What Makes This Song Great? "Been Caught Stealing" JANE'S ADDICTION
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- In this episode we explore the music of Jane's Addiction.
#WhatMakesThisSong Great #JanesAddiction #musicproduction
💫 The Beato Ultimate Bundle - $99 FOR ALL OF My Courses: ⇢ rickbeato.com/
📘- The Beato Book Interactive - $99.00 value
🎸 - Beato Beginner Guitar - $159.00 value
👂- The Beato Ear Training Program - $99.00 value
🎸- The Quick Lessons Pro Guitar Course - $79.00 value
… all for just $99.00
Get it here: rickbeato.com/
My Beato Club supporters:
Justin Scott
Terence Mark
Farren Mahjoor
Jason Murray
Lucienne Kilpatrick
Alexander Young
Jason Wagner
Todd Ladner
Rob Kline
Nicholas Long
Tim Benson
Leonardo Martins da Costa Rodrigues
Eddie Perez
David Solomon
MICHAEL JOYCE
Stephen Stubbs
colin stead
Jonathan Wentworth-Linton
Patrick Payne
MATTHEW KARIS
Matthew Barouch
Shaun Samuels
Danny Kurywchak
Gregory Reedy
Sean Coleman
Alexander Verbitskiy
CL Turner
Jason Pappafotis
John Fulford
Margaret Carno
Robert C
David M Combs
Eric Flatt
Reto Spoerli
Herr Moritz Adam
Monte St. Johns
Jon Beezley
Peter DeVault
Eric Nabstedt
Eric Beggs
Rich Germano
Brian Bloom
Peter Pillitteri
"Three Days" by Jane's Addiction is their best work IMO
No other song has ever made me feel like I was seeing colors because of the music. Hands down, my favorite song of all time. 36 years a fan.
@@premodeja5582 “Then she did” is their best. IMO
Yes, but can anybody squeeze Three Days or Then She Did into a 10/15 minutes WMTSG ? It would take a couple of hours episode ... at least !!!
Hard to disagree with either of those!
Then She Did is their masterpiece imo
"Ted, Just admit it" is a hidden masterpiece. Would love that featured in this show.
Prob my favourite of their songs
That was on the Natural Born Killers soundtrack. Balthazar Getty and Juliette Lewis at the gas station...definitely a scene-stealing song.
Jane's Addiction was the band that got this metalhead to check out alternative rock.
Jane's was the band that persuaded this alt rock fan to check out some metal.
same here. total Metallica and Slayer guy, then found myself shocked to enjoy songs like "comin down the mountain" (from nothing's shocking) enough to buy the album myself, which led to the cure, depeche mode, love and rockets... and eventually early electronica like the shamen, bassomatic and 90s rave like uberzone etc
Love me some Jane's Addiction. Probably the best show I've ever been to. Tossed a joint on stage, Perry Ferrill and Dave Navarro both hit it, and after their set, Perry gave me his set list..
Where was the show?
Such an underrated band. I love "three days".....EPIC
Freelance opportunist absolutely, 100 percent agree! 'Three days,' 'then she did' and 'of course' 3 fantastic songs that flowed into one another ..great album.
we need more hints on underrated stuff on youtube!
Freelance opportunist three days - AMAZING SONG
RayEttler Listen to "Glitch" by Blind Melon. Or "Mouthful of cavaties." This was before Shannon died. Most underrated band (w/Shannon) ever IMO.
Yes! Yes! Yes!
Eric Avery is one of the most underrated rock bass players ever. Dominant playing all through those two albums.
To this day the one-two punch of “Up The Beach” and Ocean Size” on “Nothings Shocking” sends chills up and down my spine.
JA created so many moments in just a few records.
Here’s to 1 more JA record Perry!
Perry doesn’t have it in
Him. He turned into that guy he hated back in the day. Irony
I know. That whole album is astonishing.
@@tomalafleur8602What kind of guy is he now?
