US Army Combat Veteran Reacts to Woke US Army Ad vs Russian & Chinese Ads
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 чер 2021
- Why does each country have such different perspectives on advertising and recruitment? I break down what each country might be thinking in who they are recruiting and why!
Original Video is Here: • Video
0:38 China's Commercial
8:21 Russia's Commercial
13:34 America's Commercial
Be sure to like and subscribe for more videos!
********
Merch! bit.ly/3slNSKZ
**********
Second Channel: bit.ly/3dO4tld
**********
Instagram: bit.ly/2OGwMtw
*******
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
*Disclaimers: all opinions are my own, sponsors are acknowledged. Not financial advice, for entertainment purposes only.
China: look at all our military gear
Russia: fight the enemy within
USA: it all started in California...
To be honest the United States doesn’t need to show force I mean look at the size of its military and it’s gear. It’s leagues ahead of others.
@@lordj3793 And look who they want to recruit... An army need quality manpower too or all of the high tech equipments are nothing just tin cans.
@@krizy1819 the gears are trying to find their own gender
*look at my two moms...
USA i growing up in California and i got two moms now i became patriot cos Real Patriots fuck up other by Patriots defence system. No you dont send we but we buy
China: "We're united!"
Russia: "We're strong!"
America: "We're gay!"
Hahahahahaha..
Duuuude, you are awesome!
What a ducking chad dude
Lmao
Well, this is pretty intimidating. I would not want to be captured by such army ...
Hahahah SO TRUE!!!! 😂
We all sleep peacefully because corporal Emma as two moms.
She could have 10 moms for all I care, if she can work the Patriot battery well, I'm all for it.
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview he mean there is nothing in ad about Emma skills on using Patriot missle system was told.
😂😂
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview we don't be told if she served well, we hear she has 2 mom and she is lesbian and it all.
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview I think the point is that she is a representation stereotype in an ad that fuses such politics with the dovetail politics of woke empathy. Not that we want our soldiers to be mindless killing machines, but an ad without so much animation, representation cliche characters, and emotional sap would portray a better balanced picture of a powerful/assertive unified in uniform fighting force worth joining rather than this motley crew of representational soft emotional try hards they seek to recruit.
I am not impressed with the direction our military is going in while China builds an aggressive masculine spirited fighting force and while we by contrast make artistic representation piece ads and have Gen Mark A Milley who defended Critical theory in military education and told China he would warn them in advance if president Trump is about to attack.
When I saw the Russian ad, I want to fight for the Russian army
When I saw the Chinese ad, I want to fight for the Chinese army
When I saw the American ad, I want to fight for the Russian or Chinese army
It seems everyone forgot that the Marines exists and I like their Ads way better I would definitely fight with them, hell at this point I like the National Guards Ads better than the Army fuck em
When I see the American ad, I see a person. A person that is not trying to intimidate me. Maybe a person who will not even obey a criminal order.
The Russian ad also refers to a person, but... maybe climb Everest instead of killing people to prove yourself?
The Chinese ad is standard: join the collective because we're strong.
100 like and still as value as the first
I was going to say something along the same lines dead soul
Exactly so I am not understanding this dude's take on things.
What bothers me most about the US ad, is that doesn't communicate a message of patriotism, pride in protecting our country or respect for our military. All I can hear Emma say is: "Me Me Me Me Me!"
Thats the thing with rainbow merchants. They only care about themselves
Thank god Poland is standing against this shit
@@adeptusundolios2482 ong 💀💀
Sjw feminist propaganda and woke culture is cancer
I mean, in a way, I'm glad they suck so hard, but imagine how good their numbers would be, if it was like:
"This country is on the brink of disaster. There is civil and global strife in the future. India and China are on the precipice of all-out war... By the time you need to defend the people you love, you will all be dead. Join us now and prevent it."
They'd get an effective fighting force, though it'd be harder to turn them on us. So there's two possibilities: bunch of useless woke losers trying and miserably failing to oppress the U.S., or useful, strong-charactered individuals who won't as easily turn on their own.
Chinese army: "We are strong!"
Russian army: "We are strong and fearless!"
US Army: "Our moms have strapons!"
LOL ;)
🤣🤣🤣
Russian army today: "Fuck, they gave Ukraine strapons. we're fucked."
it's illegal to be this funny
@@hakimbenzaid7904 Illegally possible in America, but legally in China, and Russia.
I have nothing against internal relations among homos, BUT the division of parents into 1st and 2nd parents is nothing more than another discrimination against a certain person. That's the illegal , divide people into 1 and 2.
Emma: Two moms
Dimitri: 6 feet, avenging his father's death, 2 balls, built like a tank
You start this comment as some entrance in porn XD
I am an American, but I found the Russian and Chinese ads more uniting, more patriotic.
That sjw feminist propaganda is pure cringe.
American ad: "I had an upper class privileged upbringing."
Russian ad: "Without an enemy, you can't have a battle, and without a battle, you can't have a victory."
And what about the Chinese ad
@@BWITHYURIchong chong
Разве балет и скрипка это дорого?
