The Kulture Study: TWICE 'Scientist' MV REACTION & REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 лис 2021
- Want to help keep the channel alive? Support us on patreon @ patreon.com/formoftherapy
Want to just make a one time donation? You can donate to the channel via PAYPAL: media@formoftherapy.com
Watch the original video here: • TWICE “SCIENTIST” M/V
For business & professional inquiries only:
media@formoftherapy.com
Follow us on social media @formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
#SCIENTIST #TWICE #트와이스 #FormulaOfLove
A listening party for this album is the biggest need of 2021. AOTY stuff, seriously.
Didn't know serial killers also like twice
@@nickbu This is a fact bro everyone like twice 🙌🏻
does someone know if they’ll upload the listening party to this album here? or only on patreon?
@@arelyolivares677 I think only on Patreon
@@rsarin18 thank u! i’ll subscribe
I SWEAR TO GOD, PD, YOU WILL NOT REGRET LISTENING TO THE WHOLE ALBUM. EVERY SONG IS JUST CHEF'S KISS.
Hell yes! This feels like the first album I've listened to of any where I actually love the bsides far more than the title track and listen to them more. 1 3 2, Last Waltz, Icon, Cactus, Rewind, Candy, such bangers in there.
Nope
@Eva Belleh What....chill bro
@@deksanbin Yes
In my opinion I will say this is not their strongest title track but in some way i absolutely love everything about it. the full album is incredible.
Def. Literally any other song on the album would be a stronger title track.
@@lordbuhcheeks just say you hate the song. Stop pretending to be music experts
Same
@@JD_Dale2608 looks like you cant interpret sentences; they said they think other songs on the album would have a STRONGER impact than Scientist, but they still like it. People are allowed to have opinions you know
I think the same. But honestly even if I wasn’t a THAT big of a fan of Scientist. The album? No skips by me. Cactus? Cruel? Espresso? Last Waltz? Amazing 😍
This is a grower rather than an immediate bop in my opinion, catchy nonetheless
100%. It's not just a grower, it's straight up addicting. Every time I listen to it I like it even more than the previous time and I absolutely cannot get it out of my head.
I actually don't like twice's titles in first listen then I become addicted but this time I love it since my first listen it's kinda interesting for me but I can understand you too!
@@TomMRF yeah they always make you catch your attention the moment you hear their songs
Not you pretending to be music experts in your comments
@@JD_Dale2608 and who’s pretending? Those are just opinions from normal people
The range on this one has them singing a lot less in their head voices and middle or low range, it gives it a feel of more ease. Just goes to show pop can be "sweet" and colorful and not being high voices.
Yo PD the album is so freaking good! Can't wait for the listening party!
hope he does it on the channel
@@mj-zv6ok nope, they only release listening partys on patreon. but they're available on the lowest tier (spring 2$)
@@marzipan24 he did feel special up to eyes wide only on the channel
@@mj-zv6ok he did that before copyright stuff
@@joy0953 pain
I honestly love the more cruisey, alto range... it let more members shine in their natural range. Plus the lyrics are about relaxing and not overthinking love, so it makes thematic sense that the music would follow suit.
Yes especially in their b sides. Momo's voice is totally different and I love it
I really like 2021 Twice because it seems like they've realized that they've like... not exactly peaked but they're kind of achieved the highest level of traditional fame that they're gonna get at this point. At this point they're allowed to get a lot more non-traditional with their songs, and Alcohol-Free and Scientist both seem to reflect that.
they have reached their peak or have yet to?
@@foreveryoung1215 i’d say fancy-i can’t stop me were their peak
@@foreveryoung1215 I mean I hesitate to say they've peaked because a lot of people will take that the wrong way, but I think they've explored all they can with the traditional pop format, so they've been experimenting with different genres and motifs.
@@HookerQueen This is a much better way of putting it, but I understand what op is trying to say. 2021 is like Twice's victory lap.
@@sourpatchghoul ...I am the 'op'
*TWICE released Eyes Wide Open*
ONCE: This is their best album.
*TWICE released Formula of Love*
Also ONCE: This is their best album.