@@tomalafleur8602Perry was always that guy. When the Jane’s were about to sign their record contract, Perry turned around to the others and announced that either they gave him the lions share of royalties, whether he was involved in writing the songs or not, or he was leaving the band and it was over. You have to remember that he was 10 years older than the rest of the band, and his father was a hard nosed businessman. For the others, who were just nowhere kids with raging drug habits and Jane’s Addiction was their only chance of escape, they had no choice but to agree. Perry knew this. Perry was always that guy.
@@tomalafleur8602 They all did. All young artists turn into what they hated once they get a bit of money.
Absolutely love Navarro’s guitar work. Hugely under appreciated by many.
"One of the coolest alternative song of all time", you are completely right.
To me this song has always sounded like party grunge, like a contradiction, like the world its burning down and they are like AWESOME.
Love it, thanks for the great video and song pick.
Dave Navarro is so underrated. His parts, though simple, are memorable and ingenious.
Dont forget eric avery
I cant agree that Navarro's parts are simple at all. Bob Dylan Plays simple guitar Navarro plays crazy rhythm and his solos are magic.
@@SuperBrooniei totally agree. He’s very underrated and even hated on for some reason. He’s a wonderful player.
@@itsMrNobleyes, I watched JA live this week here in Germany and this is totally right
At 50, hearing this after so many years makes me want to grab my skateboard and hit the quarter pipe again. Wishful thinking at this age ehh? I wouldn't last 15 seconds!
I’m there with you in spirit, I often want to get down in the mosh pit 90’s style, 50 this year, but 25 inside forever!!!
I am 44 and skate a 6 foot half pipe every weekend. Best shape of my life skating and lifting. Picked it backup at 40 super out of shape Collagen peptides!!!! Keto. Skate or die man your call : )
wadayamean? it takes more than 15 seconds to stand up now.
@@RangerCaptain11A you need to fast trust me fountain of youth!
Tony Hawk still skate so can you guys. Just take it easy.
"Comin' down the mountain"
I was hoping for Mountain Song or Jane Says, but this song really put Janes Addiction on the map. Dave Navarro’s guitar parts are cool, and that bass groove is awesome. Plus, the music video for this song is hilarious.
Steven Manning
Jane Says: Fucking brilliant song - simple songwriting at it’s very best. Lyrically heartbreaking and the mantra of the band. The melodies are played on a percussion instrument! No doubt phenomenal to witness live - never myself had the pleasure though. 🤘🏻
Steven Manning Jane says is the only song I will actually cry at. So goddamn moving
Then She Did or Three Days 🤘
and three days. but you are so right. great song to represent their drive. and the video feels a lot like the goofy primus music videos of the time
Rick the way you break down these songs, you are giving our ears targets to hone in on. So much of this can be missed without you pointing out these targets. Thanks!
Man you hit it on the head saying that bridge vocal was like a horn section, never noticed but that's perfect! Always fun watching these Rick!
...and Eric Avery is my favorite bassist of all time.
frysknj Andy Rourke was great as well.
We all have our favorites
Love Janes addiction . Nothing Shocking was on my record player constantly. Loved their version of Sympathy For The Devil too. Pixies ,Janes Addiction , Chilli Peppers were such influential bands I think . I liked their later stuff and this ,but I was blown away by Nothings Shocking . It is a perfect album I think .Thank you for this .
One of the greatest songs to come out of the 90’s. So creative!
Always loved this song. Its so weird... Perry Farrell had such an usual voice. His singing was beautiful. Everything felt wrong in a great way. LOL
Porno For Pyros was good too. I never heard anything I disliked by him, even if not all of it worked for me.
Makes you laugh, but makes the hairs stand up on the back of your neck too. Who else can do that?
Perry Farrell kind of reminds me of Van De Graaf Generator's Peter Hamill.
His vocals are always doubled and chorused, so there's always a slight out-of-tune dissonance. I think that's the "wrong" you're hearing. They really pop in any mix.
@@kevinheckeler That's exactly what I was going to say,
Good post.
