Dungeon Crawl by Smackwell Games: Is it a good replacement ruleset for HeroQuest?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 сер 2024
  • Many of you asked for this video showcasing Dungeon Crawl as a potential ruleset replacement for HeroQuest. I give you an overview of the rules, the rulebook, and make a special appeal on behalf of the game's creator.
    Patreon: / gaminggeekgiveaway
    Dungeon Crawl Website: dcblog.smackwell.com/
    Dungeon Crawl BGG site: boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/4...
    HeroQuest Reprint Preorder page (until Nov 6): hasbropulse.com/products/hero...
    Advanced HeroQuest gameplay: • Advanced HeroQuest - L...
    0:00 Intro
    1:43 Gameplay & Rules
    20:40 Rulebook Overview
    24:34 Gates of Infernus Adventure
    25:35 House Rules
    26:28 SPECIAL APPEAL
    28:00 Giveaway and GGGG
    28:38 Outro
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 199

  • @gaminggeek241
    @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +7

    Congrats to *DaRa881t* and *Tru Blu Paladin* for being the winners of a digital copy of Dungeon Crawl!

    • @DaRa881t
      @DaRa881t 3 роки тому

      Wow! You make my day :)

    • @trublupaladin7474
      @trublupaladin7474 3 роки тому +1

      thanks alot mate you made being stuck in the house for a week a little more pleasant

    • @jl.4563
      @jl.4563 3 роки тому

      Where do you buy this? I can't find it anywhere?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      @@jl.4563 At this link, click on the yellow "Buy Now" button on the right ribbon: dcblog.smackwell.com/

  • @jamesmhebert
    @jamesmhebert 3 роки тому +10

    Wow. Had no idea this existed! Can’t afford the Heroquest reprint due to covid fallout, but THIS is a terrific thing I CAN get into. Thank you both for the overview and the chance to participate.

  • @steventaylor9962
    @steventaylor9962 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for the review. I am getting the Heroquest reprint and am happy to see even more content that can use it. :)

  • @colincochran9742
    @colincochran9742 3 роки тому +6

    Just bought the download - I have two Hero Quest sets (both missing parts but making into one good set) and am already a dragons rest printer - so will be building a hero quest board and using these rules. Thanks for the tip to check this rule set out. Keep making great videos and cool content.

  • @mes1983
    @mes1983 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for the comprehensive walk through of the game, had absolutely forgotten this. Heading over to buy it now. 😊

  • @DriveThruReview
    @DriveThruReview 3 роки тому +10

    Thank you sir. I like the initiative system immediately. Will definitely pick this up due to your special appeal.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Thanks for supporting Alex!

    • @creepybunny255
      @creepybunny255 3 роки тому

      I like it too, BUT, I would prefer to print / find better cards. I LOVE rolling for initiative, BUT, I do like the card aspect.

  • @kentschoenecker6349
    @kentschoenecker6349 3 роки тому

    Neat - I purchased the reprint of Heroquest, and I think my game group would love these updated rules! Thanks for bringing this rule set to my attention!

  • @JasonMcreynoldsGooglePlus
    @JasonMcreynoldsGooglePlus 3 роки тому +1

    You are awesome! This game looks great too. I bought it to help out Alex AND I get what looks like a really great game as well. Thanks for taking the time to talk about this game and Alex!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Thanks for supporting him too! You are awesome!

  • @tireharicot9444
    @tireharicot9444 3 роки тому +3

    And thanks for making this video! This game deserves more recognition.

  • @capidano6248
    @capidano6248 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks SO much for this recommendation, you steered me this way after I commented on your "Cursed City" review as we had similar ideas. After watching this, purchasing and setting it up me and my boys are ready for our first adventure today! We also opted for the Grid less Play rules found on page 166 so we can play on our Warcry boards and our tables/terrain!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      Nice! Hope your boys really have fun with it!

  • @davidcannon1742
    @davidcannon1742 3 роки тому

    Another fantastic video! I'm so glad that I subscribed and that you keep doing these. Will definitely check out the system.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Thanks, David! Update on my 3D board coming this Friday!

  • @VetsDream
    @VetsDream 3 роки тому +1

    Just purchased Alex's game can not wait to play it. Thanks Gaminggeek for bringing this to our attention.

  • @mistervarnish3704
    @mistervarnish3704 3 роки тому +1

    Another great video. Ive heard of this game but need to snag a copy, great stuff!

