara?” and she says something like “because she likes oliver”
Honestly Marzia was such a team player. I wanted to dislike her for getting in the way of Oliver and Elio but I couldn’t bring myself to. She was so sweet and wanted to still be friends with Elio even after everything that happened between them. She deserved love, even if it wasn’t Elio’s.
I related to Marzia more than I did Elio or Oliver
Virginia Lane Oh she knew somewhat but liked him a lot. Marzia has been close friends with Elio for a long time so she knew him well enough to guess at what was going on. She ended up forgiving him because she realized that he just didn’t like her that way, and she accepted it. She’s still his friend, always will be.
“He’s getting married?? It better be to Elio” AHAHAH same
“He-he’s getting married? It better be to Elio!”
Felt that
elio is a minor...
Felt that @Polo
Not trying to be a bit*h, but the movie takes place in Rome or Italy I think. America and Canada are not the end all and be all of The Law. Pretty sure in Japan it’s different as well.
@@amara1884 right everyone’s just forgetting that or acting like it’s okay and it’s just weird…the film tricks them into thinking it’s such a beautiful thing but no
@@Itzezyyyy Italy age of consent is 14 plus thsi wasn't a older person takes advantage of a minor it's a love story don't forget that
The fact that these 2 actors are STRAIGHT and played their part so well blows me
Yes but I wish queer actors were utilized for our own roles
@@lanceelliott2504 wdym? Sexuality has nothing to do with acting. Skill is what you need to cast someone. It’s an actors job to become the role. There are queer actors in the Industry but I don’t think their sexuality has anything to do with their job
@@hannnnaareal YES
Well, apparently. One of them is undeniably married, so there's that.
Hehe blows you hehe
i love how he’s so comfortable in his sexuality that he can watch a movie revolving around a bisexual boy. a lot of men can’t do that, but he can.
its not about bisexuality. its about love. you belittle the movie by saying that
Diabolical Butler elio is literally bisexual. it’s not belittling
@@DiabolicalButler how tf is a sexuality "belittling"
Diabolical Butler what the...but he is🤷♀️😂
Diabolical Butler they said REVOLVING around not wholly ABOUT ie the movie *centers on* somebody who is bisexual not that there is nothing to the movie but ‘oh, a bisexual’
6:13 oliver starts touching elio’s lips in the same way he touched the statue that was brought up from the water
Also, if you remember Elio’s dad talking about the statues, he says that they are almost made to be desired. Oliver DESIRES Elio, it’s plain simple. He just holds back.
Yall are geniuses.
When Elio asks his dad, "Does mom know?" He means, "Does mom know [about you]?" His dad had just confided in him that he almost had what Elio and Oliver had, and never found anything like it again. That would include his marriage.
Personally, however, I think the mom definitely knew. She was just that strong and gracious and loving of a woman, that she accepted and loved both her men---her husband and her son---for who they were, and cherished them for it.
no he meant does she know ab oliver and elio and the dad was heterosexual but he was talking about a time when he was with a girl he couldve loved but he held back
Yeahh idk I think it was about Elio and Oliver
HickoryDickory86, I agree with your interpretation. It just wouldn't make make sense that the director needs the audience to know what dad knows about mom's perception of Elio and Oliver. 1) We as the audience already know mom knows. 2) What difference does it make for us to know whether dad knows mom knows (or not).
Just to reiterate, mom definitely knew. Her body language later on in the movie shows: when Oliver leaves the breakfast table first, her eyes instinctively peers at Elio. Furthermore, she explicitly asked Elio whether he liked Oliver.
@@avanorby love is love. They arent suggesting the dad is gay but that he never had such a relationship with so much love and connection like Elio and Oliver. Not even with his wife. "Does mom know this." Elio askes about his dads feelings.
Yes, because she is a smart strong woman.
The door slamming wasn’t scripted apparently so Timmy freaking out and Armie laughing was just improv
yeah thats true lol
when does this happen in the movie?
