6 Designers create the same Logo… Who’s BEST?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 чер 2024
- Vote Your Favourite Design: bit.ly/3Xufezf
Start a Packaging Design Project on DesignBro here: bit.ly/3U8ZYVD & get 15% off with code: ABI15
Designers:
Natalie: / neige_summer
Georgia: / georgiab_design
Deborah: / debsthebusybee
How I can help you ⬇️
👉 Wow your clients with easy-to-customize templates
www.abiconnick.co.uk/templates
👉 Transform into a highly-skilled, confident logo designer
www.abiconnick.co.uk/pencil-t...
👉 Elevate your biz with these FREE resources
www.abiconnick.co.uk/free-res...
👉 Where I get all my mock-ups & fonts:
1.envato.market/abidesign
👉Free weekly tips, advice & exclusive videos:
www.abiconnick.co.uk/newsletter
----------------------------------------------------------------------
After more content from me? ⬇️
Instagram: / itsabiconnick
TikTok: / abiconnick
Disclaimer: some links in the descriptions of my videos may be affiliate links which means I receive a small commission. it is no cost to you to use the links, it is totally free.
How I can help you ⬇
👉 Wow your clients with easy-to-customize templates
www.abiconnick.co.uk/templates
👉 Transform into a highly-skilled, confident logo designer
www.abiconnick.co.uk/pencil-tool-course
👉 Elevate your biz with these FREE resources
www.abiconnick.co.uk/free-resources
👉 Where I get all my mock-ups & fonts:
1.envato.market/abidesign
👉Free weekly tips, advice & exclusive videos:
www.abiconnick.co.uk/newsletter
----------------------------------------------------------------------
After more content from me? ⬇
Instagram: instagram.com/itsabiconnick
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@abiconnick
Disclaimer: some links in the descriptions of my videos may be affiliate links which means I receive a small commission. it is no cost to you to use the links, it is totally free.
I love the first one. Calm, elegant, and sophisticated with a bit of whimsy.
Great points, the illustration is just so good!
I agree! And I also want to emphasize the versatility of the design. While a lot of my other favorites had a Japanese theme (due to the matcha green tea tablets) this may make it difficult to expand and sell other teas from other countries. With this design it would be really easy and cool to have different people drawn in that same style in different colors for the other teas!
But I think the type logo dont work with illustration if she make it mora consent with logo this will be best and this 2ed one also Amazon
They all give off different brand identities to me
Natalie's feels high-end that i would find in a department store
Matt's feels like an long-established tea farm/maker
Georgia's feels like a company that sells various items and this is their tea line
Alice's feels like a health & wellness brand with a notable influencer/sponsor
Deborah's feels like it would be in a collectors set (like bright cellars but tea)
Pedro's feels like a specialty chain like a david's tea
Personally I would go for Matt's for Pedro's if I were to see it in person~
I fell for Matt's. Gives me zen vibes. If I saw this at a supermarket, I would stop.stare and seriously consider buying it, for the beauty of its packaging.
So good isn’t it!! The attention to detail was great and something I’d pick up and admire!
Thank you! 🫶
@@DesignerMatt you did incredible I loved it!
Aww thanks @@aqui0 !! 😊
Deborah and Matt; eye-catching, vibrant, distinctive. Absolutely love it.
Couldn't agree more!
Natalie fkn knocked this oUT OF THE PARK. Everyone's was amazing, truly, but I would buy Natalie's to keep as decoration in my kitchen as well! Especially if it were in a tin canister
Yes!! Her illustration was so good, plus she went into real detail when explaining her design decisons and inspiration behind it all!
I like them all but Deborah's is my favorite. That illustration is * chef's kiss *. Makes me want a cup of tea, which is the whole point!
The thing is with Deborah's is she manages to tell a little story in the illustration (like she mentioned) and it's just so creative!
Love 1, 2, and 5, but if I was to choose a favorite, it has to be 1. Personally I think the first one achieved the relaxing concept all three of the designs are aiming for without having to rely on it being coveyed through a landscape/scenery. The choice of color to match with the flavor of the tea (in which case was matcha) could be expanded further too with the inclusion of various flavors - we can use blue and a different illustration in the same style for butterfly pea tea for example. This way we could have an array of different colors and illustrations for various flavors while keeping the packaging and brand theme the same throughout (its easier to identify a brand with a character illustration than a scenic landscape).
Natalies design was so unique and different, something I wouldn't have even thought about, which definitely grabbed my attention!! Think all of the entries nailed the brief in their own way, and it's great to see how each designer interprets it too! Thanks so much for your feedback!!