  • @htmelle
    @htmelle 3 роки тому +1

    I really like the gameplay of this rule set and is something I think I’ll pickup . Thanks for the play demonstration.

  • @shaneannigans
    @shaneannigans 2 роки тому +1

    Just came across this after watching your HeroQuest video and wish I knew about it sooner!!
    Will be buying a copy and printing it out soon! 😊

  • @astronomicafilms
    @astronomicafilms 3 роки тому

    Someone on the BGG HQ page linked your video - the DC looks like a simple, clean system with a sense of humor. I like what I’ve seen!

  • @BlackDouglas1000
    @BlackDouglas1000 2 роки тому

    Not only did you get me to buy the game...now I went and subscribed to your channel. Great content...of course your game table build is where I first spotted you.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      Thanks for subscribing! Hope you enjoy Dungeon Crawl!

  • @mpisc192
    @mpisc192 3 роки тому +3

    Great video! Love this system! Thought your appeal was wonderful too.

  • @GeneralKetchup57
    @GeneralKetchup57 3 роки тому +2

    Great video, I really like your heroquest videos. I have 2 old painted copies and like the new sculpts, but agree that the rules need tweaked. This maybe the answer ....thanks.

  • @Dubstyles84
    @Dubstyles84 3 роки тому +2

    I was watching him develop this in one of the old HQ forums. I wasn't aware it was ever released! Cool!

  • @ryanfair5107
    @ryanfair5107 3 роки тому

    This game sounds fantastic! I always appreciate the support network in the gaming world.

  • @robmweb
    @robmweb 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the review, this is awesome and I will def pick it up! I miss HeroQuest from my childhood, and some nostalgia sounds nice and relaxing right now...

  • @tabletopowlbear
    @tabletopowlbear 3 роки тому +3

    This is fantastic! I’m a bit cash strapped too but I’ve still got my original HeroQuest game & this would make it SOOO much better!

  • @allanbray9480
    @allanbray9480 3 роки тому +1

    Because of your previous video where you said that you wanted to use the heroquest board for dungeon crawl. I went and purchased it. I think it's an amazing system for what you pay. Extremely great value and fantastic game!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I enjoy reading RPG rulebooks even if I never play the game and this was a fun read!

  • @baconseggs
    @baconseggs 3 роки тому +2

    Hero Qwest is a classic. Though I favor the one from GW that was before the one you have. A lot of fond memories with friends while having some adult beverages. I started modifying the rules a little also, but not completely. So the dungeon crawl might be just what I need to revive the old game.
    Thank you for sharing.

  • @JairoDiezSnotlingNegro
    @JairoDiezSnotlingNegro 3 роки тому +3

    Great video and good explanation!!

  • @jeremywade6224
    @jeremywade6224 3 роки тому +1

    Awesome video and game system!!! Great Job my friend 👍 And looking forward to the give away!!! Thank you sincerely Jeremy Wade 👍

  • @bravo320zf
    @bravo320zf 3 роки тому +1

    So I got the game and I have started printing everything out. I'm super excited :)

  • @Jeffs40K
    @Jeffs40K 3 роки тому +8

    I'm really Liking this (Purchased), I have 2 of the old Heroquest (painted up) +Expansions and backed the new one, along with my Prusa and Elegoo this will be a Great Dungeon crawl addition 8) ... this guy really needs his Own KickStarter ! I would like to see you run a Solo Game of this to see how it works also sir.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +2

      It's easy to solo even though you are running 4 heroes. It is possible to solo with less heroes but the scenarios are designed for four so you would have to take out monsters (if only 2 heroes, halve the number of monsters). This isn't perfect because you lose synergy between the classes so I would suggest just playing with 4. When my son and I play, we both take two heroes.

  • @Guru_Swami
    @Guru_Swami 3 роки тому +2

    Didn’t even know about this game! Thanks so much for the video, going to see if the kids are interested.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yes, it's simple enough for kids but the leveling options allow for a lot of variety and customizing. Having adrenaline also allows for greater flexibility with the dice rolls.

  • @gcaddo
    @gcaddo 3 роки тому +2

    Woah. I'm just totally impressed by all the content there! Amazing! And for only US$15 - that's a bargain. Is the text in the pdf searchable? Also - good on you for calling for support of a fellow gamer & content creator! 👍

  • @tevk
    @tevk 3 роки тому

    Cool idea, I like the concept of updated rules for classic games.

  • @capidano6248
    @capidano6248 3 роки тому

    Looks really solid, like that there is a rule set for no DM! I also like your rest action house rule !

