I like the first one or the 4th one. The problem with the last one is that although it's very original, you don't really understand what the product is about unless you start reading the label, I like to see what the sorbet looks like before buying so having a preview image of the product that is inside would be better in my opinion.
I really love the Design from HarryGraphics. And the T with the little branch is genius - Not only does it say "Treeze" but also "Freeze" just with a mirrored F. This is smart and I think it fits quite well and this detail is not too small to recognize it.
I agree! I thought I was crazy at first because I thought the first one nailed it. The little branch on the 'T' is a nice touch, but could be reworked to look a bit more organic (instead of a straight line).
The reason why Miguel's logo works is... because it was a direct rip-off of the logo from a Portuguese food and beverage company called Compal. The original logo/branding of the company is really good. Maybe so good that he thought it was a good idea to steal it.
I see what you mean, there are a lot of similarities there, I don't think it was intentional but that's certainly something I've experienced before where a design I've been working on turns out to already have been done by someone else! And it's a reminder to always get fresh eyes on your work!
Pedro's logo is the best one, but Ana's or Hans's packagings are cleaner and feel more premium to me. Although Pedro's packaging is more original, it looks a little crowded. It's very hard to get that we are talking about Ice cream. And the color pallet doesn't fit well either. It's more like what we see on a graphic designer portfolio, than on shelves.
before watching the video .the thumbnail made me think that i really want to open the first design and eat whatever inside it... eventhough the last is more professional but the typographical of the first one i still think is better...
Pedro killed it. Looks fruity & tropical. Miguel and Harry have very creative logos. Hans has great packaging, however, the trunk going between the EE really doesn’t do it for me and the fruit in the snowflake are a bit small. Anna should’ve put the snowflake hands on the T in white vs the red background.. too much red.
Nailed it about the tree between the EEs. However, funny enough, for me that oddity is what makes me remember the logo. You cant shake it out of your mind that something is wrong, so you keep thinking about the logo. Great for making something stick in people's minds. Lol.
The one on number 3 with the tree logo. Great logo design for the most part but not only have they used to many fonts but also the wrong type of fonts there’s no boldness there for a consumer to see what the brand is once they’re drawn in. I like the colours but there’s too much space left over, everything’s far too small and illegible. I’ve been in the packaging industry for 10 years and genuinely I’ve made these mistakes. If you’re wanting to get into packaging design, always know that you yourself are a consumer. You’ve just got to tap into the “why do I like this brand” mentality, You’ll figure it out!
Miguel's logo is actually a rip of from a portuguese brand called Compal. The leef position matches perfectly. I cant say for sure, but if you were to find out his location hed be from Portugal. Miguel is a tradicionally portuguese name
With respect, the first one had the wonderful fat, snow⛄️like font. The second one, the font you love, I feel that the letters are overlapping and/or half hidden by the slanted burgundy colour, causing the reader to do more work. The third one has a nice, but “summery” logo, and the ice cream shot does not look appetizing. The fourth one is restrained, but works. The last one is the best.
i loved the first and last one actually! however, although the last one is my favourite, i don't think they illustrate quite well the idea of the tree like the first one... but maybe that's not such a bad thing! i like how it illustrates earth itself
For me Pedro's looks very tropical, warm. I'm not sure I'd want that for sorbet. I feel like the weakness of Hans' is that you can't scale it. You lose the fruits and snowflake in the tree if you shrink it. Harry's really fun, I can't really see it as premium. And yeah that little branch on the T just doesn't work. The packaging is really nice though Miguel's packaging looks premium it's just not as pretty as the others. But the logo works well. I really like Anna's logo type. The snowflake kind of forms a tree with the T. The packaging is really nice too. I'd pick her's
@@punusername3445 To me the tones make the product itself feel warm. The others use a lot of white which in comparison makes them look cool (in the temperature sense) to me.
Miguel's logo is actually a rip of from a portuguese brand called Compal. The leef position matches perfectly. I cant say for sure, but if you were to find out his location hed be from Portugal. Miguel is a tradicionally portuguese name
I don’t ever really comment on UA-cam videos, but I’m always looking forward to your videos! I would like to see some videos of you designing something starting from sketch to screen. Maybe a live stream? 👀
Come on designers, its 2022 - accessibility is not only for the web. Your choice of light fonts on pastel colours will not be legible for many people. Keep a decent contrast.
