Schubert's fresh musical ideas and feeling for colours make his rather simple and pianistically not very interesting scores sound so vivid and exciting.
@@NovicebutPassionate I just meant that both have a second theme in E major, that's all. At that time, either instance was pretty rare, as you point out.
@@tfpp1 A second theme in E major is not rare by any means. A second theme in E major WHEN the first theme was in A minor, however, is quite a bit more rare. What matters in tonal music is not the keys themselves but their relations to one another considered in the context of an individual piece.
@@phillipbrandel7932 Yeah, I know. Going back and rereading my comment doesn't make any sense to me. I'm not sure what I meant by that. Both C major and E major would be pretty standard fare for a sonata in A minor.
Рік тому
Nice memories with this Sonata... 20 years ago, like in the 3rd year of my studies at Prague conservatory, my teacher would spend 2 hours only "working" on the first 4 bars. That time, I somehow did not understand this type of "torture" but 20 years after, I do understand. And it saves me a "s*itload of time" now when I wanna learn the piece again. Great piece, enjoying pretty much playing it.
I was listening to Alexander Malofeev playing this piece and wasn't convinced by his performance but this one works quite beautifully. A strange anomaly at 11:53 though. Gsharp in the score but Schiff plays an A. Different edition perhaps but It sounds odd. Malofeev plays G sharps.
I still don't get this Schubert. It was, I think, his last piano piece and published posthumously. Malofeev, talking about it in an interview, says something about its emptiness. The pianist that makes the most sense to me on this is Maria Joao Pires. Still, it is a bit of an enigma to me. It helps to imagine Schubert ill in bed. I can imagine him taking meds, or being bled! the just barely ok days, the good, the bad, the chaos, upheavals, the whole trauma of being sick for so long..... Is that what goes in to this jarring piece? Is that why it is so difficult to listen to?
Schubert's fresh musical ideas and feeling for colours make his rather simple and pianistically not very interesting scores sound so vivid and exciting.
Well, they're interesting in their own way. Not 100000 note liszt, it's another world entirely
Sauber und sehr gefühlvoll gespielt. Mit allen Nuancen und Frasierungen, die da hingehören. Danke! Danke!!!!
1:56 minor mode exposition (A-) modulating to the major dominant (E+) relatively rare.
You mean as opposed to the relative C major, as would typically be found? Maybe Schubert took a cue from Beethoven's Waldstein sonata.
@@tfpp1 I'm afraid that would be quite irrelevant since in Waldstein the main key is C major.
@@NovicebutPassionate I just meant that both have a second theme in E major, that's all. At that time, either instance was pretty rare, as you point out.
@@tfpp1 A second theme in E major is not rare by any means. A second theme in E major WHEN the first theme was in A minor, however, is quite a bit more rare. What matters in tonal music is not the keys themselves but their relations to one another considered in the context of an individual piece.
@@phillipbrandel7932 Yeah, I know. Going back and rereading my comment doesn't make any sense to me. I'm not sure what I meant by that. Both C major and E major would be pretty standard fare for a sonata in A minor.
Nice memories with this Sonata... 20 years ago, like in the 3rd year of my studies at Prague conservatory, my teacher would spend 2 hours only "working" on the first 4 bars.
That time, I somehow did not understand this type of "torture" but 20 years after, I do understand. And it saves me a "s*itload of time" now when I wanna learn the piece again.
Great piece, enjoying pretty much playing it.
This is my favourite Schubert sonata!
I would truly like to know why this Schubert sonata is your favourite.
@@bernardparret3191 It's a very tragic work, sparsely written and so emotional
Next time I'm not attending my 3pm tutorial because not getting first comment on a Schwammerl video really is an absolute disgrace
Out of curiosity, Oxbridge?
Nope, you must have gotten me confused with Schwammerl himself ;)
great piece!
simplement merveilleux
Schubert is my favorite composer although I love the others too. Thank you for all your uploads. New sub.
19:30 Mi momento favorito
I love this Channel ❤️❤️❤️.
Absolutely love the 6:30
16:41
Thankss ❤️!
I was listening to Alexander Malofeev playing this piece and wasn't convinced by his performance but this one works quite beautifully. A strange anomaly at 11:53 though. Gsharp in the score but Schiff plays an A. Different edition perhaps but It sounds odd. Malofeev plays G sharps.
I still don't get this Schubert. It was, I think, his last piano piece and published posthumously. Malofeev, talking about it in an interview, says something about its emptiness. The pianist that makes the most sense to me on this is Maria Joao Pires. Still, it is a bit of an enigma to me. It helps to imagine Schubert ill in bed. I can imagine him taking meds, or being bled! the just barely ok days, the good, the bad, the chaos, upheavals, the whole trauma of being sick for so long..... Is that what goes in to this jarring piece? Is that why it is so difficult to listen to?
19:00
0:51 onwards is heavy metal before heavy metal
.
not metal at all ;-)
Are you planing to upload whole set of Schubert sonatas?
Yes eventually
G dur шедевр
2주제 1:55
woody guthrie 1:59
But it is in 4/4, not 2/2.
19:15