A Band of Brothers Underground Edit: The Battle for Carentan and The attack on Foy cut together for an interesting take on these two iconic battles. Subscribe, comment, share and enjoy!
@@crnigruja2220 except when the series says Blithe died 3 years after being shot by a German sniper when in fact he only survived the war but went on to fight and serve in Korea. Also Dyke was wounded during the attack on Foye, so don't believe everything you see until you do more extensive research.
@@IrishTechnicalThinkerSo, Dyke be wounded might be why he could not press that attack? Also, when they are going straight up the road, I know it's a coordinated attack from different sides, thus Winter's pushing them. However, would not the casualty rate been quite high with 2 mg covering approach? There is no one providing suppressing fire.
I agree with you there's only a handful of military shows miniseries as great as this Pacific was really good and band of Brothers but there's not that many like them they need to make one just as good as being a brothers and a Pacific
From what I've read, Winters really did brazenly expose himself to MG fire in the middle of the road, in order to urge the troops forward. The clanging from the brass balls that man had must've been deafening to the Germans, probably threw off their aim.
By far the best and truest story of D-day and Normandy... we went to the beaches June 6, 2019 for the75th! Toured Belgium and Bastogne too! On to Hitler’s Berghof and Eagles nest!
I watched some documentary on a dude who filmed in wars. He said it was less frightening and even if explosions went off in front of him he said it felt like it was only a movie
Its crazy the mindset you must be in the consistently sprint into active fire, lose a whole bunch of your men, but take out and and take prisoner mant more and then sing your victory into their faces amazes me
WW2 is insane, that’s all I have to say about that. All I know historically is the US side against it for its very short span and Russian history against it. I will have to say though the Pacific side since the beginning of the war is probably the most brutal.
Actually not a hundred percent accurate. In reality he started running down to lead the men, but turned around after a while after realizing he was the batallion leader and couldn’t risk it
Should have kept the editing deep underground.. it is annoying, swapping between scenes.. but never mind, 'Band Of Brothers' is always watchable, even when butchered about.. :)
who runs across a open snowy field without machine gun support from the tree line where winters was standing...?? seems like a very poorly planned attack....
Oh it was bad. There commander completly shut down in fact and left the men in horrible positions. All of the solidgers even protested that commanders leadership from the beginning because he was unfit to lead
I completely understand that these are battle hardened and highly trained soldiers from World War II, but seriously who takes all their soldiers right down the dirt path in front of so many buildings and windows? Right out in the open in broad daylight, for crying out loud
I love cal of duty ** guerra e terrível mas não tem nada igual para por o homem na linha , de frente com a morte! parece mapa do cal of duty in caem France
The clues in the scene where you see the Fallschirmjager trying to escape, and getting shot down, most of the fields were deliberately flooded, it meant they only had the roads and causeways to attack along, that’s why the Germans knew exactly where to sight their weapons.
Dans les tranchées je n'ai pas vu de femmes . mais moi je suis un garçon manqué ,faudra que je le précise . cette stratégie qu'ils ont eu les chefs c'est top . bien sûr j'ai tous compris et c'est très bien comme cela .
Good point. But if they took the road, they should have fired a few rounds from behind cover to see where the mgs were from the return fire. Maybe running in quietly was a long shot but their best bet… dunno
@@direwolf6234 This was the flank, Winter’s Company was the flanking force to support the assault on Carentan and a machine gun wasn’t supposed be there but it was
There were no other ways in Carentan, and if they wanted the boys on the beach to be able to bring their mechanised infantry and tanks further inland to France they had to be able to control the roads.
supposedly their were 3 groups 2 were flanking the sides. what you saw was the middle group trying to draw out the fire. its sad but. someone had the draw out the german positions in the town
IRL they road is much longer so they were much further away from the machine gun than in the series. Like 200m away so the chances someone got hit were less
Je vais voir si c'est possible d'aller en Ukraine .car certains sont bloqués aux frontières .faut voir avec les chefs de l'armée française . c'est mieux de le vivre que de regarder .oui faut voir avec les patrons on fait pas n'importe quoi .
