The real answer is the best one doesn’t exist. Idk why someone doesn’t make a decent GameCube controller that looks and plays like the original GameCube controller
Harder than it seems. Mainly cause retrofighters is a budget company. One for a niche market, but still budget. There isn't a way for them to make their controllers as good unless it's more expensive by a bit. While other companies really try, but also try to add more unnecessary gimmicks. Like the nyxi one has different stick grooves, so they can't be as good. Or at least their focus wasn't centred on making it feel just as good. Only way to make controllers as good as gamecube controllers is by salvaging components. And that isn't really legal to sell
@@teneesh3376 all a company has to do is build a quality mold that matches the original controller with some updated hardware. There are tons of companies that could do this but it seems they focus more on their own designs instead which is fine. But I guarantee you a high quality GameCube controller would sell well.
@@duke_8747 you also forget good circuits and components. Both are much harder to surpass the gamecube's on a budget. But I agree that if they upped the price with better controllers. Retrofighters mindset just satisfies no one. Especially outside the US with them costing nearly AUD 120 with shipping
I have a Blade because I like the larger dpad for indie/retro games and the symmetrical stick placement is more familiar to me being more of a PlayStation gamer. It's a decent controller but my main issue is the face buttons feel pretty stiff. I'm not sure if that's just because I haven't used it a lot or if they're just going to stay that way.
NYXI just made something exactly like that recently called the Wizard. It really looks more beefier than the Retro Fighters, it comes with 1 GC adapter with a USB C port for PC. It can be used for a variety of systems (any system that utilizes the GameCube controller and also as a Switch controller). The NYXI also had Hall effect sticks and programmable back buttons.
While the BattlerGC seems fine as a controller with a Gamecube button layout, I can't say it's something I'm personally interested in. Part of what I like about a Gamecube controller is also the feel of the body of the controller. Funny enough, I don't even think the original Gamecube controller is even the best anymore, at least for modern standards. It's buttons feel are still the best, but it lack of of a right shoulder button, stiff and small directional pad, and lack of a select/-/share button makes me not really care to use mine. Also, I'll be honest, while I prefer the button feel of the Original Gamecube, as long as they aren't completely horrible, I don't mind the button feel of many other 3rd party controllers as much since I generally adjust pretty quickly. In that regard, my Exlene Gamecube Style controller will still be my go to but even that one is FAR from perfect.
Until someone, somewhere can make a GameCube-style controller for Switch that actually accurately mimics the original GameCube controller right down to its unique analog triggers, I’m just going to stick with my PowerA GameCube controller I already have for my Switch.
You might not know this, but it is possible to mix and match the Retro Fighters wireless controller products as long as it's the Defender, BladeGC and BattlerGC. I was able to make the BladeGC work on a PS2 via Defender receiver, and it actually works as a Defender alternative with the better form factor and directional button placement. Fighting games feel much better when using a BladeGC, though inputting the "gigantic press" motion supers can be a bit frustrating compared to OEM directional buttons.
What if the analog and dpad were on a switch-like rail and could be slid off, flipped, and would slide on again so you could swap the analog and dpad. Like a dpad/analog switch.
I just wish they'd hurry up and make a rechargeable version of the Power A GameCube switch controller. I just can't cave in and buy it until that's a thing but that's exactly the type of controller I want.
I was never able to get a Wavebird back in the day, it was always out of stock. I’m assuming this would make a good Wavdbird clone since it has an adapter for Ganecube?
Question: I wanna use this with 3D All-Stars version of Super Mario Sunshine and I saw it has an adapter for GameCube. I know when you plug in a GameCube controller with the Adapter the controls go back to the OG controls. If I use that Adapter this controller comes with would the Triggers be like Switch or OG GameCube Trigger?
@@Gtune8 that's my Idea. Plug in the GameCube Controller Adapter into the Switch, then Plug the Adapter from this Controller (GameCube Version) into the Adapter that's plugged into the Switch and use it like a Wave Bird Controller
This was working fine on my steamdeck but stopped working last night. My pc reads it fine though, anyone have a similar issue? I wonder if the recent update messed things up.
Some folks want a controller that takes the best of Gamecube while getting rid of the bad. Hot take but the controller was not perfect and had some glaring flaws. Only having one shoulder button, a terrible D pad, no select button, the sticks can't be used as clickable buttons and the C stick is a tiny lil nub. So yeah some of us want a more modern GC controller that does away with the original's flaws.
