Love having Derrik on the show -- it's impossible to replace Nate Tice but Derrik is excellent in his own right and it's exciting to have someone consistent now that we can get to know! I do still feel like the listicle episodes *really* struggle with having two lists at the same time. I absolutely love the show, the quality could not be higher, and I also work as a producer on a (infinitely smaller) pod so I am generally in awe of / deeply jealous of how good the entire Athletic feed is from a production / content / schedule perspective. This team is probably creating the best football content on the internet period, to me. I do think it may just be better if there's either *1 list* that is prepped before the show that both the host and co-host agree on / pick at, or Robert's list is not revealed until the very end as a "segment recap" to compare and contrast. Honestly I walk away from all these episodes never really remembering "The Top 10 Offenses" because I mentally can't track having two different lists happen simultaneously, and I think the wonky way Chapters have to be written here a good canary in the coal mine for how confusing it can be. Love the show, excited about Derrik, and obviously Robert is the goat. Keep up the great work team!
Cowboys with Dak have been the #1 scoring offense 3 years straight! Yes they suck postseason, but there’s absolutely no reason to believe they won’t be top 5 again, let alone top 10. And there’s still plenty of bad defenses for them to feast on. Cowboys will be statistically awesome in the regular season and that’s a fact. Postseason and against good teams may be a different story, but that’s not what we’re talking about here
Dolphins.... I'm oddly finding more negative takes on the Dolphins as somewhat fun because I look forward to seeing the same kind of takes-backs as those that saw how good Tua is during the 2022 season. The 3rd yr for McD/Tua/O-Line/Skill guys and then much better depth of skill guys and lastly - the thing no-one (even most Dolphin fans) would have thought of last year is Tua being more mobile and back to the dual-threat QB he's always been. The only real issue is the O-Line inability to pass-block well - consistently - but with a mobile Tua, we'll see more out-of-structure throws when the 1st read isn't there and pressure is preventing Tua from moving to 3rd read.... we will see throw-aways, but a LOT more scrambling away from pressure and scramble-drill for the skill guys. People are going to be SOOO SHOCKED when they see it and think it's such a dramatic risk Tua is taking to be better and they'll be sooo worried about his health or some other narrative vs the reality of Tua just going back to his roots.
For the Packers, I I would like to add the element of a running game this season. We all love Aaron Jones, but he didn’t play for the majority of it. Josh Jacobs, Dillon, & Lloyd provide way more depth and a lot more stability to the position over the course of the season whether injuries occur or not.
@@FeinkinFreky Josh Jacob’s has had at least 230 carries every year of his career, except one. That was still 217 in 15 games 🙃 Did you just come on here and make shit up hoping no one would check your work? Aside from your blatant ignorance friend, even if that was the case it’s probably a good thing they have a 2nd & 3rd rd pick backing up Jacob‘s
@@MetawreckerHe’s also missed a few games in every season he’s played except 1. Just because they bell cowed him in LV doesn’t mean he hasn’t been banged up. You going off on that comment is pretty soft bud.
@Pk54320 also go watch the episode from the same podcast "6 teams that will exceed or fall under expectations". In this episode they said "Miami is a top 2 or 3 offense." And they also said "Miami offense could be so good they get the #1 seed in AFC and have homefield advantage." Based on your first comment I'm assuming that won't be enough evidence for you
I got ripped by my circle because when Collins was in the elite 11 and going to Mich I called him a future too 10 pick. The was so agile and quick for his size. So happy I was right in the end even if it took him a bit longer
if anything they are underrated. kupp was hurt all year and karen was hurt a portion of the year. their Oline is great. this offense could easily lead the league in scoring
I really think everyone is sleeping on the Eagles. I think they’re better than the Rams offense. Elite RB, Elite WR, Elite RT, underrated superstar QB, good rest of O line and great WR2 and TE( if Goedert can stay healthy) I also have no affiliation to the Eagles
I don’t think the issue is the talent. In fact it’s definitely not they have one of the best offensive groups in football. But their play calling last year was atrocious and it’s an unknown this year especially considering it’s a massive philosophy shift which could have a serious learning curve
@@nickmurray1780 yeah I think the end of last year was really rough for them but their offense was on fire to start the year and I think the addition of Kellen Moore and Saquon Barkley is more than enough to make up for the loss of Jason Kelce
Its funny how the Chiefs offense and defense is rated good but not great by the pundits this year. Yet the Chiefs simply win Super Bowls. It must mean these teams rated higher are poorly coached and of course those team maybe simply cannot play well under pressure. I hope people don't bet the grocery money on these teams.
