@dibeshshrestha9277 are you dense? Do you understand the concept of "most of the time" it mean almost all of the time, with the exception of some times...
They contradicted themselves with nearly every pick. They praised Bellingham for how well he’s doing at Real Madrid, but then Carra said Vini shouldn’t get in because it’s “easy” to play for Real Madrid😭 Then he argued that Vini plays against easy opponents meanwhile he picked Messi who played in the French league and mls in 2023
Anyone with some ball knowledge knows Laliga is the toughest league for attackers because of the defensive nature of teams and lack of protection from referees.
I'm pretty sure carras arguments at the end weren't serious. He was just winding up Neville. He was just saying he'd rather have Messi right wing than vinicius. Don't take it so seriously bud
Carra choosing Messi over Salah in the year 2023 is completely insane but Neville choosing Vinicius Jr who doesn't even play on the right over Salah is just as bad I'd expect Salah disrespect from a former United player and club captain but that's shocking from Carra
10:41 "I'd pick him for what he's done in the MLS, whats Vinicius done in La Liga?" Are you shitting me? Messi gets more credit for barely playing and finishing bottom in the MLS than Vini does in a brilliant UCL run and a great season in a top 5 league in Europe?
@@bizz4re2be75 he had the most assists in ligue 1 , had second most goal involvment for psg that season , won ligue 1 , part of ligue 1 team of the season, already became inter miami 4th highest top scorer , won them their first trophy , what did vini won for madrid??? Now get lost , dont eat my mind idiot
Carragher saying "what has Vini jr done for Real Madrid?" Unbelievable. In 2023 Vini was rocking the knockout stages in UCL. Got the Golden Ball of the FIFA Club World Cup. Won the Copa Del Rey destroying Barça in the semifinals and giving assists in the Final. And it's funny how they praise Bellingham for what he's done in Budensleague and La Liga, but tries to downplay what Vini has done in La Liga and UCL.
John Stones in the right back is the perfect pick because he is the one who has popularised the inverted RB role and also played immense in the CL final
@@shysmy19 Anyone who thinks like you is mediocre at football knowledge. You people start with "Anyone who has a brain...." to cloud your knowledge on football matters lmao 🤣
Kyle Walker, Araujo, Frenkie De Jong and Rudiger not being nominated is genuinely laughable when you see some of the players that stunk the place out first half of the year always get a place no matter how bad they've been.
Kane instead of vini for sure Kane has the most goals in 2023 Calender year (52)of any player in Europes top 5 half of whilst playing for a spurs side that didn’t make Europe
It`s really annoying to hear people like Carra trying to discredit the Spanish Liga, a Championship which is not inferior to EPL. Just count the number of times that spanish teams have beaten english teams in Europe in the last 25 years....You should be amazed by the statistics in Champions League and Europa League. By the way, Carra, there is much more fun watching Real Madrid, Girona, Ahtletic de Bilbao, Real Sociedad and Atlético de Madrid playing good football, than watching a Premier were there are only two teams (Man City and Liverpool) with real options to win the league, while the others use to do great mistakes tactically and technically
@@bluesEvanskro just seen the defender nominations. the absolute state of them van dijk and trent. genuinely laughable the liverpool favouritism (as always)
Kyle Walker not being listed there is really unexplainable. Also, for 2023, I'd have Salah right wing. I love Messi and Vini (who doesn't) but Salah is just ridiculous. Especially his form to start this season
It’s disgusting at this point, the disrespect, undermining & overlooking Salah gets. Almost like a discriminatory agenda against him. Especially by Carra, proves it even worse. If he was South American or European they’d be hailing him as the best next thing since sliced bread.
@MirkoS1995 @jiahaogoh2822 i dont think you guys understand the definition of pr innit?😂 plus maybe he gets nominated but unlike messi does he go on to win it when he clearly doesn't deserve it?
@@ashratullahahmadi2236 he won Dubai player of the century and other obscene awards just made for him, don’t come here and act like cr7 is not favored by media ahah… keep crying
Cause Carragher is interrupting him all the time when he knows he has been had. Pick Messi who had his best performance in 22 in a 23 year line up. Then says Vini plays against easy opposition in the la liga while he is riding Messis back who played in farmers league. You can't make it up.
Had the second most g/a by a defender in a calendar year… ever, as in of all time. Liverpool also lost 1 of the last 30 prem games of the year, which only coincides with the moment he starting inverting into the midfield
@@MrJaywalk you’re embarrassing yourself. He claimed Messi should be in for his shambolic 2023 and said no Vinicius because it’s easy to play in La Liga and then says Bellingham should be in for what he’s doing in La Liga, not to mention the leagues Messi played in in 2023 are Ligue 1 and MLS that too while playing terribly. Regardless neither Vinicius or especially Messi should be in the conversation for RW. It should be Salah
@@CR7_THEGOAT777 I said Carra isn’t biased, where have you disproven that? Surely if he was biased he would’ve picked Salah 😂 There’s a difference between being biased and being hypocritical or contradictory, which I wasn’t touching on and quite frankly am not willing to engage with an inflammatory person like yourself! I’ll carry on embarrassing myself in peace thank you 😊
i feel like he doesnt actually like messi that much, he just hates ronaldo that much that he has to constantly lift up his rival. Carra will never forgive how ronaldo destroyed his liverpool multiple times including UCL final
Kane over Haaland for me. Scored 30 league goals in the Prem last season, only 6 less than Haaland, in a much worse Spurs side and is now killing it at Bayern.