China: “We are unbeatable in frontal attacks”
Russia: “We are unbeatable from the air”
USA: “Please give it to me hard from behind”
As a strategical historian, your comment brings me great pain. It litterly makes zero sense, Russia's only great military advantage is it's infantry and that's where it ends. Its Air Force and Navy cant compete with America's even on a small level. Like Russia, China has a big infantry but also a devolped Navy and Air Force. Which makes it a more likely bigger opponent to America. Russia got away with this advantage in WW2 against Germany but the whole strength in numbers thing is destroyed because war has changed since then. The Cuban missile crisis happened for a reason. America couldn't give less of a shit about its futile advantage and focused on the fact ballistic missiles capable of mass destruction is the easiest way to win against a whole country. Try listening in class next time bescause the amount of historical faults you committed in a short time frame would make a extremist political member blush.
Sorry I just get so angry sometimes, maybe you should take this as a way to actually know your positive about something before commenting.
Hell yeah dont worry you are all protected Corporal emma has 2 moms and the talibans 5 wifes
Emma's moms got a few strap-ons for counter attack.
@@aviatorfox4789 I think he meant that the Russian ad featured paratroopers, not that they had a killer air force, but obviously the setup for China and Russia was only necessary to make the main point about the US military having the wrong priorities.
Russia and China: Look how strong we are come join us.
USA: This is a female soldier with gay parents! really makes u want to join right?
НЕТ :)
@@shadow-uv9es нет, Я не буду
@@Moskal91 и я нет Товарищ
The translation of the Chinese ad:
Zhao Liang (name of soldier)
"Here!"
Bai Jiang Tao (name of soldier)
"Here!"
We are used to answering with "Here!"
Wang Jie (name of soldier)
"Here!"
"Transfer and mobilization ceremony now begins!"
An answer of "Here!", is a promise
"Comrade corps commander! Preparation of garrison transfer is complete!"
"Move out!"
"Yes!"
An answer of "Here!", is a form of parting
An answer of "Here!", is a revolution
"All combat assets in air, sea and land has revised and finished their strategic planning"
An answer of "Here!", is an assault
We use our lives, to shoulder our responsibility
We use our loyalty, to forge a "Great Wall"
The journey to reformation and to strengthen the army is glorious
President Xi: "History tells us, being contemporary, is the great path for the evolution of the people's army, the might of the people's army, originates from revolution and evolution, the victory of the people's army, comes from revolution and evolution"
"Here!"
“Here!"
"Here!"
When the motherland calls. I, will be here!
"If war strikes and duty calls! I will be back!"
An answer of "Here!", and I will always be "Here"
@The Gloved Rando Which countries are they attacking?
@@WilliamPrietoM Afghanistan iraq syria lybia Argentina cuba
@@alloha7374 Ahh then he means USA, i thought he was talking about China.
@@WilliamPrietoM
China isn't at war with any country. There are however, flashpoints around their borders that they stand vigilant against. The province of Xinjiang in Western China borders Afghanistan. The borders there are very porous and extremist elements related to ISIS have bombed and conducted terror attacks in the province, killing many Han and Uyghur Chinese in the past decades. Regardless of the garbage Western Media accuses the Chinese of there, most of it easily debunked, China's operations there are defensive.
There is also the South China Seas, where China can be considered aggressive to a certain degree. China has taken up positions in the South China Seas, which is contested with many South East Asian countries like Vietnam, Malaysia and the Philippines. However, even though it's considered a "flashpoint" zone, the odds of actual military conflict there is extremely low. The Association of South East Asian Nations and China have adopted a non-confrontational diplomatic impasse as the status quo there and frankly, the only time shit heats up over there is when Australian and American media blows the issue up, causing ASEAN diplomats great frustration to keep things in the region cool.
And of course, there's Taiwan. Taiwan is considered a part of China, and should Taiwan declare official independence, China will not allow it.
看过多个英译版，你翻译的最好👍
China: We have Fire Power
Russia: We have Discipline
USA: We have 2 mom.
China does not have conscription. They have young men there competing to get into military and have plenty of candidates to choose from.
Us:Emma was raised by two moms Russian:Vladimir Putin was raised by two bears.
To ALL, regarding Russian add. This commercial is for Russian military in general and you could see it on the main Russian TV channels.
The main message is not in the images but in words! see translation below
It is the FIRST day of your new life!
What's happened yesterday, doesn't matters today.
Who you was before nobody cares.
What is really matter now is, who you are today.
What do you know about yourself, what are you capable for?
Probably some questions will remain unanswered, will you be able to sleep well?
To know yourself, to know the limits of your capabilities. Ignore the limits, are you ready to brake your limits?
Here, you will become stronger every day.
It is your decision to prove something to yourself. Your commander here to help to identify your enemy, cause without an enemy there's no fight and without fight no victory!
But in fact the main enemy is you, you from yesterday.
Your goal is to hunt down the enemy, catch him up, surpass and become better than him and come back home victorious!
To MHGR, please by respectful to your viewers and avoid to talk about geopolitics like Russian's or Chinese's geopolitical ambitions cause you don't have a clue but assumptions based on the narratives of western propaganda main stream media only.
Don't be T.M. with her "highly likely".