  • @darryljess8744
    @darryljess8744 3 роки тому +2

    This looks so beautifully designed

  • @robertwarf3316
    @robertwarf3316 3 роки тому +1

    Man. I gotta get this. Just sub'd your channel. Thanks for this video. Looking forward to more!

  • @Rinhammer
    @Rinhammer 3 роки тому +1

    I'm going to give it a try. Thanks GG... Great video.

  • @mark2851
    @mark2851 3 роки тому +1

    Saw your vid and purchased the set, have only downloaded the rulebook so far, love the mechanics, please do more vids on gameplay and include the rogue (sneak and backstab yeh)

  • @anthonyrivera3616
    @anthonyrivera3616 3 роки тому

    Nice looking rule set. Looking forward to using them with the Dungeon Saga miniatures.

  • @djfacteau1
    @djfacteau1 3 роки тому +2

    Dungeon Crawl seems pretty cool. It’s awesome to see someone put so much soul into their creation

  • @lassebianco2957
    @lassebianco2957 3 роки тому +1

    Got so inspired by this!
    So signed up for Dragons Rest patreon and started printing the entire thing.
    Also bought the Dungeon Crawler by Smackwell - REALLY an awesome gem.
    Of course signed up for your Patreon also, love your stuff/videos.
    Where are the minis from you show in the video?
    Especially the Barbarian (He-man lookalike) ?

  • @christophersayers
    @christophersayers 3 роки тому +1

    While heroquest holds a special place in my heart as the first fantasy board game I ever played, I want to remember it as a child.
    Now that being said.... this rule set sure does sound interesting and may be worth a look.
    Thanks for the video

  • @thedragonsrest
    @thedragonsrest 3 роки тому +1

    Grabbing myself a copy of this now. It sounds awesome :)

  • @overfiendalpha
    @overfiendalpha 3 роки тому

    Great set up. Purchased today.

  • @JimWood28
    @JimWood28 3 роки тому +2

    Looks brilliant, purchasing.

  • @wonderboy2402
    @wonderboy2402 3 роки тому +2

    This game is ready for a Kickstarter! It reminds me of HeroQuest meets dungeon keeper.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      I know, it would be awesome to be in a Kickstarter with printed components.

  • @sethpeterson8261
    @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the video. Unfortunately this just isn't the ruleset, or vibe/flavor I was hoping it would be. However I bought it anyway to support the creator and his obvious passion for his project and to show my appreciation for the amazing amount of work he's obviously poured into it. It might not be for me, but I'm sure it's awesome to tons of others.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks so much for supporting Alex! I think that is super cool even though the game isn't for you. You rock!

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Well I asked you for this video, no reason I couldn't do what you requested in return Ha! I hope he gets a good spike in sales and that helps out and allows him to finally finish it up in the way he wants. EDIT: I also dig his crazy stylized artwork in it - EDIT 2: I'll also say the more I read the more I see why you want to use it for HeroQuest. Everything outside of the basic mechanics and combat mechanics is really good. All the class/race/leveling options. Rules for dark and bashing/lockpicking. The guilds/optional rules & charts. Good stuff. Glad I bought it.

  • @justinhickey4814
    @justinhickey4814 3 роки тому

    Looks awesome!

  • @chavhunter86
    @chavhunter86 3 роки тому +2

    This looks very cool

  • @WalterCrumbcake
    @WalterCrumbcake 3 роки тому +1

    Recently reacquired the original heroquest. I wasn't looking for this but I'm glad I found it! edit: This would go great with "Dungeon Books of Battle Mats".

  • @Evocatorum
    @Evocatorum 3 роки тому

    This is a great video covering this game! I don't spend as much time on BGG as I used to (work/covid), but I'm VERY much looking forward to being able to play it. Question, though, which terrain set do you think works best for it? It looks like you're using the Dragon's Rest set to recreate the HeroQuest map (you covered that on an earlier video), but does that also work with other modules like "Infernus"? I'm itching to put my printer to work...

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yes, if you take a look at this video, you can see how I can configure the board for Infernus: ua-cam.com/video/-SfzX_FO83Q/v-deo.html If you print the Dragon's Rest tiles, they are infinitely configurable and you will be able to make any dungeon you want.

