DJI Osmo Pocket 3 vs Pocket 2 vs Pocket 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2024
- Finally I decided to buy the DJI Osmo Pocket 3 to see how good this thing is. There is some massive hype around this filmmaking device and I really want to see how well it does through the generations and what the key differences are in 4k filming.
It is pretty fair to say the technology just keeps getting better and better so there will be almost no doubt that the Osmo Pocket 3 is the best. But by how much and is it worth it?
Osmo Pocket 3: geni.us/7NoC
Pocket 3 ND filters Neewer: geni.us/52Zc1
Pocket 3 Hard case: geni.us/OoH3H
SUPPORT MY CHANNEL WITH MY LUT:
Summer Vibe- geni.us/By0ro
Morris One- geni.us/WmROs
All my sound design was using:
EPIDEMIC SOUND- geni.us/LiAO
Thank you for watching my video. YOU make these videos happen from your support so please like, share and subscribe if you already haven't.
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 Intro
01:09 Specs
02:00 Form Factor
02:35 Bit Depth
03:20 Image Quality
06:23 Screen
07:10 Danny Black
08:32 Active Track 6.0
09:35 Audio
10:18 Low Light
11:10 Accessories
12:16 Demographic
MAIN CAMERAS:
Sony FX6: geni.us/SPr5RR
Sony FX30: geni.us/9snxhw4
Sony A7IV: geni.us/xa7Vw
Sony ZV-E1: geni.us/oV6O5
SECONDARY CAMERAS:
Sony A7III: geni.us/sfBgW
Sony ZV-1 M2: geni.us/nxbkbAC
Sony a6000: geni.us/BwB7csw
DJI Mini 3 Pro: geni.us/Fidtn
DJI Mini 2: geni.us/B4OStvI
=============================
Film Making GEAR
Digitalfoto Thanos Pro II: geni.us/YwuIVl
Digitalfoto Thanos SE: geni.us/bDqzEA
Neewer Tripod: geni.us/ZqYs2
Sirui Tripod: geni.us/bmlo
DJI RS3 Pro: geni.us/ywYX1b
FeiyuTech Scorp: geni.us/2KPTgf
Zeapon Micro 2 slider: amzn.to/2wsu1D4
=============================
LIGHTING:
Nanlite Forza 300B: geni.us/lCvr72
Nanlite Pavo tube 30c: geni.us/CzR2WVc
Godox VL 300 COB light: geni.us/McrXZ
Godox SL 200w ii COB light: geni.us/Efd0lAu
Godox M1 small LED RGB lightL: geni.us/QbSBcx6
Neewer 120cm Soft Box: geni.us/Bi4FWv
Neewer C-Stand: geni.us/zHaDHM
=============================
APS-C Kit:
Sigma 16mm f1.4: geni.us/WhQXd
Sigma 30mm f1.4: geni.us/xo7WGn
Sony 50mm f1.8 OSS: geni.us/MYLidN
Sony 18-135mm f3.5-5.6: geni.us/xuwV2h
Sony 18-105mm f4: geni.us/NlNTm5y
=============================
Full Frame Kit:
Sirui 50mm T2.9 Anamorphic lens: geni.us/83FRc4h
Sony 85mm f1.4 GM: geni.us/4ApmMI
Sony 50mm f1.4 GM: geni.us/749KlX9
Sony 35mm f1.4 GM: geni.us/60fWV
Sony 24mm f1.4 GM: geni.us/ZE31znC
Sony 24-105mm F4 OSS G: geni.us/Jr3ED
Tamron 28-75mm f2.8: geni.us/TH1sN
Tamron 17-28mm f2.8: geni.us/tcq2483
Sony 28-135mm f4 Power Zoom: geni.us/tuaQf9N
Sony 85mm f1.8: geni.us/MFI7j
Meike 50mm T2.1 Cine Lens: geni.us/OAc2J1
=============================
Sound Studio Set up:
Synco Mic- D1: geni.us/YA1Oz
Zoom h5 recorder: geni.us/TkqJ8
Outdoor Set Up:
Rode Video Mic Pro Plus: geni.us/JC1a
=============================
DISCLAIMER:
=============================
Companies send me products to review and they by all means do not tell me to say anything about it being a positive or negative review. I review all products with my own personal opinion. If a video is ever sponsored I will make it clear.