The song has grown onto me since my first listen. It's a lot calmer, so some were disappointed. After a few listens as usual I learned to love it. Sometimes the raps (as much as I love the girls) are just placed at the end just because. So I was glad that it didn't feel forced and just flowed with the rest of the song. Love that they didn't force Momo to do the "voice". She sounds great as usual, but still. Yes fans agree that this felt more like a Japanese release and/or should've been one with Perfect World as the Korean release instead. I like that formation at the start reminds me of The Feels starting formation with Chae in the middle and whatnot. Momo looked amazing with this red hair especially her solo scenes. Sana silver lilac hair is so pretty, she looks like a Barbie doll. The unit songs are so good especially Momo unit song Hello despite it not being everyone's fav 🥲 including her. Glad they are all able to participate this comeback OT9. Need to go a concert once it's safe in every way. The red and black outfits look so good especially how the heart designs were incorporated into the outfits.
Not related to Twice, but NCT 2021 is COMINGGGGGGGGG.
No one was disappointed
Fans complain a lot, this song has their color, the title track is not the best song of the album but the one that capture the essence of the concept🤸.
Yes, Scientist encompass the whole concept of formula of love, while all the other tracks touches on different types / feelings of love.
Yup!
As a once who consistently keeps up with their releases, I have to say I genuinely enjoyed this comeback. It felt so refreshing so different from everything they have given us. Especially with the amount of music they release in one year. Making sure that all of them have a different vibe is an art that their production team nails.
Also please check out the rest of the album, it's so freaking good. Icon, last waltz, and hello were my favs!!!
This album is a master piece!!
You HAVE to check out the album PD! It might be their best album yet, especially with songs like Last Waltz in there
Last Waltz is sooo good.
Yess Last Waltz is definitely one of my favorites!
"Still, there’s so much to love here. The bridge is another highlight, moving from bubbly rap to a harmony-rich build to an unexpected chant-along bonus hook without batting an eye (do some of those vocal ad-libs remind anyone else of the American Idol theme song?). Scientist is as assured and effortless as the girls themselves, and marks another notch in a discography that’s just getting stronger by the year." from TheBiasList
Even though this is probably the calmest TWICE title track to date, honestly, if not because of TWICE's hard work and hard earned experience, this song is super simple and there's not too much "wow". But I guess it's because we're all used to KPOP bringing WHAT, OH. moments IN EVERY TITLE TRACK, we forgot how to react to much more simple and calmer songs. But because of TWICE's charisma just oozing out of every verse, this song sold me in an instant. TWICE's deep groovy voices is just so addicting I keep coming back to this song. I just love that TWICE is in their state of careers that they're assured that they can release a more comfortable song like this that showcases all of their strengths in a not "in your face" type of way but in a very sweet and heartfelt manner.
agree
omg agreee
Facts
Unlike many people,this song is an immediate bop for me since feel special where I loved it at the first listen.
The formula of love album is also immaculate.My current favorite tracks gotta be 132,Last Waltz,Candy,Push&Pull and Real You.
FOR ME TOO. I loved it from the moment I heard it and it keeps getting better plus the LOVE AIN'T NO SCIENCE UH UH is stuck in my head all day long. AMAZING COMEBACK.
The side-tracks are INCREDIBLE, you would love the full album
I did not dig the song on the first listen, and the b-sides are so good that I almost forgot the title track. But after sitting down and re-listen to it several times, it's just getting better and better.
And now I really love this song
Same I did not instantly like it but now it is on constant replay!
im on the same boat.
Same here!
Same but I get hooked when they performed it on music shows 😂 their performance was captivating.
the more you listen to it, you will get addicted.
i adored this song from the first listen, its so catchy to me. Personally I really dont understand how people find it underwhelming and flat, but it all comes down to personal taste i think. The concept, the sound and ALL the b-sides are excellent, I definitely think its one of my favourite albums.
Surprisingly I loved Scientist at first listen. I guess because of the beat and the girls singing in lower registers. It’s definitely different, and although it isn’t their strongest title track, it’s definitely catchy and fun. The rest of the album is IMMACULATE.
on this album, there are 3 songs that are units within the group.