Exact same thoughts! I find the first to be the best for my tastes because it captured the relaxing and luxury theme of the product, especially because of the designer's limited use of colors.
Debroh!! I would buy this in a heart beat! I'm also designing a website right now for a friend who is starting a tea company - this gave me great inspo :)
This video had perfect timing, glad it could help! The scene was so great, plus the added day/night was so well executed!
I like hearing your critiques, Abi. It shows your high-level eye for design, and it's always constructive too. You definitely bring a unique quality to the design education space on UA-cam, where unlike many others who talk about 'good' design but don't actually present a lot of it in their own work, you really highlight your strong abi-lity (had to do it) to interpret a brief. I would love to see a video where you shared the process of creating your own merch. As a fellow designer, I feel that designing for ourselves can be the most difficult due to the endless amount of creative possibilities that flood our minds when given free rein. Keep up the great work, it's been nice to see you grow as a content creator since discovering the channel.
Thank you so much, really appreciate this feedback! So fun to see how a brief can be interpreted by different designers and the outcome of this! Ooh love this idea, I’ll add it to the list! Thanks again😎
Natalie and Deborah did amazing! I’d vote Natalie because it’s appealing, eye catching, and not often seen!
I really love Deborah's design. Although I wish that she had chosen more greenish colors (since its all about Matcha and "teal"). The blue makes the soft peachy orange stand out more, due to which Id automatically assume that its rather a peach-flavoured product.
1, 2, and 5 are my favourites.
1. Great use of art deco as an inspiration, especially the lettering.
2. I love the bold use gold and the pop of red.
3. Gorgeous use of gradation with blue going to orange. Clever ideas like the water from the kettle becoming a stream and the rising sun and setting moon. This one would probably look best from all angles.
Final thoughts: They all succeed in conveying calm & tranquility.
They're so aesthetically pleasing that I'd keep them after the tea was finished and use them as storage containers that I'd keep on display.
matt's and deborah's are definitely my fav... maybe more on matt's cause the gold paint did it for me. i think its brilliant
Matts with the Kanji is my absolute favorite, its so beatiful id buy it just for the packaging tbh
Matt and Deborah are my favorites. I would buy the product just for the pretty packaging.
Both of their designs were really great!! Both very strong concepts!
Natalie, Matt and Deborah hands down!
Wow! I absolutely loved how they all varied in the presentation as well, and took time to showcase the logo separately on a mockup or within a mood board. It's so inspiring to see the different takes on this challenge!
This was one of my favourite things too! Just shows how design is so subjective, but everyone's creativity can be appreciated! 😊
Deborah and Natalie, love the soothing vibe.
Im too late to vote, but my top 3 are:
3-Matt
2-Natalie
#1-Deborah!
oh wow you actually nailed the order they finished in!
Matt's design stands out to me. If I have to buy one of them, I would pick it up. It matches the concept of tea matcha which is a traditional feature. In addition, his logo is simple and dynamic. All the designed tea packages are very impressive.
Matt's one stands out the most to me :) it's elegant and contemporary yet has a traditional-zen feel. there are elements of the product's origin in the design and the colour scheme is aesthetically pleasing. my next preference is Natalie, which appears more vintage and luxurious. i love the graphics and colour scheme, it really speaks _Teal_
Thank you! 🫶
Matt actually ended up winning the competition! He did really well. And Natalie finished second, you obviously have good taste!
The second last one NAILED IT 🤩 love this challenge series
Yes! The illustrative scene is so well done 👏
all of them are so eye pleasing.
and yes, i feel like there's no better or best, but just selling to different kinds of target audiences.
Go & vote for your favourite design here: bit.ly/3Xufezf
And also don't forget to check the description to find the participants on social media!
Thanks for the reply!
What is Matt's instagram/contact info?
to be completely honest the winner of this is Matt. I know you said that the birds should be taken away but that in on itself adds layers to the design and personality! A design with subtle layers will always create a deeper connection to it's clients and audience
Matt's is great! The voting ends tonight and there is currently 0.1% between the top 2
I really appreciate this, thanks! 😊
for me the winner has to be natalie, absolutely superb design and i think she really nailed the brief, my runner up would be either deborah or pedro. just wanted to add that i submitted an entry, my design was the first of the little slideshow of designs before the video. seeing the designs here, can't be mad, still gotta keep improving haha.
Yeah Natalies and Deborahs illustrations are so so good! Thank you for enterting the comp, I really appreciate it! I will be reviewing some more of the designs in a video soon 😊
@@abiconnick ah, ty abi! love your work and always a pleasure to participate in these designs comps, always get to really explore and test my design skills.