Jane's Addiction, Alice in Chains, Soundgarden, Red Hot Chili peppers, Offspring, those were the, I don't know if you'd call them grunge or alternative bands, that I liked and there wasn't much else out of the '90s that I liked. Jane's Addiction has such a unique sound and energy that set them apart that you had to like it.
I'm rediscovering them after 30 years. I was oversaturated with them when they first came out and I lost interest. Now they sound great again.
I kind of miss this funky rock from the late 80's and early 90's. Would love to see some Living Colour and Ugly Kid Joe music featured in this series. Been Caught Stealing is a great song by the way. I like very much Stop! as well.
Yeah, there was this mini scene of bands like Chili Peppers, Jane's, Living Colour, that combined elements of funk, rock, metal, even psychedelia, and it sort of got buried by grunge. Obviously some of the bands like RHCP continued to be successful but there weren't a lot of new bands coming along that sounded like that.
Don’t forget King’s X
I Hate Everything About You dude
Yes, Ugly Kid Joe had some amazing stuff, funky fresh country club being one
I love listening to Living Color. They had so much to say, and managed to say it is a great and original way. I would play their music for my students during chem labs. Between them and Bob Marley we often danced through lab experiments. (I still think that taking careful measurements is more accurate (or at least more fun) when you can dance through it. And when the conservative administrators were busy elsewhere NoFX was also added to the mix.
Jane's Addiction and Been Caught Stealing were a staple of my childhood! This really brought me back! Great and awesome video as always Rick!
I can't say I'm a huge fan of Jane's Addiction but they've got some brilliant songs, this as well as Mountain Song and Stop! are great
Killjoy I was about to say something similar.... but I'm a pretty big Jane's fan..... mountain song, summertime rolls, up the beach... love it.
David Pollock he has the multi-tracks
Killjoy
They did a great version of PETS live back in the 90s.
Its on a single CD side B
Can't really say that this is my cup of tea either; but Rick's breakdown help's me appreciate why this is a great song anyways.
TheAgentAssassin
That was Porno For Pyros
Yes!
Rick Graham
Always liked the guitars in this!
Gotta love the unusual
;○)
One of the greatest albums in history. Bar none.
Hearing this song for the first time in over 20 years, I was surprised how the general sound, chords and groove reminded me of the happy Mondays. They were completely different bands at the time, but both so of their time I guess.
Love Janes Addiction. Love Nothings Shocking. It was such a groundbreaking album for me. I'd never heard anything like it.
Love Jane's Addiction. Scrolling through the comments I was pleased to see Soo many others love Three Days as much as I do.
My favorite Jane's Addiction song might be Ocean Size. Just how it kicks off the record with Up the beach. Up the beach is more anthemic an then "Three! Four!" hits you and Ocean Size starts pulling you in this groove! This tune gets me going everytime!
wish I was ocean size, no one pulls you and no one tries..... great lyrics on that
Awesome - thanks Rick for showing all the layers that go into the finished product. Not as easy as it sounds. It's inspiring and intimidating at the same time!
Man, yesterday i discovered this channel and since then i'm watching EVERY SINGLE VIDEO !
I love all of the bands you show in the videos, it is so good to learn more about the bands i already know
Cheers from Brazil !
An absolute groove. One of the best of the 90s.
I was hoping you'd do SUMMERTIME ROLLS, it's a MASTERPIECE
The first time I started listening to Nothings Shocking in its entirety I was hooked. The instrumentals were just so amazing
I could be mistaken but I'm fairly sure Dave Navarro said in an interview some time ago that what is described here as acoustic guitar was unplugged electric guitar(s) mic'ed up.
Ah, maybe I haven't misremembered after all :-)
That's the first thing I thought when he soloed the guitar track. Mic on the amp in the iso and one in the control room while he's overdubbing.
That's exactly what I was waiting for Rick to solo. Because I had always heard that as well.
Unless he was playing a hollow-body electric I can't hear how that is anything but an acoustic. But maybe my ears are being fooled.
