What If Jack Let Hank Live? | A Breaking Bad Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 чер 2023
  • In the episode Ozymandias, Jack Welker and his gang had hank at gun point and he said to Walter “there’s not scenario where this guy lives”
    And this video is all about finding that scenario.
    Welcome to the breaking bad what if series that I call the Heisenverse,
    A series where I make a change somewhere in the Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul time and see how that one change ripples throughout the
    Entire universe.
    Thank you for watching this video, make sure you’re subscribed to stay up to date with the latest content
    •Business email
    G.murray726@gmail.com
    -Donations
    cash.app/$MURGE2PRO
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
    #breakingbad #heisenverse #walterwhite #whatif #ozymandias #storytelling #writter #Amc #vincegilligan #bryancranston #edit #jessepinkman #theory
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 882

  • @camkb05
    @camkb05 11 місяців тому +4046

    What if Hank broke into Jesse's private domicile and saw Walter in there?

    • @Robert___98
      @Robert___98 11 місяців тому +451

      The great thing about this one is that at the time of writing the episode, the writers were in such a rut for ages as to how they could possibly get Hank to leave the RV behind

    • @JRHMC
      @JRHMC 11 місяців тому +54

      He needs to do this one next!

    • @Akizine
      @Akizine 11 місяців тому +16

      YESS

    • @ketomine.
      @ketomine. 11 місяців тому +140

      i could see Walt spinning it that Jesse kidnapped him/forced him to cook meth with him

    • @Bless3757
      @Bless3757 11 місяців тому +10

      ​@@Robert___98do you have a link to a behind the scenes where they talked about this? i def wanna see it

  • @Frank_MC
    @Frank_MC 10 місяців тому +369

    What if Walter Jr never got breakfast?
    Perfect villain arc pending

    • @kayw8224
      @kayw8224 2 місяці тому +4

      Lol thanks for the laugh! 😊

    • @novablast1695
      @novablast1695 2 місяці тому +7

      He starts cooking cocaine to compete with his dad

    • @Mrjonnyjonjon123
      @Mrjonnyjonjon123 Місяць тому +1

      Hes either intermediate fasting or going to die in 1 to 2 months from what probably is a hunger strike from the lack of breakfast

  • @Booga653
    @Booga653 10 місяців тому +1170

    If Walter was kept in the cage like Jesse, imagine the DEA find the tape and think Hank was trying to make a deal with Jack and his crew and it went wrong. So they find Walt being used as a cook and he gets away Scott free.

    • @Sebastian-km9qx
      @Sebastian-km9qx 10 місяців тому +30

      😂😂 poor Walter. Used by is brother in law & the Nazis

    • @SharkBunny
      @SharkBunny 8 місяців тому +9

      I'd like to see that one

    • @alonzosaldana4126
      @alonzosaldana4126 8 місяців тому +16

      Walter is too old his body couldn’t handle that

    • @creatureconnor
      @creatureconnor 8 місяців тому +8

      Yeeeeaaaaahhhh, but your forgetting one thing... Skyler

    • @OfArgento
      @OfArgento 8 місяців тому +33

      ​@@creatureconnoryeah but imagine they killed skyler just like they killed andrea. Retaliation for walt trying to escape

  • @solarsunne4950
    @solarsunne4950 11 місяців тому +1002

    These What Ifs really make me realize something.
    Almost always, what happened in the series canon was one of, if not the best possible outcome, being realistic.

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +104

      I try to have the best of both worlds, but I’m happy you enjoyed the content

    • @adimark42
      @adimark42 9 місяців тому +65

      missed opportunity to call it walt ifs

    • @frontsidekrookedgrind289
      @frontsidekrookedgrind289 8 місяців тому +8

      MISSED OPPORTUNITY

    • @jll716
      @jll716 5 місяців тому +3

      💯

  • @MTown587
    @MTown587 11 місяців тому +214

    Jesse in 90% of these: “Well, guess I’ll die 🤷‍♂️”

    • @UnwantedGhost1-anz25
      @UnwantedGhost1-anz25 2 місяці тому +22

      In all fairness, he was supposed to die in season 1.

    • @TymanBert
      @TymanBert 2 місяці тому +1

      We all hate Jesse!

    • @Spectrik
      @Spectrik Місяць тому +6

      ​@UnwantedGhost1-anz25 lol, yeah, it's like every decision made was to make it so Jesse survives, but just barely. Jesse (and Walt) were so close to dying so often. it's no surprise that a single change would result in their deaths.

    • @inwector
      @inwector 19 днів тому

      Jesse didn't make it easier to himself, when he became a rat.

