Do Ham Radios Need The Internet To Work?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 54

  • @Deano_K5MPG
    @Deano_K5MPG День тому +14

    4:05 winlink is how I was able to notify my wife that I was alive and well during Helene, when our grid was down.

    • @MoondancerRec
      @MoondancerRec 3 години тому

      Good! We created a Packet Winlink/BBS/APRS network in Puerto Rico (KP4DOG). Our nodes report to the master node via RF and that node has Starlink. The BBS/APRS functionality of the network don't need internet to propagate the data, but uses it if it is present. This network was created to solve the lack of telecommunications after Maria hurricane. This way, you could post bulletins and personal messages to the BBS that could be read anywhere on the island through your nearest node. We also have VARA/Ardop nodes on HF, and VARA FM on 6 meters and VHF.

  • @steveblanchard7293
    @steveblanchard7293 День тому +2

    As a SWL I used WSJTX for the first time last night, got a contact from Japan, whilst some were Russia, Italy and France and Spain, along with a couple from the UK where I am. Not bad on 80m for a first effort. I think at nearly 60 I should get my foundation to try this out for real!

  • @naman2000
    @naman2000 День тому +2

    Josh, your stick man drawings are beautiful!
    Great video, thank you for the well presented information.

  • @1958johndeere620
    @1958johndeere620 День тому

    Its good you do these entry level videos. I'm an extra, but realize many are just getting started. All my information about ham radio has come from youtube. Radiohamguy was a huge help to me years ago.

  • @bobsnead1153
    @bobsnead1153 День тому

    As a computer guy, I think the value of the internet becomes obvious if we first use some simple computer concepts to describe traditional radio. Think of RF as the "wire" that connects your radio to the another. It's the means to get information from point A (your radio) to point B (your friend's radio). Repeaters are a way to extend that wire, but really they are part of the wire. The nature of the wire is that it is not really "point to point", though, but "point to many", just like ethernet in the computer world. In the traditional radio world the signal starts as a sound wave that is translated into an RF wave for transmission and then translated back into sound waves. in digital radio we insert another step: our radios (TNCs, or whatever) converts the sound waves into digital bits and then back again. Once information is represented as bits there are more options for the "wire" than just RF. Seen this way, the internet is just a really good way to convey radio generated bits from one point to another.

  • @Ammed_KN6STX
    @Ammed_KN6STX День тому +1

    Nice video Josh!!!

  • @daniell8387
    @daniell8387 День тому +3

    Need? Definitely not. It doesn't need antenna analyzers, 9:1 wire length charts or xiegu g90 cooling stands either. Those things however make it easier and more fun. Technology changes, and anyone who refuses to adopt new things simply because they're new are going to miss out.

  • @aa3konthego
    @aa3konthego День тому

    Everytime those who are less forward looking say something will be the final nail in the ham radio coffin fail to realize we'll find a way to add that thing to our repertoire.

  • @stevesummersell_K4WXX
    @stevesummersell_K4WXX День тому +1

    It’s a great supplement or tool for the hobby, but RF and the ability to work totally stand alone should always take precedent. That being said, I love my ICOMs and D-Star 🙂

  • @stevenpeterson8444
    @stevenpeterson8444 День тому

    good info! i’ve found that digital radio is very poorly explained by hams. i think they’re often so far down the rabbit hole that they don’t think to say things like “push the mode button until it says DV”. they start at “when you’re programming your DG-ID into your repeater…” and newbies like me are immediately lost.

  • @thedoobie1
    @thedoobie1 День тому +2

    Strong Khan Academy vibes on this one. 👍🏼

    • @HamRadioCrashCourse
      @HamRadioCrashCourse  День тому

      Having never seen Khan Academy idk if that is good or bad!

    • @willblack7353
      @willblack7353 3 години тому

      @@HamRadioCrashCourse Incredibly good, it's high-quality free education for all the subjects. Well loved by homeschoolers, public school teachers, and even my macroecon professor.

  • @RB01138
    @RB01138 День тому +1

    Can you do one on offline digital modes? Like ft8 for testing propagation or using a digital hotspot without Internet?

    • @HamRadioCrashCourse
      @HamRadioCrashCourse  День тому

      I have quite a few of those videos already on my channel. Thank you for the support!

  • @RB01138
    @RB01138 День тому +2

    Can you do a video on digital modes without internet? Like using FT8 or pistar, etc!