@@Neon_Plasma I feel like if you want to play games the gamecube way get the original Gamecube controller, and if you either want retro or modern controls get an 8bitdo or switch pro controller. Nothing can really compare to the original GCC
There's no such thing a the "BEST" Gamecube anything. There's only "the least offensive and mediocre" Gamecube controllers. Let's never forget that nearly everything associated with the Gamecube (and by proxy, Nintendo) was utter mediocrity.😂
@@witchbvrner Could you be referring to the PowerA controller? It appears to be officially licensed, but not made by Nintendo. Overall, it actually doesn't look that bad. The biggest drawback is that it seems to lack the analog triggers that the original had. It also has various more minor changes like the larger bumpers that I wouldn't be able to judge without trying it. 18$ for the wired version, I might actually have to try it. It doesn't have _nearly_ as much as what the Panda Controller would've had, but it's probably the next best thing.
The real answer is the best one doesn’t exist. Idk why someone doesn’t make a decent GameCube controller that looks and plays like the original GameCube controller
Harder than it seems. Mainly cause retrofighters is a budget company. One for a niche market, but still budget. There isn't a way for them to make their controllers as good unless it's more expensive by a bit.
While other companies really try, but also try to add more unnecessary gimmicks. Like the nyxi one has different stick grooves, so they can't be as good. Or at least their focus wasn't centred on making it feel just as good.
Only way to make controllers as good as gamecube controllers is by salvaging components. And that isn't really legal to sell
Just use the gamecube adapter from the Wii U problem solved that’s what I do
@@teneesh3376 all a company has to do is build a quality mold that matches the original controller with some updated hardware. There are tons of companies that could do this but it seems they focus more on their own designs instead which is fine. But I guarantee you a high quality GameCube controller would sell well.
@@duke_8747 you also forget good circuits and components. Both are much harder to surpass the gamecube's on a budget.
But I agree that if they upped the price with better controllers. Retrofighters mindset just satisfies no one. Especially outside the US with them costing nearly AUD 120 with shipping
@@stpworld mate's got a point
I have a Blade because I like the larger dpad for indie/retro games and the symmetrical stick placement is more familiar to me being more of a PlayStation gamer. It's a decent controller but my main issue is the face buttons feel pretty stiff. I'm not sure if that's just because I haven't used it a lot or if they're just going to stay that way.
NYXI just made something exactly like that recently called the Wizard. It really looks more beefier than the Retro Fighters, it comes with 1 GC adapter with a USB C port for PC. It can be used for a variety of systems (any system that utilizes the GameCube controller and also as a Switch controller). The NYXI also had Hall effect sticks and programmable back buttons.
I'm assuming the triggers aren't analog like the original GC? Like for Mario sunshine it would only let you shoot out the full amount of water?
While the BattlerGC seems fine as a controller with a Gamecube button layout, I can't say it's something I'm personally interested in. Part of what I like about a Gamecube controller is also the feel of the body of the controller. Funny enough, I don't even think the original Gamecube controller is even the best anymore, at least for modern standards. It's buttons feel are still the best, but it lack of of a right shoulder button, stiff and small directional pad, and lack of a select/-/share button makes me not really care to use mine. Also, I'll be honest, while I prefer the button feel of the Original Gamecube, as long as they aren't completely horrible, I don't mind the button feel of many other 3rd party controllers as much since I generally adjust pretty quickly. In that regard, my Exlene Gamecube Style controller will still be my go to but even that one is FAR from perfect.
Until someone, somewhere can make a GameCube-style controller for Switch that actually accurately mimics the original GameCube controller right down to its unique analog triggers, I’m just going to stick with my PowerA GameCube controller I already have for my Switch.
You might not know this, but it is possible to mix and match the Retro Fighters wireless controller products as long as it's the Defender, BladeGC and BattlerGC. I was able to make the BladeGC work on a PS2 via Defender receiver, and it actually works as a Defender alternative with the better form factor and directional button placement. Fighting games feel much better when using a BladeGC, though inputting the "gigantic press" motion supers can be a bit frustrating compared to OEM directional buttons.
What if the analog and dpad were on a switch-like rail and could be slid off, flipped, and would slide on again so you could swap the analog and dpad. Like a dpad/analog switch.