I’d have Kane over Mbappe or Kane over vini not over haaland. Haaland won the treble and broke the scoring record you absolutely must have him in. Mbappe is in a farmers league and goes missing in UCL and vini is good but Kane is better
Im actually surprised Salah wasn't even mentioned for right wing. Liverpool had a rough end to last season, and are doing better now, but the only players who have been consistently world class throughout all that time are Alisson and Salah. Vini is obviously great, but is he better than Salah; no, and he plays left wing. Real madrid didn't win anything last season either so that's not an argument. Just seemed odd that it was between vini and messi.
Real Madrid won copa del rey, fifa club world cup, uefa super cup, semis in ucl and 2nd in laliga. What did liverpool won? 5 in premier league. Beaten by real madrid 6-2 on aggregate in ucl. Liverpool player should not be in conversation at all. They totally suck last season.
It's Salah obviously, Salah is currently one of the best if not the best in the world, top goalscorer and assister this season in the Prem since August, Since January he's been consitently one of the best in the world even with Hendo, Fab and Curtis behind him which looked lost. Put Vini in Liverpool from Jan - Dec and I guarantee he wouldn't touch Salah's records
Jamie Carragher, a football Punidt, lauds Messi's performance in the MLS while doesn't consider Vinicius worthy of praise because he plays in a "Joke League"... There's no way this man can be called a serious unbiased Pundit...
How is Osimhen never mentioned up front.... Madness... Serie A winner.... 31 goals in 39 games in all competitions last season and UCL Quarter Finalist.... Madness...
Out of the 23 champions league seasons in the 2nd milenium, El Classico won 11 titles, the other 12 are divided between 8 different teams from 4 leagues. From 2014 to 2018 there were 2 all Spanish finals, 4 times both European cups were won by Spanish teams, and 3 times there were 3 Spanish teams in the semi finals, and most importantly only Spanish teams won the CL. PL in the last 5 seasons - ManCity - 4 Liverpool - 1 LaLiga in the last 5 seasons - Real Madrid - 2 Barcelona - 2 Atletico - 1 Manchester City and Liverpool have had games in the PL where they won by 7 - 0 or 8 - 0 while no one in LaLiga has come even close to that in the last 5 years. How anyone can ever claim that PL is more competitive and higher quality is beyond me
The fact that Carra stands there and calls La Liga a "joke" while he puts Messi in his team even though he hasn't done much in 2023 and has played in Ligue 1 and MLS, is just ridiculous.
@@Romans8-9greatest player of all time. Dragged his team to a World Cup final a year ago and you think his level has dropped that far. You’re delusional
Carra automatically loses for that BS disgraceful pick of Messi over Salah, especially since he’s a Liverpool player as well. The utter disgusting disrespect to Salah continues as usual even worse and more clear since it’s from Carra. If he was European or South American and with “popularity/marketing/trending” they’d never stop mentioning Salah’s name as the next best thing since sliced bread
@@Gagefelstead I'm not saying it should be Trent over Stones, I think it should be stones or walker because they won the treble I'm just laughing at Neville because he's so bitter that he's committed a false impression of Trent to memory, when in reality from March-December he was class
@@danielward3879 I think he's worried he won't just be behind Kyle Walker in the all time XI of the premier league, because he'll be behind trent as well😂
Carragher calling la liga a joke while they have the most ucls is funny .Also not even them mentioning ter stegn who made a record is a disgrace and shows their ball knowledge
Near the end Carra says the Ballon d'Or was for the calendar year but that's not true. It hasn't worked like that since they changed it a couple years ago. Ballon d'Or is now for the season, not the calendar year.
Carrager seriously called La Liga a joke league on TV. Teens on twitter argue like that, he should be so embarrassed. Liverpool were knocked out from UCL by spanish clubs 4 in the last 5 years. He had the audacity to ask "What did Vini do?" knowing full well Vini dismantled Enfield. I know he doesn't know anything else about Vini, cuz he only watches Prem teams games, but that 2:5 he should remember well, apparently he chose to delete it from his memory. Absolute clownery.
It's crazy a team can win 5 trophies, become the best English side of all time, be undefeated at home in 2023, give out a joint biggest semi-final defeat of all time to none other than Real Madrid and still have so many players snubbed from this. Mind boggling
LOOK, dear Jamie, the clashes between Real Madrid v. Liverpool in UCL: 1981 FINAL: Liverpool 1 Real Madrid 0 2008/09 round of 16: Liverpool 4 Real Madrid 0; Real Madrid 0 Liverpool 1 2014/15 group phase: Liverpool 0 Real Madrid 4; Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0 2018 FINAL: Real Madrid 3 Liverpool 1 2020/21 quarter final: Real Madrid 3 Liverpool 1; Liverpool 0 Real Madrid 0 2022 FINAL: Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0 2023/2023 round of 16: Liverpool 2 Real Madrid 5; Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0 11 GAMES: 7 VICTORIES FOR REAL MADRID, 3 VICTORIES FOR LIVERPOOL AND 1 DRAW A JOKE LEAGUE??
