I live in Shanghai and asked Xiaomi's version of Alexa "What is the Great Leap Forward?" To which she replied, "let's talk about something else." LOL...
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 so what about the life expectancy if you all starve to death or are a mindless drone that works to line the pockets of the higher ups.... perfect
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 so freedom is classified as being able to allow your government to sterilize, or kill you for being a different ethnicity, or for having a opinion? I don't know were your from but no one on this planet sees that as freedom. Also keep in mind you lie and slander the government in China your pretty much gone
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 What you saying is garbage because it’s not worth the death of tens of millions of people for the development of China,no matter how good it was.And I don’t think freedom entails what modern China looks like today.I may be American,but I don’t have to worry about a bullet in my skull from criticizing the government,unlike in China then and likely now.
My grandma lived through that period of time. To this day she still doesn't waste a single grain of rice. She often asks me to eat as much as possible in fear of I would suddenly die of hunger.
@@MichaelDavis-mk4me Man you're a god trying to shape the entire world as you know it over the span of eons, in one turn you can outlive anywhere from three to five generations Why wouldn't it be casual?
@@thejackmage9656 Because it would cause an incredible amount of unrest which should be incredibly annoying. Your people riot if they don't have oranges and diamonds in the late game, but don't care about the fact that they are starving. In history, having starvation in your kingdom was a really big deal. Also, time slows down when you get late game, at the end, by the 1980's, you only pass a year each turn.
Neither is cultural Revolution ! Great leap forward 76 millions deaths Cultural revolution 20 millions of deaths ! Hmm it's time for the Chinese communist party to step down !
I don’t understand how people can look at China and go “oh, what a magical, mysterious place! I want to live there!” Other than the cities where market-based exchange is allowed, China is absolutely terrifying. Always remember, Communism has killed almost 10x more people than the Holocaust...
M Lau - That’s good, but you probably already know that Hong Kong is very different from mainland China, where they take any chance they get to promote themselves, even dishonestly.
i didnt even know that at first the collectiviztion was working. i always figured mao just did it all to kill off a bunch of people he didnt like. he was just an idiot who had an idea that backfired
@Jay Blake you miss the entire video here, Communism in any country afflicted by it's awful ideology is directly responsible for more deaths under their own leadership than modern capitalism has in it's entire history Was the plague a capitalist mass genocide like the holodomor because a ship with produce on it had plague ridden rats inside? Your ideology has no virtue, it's a disease on this Earth, go back to starving yourself in a commune you leach to society
It is a real shame that everyone knows the horrors of the Nazis, but people don't know anything about the things that happened in Imperial Japan, Communist China or Soviet Russia.
@@pckkaboo6800 In Mexico, a species of grasshopper can be bred for food. It is fed spices and herbs, and then is toasted with garlic until it turns dark red. It tastes fresh and crunchy like spicy chips. It's called "Chapulín", like "El Chapulín colorado", a very popular TV character.
@@Hxoibrixks the British didn’t treat Hong Kongers good either. Hong Kong also protests Ed British rule in which the British killed Hong Kong protesters
Hilarious how the CCP brainwashes mainland Chinese into hating Japan for killing Chinese people, when the CCP itself killed more Chinese people than Japan ever did.
@@peanutbuttersandwich5015 Yes, and not because the planners are twisted and evil (though they may be), but because a free market made up of thousands or millions of people is always going to be more efficient than central planning. The government can help best by doing a little refereeing likebreaking up monopolies, enforcing contracts, managing externalities like pollution and letting trade take care of the rest.
A farm worker greets Josef Stalin at his potato farm. “Comrade Stalin, we have so many potatoes that, piled one on top of the other, they would reach all the way to God,” the farmer excitedly tells his leader. “But God does not exist,” replies Stalin. “Exactly,” says the farmer. “Neither do the potatoes.”
@@potatoesandducks958 there's always gonna be stupid people in the world. it dont matter where you look, theres stupid people in any single community, and those stupid people always end up being the face of the community they "represent" to the outside world. people like that exist, but far and few between, but putting into scale the negativity bias, the internet, and modern politics, most people dont even think of others as humans in politics so now many people think that nazis are a huge problem or that communists are a huge problem. they both exist and are a problem, but really aren't starting some kind of huge revolution on behalf of the left/right.
In Parasite, the wealthy family's kid was pretending to be in a worse situation than he was. In the west, people find very legitimate flaws of capitalism, and instead of easily solving them, the American public wants to switch to communism or socialism. At this point, calling them peasants should be justified.
"Sell it or I'll have you killed.......seriously, YES I have that power. Think I'm fucking around? This isn't a game, I'll fucking kill you, my son" If anyone can translate that into Hahn Chinese, that would be amazing lolol
Incredibly, Orwell predicted all of this in Animal Farm, over a decade before these events occurred - the shortages, the inadequacy of unskilled labour in manufacturing, and the purges of anyone who disagreed with the plan. Of course he was writing about the situation that unfolded in soviet Russia, but incredibly the Chinese leadership seemed happy to repeat the Soviet’s mistakes, and condemn so many of their own people to starvation.
It’s funny how Animal Farm can easily apply to any dictatorial revolution, especially Communist ones, and there’s still tankies defending Communism by saying “Animal Farm is not about Communism”
Lao She, a famous writer in China said this is some sci-fi delusion after reading the 1984. Eventually, he committed suicide during the cultural revolution launched by chairman Mao.😂
@@sidneym8895Lao She's death can't be blamed for this. He is a man who has a great sense of face. But he was criticized during the Cultural Revolution, so he committed suicide
*Mao* : I kill more people than both of you ,why history giving you 2 a credit *Hitler and Stalin* : Do you got a cool mustache *Mao* : *Cries in Chinese*
@@RHD_lantz USSR relied on raw manpower for the majority of it's territory gain. Science was of little importance for them until the height of the cold war.
Everything is made in China by people want to jump off the buildings and commit suicide. That's why they put Nets around the buildings. They can't speak about how unhappy they are because they would be penalized for that. They may be actually sent off to have their organs stolen and be killed. Don't believe for a moment that their economy is good. They have complete empty cities full of nobody and crumbling buildings that have never been lived in. Yes some can prosper in businesses that can easily be taken away by the government. Yeah what a hero 😂 after all the millions of dead can't speak
story told by my father: His family were one of the wealthiest in the city during this period. They were living the best of their lives until the great leap happened. Land reform took all of his family's assets, leaving only one house for them to live in--my grandfather,grandmother, and 8 kids. My grandfather was drafted to the factory and my grandmother was drafted to the kitchen, being businessman, they had to learn everything from scratch. Food rations are given to them everyday. However, the given ration was not enough to feed the family, so they had to add water to their rice and make porridge. My grandmother, working in the kitchen, tries to sneak food everyday to give to her kids. This goes on until my grandparents died. Once my father's siblings are grown up, they are then sent to provinces far from home to work in factories. Thinking about this now, it pains my heart knowing my father has suffered so much during his childhood. From wealthy to poor in an instant with no parents to guide them during the day.
My grandfather was in a landlord family at the time when the Land Reform took place. He and his family were beaten severely and sent to the city factory as workers, his house was confiscated. This cruelty they've done to him actually saved his life, as during the Great Leap Forward, city workers were fed well at the price of starvation in the countryside. 20 years later when the Cultural Revolution ended, he returned to the countryside and saw the old house emptied. The farmers who took his house all starved to death years ago. We refused to live in that house and left it emptied, until two years ago my father sold that house to the government as they wanted to construct a road over it.
When did the government return your grandfather's house to him? Was there a whole era when confiscated property was returned to those that mao took it from?
@@kadafi4lyf There was a redress act(拨乱反正, Boluan Fanzheng) after the Cultural Revolution, which happened during 1978-1989. In this period Deng Xiaoping corrected a large part of Mao's mistakes and restored operation of the country to some extent. Grandpa's property was returned at about 1980, due to the government finding out most of his "crime records" were forged by farmers who held a hostile attitude towards land lord families. (Yes, before 1978, if you want your neighbor killed or beaten in China you can just report him by whatever reason you want. That's how scary it was.)
I've lived in china for almost an year. I just want to ask. Do the people who experienced these atrocities first hand still support the current governments stand that mao was a hero. And also what you guys are taught in schools regarding it.
@@hasaansamad2995 It may surprise you that, China actually talks about the GLP and Cultural Revolution in textbooks (in the version I was taught at least). They admit those were Mao's mistake, but under the condition that "He was misdirected by some malicious actors in the party". Quite a part of content in this video are mentioned, but they didn't say how many people were killed and they insist that the main cause of the starvation is land drought / other natural disasters. As for the survivors' stand, I can't say for sure. Talking about that period can be traumatizing for some of them, so usually we chose not to.
The fact that Mao refused foreign aid to save face is exactly how most asian parents are. Ego and reputation is priority in most Asian cultures and family.
@Insert Name Here that was purely intentional by Stalin. Kill of millions of Ukrainians and replace them with Russians. It's still having its effects with conflicts in Ukraine due to the Russian descendents
That's true but not whole picture . Back to 1960 , there was no trading between China and western world . After 1960 , China started to import food from other communist nations .
are you dumb? you see the problem was misinformation about farming and inexperienced undertrained factory workers. let's compare these issues to the US shall we, slavery, no human rights to workers, exploiting child labor, and forced drafting to war, etc. also they gave food not collect them
It genuienly shocks me as to how much of a disaster The Great Leap Forward was cause what’s unique about it is it wasn’t a case of a heartless man having no concern for citizens and being ok with millions suffering (tbf Mao certainly was like that) but it was instead caused by a man who had so much incompetence when it came to economics, science and geography and it pains me how tens of millions suffered due to this incompetence
Yeah but remember the situation China was in: almost 20 years of civil war, they got free from the japanese just 10 years prior, they were in a precarious situation and the Kuomintang had destroyed a lot of farms by flooding plains. It was a mostly agrarian nation with few experts and capable people,and they didn't want to listen to soviet farming advices, had a population so big that it was impossible for China's allies to feed all of them... Mao was not an economist or an engineer and shouldn't have taken this kind of decisions, but it's more justifiable than an economic crash caused by wild speculation in the 1929 or even the 2008 housing crisis...