  • @MCSRIFF563
    @MCSRIFF563 11 місяців тому +1181

    what if don hector never shot max i feel that one would be interesting

    • @Enno9
      @Enno9 11 місяців тому +22

      Good idea

    • @grug-gaming
      @grug-gaming 11 місяців тому +69

      Im not sure how that would be done since we no nothing bout his character but it murge he could make it work so good idea

    • @tjp0623
      @tjp0623 11 місяців тому +25

      @@grug-gamingI think all we know is that he was Gus’ lover

    • @tjp0623
      @tjp0623 11 місяців тому +20

      Maybe Gus would have more emotion/sympathy for others

    • @snowarmth
      @snowarmth 11 місяців тому +68

      @@grug-gaming If you watch the episode of his death, we learn that Max had an education in chemistry thanks to Gus, and he was Gus' methamphetamine manufacturer! That's a big deal! If Max never died, Gus wouldn't need Walt or Gale or anyone unless he wants to multiply the amount of cooks he has. This is probably the most extreme butterfly case scenario that can be altered by this channel lol

  • @mahino420
    @mahino420 10 місяців тому +170

    i would have loved if walt told them "hank is my brother in law, he helps me hide under the radar of the DEA, his partner was corrupt too" maybe they would let him live or try to work with him

    • @LarsLarsen77
      @LarsLarsen77 6 місяців тому +8

      He was helping him by handcuffing him? LOL No.

    • @mahino420
      @mahino420 6 місяців тому +22

      @@LarsLarsen77 well they don't know who cuffed him and Walt has shown before he can make stories out of thin air, him thinking they will let a DEA agent live was dumbest thing he did in the show (I get it though he was emotionally motivated)

    • @lzi9452
      @lzi9452 3 місяці тому +2

      @@LarsLarsen77could say it was Steve Gomes

    • @mrindeed247
      @mrindeed247 2 місяці тому +12

      hank would just say something to be a smartass and he'll get shot faster

    • @JesusLopez-cg2gq
      @JesusLopez-cg2gq 2 місяці тому

      @@mrindeed247 no kizzy😂!! That mf wanted to die soo fast like Bruh💀shut upp😭 but nah “I got my DEA pride bro🤓👌🏾!!” 🤣😭🤮🤡

  • @a_normal_georgian
    @a_normal_georgian 11 місяців тому +54

    I'm convinced that killing Jessie is a Canon event at this point

  • @HazeAbysmal
    @HazeAbysmal 11 місяців тому +132

    Walt is dead basically. Only way I see this playing out is when Hank says "you bet the calvery's coming", Jack is like "uh oh" and leaves saying "sorry walt, you on your own lol"
    Then Jack knowing Walt has a DEA brother in law, Jack would definitely have Walt killed when he finds out he's in prison and will likely talk.

    • @CapitanJorge24
      @CapitanJorge24 11 місяців тому +5

      LMAO

    • @HazeAbysmal
      @HazeAbysmal 11 місяців тому +2

      @@CapitanJorge24 what's so le funny? :D

    • @CapitanJorge24
      @CapitanJorge24 11 місяців тому +8

      @@HazeAbysmal when you said "sorry walt you're on your own"

    • @HazeAbysmal
      @HazeAbysmal 11 місяців тому +6

      @@CapitanJorge24 sounds like something he'd say if he felt the cops were coming. He'd def leave walt behind :D

    • @supernintendo182
      @supernintendo182 11 місяців тому +9

      I think Jack would've just killed Hank AND Walt on the spot and ran. If they take Walt's car away they would quickly find Jesse and kill him too if they didn't already run him over. No way they would risk being witnessed by the cops or leave any witnesses alive.

  • @profesionalz
    @profesionalz 10 місяців тому +356

    Now that I remember... Marie had confessed to her therapist Dave that she had thought of poisoning Walter when she found out that he was a drug lord. What would have happened if Marie had managed to kill Walter White by poisoning? Sounds like a pretty interesting What If concept

    • @nathanclaessen14
      @nathanclaessen14 10 місяців тому +44

      Marie would’ve never actually done it. Like she said, she wouldn’t actually hurt anyone, it just “feels good to think about it”. It would be a cool what-if but I can’t imagine it realistically happening

    • @ContactsNfilters
      @ContactsNfilters 7 місяців тому +10

      ​@@nathanclaessen14what if Walt killed himself when Marie told him too?

    • @brianlavalley3983
      @brianlavalley3983 6 місяців тому

      Marie is incompetent. Even if she did successfully kill him she'd be arrested in a second

    • @cassiusfelix2805
      @cassiusfelix2805 4 місяці тому +1

      I love that idea

    • @UnwantedGhost1-anz25
      @UnwantedGhost1-anz25 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@ContactsNfilters Then everything that happened after that scene caused by Walter doesn't happen.

  • @andrewgardiner1077
    @andrewgardiner1077 10 місяців тому +62

    - What if Walt didn’t let Jane die?
    - What if Nacho killed Bolsa as well, before committing suicide?
    - What if Hector died from his stroke?
    - What if Jesse killed Todd in the desert during the “El Camino” flashback?