I honestly really dig HarryGraphics' design the most. It has that retro feel with the color scheme and font type, but modern look with the little branch on the T, leaves in the spaces of the lowercase E's, a very 3D-looking scoop of sorbet, and implied tree trunk just below the sorbet. Makes it look classy, which is the best way to describe luxury but on a down-to-earth level, in my opinion. Also, a classy style is ageless, so this design would last a really long time, with perhaps minimal changes made to match the times.
No, the reason for you not being a designer anymore is because you didn't charge enough for your skills. The reason I'm a designer is because I'm able to charge whatever I deem reasonable for the scope of work.
I liked pedro's the most! Maybe it's because I love something that's creative and I'd base what I buy to what I see as "pretty" or catching to my eye especially if it's in a shelf of different stacked products in a supermarket. Though, I would love to see maybe a picture of the actual product somewhere on the tub. But overall, I think they were all executed great but if these products were at the supermarket, Pedro's would've definitely caught my attention first.
The 4th one is so beautiful!! Very elegant and luxurious while also looking simple and inviting. 5th one is too busy for my eyes, there's something about that square in the middle that just doesn't blend in for me.
I love them all but final two No.3 Miguel & No. 5 Pedro. For me I go for Pedro, Logo✅, Colors ✅. Looks like too many things happening but aside that awesomeness.
I liked the 4th one. My problem with the last one was that it doesn’t really feel premium. Rather like the own brand of the supermarket. I love the presentation tho, it’s pretty professional and neat.
I'm not a designer myself, but... The third one seems to have the most interesting logo, though I wonder if it might be a bit busy with as many leaves as it has. The packaging for number five is, in my opinion, the best. It might be a touch busy, but it's very clean and is interesting to the eye. The packaging for one and two are nice, but the first one probably has a bit too much text in it and it makes it hard to know where to focus. Though the eye does initially centre on the logo, so that's a good point. The second one, other than the cherries and the logo I don't really like it. The blend of the text is interesting, but the font will probably be hard to read from further away. The thing I like about number four is that it's not overly busy. There's effective use of neutral space and I also like how the logo merges with the packaging, though the logo itself is a bit busy. EDIT: After reading PuppeteerNG's comment, I have to agree that it's a bit difficult to tell what's being sold with the packaging of number five. However, since it's going to be sold in the frozen dessert section, it's not difficult to tell what you're buying. But PuppeteerNG still makes a very good and valid point.
Hi will, thanks for your woderful and usefull videos,would you please create a video that compare logos depends on 10 factors that logos should have and score them 1 to 10. Thanks a lot
i would like miguel's best, its unique, its clean, its clear what the product is, my sencond best is Hans' the last one you dont have any idea of what the product is theres no direct indication of what the product is, and the logo alone looks like too main stream and "overseen" looks like i already seen it many times the color pallet and the packaging is beautiful but the only thing that speaks to "ice cream" there is the shape of the packaging that is kinda almost the same for every brand of ice cream/sorbet out there
My vote is probably for Miguel because yes it is playful and minimalistic but that's what luxury brands are like you have also that dark red which it's more like a Royal red
I know the commission was to design a “logo” and they are well done. However on the packaging not a single one of the, addressed the most important thing, representing the energy saving technology used to freeze the sorbet. Really missed the mark on these.
I would grab the first one The colour palette is minimal and refreshing Theres a picture of the product that appears in a playful way The little sticky is negotiable and removeble And pink gives an airy feeling as opposed to the others that are heavy and sorbet is a light dessert
I like the sticky branch but it needs work. Can use optical scaling according to use/size. If done well the T-with-branch by itself would be very recognizable.
I Liked Hans' design the most. I thought it looked premium and really made you feel like it was a sorbet or ice cream brand while still showing that it has some sort of ecological, and nature elements to it. I thought the packaging looked good and I think it really hit the line between minimalism and realism good for me. Why I didn't believe in Pedro's Design as much is just because I didn't get the feeling of it being some sort of sorbet or ice cream. Felt more like a juice, or fruity drink for me.
