The Murder of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley w/ Elizabeth Randall

In the winter of 1974 Athalia Ponsell Lindsley was in the midst of a bitter feud with her neighbor, Alan Stanford. The feud ended in brutal fashion on January 23rd when she was murdered in broad daylight on the front doorstep of her St. Augustine, Florida mansion with a machete. Suspects included both Stanford and her husband, James "Jinx" Lindsley.
Elizabeth Randall, author of the book "Murder in St. Augustine: The Mysterious Death of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley" is my guest this week. She walks us through the evidence against Stanford and theorizes on why the case has never been resolved.
More information about the author and her work can be found here: www.elizabethr...

[@Realhousewivesguide]

Wow thanks so much for doing this!!!

[@MostNotorious]

Hello all, and welcome to the Most Notorious Podcast! Just a reminder, most of my episodes are not uploaded to UA-cam. Regular episodes are released every week and available at my website www.mostnotorious.com/ and wherever podcasts are heard, including:
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/most-notorious-a-true-crime-history-podcast/id1055044256
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/1JeYsvYZI4OxGTC9TJljLV
Spreaker: www.spreaker.com/show/mostnotorious
Stitcher: www.stitcher.com/show/most-notorious-a-true-crime-history-podcast
Pandora: www.pandora.com/podcast/all-episodes/most-notorious-a-true-crime-history-podcast/PC:16671
Amazon Music: music.amazon.com/podcasts/39005731-4486-40a2-a16b-1bc62255b243/most-notorious-a-true-crime-history-podcast?refMarker=null
Google Podcasts: podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuc3ByZWFrZXIuY29tL3Nob3cvNDY5ODMxNS9lcGlzb2Rlcy9mZWVk
TuneIn Radio: www.pandora.com/podcast/all-episodes/most-notorious-a-true-crime-history-podcast/PC:16671

[@MusicLeeSarah]

In the True crime genre community Florida is our jackpot, our gold mine for really messed up, crazy, can't make this stuff up, way out there cases. Lol. If a video starts out with the intro for a newscast and they say something like "now with a murder case out of Florida" you stop what your doing and give it your undivided attention because you know it's going to have some insane details, lots of moving parts, a confusing detailed and large cast of characters, and it's going to be worth it.
So you can imagine when I clicked on the description and saw the word Florida I was like "pause... let me see if I can rearrange my day."😆😆😆

[@velocitygirl8551]

Yup! Without fail!

[@DarkGlass824]

I have little respect for our legal system. Exhibit A:

[@velocitygirl8551]

Her response to why do they call him jinx… is stray!? Her response is to say his first wife’s neck was snapped in a car accident!?

[@velocitygirl8551]

25 minutes in and she hasn’t said what happened?

[@kellyowen49]

Took a ghost tour. This home was featured.

[@kellyowen49]

Wait, blonde hair? Wasn't Athena a woman of color?