Smart Lights Can Offer Both Perks and Hassles for Your Home | WSJ

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 124

  • @davidjenkins2399
    @davidjenkins2399 4 роки тому +84

    The disabled community is really benefitting from smart home tech, including smart lights. I am super grateful that accessability is becoming main stream. A smart light may seem trivial, but it is life changing for someone who is able to have a little more access to their world. Thanks for the quick run-down.

  • @JustinY.
    @JustinY. 5 років тому +112

    I can't wait to not be able to turn my lights on if my wifi doesn't work!

    • @pambrosnan577
      @pambrosnan577 5 років тому +5

      Justin Y. plz notice me sempai

    • @gus473
      @gus473 5 років тому +3

      Good to see you, Justin! 👍😎

    • @toddlee-millstein9550
      @toddlee-millstein9550 5 років тому +12

      LIFX lights can be controlled with the switch if for some reason your Wi-Fi doesn’t work. Sort of like the problem he talked about some random person turning off your lights in the video but when you turn it back on after it gets disconnected, it will turn on again and function like a normal light bulb until you turn it off with the app again. Also, smart bulbs don’t have to cost $70 or even $45. LIFX sells a good bulb for just $20 and you can even find cheaper ones from other brands.

    • @HunkMine
      @HunkMine 5 років тому +8

      This is pretty ignorant, If you flip the switch off and on even if your WiFi doesn't work it still turns on

    • @verlorenish
      @verlorenish 5 років тому

      One thing is to not have internet access and another pretty different is the actual wifi signal not working. You can still connect to the devices offline, sorta like accessing your modem's settings.

  • @DrigoBrito
    @DrigoBrito 5 років тому +77

    Hey! Thanks for making my google home turn off the living room light, and then turning it red. Nice video!

    • @michaelraney6732
      @michaelraney6732 4 роки тому +4

      Legit same. My neighbors think I’m running girls because the front porch was red.

  • @AdrianInniss
    @AdrianInniss 5 років тому +13

    Hey yeah... Thanks for turning all the lights in my house red!!! I really should have seen this coming

  • @asburyrt
    @asburyrt 5 років тому +35

    Hey WSJ how about not saying both the Google and Amazon hotwords on your videos.

  • @emjhaye
    @emjhaye 3 роки тому +4

    was there any significant change in the electricity bill if smart bulb is used in the entire home?

  • @EM-ks5my
    @EM-ks5my 3 роки тому +2

    The Philip one has actual light switches to replace your old ones, and won't interfere with your commands.
    Also, this works great on fan lights were you leave them on and now you have a wall switch without doing the whole electrical fan rewiring to a wall switch.

  • @hansjzeller
    @hansjzeller 3 місяці тому

    Thanks for the informative video! The video is a few years old, but now, with the emerging Matter standard, for someone like me who is just starting with a smart home, Matter is definitely something to consider. When it comes to smart lights, then a related standard, Thread, is something to watch. "Matter on Thread" is probably the way smart lighting will go forward, for the reasons mentioned in the video (no need for another hub, ease of setup, and reliability). There aren't a lot of smart lights that support that right now, but that will hopefully change over time.

  • @Hamsteak
    @Hamsteak 5 років тому +16

    Smart lights are convenient when you're away from home. So it looks like someone is home when your away

  • @TheLiamster
    @TheLiamster 5 років тому +34

    I don’t have smart lights I have dumb lights.

    • @PatrickBaptist
      @PatrickBaptist 5 років тому

      I don't even have a smart phone, it's a dumb phone but it still works on YT and the internet mostly.

  • @DavidKen878
    @DavidKen878 4 роки тому +9

    Brand names are very important but when it comes to smart bulbs, the $10 brand is just as good as the $60.

    • @TheAviationistKhizr
      @TheAviationistKhizr 2 роки тому

      Well not exactly, they might look the same but, cheap bulbs use wifi which cloggs up bandwidth whereas Philip hues operate on zigbee frequency, the app is better and more responsive and there are way for accessories

    • @DavidKen878
      @DavidKen878 2 роки тому

      @@TheAviationistKhizr Smart Bulbs don't require a ton a WiFi. Where did you read they clog up bandwidth?