My favorites are Nathalie and Deborah too for there beautiful illustrations, yes !
Such an amazing designs! I really like how everyone has their own creative flow and design decisions really make lots of sense... Great job for pointing and highlighting them Abi! Glad to see another video of yours
This is exactly what i love to see as well! Everyone interrupts the brief differently and has their own creative ideas! I appreciate the kind words 😊
In my opinion, if Alice designed a better name, he deserves this award because his design is wonderful classy and consistent with the content of the product.
Yes she did great
The only thing I like about hers is the title. The mesh looks like a cheap generic brand of tea
This is one of my favourite series on UA-cam. I love seeing how Pros interprete a brief
Love to here it, thanks! I hope to keep it going 😊
The thing about this design challenge is that you can take the exact same product and depending on which package you put it in, it automatically increases or decreases the value. If I saw Natalie’s and Alice’s designs on the shelf and they were the exact same product inside and both priced at $29.99, I’m choosing Natalie’s. It feels luxurious, it screams art deco and the excess of the 1920s. Alice’s logo design was adorable but the design says $9.99..if that makes sense. Same with Matt’s though, his feels imported and fancy but not overly high-end so I could see his being priced at $19.99. It just goes to show how packaging is such a psychological subject and packaging design alone can add so much value to the product itself.
Abi making these kind of videos gives us an opportunity to learn more get inspiration and your comments on the changes are really appreciable as they they give another level of insights into the already made designs. Hope to see more such videos and learn more ❤️
Thank you for your kind words, glad to hear you enjoyed the video 😊 Hopefully plenty more to come in the future!
I love the second ones. I can feel all sorts of emotions and impression when i look at the design be it tranquility, tea ceremony, matcha origin, luxury, sitting at yhe foot of a mountain, tea drinks with friends or family and lastly, the zen. I don't feel these much on other designs tho but all designs are amazing!
I agree with you about the birds. Although i don't want it to be removed i prefer if it's a bit bigger and less. By bigger i mean there's a perspective but not too big that it disturb the fonts. It's like the birds are heading to us as if welcoming us into their world. The position seems better to be a bit lower, not in the middle of the sun.
Anyway, good job on creating such eye catching design ✨
The second design actually won the comp! It's been done really well! Appreciate your comment and feedback 😊
They're all gorgeous! My personal favourite is the second one, but they're all absolutely amazing!
All look great but for me it has to be the 2nd one with red sun .. Loved the way you critiqued everything ...
I am graphic designer too and I liked the 4th one. As a costumer I first focus on what really remind me a green tea.."Green, nature, organic and fresh. 4th and 5th ones are more Green Tea to me. For 5th one I only change the color of the upper side. Not blue but maybe mint green.
Thanks for sharing, great points! 😊
My very first shot at packaging design and had a great experience. Thanks Abi and keep these design battles coming :)
Great outlook! Thank you for participating, plenty more challenges to come 😊
all of these are so incredibly good. great inspirations as well
I honestly love the commentary on this video and enjoyed the constrasting and creative packaging done by these talented designers!
Glad you enjoyed it!😊
1 & 5 are by far my favorites!
Matt and Deborah! I feel like I would 100% buy the product if I saw it on a supermarket's shelf even if I am not such a big fan of matcha tea. Their designs are eye catching but still subtle, dreamy, modern and give the idea of premium quality. Their design would make me still keep the box a long time after finishing the tea inside. Nevertheless, amazing work by all designers!
Matt actually ended up winning the comp, with Natalie 2nd and Deborah 3rd! Like you said all designers did well, the standard was high! 😊
🙌🙌🙌
i used to design products for high end fashion and perfumes in Japan and France and Deborah’s design really stood out!
I loved Deborah's so much! I would not even hesitate for a minute to buy it. From the minimal leaf in A of teal to the little heart at the back it looks so pretty!!
Yes me too! Deborah's was one of my favourites😊
1 was my favorite but oh boy I would love to have the scene from 5 as print it was gorgeous 🤩
Natalie, because I’m a huge fan of the Art Deco and Art Nouveau movement ❤
Well deserved 👏 I’m envious of these designs 😂
They all did great!! So fun to see how each designer interprets the brief 😎!!!
Matt's, hands down. 🔥🔥🔥
🙌🙌🙌
Natalie is the best with a close second being debroh!
They both have such high level illustrations!
I LOVE the last one!! With the first one as runner up.
I am falling love those designs in this video and I also love you abi.
Just found your channel, great vids - thank you!