We are ordinary people are very friendly until some of us starts to listening the politicians and defend someone's else interests.
China is not compulsory now, Chinese soldiers are also the volunteer soldiers . But, Chinese government still has the power to conscript
Ironically, military service in the “democratic” Taiwan is compulsory.
Indian army is world's largest volunterr army.
I ruined your 69 likes
@@avkk2314 that is because the Indian army is a stable and easy to access job for a large population of low income young males.
China doesnt have conscription, korea has mandatory service, Thailand has a raffle system for conscription.
correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't mandatory service and conscription mean the same thing
@@dingleberry4234 mandatory service is like what they have in Israel, Everyone serves a set number of years no exceptions, after that they go back to school or work etc. Conscription in Thailand is like picking the shortest straw, all men has 50/50 chance of giving up their lives and serve in the military indefinitely...
China has conscription power ofc, just like most other countries. There's a short period of 2 weeks of mandatory service for people reaching college age, but usually that's it, most people don't get conscripted for longer than that.
@@user-wb7ez9ud4p thats not conscription, thats 2 weeks of "basic training" for highschool students. They are not apart of the military during those 2 weeks, it's like hockey camp lol.
@@seanyang128 It's legally and officially considered conscription, they get actual training from actual drill sergeants. Also the students get to fire real guns. It's a totally different thing from military training for middle and high school students.
China: One party state
Russia: Suppression of political opponents
USA: 2 parties with overall same ideologies, backed by big corporations, thus crushing the chances of any third party to stand a chance, even to win a single seat, let alone a horribly flawed electoral system.
This is the part of the reaction were you really lose me. Chinese and Russian politics arent perfect, but the US cant claim the moral highground either.
The guy served the military here. They can say mean things about it but can never outright shit on it cause it would sorta invalidate any reason he joined and for others who want to join
Plenty of independent politicians out there. Of course the US has the moral high ground
@alexanderchenf1 and how many times these independents get even close to entering congress, especially without corporate backing? Next to zero I believe. The electoral system and lobbying has made sure that no other party or independent candinate will have a chance, unless of course he is willing to sell his soul to the elite % of the country
@@alexanderchenf1 "Независимых" от чего? От любых рычагов реальной власти?
As an insider (kinda) I would say that 80% of what you are saying about Russian PMC are mostly hearsay completely out of touch with reality. Especially regarding Ukraine and motorcycle clubs.
I mean, obviously official sources on Wagner group are few, but there is certainly a consensus that the quality of personnel has dropped off a ton in recent years
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview I would say that demand is a lot less than supply in terms of recruitment to Wagner. A lot of experienced guys who served in People's Militia (aka Donbass separatists) try to get Russian citizenship in order to serve there, for example.
Yup. Totally agree. I was cringing the entire time he talked about it. Thank you for pointing it out!
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview I just recommend you to try more sources. I am professional interpreter so I am blessed with ability to read in multiple languages - you would be surprised how different information about the same events could be represented from country to country.
yeah, part about motorcylce gangs - is my favourite. That was something!)
I understand the appeal to 19 yr olds but that makes us look like a joke to other nations. Thank God for us marines and us air force SF commercials
It doesn't matter what other nations think
@@Ho11ow661 It does matter what other nations think, it does matter how US is a joke now with it’s military., and the World know that …. So the World will be very soon ready to destroy us… after all… our military is weaker now and will become worse… Ahhh!!… and WOKE!!! 🤮
Bro 19-24, years old they love Michael Bay style recruitment ad, not some cartoony SJW woke ad
@@Ho11ow661 you don't care others think about you, you become weaker weaker and weaker than you will lost you glory
@@whalecom0 If I dont care what other think, I neither would get weaker or care about glory.
How did he manage to keep a straight face while watching the US ad?
He blue too.
Simply put it this way.
China- “We fight and defend our country together”
Russia- “We fight and defend our country together”
US- “Look what I did, look at me, look what I do, my calling, my life, I’M SPECIAL.”
The Russian ad is not about VDV. It's about RF's armed forces in general
Your information on China's military recruitment is not wrong, but out of date.
The initial stages of the Chinese PLA were definitely conscription based, and they've never repealed the law so technically the Beijing Government can enforce a military draft immediately without need to pass a new motion or law.
However, the modern PLA is mostly a volunteer force by pure virtue of the number of volunteer sign ups outweighing the need to conscript. This has been true since at least the 1970s and 80s. During the start of their modernization reforms, China actually reduced the number of soldiers necessary for annual recruitment to focus on modernization of their force rather than to bolster the size of their army.
Today, the main reason we're seeing China produce military recruitment ads is because their modernization reforms have been mostly successful. With their military budget pegged at a fixed percentage of their national GDP, they're now able to scale up.
Allow me to share a little something about the Chinese culture in relation to the military. Typically, poor people sign up for military service because of one simple reason. The military promises that their soldiers will be paid a living wage, and will be well fed. So rural communities that cannot support a larger population tend to have their young men sign up, and they may eventually return home with a pension to support their parents and elders. However, with China's increasing wealth, there are just less poor people signing up for military service because now they have the freedom and wealth to pursue other endeavors. And so the Chinese are now appealing to patriotism for their recruitment in order to avoid the need to conscript.