Anna diaz did it best in my opinion, idk about you will but I don't view it as vintage tbh, i felt the premium luxurious aspect in the whole packaging especially the font used in California blend and the color palette. I feel like the organic fruit sorbet circle adds a premium touch too to the playful logo which works perfectly in my opinion for a premium sorbet that is also ecological, i mean let's face it it's very hard to mix playfulness, premium and ecological into one logo but i feel like she managed to do so and still make it feel like a sorbet logo. Finally i absolutely love tue cherry leaves coming out of the ball of sorbet and i would love to see that in different flavours it gives a sense of uniqueness to each package which is always appreciated in consumable brands. For me she s the winner and the one who fit the brief the most
I think Pedro, nailed it! Great packaging and fun logo! The part that really sent me over, was the subtext! My experience is at bat companies love when their slogan fits in well. It is something that a lot of companies work hard to come up with, so again, in my experience, that would have won out! I really liked Anna’s as well!
Another idea! When you’re doing videos like this .. could you give the designers the brief and have them come up with something and you come up with something as well ? I think it would be cool to actually see your take on the briefs that you have given :)
Everyone did such an amazing job. Looks like quality work! but I LOVE the second to last one from Hans with the tree/snow flake/with all the different types of fruit hanging on the tree. It's absolutely the best!
I really love Hans' design, the 4th one. I love the simplicity and elegance. The emblem in the logo is fantastic! It really pulls all the elements from the brief together. I like the limited color palette. It would be really easy to modify the palette for different flavors, which gives it more versatility. The 5th design just doesn't work for me. It's too busy with the wider color palette, and the design elements are too generic. It makes me think vegan cosmetics or hair care, not sorbet.
Personally, I judge a logo by the impression it gives to make me remember it. Hans does that for me. Every time I have thought about these logos, the one that I remember first and more is that one. The way the Treeze is written looks like freeze and the snowflake tree thingy as well as the different fruits on the tree stamps the uniqueness of the product in my mind. Even though the way the tree stands dead centre, dividing the word into two, looks awkward, it makes the impression last more. I am sure anytime I remember Treeze, Han's logo will come to mind.
I m in love with Anna DS's design, after that Miguel's is not bad either. I can not understand most of the people's obsession with Miguels. Ann's design tells me a story about both company and product, I also loved the cherry image ,
The last one definitely stands out from the rest, which would be a reason for me to choose it. It's always very interesting and inspiring to see what different designers come up with and I think they all did a great job.
Hey quick question! I'm a college student who wants to be a graphic designer but I unfortunately majored in Business Administration. What do you recommend I do?
Self-study maybe? I've been a high school teacher for years and also decided to become a graphic designer, but doing the full study now is not an option. I'm still in the process of switching careers, but I'm already working on projects for family/friends of friends to learn and practice, which helps a lot. I've bought a lot of books about it, take courses, watch tutorials and practice all kinds of stuff. Maybe other designers would give different advice, but this is what I'm doing. :-) Good luck! 🍀
@@willpatersondesign That's really neat!! What learned business administration skills transferred over/helped you become a successful graphic designer? :D
I really like the first design by harry graphics. Coz its minimal, the typography is amazing, and the color itself represents sweet vibe which is very important. Coz color psychology really effects every human mind.
I watched with the sound off and just looked to see which package would get a second look from me. Hans, Harry, Anna are the only ones that looked pleasing to me. Dark gray on a fun food isn't my thing and I just don't love Pedro's color combo.
Thanks for watching! Click the link to vote for your favourite design here: bit.ly/3MRd2fE 🍧
I like the first one or the 4th one. The problem with the last one is that although it's very original, you don't really understand what the product is about unless you start reading the label, I like to see what the sorbet looks like before buying so having a preview image of the product that is inside would be better in my opinion.
Kinda looks like it some Japanese instant ramen ngl. It's pretty though.
The 3rd and 4th were pretty similar imo
The last one yells "Christmas!" at me.
I really love the Design from HarryGraphics. And the T with the little branch is genius - Not only does it say "Treeze" but also "Freeze" just with a mirrored F. This is smart and I think it fits quite well and this detail is not too small to recognize it.
Same thought about the ''Freeze'' note! Its my favourite.
Well spotted!
@@willpatersondesign Well sprouted you mean. Lol.
I agree! I thought I was crazy at first because I thought the first one nailed it. The little branch on the 'T' is a nice touch, but could be reworked to look a bit more organic (instead of a straight line).