    • @KOTEBANAROT
      @KOTEBANAROT 10 місяців тому +6

      He already done the first one. Basically jane and jesse both die and walter is sad

    • @GhuppyLord
      @GhuppyLord 9 місяців тому +2

      this is my response in my head thinking on what could have happened
      -jesse and jane would have either left the country/or overdosed on drugs leaving walt without a partner
      - at that point in time bolsa was defending gus's actions and supporting the middle ground between gus and salamancas so without him it would have gone really bad between the two groups without him to seperate them
      - hector was slowly loosing his control over the marjority of the cartel so he was getting more reckless and the cartel would have realised this eventually and 'dealt' with him meaning gus would have just been very angry that hector didnt suffer
      - in the desert that was just after jesse learnt where todds money was stored at his apartment so he would have killed him drove back to his apartment and did what he did in el camino with less complications and jacks gang would have still been alive but without formular to cook so the blue would have stopped being passed around walt would have returned home to give his remaining money to gretchen and elliot just as he did but badger and skinny pete would have not said anything about the blue (which caused him to go free jesse as he did), then after giving his money to gretchen and elliot he would have turned himself in which was his original plan
      hope this helps give you a bit of an idea what could have happened👍

  • @sword7305
    @sword7305 11 місяців тому +653

    this one really deserves a part 2 as the scenario is very well written but feels very underwhelming at the end, Great job as always murge!

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +104

      Yeah I agree and july is the month for me finishing my sequal videos, so stay tuned i have three that i can thi nk of

    • @conservativecatholic9030
      @conservativecatholic9030 11 місяців тому +24

      @@murgeproductionsI think it would very much depend on Skyler. Walt. Jr. would want Uncle Hank to go down hard after seeing that video. Skyler would be upset about that video getting out. The question would be, would she tell the truth? She would have a lot to lose in the car wash. Honestly, I think it’s possible she would let Hank go down, but it’s hard to say.

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +23

      That’s why i made it a cliff hanger, because i have to think about how I want to go about it, but I believe skylar would side with her son.
      But I have to rewatch that confession,

    • @TheEpicSpire
      @TheEpicSpire 11 місяців тому +13

      @@murgeproductions keep i n mind that they don't know what happened to walt. would Skyler be scared that walt is alive and would hurt her if she sided with hank? Does hank remember Walt saving him, and last being seen with the nazis? a lot of loose ends but this timeline seems very interesting

    • @ryguy4543
      @ryguy4543 3 місяці тому +1

      It doesn’t even make sense. You really think through 11 months of investigation they wouldn’t want to go through his bag?

  • @user-bc7vx2ob1b
    @user-bc7vx2ob1b 8 місяців тому +22

    THE WAY YOU USED THE CONFESSION CD WAS MASTERFUL OMG

  • @noahhobson4521
    @noahhobson4521 11 місяців тому +289

    I would like it if you didn't kill Jesse as much, but his problem is that there are a lot of times in the series where the obvious solution to a lot of ruthless people's problems is murder Jesse Pinkman.
    As a thought, what if Walter miscalculates when he confronts Tuco with the fulminate of mercury and kills everyone in the room including himself.

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +67

      agreed, i kill Jesse when it makes sense to the story and i like your idea definetly on the list

    • @philleotardo7016
      @philleotardo7016 11 місяців тому +14

      @@murgeproductionscan you do a scenario where crazy 8 kills Jesse because he doesn’t want his cousin to know he’s a rat?

    • @kraemerrseviltwin5768
      @kraemerrseviltwin5768 11 місяців тому +5

      He’s in the game tho.

    • @NationalA
      @NationalA 11 місяців тому +3

      what if walt was shot while holding the door with his back? or what if tuco never kidnapped waltuh?

    • @ketomine.
      @ketomine. 11 місяців тому +10

      to be fair that was his original destiny, and it works to show the collateral damage

  • @moviefanjay
    @moviefanjay 11 місяців тому +25

    This might be your biggest cliffhanger so far

  • @Crazy56U
    @Crazy56U 11 місяців тому +225

    Here’s a wacky suggestion: What if Wayfarer 515 happened a few minutes earlier?
    (Specifically, what if the plane collision happened while Skyler was letting Walt know she found out about his lies?)

    • @HazeAbysmal
      @HazeAbysmal 11 місяців тому +45

      skyler: was this you? what happened?
      walt: "i won"

    • @wabc2336
      @wabc2336 10 місяців тому +12

      @@HazeAbysmal Bro won over Mr Margolis and all the citizens of the airplane

  • @LyricalViking
    @LyricalViking 11 місяців тому +41

    What if Walt didn't snitch on Jesse being under the car and "gave him a chance"

  • @bwwestman
    @bwwestman 11 місяців тому +33

    Jack says to Jesse: What kind of man talks to the DEA? No man at all.
    All joking aside, this is a good alternate plot.

    • @G.A.C_Preserve
      @G.A.C_Preserve Місяць тому +1

      Ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding, Jesse 💥💥💥💥

  • @Debatra.
    @Debatra. 6 місяців тому +12

    Jack let Walt walk away after killing Hank and stealing 7/8 of his money, but kills him after making a deal with him that got him the other 1/8 as well? He had even LESS reason to kill Walt here than he did in the actual show.

    • @Delta_Aves
      @Delta_Aves 3 місяці тому +1

      Walt was more of a liability there than in the show. He was also probably in a bad mood.