Frida Shao the first time they hook up
Elle W. i read this as he mentioned the door slam
The three minutes at the end of Elio crying into the fire just killed me. So powerful yet underplayed at the same time. Had my heart in my throat the last 10 minutes. I can see why Timothee got the Oscar nomination. Can't wait to see him in DUNE.
broooo yes. i read somewhere that timothee had earphones in listening to the scene's song, vision of gideon , while he filmed. checks out. that song makes me feel a type of WAY!
i cried so hard watching that scene its amazing
did we find a movie that dylan actually enjoyed? i think we did.
How can you not like call me by your name? 😂😂
He also likes Titanic
CAUSE ITS AMAZING
@@phonegames9070 yep he does
he liked all Harry potter movies
dylan: *is crying*
elio: “does mom know?”
dylan: “PffFffTtfFffFf MOM BEEN KNEW”
me: *falls off bed*
I think he got the wrong meaning from that one, it's supposed to be a question about the mom knowing that his dad used to close to a man or maybe not....
exactly
Rene nope, if you have read the book then you’ll remember how the dad continued the sentence with “but even if she knew i think her reaction would be pretty much the same” (referring to his reaction to the topic) which already gives away the fact that they were speaking about Elio. They cut that out, i don’t know why tho
When they're talking about mum knowing I think they mean about the dad not being fully in love with the mother and the father possibly being gay.. that's what I thought when I watched the film awhile ago
Niamh Haugh but in the movie they don’t add a small part of the book that specifies the topic that they’re talking about.
fun fact:
the word "gay" or any word related to that was never used in the movie and thats because love IS love.
@rose petal exactly what i was thinking 😂
@@lifetheslowway huh?? the word "gay" is not a dirty word. using the words "gay" or "bi" or "queer" to describe these characters would not indicate any lack of "class" or anything else.
@@LM11116 right?? I'm reading this like why tf do you guys think saying "gay" is bad lol
@@laurapersilva1882 dylan is simply not putting labels and that means class.
It's beyond disrespectful to put a label on someone's sexuality if they haven't explicitly said that they're straight, gay, bi, pan, trans etc.
They never said that gay was a bad word, they simply said that they were happy that dylan didn't mention the word, since the characters never mention their sexuality or labels.
@@itsmemiaa738 thisss!! Yes. Thank u! I personally don't like labels, but beyond that, I don't like it when people say its a "gay movie", its not because I think its a bad word or something like that, its because they never said that! Even the actors when promoting the movie *always* said its a love story and that love is love.
I like both men and women but don't consider myself bisexual or any label, I don't like them, and I wouldn't allow someone to label me and saying it like that's the truth.
“But to feel nothing as not to feel anything.. what a waste.” This was one of my favorite lines from the movie... always makes me tear up
Nihal Nihal He means that if you choose to feel nothing instead of feeling anything (hurt, pain, loss) then it’s a waste. Like why would someone choose not to feel? Even if it’s painful.☺️
@@daisypieropan And also that closing yourself off like that leaves a mark on you. His speech resonates so hard with me because that's what I've been doing my entire life. You eventually stop being able to open yourself up to people.
I could share my entire life with a stranger and never feel closer to them because I've cut myself off emotionally to protect myself. It's no way to live.
@@Lucifronz I totally get you. I’m the same. Sending you love. xx
Wow his editing has improved sooo much since this reaction
I didn't even peep the improvement 😂
It’s wild what improved in a year
IKR ! Like I was shook.
I feel like he edited this in purpose like this. He used to have another channel in which he reacted to music or music videos and the editing was like it is now
Yeeeees I've just said this !!!!
“I know us white people, we love our haircuts”. TWO YEARS LATER AND WE SEE THAT WAS VERY TRUE.
BasicBrittani THATS WHAT IM SAYING
Hahaha
IMAO
Now Dylan looks like he doesn’t get his hair cut
@@skyemadisyn163 in the best way possible
*Dad* : Have I spoken out of term?
*Dylan* : * softly * No...no.
Turn?
I just went back to that part to look for him saying that and burst out laughing
WE DIDN'T GET TO SEE YOUR REACTION TO THE PEACH SCENE
i was waiting for that too lol
@@DiabolicalButler 😐
NothingPenguin the only thing I was thinking while watching the scene ...
WHo THE FUCK FUcks A FRUiT ESpeciAlly a PeacH 🍑😂
@@destielswizzle3655 wait what? Mind telling me what happens?