The reason why Miguel's logo works is... because it was a direct rip-off of the logo from a Portuguese food and beverage company called Compal. The original logo/branding of the company is really good. Maybe so good that he thought it was a good idea to steal it.
I was going to comment that exactly. Those leafs are basically copy/paste.
Yep, I was gonna say the same 🇵🇹🇵🇹
I see what you mean, there are a lot of similarities there, I don't think it was intentional but that's certainly something I've experienced before where a design I've been working on turns out to already have been done by someone else! And it's a reminder to always get fresh eyes on your work!
@@willpatersondesign I mean, if you look at the leaves you'll see they're exactly the same 🤡
@@catarinamsil They line up exactly in photoshop 🙊
I really enjoyed working on this project and I'm really grateful for your feedback Will.
Thanks 👍
I'm glad you enjoyed! Well done again! :D
Good job, Pedro!! You had some tough competition, but I gave you 5 stars
Very well done! 🌸
youre so cool pedro
Inspiring work buddy ❤
Pedro's logo is the best one, but Ana's or Hans's packagings are cleaner and feel more premium to me.
Although Pedro's packaging is more original, it looks a little crowded. It's very hard to get that we are talking about Ice cream.
And the color pallet doesn't fit well either. It's more like what we see on a graphic designer portfolio, than on shelves.
Great feedback!
before watching the video .the thumbnail made me think that i really want to open the first design and eat whatever inside it... eventhough the last is more professional but the typographical of the first one i still think is better...
Every logos are unique and i love it.. Hard to pick a winner.
Pedro killed it. Looks fruity & tropical. Miguel and Harry have very creative logos. Hans has great packaging, however, the trunk going between the EE really doesn’t do it for me and the fruit in the snowflake are a bit small. Anna should’ve put the snowflake hands on the T in white vs the red background.. too much red.
Nailed it about the tree between the EEs. However, funny enough, for me that oddity is what makes me remember the logo. You cant shake it out of your mind that something is wrong, so you keep thinking about the logo. Great for making something stick in people's minds. Lol.
Hans one was definitely the best
I think Hans did the best. It looks good and the packaging is clean
The one on number 3 with the tree logo. Great logo design for the most part but not only have they used to many fonts but also the wrong type of fonts there’s no boldness there for a consumer to see what the brand is once they’re drawn in. I like the colours but there’s too much space left over, everything’s far too small and illegible.
I’ve been in the packaging industry for 10 years and genuinely I’ve made these mistakes. If you’re wanting to get into packaging design, always know that you yourself are a consumer. You’ve just got to tap into the “why do I like this brand” mentality, You’ll figure it out!
That's great feedback, thanks for sharing!
Miguel's logo is actually a rip of from a portuguese brand called Compal. The leef position matches perfectly. I cant say for sure, but if you were to find out his location hed be from Portugal. Miguel is a tradicionally portuguese name
With respect, the first one had the wonderful fat, snow⛄️like font. The second one, the font you love, I feel that the letters are overlapping and/or half hidden by the slanted burgundy colour, causing the reader to do more work. The third one has a nice, but “summery” logo, and the ice cream shot does not look appetizing. The fourth one is restrained, but works. The last one is the best.
I really like the one from Pedro but the first design makes me want sorbet specifically. So as an artist the 4th but as a consumer, the first.
Pedro, for me, make me remember of Ragazzo, a Brazilian fast food! lol
i loved the first and last one actually! however, although the last one is my favourite, i don't think they illustrate quite well the idea of the tree like the first one... but maybe that's not such a bad thing! i like how it illustrates earth itself
Before the last one that is for best me colors and simple easy to read
For me Pedro's looks very tropical, warm. I'm not sure I'd want that for sorbet.
I feel like the weakness of Hans' is that you can't scale it. You lose the fruits and snowflake in the tree if you shrink it.
Harry's really fun, I can't really see it as premium. And yeah that little branch on the T just doesn't work. The packaging is really nice though
Miguel's packaging looks premium it's just not as pretty as the others. But the logo works well.
I really like Anna's logo type. The snowflake kind of forms a tree with the T. The packaging is really nice too. I'd pick her's
You usually eat ice cream on warm days, no?
@@punusername3445 To me the tones make the product itself feel warm. The others use a lot of white which in comparison makes them look cool (in the temperature sense) to me.