  • @Tworelzza
    @Tworelzza 8 місяців тому +6

    Bro literally breaking the canon events 💀

  • @dodowhisperer2114
    @dodowhisperer2114 5 місяців тому +10

    Bro you can't just leave us on a cliff hanger like that

  • @TheStudioArchitect
    @TheStudioArchitect 11 місяців тому +296

    The premiere _just_ finished, and here's my thoughts:
    This was really interesting, but also sad, and a bit underwhelming. It's sad for Walt and Jesse because of how much pain they went through, only to be put in barrels and forgotten about. It's interesting because of the potential storyline here, Hank being the only witness to that shootout, Walt and Jesse missing, Walt Jr. finding the confession tape, etc. The story has a lot of directions it could go and I feel like it has a lot of potential. But where the underwhelming part comes in is the ending. It's more or less a cliffhanger than an ending. Walt Jr. finding the confession tape is a REALLY good plot twist! But, we need a part 2. Because this story had a very underwhelming ending, and it doesn't have a satisfying conclusion.
    I imagine this will be a "What if Mike killed Tuco?" kind of thing, where it's one of the bigger stories so it's gonna take longer to complete. If that is the case, I cannot wait! :D
    But overall, excellent video man! It made me feel a lot of emotions. Mostly sadness for Walt and Jesse though. Especially Jesse, since he was the victim in all of this. Can't wait for (a potential) part 2!

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +58

      love your thoughts and appreciate the feed back and im going to spend july working on sequel videos to tie up these loose ends

    • @TheStudioArchitect
      @TheStudioArchitect 11 місяців тому +6

      @@murgeproductions Well then I can't wait man! Have a great day, and thank you! :D

    • @spacenguns
      @spacenguns 11 місяців тому +7

      ​@@murgeproductionswhat if Jimmy stole the 1.4m usd at better call Saul season 1?

    • @vandien3834
      @vandien3834 11 місяців тому +6

      @@murgeproductions I don't really see any loose ends. The video ends at the right point. The tape convicts Hank, Marie and Skyler forever have a serious rift that can't be mended, Walt Jr probably ends up on drugs or something. There's no need for a sequel on this one.

    • @LiamAnthony_
      @LiamAnthony_ 11 місяців тому +4

      Honestly, I dont think there's a lot more to go on this one. Walt Jr either confronts Skyler about the DVD, who'd either have to play along or tell him it was the truth (which from Walr Jr's perspective is even more unbelievable) or he takes the DVD straight to the police, which just further incriminates Hank (Well, both would likely happen, just switching the order). Hank gets convicted and Marie breaks contact with them.

  • @LordBloodraven
    @LordBloodraven 8 місяців тому +7

    I think Jack would've kept Walt alive until he knew Todd could achieve a legitimate blue tint purity in his cooks.

  • @oskaranddaniel7582
    @oskaranddaniel7582 11 місяців тому +146

    What if combo survived the gunshot?
    What if Lydia's hit on Mike succeeded?
    What if the skater twins got the kettlmans car?
    What if the assassins killed lalo?
    What if Hank got in the RV?
    What if Max was never killed?

    • @mappingshaman5280
      @mappingshaman5280 11 місяців тому +5

      Honestly the only thing that changes with the assassins killing lalo, is lalo doesn't kill howard and all the consequences of that don't happen. This video would be better framed as "what if lalo didn't kill howard?"

    • @oskaranddaniel7582
      @oskaranddaniel7582 10 місяців тому +3

      @@mappingshaman5280 you do realise that will also allow nacho to continue being a pawn for Gus Fring which changes a lot in Breaking bad

    • @mappingshaman5280
      @mappingshaman5280 10 місяців тому +5

      @@oskaranddaniel7582 no it doesn't. The salamanca twins will still think he killed lalo like in the OG timeline.

    • @oskaranddaniel7582
      @oskaranddaniel7582 10 місяців тому

      @@mappingshaman5280 they would blame some other gang and make some story up about nacho and why the gate was open

    • @mappingshaman5280
      @mappingshaman5280 10 місяців тому +2

      @@oskaranddaniel7582 then why did that not happen in the original timeline?
      Seriously I don't think you understand the early part of season 6.
      The twins assumed lalo is dead. They did not see nacho's body. They made the logical assumption he was a rat.
      How does lalo actually being dead change any of that?

  • @elwynnshino7383
    @elwynnshino7383 10 місяців тому +55

    I need a sequel to this story. I'm even more interested in where this progresses

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  10 місяців тому +12

      Working on it, it’s definitely coming in July

    • @armandogocaj5613
      @armandogocaj5613 10 місяців тому +3

      Breaking bad next generations 🤣

  • @thebemstar7636
    @thebemstar7636 11 місяців тому +20

    Another dark. I can see Jack's decision sure going to lead to much terrible thing in both version. It's like killing Hank was a better choice and the cliffhanger ending here was so nice mystery touch. It's leave us think on our own again

  • @closetdoorman
    @closetdoorman 11 місяців тому +8

    9:59 is truly the moment jesse pinkman became howard hamlin

  • @jdrobinson3468
    @jdrobinson3468 11 місяців тому +13

    Well this outcome turned out more disturbing than I thought it would be.

  • @ecritdelajaponographie8565
    @ecritdelajaponographie8565 11 місяців тому +23

    The ending doesn't really hold up. Flynn may not be on speaking terms with his mom and aunt, but he's probably smart enough to see that the former is not in any mood to lie for the latter or her husband, so unless Flynn goes and starts spreading rumours at school(?), he would quickly be told, and have no reason not to believe, that the confession tape was a deliberate ploy to intimidate Hank.