Got ideas for content you would like to see given an Underground Edit? Let us know in the comments below!
Qewrtyuiopmjhgfdcxbvz
Me gustaria el o los capitulos completos de la serie por favor
lame
@@MakeSomeNoiseAgencyPlaylists no you are
Winters was a true leader of men an inspiration
His book is amazing
And Now See the Germans Leaders in the Eastern Front
@@charles07km83 who
Definitely!
Don't forget speirs
The scene where the whole company jumps into the ditches and winters pushed them forward by kicking them is historically accurate.
All in this series is historycally accurate!
@@crnigruja2220 except when the series says Blithe died 3 years after being shot by a German sniper when in fact he only survived the war but went on to fight and serve in Korea. Also Dyke was wounded during the attack on Foye, so don't believe everything you see until you do more extensive research.
@@IrishTechnicalThinkerSo, Dyke be wounded might be why he could not press that attack?
Also, when they are going straight up the road, I know it's a coordinated attack from different sides, thus Winter's pushing them. However, would not the casualty rate been quite high with 2 mg covering approach?
There is no one providing suppressing fire.
God I love this show there needs to be more like it
Have you seen The Pacific?
dingus indeed it’s a great show as well this one and the pacific are the best ww2 movies out there
@peach pamon I think u mean saving private Ryan
I agree with you there's only a handful of military shows miniseries as great as this Pacific was really good and band of Brothers but there's not that many like them they need to make one just as good as being a brothers and a Pacific
@@mcjagger1872 I have seen it that’s a good one too
"I HAVE NO IDEA!" gets me Everytime 😅😅
I made it a mandatory I watched this series every year since early 2000. I love WW2 series or movies across all theater. True heroes!
Can you recommend any others? I saw Stalingrad recently and I thought that was great.
Love how Luz is always in the thick of it from start to finish, never gets peppered bad- and such a lovable personality
From what I've read, Winters really did brazenly expose himself to MG fire in the middle of the road, in order to urge the troops forward. The clanging from the brass balls that man had must've been deafening to the Germans, probably threw off their aim.
"where did everybody go?!?!"
"I have no idea!!!!"
I HAVE NO IDEA!!!
2:48 Luz is like "you wanted me to throw a grenade in here..."
By far the best and truest story of D-day and Normandy... we went to the beaches June 6, 2019 for the75th! Toured Belgium and Bastogne too! On to Hitler’s Berghof and Eagles nest!
Wow! How was the tour? Did you meet any E-company men?
@@lambeezy5014 most of them have passed on but I did meet captain Dale Dye who played Colonel Sunk in Band of Brothers when we were in St mere Elise
@@lambeezy5014 we also had a WWII veteran with our tour group, look up David Yoho on line for his story
was that an ambrose tour..?? d-day to the rhine..??
@@direwolf6234 it was a tour called “Beyond Band of Brothers”. This was the 75th anniversary tour but they have many tours short and long.
How to survive wars: *be the cameraman*
I watched some documentary on a dude who filmed in wars. He said it was less frightening and even if explosions went off in front of him he said it felt like it was only a movie
Yo Hann yeah plus they need to be brave
nah, they use several per scene, so at least one survives
@@JJMB27 explains why they teleport
These types of comments are not funny at all, 'cause everybody who can write writes them
if only men like these are leading the world today, it would be a brighter place
The world is better than it ever was. We're just seeing more of it these days, good and bad.
@@gleep1905 Very true. With today's technological abilities, anything anyone does is so much more easily accessible
@@gleep1905 the world is not better than it ever was
I'm sorely tempted to learn how to animate, just to layer some clones/stormtroopers over this.
do it man, that would be so sick!!
Now that is very realistic at 1:50
Watching Winters trying to run in there was so sad to watch
I watched this as a kid, and when I play with my toy soldiers this is what I imagine in my head
Winters, Lipton, Speirs, true heroes and amazing leaders.
