Thank you. It's not just Bach. It's how u play it. I scrolled through dozens of prelude number 1 before I stopped and fully listened to your version. It's felt. From the trenches of Brooklyn. Thank you sir
My Father loved this piece, and I just got the music for it, and will learn, and play it, in honor of my Father. I liked Keith Rodriguez's guitar version of it. Thank you. Doctor George Whitehead
I actually first heard this played on electric bass. I started to learn it on bass and got sidetracked to learning it on piano. Only then did I fall in love with the organic inevitability of the chord progressions. The soulfulness of this rendition together with the crystaline clarity of the guitar combine to produce a heartachingly beautiful experience.
Hello. I have the Schott edition version and your transcription is even better. The fingerings seem a bit more feasible too. I love your version, it's so warm and melodic. Thanks for your talent and dedication!
I changed a few of the fingerings from the Parkening version to avoid stretches and mantain the legato flow of the arpeggios. Thank you for your comments!
Bach is always nice, but what stands out for me is the sound that guitar produces! It somehow has the perfect balance of warmth and brightness that both cedar and spruce have. I wish I could play it.
Keith your playing here and the sound of the guitar are just incredible. It's inspired me to learn the piece myself, but your playing seems to differ from the versions of the Parkening arrangement I could find online. Where did you get the sheet music for this please?
Thank you for the high praise and yes, the guitar is a true gem of an instrument. I used the Parkening arrangement to learn the piece, but over the years I have made my own fingerings which for me help to keep the legato feel, as well as avoid some very uncomfortable extensions. Unfortunately they aren't even notated. Hopefully the video images will help you if you choose to use any of my fingerings.
@@keithrodriguezguitar I've spent some time in the hospital recently and haven't gotten back to classical guitar...however your touching performance has duly motivated me to "get back" to the practice of this beautiful instrument and it's your post of this Bach piece that turned the tide for me. Had difficulty finding your link to this sheet music by Parkening however my research has yielded it is contained in "Parkening Plays Bach from Hal Leonard.....sound right..? Very best regards, Ken
@@kenwilson54 sorry! I added the link from my phone and it didn’t go through. In any case, it is the Parkening Plays Bach from Hal Leonard. Some of the fingerings are changed in my version, but mostly they’re the same. I can relate very well to having an operation, and what it means to get back to the instrument afterwards. I am so glad to hear how this interpretation has inspired you. Hopefully you will find the strength and joy to play. All the best!
Very nice playing. Congrats Keith. Weird sounding high e-string. Does this guitar have carbon strings on it? If so you're not doing it any favors GSI. A lot of people think it helps balance the guitar, that should be done by the player.
Yes, it has the 6th string dropped to D. The original arrangement I used was by Christopher Parkening, but I have changed many of the fingerings over the years to try and create a more legato coninuity between each chord. Difficult!! Thanks for asking!
My last choice to enter...the compass was expectant sober to walk...the feeling was trusting. Its most likely I will chose Air next time, that will be the absolute confirmation that as long as I will be at his side I will be finally breathing...
2 роки тому
Which key ? Do You have sheets ? I have D Major version by Parkening.
Am I the only person not layup to their tv screen, how I listen and watch you tube, and expect to see a piano accompaniment to the guitar and look for it and not see a piano? This guitar sounds too much like a piano. A guitar with piano overtones, too much piano for me, otherwise I enjoyed it. But wow. Even listening more than once and watching it. Just plain crazy. Thanks for the piece anyway Keith. Strange, though.
It's true that the instrument has many rich overtones, but that ends up being a question of preference. For me it benefits certain repertoire, as long as there is a clear separation of the voices(which I believe this instrument has). The guitar had a ton of body resonance, typical of the 90 year old Spanish guitars I have played (Simplicio, Garcia). Again, a question of taste. Thank you for taking the time to comment.
Thanks for the discerning ear first of all! As is sometimes the case, the intonation on historic instruments isn't always the best. It's also possible that the strings moved during performance. I assure you that it was turned with a tuner before recording. 😅
You have a good ear mate ,,pianos don't suffer from the mathematical discrepancies of a standard guitar neck ,,there a few top flight luthiers who make what's called a compensated nut where the point at which the string leaves is cut & filed so every string hits the exact mid point on a digital tuner at any fret anywhere on the neck.some of the strings on this guitar were definitely floating flat/ sharp depending on what frets were played ,not the guys fault he played it beautifully!
Please explain how playing with the E tuned to D is what you call “cheating”? Alternate tunings such as drop D allow you to play music and chord voicings that otherwise are not physically possible to play using standard tuning, and vice versa.
Nylon sounds hollow and soulless… can you play it with heavier bronze strings? I can see in the comments that we are supposed to like the sound of nylon, but it sounds hollow to me.