Miguel's logo is actually a rip of from a portuguese brand called Compal. The leef position matches perfectly. I cant say for sure, but if you were to find out his location hed be from Portugal. Miguel is a tradicionally portuguese name
I don’t ever really comment on UA-cam videos, but I’m always looking forward to your videos! I would like to see some videos of you designing something starting from sketch to screen. Maybe a live stream? 👀
I did used to do livestreams like this, would be nice to bring it back!
@@willpatersondesign absolutely
Come on designers, its 2022 - accessibility is not only for the web. Your choice of light fonts on pastel colours will not be legible for many people. Keep a decent contrast.
Pedro work remember me of the Ragazzo, a popular fast food company in Brazil, the logo and the colors are really similar to the new visual identity!
I love everything about the 2nd one, it's perfect
Best series on this channel!
Thanks! :D
I honestly really dig HarryGraphics' design the most. It has that retro feel with the color scheme and font type, but modern look with the little branch on the T, leaves in the spaces of the lowercase E's, a very 3D-looking scoop of sorbet, and implied tree trunk just below the sorbet. Makes it look classy, which is the best way to describe luxury but on a down-to-earth level, in my opinion. Also, a classy style is ageless, so this design would last a really long time, with perhaps minimal changes made to match the times.
These designs are insane
I think the 2nd one looks pretty premium maybe its just the burgundy vibes.
the fact that you only paid $2000 for all this work is the reason im not a graphic designer anymore
No, the reason for you not being a designer anymore is because you didn't charge enough for your skills. The reason I'm a designer is because I'm able to charge whatever I deem reasonable for the scope of work.
@@willpatersondesign and you believe the $2000 you paid for this work to be reasonable?
I liked pedro's the most! Maybe it's because I love something that's creative and I'd base what I buy to what I see as "pretty" or catching to my eye especially if it's in a shelf of different stacked products in a supermarket. Though, I would love to see maybe a picture of the actual product somewhere on the tub. But overall, I think they were all executed great but if these products were at the supermarket, Pedro's would've definitely caught my attention first.
The 4th one is so beautiful!! Very elegant and luxurious while also looking simple and inviting. 5th one is too busy for my eyes, there's something about that square in the middle that just doesn't blend in for me.
I'm so dumb. The snowflake reference is intentional😭
I really liked Anna DS packaging, I wish you had linked the designers socials, so we can follow more of their works
We don't have their socials as it's done through the DB platform :)
I love them all but final two No.3 Miguel & No. 5 Pedro. For me I go for Pedro, Logo✅, Colors ✅. Looks like too many things happening but aside that awesomeness.
Where to get this mockup?
I liked the 4th one. My problem with the last one was that it doesn’t really feel premium. Rather like the own brand of the supermarket.
I love the presentation tho, it’s pretty professional and neat.
I'm not a designer myself, but...
The third one seems to have the most interesting logo, though I wonder if it might be a bit busy with as many leaves as it has.
The packaging for number five is, in my opinion, the best. It might be a touch busy, but it's very clean and is interesting to the eye.
The packaging for one and two are nice, but the first one probably has a bit too much text in it and it makes it hard to know where to focus. Though the eye does initially centre on the logo, so that's a good point. The second one, other than the cherries and the logo I don't really like it. The blend of the text is interesting, but the font will probably be hard to read from further away.
The thing I like about number four is that it's not overly busy. There's effective use of neutral space and I also like how the logo merges with the packaging, though the logo itself is a bit busy.
EDIT: After reading PuppeteerNG's comment, I have to agree that it's a bit difficult to tell what's being sold with the packaging of number five. However, since it's going to be sold in the frozen dessert section, it's not difficult to tell what you're buying. But PuppeteerNG still makes a very good and valid point.
I like the last one the best, Hans' one comes in second, for me.
Vote for pedro logo. Because the logo is simple attractive and scalable. And the packing and mockups he used is also great .
If you vote for him all of your wildest dreams will come through.
I like the last one. It's unique and just like it's element I am completely full lol.
I prefer the last one
Miguel’s logo is something really memorable and unique. Don’t know why nobody is talking about it.
because it's a direct copy of a Portuguese brand called Compal, as many others are saying
I like the first one. Very cool.
ngl i would buy Hans's packaging in a heartbeat if i saw it in the grocery store, idk what it is about it
My favorite is the first one. That’s the one I’d buy.