Carragher is choosing based on last 3 years overall it seems instead of 2023 purely. Messi is the greatest ever for me but the absolute love-in by some pundits is just ridiculous. We get it, he's elite, but he doesn't need all these ridiculous selections.
Mine is GK Alisson RB Alexander-Arnold CB Dias CB Stones CB Dimarco CDM Rodri CM De Bruyne CM Bellingham RW Salah ST Haaland LW Mbappe 12th man Kane Manager Pep Guardiola
Yeah you're not biased at all are you man utd profile picture man, neither is Gary who brought fake stats to mnf to say ronaldo was better than messi 😂😂😂
my overall toty: gk: alison defence: carvajal, militao, stones, i guess araujo? no outstanding left back for the full year and its between him and saliba midfield: musiala, frenkie de jong, rodri. although barella, de bruyne, silva and bellingham could easily slide in attack: an extremely disorganised front line of griezmann, haaland and kane with lautaro, osimhen and salah very unfortunate to miss out. but with a 4-3-3 lets have salah, vinicius and haaland. edit: rudiger has to be in the team so switch him for militao since he's missed half the year
i agree with that stones pick, he was absolutely vital to the treble winning team, whereas trent has only really been good this season, i think recency bias has caused them to pick trent. really it should be walker.
True but I get the point. What you rate more, someone who played half a season and was like 9/10 good or someone who played every game and was 8/10 good, difficult question
@@MarkHogan994he’s acting like Trent was rubish at the start of the year, when his worst period was the second half of last year. In the last 10 games of the last Prem season, Liverpool were undefeated because he started inverting into midfield, where he got 7 assists and 1 goal in those 10 games
He literally praised him in this clip lmao, said he's been outstanding the last few months and very enjoyable to watch. How's your listening comprehension?
Waxing lyricals about Jude Bellingham in La Liga, but slating Vini Jr saying its easy to do it in La Liga. Mind-blowingly bad and typical English bias 😂😂 Plus picking Vini over Salah is wild, just pure madness
Salah should be RW because Vini isn't a RW, however I would say Vini > Salah in 2023 (Salah 2nd half last season was'nt amazing, whilst Vini has had to deal with Benzema injuries last season, and Joselu as only proper striker this season)
@@ihaze8794 Salah still had more G/A than him last season as a whole so what's your point? he's also got more G/A than him this season but you focus on your little purple patch.
Salah literally has the most G/A in 2023, Mo had a much better 2023 overall and to say his 2nd half of the season wasn’t amazing just proves to me that you’re not actually watching the games
Carragher calling La Liga a joke league whilst defending Messi in the MLS is WILD
Might want to go take a look at the La Liga table @@_warra_trophy_ Also tell me the last time the 12th place team in the prem won the Europa League
i do think its a bit satire tbh
Its almost like he has a blind loyalty to Messi, an unfortunate yet common trait amongst football fans.
@@_warra_trophy_ compared to MLS is the point I'm making
@@vl7721 in comparison to MLS
Carra has an unbelievable ability to rile Neville up. It's so entertaining to watch. Love them both
@@Stephen-Nthen don’t ..
@@dibeshshrestha9277 I don't... which is what I literally said 🤨
@@Stephen-N if you don’t then y did u watch this video and commented ..
@dibeshshrestha9277 are you dense? Do you understand the concept of "most of the time" it mean almost all of the time, with the exception of some times...
@@Stephen-NI wouldn’t bother mate😂
They contradicted themselves with nearly every pick. They praised Bellingham for how well he’s doing at Real Madrid, but then Carra said Vini shouldn’t get in because it’s “easy” to play for Real Madrid😭 Then he argued that Vini plays against easy opponents meanwhile he picked Messi who played in the French league and mls in 2023
this guy knows
Anyone with some ball knowledge knows Laliga is the toughest league for attackers because of the defensive nature of teams and lack of protection from referees.
This is why they're not successful coaches.
I'm pretty sure carras arguments at the end weren't serious. He was just winding up Neville. He was just saying he'd rather have Messi right wing than vinicius. Don't take it so seriously bud
@@dteezle Nobodies taking it seriously “bud”. If you can’t handle an observation that’s not my problem
How is Kyle Walker not in the voting 🤣
Init man was the reason city won the treble pocketing Vini like nothing and more talented LWS
😩🤷
cs he not better than trent no one is
@@TheeFootballHighlights trent isnt a good defender, he should play midfield
@@TheeFootballHighlightswell he is when they’re compared as fullbacks😂
Carra choosing Messi over Salah in the year 2023 is completely insane but Neville choosing Vinicius Jr who doesn't even play on the right over Salah is just as bad
I'd expect Salah disrespect from a former United player and club captain but that's shocking from Carra
I'd have salah and kane in
Shocking omissions
Messi did brilliant as did vini but can't have them over the other 2
True, the only right answers were either Kane (who 100% deserves to be in that eleven) or Salah, if you really want to choose a RW
@@Pjj878did brilliant where?
@@obiwankenobi6317yes I would have Kane Haaland mbappe as my front 3 and salah as 12th man
@@Pjj878what did Messi do last year?
10:41 "I'd pick him for what he's done in the MLS, whats Vinicius done in La Liga?"