Oh man I'd like your videos. But you did not get the whole idea behind the Russian ad. This ad was all about, that guy in the ad he was supposed to to fight against himself in past. The whole idea he's begun new life and the previous life is Left behind. And now he's supposed to fight the against his weakness and things like that. He needs to fight himself to become a new man in his new life in army. It was actually all about that.
Ah okay. I wasn't able to get even YT's auto translate to work. That is a helpful perspective, but I think my core thesis still holds up, that it is leaning into VDV service as hard, challenging, and dangerous.
@@AnonD38 ye, the marines got it right decades ago with "we're looking for a few good men."
China don't have compulsory military service, they got enough people just by recruiting. China birth rate about 10 millions babies a year, if half of them are male, imagine the size of the armies if mandatory service is implied.
Nato mass produce millitary equipments while China mass produce manpower.
VDV needs recruitment ad because it is overwhelmingly voluntary service,
just note of mine, I always find it weird how Americans always fully miss the point of conscription, and fact that countries like Israel, South Korea, Finland, Switzerland, Austria etc. use conscription
It keeps the population ready to defend themselves.
@@itstriplem2069 My country uses conscription too, although the time served is lowered constantly.Yap, the main reason is that these armies are defensive in nature, why waste money everyday on something you dont use to make money?In the case of war you mobilize and suddenly you got a huge army that dont need training.Israel proved that many times.
conscription is a defensive measure and the US is such a fuckin' bully since it abandoned the monroe doctrine they cannot fathom that war sometimes is fought on the defense and not just on a far away land done striking goat herders...
Russian casualties is what won ww2 mate
Future USA military be like: oh no I got a splinter🥺😣😢😭
"I need a medic! I got a bruise on my knee!"
Haha young no want rasicm so weak haha. 😐
@@loganm8220 It's fine that they showcased equality in who serves, but they tried so HARD to patronize the youth that even the youth is mocking them. And if this is the actual state of the military, I do believe the comment above will come to pass.
@@Tom-H1 Yeah that's true. I feel like younger people aren't weaker, we just grew up in a world were we're taught to question everything with all the information available to us, so we're more critical of our government, so people think we're 'unpatriotic'. This ad was cringe tho 😂
@@loganm8220 I agree, was pretty cringe.
USA taking notes from Thai military 😂😂😂
The Thai military is pretty badass. Check out their recon training. It's wild
@@archeoraptorfarcensis2366 I have seen that too😏
@@archeoraptorfarcensis2366 which one
Ironically many ppl in Thailand become a trans to run from the military since ur force to do it
@@thun2262 at this point i belive most "women" in Thailand actually have a sausage in their pants
"russian opposition sitting in Gulag"
Man, Gulag stop existing more than half a century ago. But Guantanamo still exist till today. I recommend you use more sources of information that only CNN.
Exactly 🤣🤣🤣 Hollywood really messed up there mind
Whatever you say, Ivan. :P
@@SarcasticFinn saying that soviets still has Gulag is the same as saying that finns still has concentration camps.
19:30 I question that data heavily. I fit into that age bracket and dont know one person my age who hasn't found the US advert ridiculous.
Funnily enough, one of my closer nit group of friends are all very much your typical "fight for justice" kinda group and even they laughed at this advert.
Not to mention most people my age don't share that same mindset. They're very much a minority in the grand scheme.
I get what you're saying - its trying to sell to that group, but you have two glaring issues:
A. The Target market is very much self-aware and disagree with the disingenuous advert knowing full well what a militaries values are.
B. It's trying to appeal to a smaller bracket of individuals.
It's the exact same as all the adverts that try to appeal to gamers. There is not a sole out there playing call of duty modern warfare that falls for those kinda adverts calling for the aid gamers. Jesus Christ, I sore one advert recently (US again) titling a chef as "The Replenisher"....
I mean c'mon really?
The things he was saying about the “one party system” and “government approved opinions” seems to apply to the United States as well these days.....leftists ruin everything
@@dionysius4353 Ouch.... Knew there was gonna be a comment like this eventually.
@@dionysius4353 you are part of the problem
the missing subs makes the russian and (idk i havnt seen the chinese one before) a lot less impactful
the russian one was really inspiring
the people that couldnt find their place (of wich there are many these days) could find a place in the military as long as they where willing to give it their all every day
give it their all to be better then yesterday
they might not get highly educated people with that, but they will get people willing to educate themself
not sure america will get that kind of adaptability from their recruits
Well said comrade
I mean that’s a good point you gotta respect soldiers who may not be the best but have the heart to try
found the text back
This... is the first day of your new life.
What was yesterday means nothing now.
Who you were before, no-one cares now.
What's important now is-who you'll be today.
What do you know about yourself?
What are you capable of?
Questions may remain unanswered, but can you sleep soundly later on?
Knowing yourself, knowing the limit of your possibilities...
To hell with limits.
Are you ready to break yourself?
Every day, pain hardens you here.
It was you who decided to prove something to yourself.
The commander is here only for you to see an enemy in him, because without the enemy, there is no battle. Because without battle, there is no victory.