@@elis2506Masturbation with a peach. Someone then threatens to eat it, but tastes some of the semen and stops
Elio: "What your getting married... I suppose?"
Oliver: "...I might be getting married next spring"
Me: "say sike rn"
There’s a change Oliver finna leave his wife for elio and elio probably has a boyfriend after he forgot about Oliver and after the call
I started crying when I saw elio crying at the end
No cap?
It's when he asks "do you mind" and you can literally hear how his breathing gets heavier and heavier
@@meowchuu7185 Making me cry again :))))))))))
Elio: puts his head in Oliver’s shorts
Dylan: that’s weird!
Me: ohhhh boy, just you wait...
Bethan Moran 🍑
It's just a whole rollarcoaster of second-hand embarrassment and fangirling/boying
In the book he did much worse to those shorts
Ayla D like what ?
@@unknown-qe3ep what.. did he do 😳
You low-key obsessing over Timothee is so relatable
You have my life in your profile picture
Jesu Stenger same
i stan your pfp
Dylan: “He’s getting married?” *looks personally attacked*
😭😭
@@herkai06
I resonate with your name so deeply
The ending is what gets me the way he whispers Elio into the phone and when he’s crying into the fire and looks up straight into the camera
Read the second book!!
@@sushibunnn hello!! May you tell me what is in the Second book? I don’t have enough money for the book currently and I really want to know what happens! Because I’ve been waiting a while for call me by your name 2 comes out haha!
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 to make it short 2/4 of the book shows elios father falling in love with a much younger woman( they have a child in the end if i remember correctly). Then we see elio starting a new relationship with another man but he soon realized that no one can replace Oliver (ofc lmao) and the last bit is about Oliver who understand that he loves elio more then his wife and in the end they return back together
Actually I didn't really like it just because I wish it focused more on elio and Oliver but in the end I kinda enjoyed following elios father love story
Sorry for any grammatical errors english is not my fist language, also i read it almost a year ago so i don't remember every little bits of the book. I think you can also find it online to read btw^^
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 if you didn't knos btw after the events of the film elio became a very famous pianist and Oliver marries a woman (like it's said in the last scene of the moovie) and they have two sons
@@xxsunsetvibezxx3336 oh yeah I really recommend to read the first book because it's wrote by elios prospective and you are literally in his mind which btw is a low dirtier then how it's shown in the film and you get much more information about their last trip ^^
No commentary on the Peach Scene? I was waiting for it.
And Elio repeating Elio on the phone. The two he skipped over that made this film so beautiful
Michael Hardin saaaaaaame and the trip scenes
Me too
Just checking whether somebody has already commented this...
Just read the book and you Will be suprised over the peach scene🍑
As a gay man, this is one of the few gay flicks that actually made me cry. Brilliant acting, writing and directing.
Same here…I just died 😭🤷♂️❤️🩹
When Dylan cries... he's so attractive
More attractive* :p
I second that
@@alex-kv9ey Not really, just that a man that's not afraid to show emotions other than anger is very attractive.
Kilian Rayleigh HAHAHAHAHHAHA
@@sofiasalazar7983 ? Did I say something funny?
Elio’s father: “you two had a nice friendship”
Dylan: “U SERIOUS DAWG?!”
This guy was way overreacting to the Dad. If you notice when Elio asks his Dad whether Mum knows, it's unclear whether he's asking about himself or about his Dad. It's a subtle and beautiful touch.
Fun fact: they filmed the movie in chronological time so they could feel everything so real,and at the end timothee had a little like AirPod (¿) and he was listening to visions of Gideon
It’s called a Walkman… haha
Timmy deserved an Oscar
Corbin Gross SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK!!!!!
He deserves an Oliver 😭
Dan de León oh he got it
Dan de León omfg you’re so right
This film broke me. So beautiful. I could watch it again and again and go to sleep to it.
greatly relate to this
I watched it 4-5 times
I feel that when Elio asks: "Does mom know?", he means the deep love he and Oliver felt for each other, something that the dad has picked up on, displayed by his deep monologue, but the mom, throughout the entire movie, views the relationship as a summer fling/ teenage crush rather than fully realizing the extent of her son’s feelings and experiences, so I thought that was a really nice aspect of the movie when the dad says "I don’t think she does."