    • @TheAviationistKhizr
      @TheAviationistKhizr 2 роки тому

      @@DavidKen878 Watched a couple videos, they can decrease your wifi speed by up to 10mbps

    • @DavidKen878
      @DavidKen878 2 роки тому

      @@TheAviationistKhizr Really? I never knew that. I have a pretty high download speed but even with a house full of bulbs, plugs and switches, I've never noticed a difference or experienced any change.

    • @TheAviationistKhizr
      @TheAviationistKhizr 2 роки тому

      @@DavidKen878 Oh ok good to know, I didn't wanna risk it because max I get where I live is 30mb lol

  • @rossbennett76
    @rossbennett76 3 роки тому +1

    How much kilo Watts do these bulbs use when not in use, if you have to leave the switch on at the wall in order for the bulbs to work over the network.

    • @emjhaye
      @emjhaye 3 роки тому

      thats what i was wondering too… if there was a significant amount of difference between regular LED vs smart bulbs

    • @KamBamDamn
      @KamBamDamn 3 роки тому

      They do use a bit when the switch is up and the bulb is off but it’s not much I think it’s like a penny or 2

  • @1986pramod
    @1986pramod 4 роки тому +2

    Loved the ending. And yes, Lazy rocks!!

  • @AntoinetteParry
    @AntoinetteParry Рік тому

    I set up all my lights up, got them all beautifully coloring my home then a storm cut them all down. Worse still, I'd forgotten how and which ones and worked on which settings. I couldn't get them working again. It drove me nuts. What a storm can do for your sanity. I still haven't got them working again.

  • @BrieoRobino
    @BrieoRobino 5 років тому +24

    It's 2019, we know how digital assistance works. You can stop using their activation words in videos and setting off my devices.

    • @weyjey2768
      @weyjey2768 4 роки тому

      Lol I just experienced the same thing 😂

  • @mckennaConfig
    @mckennaConfig 5 років тому +9

    Why does your lightbulb need access to the internet??

    • @PHlophe
      @PHlophe 5 років тому +3

      and needs google too lol!

    • @1asdf2jklasdf31
      @1asdf2jklasdf31 5 років тому +2

      You can turn this feature off, or block it in your router.

    • @Pierrelilg
      @Pierrelilg 5 років тому +12

      It doesn't need to be connected to the internet per se, just to your local area network so you can communicate with them

  • @PirateOfTheNorth
    @PirateOfTheNorth Рік тому

    I rent so the switch issue is a problem. I do like the smart plugs though. I have 4 so far and I find them very useful.

  • @GrahamReimer
    @GrahamReimer 2 роки тому +1

    When he said “turn off all my lights” my google turned off all my lights 💡
    And then when he said play stranger things, it played on my tv😂

  • @AlexanderThickstunsChannel
    @AlexanderThickstunsChannel 4 роки тому

    Smart switches that work with smart bulbs are available. There’s the Brilliant Home Control (and dimmer switches) and the Innoveli switches. They both allow you to disable the internal relay switch so the bulb you’re controlling constantly gets power.
    And these aren’t the switches that fit over your existing switch. They replace the switch entirely.

  • @toddlee-millstein9550
    @toddlee-millstein9550 5 років тому +2

    LIFX lights can be controlled with the switch if for some reason your Wi-Fi doesn’t work. Sort of like the problem he talked about some random person turning off your lights in the video but when you turn it back on after it gets disconnected, it will turn on again and function like a normal light bulb until you turn it off with the app again. Also, smart bulbs don’t have to cost $70 or even $45. LIFX sells a good bulb for just $20 and you can even find cheaper ones from other brands.

  • @chriskarath
    @chriskarath 5 років тому +10

    Don't actually say Ok Google or Alexa in UA-cam reviews.

  • @SpiralBreeze
    @SpiralBreeze 5 років тому +10

    I would NEVER buy any smart devices for my apartment. Also, I would like to point out the reused Talenti pint jars in the kitchen, I do the same thing, I also keep change in one.