If I've learned anything from this, it is "KEEP MOVING FORWARD!" Younger viewers could learn from that.
muuuu muuuuuuuuuu MUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
Its crazy the mindset you must be in the consistently sprint into active fire, lose a whole bunch of your men, but take out and and take prisoner mant more and then sing your victory into their faces amazes me
I just saw an anachronism in the opening scene ... those electricity poles are too modern looking!
wtf you even talking about
The true story of blithe by winters is amazing
Honestly speaking, the germans had pretty nice-looking uniforms smh
Brave men hats off
miss the original HBO series band of brothers high school years 2001.
Me and the homie playing shooter games: "WHERE IS EVERYBODY???"
"I HAVE NO IDEA"
assisti 4 vezes, a melhor serie q assisti.
Thanks for the 5 minute panic attack
I hAVE No IdeA !!! such a true statement....
I understand the Air War BoB has started production! Hanks and Spielberg on board
Coming out this year too I heard but sadly on Apple though, not HBO cuz budget was too high.
spielberg's dad served overseas...
Leadership at 3:12
WW2 is insane, that’s all I have to say about that. All I know historically is the US side against it for its very short span and Russian history against it. I will have to say though the Pacific side since the beginning of the war is probably the most brutal.
Escenas que hacen vibrar !!!
Lt. Dyke didnt Lost it at Foy assault, he just needed to make a call.
WWII Soldier: Those 7 years of my life on war was the most dangerous experience for me.
1986 Chernobyl The Roof Cleaner: Hold my 90 seconds.
The Second World War didn't reach the 7 year mark
I hate to say put go to 0:42 n thats exactly how i feel when i charge the objective with someone the the team us no were to be seen
Speak english
"Ich erbege mich!" ("I surrender!") 2:28
The battle scenese are really gritty and dirty, with no bgm, and just stress.
I wonder what would have happened if Winters would have ignored Cink and lead the attack on Foy
Actually not a hundred percent accurate. In reality he started running down to lead the men, but turned around after a while after realizing he was the batallion leader and couldn’t risk it
De las mejores series de la segunda Guerra Mundial los 10 episodios son buenos y que en paz descansen todos los que fallecieron no more wars
the I HAVE NO IDEA made me laugh for some reason
バトルシーン命がなんぼーあっても足りんな♨
무능한 아니 멍청한 지휘관 하나가 백명의 적보다 못한 것.
하지만, 윈터스 소령은 진짜 찐 리더였음. 저 사지에서 모두 살리려고 고군분투.
2:53 I know this is war but I've actually seen someone have a panic attack like this. They legit just shut down. :(
In reality he was also wounded, so this doesn’t really show what actually happened
They made it look like they shot real bullets
That would be the point
Newbi mode:
Lie down 1st wait for command of the radio..
..
Heroes 👍💪
dios esta serie es tan 🛐🛐
Spiers was a machine
I don't like how you mixed two battles and played scenes out of order.
THE BEST
Charging straight into active MGs?! Let's be honest, that's a no-do right there, no matter how much you love your country.
Should have kept the editing deep underground.. it is annoying, swapping between scenes.. but never mind, 'Band Of Brothers' is always watchable, even when butchered about.. :)
Why sound so low. Even with headset on. It's like a pillow on the ears.
Watching this before hoppin on hell.let loose
2:30 epic
Eine widerwärtige Aktion ! Der Mann hatte sich ergeben.
@@DjBones67 ja
@@DjBones67it was a German no one cares i hope you have the same destiny
who runs across a open snowy field without machine gun support from the tree line where winters was standing...?? seems like a very poorly planned attack....
Plus smokes plus rockets plus everything else they had
Oh it was bad. There commander completly shut down in fact and left the men in horrible positions. All of the solidgers even protested that commanders leadership from the beginning because he was unfit to lead
Can y’all believe I was 6 years old when I whatched this
ชอบมาก..เคยเป็นทหารพลร่ม
Un film bellissimo .