  • @cjanquart
    @cjanquart 3 роки тому

    This looks great!
    The main things our group didn't like about Advanced Hero Quest were all the crazy stupid random events either getting to a settlement or being able to find equipment (bandages and other mundane supplies) and train once we got there. Nothing like not being able to find stuff because villages don't have a lot of stock or your character can't train because you either can't find the trainer or get one of the 'run out of town' results.
    Our group found the Hammer of Sigmar. Yep, used it during a half of an adventure. On the way to a city, lost it in a random event (hurricane or something, geez we were pissed!).
    This is one of those "shut up and take my money!" purchases.

  • @quakeSanchez
    @quakeSanchez 2 роки тому

    Looks really promising. Would check the rulebook out. Thank you for promoting it.
    Not really a fan of healing items being used in an instant from the backpack. But perhaps it makes sence in this system.
    P. S. "Barny is a dwarf..." - well, that was a surprise...

  • @tabletopguilds7906
    @tabletopguilds7906 3 роки тому

    That looks like a great game. Looking forward to giving it a try

  • @nickk.6735
    @nickk.6735 3 роки тому +1

    Bought this system some years ago but never tried it. Now its the time :)

  • @eadorin1554
    @eadorin1554 3 роки тому

    This is great! As someone currently working on their own custom rules, this is some amazing material! Thank you for pointing me toward it!
    As an aside, do you have links to the STLs that you're using for your terrain/walls/Doors? I'd love to order/print some myself. Thanks!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      Glad this is helpful! Check out some of my other videos where I provide information and links to using Dragon's Rest STL files to make the dungeon. they were created for HeroQuest originally.

  • @devinthunderstrike
    @devinthunderstrike 3 роки тому +2

    So to get this game...the only way is through the paypal link on the blog? What exactly am I getting? I see it's $15. but that blog hasn't been updated in 5 years...
    Is this all pdf and I have to print everything? What about the cards and tiles? This seems interesting but I like physical things.

    • @devinthunderstrike
      @devinthunderstrike 3 роки тому

      Always watch the full vid before commenting...Now I know why it's been 5 years since the last update on the blog. Sorry :(

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      @@devinthunderstrike No problem! But if it wasn't clear, it is only PDFs, no printed material. Someone else mentioned Dungeon Universalis if you like physical things. It's on Kickstarter right now.

  • @moshdang
    @moshdang 3 роки тому

    Great video! Quick question, what do you do for playing cards, print on cardstock and laminate? The rulebook you bind with a binding machine right? TIA. Best

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I print the cards on cardstock and then sleeve them, although laminating is a good option too. The rulebook is spiral bound at Office Depot.

  • @brendabiffibaldovino8306
    @brendabiffibaldovino8306 3 роки тому +1

    Bless your heart ❤

  • @p4n95
    @p4n95 3 роки тому

    This is great, thanks! Bought.

  • @GeekosdeTablero
    @GeekosdeTablero 3 роки тому

    Great Content, really like this system, congrats

  • @toddzino58
    @toddzino58 2 роки тому

    I’m printing the Heroquest board using the pre-made rooms that you designed in the community folder on Dragons Rest. Would I still be able to play this game with that, or should I go with individual tiles for this game?

  • @BodyWellnessHub
    @BodyWellnessHub 3 роки тому +1

    Hi Gaminggeek. Great video as usual. Something that puzzled me was that you have this awesome Heroquest'ish board you have created with fantastic hand painted miniatures and this wonderful alternate ruleset. Why them have you backed the Hero quest reprint? Seems like it will be a real let down in comparison!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      That's a great question--it is all for nostalgic reasons because I have such fond memories of playing it when I was younger and it was my first dungeon crawler. But you are correct, I already have the board, miniatures, and this superior alternative ruleset so there isn't really a logical reason to purchase it. Who knows? I may give it away next year when it delivers to one of my Patreon supporters.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      Well, there's also the all-the new scenarios in 2 new quest books (one by an original designer), access to the expansions if you don't already own them, Plastic furniture instead of cardboard including way better doors, several new classes. Plus the new mini designs for the core heroes and monsters are better than the originals. The new hero designs really suck though... Then there's whats been hinted at: An additional add-on Big Boss campaign, potential 4th new class, new alternate rules etc...

  • @Atracaedes1
    @Atracaedes1 3 роки тому +1

    I found my HeroQuest - Master editon. Now i paint the minis. After that, i want to test all the systems for HeroQuest.
    Is DungeonCrawl also available in german?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      No, it isn't. Dungeon Crawl was created by one person so there hasn't been any translation, although I'm sure Alex would be open to anyone willing!