    • @KrystalLovesDeeply
      @KrystalLovesDeeply 5 років тому +1

      They still turn on with the switch flip

    • @SpiralBreeze
      @SpiralBreeze 5 років тому +5

      Jackson Whitlow Cause I live in the hood and the power is always going out, my building is from the 1880’s. Further more, all it takes it one stupid smart asthmatic kid on his tablet to hack into my house just for kicks. I had a friend who used to hack into cars and over ride the key fobs from a jail broken iPhone, then he used to drive them into the park and leave them there. Bored geniuses is what I call them.

  • @jonaslemes08
    @jonaslemes08 10 місяців тому

    that last minute google command was priceless 😆

  • @vBDKv
    @vBDKv 3 роки тому +1

    Luckily this video is very old. All you need these days is a router and stuff that runs on tuya (or no router and stuff that runs on zigbee for local). A good quality smart bulb these days will cost you around 15 bucks.

  • @msdeshabangbang
    @msdeshabangbang 4 роки тому +1

    i got 2 smart bulbs for 18 on amazon! THEY are amazing

  • @koltonnebeker4550
    @koltonnebeker4550 4 роки тому +1

    When you always have the switch on does it use electricity or ruin the wires in the wall or something

    • @lareina360
      @lareina360 3 роки тому

      This is what I’m trying to figure out...

  • @stephengnb
    @stephengnb 5 років тому +1

    Philips Hue bulbs are often on sale on Amazon or Best Buy.

  • @lareina360
    @lareina360 3 роки тому +5

    If you leave the light switch on will the electricity bill go up is my question....I mean I can’t find a answer to my question anywhere😏

    • @paofifa8779
      @paofifa8779 2 роки тому

      Did you get an answer to your question?

    • @wiresbringit
      @wiresbringit 13 днів тому

      Yeah by pennies, it's a hibernation draw like when your laptop is sleeping, just enough so it can keep track of time or respond to your app request to turn it on. On the other hand with the schedule settings you're not going to forget to turn it off anymore... So it should pay for it's own standby vampire costs in energy savings...

  • @gerryseynaeve
    @gerryseynaeve 4 роки тому

    Hi. Does a smart bulb remember his last settings when turned of by the power switch?

    • @SpaceStrike
      @SpaceStrike 4 роки тому

      I’m afraid it does no

    • @SpaceStrike
      @SpaceStrike 4 роки тому

      Does not

    • @tpeasetiger
      @tpeasetiger 4 роки тому

      It depends. The philips hue bulbs are able to remember their previous power state.

  • @urlgrrrl
    @urlgrrrl 5 років тому +9

    Owwww! - My Google Home just turned all my LIFX lights red and Stranger Things is playing on my Chrome Cast TV!!

    • @jumpmanjourneys
      @jumpmanjourneys 3 роки тому

      yeah ik my tv was on and he turned all my lights to red and also turned on stranger things on my chromecast lol

  • @venkatasaisantoshperumalla917
    @venkatasaisantoshperumalla917 3 роки тому

    nice video. smoothly put. would have liked more details but you gave the big picture in a good way

  • @macberry4048
    @macberry4048 5 років тому +2

    Amazon echo automatically connects to Phillips hue lights without the hub. Set up for smart home devices have gotten better but Phillips is the easiest and if you get the hub it can work even if you don't have internet

    • @stephengnb
      @stephengnb 5 років тому

      I think it's the newer Echos that have Zig-bee built in, which is what the Philips Hue hub uses. The newer Philips Hue lights now come with Bluetooth built-in, so you can start using them without a hub. You could theoretically use them without a hub, as the bulbs mesh with each other, but the hub gives you more options and off-network functionality.

    • @macberry4048
      @macberry4048 5 років тому

      @@stephengnb that's the next thing you need to skip the small speakers

    • @TheAviationistKhizr
      @TheAviationistKhizr 2 роки тому

      Is it the same with Google nest mini?

  • @jumpmanjourneys
    @jumpmanjourneys 3 роки тому

    3:00 no don't get c by ge I got one and all I was doing was reconnecting it to the wifi. it is too much hassle. What I do recommend is sengled light bulbs. Sof ar ive had almost no connection problems with them.