Are you shitting me? Messi gets more credit for barely playing and finishing bottom in the MLS than Vini does in a brilliant UCL run and a great season in a top 5 league in Europe?
Inter miami was already bottom when messi came snd messi won them their first trophy in history
@@amaankhan3207 It was a league cup, u cant never complete mls to Europe. Just Vini jr was Miles ahead Messi in 2023.
@@waismalikzada1690 vini didnt win anything in 2023 while messi was a ballon dor winner as well
@@amaankhan3207The Balon‘Dor was for his WC Performance, the WC does not count for the best players of 2023
@@bizz4re2be75 he had the most assists in ligue 1 , had second most goal involvment for psg that season , won ligue 1 , part of ligue 1 team of the season, already became inter miami 4th highest top scorer , won them their first trophy , what did vini won for madrid??? Now get lost , dont eat my mind idiot
Not picking KBD because he only played half of the year (after a treble), but happily picking Messi based on about 5-7 games?
Messi played 7 games in 2023??
He´s doing that because he hates Ronaldo :)
@@Christian-xo2hq’based on’ can you read?
@@Christian-xo2hqhis success is based on the 7 game stretch in the world cup, IMBECILE
@@hugewang69the World Cup wasn’t even in 2023
Carragher saying "what has Vini jr done for Real Madrid?"
Unbelievable. In 2023 Vini was rocking the knockout stages in UCL. Got the Golden Ball of the FIFA Club World Cup. Won the Copa Del Rey destroying Barça in the semifinals and giving assists in the Final.
And it's funny how they praise Bellingham for what he's done in Budensleague and La Liga, but tries to downplay what Vini has done in La Liga and UCL.
He's trying to wind Neville up you idiots man.
Guy is a clown
Not to mention Vini scored in all his finals for Madrid except for one...😶
Mo Salah has the same amount of G/A as Mbappe in 2023. Ridiculous
Anyone takes 25 year old Mbappe in their team, with his blistering pace, over Salah let’s be real.
Why complain about Mbappe? Salah should be there ahead of Messi.
@@Romans8-9Messi won a World Cup capping his career off. Have a laugh
@@JakeGreen96 Cool story. Remind me what a WC in 2022 has to do with 2023. Have a laugh!
@@JakeGreen96not this year though. In 2023 he’s done nothing
John Stones in the right back is the perfect pick because he is the one who has popularised the inverted RB role and also played immense in the CL final
it's not about who popularised it though it's about who is the best at it and it's not really a debate between the two at that point
The fact that Ederson is Alison’s understudy at Brazil just shows u allis level . What a guy
Allison gets exposed as a Brazilian Kepa whenever he plays for Brazil.....
@@OfficialGobbledyGookerno
Alison is fraud Whenever he doing gk for Brazil
cap, brazil’s defence is appalling he can’t do anything about that.
@@KINGKING10109Alisson started at the World Cup if you watched it, you donut 😂😂😂😂😂
Trying to sneak Messi into this team is crazy 😂
Messi owns this team
Messi has never owned anything in his life except Old Antonella
@@kellyoniha9642and the bernaleo, Spain, Europe and football
@@kellyoniha9642Anyone who has half a brain and can read basic stats would know that Messi is the greatest to ever set foot on the pitch
@@shysmy19 Anyone who thinks like you is mediocre at football knowledge. You people start with "Anyone who has a brain...." to cloud your knowledge on football matters lmao 🤣
Kyle Walker, Araujo, Frenkie De Jong and Rudiger not being nominated is genuinely laughable when you see some of the players that stunk the place out first half of the year always get a place no matter how bad they've been.
No chance rudiger
this is from last year performance. arjuho makes it this year.kyle walker not in there is crazy
@@hawkthemans lol Rudiger has been class this season and last season. Far better over this calendar year than others like VVD.
Mate you say "players that stunk the place out first half of the year" and then ask for Walker lol... Man was warming the bench most of the time
@@Nightsu Minjae, Araujo, Kounde, Stones, Dias all much better, never mentioned Vvd
Kane instead of vini for sure Kane has the most goals in 2023 Calender year (52)of any player in Europes top 5 half of whilst playing for a spurs side that didn’t make Europe
Nice trophy that was for Kane. Also 38 year Ronaldo outscored him 😂😂😂
@@OfficialGobbledyGooker he had no opportunities to win a trophy this year
@@OfficialGobbledyGooker 38 years old - almost a year for every penalty he scored this year (32).
I think it should be Salah because you can't put 3 Strikers in the front three
If only Kane was a... left winger..
The smirk on Jamies face when Gary was waxing lyrical about Allison 🙃😂
It`s really annoying to hear people like Carra trying to discredit the Spanish Liga, a Championship which is not inferior to EPL. Just count the number of times that spanish teams have beaten english teams in Europe in the last 25 years....You should be amazed by the statistics in Champions League and Europa League. By the way, Carra, there is much more fun watching Real Madrid, Girona, Ahtletic de Bilbao, Real Sociedad and Atlético de Madrid playing good football, than watching a Premier were there are only two teams (Man City and Liverpool) with real options to win the league, while the others use to do great mistakes tactically and technically
No matter how you put it Walker gets in ahead of everyone at the RB position for 2023, he won a treble the first half of the year.