But in reality, the main enemy is you.
The you of yesterday.
Your task is to track the enemy down, catch up to him, outperform him, become better than him, and return the victor.
Because tomorrow is the first day of your new life.
can say a lot about russia, but they know how to give a motivating speech
Especially sonce a lot of that ahe group, especially college kids seem to have a desire to "cancel" any opinion that differs from their own, and when faced with facts that challenge and even destroy what groupthink consensus they have formed, they just sit there screaming not letting the one spitting facts, be heard.
Devolve into screaming mobs shouting obscenities and calling anyone that disagrees with then "Fascist" "Bigot" or any other PC yrigger word they can come up with.
Id rather have an army of 35 year old farts fighting for our country, than a bunch of narrowminded, inpressionabkex and entitled brats.
No, not all lf them are like thatz but the last two years have shown me a lot about the demographic the army is targeting...and it is concerning.
When you try to one up your friend who climbed the everest by joining the army 🤣
I'm sorry but I think you might be a bit misinformed about Ukraine's military and the casualties the russians took in the war🤷♂️
China:Our victory come from innovations and reforms.
Russia:Are you ready to break yourself?
Emma Malonelord has a bachelor's degree from UC Davis and yet is a mere corporal? Give me a break! And what has her two lesbian moms - a theme repeated again and again -- got to do with complex Patriot systems?
My question exactly. She is a corporal because there are minimum time in grade requirements to make sergeant. They need even smart soldiers to take time to learn the army way of doing things before they get expected to lead soldiers.
You'd be surprised. There were a few guys in my unit that enlisted. I was out of shape for ocs, so I went enlisted and physically developed. When so joined the USMC I was overweight. I could only do 4 pull ups, 60 crunches, and ran a 3 mile at 26 min. After boot camp, I was able to do 16 pulls, 100 crunches, and ran 3 miles at 21 min. At comm school, I was able to get it up to 18 pullups, 100 crunches, and 19:59.
Chinese ad:
“Soldier 1”
“Ready”
“Soldier 2”
“Ready”
We are used to answering “ready”.
“Soldier 3”
“Ready”
“The mobilization conference commences now”
A “ready” is a promise.
“Sarge, defensive mobilization is complete, please give instruction”
“Let’s go”
“Understood”
A “ready” is a sacrifice.
A “ready” is a remoulding.
“All battle groups, naval, aerial and ground, have completed and refined edition of battle plans.
A “ready” is a charge.
We spend our lives fulfilling our duties.
We use our loyalty to build a Great Wall;
to reform our military; to secure a bright road ahead
Xi: History tells us that revolution and innovation is how the people’s military has developed and advanced. The power of our military comes from revolution and innovation. The victories of our military come from revolution and innovation.
“Ready”
“Ready”
“Ready”
Narrator:
Motherland calls. I answer.
Soldiers:
If there be fight, I shall answer to it.
Narrator:
One call of “ready”, one life of “ready”.
Obviously the language is a lot more poetic in the video, as I translated everything literally.
A thing to note: Soldier 3, Wang Jie, jumped on a f*cking bag of explosives to save 12 people, which is why all his comrades answered ready.
UA-cam is afraid of Chinese army music.
China: "We have many soldiers!" ._.
Russia: "We have many tanks!" o_o
America: "We have many..., - Woke/gay/unicorns and rainbows!..." O_O
Amazing, so in America, if you have 2 moms, you are mostly welcome in the army? Good for the LGBT👍👍👍
Chinese Army: RESPECT✊
Russian army: POWER💪
US Army: VAGINA🏳️🌈
Hi China and Russia, it's the UK here. We're looking for some new allies
The Taliban actually got the courage and confidence after watching the US ad... Emma and her two mom are spreading courage to everyone 👍...
Wonderful wow so inspiring “it doesn’t take a genius”
Ha Ha Ha!, That was funny.
lol
"the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself."
-Sun Tzu
Meanwhile, USA military ads*
America is actually destroying itself from inside
@@Dusthandle999 China will soon follow
What i fully feel is missing from the overview you made on the American commercial is how it doesnt say anything about teamwork, it doesnt promote unity, it only inspires a very target group and no one else
To a veteran i can understand, yeah id want someone qualified behind an advanced weapons system that requires such technical skill, in a military that relies on volunteers and where teamwork is practically heart and soul elsewhere it doesnt give any of that, in a place where you go to be a part of something all this screams is individuality
A person can be an individual without being a narcissistic piece of garbo. The ad screams narcissism.
The Chinese ads appeals to patriotism. The Russian ads appeals to masculinity. American ads used to appeal to both of these aspects in the past.
America in 80's :- Rambo
America now :- Rainbow 🤪😂
rainbow is good. The world could be safer.
@@aredtomato8957 is it getting safer 😂
@@JehadiHellTransportAgency the lgbt forces are being more aggressive to the straight forces
Look at it, it's a cartoon, understanding that a cartoon is more appealing to children. That everything it talks about is what GenZ is into. It doesn't matter what an adult brain thinks because at the adult age you either did or you didn't enlist and if you didn't, chances are low that you will enlisted so doing all the the boom boom macho stuff isn't actually a good idea. Actually this is perhaps the most serious push at recruitment the military has ever done and it's aimed a very large net at the most easily manipulated group out there (underage children) probably all the way from. Elementary school and up.