"1,3,2" (Jeongyeon, Mina and Tzuyu)
"Push and Pull" (Sana, Jihyo and Dahyum)
"Hello" (Nayeon, Momo and Chaeyoung)
It would be very interesting to see a more professional view of this new experience of the Twice girls
I just love how TWICE rented a whole science museum for one of their sets
Both Scientist and The Feels grew on me tremendously. I liked them both initially when they came out, but then I couldn't get them out of my head. S tier tracks, both of them.
The best way that I can describe it is a track that you can "play in the background" while you are doing other stuff. I really like it, it's different and the pace of the song allows you to play it on repeat without you thinking "this song is on repeat". I want to say its one of their more mellow, easy to listen track.
I agree with PD in this is one of their best songs in a while. Personally, I think this is their best since Feel Special. Not that More & More and Alcohol-Free weren't great, they were. But there's just something about this song, nay, the whole album that feels...energized. Maybe it's because they're trying so many new things on this album, the song styles, the way they're using their voices. Overall it's just really...good.
For me, Twice has always been a group on the periphery of my music taste. I liked their debut song a lot and then their next titles tracks weren't my taste as much, until fancy, feel special and the feels. I loved Scientist since the first listen, it surprised me in a good way, I loved the fact that some members seemed more comfortable with the vocal range of the song and it let them shine. This will defenitly will turn me from a casual listener to a more invested one; the song made me want to listen to their album for the first time and oh boy what I've missing. Overall, I really admire Twice bc they´ve have transitioned from their early years to adulthood very smoothly and it makes me excited to see what's next for them (as you said, they're not done). The only downside for me is that I wish there was more Jeongyeon in their title tracks, I know she's not in her best place atm, but this has always something I wished there was more of since I listened them from the first time bc I love her voice tone.
I totally agree with your Jeongyeon opinion. Her voice is so unique and really stands out. She does have some bsides where she gets more but its a shame that she's never really highlighted in their title tracks (Yes Or Yes is kinda the only exception). It REALLY sucks that JYP shut down the opportunity for Cry For Me to be a title track. Jeongyeon had 2 choruses and really stood out in that song.. But then again she was on hiatus anyway then. Just bad timing all around :(
Whatever happens next year with their contract I just hope Jeongyeon gets to do what she wants to do with no pressure and with the support from those around her
YES TZUYU’S LAST CHORUS IS THE BEST
I'm happy they were able to showcase their lower vocals. Jeongyeon looked amazing as always. I think Mina is trying to become my new ultimate bias. She straight up destroyed me.
YES EXACTLY, a mature progression of their cute songs of the past. Idk why everyone is saying what they are but this title track is a straight bop. So catchy right away and the low register is so soothing (cmon momo) Literally, the chorus is stuck in my head right away. Yeah the other songs on the album could have been GREAT title tracks too (i love Last Waltz) but there’s something about Scientist I love just as much! Thanks PD! (P.S the set reminded me of the doctor who tardis lmao)
I honestly loved this song from the start. I’m a big fan of bass so they had me hooked immediately but after finishing the MV I just noticed how my face hurt from smiling. This song simply makes me happy.
I was surprised about the “deep” melody too and I love that they went with that as the title track.
I agree with PD, even thought it's a cute concept It's very refreshing song! It's a cute/mature concept. I FULLY AGREE WITH YOU when you were talking about Tzuyu being the one who did the best the chorus move. And omg Momo's voice... i love it so much. Can't wait to see your listening party!
as a long time Twice fan, I LOVE IT! this whole album is some of their best works ever. i feel like Fancy was the point where they decided to make the switch and each comeback after has been improvement after improvement, bop after bop and I am so grateful! The old bubblegum pop stuff was different enough from the western music i was used to and grew up with that i became a fan of them for that, plus the simple cute dances (and momo
I love the way he point out TzuYu and every details ~ subscribe!
The Formula of Love album has a ton of great b-sides! Definitely worth checking out!!