  • @jupyjohn7362
    @jupyjohn7362 3 роки тому

    love your youtubes been 3d printing like you nice job

  • @tonyosborne666
    @tonyosborne666 3 роки тому

    Trying hard not to necro a post, but what do you use to print out the rulebook? (A printer yourself, and specific paper - or a service of some kind?)

  • @tunaboatz2431
    @tunaboatz2431 3 роки тому

    Neat set of rules. I'll have to look into what type of board I'll need to play.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      Check out my video that is coming out tomorrow--shows you my option.

    • @tunaboatz2431
      @tunaboatz2431 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Will do thanks.

  • @werolldice1877
    @werolldice1877 3 роки тому +1

    Looks like a great game to add to my collection! The design looks easy enough for new players... And crunchy enough for us grizzled veterans...

  • @trublupaladin7474
    @trublupaladin7474 3 роки тому

    Wanted to again thank gaminggeek and alex for the dungeon crawl download. Got a dumb question did you put the dungeon crawl rule book binder together yourself or did someone else?.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I had it done at a print store. It cost about $30 USD for one color copy for the cover and the rest black and white, along with binding costs. You can find cheaper with online printing companies, although shipping might be more expensive.

  • @LyleH-13
    @LyleH-13 5 місяців тому

    Perhaps you cover it later in the video, im still watching but I wanted to ask. Is this rule set compatible with some of the other rules additions from other companies like Axian or Advanced Armory or does it stand as a complete replacement? I just bought the remade Heroquest and am deciding how best to upgrade the game. My kids are 5 and 6 years old, so in a way this seems too advanced so I am hoping these different systems are compatible so I can add Axion for now, then introduce this later.

  • @Nerdiac
    @Nerdiac 2 роки тому +1

    Hero Quest video? The bard appears, what a legend :)

  • @kanesanders1579
    @kanesanders1579 3 роки тому +1

    What are your thoughts for adapting this to the D&D series of board games? I’m purchasing this anyway but am not ordering HeroQuest.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +2

      Absolutely would work. I bought the very first one, Castle Ravenloft but got rid of it because it was too simplistic and random for my tastes. But the components would work well with Dungeon Crawl!

  • @pokemonmandag2108
    @pokemonmandag2108 2 роки тому +1

    OK, so i've gone about 8 mins in on this video and im already thinking "updated heroquest rules".
    True the old "original" rules are for kids so they are very very....very basic.
    But if you master those rules then these are just for added fun and are better for adults.
    I will try these out.
    Again awesome video explaning the most of this set.

  • @sethpeterson8261
    @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому +3

    Where did you get your Dungeon Crawl instructions printed and bound like that at?

    • @mark2851
      @mark2851 3 роки тому

      Yeh where ?

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @Gaminggeek Can you let us know how you had the book printed?

    • @WalterCrumbcake
      @WalterCrumbcake 3 роки тому +1

      You could do it yourself but the cheapest binder punch I've seen was $40 for 21 hole. A cheap alternative would be unruled notebooks, remove the wire then print on the paper. It is hard to justify buying a punch unless you're doing print n play rulebooks on a regular basis. I focused my efforts and money on the cards. I've done the MTG rulestip/token + sleeve method on other print n play games but I wanted to go the sleeveless. I also didn't want to mess with glue and lacquer either. So I went the laminator route. Printed on 110lb cardstock with 3mil laminating pouches, ran at the hotter 5mil setting to really bond the sheets to the paper. Finished off with a corner punch. They feel and shuffle great. laminator, laminating pouches, corner punch, paper trimmer, and cardstock was about $70

    • @toddzino58
      @toddzino58 2 роки тому +1

      Office Depot, Staples, Office Max, etc. will do this for you.

  • @bradp6452
    @bradp6452 3 роки тому +2

    I keep half joking about converting the Heroquest missions into the dungeon saga ruleset and component group. Maybe this weekend I will have to give it a go.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Shouldn't be too difficult to convert since it's just replacing the map tiles with the board.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      The DS ruleset is great, simple and quite tactical. Should be simple to plug it into HQ

    • @bradp6452
      @bradp6452 3 роки тому

      Couple of key differences. DS due to the magic structure and the nature of the minions generally needs something to push the pace. If you let the heroes essentially swat every door, it is not ideal. Also need a little tweaking of traps and searching.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@bradp6452 Do you think just using the combat rules and leaving the other rules (magic, traps etc...) basically the same (adjusted values here and there) would work? I'd also plug in the skeleton/bones mechanics to I think.