LOL Im not an eagle fan… but you have embarrassed your entire show by not putting them in the top 5 offense never mind top 10. Embarrassing. They were 7 - 10 last year with the disaster
As is usual, this show underestimates Lamar & his Ravens. While hyping the QB's whose game they like & understand. One year of Stroud 8 games from Love & the perineal love no matter the interceptions or brain fart passes. I remember Robert M, 2018 draft, he was low on L.J & nothing has changed. Lamar will keep proving him & his ilk wrong. New OC, no Joe Burrows type receivers, usual doubts & MVP & AFC champ game & all I hear is criticism. WoW!
lamar wasn’t top 10 in any sort of passing categories. if you watch the games he badly misses receivers. he’s had plenty of weapons and coaching changes over the years now, so there are no excuses. he’s profoundly underwhelming
The Rams offense is going to be so fun to watch this year. Puka, Kupp, Kyren and Corum are going to pummel defenses
Love having Derrik on the show -- it's impossible to replace Nate Tice but Derrik is excellent in his own right and it's exciting to have someone consistent now that we can get to know! I do still feel like the listicle episodes *really* struggle with having two lists at the same time. I absolutely love the show, the quality could not be higher, and I also work as a producer on a (infinitely smaller) pod so I am generally in awe of / deeply jealous of how good the entire Athletic feed is from a production / content / schedule perspective. This team is probably creating the best football content on the internet period, to me.
I do think it may just be better if there's either *1 list* that is prepped before the show that both the host and co-host agree on / pick at, or Robert's list is not revealed until the very end as a "segment recap" to compare and contrast. Honestly I walk away from all these episodes never really remembering "The Top 10 Offenses" because I mentally can't track having two different lists happen simultaneously, and I think the wonky way Chapters have to be written here a good canary in the coal mine for how confusing it can be. Love the show, excited about Derrik, and obviously Robert is the goat. Keep up the great work team!
Thanks for the support!!
Cowboys with Dak have been the #1 scoring offense 3 years straight! Yes they suck postseason, but there’s absolutely no reason to believe they won’t be top 5 again, let alone top 10. And there’s still plenty of bad defenses for them to feast on. Cowboys will be statistically awesome in the regular season and that’s a fact. Postseason and against good teams may be a different story, but that’s not what we’re talking about here
Meant to post this to comments, not replies dang it
Dolphins.... I'm oddly finding more negative takes on the Dolphins as somewhat fun because I look forward to seeing the same kind of takes-backs as those that saw how good Tua is during the 2022 season. The 3rd yr for McD/Tua/O-Line/Skill guys and then much better depth of skill guys and lastly - the thing no-one (even most Dolphin fans) would have thought of last year is Tua being more mobile and back to the dual-threat QB he's always been.
The only real issue is the O-Line inability to pass-block well - consistently - but with a mobile Tua, we'll see more out-of-structure throws when the 1st read isn't there and pressure is preventing Tua from moving to 3rd read.... we will see throw-aways, but a LOT more scrambling away from pressure and scramble-drill for the skill guys. People are going to be SOOO SHOCKED when they see it and think it's such a dramatic risk Tua is taking to be better and they'll be sooo worried about his health or some other narrative vs the reality of Tua just going back to his roots.
For the Packers, I I would like to add the element of a running game this season. We all love Aaron Jones, but he didn’t play for the majority of it. Josh Jacobs, Dillon, & Lloyd provide way more depth and a lot more stability to the position over the course of the season whether injuries occur or not.
Josh Jacobs also has a injury problem
@@FeinkinFreky Josh Jacob’s has had at least 230 carries every year of his career, except one. That was still 217 in 15 games 🙃
Did you just come on here and make shit up hoping no one would check your work?