Interesting take. I can see it doing that too.
Dude I don't even think most children would like this crap
@@killertigergaming6762 i'd hope not, but its been shown in the field of psychology that children are really suckers for cartoons
I could do so much better though with animation and a budget...
For example many Millennials and Generation Z are gamers right? I would have it tie in with a game ad where the tag line is "Its not a game anymore"
I mean image Halo for example the ad starts off with a Warthog running and gunning aliens left and right at full speed with its turret blazing. Then the shot changes to a Humvee doing the same thing IRL. Then the scene switches to a Scorpion tank smashing through a barricade then to a M1 Abrams crashing through a middle eastern compound wall.
Or go full aggressive and have the ad go "You want to kill shit? Good. Were waiting..."
There was so many ways they could have gone...
@@happyjohn354 that's honestly a terrible, you haven't really put any thought into the actual recruitment numbers that need to be achieved by this have you. Do you know how many times I've died in the Halo campaign and how many of those times were not even epic. All you going to end up with is a commercial that looks really cool and almost nobody coming to join the army because they don't want to die like any video game but at least the commercial your army commercial was was super cool, but no way am I ever doing halo in real life, I'd be terrified being subjected to that would be horrible.
You can't really evaluate the Russian ad without a translation. It says: "your biggest enemy is your yesterday's self. You need to catch up to the enemy, be better than him, and defeat him, because tomorrow is the first day of your new life."
"HEY, I'M EMMA, AND IF YOU RUSSIAN BULLY KEEP HARASSING ME, I'M GOING TO TELL MY TWO MOMS"...
The American should not worry about the Russian or the Chinese.. they should be worry about Emma aka feminist operating patriot 😂😂😂
Just my own two cents in the matter, but for the US ad, we could talk about the insane heredity rate for US military enlistment; it's almost to the point where it's a family business. So it's possible they swapped target audiences in the hopes of varying the people they attract.
That's a good point. And if they bring people in now, they might end up recruiting generations down the line
too bad the new target audience can't procreate
I never took that into account. Good observation
I dont think the current 19 year old who identifies himself as bigenderfluid does nothing but posts tik toks while living with their parents and call themselves zxe/xze as pronouns would be the best target audience at all to send in the Frontline
@@MilitaryHistoryGearReview Thats a huge misrepresentation of the vision of the ad lol. The simple idea is white men display strength, they are showing other forms of strength and attacking patriarchy of strength.
Dear Veteran, You know nothing about Wagner group. You can learn more in Grey Zone you tube channel. Best wishes from Russia.
Killers and murderers. Doubtful combat value. Two companies of Wagner were destroyed in Syria by US forces to the point - the legs and arms of those "soldiers of fortune" were driven to russia by several planes.
@@sergeontheloose ulol
sparta would be laughing its ass off if a spartan warrior saw the ridiculous usa ad, the military breeds warriors not emmas with 2 moms
Girl with two Mom
I join in for equality
Yeah mate, now how about you tell me how's your day in training camp?
Afghan child seeing his village getting bombed by Emma with two moms: 🗿
I'm afraid the us ad will actually cause people to leave the army... I'd be ashamed of serving in such institution, much less be ready to die for it!
A shittily animated MCU-like cartoon would be a stupid reason to leave the army/military.
The cartoon leaves out mutilation, death, paralysis, and PTSD from seeing a partner of yours explode from an IED.
The cartoon is a FARCE and mockery of the US military. Who greenlit this shit? That's my question.
You stay in the military because you love your country, your freedom, and family and friends and will fight to protect them at all costs.
@@YumegakaMurakumo If it was just some random joke video - of course, but it's the official recruitment video if I understand correctly.
And that is not a small thing... it means it was approved by the army's HQ - i.e. the message is completely aligned with the army's core principles etc...
Not sure what ptsd and mutilation has to do with it, but even if they were included, it wouldn't have made the video any more repugnant, than it already is - for normal red blooded men at least.
I respect you for having your opinion. Alas, I believe that there is clearly some bias and feelings of exclusivity. It's good and bad. Сan see that you are a patriot of your country, but in my humble opinion, this imposes an imprint on the perception of the surrounding reality.