I honestly thought the dad was telling Elio he was gay too, and that's why he was asking if his mom knew. Like I've only watched it once and that's what I thought and I'm here shocked that no one thinks that too lol
@@eneswk same, I thought his dad was saying how he was in love with another man once and so Ellio was asking if the mom knew that the dad had those feelings
Some stuff in the movie I don’t understand, or at least I didn’t as much the first time, I’m catching on to things more and more when I watch the movie, but that part of him asking if mom knows is the many little stuff I hear throughout the movie that don’t fully understand but I questioned it and thought a lot about it afterwards trying to comprehend, the mom seems aware and accepting of Elio and Oliver but like u said in that summer fling/crush type of way, she’s doesn’t know the full extent of what they’re actually r to each other but the dad seems very aware, the dads iconic talk with his son he’s sounds like he even had sort of the same thing Elio and Oliver had, this movie makes me feel and think so many things it’s crazy
@@eneswk Your interpretation is correct. ELIO asked his dad if his mom knows this heretofore-unknown story of his father's gay past. This revelation shatters the seemingly perfect and open family life they have. But yes, some things are better left unsaid.
Great film, don't need to be gay to appreciate this masterpiece
serenityq26 what? I don’t get how the comment was supporting pedophilia
@@serenityq26 elio:*is 17*
Oliver:*is 24*
Both of them:*fall in love with each other*
People who didnt get the point at all:'what a pedophile'
serenityq26 age of consent there is 17.......
The age of consent in Italy is 14. Serenityq26 - what you said is disgusting and derisive, apart from the fact that it’s factually wrong.
Did you not watch this film? Elio (the 17yr old) pushed for a physical relationship, Oliver tried repeatedly to prevent it.
serenityq26 “White” so you think that if someone is “supporting” that that’s automatically a white thing? What do white people do today that is pedophile? In Afrika a 13 ist married to a 26 so is that not pedophile. That happens really often in Afrika but I don’t say supporting Pedophile is a African thing?
And he didn’t even supported Pedophiles. you’re so mad about 1 Year till he’s “legal” (in America but they are in Italia”) but his parents where fine with him and he also was Oliver never forced him to do something and didn’t try anything it was always Elio. So yeah watch the movie before you talk about stuff you don’t know nothing about
I think the 'does mom know' was more about his dad and his sexuality
Shanne Pieters that’s exactly how I interpreted it!
@@EXOsNoona that's what exactly it is!
It was more so that he had been close to being in love like that of elio’s relationship
Wait, what implies that dad is talking about his sexuality? From what he said I get that he found someone who could be what oliver was to elio but he didnt go for it and settled with elios mom. Dad could have a love story just as powerful as elio and Oliver's. Not necessarily with a man. But I have seen so many people say that, and I'm genuinely curious what gives it away?
@@yoanapetrova3767 I can't rememder exactly what it was but just watch the scean again maybe you find out
12:53 he missed a cool factor in the movie. Elio had been on the phone 2 times prior to this. First with Marzia and then with his mother. Both times he was unable to recognize them; two people whom he had known his whole life. But he was able to recognize Oliver instantly.
Actually the second time was Mafalda iirc, but yeah, this is true
"So he said what genre and i said Timothée Chalamet that's the genre" MOOD
I love when straight men respect and even admire LGBT content, well done dude, you are an example to many!
MaxMartell 'straight men'
i dont think dylan said hes straight
Straight or gay aren't the only two options available to mankind.
he's not gay? :(
MaxMartell omg it was a joke
Dylan: “He’s getting married... It better be to Elio”
That is TOO relatable a response
"Do yOU MIND??"
....
"Do you want HIS BLESSING?!"
*Sad but funny*
Richell R. i think oliver said “do you mind?” hoping that elio would stop him. of elio had said “yes, i do mind.” then oliver wouldn’t have married her. it’s a shame that elio didn’t say anything
I'm glad you picked up on the little things that make this movie incredible. Everyone who worked on this is an amazing job. Hope you do more videos like this in the future!
watching this 6 years later, and the fact that dylan said AUDIBLE without it introducing a sponsor is very funny to me
I’m honestly so sad that Dylan didn’t put the “call me by your name and I’ll call you by mine” scene in the video.