Just need an electric with enough resonance, doesn't have to be a semi. See FOD by Green Day, the entire first 2/3 of the song is just him and his strat with the volume turned off.
One of the most perfect songs ever recorded. Have major chills. Thanks Rick. Do Stop too
One of my all time favorite bands. The two songs after it definitely deserve a WMTSG as well. (In my humble and incredibly biased opinion).
I would LOVE to see you break down THREE DAYS. I think that's their best song. Just an epic, beautiful piece of music.
Interesting song choice to break down. Great record. Great band.
This record was so textured, dreamy stream of consciousness, silly, ironic, introspective, deep and moody. And it rocked!
Dave Navarro... Great solo on this track
Channel Favorite so much grunge and metal i consumed and still so many guitar solos make me cringe but dave‘s i have always loved!
I LOVE everything about this song! This song encapsulates the vibe and attitude of the early 90's. It still sounds fresh 32 years later. Always turn the volume way up for this one!
Who doesn't dance around like perry farrell in a supermarket, with that PHAT BASS LINE going on....
I was a freshman in college when this came out. It was mind blowing and really was different from everything else that was out at the time. It has certainly stood the test of time. It still sounds great.
I distinctly remember Alice Cooper talking about how much he liked this song, in the 1995 10 part mini-series / documentary on rock and roll.
the hook during the solo is definitive of the whole band for me.
Yess janes addiction 🤘🤘
Friggin love this band. Love the way even their name sounds when you say it. But the colour of their percussion (e.g. conga), beautiful rhythms, Perry’s penetrating tone, the musicality of the guitarists. The excitement and slightly exotic sound JA brought that other bands just never would have found.
Three days would have been a nice one to analyze to Rick
I listened to this record like 1.000 times when I was 20.. it blew my mind thanks Rick!!!
woof woof....woof woof woof....woof
Where are the emojis? LOL just imagine a German Shepherd dog barking, then a quick cutaway to the same dog emoji smiling at the camera, like, "I'm a fuckin' STAR, Daddy!"
This is one of the most earliest 90s songs with that unique transition sound I can think about!
Always gave me that vibe of summer and beach/surf. 🙂
Steven Perkins is a BEAST
uneedtherapy42 yep he's amazing. What he brought to Porno for pyros as well was awesome like Meija.
My favorite all time drummer, dude is incredibly underrated
1990 Jane's Addiction tour one of the greatest shows of ever seen in my life
This. Was. Fantastic.
LOVE Janes Addiction. This song was huge but I think other tracks of theirs define them a lot better.
Thanks Rick!! Can't wait to watch this (working right now)
Love Jane's Addiction. Jane's Addiction was the first band to be called Alternative
sorry, REM was. Love Jane's tho!
Even The CURE... REM and the Cure, Jane's wasn't far behind tho, one of my all time favs
This whole album is amazing. I feel like I am in a trance when I put on this record, it's like an outer body experience.
You left out Faith No More for the transitional bands
Pixies too
I’m getting to them
Future video title: What Makes "Epic" Epic? : Faith No More
Awesome. Just please, anything but "Epic"! LOL
I can name tons of songs from FNM I love. Some of my favorites being "Zombie Eaters" , "Edge of the World", "The Real Thing", "Midlife Crisis" , "Kindergarten" , "Smaller and Smaller", "Crack Hitler", "Be Aggressive"
Furst time I saw them was at First Ave in Minneapolis in Dec of 1990. Still one of the best shows I've ever seen!
Ritual de lo Habitual is one of the most musically satisfying albums in the rock genre that I own. (1600+ albums) Avery is a frickin genius and if they didn't have a him as a bass player, they wouldn't have gone anywhere. Three days and Then She Did... deserves more attention than this song.