  • @sammy_khalaf
    @sammy_khalaf 11 місяців тому +91

    What if Hector died at the end of season 3?
    What if Mike killed Hector and the twins?
    What if Kim was in Breaking Bad?
    What if Mike killed Lydia?
    What if Jesse didn’t leave the business?
    What if Mike was able to get along with Walt?

    • @bearpoop720
      @bearpoop720 10 місяців тому +8

      First 3 seem kinda random

    • @el1n3
      @el1n3 4 місяці тому +1

      @@bearpoop720 not random, its referencing better call saul. hector has a stroke and nearly dies in season 3 finale (resulting in his paralysis) but is saved due to gus's intervention. mike was going to kill hector and the twins but again gus intervenes and stops him.

    • @bearpoop720
      @bearpoop720 4 місяці тому

      @@el1n3 I've watched BCS don't explain to me. If Kim was in BB what difference would it make. Only way I see her returning is if Saul Goodman never truly manifests within Jimmy. The other 2, are just what if BB didn't have these villains.

    • @el1n3
      @el1n3 3 місяці тому +1

      @@bearpoop720 if you claim to have seen the show... literally how is it random.
      the events in bb would transpire differently if even a single member of the salamanca family was killed off earlier. because they are, quite literally, the overarching antagonists in the show that are the cause for many butterfly effects. its an interesting thesis to delve into.
      while i do agree that kim's presence in breaking bad would serve little to no narrative purpose except shock value, these are what if scenarios. they're for fun and speculation. however if kim was somehow in bb by some off-chance, then saul's story would've definitely turned out very differently.

    • @UnwantedGhost1-anz25
      @UnwantedGhost1-anz25 2 місяці тому

      ​@@bearpoop720 The second one happened in "What if Mike killed Hector?'

  • @Sheikh_Speare
    @Sheikh_Speare 11 місяців тому +7

    Had to rewatch Walt's Confession just to get an idea on what Flynn would be thinking watching the video.

  • @declanmacpherson9276
    @declanmacpherson9276 11 місяців тому +22

    here's a good one: what if Howard hired jimmy for sandpiper in spite of chuck?

  • @Jacob-23
    @Jacob-23 9 місяців тому +4

    What if Jack and his gang never came to the desert

  • @animegamerjace9851
    @animegamerjace9851 11 місяців тому +56

    Todd of all people being the one that killed Walt was shocking😳

    • @thebemstar7636
      @thebemstar7636 11 місяців тому +9

      Totally felt. He was the mix of being nice and vile at the same time

  • @mude_dadude87
    @mude_dadude87 11 місяців тому +16

    When I watch your videos...I realise that everything went almost perfect for Walt and that
    the slightiest change of his actions or other characters actions almost everytime leads for his death or Jesse's lol

    • @SomeGuyWhoPlaysGames333
      @SomeGuyWhoPlaysGames333 10 місяців тому

      “Everything went almost perfect.” Except for Hank getting killed, his whole family hating him and him losing a vast majority of his money.

    • @joem.6940
      @joem.6940 10 місяців тому

      @@SomeGuyWhoPlaysGames333 it could've been worse lmao

  • @TheShadowGames854
    @TheShadowGames854 11 місяців тому +18

    What if they killed Lydia to early when they thought she put the tracking device on the barrels.
    What if hank went to el paso.

  • @fmdesperado6110
    @fmdesperado6110 11 місяців тому +16

    What if Jimmy died in the events of batman?
    What if Marco didn't die?
    What if Skyler didn't take the money and gave it to Ted?

    • @fmdesperado6110
      @fmdesperado6110 11 місяців тому +7

      *what if Jimmy died in the events of Bagman

  • @katonaj114
    @katonaj114 11 місяців тому +33

    Some ideas for the next “What if” videos (maybe you did some of them already)
    - What if Hank didn’t have to take a 💩
    - What if Chuck didn’t take out Jimmy from the prison, and Jimmy never become a lawyer?
    - What if the dirty cops managed to kill Mike?
    - What if Nacho didn’t want to poison Hector?
    - What if Tuco managed to kill Hank?

    • @KeyUploads
      @KeyUploads 11 місяців тому +9

      1. He pissed on the book instead by accident and he checked it before trying to fixing it because he is... Hank.
      2. He defecates through a sunroof again
      3. Mike's middle fingers move up and then avenge him by moving like a bullet with each one shooting the other one
      4. He probably gets killed by him due to protecting his father.
      5. Walter finds Jesse as the reason of Hank's death the same way in S5E14, but takes his anger on his friends as a punishment for him, then he goes against Tuco.

  • @richclarkson8917
    @richclarkson8917 11 місяців тому +10

    That's a good what if theory. Though instead I'd have the gang keep walter as there cook, similar to what they did with Jessie.

    • @Delta_Aves
      @Delta_Aves 11 місяців тому

      Walt having a DEA brother-in-law was too much of a liability for them.