    • @bradp6452
      @bradp6452 3 роки тому +1

      @@sethpeterson8261 My plan is probably best described as a DS campaign inspired by the classic heroquest adventure plots and maps. Then use it as a testing ground for modifications/alternative rules to DS which may appear in later stuff.

  • @DaRa881t
    @DaRa881t 3 роки тому

    This sounds awesome! I'm glad the Algorithm has sent me to your channel ;) Keep up the great work and thanks for the information.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      You won a digital copy of Dungeon Crawl! Can you send me your name and email address?

  • @tireharicot9444
    @tireharicot9444 3 роки тому +1

    I don't have HeroQuest (yet?) but I have played one third of the Dungeon Crawl campaign before my group dissolved and it was great. Simple, fun but with enough decisions to take to not make it boring. The progression system, the skills and treasures/artifacts are top.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      That's what I love the most about DC--the leveling options and different paths to take. Any dungeon crawler has to have good leveling options for me to like which is why I enjoy Gloomhaven, Shadows of Brimstone, and Middara. I'm hoping Descent 3rd edition will be like this too.

  • @trublupaladin7474
    @trublupaladin7474 3 роки тому

    Sorry if this is a dumb question but does this have to be done on a custom board or can it be done on an original hero quest board?.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      You won a digital copy of Dungeon Crawl! Thanks for being a patron too--I'll send Alex your email and you should receive a link to the download. And yes, you can play this on the original HQ board.

  • @andyz.5431
    @andyz.5431 3 роки тому

    To complicated, the charme of the original HQ is that the rules are simple and the game flows, while in other dungeon crawlers you drown in markers and rerolling dice until arm fells off. The only rule I changed is giving the heroes a fixed movement of 7 instead of rolling 2 red dice. Then the game has even more pace and flow.

  • @RodIII1000
    @RodIII1000 3 роки тому

    What a just-plain cool looking game!

  • @Raida7
    @Raida7 3 роки тому +2

    This sounds great, considering I've only just discovered the HeroQuest crowdfunding, 22hrs before it ends - wow great advertising Hasbro - and came here from GamingGeek's video on how to buy it from Aus.
    The unlocks, new hero mini design, cost, marketing, info on Hasbro's actual page for it are all leaving a bad taste in my mouth, and so I'm going to go with Dungeon Crawl instead! I'll budget the difference in price to adding to Dungeon Crawl if it's fun to play, like 3D or 2.5D walls.
    Thanks Gaminggeek!

  • @dndforbeginners
    @dndforbeginners 3 роки тому

    how does one download this game and from where my computer seems like it doesnt like the site

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      You purchase the game by going to the website and clicking on the "Buy Now" yellow button to the right side of the page. Once you buy, Alex will email you so you can download the files. I just checked the website and it is working fine--not sure why your computer doesn't like it.

  • @samuelbroad11
    @samuelbroad11 3 роки тому

    Dilly Dally Doom! Great vid man.

  • @rainerbreitsprecher7960
    @rainerbreitsprecher7960 3 роки тому +1

    I recently was looking for a new dungeon crawl ruleset. Something in between Dungeon Saga and D&D, and this might be the perfect choice! Looking forward to reuse the classic 'Das schwarze Auge' (Dark Eye) Board Games 😎

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      Not sure what you mean exactly by inbetween D&D and DS, but I'd say Dungeon Saga is definitely more tactical than Dungeon Crawl

    • @rainerbreitsprecher7960
      @rainerbreitsprecher7960 3 роки тому

      @@sethpeterson8261 Judging by the video, Dungeon Crawl seems to have more overall options, possible player actions, varied turn order, events and character levelling. We did enjoy DS (painted most Minis, doors etc), but if you look for example at "move first, then 1 action", and no search options, no use for exploration, its just "go from a-b before the time is up without getting stuck". (We played the undead campaign and the tyrant of halpi, but did not use the Adventurers Companion). Both time the heroes won if they rushed from start to finish, both times the Overlord won if he dispatched the wizard quickly ;-) . I am hoping that in Dungeon Crawl there is a real point to explore the dungeon and discover treasures or dangerous traps. Additionally you might level up your hero... for instance, i like the option to join a guild or learn new skills, aquire items and new weapons... Dungeon Saga has predefined character loadouts per scenario. So, i guess there should have been just something "more" to Dungeon Saga.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@rainerbreitsprecher7960 I see what you mean, and I agree with you that Dungeon Crawl is better than Dungeon Saga for most everything else (searching, adventuring, classes/races, skills, leveling etc...), . I was speaking specifically about the turn-by-turn combat actions which is where DS has more to it tactically with engagement arcs, facing, outnumbering, breaking away, how damage works, how armor works, I think the dice comparison mechanics are better etc... But yes, I agree the rest is better done in Dungeon Crawl.