I look forward to your album listen PD. Because if you loved Taste of Love and Eyes Wide Open, this new album blows it out the water.
Man i see you everywhere whenever i watch twice related content, also in twitter lol. Hahahahha
@@imsocurious3157 Lmao i just tweeted him the same thing
For me, Scientist is definitely one of those TWICE title tracks where you need to play it a couple of times before it suddenly becomes a song that you just sing it out loud without even realizing it. TWICE just has that feel wherein you just get addicted to their songs regardless of when you didn't like it at first or you already liked it. You gotta check out the full album cuz its one of the best albums TWICE has MADE!
They stopped working with Studio Naive since More and More. This MV and Alcohol Free were directed by Rigend Films.
oh interesting, thanks for the info
PLEASE DO A LISTENING PARTY FOR THIIS ALBUM
they said they'll do it in december, on patreon
@@apersonwholovescats79613 nooo why on patreon💔💔💔💔
@@maglocotmarinel7007 we broke🥲🥲
@@maglocotmarinel7007 because of copyright reasons :(
I am in love with their voices in this song - they sound so silky in the verses. It’s everything when girl groups sing in a deeper range.
Scientist is a song you'll put on idly on ur earphones, it isn't really hype music but ull find yourself humming to it unconsciously throughout the day if that makes sense
I’m in love with Nayeons ‘whatchu’ part at the end 5:47, she says it with a cuteness but also sexiness.
yes!!! i didnt immediately love this song like i did for example alcohol free, but still it's been stuck in my head for days now!! the album has some bangers too - my faves are cactus, candy, last waltz, and espresso!
As a regular Twice listener, I haven't felt this good about a Twice release since the Feel Special mini. Scientist is great, and the rest of the album is absolutely fantastic.
"Visual SMR" i think you summarized Twice perfectly.
the album is 11/10 it's so good, my favourites are Cruel, Espresso, Last Waltz and Fall in love again
I really liked this song at first listen, listening to them on low range is amazing
God I'm IN LOVE with this cb, scientist is one of their best title tracks for me. Loved the song on first listen, still can't believe most people don't like it.
The album is incredible as usual, can't wait for your listening party!!
twice sound like a good first step towards getting concerts back, and when companies see how successful it's going to be they too will follow along
I'M SO EXCITED FOR YOUR FULL ALBUM LISTENING PARTY OMG THE ALBUM IS AMAZING AOTY MATERIAL
PD is my favourite person on YT, cause EVERYTIME I think a song is GENIUS and the majority doesn't agree, I come here and you're like naming everything that I love about it.
Patreon vouch! PD has the most diverse and loaded Patreon schedule of any creator I know. Worth checking out if you want more content like variety shows, survival shows, Japanese comebacks etc :)
I loved Scientist, Twice can never do wrong, the album is just as good or even better.
scientist is definitely a grower. so far, i still love the Eyes Wide Open album more, but you should definitely check out the b-sides on this album, PD! - moonlight and last waltz are my current favorites 🤗
This is my favourite era. I literally love every song on the album!!!
yesss, i've been waiting for this one!
i'm not the biggest fan of scientist but the album is sooo good, i'm obsessed, can't wait for the listening party
If you love the title track, you'll be blown out with the side tracks of this album. Seriously, one of the best KPOP albums I have heard. I am excited for your reaction. Will definitely be subscribing to your Patreon. Thanks PD! 🔥
I hope you poste your listening party on youtube the album is really treat you wont regret doing a listening party
There are copyright issues so he only does it on patreon
I've been a Once since just before "Signal" dropped in May 2017 and I gotta say I adore this whole album. They've evolved so much over the years and their music never gets old. Pretty much whatever I'm in the mood for Twice has it covered.
看來PD也中了阿瑜的可愛殺招啦😂感謝您在這少少畫面的mv提到她🙏
I love this comeback!!!
I missed songs like TT, Heartshaker etc. & this does fit into that
I live the concept & styling as well
Most of their MVs pre-"I can't stop me" are under Naive, they've been changing production studio since the issue with More&More
This MV was probably done by Rigend( same with alchohol free ).