Yea shocking take from them
Blame ea they didn’t even put him in as a nominee
@@bluesEvanskro just seen the defender nominations. the absolute state of them van dijk and trent. genuinely laughable the liverpool favouritism (as always)
Kyle walker is extremely overrated and not just that he doesn’t even okay rb he plays as the right sided center back
@@NightsuComplain over a Game, City always get favourited when it comes to real life
Kyle Walker not being listed there is really unexplainable.
Also, for 2023, I'd have Salah right wing. I love Messi and Vini (who doesn't) but Salah is just ridiculous. Especially his form to start this season
Salah surely like how he’s never been in a toty amazes me
True, if this Salah played between 2003-2010 he would have been in at least 5.
It’s disgusting at this point, the disrespect, undermining & overlooking Salah gets. Almost like a discriminatory agenda against him. Especially by Carra, proves it even worse. If he was South American or European they’d be hailing him as the best next thing since sliced bread.
Salah wasn't that good the first half of the year and didn't even make the PL TOTS.
By numbers he should get over vini!
@@DionBakangaand what has Messi done this year?
They’re like two siblings arguing over Vini 😂😂😂
Putting Messi in a 2023 team of the year is criminal
Messi's PR is unbelievably good.
Carragher actually trying to justify it
Nowhere near CR7's PR with his nonsense inclusion into the selection of best XI of 2023 lol
ronaldos pr is even better people are pushing him to win the golden boot for scoring goals in the saudi league
@MirkoS1995 @jiahaogoh2822 i dont think you guys understand the definition of pr innit?😂 plus maybe he gets nominated but unlike messi does he go on to win it when he clearly doesn't deserve it?
@@ashratullahahmadi2236 he won Dubai player of the century and other obscene awards just made for him, don’t come here and act like cr7 is not favored by media ahah… keep crying
Kyle Walker not in the choices? Surely the Glazers have to take responsibility for this farce Gary
The way Gary Neville crumbles and stutters is too funny 😂😂😂
Cause Carragher is interrupting him all the time when he knows he has been had. Pick Messi who had his best performance in 22 in a 23 year line up. Then says Vini plays against easy opposition in the la liga while he is riding Messis back who played in farmers league. You can't make it up.
Trent at right back is outrageous
Had the second most g/a by a defender in a calendar year… ever, as in of all time. Liverpool also lost 1 of the last 30 prem games of the year, which only coincides with the moment he starting inverting into the midfield
Him being nominated is outrageous alone. Let alone getting picked
It’s about 2023, not the whole of last season..
@@juanteranlopez4900Koundé clear though
@@juanteranlopez4900he’s a defender, why are you mentioning G/A???
No Gundo is mental, absolutely pivotal to the City treble and was 100% more important than KDB and B Silva for the treble...
Carra trying not to smile when Neville said Alison is the best GK in the world 😂 love it
He agrees unlike carragher who brings up Liverpool player all the time in every conversation ..
@@dibeshshrestha9277 he agrees now after realising Carra is bang on as always. Carra isn't biased but you can believe what you want of course
@@MrJaywalk you’re embarrassing yourself. He claimed Messi should be in for his shambolic 2023 and said no Vinicius because it’s easy to play in La Liga and then says Bellingham should be in for what he’s doing in La Liga, not to mention the leagues Messi played in in 2023 are Ligue 1 and MLS that too while playing terribly. Regardless neither Vinicius or especially Messi should be in the conversation for RW. It should be Salah
@@CR7_THEGOAT777 I said Carra isn’t biased, where have you disproven that? Surely if he was biased he would’ve picked Salah 😂
There’s a difference between being biased and being hypocritical or contradictory, which I wasn’t touching on and quite frankly am not willing to engage with an inflammatory person like yourself! I’ll carry on embarrassing myself in peace thank you 😊
@@CR7_THEGOAT777 oh, also, no surprise you hating on Messi with a username like that! Seems like someone here IS in fact biased, but it ain’t Carra 😬
Salah walks in at RW, no one is close to him in that position
Saka is in a category of his own, above every right winger in the PL, but one.
Salah.
Fr tho
Stone's pick is absolutely right.
He had to be THERE ❤
GK-Alisson
LB-Grimaldo
CB-Dias
CB-VVD
RB-Frimpong
DM-Rodri
CM-Bellingham
CM-KDB
LW-Rafael Leao
ST-Haaland
RW-Salah
I seriously think Jamie wants a intimate relationship with Messi
Who doesnt
i feel like he doesnt actually like messi that much, he just hates ronaldo that much that he has to constantly lift up his rival. Carra will never forgive how ronaldo destroyed his liverpool multiple times including UCL final
Griezmann is Laliga player of the season , has more goals and assist then any other player. How can he be not in that list. Crazy
I wonder why Neville never made it as a manager with such an incredible ability to balance a team.
a team of the year isnt about making the most balanced side, its to put the best player of that year in the respective positions
You don’t actually play with this team it’s the best players
@@brodiedunn1812exactly I hate when people start thinking about how the team would play like that’s not what it’s about
@@otherbrookzy Oh so its not 'team' of the year then. Why not just pick 6 strikers then or 2 goalkeepers?
Kane over Haaland for me. Scored 30 league goals in the Prem last season, only 6 less than Haaland, in a much worse Spurs side and is now killing it at Bayern.