  • @oneanotherstudios
    @oneanotherstudios 2 роки тому

    Sorry, I know this is not a recent video, but where did you print the rulebook? I bought this game and am trying to find somewhere to print it but every place I try says they cannot print it because the fonts are not embedded.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому +1

      I had my local Office Depot/Max print it out for me and it was fine. Did you receive a PDF?

    • @oneanotherstudios
      @oneanotherstudios 2 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Yes, it is a PDF which is why I was confused. I've never had such an issue before. Thankfully, though, I think I now have a solution: apparently my employer increased the file sizes we can accept from outside emails. So now I can send it to my work email address and print it at the office. Thanks for responding!! :-)

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      @@oneanotherstudios Great! Glad you found a solution!

  • @hbkkenobi3225
    @hbkkenobi3225 Рік тому

    Is this still available for purchase? The website looks old

  • @frankblazkiewicz2636
    @frankblazkiewicz2636 3 роки тому

    Thank you for the detailed overview of Dungeon Crawl. I'm interested.
    On another subject, do you have any experience with Dungeon Universalis? Its currently back on kickstarter.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I looked into it but it has a really crunchy ruleset (relatively complex). I'm all about simplifying things but if you like deep and complex games which combine RPG elements with tactical skirmish rules, then Dungeon Universalis is for you! Especially since they are providing all of the cards and elements printed for you. I don't think it would be easy to adapt to HeroQuest though.

    • @Jeffs40K
      @Jeffs40K 3 роки тому +1

      Me and my Fiends are the Old School AD&D First edition type, this would be a good game for us, Universalis just has to much tinkering with this and that for a Simple fun Hack n Slash. but to each there own, PS Hated Gloom haven, I dont like Being limited to what I can do by Random cards and running out we loose, its more of a Card Puzzle game wrapped in a dungeon crawl theme.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@Jeffs40K Yes, Gloomhaven is really a card management system with a little bit of tactics thrown in. I know not everyone likes that. I didn't like Descent 2 because it was just a race rather than a real dungeon crawl. But fortunately, there are a lot of dungeon crawlers now so we have our pick!

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Well Dungeon Universalis has a rules section all about making it work with other game systems. plus the current 2nd printing now includes a separate, basic lighter rules version book that would probably be perfect for using with HQ.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@sethpeterson8261 Do you know how easily you could translate the maps for the HQ board? EDIT: Actually, I see they have a video on the Kickstarter site using the HeroQuest board so I'm assuming it can be done--it's in Spanish though: ua-cam.com/video/OQrnloVDv9k/v-deo.html

  • @kingofthe1s214
    @kingofthe1s214 3 роки тому +1

    I thought Heroquest made a mistake when they didn’t update the rules with the new release... gonna check these out...

  • @The_Digital_Samurai
    @The_Digital_Samurai 3 роки тому

    This is cool. I will definitely be interested in a Kickstarter to support him. Are you going to set this up for him? I know what medical issues are. Had to take another mortgage out to help my kid. Still paying for it but almost done.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I won't be setting up the Kickstarter since I don't have any experience! I'm glad that you are almost out from underneath the weight of medical debt. Hope you child is doing well.

  • @recowabunga7200
    @recowabunga7200 3 роки тому +1

    You are a good person.

  • @Achban
    @Achban 3 роки тому

    Looks really nice. I was more or less sure that any remake of HeroQuest would HAVE to update the rules. Sad that they didnt even try.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yeah, it would have been nice if they provided both the classic rules and had an updated ruleset. I wish instead of extra minions and quests, they had a stretch goal to update the rules or creating an app to run the Game Master.

  • @trdmr2ct
    @trdmr2ct 3 роки тому

    I donated to smackwell after seeing your vid, but i never recieved the files, thanks for the amazing reviews, i was wondering if you cant help me get in contact with the author of the print and play.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yes, I can definitely help. Email me at gbummer@gmail.com.