I don't mean to sound offensive and everyone has preferences, but I think in general you are probably in the minority thinking nylon guitars sounding hollow and soulless. Classical guitarists play practically always nylon strings and I personally think any steel string guitar would sound too bright especially the high strings. I have and like both kind of guitars, but for different purposes.
@@ManWithoutThePants you don’t sound offensive, because it’s not true. Because of how much harder it is to get the good sound, I think people are lazy and settle for nylon. I noticed the head of Juilliard has joint problems from playing nylon, and that just tells you everything. Moreover, nylon strings are much easier to synthesize than other various metallic compounds.
@@jamessmyth Lots of players have all kinds of hand issues if they play a lot even with proper technique and I don't see how nylon string guitar has anything to do with it. But I say play on which kind of guitar you like the best for the song. I play nylon, steel string acoustic or electric whatever fits what I'm playing. Let everyone play what they like.
@@ManWithoutThePants it’s about being serious enough to play real strings. Back in the 90s Roland came out with a terrific nylon string guitar sound, and that really takes away from the specialism of guitar itself. I’m still waiting for the person who tells me to play nylon instead of a metal compound. The truth is that 99% of guitar players never advance beyond intermediate level, so nylon is a crutch for the lazy. Are you part of the 1%? Do the people around you actually prefer the sound of nylon? I would like to know what color the sky is where you live if that’s true.
@@jamessmyth Classical guitars have rounder smoother sound which lots of people prefer. I don't think guitar playing as way to prove your technical abilities, but as a way to express yourself. That is true probably that many beginners start with nylon strings, because they are easier for fingers though. I had already bunch of guitars until I bought my first nylon string and I bought it for the different sound it produces. But I think there is no point to continue this conversation since it seems that it's not going to go anywhere. Happy playing anyways. :)
A guitarist who understands the music of Bach and can bring it to life on a classical guitar. Bravo!
Yeah, really. The fingerings are killers!
For a second, if you close your eyes, you almost forget it's a guitar and not a piano - brilliant interpretation, thank you!
❤
Someone who hasn’t played guitar cannot understand how difficult this is. He makes it look easy.
it is so shockingly unintuitive for me!!! beautiful music
Thank you. It's not just Bach. It's how u play it. I scrolled through dozens of prelude number 1 before I stopped and fully listened to your version. It's felt. From the trenches of Brooklyn. Thank you sir
That is the best praise I could ask for. Thank you for taking the time to say it.
The guitar is in perfect tune.
It's a well tempered guitar 😉
❤@@contafamilia2092
Excelente maestro.
My Father loved this piece, and I just got the music for it, and will learn, and play it, in honor of my Father. I liked Keith Rodriguez's guitar version of it. Thank you. Doctor George Whitehead
Bravo!!!!!!
Perfection in execution! Bach would be proud ❤❤❤
Masterclass. Bravo. I was watching your left hand stretch from the 1st to 5th fret effortlessly. And you play with such emotion too.
That is high praise indeed! I'm glad it looked effortless, but I can assure you it was not! 😊
non cercherò altro preludio: splendida interpretazione su una chitarra dal timbro eccezionale:
chapeau!!
Simply stunning...
❤
Still will always be my favorite song
I actually first heard this played on electric bass. I started to learn it on bass and got sidetracked to learning it on piano. Only then did I fall in love with the organic inevitability of the chord progressions. The soulfulness of this rendition together with the crystaline clarity of the guitar combine to produce a heartachingly beautiful experience.
That guitar has awesome tone and beautifully played
vero! difficile trovare delle classiche con quel timbro... è anche vero che lui la suona con grande pathos...
simply divinely good playing... Thank you Sir
Thank you for sharing your enjoyment of my music. (Bach's actually!)
Nothing more refreshing than humility... @@keithrodriguezguitar
Je suis enchantée par votre interprétation de ce Prélude de Bach. C'est très bien joué et vous y mettez beaucoup de sensibilité. Bravo à vous !
I absolutely love Bach's Prelude in C Major, especially played on the Spanish Classical Guitar.
resta da capire che marca e modello è questa splendida chitarra...
Coherent and SOLID! Indeed one of the best version on guitar. Thanks!
Finora la migliore mai sentita: chitarrista e chitarra eccezionali!
Absolutely lovely arrangement & gorgeous playing! Bravo!!
Hello. I have the Schott edition version and your transcription is even better. The fingerings seem a bit more feasible too. I love your version, it's so warm and melodic. Thanks for your talent and dedication!
I changed a few of the fingerings from the Parkening version to avoid stretches and mantain the legato flow of the arpeggios. Thank you for your comments!
Bach is always nice, but what stands out for me is the sound that guitar produces! It somehow has the perfect balance of warmth and brightness that both cedar and spruce have. I wish I could play it.
WONDER WHAT KIND AND HOW MUCH?