He won nothing and haaland scored more goals and won a treble try again
@otey7326he’s been injured what you talking about he hasn’t players for about a month
Where his trophy's🤔? Yeah he doesn't have ANY!😢
@@FbgAbe Kane scored more goals in 2023 than Haaland
I’d have Kane over Mbappe or Kane over vini not over haaland. Haaland won the treble and broke the scoring record you absolutely must have him in. Mbappe is in a farmers league and goes missing in UCL and vini is good but Kane is better
Im actually surprised Salah wasn't even mentioned for right wing. Liverpool had a rough end to last season, and are doing better now, but the only players who have been consistently world class throughout all that time are Alisson and Salah. Vini is obviously great, but is he better than Salah; no, and he plays left wing. Real madrid didn't win anything last season either so that's not an argument. Just seemed odd that it was between vini and messi.
Bernardo
he deserves it more then messi mate and i aint no salah fan
Real Madrid won copa del rey, fifa club world cup, uefa super cup, semis in ucl and 2nd in laliga. What did liverpool won? 5 in premier league. Beaten by real madrid 6-2 on aggregate in ucl. Liverpool player should not be in conversation at all. They totally suck last season.
Ederson won everything and had good season and ppl still pick Allison🤦♂️
I’m an Arsenal and it’s Salah for that RW all day long
What does being an Arsenal fan have to do with anything? It‘s not that any of your players would be in the discussion anyway.
I don't know why Jamie Carragher is soo dumb calling La liga a joke league, that truly shows his football knowledge mate
They didn't want to put Kane in so they don't look biased, but Kane has the most goals out of any player in 2023. Huge error.
No Ronaldo did
@@tommurrell7605what in that want to be farmers league?
Not quite a treble tho is it
why would they look biased?
@@kb4903 just corrected a fact, keep your hair on
I love this duo the way they fight close up, breaks me up fr
It's Salah obviously, Salah is currently one of the best if not the best in the world, top goalscorer and assister this season in the Prem since August, Since January he's been consitently one of the best in the world even with Hendo, Fab and Curtis behind him which looked lost. Put Vini in Liverpool from Jan - Dec and I guarantee he wouldn't touch Salah's records
Carra contradicted every pick he made, nessi😂😂😂😂 played in usa and France, yet vini junior playing weak opposition😂😂😂
The RW answer is Salah, can’t believe they didn’t even mention him🤨
Jamie Carragher, a football Punidt, lauds Messi's performance in the MLS while doesn't consider Vinicius worthy of praise because he plays in a "Joke League"... There's no way this man can be called a serious unbiased Pundit...
Who invited messi into the discussion? 💀
Best player in th world mate .
yh 5 years ago@@mattevans911
@@mattevans911what world
@@mattevans911not this year tho..
@@sanghitathakuria9255 he is tho. Literly Nobody is better than him. Doesn't matter where or who he is playing. He's still th best.
Martinez, Walker, Dias, Kim, Di Marco, Rodri, De Bruyne, Silva, Messi, Mbappe, Haaland.
How is Osimhen never mentioned up front.... Madness... Serie A winner.... 31 goals in 39 games in all competitions last season and UCL Quarter Finalist.... Madness...
Out of the 23 champions league seasons in the 2nd milenium, El Classico won 11 titles, the other 12 are divided between 8 different teams from 4 leagues. From 2014 to 2018 there were 2 all Spanish finals, 4 times both European cups were won by Spanish teams, and 3 times there were 3 Spanish teams in the semi finals, and most importantly only Spanish teams won the CL.
PL in the last 5 seasons - ManCity - 4 Liverpool - 1
LaLiga in the last 5 seasons - Real Madrid - 2 Barcelona - 2 Atletico - 1
Manchester City and Liverpool have had games in the PL where they won by 7 - 0 or 8 - 0 while no one in LaLiga has come even close to that in the last 5 years.
How anyone can ever claim that PL is more competitive and higher quality is beyond me
Completely agree Kyle Walker should be in the team let alone in the short list!
Playinig in the MLS and Saudi Arabia should disqualify players from these discussions
And when does Jamie carragher watch foreign leagues? He's winging his job big time
The fact that Carra stands there and calls La Liga a "joke" while he puts Messi in his team even though he hasn't done much in 2023 and has played in Ligue 1 and MLS, is just ridiculous.
These two are the best British duo
Messi and Vini getting shouts ahead of Salah and Kane😂
carra was on a pure wind up to gary all video love it
Neville: Picks DeBruyne despite missing half the year
Also Neville: Doesn’t pick Messi despite missing half the year
I already know Carra’s team will be better than Neville’s. Neville is a great pundit for some things but baaadddd at things like this.
Neville’s was actually better,
Carra picking Messi is ridiculous, his team is automatically worse because of that.
@@Romans8-9greatest player of all time. Dragged his team to a World Cup final a year ago and you think his level has dropped that far. You’re delusional
@@HM-mw7cg 2022 is not 2023 bro. Did you ever learn math?
Carra automatically loses for that BS disgraceful pick of Messi over Salah, especially since he’s a Liverpool player as well. The utter disgusting disrespect to Salah continues as usual even worse and more clear since it’s from Carra. If he was European or South American and with “popularity/marketing/trending” they’d never stop mentioning Salah’s name as the next best thing since sliced bread
How Trent gets in after his season is hilarious, john stones was clearly better last season
These teams always end up bring affected by recency bias.