    • @richclarkson8917
      @richclarkson8917 10 місяців тому

      Depends on the fine meth walt will cook for them, plus walt's cancer that they will notice as the weeks go by.

  • @GP12810
    @GP12810 10 місяців тому +10

    PLEASE MAKE A PART 2! I'd love for this to be continued, great story telling potential! Loved this one ❤

  • @hyde5213
    @hyde5213 8 місяців тому +2

    "Do what you gotta do."
    "Well, now that I think about it, I don't gotta do it, huh? So long, Agent Schrader!"

  • @feiwnakausvkaxbdkebkswowbq8331
    @feiwnakausvkaxbdkebkswowbq8331 11 місяців тому +35

    1. Jesse wouldn’t be taken by the Nazis because Walt won’t be angry at him.
    2. Hank would probably let Walt be free realizing he had good intentions at first. Or he’d give Walter some kinda plea deal.
    3. Walter would either be in jail, or in Witness protection. Either way he still has his family’s respect and probably get Skylar to forgive him.

  • @maxwelll1137
    @maxwelll1137 11 місяців тому +8

    What if Hank never found the Walt Whitman book in Walter' s bathroom

  • @hey8479
    @hey8479 11 місяців тому +21

    What if hank accidentally beaten Jesse to death in season 3 episode 7?

  • @teawa_
    @teawa_ 11 місяців тому +5

    Yoo that gunshot sound effect took me into the scene, I felt Walters heart shatter

  • @gryphonnystrom2973
    @gryphonnystrom2973 11 місяців тому +18

    Murge is Vince's adopted son with the amount of script he wrights for these vids

    • @murgeproductions
      @murgeproductions  11 місяців тому +6

      he did say he was getting milk and never came back lol

  • @wabc2336
    @wabc2336 10 місяців тому +10

    Thing is, Hank would know that Walter was talking to a guy named Jack. Being an excellent cop and working with his boss who trusts him, even if the public no longer trusts him, Hank would track down Jack and possibly bring him in for questioning regarding Walter White

    • @Grumpollion
      @Grumpollion 10 місяців тому +5

      Hank also has undoubtedly noted the license plates of every car present at the shootout.

  • @tonydoinstuff
    @tonydoinstuff 10 місяців тому +8

    Fantastic what-if! The shit-storm that would be caused by that DVD is unfathomable! Very good stuff. Vince Gil would be proud

  • @abluecar5375
    @abluecar5375 11 місяців тому +7

    "Do you wish I don't kill Jesse so much"
    Yes lmao

  • @whatifgaming1661
    @whatifgaming1661 11 місяців тому +18

    We should really get a part 2, i think theres potential for something interesting with the confession. Either way though great video

  • @themoviemobster9148
    @themoviemobster9148 10 місяців тому +5

    I still can't get over how dark some of these get.
    Great what if Murge! Can't wait for part 2!

  • @TKG785
    @TKG785 10 місяців тому +9

    What if Gus never suspected Lalo survived? In order for that to happen, Hector would have to not smile at Gus so much and actually keep his poker face, thus confirming no one was coming to get Gus.
    What if Walt (reluctantly) became a mole for the DEA? Instead of telling Skyler that he is the danger, the two talk about how to break the news of his drug dealings lightly to Hank and now Walt is going to be a man on the inside.

  • @jamesjoe1690
    @jamesjoe1690 11 місяців тому +6

    Man hmwalt and jesse were knocking on deaths door through this entire story. One single change and it ends up with both of them dead

  • @oscargermaine9221
    @oscargermaine9221 6 місяців тому +1

    Excellent. I could literally see the scenes playing out in my head as you read them

  • @Unknown0525
    @Unknown0525 10 місяців тому +6

    What if Walter never entered remission?
    What if Walter’s cancer never came back?

  • @Jared_Wignall
    @Jared_Wignall 11 місяців тому +6

    This is an interesting idea I never thought would be a video. Great video man!

  • @Alex_-_148
    @Alex_-_148 11 місяців тому +4

    Hey murge ,you Could do a second part of this story , about what will happen to walter Jr after seeing the confession tape , this was probably the best what if ending that you ever done , i love your work man.

  • @AnonimanPiotr
    @AnonimanPiotr 10 місяців тому +5

    What if Jessie convinced Tuco to eat the poison?

  • @mickeydoodle69
    @mickeydoodle69 7 місяців тому +2

    Dude. This is your best yet. You really nail Jack.

  • @volnartheunforgiving3952
    @volnartheunforgiving3952 9 місяців тому +2

    These are great, always very well written

  • @brandonfly4611
    @brandonfly4611 11 місяців тому +5

    Idk if you've already done this, but maybe ypu could try
    "What if Walter and Jesse went to Mexico to cook for Tuco?"
    So basically they take up tucos offer from season 2 ep 2.
    Rlly love the content btw, keep it up!