I was thinking the same thing. I love this song and listen to often but that guitar sound was really a standout!
Cedar or spruce? Not both
Thanks you for this guitare version officielle one's of m'y favorites Bach creation
Mempesona.! This is beyond musicianship. Sebuah penampilan penuh perasaan
Lindo
Definitivamente excelente ejecución
Gracias
Amaing. Thank you.
Wonderful
Music so soothing it makes me forget about the Third Impact.
this is like when i played the cello
I get the reference bro
One day we will all become one
Listened to a few of this tune on youtube. I liked this one the most. It has more feeling than the others I heard.
Well thank you so much! Feeling is such an important part of music making.
Magnificent
Just beautiful!
Thank you so much!
@@keithrodriguezguitarYou're welcome! I learned to play classical guitar a very long time ago.
Bravo bravo!
Gorgeous!
Marvelous!!!
I love how you have beautifully played that prelude.
That guitar seems to be a Romantic one ,due to the softness of the tone.
Perfection!
Beautiful
Spectacular.
Peaceful and beautiful!
Magnificent!
Beautiful
Muy buen control de su interpretación.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Stu Hamm played this on bass guitar a few years back. A lovely piece of music
Muito grato.
Amazing, Sir
VERY FLUID NICE JOB
FANTASTICO! 🤩
Bravo Maestro
Awesome
Glad you liked it. Thanks for the comment!
Какая красота, хочу выучить
This guitar is the most piano like sound that I have ever heard
yes it sounds epic and I'm sure it's about 25k to buy it OR MORE
Que bonito se escucha cuando no esta amplificada gracias José besos de Francia buena noche👋👍❤
Felicitaciones amigo! Its so beautiful.
"Ave Maria".
Beautiful performance.
Next time Fred we’ll be waiting for you singing on this arpeggio…
@@francescodefendi3201 , It'll be magic, my friend.
Very nice job ❤
Good performance 👏🏻👏🏻
Beautiful!!!
Very nicely done. Looks like Parkening’s arrangement. I play this song every day, so beautiful 😊
I love this version. Bach originally wrote this for clavichords and harpsichords. The guitar has a similar sound to the clavichord
Merci ❤
Love that guitar. No doubt spruce.
beautiful stuff
Complimenti 🌹
👏👏👏
Nice work, I play this in drop D tuning
Bravoooo ❤❤❤
Keith your playing here and the sound of the guitar are just incredible. It's inspired me to learn the piece myself, but your playing seems to differ from the versions of the Parkening arrangement I could find online. Where did you get the sheet music for this please?
Thank you for the high praise and yes, the guitar is a true gem of an instrument. I used the Parkening arrangement to learn the piece, but over the years I have made my own fingerings which for me help to keep the legato feel, as well as avoid some very uncomfortable extensions. Unfortunately they aren't even notated. Hopefully the video images will help you if you choose to use any of my fingerings.
Very nice!
Amazing! It's the first time I see an arrangment in drop D. It solves some problems but creates others, right?! Really nice anyway!
Gracias
Bravo, amazing performance and the arrangement is not bad neither!
Gorgeous playing. Does anyone know of a download for this transcription? (preferably with tabs too). Thanks.
And then came music..
🔥🔥
Bravo! score pdf?
Super ! :)
¿ Dónde puedo conseguir la lista de acordes?
Really greatly inspiringly beautiful....please anyone know where the sheet music for this piece arranged by Parkening might be found?
Thank you Ken. Here is a link to the book which I purchased many years ago, but is available through Amazon.
@@keithrodriguezguitar I've spent some time in the hospital recently and haven't gotten back to classical guitar...however your touching performance has duly motivated me to "get back" to the practice of this beautiful instrument and it's your post of this Bach piece that turned the tide for me. Had difficulty finding your link to this sheet music by Parkening however my research has yielded it is contained in "Parkening Plays Bach from Hal Leonard.....sound right..? Very best regards, Ken
@@kenwilson54 sorry! I added the link from my phone and it didn’t go through. In any case, it is the Parkening Plays Bach from Hal Leonard. Some of the fingerings are changed in my version, but mostly they’re the same. I can relate very well to having an operation, and what it means to get back to the instrument afterwards. I am so glad to hear how this interpretation has inspired you. Hopefully you will find the strength and joy to play. All the best!
Thank you much for sharing your source with us
Very nice playing. Congrats Keith.
Weird sounding high e-string. Does this guitar have carbon strings on it? If so you're not doing it any favors GSI. A lot of people think it helps balance the guitar, that should be done by the player.
0:26 is anyone seeking how to get through the Bar 5 as well? The bar chord at V position by pinky finger is really challenging.
he is playing 3rd finger on b string and 4th on e string so no bar chord
maybe it could help you
Drop D!!
What guitar is he playing ..model ..