Tbf John Stones has been injured a lot and the year 2023, Trent has been good
@@nmz3450 he hasn’t been injured a lot just for a few weeks recently. Shows how people base a whole year off of just a few months
carragher saying de bruynes played half a season but picking trent whos had a good 3 months
How Harry Kane isn't even mentioned is unbelievable. Disrespected once again.
Neville saying Trent did okay after the inverted move lol he had 1 goal and 7 assists in the last 10 games of the season, he was absolutely incredible
To be fair, Trent himself said he models his game & movement in that inverted role on John Stones.
@@Gagefelstead I'm not saying it should be Trent over Stones, I think it should be stones or walker because they won the treble
I'm just laughing at Neville because he's so bitter that he's committed a false impression of Trent to memory, when in reality from March-December he was class
@@danielward3879 I think he's worried he won't just be behind Kyle Walker in the all time XI of the premier league, because he'll be behind trent as well😂
Still… Koundé was miles ahead Trent last season
@@Gagefelstead 8 times PL champion .. trent needs to win atleast half of it to be even on the same bracket .. useless comparison ..
Carragher calling la liga a joke while they have the most ucls is funny .Also not even them mentioning ter stegn who made a record is a disgrace and shows their ball knowledge
Near the end Carra says the Ballon d'Or was for the calendar year but that's not true. It hasn't worked like that since they changed it a couple years ago. Ballon d'Or is now for the season, not the calendar year.
Carrager seriously called La Liga a joke league on TV. Teens on twitter argue like that, he should be so embarrassed. Liverpool were knocked out from UCL by spanish clubs 4 in the last 5 years. He had the audacity to ask "What did Vini do?" knowing full well Vini dismantled Enfield. I know he doesn't know anything else about Vini, cuz he only watches Prem teams games, but that 2:5 he should remember well, apparently he chose to delete it from his memory. Absolute clownery.
No Salah or Kane? 😳
English media 😂😂
@@vendexa5840 ...English media not picking English striker?
don’t understand why more people are complaining about jamie’s biasness 😅
Snuck Messi in the thumbnail
I love Messi but his 2023 was pretty much complete empty lol
Snuck the Ballon’dor winner in the thumbnail?
@@-RSH it's a team of the year not team of the world cup
Snuck in Trent....
he’ll be in the toty because he won the ballon dor, fifa have never not put the ballon dor winner in the team
It's crazy a team can win 5 trophies, become the best English side of all time, be undefeated at home in 2023, give out a joint biggest semi-final defeat of all time to none other than Real Madrid and still have so many players snubbed from this. Mind boggling
Any team of the year without SALAH is an Absolute Joke, his stats are outrageous and mind blowing even when Liverpool struggled
Carrara had a shocker here
Carra understand what a year means, Jan 1 - Dec 31, i know people arrange stats to fit their agenda but the year is non negotiable
my pick is Di rorenzo -Min jae-Dias-Arnold, Gundogan-Modric-Rodri, Benzema-Haland-Vini
Modric? Over Bernardo and De Bruyne
Real Madrid fan, Benzema? Really?
Carra just loves winding Neville up😂
LOOK, dear Jamie, the clashes between Real Madrid v. Liverpool in UCL:
1981 FINAL: Liverpool 1 Real Madrid 0
2008/09 round of 16: Liverpool 4 Real Madrid 0; Real Madrid 0 Liverpool 1
2014/15 group phase: Liverpool 0 Real Madrid 4; Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0
2018 FINAL: Real Madrid 3 Liverpool 1
2020/21 quarter final: Real Madrid 3 Liverpool 1; Liverpool 0 Real Madrid 0
2022 FINAL: Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0
2023/2023 round of 16: Liverpool 2 Real Madrid 5; Real Madrid 1 Liverpool 0
11 GAMES: 7 VICTORIES FOR REAL MADRID, 3 VICTORIES FOR LIVERPOOL AND 1 DRAW
A JOKE LEAGUE??
How is Mo Salah not in this team!!!!!
Retired Leo Messi over prime Vinicius Jr any day . A generational talent vs someone who is only in the news for getting abused 😂
Would hurt Neville to much to also let Trent in 😅
because he shouldnt even be nominated 👍
@@Nightsuwhy not ? every RB in the world is being compared to him he is the benchmark
@@TheeFootballHighlights no he isnt you drip and walker literally won a treble last season and didnt strip to finish 5th and go trophyless.
Typical sad Manchester lad 😂
Too
April last year Trent broke the record for the most assists in a month. Neville talking nonsense.
Carragher is choosing based on last 3 years overall it seems instead of 2023 purely. Messi is the greatest ever for me but the absolute love-in by some pundits is just ridiculous. We get it, he's elite, but he doesn't need all these ridiculous selections.
