You were doing so well… I was relatively agreeing with your placement of the stories and then you got to the chibnall Dalek stories 😐 I don’t agree with your placements of them at all sorry 😅…I’ll set that aside for now though as I do agree with your placement of Eve Of The Daleks. Personally the stories I would have placed Lower are Daleks invasion of Earth (overrated imo), day of the Daleks (dreadful imo), destiny of The Daleks (I have a soft spot for it but it has too many flaws to ignore). I’d place all of these in C tier with The Chase (the Chase is shit ngl lol 😂) You’ve included some stories here I don’t personally consider Dalek stories but i respect your opinion. I agree with all of your placements on S tier, though i personally would change them around a bit but overall a good tier list. Idk why you were worried about me not agreeing with your new who placements because i agreed with the majority of them ahah. The think about Destination Skaro I feel like you were a bit too harsh with the comedy bot since it a comedy sketch made for kids on children in need night so it’s targeted towards them 😅. Great video though. Keep calm and Carry on, living the geek life 🤓😎…
See with the Chibnal Stories, I have just never liked them and I really don't the way the Daleks were handled in this Era much either. Like with Resolution & Revolution Of The Daleks, I feel like I made a couple of decent points with those 2 at least for why I dont like them, especially for Revolution god that Episode is a mess I'm sorry lol give me Love And Monsters any day lol So needless to say when I watched Eve Of The Daleks, I was very surprised that I actually liked that one cause it is really good and rrally enjoyable and I was happy that there was at least one Dalek Story in that Era that I liked. In terms of Destination Skaro, yes I am aware that it was for Children In Need, I was in fact watching CIN when it aired. However take look at Born Again or Time Crash as 2 great examples of this, those were both for Chartity as well and still contained comedy, those Minisodes were great... However the very specific comedy in this, was just cringe I'm sorry lol so you cant just pin that on the fact it was for CIN when you have Born Again and Time Crash which are 10x better lol it was the writing and the comedian lol
@ i don’t agree with pretty much anything you said their respectively ahah. I’m gonna pretend you didn’t say that about love and Monsters because no one’s truly that crazy…(jk love you really mate lol 😂) I loved how Chibnall handled the Daleks because he treated them like actual characters which is always a plus for me. He blended the characterisation of the classic and New who Daleks which is another huge plus! I also love how he delved more into the sadistic predatory side of the Daleks. Which makes them feel like an unstoppable threat. A predator stalking its prey. It also puts an emphasis on Dalek purity. The Dalek variants in revolution are called Defence Drone Daleks btw. Again I would argue CIN is more aimed towards children than adults so I don’t think comparing DS to Past skits from the show is that fair considering how much the show has changed over the years. I also say it comes down to your comedic preference it’s not bad necessarily just because you didn’t enjoy it yourself. I respect your opinion though 🫡. Great video as always can’t wait for more xx
Oh I mean it, I would watch Elton dancing to ELO over those Dalek Episodes any day of the week mate lol and honestly did we watch the same Chibnal Episodes? You must have seen them in an alternate reality because the Chibnal Dalek Episodes do not give off any of that at all. The only Daleks that have their own Character in that Era is the Recon and the Traitor in Power Of The Doctor.... and while a Dalek Controlling a person is a cool concept but to do that for nearly the entire Episode was boring to watch omg lol it was actually entertaining when the casing came in. But then that casing was also made in such a short period of time, also built by one person A how did she not die of exhaustion? I feel like she would have, especially given she was also controlled most of the day as well and B htf did they Implement Rockets into a homemade HAND BUILT dalek.... also in a very short period of time.... now rockets on a normal Dalek I can get by but that? On a homemade dalek, built by a Singular Persons Hands? In a very very short period? She would have died of exhaustion man lol its just silly. Revolution, theres so much wrong with it, down to Jack helping the Doctor escape Prision? How did he find her? What the fuck was the point in her being Imprisoned anyway for her to be broken out literally in the first few minutes of seeing her again? That could have made a Fascinating Episode on its own. But no no, Chibnal clearly did not think of that lol. The Daleks fighting eachother was cool but they werent the only Daleks obsessed with Purity and I mean in New Who take the Paradigm Daleks as an example and the Daleks talking to Robinson? Seriously? Dude they would have realised he was bullshitting and killed him lol its such a stupid Episode. To me anyway. If you enjoy it thats fair enough. Im glad you do. Lets agree to disagree and leave at that. In terms of Destination Skaro, I can so compare them to past CIN Minisodes becayse they were all CIN lol and they were all made for kids mate lol I will agree with you however that its 100% a comedic preference as the Comedy in that Story was a very specific kind they went for.