Domingo Esteso 1933. An historic instrument for sure. Thank you for asking.
What is the tuning? I know it's drop D on the top string but more than that I believe.
Its just drop D. He is most likely playing an arrangement by christopher parkening where he uses D tuning as well
Yes, it has the 6th string dropped to D. The original arrangement I used was by Christopher Parkening, but I have changed many of the fingerings over the years to try and create a more legato coninuity between each chord. Difficult!! Thanks for asking!
My last choice to enter...the compass was expectant sober to walk...the feeling was trusting.
Its most likely I will chose Air next time, that will be the absolute confirmation that as long as I will be at his side I will be finally breathing...
Which key ? Do You have sheets ? I have D Major version by Parkening.
The Parkening transcription I used is in C major.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 👍
drop D??
this song made me literally shit myself. real nice.
I don't think his fingers are long enough.
So sleepy 😴😴
Am I the only person not layup to their tv screen, how I listen and watch you tube, and expect to see a piano accompaniment to the guitar and look for it and not see a piano? This guitar sounds too much like a piano. A guitar with piano overtones, too much piano for me, otherwise I enjoyed it. But wow. Even listening more than once and watching it. Just plain crazy. Thanks for the piece anyway Keith. Strange, though.
It's true that the instrument has many rich overtones, but that ends up being a question of preference. For me it benefits certain repertoire, as long as there is a clear separation of the voices(which I believe this instrument has). The guitar had a ton of body resonance, typical of the 90 year old Spanish guitars I have played (Simplicio, Garcia). Again, a question of taste. Thank you for taking the time to comment.
Drop D tuning
I fucking hate it when musicians move themselves with the music
Am I really the only one who can hear that guitar needs tuning? (NOT saying the playing isn't good)
Thanks for the discerning ear first of all! As is sometimes the case, the intonation on historic instruments isn't always the best. It's also possible that the strings moved during performance. I assure you that it was turned with a tuner before recording. 😅
Yes, You are the only one. Please, enjoy the music without analyzing so much
Yes, you’re the only one.
No guitar sounds fine
You have a good ear mate ,,pianos don't suffer from the mathematical discrepancies of a standard guitar neck ,,there a few top flight luthiers who make what's called a compensated nut where the point at which the string leaves is cut & filed so every string hits the exact mid point on a digital tuner at any fret anywhere on the neck.some of the strings on this guitar were definitely floating flat/ sharp depending on what frets were played ,not the guys fault he played it beautifully!
Walter white plays guitar
I hate to tune a string down. It seems like cheating.
You obviously don’t know what you’re talking about. This piece is 10 times harder to play in drop D than standard tuning.
Please explain how playing with the E tuned to D is what you call “cheating”? Alternate tunings such as drop D allow you to play music and chord voicings that otherwise are not physically possible to play using standard tuning, and vice versa.
intonation is whackadoozy
Nylon sounds hollow and soulless… can you play it with heavier bronze strings? I can see in the comments that we are supposed to like the sound of nylon, but it sounds hollow to me.
I don't mean to sound offensive and everyone has preferences, but I think in general you are probably in the minority thinking nylon guitars sounding hollow and soulless. Classical guitarists play practically always nylon strings and I personally think any steel string guitar would sound too bright especially the high strings. I have and like both kind of guitars, but for different purposes.
@@ManWithoutThePants you don’t sound offensive, because it’s not true. Because of how much harder it is to get the good sound, I think people are lazy and settle for nylon. I noticed the head of Juilliard has joint problems from playing nylon, and that just tells you everything. Moreover, nylon strings are much easier to synthesize than other various metallic compounds.
@@jamessmyth Lots of players have all kinds of hand issues if they play a lot even with proper technique and I don't see how nylon string guitar has anything to do with it. But I say play on which kind of guitar you like the best for the song. I play nylon, steel string acoustic or electric whatever fits what I'm playing. Let everyone play what they like.
@@ManWithoutThePants it’s about being serious enough to play real strings. Back in the 90s Roland came out with a terrific nylon string guitar sound, and that really takes away from the specialism of guitar itself. I’m still waiting for the person who tells me to play nylon instead of a metal compound. The truth is that 99% of guitar players never advance beyond intermediate level, so nylon is a crutch for the lazy. Are you part of the 1%? Do the people around you actually prefer the sound of nylon? I would like to know what color the sky is where you live if that’s true.
@@jamessmyth Classical guitars have rounder smoother sound which lots of people prefer. I don't think guitar playing as way to prove your technical abilities, but as a way to express yourself. That is true probably that many beginners start with nylon strings, because they are easier for fingers though. I had already bunch of guitars until I bought my first nylon string and I bought it for the different sound it produces. But I think there is no point to continue this conversation since it seems that it's not going to go anywhere. Happy playing anyways. :)