It is the only way for certain people in certain places to remain patriotic, in a sense I guess
I like your breakdown and would like to share my own: China I very much agree, it has an appeal towards nationalistic people, jingoist as some may say and people with high sense of pride in their country to increase the amount of active duty soldiers, most of the stuff displayed is surrounding technology and battle readiness meaning that it has a second aim as deterrant and third aim as a potential basis to expand it's influence and stablish deals with other militaries for cooperation. Russia is where the issue begins seeing as from 2011 onwards the number of active duty men compared to conscripts increased due to better pay, in fact quite a few Russians see the military as a completely acceptable and good career due to good pay and benefits which where improved with time to the point where the professional core of the Russian army now is comparable to the conscript force whilst previously it was significantly smaller. This comercial is from around 2018 time by which this change had already cemented itself. Hence I believe it's not so much for that but rather to appeal to the young who perhaps are attracted by adventure and all the testosterone in display hence further increasing the chances that quite a few of these young folk will decide to follow the military career to further increase the amount of professional soldiers when compared to the conscripts which I believe the professional core actually is bigger now in 2021 than the conscript base, and yes I actually have the context of the translation so I know it's not aimed at the vdv. As for US...... Okey I'm at a complete loss with that one honestly, probably because I lack the intel regarding the changes that occurred over the last few years to it's organization and institutional objectives. Either ways, great vid and you earned yourself a sub
Thanks for the extra context! That really helps
Fellas. As a russian military I can say - nobody get into for the testosterone, RUSarmy is about stable salary and career, also about fantastic social guarantees.
TAlking about lack of light infantry and specops groups - can't say where did you get that, because there is no any sign of that here. Moreover still is a sort of a competition for getting into the Frontzone between candidates.
And i do not even what to comment info about casualties - fellas, at your age you gonna be smarter. Do you know about casualties of Turkish army for ex? Dont you think it is a secret info,huh? So how do you know that, when even we do not no anythinG?
@@ariktaranis3016 I think the Brazil's ad would probably be the idea of going to the army bcs he loves too, not bcs he really wants the money (which isn'tthat much tbh)
As for Russian ad:
First of all the main core of the RF millitary are contracters, not conscripts.
Second of all some of the units are fully volunteer, such as Naval Infantry, VDV and Arctic troops.
Third of all alongside millitary their's private companies (including foreign ones), so they need competition to get dome candidates
this video should be titled "US Army Combat Veteran Overdoses on Copium"
I don't know where you found this information about the losses of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation in Ukraine, there are no regular units of the Russian Army in Eastern Ukraine, and there are Russians (who live there) some of the separatists came as volunteers from other CIS countries (including Russia) but there are no Armed Forces of the Russian Federation there, they were in the Crimea where they disarmed the Ukrainian Army without losses. According to your logic, if there are several US citizens somewhere in Sudan who took up arms there and decided to fight, will they be called the US Army? I personally know people of the former military who went to Ukraine as volunteers, and they did it at their own expense and they were not supported in any way by the Russian Ministry of Defense. If the Russian Army had been there, they would not have fought with weapons from the 70s, and the Ukrainian, as you call them, "Professionals" would not have been able to hold their positions for a couple of hours. The army is not a bunch of people armed with AK-47s and captured equipment, why have your professionals been unable to win on their own land for almost 8 years, having an advantage in the number of weapons and air power? And for some reason, your instructors have not been able to help them with this.
Its funny that the patriot missiles are known to friendly fire friendly aircrafts lmao
Can almost bet alll those happened exactly on the days Emily was operating them
Imagine showing US military ad to Union fighter in 1800's. He would instantly desert at spot 🤣
Emma has two moms....
Ivan has two guns....
Bro, next time make some research in geopolitics... and use subtitles so you have an idea what is the main idea of AD....cmn rly....
I thought the US ad was a joke when I first saw it. I can’t believe it’s real.
It IS a joke. Our enemies are ROFLing
I think you are missing the point, but seeing your reaction I understand the mindset that led to the making of the US recruitment ad. There are a number of fatal assumptions here: 1. That wars will be fought technologically only, like a video game with more thrill (wars always eventually involve army combat) 2. That the US ad is attractive to US youth (by and large, it is not. Young strong men and women deeply despise pandering). 3. That toughness doesn't matter if you have technology ( in reality physical toughness still matters, but mental toughness matters even more), 4. That appeal is equivalent to loyalty or leads to it (of those who social media "like" the US ad, very few would be willing to sacrifice their lives for their country).
That guy complaining about China having only one political party but United States has only two and both of them behave the same way.
And the question is: how more than 35 countries, supplying and deploying weapons, financing in astronomical ways to one county, intelligence, logistic, training without against one country and they haven't been able to stop Russia.
Then woke soldiers are for movies and propaganda shows.
At the beginning of the smo there were high casualties in the Russian army, because this was a conventional war, not the way USA does.
Flattening the ground first, lost. of civilians death. But what about now?
Ukranians fatal casualties are more than 550, 000.
Russian economy is the biggest in Europe.
USA, OTAN expertise and all their technological power have been ineffective against Russia.
China hasnt used conscription in years, all active duty troops are volunteers.
Chinese military is not conscripts by the way, pilots also sign a 10-12 year contract like in the US, with other personnel having minimum of 4-6 year contract just like in the states.
I think you’re confusing the Chinese military and mandatory service with Korean mandatory service.
I honestly think that that girl Emma raised by two lesbian mothers, confused her head to make her think that she needs to be a man since she was not raised by one
Yeah, Ivan will destroy us before 6am
Well I am 18 and I definitely would not want to be a part of an army like this one…!
Then don't
Chinese ad is the best. U.s. one is a joke.