It’s a wall to wall masterpiece. Every note from every instrument matters, but the production is so dense that each time you listen, you can hear new things. On top of that, depending on what system and/or medium you’re listening with, this can change the way you perceive the music as well. It’s almost like a new experience each time if you pay attention. I think it contains Perry’s best lyrics cumulatively and each instrument shines in every song. There’s a lot of bands from the 1986 to late 90’s era that are celebrated, but I’m not sure if any of them made an album as thoroughly impressive as Ritual. Just my opinion after listening to it for 32 years.
As pointed out in this comments section, "Three Days" was a true masterpiece. Slow start, builds up & becomes a mammoth crescendo with Navarro's genius guitar work.
Its almost pieces of songs, sewn together to make a medley, but with invisible stitching.
Undoubtedly it was their Magnus Opus & truly ageless....
Although I despise this song, I very much appreciate your analysis. I learn so much from you Rick. Thank you!
Their worst song ever. Three Days is the one.
Well who gives a s$@t what you think bro?
Rick, everyone has an opinion... but why attack your subscribers? I appreciate the song BTW, it's filled with tons of hooks. Peace.
Rick Beato Rick my apologies if I came off rude. If it helps matters, your analysis helped me see that song in a new light. I still don't like it, but I respect the musicality of it. Keep up the great work.
Lol Rick getting heated! Sorry Rick its not there best song n this album is when they went down hill..but appreciate the break down nonetheless.
Thank you for breaking down one of my all time favourite songs. Your passion for music is inspiring
Love this series ! I would like to humbly submit a suggestion for this series “ what makes this song great “ my suggestion is Hocus Pocus by Focus .
I’ve often thought that as well. I doubt Rick would have the multi-tracks, though.
Marc Scordato you’re out of tune mister! Oh sorry, that’s scordatura. :)
Timothy Reeves yes I’ve looked into that it could mean out of tune but it also can mean alternate tunings like DADGAD
Marc Scordato right it means intentionally altered tuning. Usually applies to violin, viola, cello
It's a perfect song. You know it when you hear it the first time. "It's just as simple as that."
8:19 - Sound like something Jon Anderson from Yes would do.
Yes when I 1st heard Jane's late 80s I thought that he sounded lots like jon ..Anderson... cool man
I love how you break each song down. The isolation of each part of the track. It’s helped me appreciate songs I’ve really never cared to hear! Great job!!!
When I was a boy, my big brother held onto my hands
And he made me slap my own face
I looked up to him then and still do
He was trying to teach me something
And now I know what it was!
Haha that was my favorite along with many other Jane's songs.
Love hearing Perry's grunts in between vocal phrases in the second verse when they're soloed. Also never noticed that the lead and the double are slightly different on the first line of the second verse. Great content as always!
How bout a little nod to punk ? It wasn’t my big thing but bands like television and the stranglers are worth taking a crack at. They were both very complex for punk/new wave.
Evan Rice
The Minute Men, Fugazi or Jawbox even!
The Buzzcocks too
i've heard this song many times & love it, but didn't know who it was. fantastic song! the singer does have a unique & cool style of singing. thanx 4 sharing.
We need Jeff Buckey’s Grace or Lover USCO
or So Real
fantastic chords in that song
Yes. Any song off the album Grace would be awesome.
Dre Batista definitely. Lover You Should Have Come Over is perhaps the most finely crafted song on the album, it would be a great choice.
LUSCO would be awesome!!
Was never a fan until I saw them live at a festival 15 years ago... blown away.
Navarro is an extremely underrated guitarrist
Jane's Addiction has always been may favourite band. Innovative and ahead of their time. Awesome break down Rick as always
Been caught stealing what a great song
Thanks for breaking that song down Rick. Many cool details that I could never quite put my finger on, but wow, you made it accessible. That's your gift!
Jane Says 🎵🎵
ldahui have you seen my wig around? I feel naked without it.
Zeruda Densetsu she knows they all want her to go
Jane says that I'm going away to spain when I get my money saved gonna start tomorrow....
YES!
I think I read an interview with Dave Navarro saying they actually mic'ed up an unplugged electric.
Summertime rolls always brings tears to my eyes!