    • @HH-CA
      @HH-CA 23 години тому

      Good suggestion

  • @jameskelly9243
    @jameskelly9243 День тому

    Thank you

  • @bkreps
    @bkreps 21 годину тому

    Being mindful that the ARRL referred to Amateur Radio as an “art and science,” my opinion is that a real Ham is anyone who earns a license to engage, experiment, innovate, participate, and practice behaviors that promote and protect the privileges granted us through our licenses. The means for manipulating energy to convey voice and data is ours to experiment with, and utilizing a network that is not entirely dependent upon free space is still a legitimate medium, and no less reliable than our solar influenced atmosphere. And now I hope this digitally conveyed message will be received on everyone’s internet connected devices as a strong 59… ;-)

  • @MrBrachius
    @MrBrachius День тому

    If your radio is digitally identifying you by callsign each time you transmit, is it still required that you identify by voice every 10 minutes?

    • @willblack7353
      @willblack7353 3 години тому

      Yes, it's just that the ident can happen automatically, like in the datastream whenever you key up.

  • @remedy334
    @remedy334 11 годин тому

    I’ve always been interested in ham radios but like most channels they never explain in detail the basics for beginners which probably deters a lot of ppl.i want to know the best cheap radio to get that i can get for my wife as well to use in case of emergency?which would that be? A radio that can get really good long range,dont really know what to go for as most channels aren’t new user friendly smh..

  • @jampskan5690
    @jampskan5690 18 годин тому

    Sea change, lol. There should be like a Farmers' Almanac for Amateur Radio or something. (if there isn't already)

  • @Eric10179
    @Eric10179 19 годин тому

    Wait, Josh has been a fellow southpaw this whole time and I’ve never noticed?!?

    • @HamRadioCrashCourse
      @HamRadioCrashCourse  16 годин тому

      Yep. Only really write left handed though. Mouse, Morse and gun on all the right.

    • @Eric10179
      @Eric10179 6 годин тому

      @ Same! The only things I do left are write and play guitar. Shooting, badminton, hockey, baseball, mouse, Morse, etc. are all righty for me too lol

  • @forgetyourlife
    @forgetyourlife 15 годин тому

    The internet helps sell garbage antennas based on successful activations and “great contacts” that are mostly due to the spotting network not radio knowledge and efficient antenna builds.

  • @cworkman74
    @cworkman74 День тому +4

    There are definitely conveniences that the internet brings to ham radio. I try to operate completely disconnected periodically, though, to stay fresh on operating "off the grid". FT8 without internet is kind of fun! I like knowing that every piece of information I have about the other party is only from what they send over the air. Similarly, forcing yourself to do a POTA activation (or hunting) without internet (even if available) helps polish up those skills.

    • @fyrfyter33
      @fyrfyter33 День тому +1

      @@cworkman74 It’s like doing Winlink via IP is convenient. Winlink without the internet, proves you know more than one way to communicate when the internet isn’t there.

  • @MichaelGregg-wc2bg
    @MichaelGregg-wc2bg День тому +3

    No they don't have or need internet to work

  • @ehayes5217
    @ehayes5217 13 годин тому

    It's technology, but personally, I only care about point-to-point comms, A to B, thanx to the ionosphere👍🇺🇸

  • @HH-CA
    @HH-CA 23 години тому +1

    The only reason that got me interested in HAM radio is not using the Internet at all and mostly simplex .

  • @billcosgrave6232
    @billcosgrave6232 День тому

    👍👍👍

  • @forabuck380
    @forabuck380 18 годин тому

    ive come realize that its nothing but radio checks...

  • @KB0OTY
    @KB0OTY День тому

    Only the good ones.

  • @bordaymoo9228
    @bordaymoo9228 День тому

    Your the first to explain DMR and not make it sound like Zello.

  • @williebeamon3083
    @williebeamon3083 День тому +17

    Any "ham radio" that uses the internet for communications is no longer a ham radio...

    • @jgiffin25
      @jgiffin25 День тому +8

      I would reword that to say relies not uses

    • @ghostmandka5498
      @ghostmandka5498 День тому +6

      So utilizing a medium of communication, other than RF alone, somehow isn’t communication, educational or experimentation?

    • @williebeamon3083
      @williebeamon3083 День тому

      @@ghostmandka5498 No it's a waste of time and relies on infrastructure constantly prone to failure and cyber attacks.

    • @fyrfyter33
      @fyrfyter33 День тому +6

      Lots of radios can use the internet; None of them require it. It just adds functionality to the radio and enhances your capabilities. Shying away from something because you don’t like it, limits your potential capabilities as a Ham.

    • @holdfastjoe8841
      @holdfastjoe8841 23 години тому +3

      if ham radio needed the internet I would be looking for a new hobby

  • @AllanBProductions
    @AllanBProductions День тому

    Yes and no