I just wish they'd hurry up and make a rechargeable version of the Power A GameCube switch controller. I just can't cave in and buy it until that's a thing but that's exactly the type of controller I want.
I was never able to get a Wavebird back in the day, it was always out of stock. I’m assuming this would make a good Wavdbird clone since it has an adapter for Ganecube?
Question: I wanna use this with 3D All-Stars version of Super Mario Sunshine and I saw it has an adapter for GameCube. I know when you plug in a GameCube controller with the Adapter the controls go back to the OG controls. If I use that Adapter this controller comes with would the Triggers be like Switch or OG GameCube Trigger?
I reckon if you use the GC adapter on Switch it'd detect it as a GC controller. Someone would have to test it, but it makes sense logically
@@Gtune8 that's my Idea. Plug in the GameCube Controller Adapter into the Switch, then Plug the Adapter from this Controller (GameCube Version) into the Adapter that's plugged into the Switch and use it like a Wave Bird Controller
I have this retro fighters one with the yellow C stick. I use it more than the pro
The USB dongle has been laggy on anything i tried it on , the GC dongle is great tho .
Does it have rumble when connected to the GameCube. Wave bird does not.
This was working fine on my steamdeck but stopped working last night. My pc reads it fine though, anyone have a similar issue? I wonder if the recent update messed things up.
kevin my question is if this controller have a drift like the original joycons because i like the design and might buy it if doesnt have a drift
Used it, comfortable shape and feel but the analog triggers are not for me.
I actually dont like the original GC triggers, so this is a plus for me :) I just miss the yellow right analog
No Kevin, I really wish you could have EXLENE gamecube controller in hand.
you will see the light my friend.
As of know, its the nyxi wizard
Hear me out, the best gamecube controller is the…. Original gamecube controller
THIS!!! ☝️☝️☝️
Some folks want a controller that takes the best of Gamecube while getting rid of the bad. Hot take but the controller was not perfect and had some glaring flaws. Only having one shoulder button, a terrible D pad, no select button, the sticks can't be used as clickable buttons and the C stick is a tiny lil nub. So yeah some of us want a more modern GC controller that does away with the original's flaws.
@@Neon_Plasma I feel like if you want to play games the gamecube way get the original Gamecube controller, and if you either want retro or modern controls get an 8bitdo or switch pro controller. Nothing can really compare to the original GCC
they were so close to a must buy for me but then ruined it with the triggers. dang
theyre all ass except the OG gamecube. nobody has gotten it right and the only real chance was panda global and they got shut down to oblivion
While cool, people seem to miss the point of the Nyxi Wizard. ACTUAL JOYCONS.
Looks cheap + for me, needs to be split/joycon compatible
MR KENSON SF6 YOU SHOULD TALK ABOUT SF6!
Exactly like 8bitdo triggers from what it looks like.
6:11 The Sauce*
If the Switch can actually play GameCube games.
I bought one a week ago today, and I returned it yesterday because of stuck-drift. I personally don’t recommend this.
They just need to bring back the wavebird. Problem solved
What if Kev has a rasta under that cap?
He has appeared without the cap in his second channel
There's no such thing a the "BEST" Gamecube anything. There's only "the least offensive and mediocre" Gamecube controllers. Let's never forget that nearly everything associated with the Gamecube (and by proxy, Nintendo) was utter mediocrity.😂
I got this controller but I didn't like it it feels cheap for what I pay.
Yall know theres an actual Gamecuber controller made by Nintendo for the switch, right?
Yepp, I just got the Japan Import Version.
That's missing about 5 buttons and gyro support, but yes.
@@angeldude101 lmao my guy I have gyroscope support on mine, and what buttons are missing? Try again hoss
@@witchbvrner Could you be referring to the PowerA controller? It appears to be officially licensed, but not made by Nintendo. Overall, it actually doesn't look that bad. The biggest drawback is that it seems to lack the analog triggers that the original had. It also has various more minor changes like the larger bumpers that I wouldn't be able to judge without trying it.
18$ for the wired version, I might actually have to try it. It doesn't have _nearly_ as much as what the Panda Controller would've had, but it's probably the next best thing.
>no gyro
Hard pass.
Not a fan of these at all, they look like Fisher Price toys..
A failed controller experiment.
First