I was waiting for this for so long but i didnt got choosen but its okay i had so much fun designing teal and i will try better next time 💕
Apart from that these all people have done a great job i have voted for my favorite 💕
Don't be disheartened by it, I had over 500 people enter and all work was of high quality! Plenty more competitions coming in the future 😊 Thank you for your positivity!
Would combine: The graphic and green color of Natalie & the placement of information from Georgia with some of the nicer font designs like Matts, Alice or Deborahs. To add the golden brushstroke to it like Matt did could be a nice eye-catcher. If on the other side of the logo a nice quote would be placed, this would definetly be a box to keep and maybe with other designs also to collect. Although I prefer the vibe of Natalie with the complete design Matt did the best job.
Thank you 😁
First of all I would like to say thank you Abi because you are the first reason for all of this amazing design works and you are build the true designers community!
To be honest When I see all of the designs I really heat my design beside that I rally like Matt design and he did it well. From this competition I learn a lot of things and I really exited for the up coming design challenge...
Aww appreciate the kindness!! Such a great community 🧡 Matt did an incredible job and definitely would be something I’d pick up! Glad this video has helped and I can’t wait for the next!!!
All of these are so amazing! For me personally, it's between Natalie and Matt. Absolutely nailed the simplicity and elegance. I specifically am a fan of what they each did with the type. The other designs are really great, but they were mostly too busy for a packaging design.
Great points! Matt actually came first with Natalie just behind in second!
Hi Abi!! It would be great if you could do a vid on colors when it comes to printing. Especially 2 color, 4 color etc, things to consider when it comes to printing things, as it's a big part of the graphic designer role :/
Great artwork on show here! Pedro is definitely my fave with georgia as a runner up as these are the only designs in my opinion that would actually be seen on a shop shelf. While the other entries are beautiful and show great artwork, with only a tiny logo on top there is nothing telling the consumer that this is a tea brand and it is not reflective of the layout of its biggest competitors. This is a branding competition and great artwork doesn’t always necessarily mean great brand.
I completely agree! The artwork is definitely beautiful and draws the eye of the consumer however it doesn’t work to base the entirety of a brand on some artwork. For example, if this brand wanted to expand into different flavours of tea, pedros could easily be edited by just changing the colours / shapes while the product would still be recognisable under the brand of teal. However, the artwork based brands would be very difficult to expand as new artwork could be created but how would consumers recognise that the different products are from the same brand with such little attention on the logo / brand assets. If you go into a store and look on the shelves the emphasis of product packaging is placed on a) the logo and b) information on what the product is. It should be clear at first glance what the product is to the consumer. For example, based on how these products are stocked on shelves, Natalies design would likely be stored backwards as the back contains the typical information that is seen on the front of most tea products. Therefore the beautiful artwork would not even be seen by customers and so the selling point of this packaging / brand has been lost and all of the work that Natalie put in would be pointless. Overall I think a lot of these were chosen because of how pretty or aesthetic they are but little attention has gone into the actual branding and hence these packaging designs would not work in a real life scenario.
I agree! If this was an artwork competition I get why these designs would be picked but as a branding competition I don’t think these designs should have ranked as high, as the branding is basically non existent. If I quote abi’s recent Instagram post on the secret sauce behind crafting a timeless brand, she states “strategy-led design that is structures around any future business plans”. In terms of the designs chosen, I think most of them lacked the strategy-led design and were instead more artwork-led. Although pretty to look at, this kind of branding does not work in the industry as when “teal” need to bring out new products they will need to rebrand as the packaging is not replicable for their new products. This wastes a lot of money and time and therefore is not great strategy-led branding and I think as a brand designer, a lot more emphasis should have been put on overall branding when judging the best designs.
This was one of the best design bro videos I’ve seen! Great work everyone! 😍👏🏼
Really appreciate it, thank you 😊
these all look so great but im supprised i havent seen anyone mention that the T in the first design makes it look like it says Peal
Didn't notice that until I read your comment 😅
I thought that as well!
I just commented about this! Lol finally found someone thinking the same thing 😂
Damn these are so good! Well done everyone!
1 or 5 are amazing !!
4 to me was the best in terms of illustration and I think the logo has so much potential .Logo wise I liked 1 and 5.
Matt's work is insanely cool! Love it love it love it! Very elegant and strong at the same time!
Yeah it is! All the elements used work together really well. I love the gold, can look overdone sometimes but he’s used it really well!
🤗🤗🤗
I Like Georgia ( and Matts( design most, just with a little bit more pleasing color instead of grey. It is very different and giving minimalism vibes
If I were to buy this, I'll choose the first one! So my vote goes to Natalie. 👏🏽
The most elegant and sophisticated looking of the designs was the very first by Natalie. However, all six of the designs of the logo text "Teal" could have benefited from a bit more effort. In some instances they were too small on the package (Georgia) and in others too thin (Deborah) making them difficult to notice on a busy shelf or read at a glance. The last package design by Pedro was simply too busy to have a "fresh, elegant" tone.