  • @fmmuuhh7597
    @fmmuuhh7597 3 роки тому

    I just subscribed!! Dungeon Crawllll:D

  • @creepybunny255
    @creepybunny255 3 роки тому

    Gaminggeek can you do a more in depth video on the rules of Dungeon Crawl? We bought the game and ran a one shot with it's mchanics and seemed to be clunky... have to have had something wrong? A battle with 2 small goblins took forever because no one was hitting.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yeah, sometimes the dice rolls make some of the battles long so you probably aren't doing something wrong. We house-ruled a rest action that allows you to regain 2 adrenaline. Using adrenaline adds more dice to your attack so if you are finding it difficult to hit, don't skimp on using adrenaline to boost your attacks. Regarding a video, I plan on doing a play-through once the 2nd edition of HeroQuest ships this fall.

    • @creepybunny255
      @creepybunny255 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thanks, but that was a main question too. We only see adrenaline mentioned once or twice but it doesn't tell us the mechanics such as how much to start with, who uses it etc.
      I MAY have missed it, perhaps it's in a section I can't find / didn't print idk. but I've looked through twice and still not getting it, lol

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      @@creepybunny255 No problem, on the top of page 24 under "Add Up Stats" it says "Each Hero's Adrenaline is his Beef + Zip + 3." It's also on page 18 where you get all the rules for Adrenaline usage.

    • @creepybunny255
      @creepybunny255 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 I appreciate it, bro! I'll check it out when I'm not busy in the office. I'll probably add your house rule as well.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@creepybunny255 No problem!

  • @sethpeterson8261
    @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

    OK. Asking again. Where did you get yours printed at? I just priced Office Depot and it came up to $83 just to print it of like what you have there... that's insane.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Is that color copies? That's super expensive. I printed it at my local Office Depot for about $30 for B&W (color cover) and spiral binding with clear cover and black vinyl back. You can get even a better deal with online print services--try googling.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 yeah. Thats for color. Normally I print everything full color at work, but the damn Ronas' got us all working from home.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@sethpeterson8261 At that price, you might want to wait until the office opens up again! A lot of the PDF is monochrome so you could be selective with which pages to print in color and do the rest in B&W.

    • @sethpeterson8261
      @sethpeterson8261 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 For sure. I'll be waiting until at least june of next year before return to office they say (eesh), but I'll be back to unlimited full color high quality printing. I can even print 11x17 heavy cardstock there which is how I got printed my oversized Monolith Conan tiles (that Office Depot quoted me several hundred to do... damn)

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      @@sethpeterson8261 That's awesome you have that as a resource!

  • @genevahuff2102
    @genevahuff2102 2 роки тому

    Did not get any download after paying whats going on? need help if you can.....😑

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      He emails the purchaser with a code or link to get the files. Might be because it was over the weekend. If you don't get anything soon, try emailing him. Tell me if that doesn't work.

  • @joshbarnhart6714
    @joshbarnhart6714 3 роки тому

    How long will it take to receive the email for the download?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Alex is pretty good at sending it within a day. Make sure to check your spam folder if you don't receive it. Also, you can email me if you have issues and I can reach out to Alex directly for you. Look at my channel About section for email.

    • @joshbarnhart6714
      @joshbarnhart6714 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 OK thank you I purchased it today but it asked for a shipping address and not my email Hope I didn't mess it up I have not received the email yet but will wait it out

    • @joshbarnhart6714
      @joshbarnhart6714 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thank you for your help Im new to all of this I played some board games but think they are over complicated and spend to much time on set up I have the original heroquest but have only played the introduction quest and loved it Saving it for the remake also wanted to do my own dungeons

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@joshbarnhart6714 No problem. Again, if you don't hear from Alex soon, just message me.

  • @exodous02
    @exodous02 3 роки тому

    So is this your fav dungeon crawl system or is it just a good replacement for HQ?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      It's a good replacement for HQ--simple and easy to learn for beginners but has enough upgrades and options for veterans. I like other crawlers better, like Shadows of Brimstone and am looking forward to Tanares Adventures, Stormsunder, and Oathsworn but those are more complex and I wouldn't necessarily play with children nor beginners.

  • @mattlisa69
    @mattlisa69 3 роки тому

    Doesn't 'Ye Olde Inn' already cover these new rules for Heroquest already!

  • @mykediemart
    @mykediemart 3 роки тому

    interesting rules set. seems simple and easy enough. I dont like the names of the stats but that is easy enough to over look.

  • @RavenTheScythe
    @RavenTheScythe Рік тому

    I had to double take, I am pretty sure the photo pan is of my copy of the game when I printed it out.