@2:14 Something can't be "most unique". It is either unique or it is not.
Hi will, thanks for your woderful and usefull videos,would you please create a video that compare logos depends on 10 factors that logos should have and score them 1 to 10. Thanks a lot
I also like Hans clean and simple packaging that also shows that it’s sorbet. Pedro’s doesn’t show that it’s sorbet. Idk maybe that’s just me.
i would like miguel's best, its unique, its clean, its clear what the product is, my sencond best is Hans'
the last one you dont have any idea of what the product is
theres no direct indication of what the product is, and the logo alone looks like too main stream and "overseen"
looks like i already seen it many times
the color pallet and the packaging is beautiful but the only thing that speaks to "ice cream" there is the shape of the packaging that is kinda almost the same for every brand of ice cream/sorbet out there
just saw that miguel stole the logo idea from "Compal", what a shame but i guess itsmore comom that we would expect right?
Pedro or Anna for sure
It got better and better. Loved all designs, but Hans has my vote
I liked Anna's and Pedro's the most!
The 4th is the cleanest design.
2:55 nice voice crack dude lol
I think a good design is important to attract the attention of buyers
Does anyone know how they made the examples on an actual ice cream bin? Was it photoshop?
Any logo+web design contest in mind? Love your video's and as a logo/web designer I feel a bit left out haha!
I think a new competition on the Reddit would be a good idea, what do you think? :)
@@willpatersondesign I think its a great idea! I'm in! :)
I like the first one. The pink.
My vote is probably for Miguel because yes it is playful and minimalistic but that's what luxury brands are like you have also that dark red which it's more like a Royal red
As a customer i will pick hans' design in supermarket. It looks very delicious!!
Beanie.
Harry Ate no discussion
Hans was best. If i see the last one i will never know that it is sorbet. The package didnt help me to figure out.
5th one reminds me of sainaburys products haha 😂
Pedro's looked the most tasty based of the package of all of them Id buy that one if I saw them side by side on the shelf
Perhaps you'd like to check your subtitles in spanish. When you refer to yourself they use the femenine gender!
I like the first and the second.
i would've liked to see you re-design these logos and fixing their "errors" :(
I know the commission was to design a “logo” and they are well done. However on the packaging not a single one of the, addressed the most important thing, representing the energy saving technology used to freeze the sorbet. Really missed the mark on these.
All of these logos are very similar... And no one is premium.
HarryGraphique 🤝
I would grab the first one
The colour palette is minimal and refreshing
Theres a picture of the product that appears in a playful way
The little sticky is negotiable and removeble
And pink gives an airy feeling as opposed to the others that are heavy and sorbet is a light dessert
I like the sticky branch but it needs work. Can use optical scaling according to use/size. If done well the T-with-branch by itself would be very recognizable.
I Liked Hans' design the most. I thought it looked premium and really made you feel like it was a sorbet or ice cream brand while still showing that it has some sort of ecological, and nature elements to it. I thought the packaging looked good and I think it really hit the line between minimalism and realism good for me. Why I didn't believe in Pedro's Design as much is just because I didn't get the feeling of it being some sort of sorbet or ice cream. Felt more like a juice, or fruity drink for me.
I agree, I feel the same way about them
Sameee
Anna diaz did it best in my opinion, idk about you will but I don't view it as vintage tbh, i felt the premium luxurious aspect in the whole packaging especially the font used in California blend and the color palette.
I feel like the organic fruit sorbet circle adds a premium touch too to the playful logo which works perfectly in my opinion for a premium sorbet that is also ecological, i mean let's face it it's very hard to mix playfulness, premium and ecological into one logo but i feel like she managed to do so and still make it feel like a sorbet logo. Finally i absolutely love tue cherry leaves coming out of the ball of sorbet and i would love to see that in different flavours it gives a sense of uniqueness to each package which is always appreciated in consumable brands.
For me she s the winner and the one who fit the brief the most
MIGUEL'S LOGO IS JUST COMPAL'S LOGO WHICH IS A PORTUGUESE COMPANY BTW
I think Pedro, nailed it! Great packaging and fun logo! The part that really sent me over, was the subtext! My experience is at bat companies love when their slogan fits in well. It is something that a lot of companies work hard to come up with, so again, in my experience, that would have won out! I really liked Anna’s as well!
gotta agree but i might be bias cause i have same name as the logo designer lol
I agree! All are really good but I like their logo the most 😸
I think that Pedros design is too crowded...