Affiliate Links:
=============================
Some of the links in my video descriptions are affiliate links, which means, at no extra cost to you, I will make a small commission if you click them and make a purchase. - Фільми й анімація
Hi Jason. I've been waiting for your review since this camera came out because back in a days your videos encouraged me to buy Osmo Pocket 1. So again, thanks Jason👍
I really enjoyed the comparison with the previous two models. Thank you.
Pocket 1: super sharp and actually fits in pocket. Active track works. Best with Controller Wheel.
Pocket 2: Not as sharp but wider and actually fits in pocket. Active track not working CPU is too weak. Best with Controller Wheel.
Pocket 3: Bigger like a camcorder. Needs much more care. Pixels are finally that size what video camera needs. Active Track works and HEVC. Tilting while panning not working at the same time like P1/P2 it works. Plastic feels more paper. Mic and battery handle are great. 16gb file size. Float audio mic2.
They actually cant compare each other. They are all good in this class of gear. Actually Pocket 2 also has base without thread! That thread base is accessory.
As usual don't care 120fps 422 12k 1600mbps luts logs actually what matters is audio, story, lighting and the less DOF the better. Useless to watch blur.
Anyway these are great for family cameras as they are meant to be. Image quality is far more than enough for that use. I use them all.
I actually came to this channel years ago because of Pocket 1. Thats why I found this channel. Great you compared all these 3 cameras.
They just copied Action 4 software to Pocket 3. I have both and the UI is like the same. Its great it works. It was actually great they added MIC 2 support for Action 4 as well. Wireless audio works great same mic.
excellent summary
i love this summary! May i know what are your thoughts on the mic? How does the pocket 1 deal with wind and background noise? and is there wireless mic for 1? (or is there no need for an external mic?)
@@jerlynyeo Mic adapter for Pocket 1 is no great at all. Mic2 is great it also works standalone device without any camera. But if you are "post" geek you record audio separately and 2 click sync it in the post what ever camera you are using. Audio recorder audio electronics are far better than any camera build in audio electronics. So if you are not using Pocket 3 with Mic 2 synced then record audio separately and sync it in the post. Anyway. Pocket 1 mono audio is enough for what it is but it is not wind protected. Audio is never wind protected good enough without proper dead cat and physical wind protection.
Danny in the House! Glad to see you guys work together.
Just got mine today… always considered these more of a toy then something to utilize for what I do, real estate. But for that I think this will be phenomenal. Wish this came out a year ago lol
Def planning on picking up one of these, would love it even more if it was a bit more rugged with weather sealing. That being said, I think it's a great run & gun portable solution for vlogging, IG Stories & Reels, YT Shorts, etc.
Just ordered a refurbished Pocket 1 to see how it goes. I plan to Vlog my classic truck rebuild and needed something cheap and to the point. Thanks for the detailed review and comparison!
thank you for this review!
Finally great to see the next videos 😁
Thank you
Thank you, great video as usual I admit I watched your pocket 1 video also brought me to the channel as other have said, although am a Sony user primarily...although I bought the pocket 3 a few months ago as an upgrade and for the purpose I need it is suitable, its genuinely better in low light and the easy integration with 'lightcut' is fab, a great tool to go hand in hand with my other cameras, fab for blogging for simplicity with the mic, but has its negatives also I admit. Keep the reviews coming, spot on!
That’s awesome! Thanks for the support
Got it, love it even more with the mist vnd filters from freewell🙏🏼🙏🏼
Welcome to the party. Better late than never! Great review. Love this little bad ass camera on a tiny gimbal!
It is a crazy powerful little thing for sure!
I'm 90% on purchasing a Pocket 3 for me. I have a ZV-E10 and an A6000 I sometimes take to the gym with me to record some stuff, but usually i take my Insta360 to record, because it's much easier to take it to places due to it being a much smaller setup and i can alse record POV while I'm biking. The insta360 one RS image quality is decent, but the Pocket 3 seems like a big upgrade.