@@SatchelChannel the Great Depression and Financial Crisis were awful but at least they didn’t lead to the deaths of 30-50 million and there were many policies of the GLF that even someone with no economics or scientific knowledge would call idiotic such as the substantial use of metal or wood for the backyard furnaces
It was short sided to kill all the sparrows bc killing them all means that their pray can eat all of the people’s crops and which means that people would die because of no food
I think Its actually kind of related with the Corona virus, you know that stereotype that Chinese eat dogs? It originates from the starvation caused by this "great leap forward". People had to eat anything they could find, so they catch other diseases that can spread later
"When there is not enough to eat people starve to death. It is better to let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill" Mao Zedong 1959 Edit-After looking around some i found a transcript in Chinese and translated it. Yes, the quote is actually out of context but in light of Mao's murderous ideology i think the post is worth keeping. Anyone wanting another real doozy, look into the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976)
That has always been the collectivist view. They call it the "end of hostory". The fantasy that you can stabilize human endeavor, growth, and invention into a standstill. They would rather kill millions than to use scientific progress to feed them.
Kalpesh Manna thats a horrible, worthless and dehumanizing sacrifice to make. It’s a waste of humanity. And it wasn’t salvation, it’s feudalism under the guise of communism.
Mao: "Everyone please kill the sparrows, they're eating all the crops" Nature: *booms cricket population because there was no predators Mao: *surprised pikachu face*
In 1969, when the Soviets and Chinese were having a huge border dispute skirmish, Brezhnev was so furious with Mao that he was ready to launch nukes on them. The only reason he didn't is because Nixon told him not to (as he stated America had "interests" in the Chinese region). It certainly is a powerful thought as to how different history could have gone if the US let them do it.
@@tastefullyoffensive2412 I meant what could have happened if America let the Soviets nuke China. We would have had one of the ugliest wars in human history between the Communist powers, and one can only imagine how the rest of humanity would have dealt with it.
hope all foreign people know what happened and happening now in CHINA ' CHINIA IS NOT PANDA CHINA IS BITTER SNAKE Chinese CURSE amaerican everyday , american goverment never told you that !!!!!
"We got a plan to modernize China. It's call The Great Leap Forward." - China 1958 "Nothing is going on in Tiananmen Square." - China 1989 "There is no protesting in Hong Kong. Who ever says otherwise is a liar, and should watch...I am will probably disappear....I mean will go on a long vacation." -China 2019 "There is this virus. That is in no way deadly to anyone." -China 2020
I have parents and grandparents that survived the Great Leap Forward. Basically, they had almost nothing to eat. Meat was non-existent and only ate low-quality vegetables. My grandfather on my mom's side was sent to a "reformation" camp for a while and really didn't tell how much he much abuse he endured. My grand-uncle on my dad's side was a jerk for being highly prominent and highly convicted to the Communist party while leaving his family to starve in the countryside. Although he passed away, my dad's father lived a happy life, more so than his brother. To this day, my parents have an absolute hatred for socialism.
Lauti Cruz how could he be living in China if he is making this comment and watching a video probably banned they have very restrictive internet rules if he lives in China he would be doing this illegally and would be caught
@@thessop9439 Funny, so you can provide accomodation to them along with other Nazis who fled from the defeat in 1945? Did everyone simply disregard the reason why his family got into those situation? Those end up in camps are the few who used to get fed by exploiting others, take no responsiblity in defending the facists Japanese invader when the whole country is shattering, and still dreaming about their "modern nobility" when the majority of people came to power. I can understand it could never be happy knowing one's ancestor had something to suffer, but it's just the time for them to take their toll.
communism means stateless, classless and tradeless society - please tell me how china was communistic? just beacuse one claims to be someone doesn't mean they are.
@@enderpup9289 because it was specifically the scare the current leader of China that's banned Winnie the Pooh on China and it's used as a slur against the Chinese leader
Nah, in Burmese, he's called Mr.Shithole. www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2020/01/facebook-apologises-rude-mistranslation-xi-jinping-200119071125127.html
There’s a brilliant Chinese film about a family that survived all of Mao’s five year plans and the Cultural Revolution. The film is called To Live and its seen as a masterpiece of historical storytelling
There’s another one called China Cry. My mom bought that for me for Christmas because I had an interest in Asian culture. She had absolutely no idea it was based on a true woman’s story of the Great Leap Forward. Same with Hachi on the famous Japanese Akita dog.
My high school teacher once explained the Great Leap Forward in this manner: She asked for a volunteer, told them to face the wall leaving about an inch from his face. She then said “ok now jump forward as far as you can”, and there was an audible this as his forehead came into contact with the wall.
Ya know, this is actually something that would have happened and HAS HAPPENED in communist states all the time when those were still commonplace(now days theres only a a mere handful of those dreadful communist hellholes left like north korea and china and cuba - and maybe some other ones but those are the only REAL ones left that are genocidal antiHUMAN EVIL states - which is what communism is). Same wiht Jake 202. That sounds REAL from all ive read about the communist scourge in various countries over the years.....people who arent aware of history may think its far fetched or not true but that sort of thing was actually extremely common. Che Guevera for instance took GREAT PLEASURE in watching "prisoners"(non-communists) rounded up, given mock show trials(quickly of course), then brought to the execution ground which he ordered be made DIRECTLY OUTSIDE HIS WINDOW SO HE COULD "ENJOY" WATCHING THESE POOR PATRIOTIC MEN GET SHOT IN THE HEAD BY HIS MURDERERS AND THUGS. And yeah thats actually for real, look it up if you have any doubts. Far leftists are DISGUSTING creatures DISGUSTING and EVIL and NEED TO BE OPPOSED ALWAYS.
And the sad thing is that while most older generations remembered this part of history, they are getting old and too traumatized to tell the tales to their grandchildren… Or that people who survived the period are those who were benefited from other people's suffering. Truth is, not many young generations know much about their own history, and all they're talking about is how communist party of China succeeded their people. Now both Mao and Xi is godly feature in China, and people would not allow anyone to criticize their Gods
If actual outcomes ≠ theorized outcome, then execute "that wasn't real socialism/communism" Promote socialism/communism Enact socialism/communism Repeat
@@fireiron369 Makhnovia and Anarchist Catalonia were much closer to Communism than any authoritarian dictatorship that labeled itself as "Communist", guess what happened when the farms were collectivised in Catalonia, production went up 50%, only difference was that the collectivisation was voluntary and not forced. Also Rojava and the Zapatistas are having a pretty good time with their stateless anarchist systems.
Funny thing is, Mao's picture still hangs on the Tienanmen Square. He laughed at all those starving people, he laughs again at the dying people who wanted freedom. Real funny
@@fcondro so what? Does plastic surgery laugh in the face of dying people? Does it pretend starvation is just a myth to take power over the authority? Whatever link you are making, I cannot see it nor understand it.
It’s funny, in Beijing, his photo and image is everywhere. I kid you not, he’s got merchandise everywhere. He’s still held in high regard there despite everything he’s done. Even dedicated an entire building for his grave. Wonder what a Chinese history book looks like
I recently started to read the book Tombstone by Chinese author Yang Jisheng. The book dissects the causes and effects of the Great Famine in detail - his thesis was that it was an entirely man-made disaster. I couldn't even get through the first chapter - it gave me an existential crisis and a horrible depressive episode lasting days. It will completely destroy your faith in humanity, to witness the greed, cowardice and cover-ups resulting in the deaths of tens of millions of innocent people for absolutely nothing. No benefit to anyone. And they are not even allowed to have a tombstone to remember them (which explains the title of the book - this is the tombstone). I found the complete inhumanity in the book terrifying. It wasn't foreign invasions, it wasn't aliens, it wasn't the universe ending - it was the complete indifference to the suffering of one's fellow humans that led to this disaster unprecedented in human history, which could have been prevented if the responsible parties even had one shred of human decency. It saddens me that this topic is still twisted and censored in China, so that few people know the truth of what happened or dare to speak if they knew. And too few outside China know or care. The era in China under Mao deeply scarred the population and it's a scar that will be carried by generations. I hope one day the truth will come to light before this period of history is forgotten.
China had repeated droughts and famines throughout the 1800s, so they were pretty used to starving. Great Leap Forward was probably the worst one, but definitely not the first.
Nearly every country had mass starvation during it's industrialization and the fencing in of formerly commonly accessable land. Combine that with the millions of people starving as direct consequence of colonial powers deliberate decisions. Millions starved in India, the middle east and China during the 1800s and 1900s. There even was a widespread theoretical groundwork to justify that kind of inhumanely cruel policy in the western, capitalist empires: the theory of overpopulation by Robert Malthus. Mass starvation as desired policy goal - instead of catastrophic byproduct of poor decisions.
They have the largest population in the world, third largest land mass, vast temperate climate, and containing over 10% of the world's arable land. And don't the Yangtze, yellow, pearl, and songhuajiang rivers. With all that in mind they better be an agricultural power house because they simply have resources that no one else has.
@@patricks1333 Yeah, because mortality rate is so important that we ignore other underlying problems such as people disappearing when they dissent, suppression of free speech, loss of privacy and the brainwashing of ethnic minorities because China good. Your opinion is a joke.
@@project_romaniacore It's like that knight reaction meme where a knight is walking and he says "Greetings peasants, how goes the..." then he sees something repulsive and says "By the Pope!" Like this: knowyourmeme.com/photos/1396258-by-the-pope
Odd, I chased off the Sparrows and rats in my area, and the thrushes, robins and blackbirds all returned. Obviously he couldn't even do pest control properly.