I am SO out of my element!
They did all their design by hand too, apparently (maybe not fonts but that tree branch one was sped up and looked to be done entirely by hand for "Teal") and whoa!
I like the Japanese one best, with the T (plant bud) tied. That valley one is pretty too.
Mind-blowing 🤯 to see my fellow designers I also participated and didn't make it but I have learned a lot from this project ♥️
So glad to hear! This is what it's all about 😊 More to come in the new year!
I love your personality, you are such a bubbly girl! Keep up the good work
Ah thank you! Really appreciate it 😊
1 and 2 were amazing!! I also liked 5! :D
i love deborah's design!!!
Natalie and Deborah; They have stolen my heart, passionate about fine and elegant design. But it is true that Deborah connects me a little to the perfume and, perhaps it looks too elegant, but I understand that to communicate the premium of the product. I think Natalie got it 100%💚
¡Saludos desde España!
1,2 and 6! 2 being the best
I love Deborah’s. It’s so beautiful.
I had a great time working on this design challenge. Although I was not chosen, I learned a lot! Hopefully, this type of challenge will be a regular thing in the future! 🎉🥂
First, thank you for participating, I really appreciate it! There were over 500 entries all of high standard! And yes this is just the first of many 😊
sorry but its just criminal what natalie did, her design its SO GOOD that send shivers down my spine, omg...
Yes!! She did such a great job!
SECOND LAST ONE!! OMG!! IT'S EXTRAORDINARY
Yes this is so good! I was honestly blown away but the high standard of every design, I can't give anything away but I will say the voting in very very close between the top 3!
These are all fantastic! I would have a hard time choosing if these designs were presented to me.
They all did great! Matt ended up winning the comp but only by 1%
love natalie’s and deborah’s!
Love the first, the second and the forth one.
Feel like the quality of all was so high! The voting was so close, only 1% between first and second (Matt and Natalie)
I love Pedro's!
Deborah and Natalie are just, chef kiss
Yes! Both are great! Natalie ended up winning the ipad!
I feel like ive seen the other designs before. Theyre a bit trendy looking. Natalie's illustration took it to another level. Its the most elegant for me plus points on the depth of research. Though i think all of the logos could be improved. Theyre not as strong as i would like + most of them are in thin weights which would be more difficult capturing in actual printing. Theyre all good but my bet is Natalie on this one.
1&2!
i clicked on this for deborah’s design. i’m so in love
Matt’s is totally my style. Super elegant ❤
He ended up being the winner! Was a greta design!
I’m Japanese and i can tell those two are Japan inspired design but also I’m 100% for sure it’s designed by non-Japanese by looking at the design👀
Hands down my favourite youtuber!!
Thank you 💛💛
3 and 6 are my favorites ❤️ but the first design is the one I would choose.
The first one actually won!
@@abiconnick yep, it fits really well for a Tea brand 😎👍
Deborah's packaging is amazing and unique
natalie and deborah have the best ones imo
These are all amazing! Also had so much fun participating in this design battle!
They are! I was blown away by the quality of the submission! P.s I'm doing a video soon reviewing some of the other designs that were submitted 😊 p.p.s thank you for support me and participating in the challenge, just the first of many!
@@abiconnick Can't wait for the video! Loved it, It was my first time attempting to design a product and love your videos!
HEY! I would love to see how you create stickers ❤💛
These are some amazing creatives and designs, even if mine wasn't here, it was an honor going against all these people! I am waiting for the next battle and I am ready for it 😎😎
The standard of work is so high, I'm honestly so impressed by everyone who submitted their work! Thank you for the support and taking part 😊😊
2,4,5 😍🤩
I mean DEBORAH!!! I loooove! Natalie as well, so beautiful! Some of the other ones I didn’t like at all to be honest, like a couple geometric ones didnt feel very premium
at 8:25, I like the one in the top-middle and the bottom-right.
I like the first one
Hey! I was thinking something.. Have you ever thought of redesigning Carmex? Recently, I 've been using Carmex a lot and I thought (as a consumer( that logo and packaging of the lip balm could be better... Then I' ve started practicing and I've tried to come up with some idea by myself and I thought that it would be interesting to see you trying to redesign it... I think that brand could be seen from two POVs and I would love to see your try💛
ooo great idea! I'll make a note of it 😊
deborah was breathtaking
Th illustrative scene and how she did day and night was great!!