What was the issue with More & More? 🥺
LAST CHORUS WHERE NAYEON SINGS OMGGG IT HITS SO DEEP! 🥰
For me personally, I was a little iffy about it at first. Didn't love or dislike it so I was kinda in between but it grew on me after the third listen and now I love it! They all looked and sounded amazing and the choreo looks so fun! I'm so happy to see Jeongyeon back as well especially since she's my ult bias 🥰 She looks so happy and I'm glad she's taking baby steps to come back fully and not pushing herself too much. As for the whole album, this one is by far one of their best ones in my opinion. I love pretty much every track ESPECIALLY Moonlight, Last Waltz, 1 3 2, Icon, F.I.L.A, Cactus, and Candy. These girls do not disappoint and I pray I finally get my chance to see them for the first time live on tour next year 🤞❤
Thanks for your review! I agree with you - it is a great track. I have been binge listening to Scientist. I have been a ONCE since DTNA era and for me it is one of their most satisfying title tracks and videos, and it gets better and better the more I listen. By the way, it is still trending on UA-cam music at #29 more than 6 days after it dropped, so somebody likes it. :-). Also, the album Formula of Love is rated 82 by Beats Per Minute, the highest rated K-pop album of all time.
This title track is honestly the most “tame” out of their newest album. I’m excited to see your reaction to it on Patreon :)
I'm really looking forward to the listening party! This was absolutely a no-skip album for me.
*i've been replaying all the bsides since friday because it's so good! pd please upload a album listen even just highlight* 🔥
amazing mv and I can listen to this song all day without getting tired
They saved that half of the chorus into the entire 10/10 album :)
The songs on “Formula of love” are all pretty good, My favorite is “Moonlight” “Candy” “1,3,2” and “Cactus”
THE ALBUM IS DIVINE!! THE BSIDES ARE SO GOOD
I usually forget their bsides aside One in a Million... and love all their titles... but now I'm obsessed with the wholeeee album, you should totally listen to it, they're so mature
I really love this release, was surprised to learn that some fans really don't like it. I love the return to cute but with an edge. I love Momo's lines so much, and this has my fav Chaeyoung rap, especially the way she did the last "...a crush on me". Only minus is not enough Jeongyeon, but it's understandable since she was not back at %100 yet. My fav Twice title tracks are Knock Knock, What is Love, Dance the Night Away, Feel Special, and now The Feels + Scientist.
MAAAAANNNN YOU'RE GOING TO LOVE THEIR ALBUM. I PROMISE! IT'S THAT GOOOOOD. LOOKING FORWARD TO YOUR REVIEW ON FORMULA OF LOVE. LOVE YOUR REVIEWS MAN!
I dont know what it is about you man, the way you talk, and you overall insight is just so refreshing
When I listen to you I think to my self wow I didnt consider this or that or see it in this angle
And as for Twice I really loved this album the title for me is like a hidden slow burner and when you listen to the rest the songs its just like a bomb an explosion of greatness
There is something about the beginnning pre-chorus melody in scientist that reminded me immediately of the beginning pre-chorus melody in red velvet's umpah umpah - not in a bad way at all!! I adore these pre-choruses and just found that to be a happy coincidence since both songs are bops ^_^
me too! i thought i was the only one
Samee I was wondering why it was so familiar
The whole album is amazing 🔥
Thank you PD! Will be waiting for your full album review. 🙏💯
the b-sides of their new album are SO good. Really hope you will post it here 😭
Can’t wait for the album review!! Thank you for this I will be support u on Patreon!!
The only reaction video that I've been waiting for and the only reactor that's valid. Waiting for your listening party!
This song can give you addiction! It's a grower for me and now I'm fucking singing and dancing to it! Definitely one of TWICE's best TT!
The addicting effects of TWICE's title tracks, even with different concepts, it always hits. The B-sides are so goddamn good too.
At first listen I was surprised the chorus didn't go as hard as I've grown to expect. But after every other listen I keep getting more and more addicted to it! The album is a 10/10 from start to finish, no doubt my AOTY. It's such a strong album, so many songs and they're all such high quality I'm impressed they dropped this only a year after their previous full length album (which was also amazing to my ears).