It makes me wonder how China had so many events that resulted in millions dieing, yet somehow they have been able to obtain the most people in any country.
Statistically there's a very strong correlation between high birth rates and high infant mortality rates. The more likely you are to lose people the more populations seem to breed.
If there's one thing China's poor understand, it's sacrifice. Communism didn't make life better, nor did Capitalism. What allowed them to escape poverty was the sacrifice of fathers and mothers
@@kingsweden4636 you mean you want me to see the success of communism by looking at two examples of how communism failed? Or is it that you want to highlight examples of mass murder and genocide? Either way you've just proven my point.
Hate to be that guy, but China wasn't communist, Communism is a stateless, classless, moneyless society where workers own the means of production. Is the Democratic Republic of Korea Democratic? If we called it so then what do we call a country that is democratic?
@@Suth1172 Of course Communism and Socialism are not the same (Socialism is the transition system betwen Capitalism and Communism) and Communism is basically Anarchism (a World without States, classes, money, private ownership, etc). But we (the ones who criticize Marxism) use Communism and Socialism as synonyms: all marxists call themselves "socialists" or "communists", so all of them want the same "Capitalism=>Abolish Capitalism=>Socialism=>Comunism" formula.
@Sue Martino It's not about trust, it's about enforcing public sovereignty. Conservatives trust that removing democratic elections in favor of corporate control will result in less government, rather than the explosion of corporate welfare it always produces. Democrats want to tie government to public services that expand the resources available to small business and free enterprise. Burning the flag is what you get when people are hurt by what that flag represents. If that isn't understandable, you either have lead poisoning or you aren't human.
Oskar sutherland China at the peek of the great leap forward was exactly what Marx dreamed of. It WAS following Marxism like a bible, land redistribution, equal rations, drafting into the work force, “power” to the people. I will acknowledge now China is getting closer to capitalism but many of its communist policies remain and it is still socially a communist state.
They got into a civil war, got owned by Japanese, got into another civil war, got involved in Korean War, and then the Great Leap Forward... my goodness China... 😂
My mom's family is from Beijing, during the great leap forward, My grandparents would bring wild animals back home for consumption. they also had to save the limited egg ration quotas for my mom's younger brother (my uncle)... That was in Beijing, the capital of China... you can imagine what was happening in other cities or even villages in countryside.
People are freaked out by the random things Chinese People eat. Like Bats, Beavers, Dogs, and other exotic Animals. However given the History of the Great Leap Forward. It sort of makes sense why. Their Grandparents had to eat whatever was around
And no famines ever happened under capitalism? Silly. Red China lifted nearly a billion people out of poverty, they saved billions of lives. Read this study then! ”China's growth in life expectancy between 1950 and 1980 ranks as among the most rapid sustained increases in documented global history.” Source: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4331212/
They made mistakes you ignoramus. You make it sound like somehow, the second five-year plan under Mao was an extermination campaign. It was not. It was an economic program intended to speed the construction of their industrial base. It backfired & accounting for the floods and droughts, made those times worse. Having an honest conversation on this topic is impossible because people are shrieking that 'if only they had Western freedoms.' That's not an argument. www.invent-the-future.org/2013/12/monster-liberator-legacy-mao-zedong/
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 In practice, it caused widespread Famine and more damage to their agriculture sector rather than improving it (By rigorous farming that affects the soil fertility, and other shenanigans the CCP did) Although the first few years has somewhat improved food supply and the quality of life (within farming communes), overall, it's an ineffective economic program that caused significantly more harm than benefits
And no famines ever happened under capitalism? Silly. Red China lifted nearly a billion people out of poverty, they saved billions of lives. Read this study then! ”China's growth in life expectancy between 1950 and 1980 ranks as among the most rapid sustained increases in documented global history.” Source: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4331212/
No food ✔ No water ✔ No help✔ Death✔ Living in agony ✔ Mao: SOUNDS GREAT Stalin: SOUNDS AMAZING Kim Il Sung, Kim Jong Il, Kim Jong Un: SOUNDS GOOD Pol Pot: SOUNDS FFFFFFUUUUUNNNNN Lenin: WONDERFUL Castro: COOL Hitler: THATS BEAUTIFUL
Having the power that Mao had over his people is the wet dream of every leftist around the world, here in Brazil some communist fucks praises Mao all the time and tell the people he was a hero.
@@LucasCunhaRocha E o mais engraçado é que eles adoram misturar narrativas se dizendo a favor das minorias, mas se eles vivessem na era de Mao ou de Stalin todos eles já teriam sido executados.
One of my friend's dad ABSOLUTELY hates the communist party. According to him, his father's grandpa was really rich and worked for the communist party. But he got thrown into jail because he is simply not chinese and they said he "might betray". They had numerous ways of torturing him, like letting him starve for days before giving a potato. After a few years, he was released. He went mad and did suicide after a week. This is just absurd.
My grandparents said that during the great leap forward people ate clay and dirt to fill their bellies or just sesame seed oil in water to give them some flavour...those were certainly horrible times.
This reminds me of a slogan by the Bulgarian communist party. "Before 9th of September, 1944 (The date of the communist coup d'etat), Bulgaria was at the cliff's edge. After 9th of September, 1944, she took a great step forward.". I wish this was an anecdote, but no.
not likely Yeah they’re the number 2 superpower, but at a cost. They build abandoned and empty infrastructure in order to gain GDP. A lot of people in China are struggling a lot, but China builds a lot of ghost villages and uses other tactics to get to the top. You’ll see in a few decades when their power collapses due to the unethical ways they gain economic power.
Monarchy has a better track record than Communism. Being ruled by a single inbred royal who got the job by having the correct parents has worked incredibly better for humanity than being ruled by a group of sociopaths who believe in Marx's bullshit.
"Communism" is a broad term so that person may be referring to something like council communism (decentralised and controlled by worker councils), which isn't very comparable to either of those dictators
There are virtually no people today who promote communism. Maybe NK. Socialism has become very successful when part of a mixed economy like Sweden and China. If you think modern socialism is synonymous with communism, you’re an idiot. I have lived in China for seven years. I have looked for a commune and found none. So just how many people are you reminding of Stalin and Mao? Since nobody truly wants Mao’s or Stalin’s form of communism, I’m guessing zero.
@@Cairo40000 Napoleon III actually was working fairly well for them for a while...until he botched foreign policy stuff in the 1860s. It's safe to say that the Bonapartes (with all their flaws) were better than at least 2-3 of their 5 republics.
Apparently cannabalism became quite a common thing during that period because the entrances to all those villages were deliberately blocked by CCP to prevent villagers from escaping. Anyone caught digging for even a potato gets brutally beaten. Then the starved villagers started eating corpses.
@@5mwa So horrible. It’s not their fault either, they were forced to turn to cannibalism thanks to their government establishing peoples communes to convert their entire society into a communist one.
Simple History, thank you for this extensive look into the Great Leap Forward. Context and why something happens is super important, so I really appreciate that you guys included not just what the GLF was, but why and how it happened. Its well-researched and well-expressed videos like yours that first interested me in history, so thank you once again and keep up the good work!
Check out Yugoslavian communism, millions didnt die because our leader wasnt a narcicist who refused foreign aid, he worked with the west and the soviet block, the leader is the problem, not the system. Incompetent people will fail in any system. My father lived in that system and he tells me that nothing is better now in a democracy, its actually worse cause of all the corruption, in the communist system corrupt people would be punished severly, the only difference was you couldnt voice your opinion against the leader or the party, but they lived modest lives, had food and had everything, the country was producing everything it needed, its industry was strong, nobody starved. When the leader of Yugoslavia died everything fell apart because he kept all the nations of the federation in check and punished extreme nationalism, the motto of the people was Brotherhood and Unity, when he died the brotherhood died and the unity was shattered and war started which takes its toll even today on my country, our industry is non existant, the leader is the key.
Here in Hungary, many people want back, and much more things was better than in thisa oligarhic capitalism. I talked with many people who lived in that time and want it back. So that was you said that's a thing what says that people who live in a country that never was socialist
Only when antitrust legislation is strongly enforced to prevent corporations like Microsoft adobe google monsanto cargill tyson ibm pfizer etc from having monopoly control of markets. Capitalism works great until corporations give money to NGO’s that then payoff lobbyists to push corporate interests This is why we have extremely rich and extremely poor with a quickly disappearing middle class.
I live in Shanghai and asked Xiaomi's version of Alexa "What is the Great Leap Forward?" To which she replied, "let's talk about something else." LOL...
Terrifying
For real??
@@dardalion3199 For real 100%. It said, "我们谈一些其他的吧。“
Try asking what happened in april 15, 1989
Gonna end up in a re-education camp if you keep that up 😂😂😂
They didn't tell them the leap forward was into a grave.
**spits tea*
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 so what about the life expectancy if you all starve to death or are a mindless drone that works to line the pockets of the higher ups.... perfect
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 so freedom is classified as being able to allow your government to sterilize, or kill you for being a different ethnicity, or for having a opinion? I don't know were your from but no one on this planet sees that as freedom. Also keep in mind you lie and slander the government in China your pretty much gone
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 What you saying is garbage because it’s not worth the death of tens of millions of people for the development of China,no matter how good it was.And I don’t think freedom entails what modern China looks like today.I may be American,but I don’t have to worry about a bullet in my skull from criticizing the government,unlike in China then and likely now.
Under rated comment
Even Stalin said Mao was out of control and that's coming from a madman.
EXCUSE ME!?!
@@josephstalin364 At least you had swag ;-)
When did he say that?
that was a tantrum of Stalin. He stated the same about Trotsky
Share my version, i am a capitalist: ua-cam.com/video/YB_Gx04Ke_Q/v-deo.html
My grandma lived through that period of time. To this day she still doesn't waste a single grain of rice.
She often asks me to eat as much as possible in fear of I would suddenly die of hunger.