@ erm…no lol 😂 because it’s my own personal opinion and preference as is yours…neither of us are right or wrong because it’s all subjective. I hate when people suggest their point as being an objective opinion (not saying you are specifically it’s just something that bugs me) I’m sorry but I just don’t agree with your analysis of the Chibnall Dalek stories. You are being too pedantic tbh (and that’s coming from me I’m incredibly pedantic trust me so it’s ironic I’m even saying that). It’s not wrong for me to love the Chibnall era Dalek stories, nor is it wrong for you not to. It’s our personal preference at the end of the day…to each their own as they say. Can’t wait for the next one mate, Don’t forget to Keep Calm And Carry On, Living The Geek Like 🤓😎…xx
@@TheWhovinerd-1963 Dude I didnt say it was wrong for you to like the Chibnal Era Episodes I literally said "its such a stupid Episode. To me anyway. If you enjoy it thats fair enough. Im glad you do. Lets agree to disagree and leave at that" I never said anything about your opinion being wrong mate lol please do not twist words.
The daleks in colour disappointed me, maybe it’s the way they added dialogue to explain everything but I’d take the episode too long original all day long, I don’t get why they couldn’t just re colour the whole episode anyway. Still waiting on an animated daleks master plan so we can have all dalek stories complete in some form 🤞🏻
I mean that's fair enough, as I said in the vid, I do still think that the edit was quite rough and the New Music Score was good but they should have turned it down a bit because you could barely hear people speak in certain Scenes. On top of that, the Colour was great, however they could have turned the Vibrance down a little bit too, as I think it was a bit tooo bright. In terms of the Story, the Original is a chore to get through sometmes with the sheer amount of padding this Story had, you could have taken out an entire Episode and have it be a 6 Parter and that might have actually helped the pace a bit. Because its not that I dont like longer Stories, as I am a massive fan of The War Games which is 10 Episodes but the difference between that Story and the Daleks is even though it admittedly, has some badding itself the overall Story flows a lot better in The War Games, it feels a lot more fluid but with The Daleks the padding is far more obvious and it shows and drags the Story down. And an Aninated Master Plan would be great, hopefully we get one in the near Future cause the Photo Recons are terrible to through lol
You were doing so well…
I was relatively agreeing with your placement of the stories and then you got to the chibnall Dalek stories 😐 I don’t agree with your placements of them at all sorry 😅…I’ll set that aside for now though as I do agree with your placement of Eve Of The Daleks.
Personally the stories I would have placed Lower are Daleks invasion of Earth (overrated imo), day of the Daleks (dreadful imo), destiny of The Daleks (I have a soft spot for it but it has too many flaws to ignore). I’d place all of these in C tier with The Chase (the Chase is shit ngl lol 😂)
You’ve included some stories here I don’t personally consider Dalek stories but i respect your opinion.
I agree with all of your placements on S tier, though i personally would change them around a bit but overall a good tier list.
Idk why you were worried about me not agreeing with your new who placements because i agreed with the majority of them ahah.
The think about Destination Skaro I feel like you were a bit too harsh with the comedy bot since it a comedy sketch made for kids on children in need night so it’s targeted towards them 😅.
Great video though. Keep calm and Carry on, living the geek life 🤓😎…
See with the Chibnal Stories, I have just never liked them and I really don't the way the Daleks were handled in this Era much either. Like with Resolution & Revolution Of The Daleks, I feel like I made a couple of decent points with those 2 at least for why I dont like them, especially for Revolution god that Episode is a mess I'm sorry lol give me Love And Monsters any day lol
So needless to say when I watched Eve Of The Daleks, I was very surprised that I actually liked that one cause it is really good and rrally enjoyable and I was happy that there was at least one Dalek Story in that Era that I liked.
In terms of Destination Skaro, yes I am aware that it was for Children In Need, I was in fact watching CIN when it aired. However take look at Born Again or Time Crash as 2 great examples of this, those were both for Chartity as well and still contained comedy, those Minisodes were great... However the very specific comedy in this, was just cringe I'm sorry lol so you cant just pin that on the fact it was for CIN when you have Born Again and Time Crash which are 10x better lol it was the writing and the comedian lol
@ i don’t agree with pretty much anything you said their respectively ahah.
I’m gonna pretend you didn’t say that about love and Monsters because no one’s truly that crazy…(jk love you really mate lol 😂) I loved how Chibnall handled the Daleks because he treated them like actual characters which is always a plus for me. He blended the characterisation of the classic and New who Daleks which is another huge plus! I also love how he delved more into the sadistic predatory side of the Daleks. Which makes them feel like an unstoppable threat. A predator stalking its prey. It also puts an emphasis on Dalek purity. The Dalek variants in revolution are called Defence Drone Daleks btw.