Aside from your blatant ignorance friend, even if that was the case it’s probably a good thing they have a 2nd & 3rd rd pick backing up Jacob‘s
@@Metawreckeru typed all that and none of it directly disproved what was said. Take ur panties out a bunch he’s a great player it wasn’t a diss
@@MetawreckerHe’s also missed a few games in every season he’s played except 1. Just because they bell cowed him in LV doesn’t mean he hasn’t been banged up. You going off on that comment is pretty soft bud.
Houston over Dolphins... i think you got a little ahead of yourselves on that one
Why is that? I mean I guess if u really value what their offense and epa looks like when they’re playing mid
@Pk54320 dolphins have better passing attack, better rushing attack, and a better offensive coach. Pretty cut and dry lol
@Pk54320 also go watch the episode from the same podcast "6 teams that will exceed or fall under expectations".
In this episode they said "Miami is a top 2 or 3 offense." And they also said "Miami offense could be so good they get the #1 seed in AFC and have homefield advantage."
Based on your first comment I'm assuming that won't be enough evidence for you
The Falcons are the team not mentioned at all in this video but could easily see finishing top 10 this year
I got ripped by my circle because when Collins was in the elite 11 and going to Mich I called him a future too 10 pick. The was so agile and quick for his size. So happy I was right in the end even if it took him a bit longer
Not even having the Falcons as an honorable mention is an interesting choice here.
Dolphins #1. Fins up!
As a Ravens fan I can accept tenth. I will say this Lamar doesn't get enough credit for protecting the O-line.
Awesome idea and I love your takes, but I am pretty sure Mina Kimes also did this style podcast
These guys know ball
I would guess 2-3 of these are going to be great comedy fodder in 3 months
Derrik what's your summoner name
i almost turned this off when they said they were gonna put seattle top 10 but leave philly out
I hope Derrick isn’t saying the rams o-line is better than the lions. The rams offense is good, but overrated.
if anything they are underrated. kupp was hurt all year and karen was hurt a portion of the year. their Oline is great. this offense could easily lead the league in scoring
Eagles not making the top-12 really brings into question if the hosts are taking hard drugs…
I really think everyone is sleeping on the Eagles. I think they’re better than the Rams offense. Elite RB, Elite WR, Elite RT, underrated superstar QB, good rest of O line and great WR2 and TE( if Goedert can stay healthy) I also have no affiliation to the Eagles
I don’t think the issue is the talent. In fact it’s definitely not they have one of the best offensive groups in football. But their play calling last year was atrocious and it’s an unknown this year especially considering it’s a massive philosophy shift which could have a serious learning curve
Can I have some of whatever you’re smoking?
@@nickmurray1780 yeah I think the end of last year was really rough for them but their offense was on fire to start the year and I think the addition of Kellen Moore and Saquon Barkley is more than enough to make up for the loss of Jason Kelce
@@nickmurray1780Better than the Rams? Dude. Do you even watch football?
@@Theodoredarlinga running back is not enough to make up for losing a top 5 all time center man. thats insane.
Its funny how the Chiefs offense and defense is rated good but not great by the pundits this year. Yet the Chiefs simply win Super Bowls. It must mean these teams rated higher are poorly coached and of course those team maybe simply cannot play well under pressure. I hope people don't bet the grocery money on these teams.
one of these guys talks way too much
This was weak.
LOL Im not an eagle fan… but you have embarrassed your entire show by not putting them in the top 5 offense never mind top 10. Embarrassing. They were 7 - 10 last year with the disaster
Eagles not in the top 10 is blasphemy
As is usual, this show underestimates Lamar & his Ravens. While hyping the QB's whose game they like & understand. One year of Stroud 8 games from Love & the perineal love no matter the interceptions or brain fart passes. I remember Robert M, 2018 draft, he was low on L.J & nothing has changed. Lamar will keep proving him & his ilk wrong. New OC, no Joe Burrows type receivers, usual doubts & MVP & AFC champ game & all I hear is criticism. WoW!
I wonder which team you're a fan of lol
lamar wasn’t top 10 in any sort of passing categories. if you watch the games he badly misses receivers. he’s had plenty of weapons and coaching changes over the years now, so there are no excuses. he’s profoundly underwhelming
Came to hear about the Eagles, saw their category and then your thoughts. Stopped watching
Flu Game comparison… really dude?
Robert's performance was better.