  • @BertLiu
    @BertLiu 4 роки тому +1

    Very nice simple overview. Thank you

  • @Tithis
    @Tithis Рік тому

    You should use smart switches for any light fixture, period.
    For lamps I've been working on converting to lamp itself to be smart. It takes some work but you can rewire a lamp with a small device in its base. The lamp switch goes to the device so it can still be controlled like a dumb lamp, but the device itself actually powers the lightbulb socket.
    Sure you don't get multi-color bulbs or different temperature settings, but nobody can screw stuff up because it doesn't lose any of the ease of use of 'dumb' lights.

    • @bolivarharrigan6027
      @bolivarharrigan6027 Рік тому

      It's going catch on fire with all that off and on switch

    • @Tithis
      @Tithis Рік тому

      @@bolivarharrigan6027 That's nonsense.

  • @AnimeMangaBazinga
    @AnimeMangaBazinga Рік тому

    Watching this 4 years later, it's surprising that the Ikea Smart product lineup was never mentioned, especially for how cheap it is in comparison.

    • @Mia-ht8oi
      @Mia-ht8oi Рік тому

      Good to know! I wasnt even aware of Ikea having one. Can we use any voltage on these smart bulbs or does it have to be what the max voltage is for the lamps? Thanks!

  • @samm9017
    @samm9017 2 роки тому

    Dude ended with “I’m cool” 😎

  • @fkatarot6755
    @fkatarot6755 2 роки тому

    Mochiba smart wifi led lights cost me only 40$ for 8 of them and they connect to your phone. There really coming down in prices if that is what they were in 2019.

  • @gus473
    @gus473 5 років тому

    Good report, David! Thanks!

  • @PrasadBSK
    @PrasadBSK 4 роки тому

    Nicely explained 👍👍👍

  • @nyancoti
    @nyancoti 2 роки тому

    04:18 The snoop dog moment! Just Epic

  • @Roboboy
    @Roboboy 5 років тому +4

    I'd rather have really bright bulbs and see my house than have 'smart' bulbs I can turn off from across the room or customise the colour temperature. I have 2600lm bulbs for my living room torch lights and pretty much every smart bulb series seems to max out at 1000lm.

    • @zuzoscorner
      @zuzoscorner 2 роки тому

      Sounds easier to just use a clapper XD

  • @anidiotontheinternet3514
    @anidiotontheinternet3514 3 роки тому

    This needs to be updated, you can now get Cree smart bulbs (color) for $10s a piece, and the google home app is very useful

  • @ninjanerdstudent6937
    @ninjanerdstudent6937 4 роки тому +1

    There’s nothing to install. You just plug your lamp in a WiFi block and control it with phone. I set it on a timer on vacation that varies day to day. Other than that, I never use it.

  • @HabiburRahman-xs9gb
    @HabiburRahman-xs9gb 2 роки тому

    The only smart home device I want to buy

  • @IkramulHossain
    @IkramulHossain 4 роки тому

    In India now smart bulb 💡(All colour) cost around ₹300 to ₹400 (usd $4 to 6)...
    And the smitch bulb doesn't need a hub...

  • @edizepeda
    @edizepeda 4 роки тому

    I can’t connect more than two lights

  • @KrystalLovesDeeply
    @KrystalLovesDeeply 5 років тому +2

    I changed all my light bulbs to smart light bulbs because we don't have dimmers. GREAT investment, doesn't strain eyes at night

  • @NathanCroucher
    @NathanCroucher 2 роки тому

    Heres how practical they are, i just bought 5 at the tip for $10 brand new, $2 each 😐

  • @TheGNCShow
    @TheGNCShow 2 роки тому

    One of the very first things that was mentioned as being sensible was automatically activating a lock when you approach it, but the idea of a lightbulb turning on at the same time seems completely ridiculous? Lost me 20 seconds in.

  • @1stGruhn
    @1stGruhn 5 років тому +3

    smart locks... great idea, one more thing to spoof and grant open access to anyone who can copy a wifi signal....

  • @HunkMine
    @HunkMine 5 років тому

    Smart outlets are the way to go unless you don't want to spend the money

  • @elijahquinones3396
    @elijahquinones3396 Рік тому

    Roku smart light bulbs are. $9.88 at walmart

  • @adiposerex5150
    @adiposerex5150 5 років тому +1

    I use a $2 timer.

  • @CatBigCat
    @CatBigCat 5 років тому

    The (current) extra cost/extra features just don't make sense.

