Agreed. Great orchestration- piccolo in the third register is bold and sounds right and nice low brass parts. Similarities between Debussy's _La Mer_ (which came 10 years after this work) and Gilson's appear to end at the title, as Gilson's harmony is usually characterized as Wagnerian while Debussy established a new school of harmony. Your comment inspired a search for any connection between the two contemporaries, but I couldn't find any, Gilson's work centered in Belgium and Debussy in France. But I can't help but think Debussy must have been aware of Gilson, his academic writing and this piece, but that did not deter him from using the same title. An unreferenced forum comment states, "It is said that Debussy took his inspiration for his own La Mer from Gilson's work.," which, if true, might be categorized as imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, or more likely drove Debussy to write in a wholly new way, kind of an anti-inspiration. Interestingly, Gilson's work was well regarded in his lifetime while Debussy's _La Mer_ was not well received, but history is capricious, and novelty is often rewarded.
Is this AI generated? It seems there is a lot of style transfer. Sometimes Nikolai Rimsky Korsakov, sometimes somebody else, Sounds too generic to be a real person. Tchaikovsky's Tempest was way better. Wait, now that I've listened too more of this crap, the more I listen this the angrier I get. Why would anyone bother writing all these useless notes?
Moscow Symphony Orchestra conducted by Frederic Devreese.
Excellent work!
What?
@@donaldlidman8670 I like the piece
Beautiful work. Guess you can use any title that's been used before if your work does not resemble the other work .
Especially if it's a title as basic as "The Sea"
Agreed. Great orchestration- piccolo in the third register is bold and sounds right and nice low brass parts. Similarities between Debussy's _La Mer_ (which came 10 years after this work) and Gilson's appear to end at the title, as Gilson's harmony is usually characterized as Wagnerian while Debussy established a new school of harmony. Your comment inspired a search for any connection between the two contemporaries, but I couldn't find any, Gilson's work centered in Belgium and Debussy in France. But I can't help but think Debussy must have been aware of Gilson, his academic writing and this piece, but that did not deter him from using the same title. An unreferenced forum comment states, "It is said that Debussy took his inspiration for his own La Mer from Gilson's work.," which, if true, might be categorized as imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, or more likely drove Debussy to write in a wholly new way, kind of an anti-inspiration. Interestingly, Gilson's work was well regarded in his lifetime while Debussy's _La Mer_ was not well received, but history is capricious, and novelty is often rewarded.
again what?
Is this AI generated? It seems there is a lot of style transfer. Sometimes Nikolai Rimsky Korsakov, sometimes somebody else, Sounds too generic to be a real person. Tchaikovsky's Tempest was way better. Wait, now that I've listened too more of this crap, the more I listen this the angrier I get. Why would anyone bother writing all these useless notes?
Well, there are people who bother writing useless comments. :)
@@SPscorevideos And then there are people that don't realize a joke comment when the see one.
@donaldlidman8670 A joke? Thank God you don't work as a comedian then 😂