Or the waterfall one
@caro in the book, oliver says that while doing elio... so the meaning is really powerful as their bodies complement each other
caro it’s their own way of saying ily
caro when I read it two or so years ago, I understood this as Elio finally being able to feel love of some sort. Before he really didn’t love himself en hearing Oliver say his own name (Elio) back to him in a loving way they made that love connection. I don’t know if I really understood it as how the writer wanted it to be interpreted but I found it a sort of victory for Elio to finally feel some sort of love
@caro I thought it was a reference to marriage/union. When a couple marries, the wife usually takes her husband's last name. Since they are both men I guess they would take eachother's last name. So the "Call me by your name, and I'll call you by mine" line, implies that they are life long lovers in a sense that are taking eachother's identity for their own. They form one bond.
That speech from his dad changed my life. Like, literally it changed my way of handling relationships. This book and movie are so touching and I cry even watching just your video lol. There are rumours that there's gonna be a sequel and I hope Luca (the director) gives them a good resolution because the book doesn't and that left a hole in my soul. I love everything about this story ;;___;;
MG Alvarez now that we know the second book is coming out, “Find Me”, is coming out this year, i’m really hoping that we get a movie from it as well
Katie We will but Luca says the film won’t come out until like 2023 ish
@@corinnacarlotti3141 it's worth the wait
@@kaytanna wait what there's a second book coming, I'm literally crying rn
@@kaytanna NO WAY! I'm so happy 😭
Another thing I really enjoyed about cmbyn is that the same sex attraction was never a source of conflict or despair, which is so unique. Even if it is realistic that thats what happens, it nice to see lgbt people in movies who can just exist and be happy, not have to suffer for their arc.
12:40 It's funny, I never interpreted the "does Mum know?" as Elio asking about him and Oliver, but about that Dad has come close to true love once, and it wasn't with her.
Same, I was so confused when Dylan mentioned Oliver and Elio, like "wait, isn't he talking about his dad never giving himself completely away to another person?"
I went through the entire chat to find this. Exactly my thought!
True, I'm sure he wasn't... Surprised no one told Dylan like higher up, I thought the dad had something with someone he shouldn't have had feelings for.
I join in
@@danielag.medrano8987 He came back around at the end of the vid and mentioned that he realized it I believe. Or rather caught his drift later on when he mentioned how much he loved the dads monologue
You didn't pick up the dad part. The dad once had his own Call Me By Your Name story but never came close to being with that person.. he kinda meant he settled for the relationship with Elio's mother.. that's what he meant when he asked "does Mom know?" (About that relationship)
Luna S. aaahhhhhhhh
Ya he addressed that near the end of the video
Ohhhhhh yea that makes more sense now
But in the script it says “I don’t think she does” he said meaning if she did she would say the same thing. So i think it was about elio and oliver
i thought so too but the script implies the latter
i love being here in 2023 and hearing the word "DVD player" i miss these days
at least its better than when you hit the spacebar on disney+ and it doesn't pause
Love seeing a more masculine "presumably straight" guy watch a movie like this instead of a superhero movie or action film. The way he delved into the story and analyzed is so refreshing to see from a younger straight guy. Love the video!! Can't wait to see the movie!!!!
This movie has sooo many amazing things to appreciate, but something I personally really enjoyed is that it never felt slow in a bad way. Like, the movie as you said didn't have thaaat much dialogue, there were long scenes just based on body language, yet they were made in a way that they felt so necessary and the acting just was great. All this moments without dialogue could've slowed down the movie but they didn't, it flows perfectly. Like the scene in the end of Elio crying infront of the fire place, at that point one could just stop the movie and skip that crying scene, you technicaly wouldn't miss anything "important" yet in my opinion is one of the most important scenes in the movie and it's just perfect.
he said "what genre", and I said "Timothee Chalamet, that's the genre" 😂 LMAOOOO
“So he said ‘what genre’ and I said ‘timothee chamalet” 😂
you need to read the book so you can read Elio's mind
I bought the book after I saw the movie , but I haven't read it yet
The book is SOOOOOOOO good...