  • @blkmusic__
    @blkmusic__ 4 роки тому +1

    Ummm can you censor the “Hey Google” part cause you’re triggering my lights

  • @sezwo5774
    @sezwo5774 Рік тому

    The idea of needing a phone to turn on the lights is stupid. Having functional in wall switches plus the ability to program and control lights from the phone is another story.

  • @ridhamehta3432
    @ridhamehta3432 5 років тому

    You guys should try
    Wipro Garnet Smart Light 7W B22 LED Bulb, Compatible with Amazon Alexa & Google Assistant
    Which is about 20 usd
    It is a well known indian brand

  • @imgrankie7176
    @imgrankie7176 5 років тому +2

    You trigger my assistant

  • @kevinrobbau
    @kevinrobbau 4 роки тому

    I just can't find a bulb bright enough to light a room adequately

  • @auro1986
    @auro1986 5 років тому

    won't work when there is no network and if computers fails then there will be no light

  • @hbarudi
    @hbarudi 5 років тому +1

    To me this product is only good for if you truly own your house and have a fully paid off mortgage loan. I still prefer ordinary LED light bulbs for basic lighting inside general living in homes owned by other people such as houses without fully paid mortgages and rental properties.

    • @MsZooper
      @MsZooper 3 роки тому +2

      Not really, you can bring a switch or bulb anywhere you move to. It’s not like you have to do any major construction especially for the bulbs

    • @PrimeForm1
      @PrimeForm1 3 роки тому +7

      Fully paid off mortgage just to use a light bulb?

  • @soundknight
    @soundknight 5 років тому

    Who is listening to your private conversations? Alexa

    • @noreenlyons1960
      @noreenlyons1960 4 роки тому +1

      does anyone REALLY care? I don't say or do anything THAT exciting. Let them listen, my God, when I hear them snoring......

  • @Peizxcv
    @Peizxcv 5 років тому

    So unnecessarily complicated. Now you might have to use your phone’s flashlight when troubleshooting networking issues

  • @collin5022
    @collin5022 5 років тому

    LIFX has made the best smart bulbs for the past few years and you only mentioned them once, without even recommending them. Shame. No hub necessary, no hassle, integrates with Google, Alexa, IFTTT, Nest, and each bulb connects directly to the wifi. Costs a bit more, but you get what you pay for. Rated for 10 years usage too. Viewers, do your own research!

  • @darrylchewDC
    @darrylchewDC 5 років тому

    We all could have done without that last silly google command.

  • @flowstate5465
    @flowstate5465 5 років тому +2

    LED light strips with a raspberry pi, arduino, and some GitHub code or nah?

  • @willdwyer6782
    @willdwyer6782 4 роки тому +1

    Philips Hue sucks too. Overpriced junk. Go with Merkury Innovations or Feit Electric.

  • @chrislambe400
    @chrislambe400 4 роки тому

    Smart bulbs are dumb. Smart light switches are smart.

  • @randomshuffles1074
    @randomshuffles1074 5 років тому +1

    I hope you have a goo day love from a small UA-camr

  • @BradThePitts
    @BradThePitts 5 років тому

    When I grow up, I want to be one of the fat, lazy people in Wall-E.

  • @Freddylikefood
    @Freddylikefood 3 роки тому

    To much talk around the subject and 0 details

  • @chasescomedyshow
    @chasescomedyshow 5 років тому

    The light switch thing is so ANNOYING and setup

  • @g43s
    @g43s Рік тому

    i paid 10 bucks in 2019 for 1 smart bulb, now in 2023 i paid like 5 for a set of 2. this guy doesnt know how to buy stuff from the internet.

  • @seawinds12
    @seawinds12 2 роки тому

    lol i payed 10 euro for my light

  • @tofu7397
    @tofu7397 4 роки тому

    The fact that they try to force me into giving up my location just to use bluetooth is enough to throw this bulb in the trash. You don't need my camera OR my location.

  • @willdwyer6782
    @willdwyer6782 4 роки тому

    C by GE sucks. Don't waste your money.

  • @davidramirez8030
    @davidramirez8030 5 років тому

    CaSeTa

  • @STNG17-
    @STNG17- 5 років тому

    Smart lights is kinda dumb idea actually..