Heartbreaking
You better eat Jay, a similar situation may happen all over again within next 30 years
@@richbrake9910 in the USA dude? 😑
@@JacobLozano-mr8ll Facts don’t care about your feelings.
Ah, bless her dear soul!
When you have no idea wtf you're doing in Civilization 5.
More like when you know wtf you’re doing
its literally just turning every tile you owned into a mine or a factory. idk what y'all were expecting.
I like how casual letting your people starve to death is in Civ games. Like people don't really mind dying or being nuked.
@@MichaelDavis-mk4me Man you're a god trying to shape the entire world as you know it over the span of eons, in one turn you can outlive anywhere from three to five generations Why wouldn't it be casual?
@@thejackmage9656 Because it would cause an incredible amount of unrest which should be incredibly annoying. Your people riot if they don't have oranges and diamonds in the late game, but don't care about the fact that they are starving. In history, having starvation in your kingdom was a really big deal. Also, time slows down when you get late game, at the end, by the 1980's, you only pass a year each turn.
“Did you ever hear the Tragedy of the Great Leap Forward?”
“No.”
“It’s not a story the Chinese government would tell you.”
Neither is cultural Revolution !
Great leap forward 76 millions deaths
Cultural revolution 20 millions of deaths ! Hmm it's time for the Chinese communist party to step down !
I don’t understand how people can look at China and go “oh, what a magical, mysterious place! I want to live there!” Other than the cities where market-based exchange is allowed, China is absolutely terrifying.
Always remember, Communism has killed almost 10x more people than the Holocaust...
Everyting that included in Tiananmen Copypasta is what the Chinese Goverment is hiding from us.
Histocrat 641402 I am Chinese and we learned this during History lessons in Hong Kong schools.
M Lau - That’s good, but you probably already know that Hong Kong is very different from mainland China, where they take any chance they get to promote themselves, even dishonestly.
Chinese civilians: Thank god we survived the Japanese invasion
Mao: You spoke too soon
Ooooof size large
*This is where the fun begins*
Chinese are atheist lol.
@@unsec-genantonioguterres5788 i thought they were buddhist/confucius
@Silver Chariot -_-
Mao: We are going to make a Great Leap Forward!
Chinese Civilians: That is fantastic! Where are we leaping?
Mao: This cliff over here!
Mao: into this big pit. Just ignore the soldiers with ak47s.
@@tachyon8317 also ignore those flames coming from the pit
@@kronoso_o8042 he's also ignoring all those piranhas right?
True
They did gain more food and people despite you losers crying with your cartoon propaganda though.
I still remember my History teacher saying "Great Leap Forward, more like a giant step back." She was right.
But it did end up modernizing China. With the millions of deaths and suffering this was truly a horrible time to live in.
@@Argos-xb8ek The woes of economy of progress.
well it's what my teachers said too, I guess it is right
I prefer "Not So Great Stumble Backwards".
@@Argos-xb8ek there is literally no way the "great leap forward" contributed to modernization
Mao: _redistributes land_
Peasants: “thanks m8”
Mao: _collectivizes land_
Peasants: “m8 wtf”
Show More: Shows nothing more
lmaooooo
T L Shorty Shorty he basically turned from
Lenin to Stalin
i didnt even know that at first the collectiviztion was working. i always figured mao just did it all to kill off a bunch of people he didnt like. he was just an idiot who had an idea that backfired
that's been done soon as the civil War is over
1 step forward, 60 million steps back
You reminded me with the song, One step forward and two steps back from San andreas XD
@Jay Blake you miss the entire video here, Communism in any country afflicted by it's awful ideology is directly responsible for more deaths under their own leadership than modern capitalism has in it's entire history
Was the plague a capitalist mass genocide like the holodomor because a ship with produce on it had plague ridden rats inside? Your ideology has no virtue, it's a disease on this Earth, go back to starving yourself in a commune you leach to society
@Jay Blake if you're gunna post BS at least make it believable. These deaths too were brought by collectivism.
Jay Blake Soooo...... could you maybe be more specific. I'm not asking for sources; just name actual events. Please and thank you!
@Jay Blake dude, watch the video, its VERY CLEAR Communism is a MURDEROUS Ideology!
It is a real shame that everyone knows the horrors of the Nazis, but people don't know anything about the things that happened in Imperial Japan, Communist China or Soviet Russia.
It's why I sum up Mao as two Hitlers and a Stalin
Never ask the Japanese what they did in WW2
Seriously the Japanese killed more people than the Nazis, but it’s not spoken about in the West for some reason.
What about Winston Churchill ?
We all know that the good guys won every major war, it says it here in my history book@@nischaymiglani2617
Chinese farmers: kill sparrows
Crickets: Hippity hoppity, your food is our property.
@array s I doubt that would be a good idea, if they've been killed with spray or something.
Ever tried fried crickets? XD
@@pckkaboo6800 No. They don't bring them in my country in other form than as baked in a loaf of bread.
@@pckkaboo6800 In Mexico, a species of grasshopper can be bred for food. It is fed spices and herbs, and then is toasted with garlic until it turns dark red. It tastes fresh and crunchy like spicy chips. It's called "Chapulín", like "El Chapulín colorado", a very popular TV character.
Then eats cricket
My Grandfather lived through this and somehow survived.
Mine too. Cheers
Man at least my grandmother lived in Hong Kong
@@Hxoibrixks the British didn’t treat Hong Kongers good either. Hong Kong also protests Ed British rule in which the British killed Hong Kong protesters
My grandpa went through the gulag system and also survived somehow
@berat ergin if their grandads died they wouldn’t even exist rn
It's astounding how little about Mao is taught in US schools today
There are hundreds of thousands of years of history, school is about 12 years long
We only focus on US
@@BuiltSimilarG And we don't even focus on that these days.
@@candyjack3659 Bruh
Freshman year: SLAVERY
Sophomore year: COLONIZATION
Junior year: SLAVERY
Senior year: COLONIZATION
Mongols: “We killed the most Chinese people!”
Japan: “No, WE did!”
China: “Amateurs”
Just look at Chinese history. They've probably had more civil wars than any surviving nation of today.
Hilarious how the CCP brainwashes mainland Chinese into hating Japan for killing Chinese people, when the CCP itself killed more Chinese people than Japan ever did.
@@ennui9745 for a party that got saved by the japanese, the CCP is sure the most ungrateful one i have ever seen
@@kuomingangenjoyer3242 Exactly.
@@ennui9745 I mean... Japan has trade embargos with any country that teaches the tragedy of Nanking, so I see a big reason to hate Japan.
"The Great Leap Forward" has to be the most gallows humor name ever given to anything. It would be hilarious if it wasn't so serious.
That is why there is lmao zedong
Lmao za-*DONG!*
This is all his big joke. Thus lMao Zedong
Reminds me of the “ affordable care act “
@@peanutbuttersandwich5015 Yes, and not because the planners are twisted and evil (though they may be), but because a free market made up of thousands or millions of people is always going to be more efficient than central planning. The government can help best by doing a little refereeing likebreaking up monopolies, enforcing contracts, managing externalities like pollution and letting trade take care of the rest.
As the old joke states: "Put a Communist in charge of a desert and eventually you run out of sand."
You do know that China is still classed as a communist country, right?
@@bedsdavies8210 yes
@@no2party Doesn't that seem contradictory to you?
@@TeifiValley123 Not really, now with Coronavirus and their One-Child policy they're running out of people!
@@TeifiValley123 they are only politically communist, they are economically capitalist which is what helped them.
A farm worker greets Josef Stalin at his potato farm.
“Comrade Stalin, we have so many potatoes that, piled one on top of the other, they would reach all the way to God,” the farmer excitedly tells his leader.
“But God does not exist,” replies Stalin.
“Exactly,” says the farmer. “Neither do the potatoes.”
Then the farmer is brutally tortured and left to rot at vorkuta gulag
The lols are real though
This Enraged Stalin who punished him Severely
Gamer moment
@MarineSlayer And then he sacrifices himself to save the American
It's sad to see alot of people starting to glorify Mao and his revolution in the west
Who?
@@potatoesandducks958 there's always gonna be stupid people in the world. it dont matter where you look, theres stupid people in any single community, and those stupid people always end up being the face of the community they "represent" to the outside world. people like that exist, but far and few between, but putting into scale the negativity bias, the internet, and modern politics, most people dont even think of others as humans in politics so now many people think that nazis are a huge problem or that communists are a huge problem. they both exist and are a problem, but really aren't starting some kind of huge revolution on behalf of the left/right.
@@TheDigitalApple what about those stuff where you ship some austrian dude with the thing that is related to what your saying.
In Parasite, the wealthy family's kid was pretending to be in a worse situation than he was.
In the west, people find very legitimate flaws of capitalism, and instead of easily solving them, the American public wants to switch to communism or socialism.
At this point, calling them peasants should be justified.
It's even worse how that is not a taboo like nazism is when both ideologies are inhumane.
"Sell the rice!"
"But, sir...."
"Just do it!"
Sell them, sell them now. *Dewit!*
I can’t believe Mao was selling the fucking rice when his people were dying.
@@arandomzoomer4837 Oh my, a communist dictator was evil. What a surprise, surely that has never happened before or since!
@@fredrikcarlen3212 I know that this has happened in other situations but it's still disgusting.
"Sell it or I'll have you killed.......seriously, YES I have that power. Think I'm fucking around? This isn't a game, I'll fucking kill you, my son"
If anyone can translate that into Hahn Chinese, that would be amazing lolol
Mao: This will be called The Great Leap Forward
Communism: *UNO REVERSE CARD*
Communism* not nature
@@the4thindustrialrevolution225 yikes im dumb
@@afif8472 No you're not. it's just a mistake.
Battlefield 4 the Great Leap Forward DLC
A.K.A The Great Leap Backward
Foreign nations: Dude... you need any help?
