If we speak about this C sharp? My question is very simple.If your A string is exactly 440Hz, can you be sure that this C sharp can have invariable place on A string and how to be sure of that?
Unfortunately, there are many changing variables (even the weather) that can affect the pitch and response of an instrument, so there is no way to guarantee that a C sharp one day will seem like it's exactly in the same place the next day. With enough correct practice however, the combination of muscle memory and sensitive hearing lets us hit the note in tune every time. For example if an experienced performer's strings go out of tune during a concert, they will subconsciously adjust their intonation without effort and stay in tune.
@@DoublestopMusic Or it is very important to know what place to memorise! If we must adjust all the time it will be impossible to memorise these places if the place change! I prefer to educate my ears to know how big must be the interval I have to play...To know that I need to have an universal reference for the half ton! Little bit math can help. Take the half ton of the pure octave and this one of the pure fifth. Then with a simple calculation you can find this universal half tone! Be curious to listen how it sounds using this half tone in a new equal temperament. The result is fantastic! End of any intonation problem! You will have universal reference for all interval. Just must dare to try it!
@@DoublestopMusic By the way-I found a voice example on UA-cam. This is an example of perfect melodic intonation. How it sounds for you, please? ua-cam.com/video/F-3q60ziHHQ/v-deo.html
Which tip was the most helpful for you? Let me know if you have other suggestions as well! I'm all for practicing and improving together. :)
Great tips! Thank you
I love the earplug tip!
The 2nd tip is very useful. But also all the others! Thanks!
I'm so glad you find them useful!
Thank you. I love the ear plug idea. Those overtones do change your hearing of the note. I never thought of that before
Second one.. I couldn't agree more. I hope someone mentioned that in the beginning of my violin journey! Thx
Better late than never! Best of luck on your violin journey xx
ganda mo ate
If we speak about this C sharp? My question is very simple.If your A string is exactly 440Hz, can you be sure that this C sharp can have invariable place on A string and how to be sure of that?
Unfortunately, there are many changing variables (even the weather) that can affect the pitch and response of an instrument, so there is no way to guarantee that a C sharp one day will seem like it's exactly in the same place the next day. With enough correct practice however, the combination of muscle memory and sensitive hearing lets us hit the note in tune every time. For example if an experienced performer's strings go out of tune during a concert, they will subconsciously adjust their intonation without effort and stay in tune.
@@DoublestopMusic Or it is very important to know what place to memorise! If we must adjust all the time it will be impossible to memorise these places if the place change! I prefer to educate my ears to know how big must be the interval I have to play...To know that I need to have an universal reference for the half ton! Little bit math can help. Take the half ton of the pure octave and this one of the pure fifth. Then with a simple calculation you can find this universal half tone! Be curious to listen how it sounds using this half tone in a new equal temperament. The result is fantastic! End of any intonation problem! You will have universal reference for all interval. Just must dare to try it!
@@DoublestopMusic By the way-I found a voice example on UA-cam. This is an example of perfect melodic intonation. How it sounds for you, please? ua-cam.com/video/F-3q60ziHHQ/v-deo.html