Russian army ad translation(made by an actual Russian so its correct) This is the first day of your new life. What was yesterday doesn't matter anymore. No one cares about what you were before. Now it's important who you are today. What do you know about yourself? What are you capable of? You may not answer these questions, but will you sleep calmly after that? Know yourself. Know your limits. Fuck limits, you're ready to break yourself till you can't anymore. Everyday. The fight here makes you stronger. Scars are an everyday thing. It was you who decided to prove something to yourself, the commander is here only for you to see the enemy in his face, because with no enemy there is no fight, and with no fight there is no victory. But in reality, you're your own worst enemy. You from yesterday. You must find the enemy, chase him and overcome him, become better than him, and return as a winner. Because tomorrow is the first day of your new life.
when I watched the US one : "WTF????"
You show everything I want. Guns, army trivia, all amazing!
This is the channel for you hahaha
Ahh yes so were suppling toys to Afghanistan now huh?
In few years China, Russia or any other USA enemies will not have to shoot a single shot they just need to call these woke millitary with wrong pronoun...😂😂
The point is the military is about a team and one element. This commercial is about Emma’s personal life that no one cares about and is sending the complete wrong message about what the military is about. This commercial is a joke and makes the United States look weak
O pior é que isso tá quase virando meme no Brasil
Will there be more outdoor content too?
He's gone soft
@@JP-qj7te No, he mentioned in another video that they got poor viewership engagement with them
Correction @9:46 China does not have a mandatory military service period. However Taiwan does (due to their democracy?)
USA Lost The War To China & Russia Before Its Really Happen 😅
Sun Tzu type of shit going on in there :D . Stalin is laughing from his grave. "We finally did it Comrades"
First of all, respect to you for serving in the US army, anyone who is willing to sacrifice for their country deserves a lot of respect and recognition. The Chinese ad really remind me of the old ads from the US during initial war on terror. Lot of flexing with technology, lot of focus on the call of the nation, defending our country, and unity in strength with a strong focus on patriotism.
It's a propaganda piece what do you expect? Every enlistment video so far has been trying to flex what you have until the US army decided to be alternative and quirky
China:Patriotism
Russia:Patriotism
US: Scissoring
Imagine the Russians, sitting there, jacked up, Ready to go in, and they look down range and see a band of transvestites running around in camo with pink fingernails!
Not an expert but i think that people that want to join the military and people like the girl in the ad would be 2 pretty different kinds of people imo
When I was in highschool, it was "Be all that you can be."
Now it's, "Cartoon College Sorority Girls."
Doesn't have quite the same ring to it.
Although they'd probably get a lot more views if they actually titled it that.
You should take the “anti” in anti piracy missions. Haven’t you seen how Iranian forces chased away US forces that tried to get their pirate hands on an oil shipment?
Chinese one didn't mince it, had all the bits for a good recruitment ad. It roughly said it is your duty to serve, you were made to be brave, to have honor, to be strong, to fight to death if need be for your country. Aims for retention. The Russian one was about duty to protect what you hold dear. To be ready, to be strong, and to fight and defend all aginst the enemy. To be transformed into a soldier. Again the right stuff for a recruitment ad. Tbh, the last one looked like an ad for a new MUSH-VR Roleplay game called "The Calling". Maybe trying to recruit gamers to operate drone controllers and such? If it came to open HTH combat warfare though. ☹
У Китайцев настоящая реклама, вот смотрите что у нас есть, вот что вас ждет, давайте к нам. У наших эмоциональное видео. А у Америки видео которое хочет просто удовлетворить всех в Америке но при этом не несет в себе ничего полезного для армии
Teach me russian
Let’s be honest, we have no chance against China.
Honestly the tie-in to values of freedom and having rights is quite smart
And you know, I really want to just talk. Just to talk. Not about politics, not about anything at all.
You sound like a Biden, Democrat and woke. You should be a woke politician.
Despite i really like this video... you make opinion on the russian army.... based on Vagner company? Vagner is a PMC. They do have good professionals, but they are not regulary troops.
And man... Learn something about russian politics...GULAG? Really?
Another thing - you tell that target audience of US commercial are people between 19 and 21. Well, guess what - Russian too. So... Russian young people are supposed to react better on a video woth a motto "become stronger, push it over the limit.", while American audience supposed to react better on anime with a woke girl? Is that how it is?
It is a cultural thing. Certainly US made some research on the targeted audience before planning the adv. So while in Russia young generations are seek adventure, career, some extra money. In US youth are not interested in the adventure, action, anything else related with war, since they all have this "love everyone" moto, that is why the ad don't show any action. Can you imagine a snowflake in a real battlefield? So, hide the things they don't like, and show what they like.
With this ad you can just have an idea of how is the mind of young people in US.
I am not from US, so I can laugh.
@@alissonlares2926 yeah. Operate "patriot" with love 💞😆
@@ferzzfilinn hahaha. Love the criminals, love the idiots, etc. Hire lots of pronoun people to work for you. The army will need to make a whole new language to prevent REEEactions against each other. Imagine put a drone full of ammunition in the hands of a feminist?
@@alissonlares2926 imagine Emily not wanting to operate the Patriot when China attacks cause the superior used the wrong pronoun when ordering her
@@Jashua- she will not operate because the name "patriot" is oppressive and a patriarchal word. HAHAHA