Mao: Nah! it's all good.
Foreign nations: B-but people are dying in mass...
Mao: No they're not...
Hmm.. Sounds kinda familiar.
Mao: I have perfected Megalomaniacal Sociopathic Narcissism!!!
Trump: Lol..
Jay Blake They aren’t saying he hid it. They’re saying he refused help that China needed.
OrigamiOwl ya, but trump isn’t killing millions.
Cmon, it was only 45million out of billion
Lmao.
Incredibly, Orwell predicted all of this in Animal Farm, over a decade before these events occurred - the shortages, the inadequacy of unskilled labour in manufacturing, and the purges of anyone who disagreed with the plan.
Of course he was writing about the situation that unfolded in soviet Russia, but incredibly the Chinese leadership seemed happy to repeat the Soviet’s mistakes, and condemn so many of their own people to starvation.
I read 1984 and I’m reading life and death in Shanghai and the parallels are scary
It’s funny how Animal Farm can easily apply to any dictatorial revolution, especially Communist ones, and there’s still tankies defending Communism by saying “Animal Farm is not about Communism”
Lao She, a famous writer in China said this is some sci-fi delusion after reading the 1984. Eventually, he committed suicide during the cultural revolution launched by chairman Mao.😂
@@klm9440i'm Chinese,and you right
@@sidneym8895Lao She's death can't be blamed for this. He is a man who has a great sense of face. But he was criticized during the Cultural Revolution, so he committed suicide
*Mao* : I kill more people than both of you ,why history giving you 2 a credit
*Hitler and Stalin* : Do you got a cool mustache
*Mao* : *Cries in Chinese*
💀💀💀
Stalin killed millions pf people but the population increases lol
@303en it is because USSR in science was advancing too, unlike china whom relies of USSR too....
@@RHD_lantz USSR relied on raw manpower for the majority of it's territory gain. Science was of little importance for them until the height of the cold war.
LMAOOOO
Mao is still considered as a hero... let that sink in...
So is Washington who promote slavery, these historical figure always become heros to someone. All comes down to perceptive.
a aron True but the difference is that in our system we were able to abolish it
It's becuase of him China is what today , everything you use is made in China and he lifted millions from poverty
@@Кенжетайұлы HA HA HA Ridiculous!
Everything is made in China by people want to jump off the buildings and commit suicide. That's why they put Nets around the buildings. They can't speak about how unhappy they are because they would be penalized for that. They may be actually sent off to have their organs stolen and be killed. Don't believe for a moment that their economy is good. They have complete empty cities full of nobody and crumbling buildings that have never been lived in. Yes some can prosper in businesses that can easily be taken away by the government. Yeah what a hero 😂 after all the millions of dead can't speak
story told by my father: His family were one of the wealthiest in the city during this period. They were living the best of their lives until the great leap happened. Land reform took all of his family's assets, leaving only one house for them to live in--my grandfather,grandmother, and 8 kids. My grandfather was drafted to the factory and my grandmother was drafted to the kitchen, being businessman, they had to learn everything from scratch. Food rations are given to them everyday. However, the given ration was not enough to feed the family, so they had to add water to their rice and make porridge. My grandmother, working in the kitchen, tries to sneak food everyday to give to her kids. This goes on until my grandparents died. Once my father's siblings are grown up, they are then sent to provinces far from home to work in factories.
Thinking about this now, it pains my heart knowing my father has suffered so much during his childhood. From wealthy to poor in an instant with no parents to guide them during the day.
Which city was he from? Did his family try escaping before the communists took over?
Would you happen to know what your family did for a living?
@@alleviatedaubergine8130 They ran a textile business.
@@anonymousanimal1534 They were from Xiamen, Fujian.
Ok, while I cannot empathize with your loss, I can extend my sympathies, however little they are worth.
My grandfather was in a landlord family at the time when the Land Reform took place. He and his family were beaten severely and sent to the city factory as workers, his house was confiscated. This cruelty they've done to him actually saved his life, as during the Great Leap Forward, city workers were fed well at the price of starvation in the countryside. 20 years later when the Cultural Revolution ended, he returned to the countryside and saw the old house emptied. The farmers who took his house all starved to death years ago. We refused to live in that house and left it emptied, until two years ago my father sold that house to the government as they wanted to construct a road over it.
Cat, dog and rat meat were prevalent. There's a dog meat festival in China.
When did the government return your grandfather's house to him? Was there a whole era when confiscated property was returned to those that mao took it from?
@@kadafi4lyf There was a redress act(拨乱反正, Boluan Fanzheng) after the Cultural Revolution, which happened during 1978-1989. In this period Deng Xiaoping corrected a large part of Mao's mistakes and restored operation of the country to some extent. Grandpa's property was returned at about 1980, due to the government finding out most of his "crime records" were forged by farmers who held a hostile attitude towards land lord families. (Yes, before 1978, if you want your neighbor killed or beaten in China you can just report him by whatever reason you want. That's how scary it was.)
I've lived in china for almost an year. I just want to ask. Do the people who experienced these atrocities first hand still support the current governments stand that mao was a hero. And also what you guys are taught in schools regarding it.
@@hasaansamad2995 It may surprise you that, China actually talks about the GLP and Cultural Revolution in textbooks (in the version I was taught at least). They admit those were Mao's mistake, but under the condition that "He was misdirected by some malicious actors in the party". Quite a part of content in this video are mentioned, but they didn't say how many people were killed and they insist that the main cause of the starvation is land drought / other natural disasters. As for the survivors' stand, I can't say for sure. Talking about that period can be traumatizing for some of them, so usually we chose not to.
Mao: hey peasants, want to hear a joke?
Peasants: sure
Mao:Food
Peasants: I don’t get it.
Mao: Thats the point.
😂😂😂😂😂
Lmao that is so good.
@@mihailojovicevic5576 stolen old and no one cares
*LMAO*
Isn’t it “we” nit “I”?
The fact that Mao refused foreign aid to save face is exactly how most asian parents are. Ego and reputation is priority in most Asian cultures and family.
In my family too
They would lose face that way
Lol yes.
@Insert Name Here that was purely intentional by Stalin. Kill of millions of Ukrainians and replace them with Russians. It's still having its effects with conflicts in Ukraine due to the Russian descendents
That's true but not whole picture . Back to 1960 , there was no trading between China and western world . After 1960 , China started to import food from other communist nations .
Stalin: let's collect food
Everybody: dies
Mao: we should try that again 🤔
*I'll fuckin' do it again*
Dead meme.
Weeaboo Karwan yet a timeless message
Kalpesh Manna college kids today:
We can get it right this time.
are you dumb? you see the problem was misinformation about farming and inexperienced undertrained factory workers. let's compare these issues to the US shall we, slavery, no human rights to workers, exploiting child labor, and forced drafting to war, etc. also they gave food not collect them
It genuienly shocks me as to how much of a disaster The Great Leap Forward was cause what’s unique about it is it wasn’t a case of a heartless man having no concern for citizens and being ok with millions suffering (tbf Mao certainly was like that) but it was instead caused by a man who had so much incompetence when it came to economics, science and geography and it pains me how tens of millions suffered due to this incompetence
Reminds me of the great reset with Klaus Schwab
Yeah but remember the situation China was in: almost 20 years of civil war, they got free from the japanese just 10 years prior, they were in a precarious situation and the Kuomintang had destroyed a lot of farms by flooding plains. It was a mostly agrarian nation with few experts and capable people,and they didn't want to listen to soviet farming advices, had a population so big that it was impossible for China's allies to feed all of them...
Mao was not an economist or an engineer and shouldn't have taken this kind of decisions, but it's more justifiable than an economic crash caused by wild speculation in the 1929 or even the 2008 housing crisis...
@@SatchelChannel the Great Depression and Financial Crisis were awful but at least they didn’t lead to the deaths of 30-50 million and there were many policies of the GLF that even someone with no economics or scientific knowledge would call idiotic such as the substantial use of metal or wood for the backyard furnaces
@@HenryBenedictUSA Schawb is systamatic.
It was short sided to kill all the sparrows bc killing them all means that their pray can eat all of the people’s crops and which means that people would die because of no food
Houses of happyness sounds like something stright out of an Orwell novel.
I mean they were just places the elderly could go in the day
Damn, this is just like 1984
(Mao reads marx communist manifesto)
Mao: we can make a religion out of this.
Normie tier meme.
Both Marx and Moses hess were [Censored]
in fact no, there is also a policy called "cultural revolution"
@Richard Vaughn so was Yagoda, stalin's wife, Rosa Luxemburg and beria. But that must be COINCEDENCES
China is whole again then it broke again
"No don't"
China: dying from coronavirus
Simple history: let’s revisit history
That's a billion less
they're trying to animate Chinese history before they die out
@@Noisykiller12 Implying it wasn't already dead and buried under Mao's Cultural Revolution
@@MikoyanGurevichMiG21 it still lives in Taiwan
I think Its actually kind of related with the Corona virus, you know that stereotype that Chinese eat dogs? It originates from the starvation caused by this "great leap forward". People had to eat anything they could find, so they catch other diseases that can spread later
“So, to grow our steel production, how much lifeswill be lost?”
“More than 18 million sir.”
“Well we had too many people anyway”
Just like sending money to Ukraine
Mao when asked about China’s progress:
“It’s evolving, just backwards”
@Jay Blake it didn't.
Jay Blake maybe because half the people dying left the other half all the medicine and food? Great strategy. Do you sexually identify as Thanos?
He sacrificed people to the dark gods . BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD . SKULLS FOR THE SKULL THRONE.
So backpedaling?
@Schlomo Shekelbergtransgenderstein Does the end justify the means?
"When there is not enough to eat people starve to death. It is better to let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill"
Mao Zedong 1959
Edit-After looking around some i found a transcript in Chinese and translated it. Yes, the quote is actually out of context but in light of Mao's murderous ideology i think the post is worth keeping. Anyone wanting another real doozy, look into the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976)
Thanos?