Do Pavement
Great thing about music is it can put you in a certain place at a certain time. This song (and entire album) puts me on the North Shore of Oahu, winter 1990-91. We would bump this on the cassette player in my truck to get pumped up before paddling out to surf ... and , damn, this song would be in my head all day as I would drop into some killer waves and shred ...just like this song shreds!
OMG Todays music sound so boring when you compare it to a song like this.
Exactly!
Ok, no disrespect intended at all but what exactly are you comparing it to? The best songs from 25 years ago are certainly heads and shoulders beyond most of the music being released today, but also heads and shoulders above and beyond most of the music that was released that year. This isn't a time based argument... it's just a darn good song from a darn good band. Take a serious look at any of the music that isn't top 40 right now... it won't take long before you find some wonderfully complex and interesting things.
I`m comparing it to the songs that on the radio right now. Fair comparison IMO since this song was also played on the radio a lot.
Not entirely sure it's fair... there was a lot of generic not good rock on the radio then as well. There's a certain perceptual shift that happens with time and distance. 99% of radio music has been easily forgettable ever since the beginning so, we forget it. I mean look - "I'm too sexy" by Right Said Fred is a fun song.. I remember signing along to it when I was in High School but it hasn't stood the test of time nearly as well as Been Caught Stealing and nor should it. That year there were probably a dozen great songs that are memorable and had great airplay. 25 years from now we'll probably remember a couple of gems from 2018 as well.
Jestem Genek that's the problem ur comparing this to modern day radio hits
Really enjoyed this break down. Not a huge Jane’s fan but this has to be one of my favorite songs ever; it always puts me in a good mood when I hear it. Excellent work.
Queens Of The Stone Age please
I already made it and it got blocked. You can watch it at www.flatfiv.com
If it's true that they only block No One Knows, you should have a go at Go With the Flow which imo was the best pure rock pop song I had heard in years when it came out.
podpod.. Or Little Sister..
I Appear Missing, such a great 'lead' guitar near the end. Has a hook without sounding forced or mundane.
True. And bass line in final part is really cool
Every time this song comes up in my shuffle I try to pretend I've never heard it before to appreciate how great it is. Now I understand why it's so brilliant a bit more -- those 7th chords!! And the bassline. Man, that bassline. One of the greatest basslines of any song, ever.
Please do No One Knows by Queens of the Stone Age!
Already did. Go to www.flatfiv.com and you could watch it. Those guys are blockers
The link doesn't work for me. Love this series though
Separate are 4 complete different things, even that acoustic, but when combined... wow.
We need more dissonance in music.
Matt Sherman working on it
Can I interest you in some Melvins?
Bartok, Stravinsky, King Crimson, Mahavishnu Orchestra, Soft Machine
Alice in Chains
Check out Ligeti, Penderecki, Schoenberg, Stockhausen, Ferneyhough, Nancarrow, Ives....
Hell yeah! Rick is the man! Love Jane's Addiction
I know it's not rock, but could you do eminem rick?
Also sum 41!!
This is weird! Earlier today I went through your playlist of this series because I clearly remember you had a Jane's Addiction song in there but to my surprise there wasn't! Then you upload this one! Our minds were synced up, Rick. Great video.
Thank you for not doing Jane says! hate that song, love the band
What a great Band! THanx Rick Beato, you are a master
great take on that song, it used to drive me crazy as it was over played, but hearing it now and explained, its refreshing!
Wow! You have enlightened me! I always loved this song... now I love it even more.
Beato makes me remember why I loved some of these (eventually overplayed) songs in the first place.
One of my all-time favorite bands - at least for the first 2 records before Eric Avery left. i have to say that MOST of those songs from the first 2 albums, but especially the first, seem like they were written off the bass riffs. Great video Rick!
Wow this one was great rick! Really liked the summation at the very end highlighting exactly what really makes the song great. Hearing those little samples alone would make me recognize this song.
It amazes me how you can hear a song on the radio, and never understand the complexity of the music. What a great band.