  • @jamesgoodman3192
    @jamesgoodman3192 11 місяців тому +6

    What if Walt’s ego didn’t grow like it did in season 5 (basically season 4 Walt in season 5)

  • @chrisreed4661
    @chrisreed4661 11 місяців тому +12

    What if Walt had died sooner, as if his cancer got worse after the events of 4 days out. What would Jesse do with the meth they cooked and if Jesse would give walts family the money

    • @KOTEBANAROT
      @KOTEBANAROT 10 місяців тому

      Man that would be a fun story. I really dont know if jesse could think far enough ahead to NOT simply drop the money off on their porch leaving skyler absolutely flabbergasted. If she notices jesse, then shed probably get him to spill the beans and man that would be such a shock. But then shed realize she has to launder the money somehow, maybe forcing jesse to help her... the adventures of jesse and mrs white

  • @nejamin
    @nejamin 8 місяців тому +4

    This was awesome, took me back to the days of reading fanfiction. Nice story telling, dude!

  • @ChevyboyCaprice_
    @ChevyboyCaprice_ 7 місяців тому +2

    Mane, you come up with believable scenarios for the series, also you do some on point impressions for Jack and for Hank in your other video

  • @Nodosch
    @Nodosch День тому

    Bro should write a show😭 I really thought there's no way you could make this good but again, it's amazing and the ending with Walt Jr. And the confession tape was just🤌

  • @johnathangong5463
    @johnathangong5463 8 місяців тому +2

    dude. this is the first video of yours i’ve ever seen. amazing work, such creativity! i’m gonna go ahead and end the comment here. have to binge your other stuff lmao

  • @Big-guy1981
    @Big-guy1981 Місяць тому +2

    This ending - while unlikely - is more respectful towards the character.

  • @swron_rules
    @swron_rules 10 місяців тому +4

    A different way you could have done this was having hank be the inside man for Walter. Having Walter saying Hank was his inside man and having Hank go with it knowing the only other way out would be a bullet in the head.

  • @optisyde284
    @optisyde284 11 місяців тому +2

    the way my jaw dropped when the CD showed up at the end was wild

  • @DrMosseeay
    @DrMosseeay 10 місяців тому +2

    My goodness, this feels like your masterpiece..! I love it. Great work..! 👏

  • @butters849
    @butters849 11 місяців тому +18

    Will you have a part 2? This one feels like a cliffhanger.

  • @thenamesianna
    @thenamesianna 11 місяців тому +6

    Oh this won't end well , the best case scenario at that point was the canon Breaking Bad ending.

  • @InvaderDeegan
    @InvaderDeegan 10 місяців тому +45

    One I'm kinda surprised you hadn't done yet: What if Gus didn't die? I feel like two versions of this have potential:
    The realistic one, where the bomb simply fails to go off, and the less realistic one, where Gus is horrifically scarred, yet still alive after the explosion.

    • @itaynaveh880
      @itaynaveh880 10 місяців тому +8

      Or if he took tyrus offer to do it by himself

    • @metaluigi423
      @metaluigi423 10 місяців тому +3

      Gus could’ve been the Two-Face of Albuquerque.

    • @squidwardfromua
      @squidwardfromua 7 місяців тому

      I don't think the Gus surviving is so unrealistic though, pipe bomb isn't the thing powerful enough to guaranteed kill everyone in the room, so canonically Gus got a bit unlucky.
      What I always think of though, is the pipe bomb is surely not powerful enough to kill the car passengers, so Gus would definitely have survive that case of bombing if he used the car.

  • @Robsli479
    @Robsli479 9 місяців тому +2

    This one, was absolutely fire.

  • @taylorkeeton9602
    @taylorkeeton9602 11 місяців тому +4

    Great job leaving this open ended! Your content keeps getting better.

  • @Tappedddddddd-rt
    @Tappedddddddd-rt 3 місяці тому +1

    Damn just seen this video today and your actually so underated surprised you dont have more views and subs as these What If videos are well good keep it up man 🔥

  • @henry9020
    @henry9020 11 місяців тому +2

    Another Murge Production masterpiece🙌

  • @newtthelizardwizard
    @newtthelizardwizard 10 місяців тому +4

    This is such a great series dude, you've got a great voice and these are always super creative and fun to watch.
    Some scenarios that I've thought about: 1.) what if Skyler never gave Ted Walt's money? At this point Walt can actually attempt to start his whole family's life over (if they'd even be willing) and the consequences of that could be interesting. Not to mention the IRS might have a lead to them with Ted in lock-up. Jesse and Gus are still together, Brock never gets poisoned, and Hank still has a huge target on his back.
    And 2.) what if Skyler never figured out that Walt was a meth cook? This one requires a bit more of a leap but even something as simple as "Walt doesn't let it slip that he has two cellphones" could have ripples. I'd imagine the divorce still happens but if it does then Walt would need someone else to launder his money.
    Again keep up the great work man, have a good one.

  • @HalloweenYearRound
    @HalloweenYearRound 11 місяців тому +5

    Love these videos! You should do one where what if Walt had kept working with Gale in Season 3 and never replaced him with Jesse and stayed in Gus' good graces.

  • @mustardbiscuits9750
    @mustardbiscuits9750 10 місяців тому +2

    I love how you still gave Jr the stutter bro 💀

  • @Norinot1
    @Norinot1 8 місяців тому +3

    I still believe walter is too smart to not know that he was about to die, he would have done something about it. I mean Gus was a much smarter criminal than Jack and the plotting is so obvious, Walter wouldn't have just "let it happen", I do not know what but he would have done something to not die.