That has always been the collectivist view. They call it the "end of hostory". The fantasy that you can stabilize human endeavor, growth, and invention into a standstill. They would rather kill millions than to use scientific progress to feed them.
A small sacrifice for salvation 😌
Kalpesh Manna thats a horrible, worthless and dehumanizing sacrifice to make. It’s a waste of humanity. And it wasn’t salvation, it’s feudalism under the guise of communism.
Mao : I am.. Inevitable
Mao: "Everyone please kill the sparrows, they're eating all the crops"
Nature: *booms cricket population because there was no predators
Mao: *surprised pikachu face*
Mao: Nature is an agent of Imperialistic Capitalists!
L MAO!!!
Now they are eating cricket.
I laughed at the big rat appearing, because tiny annoying sparrows, don't eat rodents.
LMAO
Mao: This is a famous chinese dish;
Chinese citizen: But Mao, there's nothing on the plate
Mao: *It's called emptiness :)*
Mao: That’s the idea! :D
When you're so insane that even Stalin has to call you out
In 1969, when the Soviets and Chinese were having a huge border dispute skirmish, Brezhnev was so furious with Mao that he was ready to launch nukes on them. The only reason he didn't is because Nixon told him not to (as he stated America had "interests" in the Chinese region). It certainly is a powerful thought as to how different history could have gone if the US let them do it.
@@thunderbird1921 It wouldn’t have been a good idea, if the US nuked them WW3 would have kicked off
@@tastefullyoffensive2412 I meant what could have happened if America let the Soviets nuke China. We would have had one of the ugliest wars in human history between the Communist powers, and one can only imagine how the rest of humanity would have dealt with it.
@@thunderbird1921 Oh ok, now I understand. Thank you!
Stalin died in 1953… Great Leap Forward started in 1958
Mao: we shall give all land to the people
Rural bois: this sounds good
Mao: also you're going to Chinese gulags
hope all foreign people know what happened and happening now in CHINA '
CHINIA IS NOT PANDA
CHINA IS BITTER SNAKE
Chinese CURSE amaerican everyday , american goverment never told you that !!!!!
It's called reeducation study camp.
@@viettrungnguyen1242 Nice newspeak there comrade.
Anthony Le lmao
@TheGreaterGood80 i'm a chinese i know how ccp tought people to hate america
"We got a plan to modernize China. It's call The Great Leap Forward." - China 1958
"Nothing is going on in Tiananmen Square." - China 1989
"There is no protesting in Hong Kong. Who ever says otherwise is a liar, and should watch...I am will probably disappear....I mean will go on a long vacation." -China 2019
"There is this virus. That is in no way deadly to anyone." -China 2020
CCP: 'no human to human transmission' late January (when they knew)
WHO: Ok then, you heard it lads. Nothing to worry about, go about your day
China's 4 big lies
Ah I see, you are not the only one cursed with Knowledge -
Legitly one of the finest comments in here.
After wild farming was permitted because of the famines caused by Mao this virus has been the direct result. Mao why are u still killing people???!!!
Whenever I watch Naruto and criticise Madara's plan for being so stupid I remember Mao and think, "Eh, well."
Well said.
Chinese officials: ‘How many farmers will work the fields?’
Mao: ‘Yes’
A small sacrifice for salvation 😌
Kalpesh Manna eternal pain*
@@andychen5579 lol
They will also produce steel
I have parents and grandparents that survived the Great Leap Forward. Basically, they had almost nothing to eat. Meat was non-existent and only ate low-quality vegetables. My grandfather on my mom's side was sent to a "reformation" camp for a while and really didn't tell how much he much abuse he endured. My grand-uncle on my dad's side was a jerk for being highly prominent and highly convicted to the Communist party while leaving his family to starve in the countryside. Although he passed away, my dad's father lived a happy life, more so than his brother.
To this day, my parents have an absolute hatred for socialism.
Run from china please. You are welcome in Argentina. Even in my house .
Why do we all have to wear these ridiculous white backdrops?!
Lauti Cruz how could he be living in China if he is making this comment and watching a video probably banned they have very restrictive internet rules if he lives in China he would be doing this illegally and would be caught
It is so sad how much suffering the Chinese people endured throughout the 20th century.
@@thessop9439 Funny, so you can provide accomodation to them along with other Nazis who fled from the defeat in 1945? Did everyone simply disregard the reason why his family got into those situation? Those end up in camps are the few who used to get fed by exploiting others, take no responsiblity in defending the facists Japanese invader when the whole country is shattering, and still dreaming about their "modern nobility" when the majority of people came to power. I can understand it could never be happy knowing one's ancestor had something to suffer, but it's just the time for them to take their toll.
“We made China communist!”
“What about the food?”
*”you wouldn’t get it.”*
"Real food hasn't been tried before!"
@DEADMAN TV Vi estas malinteligenta se vos pensas tio estis cringe
@Deadman TV Cringe “Real Communist hasn’t been tried before” enjoyer
@Deadman TV........... Communism is a leftist ideology stupid.
Communism is when capitalism
*"bUt ThAt WaSn'T rEaL cOmMuNiSm!!1!!11!"*
@@Anonymous-uh8mz It wasn't real communism, it was just communism.
@@Anonymous-uh8mz if it’s not real communism then real capitalism has never been exercised
@@garyoakham9723real capitalism is all in le head
communism means stateless, classless and tradeless society - please tell me how china was communistic? just beacuse one claims to be someone doesn't mean they are.
Build back better
Sparrows exist
Mao: They are eating our crops! Kill them all!
More crops get harmed by insects
Mao: *surprised winnie the pooh face*
Murasaki Budou stop.
Murasaki Budou I was confused about the Winnie face but then China's backward ness
@@enderpup9289 ew furry
@@enderpup9289 because it was specifically the scare the current leader of China that's banned Winnie the Pooh on China and it's used as a slur against the Chinese leader
Nah, in Burmese, he's called Mr.Shithole.
www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2020/01/facebook-apologises-rude-mistranslation-xi-jinping-200119071125127.html
When the narrator said "they copied the Soviet system" he forgot to mention that also starved tens of millions of people to death.
Yeah. The Holomar sucked the big red one
+1
The Earth's greatest weight loss program.
Redips well said
Mad STONKS
maybe this is why all the fat feminists want socialism
Its better than weight watchers that's for sure. Communism you will lose weight and more guaranteed!
Kim Jong Un needs this
There’s a brilliant Chinese film about a family that survived all of Mao’s five year plans and the Cultural Revolution. The film is called To Live and its seen as a masterpiece of historical storytelling
There’s another one called China Cry. My mom bought that for me for Christmas because I had an interest in Asian culture. She had absolutely no idea it was based on a true woman’s story of the Great Leap Forward. Same with Hachi on the famous Japanese Akita dog.
The Sequel is called: “Build, back, better”
Love the opening with the aesthetic poster cutting away to the harsher realities
Stalin: I killed the most people!
Mao: *There is always an Asian better than you!*
Technicaly stalin is asian too
@@vanjasenjanin1797 Georgia is in Europe.
Pol Pot: I got you fam
@@lowkey7914 its disputed i consider georgia europe but european borders are the caucasus and the ural mountain
Mosquito that passed the bubonic plague from rats to humans:
Hello we are all friends here
My high school teacher once explained the Great Leap Forward in this manner:
She asked for a volunteer, told them to face the wall leaving about an inch from his face. She then said “ok now jump forward as far as you can”, and there was an audible this as his forehead came into contact with the wall.
Great Leap Forward into big time insanity, retardation, and hunger
This is such a blatant lie that it’s hilarious you even posted it
@@PartnershipsForYou as someone who's from an European school, this sounds pretty plausible if OP comes from Europe
I’ve had professors that defended this man. Defended him. I just… I don’t understand.
Your professors were right, you've just been brainwashed by bourgeois lies about this great man.
Because education was the very first area the marxists tookover in the 60’s….
Now it’s the DEI bs - Boeing disney etc…
Because your professor is Commie
I imagine they were in China
When you scare off crop-eating birds allowing crop-eating bugs to roam freely
*Task failed succesfully*
Every potential bureaucrat; All I can see is my nose
Mao; “you’ll die quite nicely”
task failed un succesfully
More like
**Task succeed with failure**
Not scare off, but exterminate, extinguish completely.
If you think about it Mao Zedong was Thanos before Marvel created Thanos.
L *MAO
Except Thanos had a point.
mao is just pure idiot.
That made more sense.
Chairman Zedong: "I'm gonna take over right *Mao* "
Polticians: *Laughs*
Chaiman Zedong: "Execute everyone who laughed and Gulag those who smirked."
Just like that time when the first person who stopped clapping was sent to a gulag.
Yup
Mao is his last name by the way
Ya know, this is actually something that would have happened and HAS HAPPENED in communist states all the time when those were still commonplace(now days theres only a a mere handful of those dreadful communist hellholes left like north korea and china and cuba - and maybe some other ones but those are the only REAL ones left that are genocidal antiHUMAN EVIL states - which is what communism is).
Same wiht Jake 202. That sounds REAL from all ive read about the communist scourge in various countries over the years.....people who arent aware of history may think its far fetched or not true but that sort of thing was actually extremely common. Che Guevera for instance took GREAT PLEASURE in watching "prisoners"(non-communists) rounded up, given mock show trials(quickly of course), then brought to the execution ground which he ordered be made DIRECTLY OUTSIDE HIS WINDOW SO HE COULD "ENJOY" WATCHING THESE POOR PATRIOTIC MEN GET SHOT IN THE HEAD BY HIS MURDERERS AND THUGS. And yeah thats actually for real, look it up if you have any doubts. Far leftists are DISGUSTING creatures DISGUSTING and EVIL and NEED TO BE OPPOSED ALWAYS.