Another idea! When you’re doing videos like this .. could you give the designers the brief and have them come up with something and you come up with something as well ? I think it would be cool to actually see your take on the briefs that you have given :)
Everyone did such an amazing job. Looks like quality work! but I LOVE the second to last one from Hans with the tree/snow flake/with all the different types of fruit hanging on the tree. It's absolutely the best!
I really love Hans' design, the 4th one. I love the simplicity and elegance. The emblem in the logo is fantastic! It really pulls all the elements from the brief together. I like the limited color palette. It would be really easy to modify the palette for different flavors, which gives it more versatility. The 5th design just doesn't work for me. It's too busy with the wider color palette, and the design elements are too generic. It makes me think vegan cosmetics or hair care, not sorbet.
hey would be nice to see all designs at the end to compare them on one screen
Will keep that in mind for next time, thanks for the suggestion!
I actually expected it. Makes it easier to compare and contrast.
The Miguel one is a rip off of Compal, a Portuguese juice company
Personally, I judge a logo by the impression it gives to make me remember it. Hans does that for me. Every time I have thought about these logos, the one that I remember first and more is that one. The way the Treeze is written looks like freeze and the snowflake tree thingy as well as the different fruits on the tree stamps the uniqueness of the product in my mind. Even though the way the tree stands dead centre, dividing the word into two, looks awkward, it makes the impression last more. I am sure anytime I remember Treeze, Han's logo will come to mind.
For me i find Harry's design is more friendly and playful for such brand, Also i can see that Treeze feels like "Freeze" when you look at that logo.
Anna wins this one, hands down!
Every Logo was unique at there places !! Great work done by all of them✌
I m in love with Anna DS's design, after that Miguel's is not bad either. I can not understand most of the people's obsession with Miguels. Ann's design tells me a story about both company and product, I also loved the cherry image ,
I love them all, but Pedro gets my vote! I’m not usually into modular logos but it works really well 😻
The last one definitely stands out from the rest, which would be a reason for me to choose it. It's always very interesting and inspiring to see what different designers come up with and I think they all did a great job.
7 minutes in and I’m ready to combine 3’s logo with 2’s package design.
Hey quick question! I'm a college student who wants to be a graphic designer but I unfortunately majored in Business Administration. What do you recommend I do?
Self-study maybe? I've been a high school teacher for years and also decided to become a graphic designer, but doing the full study now is not an option. I'm still in the process of switching careers, but I'm already working on projects for family/friends of friends to learn and practice, which helps a lot. I've bought a lot of books about it, take courses, watch tutorials and practice all kinds of stuff. Maybe other designers would give different advice, but this is what I'm doing. :-) Good luck! 🍀
@@tulp_graphics Thanks for the advice!!
I also did business administration! College in the UK is different to the US though - and it didn't stop me from doing graphic design :)
@@willpatersondesign awesome!:D
@@willpatersondesign That's really neat!! What learned business administration skills transferred over/helped you become a successful graphic designer? :D
Hiiiii
All artists were amazing with there work and their logos had their own Unique story✌🏻❤️
I like the first one I can see the product and the color and how fun it is.
Vote for Pedro 🤓
the third one is very much like the "compal" logo, a juice company from portugal
Exato!! Ainda por cima Miguel é um nome super comum em Portugal. A posição da parte de cima das folhas é basicamente igual às da Compal
I really like the first design by harry graphics. Coz its minimal, the typography is amazing, and the color itself represents sweet vibe which is very important. Coz color psychology really effects every human mind.
I have to say Anna's was my favourite - I can see myself reaching for it if I saw it in a shop!
I watched with the sound off and just looked to see which package would get a second look from me. Hans, Harry, Anna are the only ones that looked pleasing to me. Dark gray on a fun food isn't my thing and I just don't love Pedro's color combo.
I love the design number 6 🤯
Which one? There are only 5 designers!
Me too, is definitely the best one!
Anna DS is by far my favorite. Looks very professional and polished. The rest are good but look more like student projects
Last one: I stared putting the letters together, but they froze in the process.
Search for "compal logo" and compare it to miguel's... ups