Again I would argue CIN is more aimed towards children than adults so I don’t think comparing DS to Past skits from the show is that fair considering how much the show has changed over the years. I also say it comes down to your comedic preference it’s not bad necessarily just because you didn’t enjoy it yourself. I respect your opinion though 🫡.
Great video as always can’t wait for more xx
Oh I mean it, I would watch Elton dancing to ELO over those Dalek Episodes any day of the week mate lol and honestly did we watch the same Chibnal Episodes? You must have seen them in an alternate reality because the Chibnal Dalek Episodes do not give off any of that at all. The only Daleks that have their own Character in that Era is the Recon and the Traitor in Power Of The Doctor.... and while a Dalek Controlling a person is a cool concept but to do that for nearly the entire Episode was boring to watch omg lol it was actually entertaining when the casing came in. But then that casing was also made in such a short period of time, also built by one person A how did she not die of exhaustion? I feel like she would have, especially given she was also controlled most of the day as well and B htf did they Implement Rockets into a homemade HAND BUILT dalek.... also in a very short period of time.... now rockets on a normal Dalek I can get by but that? On a homemade dalek, built by a Singular Persons Hands? In a very very short period? She would have died of exhaustion man lol its just silly.
Revolution, theres so much wrong with it, down to Jack helping the Doctor escape Prision? How did he find her? What the fuck was the point in her being Imprisoned anyway for her to be broken out literally in the first few minutes of seeing her again? That could have made a Fascinating Episode on its own. But no no, Chibnal clearly did not think of that lol. The Daleks fighting eachother was cool but they werent the only Daleks obsessed with Purity and I mean in New Who take the Paradigm Daleks as an example and the Daleks talking to Robinson? Seriously? Dude they would have realised he was bullshitting and killed him lol its such a stupid Episode. To me anyway. If you enjoy it thats fair enough. Im glad you do. Lets agree to disagree and leave at that.
In terms of Destination Skaro, I can so compare them to past CIN Minisodes becayse they were all CIN lol and they were all made for kids mate lol
I will agree with you however that its 100% a comedic preference as the Comedy in that Story was a very specific kind they went for.
@ erm…no lol 😂 because it’s my own personal opinion and preference as is yours…neither of us are right or wrong because it’s all subjective. I hate when people suggest their point as being an objective opinion (not saying you are specifically it’s just something that bugs me) I’m sorry but I just don’t agree with your analysis of the Chibnall Dalek stories. You are being too pedantic tbh (and that’s coming from me I’m incredibly pedantic trust me so it’s ironic I’m even saying that). It’s not wrong for me to love the Chibnall era Dalek stories, nor is it wrong for you not to. It’s our personal preference at the end of the day…to each their own as they say.
Can’t wait for the next one mate, Don’t forget to Keep Calm And Carry On, Living The Geek Like 🤓😎…xx
@@TheWhovinerd-1963 Dude I didnt say it was wrong for you to like the Chibnal Era Episodes I literally said "its such a stupid Episode. To me anyway. If you enjoy it thats fair enough. Im glad you do. Lets agree to disagree and leave at that" I never said anything about your opinion being wrong mate lol please do not twist words.
The daleks in colour disappointed me, maybe it’s the way they added dialogue to explain everything but I’d take the episode too long original all day long, I don’t get why they couldn’t just re colour the whole episode anyway. Still waiting on an animated daleks master plan so we can have all dalek stories complete in some form 🤞🏻
I mean that's fair enough, as I said in the vid, I do still think that the edit was quite rough and the New Music Score was good but they should have turned it down a bit because you could barely hear people speak in certain Scenes.
On top of that, the Colour was great, however they could have turned the Vibrance down a little bit too, as I think it was a bit tooo bright.
In terms of the Story, the Original is a chore to get through sometmes with the sheer amount of padding this Story had, you could have taken out an entire Episode and have it be a 6 Parter and that might have actually helped the pace a bit.
Because its not that I dont like longer Stories, as I am a massive fan of The War Games which is 10 Episodes but the difference between that Story and the Daleks is even though it admittedly, has some badding itself the overall Story flows a lot better in The War Games, it feels a lot more fluid but with The Daleks the padding is far more obvious and it shows and drags the Story down.
And an Aninated Master Plan would be great, hopefully we get one in the near Future cause the Photo Recons are terrible to through lol