That lean on the Pocket 1 when you were running alongside your daughter, is the accelerometer getting confused. I stuck my Pocket 1 to the window of a plane when going on holidays last year and as soon as we started the take off roll there was a pronounced lean. it leaned the other way when we landed. It's good to see the 3 seems to have overcome that.
hey thanks again for inviting to join in on this one… this camera is going to be hard to beat (until pocket pro, but that’s a guess 🤷)
Hi. Thank you for this video. But I am sure which product is suitable for me. I'm still looking for a good product for my travel vlogs that is not too high priced. What would you recommend?
The Pocket 3 is probably the best thing to come out of the media lineup since camcorders. The Pocket 1 and 2 were great alternatives to smartphones but the Pocket 3 completely became a great tool and even a video cam replacement. It's actually quite nice to have a recording device that doesn't have notifications interrupt you every time you want to record something. Pretty great tech. Maybe Pocket 4 they can add zoom on it too since the main FOV is wide enough.
im planning to buy pocket 3 to replace my gimbal shots for wedding venue, as some wedding venue i go require me travel light. Do you think is a good idea to invest on this jason? Im just a little worry bout the 4k image quality is gonna be like go pro hero 10..
I have the Osmo Pocket 1. Amazing image quality... and used it about 10 times in 5 years.
Decided on a whim to get one of these. Had no idea what was going to use it for haha. Turns out it’s really cool for behind the scenes footage and test footage 👌
Yeah behind the scenes it literally is perfect
0:00 🎥 This video compares DJI's Osmo Pocket 1, Pocket 2, and the new Osmo Pocket 3.
1:10 📊 Specs comparison: Pocket 3 features a larger 1-inch sensor, 4K at 120fps, 1080p at 240fps, and 10-bit codec.
2:01 📏 Form Factor: Pocket 3 is larger due to the 1-inch sensor, less pocketable compared to Pocket 1.
2:36 🎨 Bit Depth: Pocket 3 introduces 10-bit color, offering smoother transitions and richer colors.
3:20 🖼 Image Quality: Pocket 3 provides cleaner, sharper images compared to Pocket 1 and Pocket 2, especially noticeable in 4K footage.
6:25 📺 Screen: Pocket 3's 2-inch OLED screen offers better visibility and resolution compared to previous models.
8:34 🎯 Active Track 6.0: Pocket 3 introduces advanced tracking features, allowing for precise framing adjustments.
9:36 🎤 Audio: Pocket 3 includes DJI Mic 2 with 32-bit internal recording, providing audio recovery in case of clipping.
10:22 🔆 Low Light: Pocket 3's low light mode produces bright, clean images, outperforming Pocket 1 and Pocket 2.
11:10 🛠 Accessories: Pocket 3 lacks a quarter-inch mount but offers external battery options for extended use.
12:16 🌍 Demographic: Pocket 3 appeals not only to vloggers but also professionals seeking portable, high-quality video solutions.
Thank you for the video. After watching this, i change my mind and gonna have pocket 3 🎉
Good choice!
This has replaced my A7IV for most of my content now. I've been looking forward to your review
Wow that’s a bold move! Love it
Hmmm. Unless I missed it, I don't think you specified how the cameras were configured, at least in broad terms. In particular, when the little girl was cutely dancing around, the Pocket 3 footage looked somewhat dull, underexposed, in comparison with the Pocket 1 - which is the opposite of expectation, as the Pocket 3 is generally said to over-expose a bit. Did you have the EV and / or sharpness dialled down? What colour mode were you using? Some are now suggesting, with persuasive examples, that the Normal mode is actually the best to use unless you are going to get deep into LUTS and stuff - with light behind a face, the normal mode seems to give best facial exposure for instance, possibly due to in camera AI-type processing which is not used in the more "Pro" modes. But Pocket 2 owners have often said that the Pocket 1 PQ is often better (possibly as you point out due to lens differences tricking the eye). (I noticed late in the video that there was a shot with the child running round, and then you appear in the picture with grey sky behind, and your face is hard to make out - I bet if that had been shot in normal mode, your face would have been nicely exposed without the sky blowing out).