  • @SunnyProductions.
    @SunnyProductions. 11 місяців тому +11

    Here’s an interesting one probably, What if Walter didn’t intervene and do a Full Measure at the end of Half Measures?
    Also I will keep asking this but what if Kim didn’t leave Jimmy, and how that would have changed the rest of the HeisenVerse?

  • @louisnall3102
    @louisnall3102 11 місяців тому +6

    One other thing, in this series of events, if Gene Takovic is arrested a couple months later he's most likely going to die.

  • @TheProfessionalReject
    @TheProfessionalReject 8 місяців тому +5

    I feel like it would be cool if they would’ve made like three alternate season fives that are the same up until these points. It would be really cool and everything you’ve said fits what would actually have happened and it’d be so freaking awesome to see an end where the big death is Jesse.

  • @SJ-lu3gc
    @SJ-lu3gc 11 місяців тому +6

    what if walter was a dea agent and hank was the meth dealer

    • @Delta_Aves
      @Delta_Aves 11 місяців тому

      It’d be the same story, just with the roles reversed.

    • @SJ-lu3gc
      @SJ-lu3gc 11 місяців тому +1

      @@Delta_Aves well not really hank in the show isnt the smartest

  • @Spikedog777
    @Spikedog777 11 місяців тому +1

    This might take the place as my favorite, youre only improving as you go.

  • @Daveyk021
    @Daveyk021 8 місяців тому +2

    Like it. That DVD Walt made totally implicated Hank and neither Walt or Jessie are around to let the police know it's fake, Hank sadly goes down for the entire five year story.

    • @TheLewistownTrainspotter8102
      @TheLewistownTrainspotter8102 5 місяців тому

      Nah. Skyler could confirm what parts of the confession tape were real and what was bullshit.
      The only "evidence" of Hank's involvement at this point is Walt's tape. And who is the DEA more likely to believe, their own ASAC or Walt? Especially when you consider that the one thing that would exonerate Hank is the fact that after he got shot, he spent the back half of season 3 and all of season 4 out of commission while he was recovering, and Heisenberg was very active during this time that Hank was in no condition to be doing much beyond tending to his mineral collection.

  • @CommunistCreeper
    @CommunistCreeper 9 місяців тому +2

    this needs a part 2

  • @richmartinez2935
    @richmartinez2935 10 місяців тому +2

    I LOVE this scenario! Excellent Work!!

  • @StalinkTz
    @StalinkTz 11 місяців тому +5

    i've got an idea for a video:
    what if gus never takes jesse with him to casa tranquila? that way walter and jesse wouldn't find a way to make the explosive idea work since they wouldn't find a place where gus goes that isn't being monitored constantly. i think this might be a good idea for a video.

  • @darthpalpaduck
    @darthpalpaduck 11 місяців тому +3

    What if walter jr went out on a breakfast quest

  • @JaysasterGaming
    @JaysasterGaming 7 місяців тому +2

    Walter got a taste of his own medicine, but no one deserves that.

  • @CoderSV3
    @CoderSV3 7 місяців тому +1

    The SECOND you said "Fake news about the DEA being dirty" and why Junior would believe Walt was the cook, I *KNEW* you were gonna go with the confession DVD..

  • @jktacoim5506
    @jktacoim5506 10 місяців тому +2

    what if jesse took jane on her offer to go to meetings. basically what if jesse got clean earlier in the series

  • @mappingshaman5280
    @mappingshaman5280 11 місяців тому +6

    Nice one!
    I feel like after 11 months of walter being missing and her not loving him at that point anyway, skyler would testify in hank's favour. The only consequences are that she would lose the car wash and that walt jr would hate her for a bit, but let's face it that is nothing new.
    Also what happened to Saul in this timeline? Does he just do his gene thing as normal?

  • @millabasset1710
    @millabasset1710 10 місяців тому +2

    I know it gets hard to do these what ifs, even with the ending be logical since Jack and his gang are lowlife thugs, not business frontman like Gus. If Walter could kill Gus, he could easily kill Jack and his gang without the M60. Gus was monitoring Walter and Mike kept tabs on him, Walter still won; Jack was impulsive and sloppy.

  • @Toanon
    @Toanon 11 місяців тому +6

    Particularly dark one: What if Walter and Skyler accidentally stabbed Walter Jr. during their fight?

  • @scrapbrainsinc
    @scrapbrainsinc 8 місяців тому +2

    Good listen, I think you made the story as it should happen. In my world I think I would have really wanted to explore a saved Hank how he would feel toward Walt moving forward. Could he really forgive Walt, knowing he lost everything to save his life? What could their future interactions be? Could there be a way forward, or would everyone sort of fall trap to Walt's world, having Hank sort of giving up and just dealing with Walt and everything he's done.

    • @gabesmath105
      @gabesmath105 7 місяців тому

      He could've not hooked up with jack at all

  • @walterwhite8395
    @walterwhite8395 10 місяців тому +3

    What if Lalo and Gus somehow killed each other at the same time in the episode after Howard death