Mao didnt have gulags. That was stalin
And the sad thing is that while most older generations remembered this part of history, they are getting old and too traumatized to tell the tales to their grandchildren… Or that people who survived the period are those who were benefited from other people's suffering. Truth is, not many young generations know much about their own history, and all they're talking about is how communist party of China succeeded their people. Now both Mao and Xi is godly feature in China, and people would not allow anyone to criticize their Gods
We have the sequel now: Build back better
China: *makes communes*
Present day communists: "That's not real communism!!"
If actual outcomes ≠ theorized outcome,
then execute "that wasn't real socialism/communism"
Promote socialism/communism
Enact socialism/communism
Repeat
Well... it isn’t.
Communism wouldn’t work but it has never been tried, unless you count Makhnovia
@Trinidad and Tobagoball not really a state/not-state
@@fireiron369 Makhnovia and Anarchist Catalonia were much closer to Communism than any authoritarian dictatorship that labeled itself as "Communist", guess what happened when the farms were collectivised in Catalonia, production went up 50%, only difference was that the collectivisation was voluntary and not forced.
Also Rojava and the Zapatistas are having a pretty good time with their stateless anarchist systems.
@@1997lordofdoom But that's not Communism. Communism must be global
"Black humor is like communist food."
"I don't get it."
"Exactly."
Black humor?
You had one job.
Andy Davis dark/gallows humor.
Has nothing to do with race if that’s what you’re asking.
I’ve seen a lot of variations of this joke, and this is definitely the shittiest one.
@@localshithead7430 Clearly its not, since you took the time out to respond, and notice it.
Funny thing is, Mao's picture still hangs on the Tienanmen Square. He laughed at all those starving people, he laughs again at the dying people who wanted freedom.
Real funny
It's funny how the best I have heard of the Chinese government was in Ancient History.
I believe he's still on the currency. I have a Chinese bill with his picture on it.
@@fcondro so what? Does plastic surgery laugh in the face of dying people? Does it pretend starvation is just a myth to take power over the authority?
Whatever link you are making, I cannot see it nor understand it.
It’s funny, in Beijing, his photo and image is everywhere. I kid you not, he’s got merchandise everywhere. He’s still held in high regard there despite everything he’s done. Even dedicated an entire building for his grave. Wonder what a Chinese history book looks like
@@fcondro whatever you say, wu mao slave
I recently started to read the book Tombstone by Chinese author Yang Jisheng. The book dissects the causes and effects of the Great Famine in detail - his thesis was that it was an entirely man-made disaster. I couldn't even get through the first chapter - it gave me an existential crisis and a horrible depressive episode lasting days. It will completely destroy your faith in humanity, to witness the greed, cowardice and cover-ups resulting in the deaths of tens of millions of innocent people for absolutely nothing. No benefit to anyone. And they are not even allowed to have a tombstone to remember them (which explains the title of the book - this is the tombstone). I found the complete inhumanity in the book terrifying. It wasn't foreign invasions, it wasn't aliens, it wasn't the universe ending - it was the complete indifference to the suffering of one's fellow humans that led to this disaster unprecedented in human history, which could have been prevented if the responsible parties even had one shred of human decency. It saddens me that this topic is still twisted and censored in China, so that few people know the truth of what happened or dare to speak if they knew. And too few outside China know or care. The era in China under Mao deeply scarred the population and it's a scar that will be carried by generations. I hope one day the truth will come to light before this period of history is forgotten.
You mean gill bates and the war on meat eggs and water?
When you force the farmers to make steel out of kitchen utensils
SMITHING *100*
Empire is the best.
Ohh Ahh! YOU'VE REACHED LEVEL 100
Biesliek1 stuff the imperial empire the stormcloaks are better
*chinese starving to death*
Soviets: first time?
China had repeated droughts and famines throughout the 1800s, so they were pretty used to starving. Great Leap Forward was probably the worst one, but definitely not the first.
Nearly every country had mass starvation during it's industrialization and the fencing in of formerly commonly accessable land.
Combine that with the millions of people starving as direct consequence of colonial powers deliberate decisions. Millions starved in India, the middle east and China during the 1800s and 1900s. There even was a widespread theoretical groundwork to justify that kind of inhumanely cruel policy in the western, capitalist empires: the theory of overpopulation by Robert Malthus. Mass starvation as desired policy goal - instead of catastrophic byproduct of poor decisions.
It was just a joke :/
ua-cam.com/video/fxnaXKR4Ueo/v-deo.html
so why China becomes the biggest producer of wheat in the world?
They have the largest population in the world, third largest land mass, vast temperate climate, and containing over 10% of the world's arable land. And don't the Yangtze, yellow, pearl, and songhuajiang rivers. With all that in mind they better be an agricultural power house because they simply have resources that no one else has.
Reddit Communists: "Well, ACKSHULLY....."
Nope
@Minecraft Veteran try visiting r/worldpolitics
@Minecraft Veteran r/sino
Minecraft Veteran none of them call themselves commies but the political subreddits have a heavy left wing bias, stay away from those shitholes
@@patricks1333 Yeah, because mortality rate is so important that we ignore other underlying problems such as people disappearing when they dissent, suppression of free speech, loss of privacy and the brainwashing of ethnic minorities because China good. Your opinion is a joke.
“Some of you may die and that is the sacrifice I am willing to make.”
Thanks, got to learn this for my school lessons. What a coincidence!
China number 1
Are you also a Hong Kong Student studying Chinese History? Cause i am.
@@russell4658 you forgot that they actively censor and oppose free speech
@@clintonktho No, I'm studying over seas but live in Hong Kong. But I'm learning Chinese History Currently, really cool.
China enemy of human progress, liberation and existence
Everyone: *goes to the steel foundry
Crickets: *It's free real estate*
Best comment here
@@jakefisher8691 makes no sense
Nissan skyline; makes sense in a way
Chinese Red Guard: Greeting Peasants how's goes....
by the *MAO!!!*
???
I don't get it either.
?
@@project_romaniacore It's like that knight reaction meme where a knight is walking and he says "Greetings peasants, how goes the..." then he sees something repulsive and says "By the Pope!" Like this: knowyourmeme.com/photos/1396258-by-the-pope
@@chaosXP3RT Alright. Thank you for explaining and posting a link as well.
I don’t know if it was intended or not but there was a moment of silence at the end. Very meaningful in my opinion.
Diane Abbott: “MaO DId moRe GOOd thaN HaRm”
Also Bernie Sanders
Leon Edralev also Justin Turd au
All front benchers of her majesty's opposition are clueless assholes
ConservativeLibertarian 2004 also Jeremy Corbyn
yeah no. I had a 3 day argument with a friend cuz she supports mao and I absolutely hate him.
PRC: *Chases off Sparrows*
Vermins: It's free real estate
Odd, I chased off the Sparrows and rats in my area, and the thrushes, robins and blackbirds all returned. Obviously he couldn't even do pest control properly.
It makes me wonder how China had so many events that resulted in millions dieing, yet somehow they have been able to obtain the most people in any country.
Statistically there's a very strong correlation between high birth rates and high infant mortality rates. The more likely you are to lose people the more populations seem to breed.
@@HDZ274 Exactly, more people = more deaths.
If there's one thing China's poor understand, it's sacrifice. Communism didn't make life better, nor did Capitalism. What allowed them to escape poverty was the sacrifice of fathers and mothers
I'm pretty sure it's the other way around. China had extremely deadly civil wars because of their huge population and resources.
Every time I see some young person talk about how wonderful socialism and communism would be in America, I refer them to this video.
Communism works my friend look at the ussr and the Khmer rouge
@@kingsweden4636 you mean you want me to see the success of communism by looking at two examples of how communism failed? Or is it that you want to highlight examples of mass murder and genocide? Either way you've just proven my point.
@@kingsweden4636 You should move to a communist country and get back to us.
*_"But that wasn't real communism"_*
Hate to be that guy, but China wasn't communist, Communism is a stateless, classless, moneyless society where workers own the means of production. Is the Democratic Republic of Korea Democratic? If we called it so then what do we call a country that is democratic?
@@Suth1172 Of course Communism and Socialism are not the same (Socialism is the transition system betwen Capitalism and Communism) and Communism is basically Anarchism (a World without States, classes, money, private ownership, etc).
But we (the ones who criticize Marxism) use Communism and Socialism as synonyms: all marxists call themselves "socialists" or "communists", so all of them want the same "Capitalism=>Abolish Capitalism=>Socialism=>Comunism" formula.
you discredit the marxists who internally criticize maoists and stalinists (tankies)
@Sue Martino It's not about trust, it's about enforcing public sovereignty. Conservatives trust that removing democratic elections in favor of corporate control will result in less government, rather than the explosion of corporate welfare it always produces. Democrats want to tie government to public services that expand the resources available to small business and free enterprise.
Burning the flag is what you get when people are hurt by what that flag represents. If that isn't understandable, you either have lead poisoning or you aren't human.
Oskar sutherland China at the peek of the great leap forward was exactly what Marx dreamed of. It WAS following Marxism like a bible, land redistribution, equal rations, drafting into the work force, “power” to the people. I will acknowledge now China is getting closer to capitalism but many of its communist policies remain and it is still socially a communist state.
They got into a civil war, got owned by Japanese, got into another civil war, got involved in Korean War, and then the Great Leap Forward... my goodness China... 😂
They lost almost every war they go to except going war against themselves
@@unknownmasksw2serialirious580 China got a huge nerf after the 1800’s, good thing they got recently buffed but now they’re too overpowered.
@@SageAmariKeyes oof china gonna fall if they started another war
@@unknownmasksw2serialirious580 They won the Korean War, they successfully repelled the U.N forces despite being heavily under-industrialized.
@The Professional it was a stalemate you peabrain
More accurately: "The Great Leap Backwards".
Most accurately: “The Great Leap Forward… Off the Stool”.