The tiny handle add-on had the merit of giving you something to hold comfortably - but if you have tiny hands or really want the smallest possible overall size, you can leave it off. Also, if you have the camera on a tripod, you can detach the camera instantly from the little handle, leaving the handle waiting on the tripod, if that's useful.
You didn't mention the audio backup feature which turns the Pocket 3 into a four channel audio recorder, which happens to also do video. (Of course you couldn't mention everything unless you did a 2 hour + presentation!). DJI introduced USB-C audio functionality back in the days of the Action 2 camera. So basically you can connect any reasonable USB-C audio device (mic, mono or stereo, or playback headphone, with or without a 3.5mm to USB-C adapter as required) and that can be direct into the base of the camera, or via the tripod adapter, or into the USB-C socket on the battery handle if that's what you are using. You could generally say that if it works with a phone it will work with the Pocket 3. And if you turn on the audio backup feature, USB-C audio is recorded onto the video file in AAC format (in stereo if the input is stereo), and the three internal mics are recorded onto a wave format audio file in stereo, which you can then mix in editing. Even if you don't have an external mic in use, you can have the same internal mic audio recorded in both AAC and Wave formats, and for the best results (in theory) you can ditch the data-compressed AAC audio and use the data-uncompressed wave audio instead. I suspect this may be unique to the Pocket 3.
Furthermore, if you use the Mic 2 with audio backup in use, you get Mic 2 audio in AAC and internal mic audio in the wave file - BUT due to a presumed bug, the internal mic audio is collapsed to mono, which is a great pity as it means you can't do the obvious thing of having ambient sound from the internals in stereo, mixed in editing with the mono output from the Mic 2 to make your voice clearer against the ambience. Weirdly, if you connect any other USB-C-friendly wireless mic system instead of the Mic 2, you don't hit this bug.
Lastly, if you have any USB-C audio device connected to the battery handle, when the battery handle goes dead you will lose the audio from the USB-C source connected to it. You've then got to quickly unplug the battery handle, disconnect the mic from it, reconnect that to the Pocket 3, and carry on shooting. And that can be awkward or even impossible during event recording - eg a wedding. "Sorry folks, we lost the audio from the vows when the battery handle went dead..."
Sorry for long comment but I'm a great believer in using UA-cam as a shared knowledgebase. A great video which actually inspires me to dig out my Pockets 1 & 2 to use alongside my Pocket 3 when appropriate!
(And I can't help editing in a suggestion that you check out our Aussie "brother" ScottyMakesStuff cases for the Pocket 3, which might appeal to you in the context of professional use - there is some evidence that the supplied DJI case can cause damage to the screen when you remove the camera, so...)
Hi Jason, at the 10:10 mark, i noticed you were wearing airpods. Might I ask if it was because you can use that to monitor the audio of the pocket 3 as you record ? If so, can share how was it done? Thanks!
I would only use this a few times to use the active tracking function for shooting car clips. Even though the Pocket 3 seems like a great device, the price is a little too much for my needs. Would it be a total waste of money for me to buy the Pocket 1? Based off the experience maybe other people have with this camera
I have all 3 of the pockets and was surprised that the pocket 1 was better than the pocket 2 in some of your tests. I have used the pocket 2 for a lot of my projects so when the 3 came out of course I knew I would have work for it. The bigger screen alone was cause. Pocket 1 and 2 the screen is so small you have to look very carefully to make sure you were getting the shot. I haven’t had much time to work with the 3 yet, however I will be interested to see how much better the face tracking works. On 1 and 2…. Meh. Usually the 2 would lose track if the sun was behind you. Additionally if you were in a higher frame rate than 30 or resolution 1080, it would lose track easier. So most of the time I would shoot without tracking and it follow mode. Works fairly well actually. Great video, always enjoy your stuff.
Hi there. Could you please share your feedback on pocket 1 since you might have used for few years like any issues with gimbal, or screen, or any buttons etc. I am planning to buy pocket 3 but it nearly cost 900 usd in my country which is expensive so is it worth. Currently using go pro 8.