He isnt even elite anymore if other players have had the last few years messi had tjy ain't getting the same amount of rewards and team nominations
Mine is
GK Alisson
RB Alexander-Arnold
CB Dias
CB Stones
CB Dimarco
CDM Rodri
CM De Bruyne
CM Bellingham
RW Salah
ST Haaland
LW Mbappe
12th man Kane
Manager Pep Guardiola
Spot on about Messi Neville, Jamie’s hate for Ronaldo is what drives his love for Messi
Yeah you're not biased at all are you man utd profile picture man, neither is Gary who brought fake stats to mnf to say ronaldo was better than messi 😂😂😂
@@Pjj878did he actually 😂
@@ozzylyon3180 no (i prefer messi). all neville said was he prefers ronaldo but the sped above twisting it to "fake stats"
@@Pjj878 doesn’t change the fact Messi has been above average at best in 2023, there’s at least 20 attacking players who have been better
Mo is clear of messi and you know it
Ederson
Frimpong. Kim. Diaz. Di Marco
Bellingham Rodri. Musiala
Haaland. Kane. Mbappe
Terrible
김민재... 제대로 인정받는구나
my overall toty:
gk: alison
defence: carvajal, militao, stones, i guess araujo? no outstanding left back for the full year and its between him and saliba
midfield: musiala, frenkie de jong, rodri. although barella, de bruyne, silva and bellingham could easily slide in
attack: an extremely disorganised front line of griezmann, haaland and kane with lautaro, osimhen and salah very unfortunate to miss out. but with a 4-3-3 lets have salah, vinicius and haaland.
edit: rudiger has to be in the team so switch him for militao since he's missed half the year
I feel like their decision is spot on!
i agree with that stones pick, he was absolutely vital to the treble winning team, whereas trent has only really been good this season, i think recency bias has caused them to pick trent. really it should be walker.
Alisson;
Alexander-Arnold, Saliba, Van Dijk, Stones;
Rodri, Rice;
Salah, Saka, Mbappé;
Haaland
Van Dijk that finished with no trophies, 5th in the league and bodied by 64 year old Perisic.....
It's a European 11 not a prem 10 + Mbappe
Worst list I have ever seen
@@OfficialGobbledyGooker
Individual performance ≠ team success. Wrap that around your empty skull.
@@Cespar997
Care to explain who else should make it in?
Kane astronomically clear of the full 11
I dont care what anyone says, KDB not being there is an absolute disgrace.
True but I get the point. What you rate more, someone who played half a season and was like 9/10 good or someone who played every game and was 8/10 good, difficult question
@@obiwankenobi6317but Messi who played half a season in farmer league and the rest in burger league deserves to be there 😂😂😂😂😂😊
@@DanielWilson-bu4cq Neither Messi nor Ronaldo deserves even close to being in toty
This sounds like a marriage counselling session, with Kelly taking the role of the therapist 😂
the thing about Trent is that he also ended last season with 8 G+A in the last 10 games. he was revolutionary in that new role
Yeah walkers treble clears
@@IA67676Trent’s legend status clears
@@Deathmare235 Walker clears that dude who can’t even do his job
@@CR7_THEGOAT777 Walker isn’t even as good at attacking as Reece James
@@Deathmare235 and he’s still better than hospital merchant and the defender who can’t defend
I’m a huge Messi fan but I would have chose Salah over Messi
Gary Neville hates Trent 😂
In this clip Gary literally said Trent has been outstanding the last few months and very enjoyable to watch.
@@MarkHogan994 and yet he's gone with Stones at rb😂
@@MarkHogan994he’s acting like Trent was rubish at the start of the year, when his worst period was the second half of last year. In the last 10 games of the last Prem season, Liverpool were undefeated because he started inverting into midfield, where he got 7 assists and 1 goal in those 10 games
KDB scored big important goals at critical points in the treble season that’s why he’s over Bernardo
It would absolutely kill Gary Neville to praise Trent.
Iv noticed this
He literally praised him in this clip lmao, said he's been outstanding the last few months and very enjoyable to watch. How's your listening comprehension?
How is Harry Kane not on the team? Man‘s been phenomenal!
Obviously they’re experts for BPL, not watching any other than that and CL …
Bro what are you smoking.. Bayern isnt even top of their league..
Waxing lyricals about Jude Bellingham in La Liga, but slating Vini Jr saying its easy to do it in La Liga. Mind-blowingly bad and typical English bias 😂😂
Plus picking Vini over Salah is wild, just pure madness
No De Bruyne??? Nah y'all are having a laugh.
He has played 25 minutes in the last 7 months...
My team: GK: Ter Stegen DF: Van Dijk DF: Kim Min Jae DF: Dias: DF: Saliba MF: Rodri MF: De Bruyne MF: Bellingham ATT: Haaland ATT: Kane ATT: Salah
Salah should be RW because Vini isn't a RW, however I would say Vini > Salah in 2023 (Salah 2nd half last season was'nt amazing, whilst Vini has had to deal with Benzema injuries last season, and Joselu as only proper striker this season)
Mo is clear
Salah had more G/A than Vini last season but ok
@@thisguyrighthere8502 "Salah 2nd half last season was'nt amazing"
Salah has 21 G/A between January and July, Vini had 26. "But ok"
@@ihaze8794 Salah still had more G/A than him last season as a whole so what's your point? he's also got more G/A than him this season but you focus on your little purple patch.
Salah literally has the most G/A in 2023, Mo had a much better 2023 overall and to say his 2nd half of the season wasn’t amazing just proves to me that you’re not actually watching the games