Racist
As a Chinese from Hong Kong, this is surprisingly true
EastCoast Podcast What?
@@ECP90 how?
My mom's family is from Beijing, during the great leap forward, My grandparents would bring wild animals back home for consumption. they also had to save the limited egg ration quotas for my mom's younger brother (my uncle)... That was in Beijing, the capital of China... you can imagine what was happening in other cities or even villages in countryside.
People are freaked out by the random things Chinese People eat. Like Bats, Beavers, Dogs, and other exotic Animals. However given the History of the Great Leap Forward. It sort of makes sense why. Their Grandparents had to eat whatever was around
"it's evolving, but backwards"
basically the summarization of this period.
And no famines ever happened under capitalism? Silly. Red China lifted nearly a billion people out of poverty, they saved billions of lives. Read this study then!
”China's growth in life expectancy between 1950 and 1980 ranks as among the most rapid sustained increases in documented global history.”
Source: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4331212/
stop copy and pasting
Patrick S that’s propaganda.
They made mistakes you ignoramus. You make it sound like somehow, the second five-year plan under Mao was an extermination campaign. It was not. It was an economic program intended to speed the construction of their industrial base. It backfired & accounting for the floods and droughts, made those times worse. Having an honest conversation on this topic is impossible because people are shrieking that 'if only they had Western freedoms.'
That's not an argument.
www.invent-the-future.org/2013/12/monster-liberator-legacy-mao-zedong/
@@zhouenlaienjoyer6306 In practice, it caused widespread Famine and more damage to their agriculture sector rather than improving it (By rigorous farming that affects the soil fertility, and other shenanigans the CCP did)
Although the first few years has somewhat improved food supply and the quality of life (within farming communes), overall, it's an ineffective economic program that caused significantly more harm than benefits
Mao : Wanna hear a joke?.....
Peasants : Yea sure
Mao : Private Property!
Peasants : We don't get it....
Mao : *EXACTLY!* :-)
I get it
(I don't get it)
@@the-j69 exactly
@@dakotaharnish5515 [seinfeld theme plays ]
And no famines ever happened under capitalism? Silly. Red China lifted nearly a billion people out of poverty, they saved billions of lives. Read this study then!
”China's growth in life expectancy between 1950 and 1980 ranks as among the most rapid sustained increases in documented global history.”
Source: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4331212/
dude, srsly?
No food ✔
No water ✔
No help✔
Death✔
Living in agony ✔
Mao: SOUNDS GREAT
Stalin: SOUNDS AMAZING
Kim Il Sung, Kim Jong Il, Kim Jong Un: SOUNDS GOOD
Pol Pot: SOUNDS FFFFFFUUUUUNNNNN
Lenin: WONDERFUL
Castro: COOL
Hitler: THATS BEAUTIFUL
@gel mibson so true
Hotel: Trivago
@@randomnepali7772 WTF 🤣
American Champagne Socialists: "That wasn't _real_ socialism. Let us give it a try."
Pol Pot: Sounds FUN!!
-999.999.999 Social Credits
No wonder my dad is so much shorter than me lmao he was born in 1962
L Mao?
lMao 🤣🤣🤣
Oof
Hey at least he lived
Great Leap Forward in a nutshell: China takes a huge leap!
Into a long hole of starvation and depression
Hi Uncle Joe,
I'm a huge fan. Especially of what you accomplished on March 1st 1953!! That was your finest work :)
You would know a lot about taking a huge leap Ioseb.
China takes a huge leap and misses.
PREVIET
Leche de caballo you miss 100% of the leaps you don’t take.
"Chairman Mao did more good than harm" - UK Labour MP, Dianne Abbott. Jesus.
Wow.
I find it telling no one questions the western propaganda; it's like established fact because everyone says it.
Having the power that Mao had over his people is the wet dream of every leftist around the world, here in Brazil some communist fucks praises Mao all the time and tell the people he was a hero.
@@LucasCunhaRocha E o mais engraçado é que eles adoram misturar narrativas se dizendo a favor das minorias, mas se eles vivessem na era de Mao ou de Stalin todos eles já teriam sido executados.
@@LucasCunhaRocha mao wasnt a hero lol its due to a "famine" that killed the people
One of my friend's dad ABSOLUTELY hates the communist party. According to him, his father's grandpa was really rich and worked for the communist party. But he got thrown into jail because he is simply not chinese and they said he "might betray". They had numerous ways of torturing him, like letting him starve for days before giving a potato. After a few years, he was released. He went mad and did suicide after a week. This is just absurd.
Sort of like what they want to do to Trump people
My grandparents said that during the great leap forward people ate clay and dirt to fill their bellies or just sesame seed oil in water to give them some flavour...those were certainly horrible times.
I like how the first 7 seconds of this video says everything we need to know about the Great Leap Forward without saying a word.
Mao Zedong took a great leap foward.
Unfortunately, he leaped China right into a very deep hole.
This reminds me of a slogan by the Bulgarian communist party. "Before 9th of September, 1944 (The date of the communist coup d'etat), Bulgaria was at the cliff's edge. After 9th of September, 1944, she took a great step forward.". I wish this was an anecdote, but no.
It is said the Great Leap Forward and the cultural revolution set China back 30 years
Well...they're the worlds #2 superpower
And moving up
Is that...backwards?
not likely
Yeah they’re the number 2 superpower, but at a cost. They build abandoned and empty infrastructure in order to gain GDP. A lot of people in China are struggling a lot, but China builds a lot of ghost villages and uses other tactics to get to the top.
You’ll see in a few decades when their power collapses due to the unethical ways they gain economic power.
@@Dance_Party
China's debt to GDP is 54%
USA's debt to GDP is 105%
Guess who I'll be betting on.....
Zhong Xina will never told you this in Public American School.
Mao: "Let's start the Great leap forward."
*Millions subsequently die*
Mao: "Ah, communism works wonders."
A plan only Thanos could admire. Not enough food? Kill off about 10% of the population, then suddenly there's a lot more food to go around.
While Soviet Union countries more approach to West culture, Mao blamed Khrushchev for not being loyal Marxist while he reforms a new Marxist ideology.
@Jay Blake ok boomer
Any time I see someone saying they want communism. I just remind them of Stalin and Mao.
Monarchy has a better track record than Communism. Being ruled by a single inbred royal who got the job by having the correct parents has worked incredibly better for humanity than being ruled by a group of sociopaths who believe in Marx's bullshit.
@@gorkyd7912 tell that to the french
"Communism" is a broad term so that person may be referring to something like council communism (decentralised and controlled by worker councils), which isn't very comparable to either of those dictators
There are virtually no people today who promote communism. Maybe NK. Socialism has become very successful when part of a mixed economy like Sweden and China. If you think modern socialism is synonymous with communism, you’re an idiot. I have lived in China for seven years. I have looked for a commune and found none. So just how many people are you reminding of Stalin and Mao? Since nobody truly wants Mao’s or Stalin’s form of communism, I’m guessing zero.
@@Cairo40000 Napoleon III actually was working fairly well for them for a while...until he botched foreign policy stuff in the 1860s. It's safe to say that the Bonapartes (with all their flaws) were better than at least 2-3 of their 5 republics.
I remember once seeing a picture of a man who was arrested in China for cooking and eating his own infant son during the Great Leap Forward.
*Dear god*
desperate times equals desperate measures
@@OatmealGrillBlazer That’s pretty god damn desperate
Apparently cannabalism became quite a common thing during that period because the entrances to all those villages were deliberately blocked by CCP to prevent villagers from escaping. Anyone caught digging for even a potato gets brutally beaten. Then the starved villagers started eating corpses.
@@5mwa So horrible. It’s not their fault either, they were forced to turn to cannibalism thanks to their government establishing peoples communes to convert their entire society into a communist one.
3:35
Girl : Banging pots to scare the sparrow off
The sparrow : This is fine
Simple History, thank you for this extensive look into the Great Leap Forward. Context and why something happens is super important, so I really appreciate that you guys included not just what the GLF was, but why and how it happened. Its well-researched and well-expressed videos like yours that first interested me in history, so thank you once again and keep up the good work!
“Top ten biggest bruh moments in history. Number 10....”
number 2: the minutemen from fallout4
Number 15 Burger King foot lettuuuce
“Communism will work this time.” - someone who has never experienced communism
Have you experienced communism?
Check out Yugoslavian communism, millions didnt die because our leader wasnt a narcicist who refused foreign aid, he worked with the west and the soviet block, the leader is the problem, not the system. Incompetent people will fail in any system. My father lived in that system and he tells me that nothing is better now in a democracy, its actually worse cause of all the corruption, in the communist system corrupt people would be punished severly, the only difference was you couldnt voice your opinion against the leader or the party, but they lived modest lives, had food and had everything, the country was producing everything it needed, its industry was strong, nobody starved. When the leader of Yugoslavia died everything fell apart because he kept all the nations of the federation in check and punished extreme nationalism, the motto of the people was Brotherhood and Unity, when he died the brotherhood died and the unity was shattered and war started which takes its toll even today on my country, our industry is non existant, the leader is the key.
I am still living in communism
Here in Hungary, many people want back, and much more things was better than in thisa oligarhic capitalism. I talked with many people who lived in that time and want it back. So that was you said that's a thing what says that people who live in a country that never was socialist
@@kpisti680 those are the party higher ups and unproductive people
If you want a strong economy. The trick is to keep the government's greedy claws off of it.
Are you Anarchist?
@@BuiltSimilarG No I just have common sense. Didn't you just watch the video?
and thats why capitalism always wins
@@kacpernap2863 **Contolism*
Only when antitrust legislation is strongly enforced to prevent corporations like Microsoft adobe google monsanto cargill tyson ibm pfizer etc from having monopoly control of markets.
Capitalism works great until corporations give money to NGO’s that then payoff lobbyists to push corporate interests
This is why we have extremely rich and extremely poor with a quickly disappearing middle class.