@4:15 there's a dog lol
Keep up the good work
Good place for entertainment.
Feels like i watched a whole movie in 5 mins
0:46 Is that Penkala with the radio?
Nope, thats George Luz
Why did you mix up scenes like this?
Just for a different take.
I completely understand that these are battle hardened and highly trained soldiers from World War II, but seriously who takes all their soldiers right down the dirt path in front of so many buildings and windows? Right out in the open in broad daylight, for crying out loud
I thought the same thing! They knew germans had machine guns. There was no way of making a suprise attack on a main road
1943 realty
Poor Chickens
Phim hay quá
Но в Ленинграде было жёстче,там людей от продовльствия блокировали,выживали самые наглые и парадокс -самые добрые люди,непросящие,там был АД.
Would a battalion commander like Winters really be that close to the line? Doubt it
wasn’t even technically a company commander at Caretan.
Café de Normandie
I love cal of duty ** guerra e terrível mas não tem nada igual para por o homem na linha , de frente com a morte! parece mapa do cal of duty in caem France
Someone know similar movies or series like this ? ( no pvt ryan or pacific )
Why the hell did they run into carentan from the most obvious approach with mgs waiting
The clues in the scene where you see the Fallschirmjager trying to escape, and getting shot down, most of the fields were deliberately flooded, it meant they only had the roads and causeways to attack along, that’s why the Germans knew exactly where to sight their weapons.
The german is not stupids...
That fucking MG-42!!!!
Rate of fire is unreal….
1200 rpm....
Dans les tranchées je n'ai pas vu de femmes . mais moi je suis un garçon manqué ,faudra que je le précise . cette stratégie qu'ils ont eu les chefs c'est top . bien sûr j'ai tous compris et c'est très bien comme cela .
Keeps jumping from diff scenes.
Classic
D days to me today?
0:30 same map from cod multiplayer ? Carentan ?
I don’t trust like that
@JULIAN JULIAN I don’t trust like that
Huh?
Damn, yankees are true super heros, they take Carentan in 5 mins...
Lol
Why straight up the road into Carentan? I've been there. There are fields.
Mines?
Good point. But if they took the road, they should have fired a few rounds from behind cover to see where the mgs were from the return fire. Maybe running in quietly was a long shot but their best bet… dunno
Real war
Straight down the road at 0:27? They were asking to get shot at.
yeah...where's the flanking and machine gun fire support..??
They didn’t know a machine gun was there
@@direwolf6234 This was the flank, Winter’s Company was the flanking force to support the assault on Carentan and a machine gun wasn’t supposed be there but it was
Wow
지금 저 중대장 통신병이 메고 있는 거 99k인가? 우리가 사영하는? 개충격이네
Скажите пожалуйста как называется фильм?
昔話ではない、これと同じことが21世紀の今、ウクライナで起きている。
running down the middle of a bloody road?I doubt they were that silly
There were no other ways in Carentan, and if they wanted the boys on the beach to be able to bring their mechanised infantry and tanks further inland to France they had to be able to control the roads.
supposedly their were 3 groups 2 were flanking the sides. what you saw was the middle group trying to draw out the fire. its sad but. someone had the draw out the german positions in the town
IRL they road is much longer so they were much further away from the machine gun than in the series. Like 200m away so the chances someone got hit were less
Siempre la guerra siempre malificio de la humanidad nunca redencion
Hindi tatagal si batangas quiapo dito 😂
3:32
C'est vrai il est pas mal ce film mais y a mieux
Je vais voir si c'est possible d'aller en Ukraine .car certains sont bloqués aux frontières .faut voir avec les chefs de l'armée française . c'est mieux de le vivre que de regarder .oui faut voir avec les patrons on fait pas n'importe quoi .
generation war is another good one without all the "hero bravery" bullshit
Série top!