The full choreo also matches the song SO WELL I swear it enhances the listening experience. So many cool accents in all the right spots and as always the girls slay. ONCE can rest assured we got TWICE for a long time, no signs of slowing down here
As a Twice fan, I liked this immediately. The whole album is great! I detected a bit of soul in a couple songs. I can't wait for you to hear it! On another note, Perfect World is the absolute best Twice song.
I like it bc it has an essence of classic Twice, which means lot of brighness and quality ❤️
YES I LOVE THAT THEIR VOICES SOUND SO MUCH MORE NATURAL I think that's the main thing that makes me love this song so much
Scientist has the same energy to me as Oh My Girl's Remember Me in how the chorus felt a little subdued or that it was supposed to have a second part to it, and like Remember Me it took a couple of listens for me to conclude that I liked the song!! Definitely new for Twice, but it is their 6th year, so it isn't strange for them to change their sound up
I'm glad you liked it! As a once I loved this cb, especially scientist many people says it was borring but I really loved it at first listening! Waiting for your listening party, hope you like the album!
I always love you review. Its honest and really true.
What you said is exactly what I first thought watching the MV, It is kinda a throwback to their cute concepts but executed more maturely. Also, I really enjoyed how strong the bass in this song is, and how is not so high-pitched as some of their previous releases, it really gives a new feeling to it and after some time it got stuck in my head haha
The whole album is amazing too, it's been on repeat here since it was released
Had the same reactions as you did with this song. It's been growing on me every day. I really like it. And the album is pretty good as well. I completely agree that Twice isn't done yet with surprises.
So excited to see your first reaction to their b-sides!!
You helped me sort out something that I've been feeling about this song and the album as a (w)hole. There's a music theory idea of tension-and-release, where chord progressions in a song build a sense of tension that begs for resolution, and good songwriters can play with our emotions by how they provide, and sometimes deny, that release.
The TL;DR is that Scientist is a song that builds tension toward a release that doesn't quite arrive, because the release comes only through listening to the rest of the album.
It hit me when you pointed out the way the chorus ends with "What u what u waiting for...?" There's an echo/reverb on Jihyo's vocal at the end of the first chorus, like it's highlighting a musical "hole" where something is missing. The something feels like the missing second-half of a typical two-part Twice chorus, but more generally, the answer to Jihyo's question is, "I'm waiting for a release of this tension."
At the end of the song, you get a kind of release during the dance break, but even then, it's not quite complete. It's like the rest of a Twice chorus but without a Twice vocal. And even the vocal sample they use ends mid-word. This is why I'm saying that Scientist denies us complete resolution to the tension it builds. It's only when you put it in context as the opening track on an album totally packed with no-skip bops and bangers that you can get that full experience. Scientist builds the tension, and the rest of the album releases it.
Sorry, I just had to Einstein for a minute. Now back to Frankenstein.
That's it. Same. You are really smart Mr. Frankenstein who had Einstein brain 👍
hmm interesting.. this is such a good interpretation because scientist as the lead track makes it so easy to just listen to the album from the first song til the last, with the tension build-up you’ve mentioned, it just makes sense to me, not everyone listens to all 17 songs in one sitting but formula of love really has that flow where you can just vibe no matter how powerful (last waltz) or soft (candy) the song is, it’s just so excellent of an album overall
I'm so happy you liked it. I felt the EXACT same way as you, literally every single thing you pointed I commented about. This divided a lot of onces opinions, but I REALLY love it and it just gets better as more as you listen to it. AND THE ALBUM... PERFECTION. definitely AOTY for me.
I think this album is their best one yet. It's so good!!! Can't wait for you to react.
Can't wait for you to check out the album! It's amazing, pure gold!
I absolutely love the vibe of this song
I can get the same energy as him everytime i listen to twice. i feel you bro
Initially i didn’t love this song but it’s grown so much on me. I like it a lot.
But this album is insane. There’s so many absolute BANGERS