@@roninr8199 I was amazed how good the footage the OSMO Pocket (1) created when I first bought it. I purchased it used off of eBay 4 years ago. It has 4k with 60 fps which at that time was unheard of in anything other than SOME of the full frame cameras. But I owned a DJI Air drone and was always blown away with the clairity of the footage I got from it. Maybe the same technology. Depending on what you need it for it’s a great camera. UA-camrs griped about the lens being too narrow for vlogging, if you use even a short selfie stick, that is not an issue. If you need better sound (the onboard is not bad) you can hook an external mic to the USB just make sure it’s the right cord. It’s great for collecting B roll and has great creative features like Timelapse, and motion lapse. You can add ND filters if it is too bright and you need to slow the shutter. None of the pockets have apertures, they are locked at 2.8. The battery life is good probably the same as your GP8, maybe a little more. I would get the accessory kit from DJI that has the scroll wheel and the wifi transmitter. The wheel is precise for smooth gimbal movement, and the wifi transmitter that clips to the bottom gets rid of the need to use the phone connector to connect to your phone to view the screen on your phone. The viewing screen on the 1 and 2 are small and sometimes hard to see just how much is in the shot. Look up Jeven Dovey on YT, a few years back he did several videos on using the pocket and using it to make stock footage for money. If you can do that, you know the quality of the output is good. Hope this helped.
May i know what are your thoughts on the mic? How does the pocket 1 deal with wind and background noise? and is there wireless mic for 1? Thanks!!!
I love my pocket 3 and the creator combo is a must!
Ofcourse you get that and not a Sony camera 😂
@@JasonMorrisphotocinema Only the highest quality for me lol
Pocket 3 or stay with iphone 15 Pro for run and gun vlogging?
DJI Osmo Pocket 1 is so tiny, that I really can say that this is the only fair "Pocket" camera
So besides all the cool features, I feel that we could also have talked about the price tag. They kinda doubled the price. I also really really don't get, why the camera can't flip for vertical, leaving you with a cropped image.
It is almost the price of the mini 4, that you could also use in a kinda similar way + all the other features.
I don't say it's bad or you shouldn't buy it, but rethink if it really is beneficial to you workflow and the way you want to experience a creative process.
Yo Jason, your DJI Osmo Pocket trilogy breakdown had me like a kid in a candy store! 🍭📸 First, I caved and got the Dji Osmo Pocket 3 Creator Combo - the new rockstar in town. Now, thanks to your review, I'm grabbing a second-hand Dji Osmo Pocket 1 for that 4K camera sidekick! 🕵♂🤘 Who knew cameras could be this addictive? Cheers for being the enabler, Jason! 🌟 #PocketCraze #DjiOsmoFiesta
I'm just starting to get into travel vlogging. I can get the Pocket 2 for about $214. Do you think the Pocket 3 is $300 better?
I saw the Coles sign and thought - thats weird - it must be downunder - thanks jason - still questioning do i need one due playing on S ultra and wifes iphone 12 too much.
Haha yeah down under. Oh that’s interesting. I personally think image quality it would best those to phones but stuck at one focal length
Well, I do have a birthday at the end of this month…….#55, coming……so I might as well buy the Pocket 3.
Thanks for the great comparisons on all three Osmo Pockets, my man.
🍻👊🏾
So if I'm not getting the 3, get the 1? The 2 looks worse than both when it comes to image quality
Something I haven't seen anybody address is whether you need the pocket 3 to get 32 bit float on the DJI mic 2. Can you use the transmitter as a 32 bit device by itself or to get audio from any other device? If not it's not a great a value as it's being made out to be.
The mic can be used independently as a standalone recorder without needing any cameras attached to it. Later this year DJI will officially release the Mic 2 which will allow you to connect it to other cameras. For now it only works with the Pocket 3 but as I said, you can use it on its own. I've been using it while filming with my A7IV then syncing the audio in post.