Omg the book is amazing
The audiobook is narrated by Armie Hammer... just saying 😍
i LOVEEDD watching the movie after reading the book, and, like you said, read elios mind. like, i KNOWWW what elio is thinking hahaha
I agree that the story jumped too quickly to the winter scene. It would have been intense if we had been given one or two scenes showing Elio normalizing and adjusting to life without Oliver during the fall, autumn colors fading in, beginning to get over the heartbreak... and then to get that phone call and have to relive it all over again. All the same, an outstanding movie, and this was one of the best review and reaction videos for it. Great job.
The problem with that is the family leaves and goes back to the US for the school year and only comes back for Christmas season. The book skips straight to winter, and I don’t think they wanted to establish him at an American school and a whole new location just for a montage.
@@lifetheslowway in the book he goes to England no back to the us
11:06
"look you had a beautiful friendship" Dylan: 😂
"..maybe more than a friendship" Dylan: OH 😯
LMAOO IM TWO YEARS LATE BUT THE EMOJI FITTED HIS FACE SO WELL LIKE HIS MOUTH MADE A O SHAPE LMFAOO
We rip out so much of ourselves to be cured of things faster , that we go bankrupt by the age of thirty.
And have less to offer , each time we start with someone new.
But to make yourself feel nothing , so as not feel anything.
What a waste.
💔 ugh
that was one heavy wisdom i found really hard to take for its relevance
the reason why Mr. Pearlman thought they had a nice friendship is because he read way too many history books
😂😂
Ah yes the historian and their friendzone lens.
You HAD to see the ending, when Elio looked at the camera, you could FEEL his pain and emotion.... 😭
bro dylan on the verge of tears and then laughing at the first chance is such a solid mood
That talk with dad at the end is literally the most beautiful parenting I have ever seen on film
Honestly....my biggest weakness is guys in a black turtle neck shirts or no sleeve shirts........wow my prayers have been answered *such. a. look.*
CheerUp2 bdfbdbf same omgg! it’s so attractive
Reminded me of Dwayne Johnson on that turtleneck
Steve jobs kinky
@@thebelovedsavage2261 ok you read my mind
Ok in the scene where his dad is comforting him in the end, I think he didn't realise the dad was coming out to his son in a very subtle way. And Elio was asking if mum knew he was gay not Elio himself. Or at least that's what I got from it
miranda correa no in the book elio asked if his mom knew about elio’s sexuality. there is a line that reveals it
@@elysian404 hmmm
No the dad is actually straight because in the second book he gets together with a younger women and falls in love.
What i got from the movie is that his dad is bisexual and he almost had an experience like his son
@@dikshamalhotra321 what about Elio's mother??
When Dylan said "you're a good dad" I felt that, my mom felt that, my boss felt that, even God felt that.
I was really drunk when I watched this movie and I was expecting it to be a nice summer romance so I sobbed relentlessly through the end of the movie and then got incredibly angry because the ending made me sad. Also when Oliver said he was getting married I literally shrieked
“He schedules Marzia” 💀
i was almost about to roast them for not wearing mask but then i remmembered: 'oh yeah, people didn't wear masks two years ago when shit was normal'
Cringe
we never had to wear masks at all where i live oop
This movie was set in 1983, almost four decades before COVID-19.
@@A1441 they obviously mean the part where he was at the hairdresser
*The arm*
And it’s reaching
*RIGHT THERE*
the guy with the white blazer who watches elio play the piano is the author of the novel YOU SHOULD READ IT you will hear what elio is thinking when he’s not talking in the scenes in the movies ITS THAT GOOD OF A BOOK i read it before watching and you will hear him in the movie because you know what he’s thinking
agree agree agree. I watched the movie after reading the book and i could hear Elio’s thoughts throughout the movie even if there weren’t any words involved in the scenes
"Do you guys like this asmr?" *talks over the sounds*
Straight guy reacting to gay stuff the right way... Heteros please take note!
preach!
We all react like that lmao stop grouping us
Fanette Grivet actually a lot of straight men would find a gay relationship uncomfortable to watch so it’s nice to see this kind of reaction
eww.. why do you have to make it so dramatic? its supposed to be normal right? people like you disgust me
wow ok that was not necessary
YOU DIDNT EVEN TALK ABOUT THE PEACH SCENE!!!
@I don’t exist "you're killing me when you do that"
The director wanted us the viewers to feel what Elio was feeling, especially during the credits they wanted that scene to stick. It was good
Literally paused this video just to go watch "Call Me by Your Name" and it was such a good movie!
Omg sameeee. But then I read the book
@@dorishysa490 is thge book bad or something?
@@valkyrie7304 the book is more explicit
throwing hands at 4 o'clock oooohh yeah that is true
saaame! and i loved it
Dylan: is crying
Elio: does mom know
Dylan : ptfptfptfp mom been knew
dad: I don’t think she does
Dylan : starts laughing
hotel: travago
@@janaloff HAHDHD
i love how dylan reads the movie in such a detailed way
"Timothy Chalamet, that's the genre."
Best Dylan Quote
By the way Dylan, the “I don’t think mom knows” was talking about the father’s homosexual relationship when he was younger, which is what he had just confessed to elio. That’s what elio was asking about
ikr!!
I think he was saying that he'd come close to have a love like oliver and elio did (or do), not that it's with a man (well, could be) but more of like the feels, like this intense first love, it's just what I think tho
No. "Does Mom know? I don't think she does" is about Elio/Oliver relationship. Dad lies to Elio in that moment. Luca didn't like the line because clearly she did know but the author insisted it be in there for some reason. Plus, I know it's a bit confusing but Dad didn't confess to almost having a gay relationship. He confessed to not being courageous enough to love as deeply and with as much abandon as Elio did.
That's actually up to interpretation, I so it as he never found true love
I like to think that the pause Professor Perlman takes as he looks in his wife's direction before he says to Elio "I don't think she does" means he doesn't want to speak for her. So, he tells a white lie until Elio can talk to her himself. I also read somewhere that a scene was cut in the Perlman's bedroom that makes it clear that they overhear the boys. I love that idea. They are so cool. His mom's gorgeous.
These old videos are sooo .... I don't know what the word is... It's... I need more.. Dylan is entertaining
As a gay man I appreciate your reactions on both channels to the LGBT content. I was wondering in your reaction you commented when Oliver ran his finger around Elios. Mouth if you missed the fact it was exactly as Oliver first touched the face of the statue? Your action as filmed was how I felt till I watched the second time.
Dylan was just so speechless during the peach scene he just didn't add it in
'Don't sniff anybody's clothes...in private. ' Dylan buddy it's not okay in public either. I love you. You're hilarious
I cried on and off for three days straight after I finished watching. Truly it is one of the most beautiful movies I have ever seen. Everything is just freaking AMAZING
When mystery of love starts playing, I'm crying from then on till the very end
Like Hephaestion, who died
Alexander's lover
Now my riverbed has dried
Shall I find no other?
My song
do you think Hephaestion was Alexander's lover?
@@akshitamaheshwari2978 You should watch the film Alexander, starring Colin Farrell
@@Dove101 it was a shit film lmao. Also there's no reputable evidence that Hephaestion and Alexander were lovers
It's Christi I respect your opinion about the film but regarding Alexander’s sexuality it’s merely common knowledge...
His mother actually didn’t know until later, her line “he likes you” was actually taken from a book character Vimini (she figured them out) she was a 10 year old genius with terminal leukaemia, in the book she had a whole side plot going. since the line of great importance with Elio figuring Oliver out they gave the line to the mother.
Wizardporn2008 The mom in the movie CLEARLY KNOWS. The director obviously made a different decision to the writer of the book.
“It might be a FORGED signature” I died 😂
Timothée cried during the credits, if that’s not good acting then I don’t know what that is
I love your reaction and how you point out the silence and how it speaks volumes. I remember when first watching this I thought that they said something to each other at the train station but when I rewatched it I realized that they don’t actually speak to each other. Their connection and emotions are so palpable it just seems like they’re speaking to each other.
When Elio was crying at the end during the credits, I couldn’t look away. If I didn’t cry before then I did during the credits. THE CREDITS. he just conveyed so much without any words.
Ellio has the best parents ever
In the book, elio wants to get caught in his shorts