The external mic can be used by itself, it has a record button and 8 gigs of internal storage then you can sync it in post
@@RyanKorea It also works with the Action 4, and with iPhones and Android phones (but probably depends on the phone version and what app you use). It records internally in 32 bit float but it doesn't transmit in that format - I suspect no wireless mic does due to the data rate required.
Yes you can use the device by itself. How I’ve been using it for a couple weeks
still looking at getting the pocket 2 since i can get the more combo for $594 the pocket 3 combo is $1129 AUD what do you think of that price?
I price matched at OW and got it for 550. Rkn that’s a good deal will do 80% of what the pocket 3 will do for half the price. 1100 is just too much.
In my opinion the OP3 is worth it. Even just for the beginner pack
@@robbiefushu5724what’s OW?
3:30 sais pocket 1 seems sharper in some situations when in fact it's sharper in all situations. still the benifit goes to pocket 3 . WTF?
how to audio monitoring via pocket 3?any jack output?
USB-C either natively or using a suitable adapter to 3.5mm
Through USB-C
Apart from the screen, you haven't shown me anything that worth upgrading from the one to the three. That's just my opinion though
Pocket one still best 😂
osmo pocket 1 FTW
Holds up so well
I will wait for Pocket 4 hoping the size will come back to Pocket 1 and quality will be improved cause 3 model still does not look ideal
You’ll be waiting a while since this was 3 years after the pocket 2
@@JasonMorrisphotocinema Only 3 years?? That’s soon🤣🤣
First came to your channel due to the DJI pocket one. Im still using it .. latest model 3 sensor in particular is very tempting but im just not going to spend the money for the upgrade as i dont feel its so important that ill give uo the smaller size. This is not a main camera for me. The pocket one is still doing a great job for me. It's out of date compared to the 3 but still a good device
😅eheh the same i came with pocket 1, but now i'm using dslr items;)
I using pocket one because I can use the self telescopic stick.
I'm sure pocket two can use the stick as well
But pocket three can not. Why ?
Pocket 1 is still king!
1" sensor but still not have phase af
I Like Pocket 1
youtubers are praising this but dji made a stupid decision imo for not rotating the camera to portrait mode, instagram, tiktok, snapchat? Somebody should tell dji that there are a lot of those users and they want slomo and low light too
Have you tried one? It has vertical shooting built-in that works great. No need to rotate the camera. I heard that physically rotating the camera would cause you to lose one of the gimbal axes
You've definitely never used one because it can absolutely shoot natively in vertical.
Does having this on the market make you worry about job security as someone in the world of cinema?
Absolutely not. The pocket 3 does will in its class but cannot compete with my full frame cameras or my red Komodo x
@@JasonMorrisphotocinema you’re the man, Jason
I have a pocket 3 and it's great, but it's still nowhere near the quality of something like an Arri or Red camera. It will be great for stuff like vloggers and home video though
but don't buy dji pocket if you are still filming or vloging with your iphone. dji's image quality could be better but they don't care about their customers, there are many problems from dji pocket 1 but they still don't fix it, like the gimble will tilt when recording in slowmo or lose tracking. The community has been asking for a patch to able to manual focus and locked focus for years, but they still don't care. the pocket 2 is dead . The same goes for pocket 3, there won't be any firmware updates in the future.
I just literally updated my DJI Pocket 3 to the latest firmware released in late January, making this statement invalid.
@@andrewcasesjrfacts
Why you care so much? I have iPhones and all Pockets. And iPhone never replaces Pocket series. Maybe for stypid tiktoks but try recording over 1 hour continous event..
I have no idea what ur talking about iPhone suck Apple sucks.
@@juhaaavalaakso455this is why i need one the iphone has minimum storage
pocket 1 is the best it has warm colours and pocket 2 and 3 are ugly wideangles lenses now
Jesus loves you
it was your osmo pocket 1 video that got me subscribed and eventually i bought it! still using it and dont see the need to change as it is still a very solid piece of equipment
That is so awesome to hear! Thanks for sticking around
Fantastic video - been waiting for a good comparison like this. I have the Pocket 1 (love it) and the Osmo Action 2 (love it too), so no real need for the Pocket 3. If I change my mind it’ll be AFTER that price comes down. 😳