This is what I prefer over the modern T&F. Stories where Nia and Rebecca are main characters but not replacements for Edward and Henry. I hate how two of the oldest engines on Sodor got moved to different sheds and were kicked off the steam team, but I’m not like people who want to see the two new ones scrapped. Great work!
@@BrendamProductions since James already messed the sheds up once, just repeat the story. Make it more dramatic, and use two episodes. One the crash, one rebuild
That was a superb story. Poor Rebecca getting tricked by Bill and Ben and then Diesel, Splatter and Dodge. You have to feel sorry for Rebecca, she really is a very soft and believable character. But I'm glad Nia helped her out in the end. I am still astonished with how you made the lips move on the characters :D .
A heartwarming, but also quite tearful and emotional episode to be honest! This, along with New Engines in Charge are tied to being my favorites from your series! I really love how you gave Rebecca more character development (just like in her episodes in S22, as well as being relatable to anyone), being naive and worrisome (as well as still being new to Sodor), and I do feel sorry for her when she got tricked by Diesel, Splatter and Dodge, and the heart-to-heart relationship between her and Nia is beautifully written, along with the message the latter gave (which is a great moral). Liz Productions5784 and Yilin Zhou did spectacular with their roles respectively. Also, I like how you've added Boomer's theme from TUGS into that scene. As for Diesel, Splatter and Dodge, the humor with them is great, especially the parts where Diesel gets annoyed with them and when he tries to pull the heavy express. Same would go for Splatter and Dodge when their funny lines crack me up. I only do have one question, (and I hope you don't mind me asking), but would Diesel 10 also be in your series as well?
Thanks for all this feedback it's great to know which parts people really enjoyed! I felt that rebecca being guilable was too obvious a trait for me to not make a story about it. You're absolutely right both vas did a great job! Also the biggest aim of splodge was to make them funny so I'm happy that worked! Also D10 will be in my series in the future (yes I have that much planned out).
I agree, this is a good emotional story. I feel bad for Rebecca for getting deceived by Bill & Ben and then the diesels. Thank you Nia for helping out Rebecca.
Nice work on this one, and I like the characterizations of Rebecca and Nia. Stupid Diesel, tricking the latter like that. Though Splatter & Dodge for once managed to pull off helping him with his trick, even if it sort of barely went as planned at first. I knew Diesel wasn't strong enough to pull the Express, but when he blew his motor out, I appreciated that he got Splodge (I like how even the narrator called them that, by the way) to help him. Also, I like how all the engines were worried about Rebecca and searching for her. Plus, James taking the Express instead of Diesel in that one part really provided a prelude to when Diesel would be in for it. As for The Fat Controller sending him to the waste dump, that was a perfect way to give him his comeuppance.
This was really good mate! I quite like how you base your James voice on Top Hat. Makes a change from his scouse roots haha. So many good things I could list here: Nia and Rebecca's character personas, Diesel's character being Zorran-esque with Splatter & Dodge and that engine-belch when he's confronted by TFC was brilliant! Love it!
@@BrendamProductions You did great! I officially accept these as canon over BWBA now xD It's pretty easy to forget all the characters are voiced by one or two actors sometimes, which is really great for immersion! In a world where Mattel is pretty much ruining Thomas you and people like you offer a breath of fresh air. :D
@@qui-gontimtherandomraptor1072 aww thank you people like you with your amazing feedback are a huge part of my inspiration, I’m glad I’ve managed to do what mattel can’t and I’m glad that you enjoy these videos. Having people say why they like my videos more than just yay blue train means a lot to me so again thank you!
Hi Brendam! Your Steam Team is awesome! But for my version of the Steam Team, it's: Boys:Thomas, Edward, Henry, Gordon, James, Percy & Toby Girls:Emily, Nia, Rebecca, Rosie, Molly, Gina & Mavis
There is no way on Earth Diesel can pull the express he's not as powerful as Rebbeca Gordon and Herny put together. They're more capable of pulling express trains while Diesel isn't. Heck even James can pull express trains.
Very well-written story! Nice to see Splatter and Dodge get a role in it, too! If I may offer some constructive criticism: It's honestly distracting to see a character's face being animated and then the next shot it isn't. It's really inconsistent. Either have no animation or always have animation - if there are parts you can't be bothered to have a face animated, simply have the camera facing the speaking character's direction so their face isn't seen, despite clearly talking.
the reason that there sometimes was no face animation is because it would look weird usually because of the characters teeth. When I use my own models the problem will hopefully be gone! Also thank you for the feedback!
This was a great video! I loved the facial animations, the story, I simply loved it! However, when the engines talk, why do sometimes their mouths move, whereas other times, they don't move their mouths at all.
James: I will be very happy to keep Henry here, for one, When I dump Rebecca. Rebecca: (sobbing) Thomas: What? Skarloey, Rheneas, Sir Handel, Falcon, Peter Sam, Stuart, Rusty, Duncan, Duke, Bertram, Mighty Mac, Fearless Freddie, Luke: (laughing)
If I remember correctly I finished writing this before the episode had even aired haha that does mean that this isn’t a rewrite though glad you enjoyed it either way !
If Diesel keeps this bad behavior up Diesel should be kept at the waste dump working at the waste dump for ever more where Diesel belongs from here on in.
I ment: Can I make a history styled version of it using footage from it as well? (Like giving it a date, going into details and stuff. I stick to the topic + you'll be credited.)@@BrendamProductions
I like this quite a bit, but the moving lips and faces are quite off putting. I get that this is supposed to be based on more modern cgi thomas, but I think making it in a purely classic style would still look and feel very good. I don’t think Rebecca’s lips have to move just because she is a cgi character.
This was very early days of doing this I think nowadays I've improved a lot on it (see the arthur saga) also when the series comes back it'll be fully cgi and therefore won't be as weird having mouth animations :)
@@BrendamProductions Ive watched alot of your newer videos and I enjoy them quite alot. You do fantastic work, this is the first video of your’s Ive seen with the moving mouths, which is probably why it stuck out to me. And tbh, the moving mouths have always been a bit unnerving for me going back to when HiT first introduced them. Keep up the great work!
@@trailduster6bt Aww thanks and ah ok yeah as I say when the series properly comes back it'll be in full CGI so it'll be more like watching the CGI series rather than s12
For what Diesel did to poor Rebecca Diesel should live at the waste dump for ever more and Diesel should live at the waste dump for a life time sentence if Diesel keeps causing trouble because it's about time Diesel should keep on working at the waste dump for ever without stopping all day Diesel should be working at the waste dump and Diesel should be working at the waste Dump for the rest of his life from here on in.
I found it interesting that in these fan made thomas series so many people give attention to characters from two different eras of thomas that no one likes/trusts more respect than characters from season 7 (the one season that wasn't completely corrupted with flanderization to the series as a whole). Seriously, Emily gets hated on and shunned by fans for supposedly replacing duck, oliver, and the scottish twins (even though they weren't main characters at all so she didn't really replace them) yet characters like Nia and Rebecca, two characters that only exist to replace edward and henry (who was confirmed out right unlike the "controversy fans have with emily) for the sake of gaining NPC/feminist brownie points get respect and attention by fans, this makes no sense to me and feels like a double standard to me. Hell I also question why annoying characters like philip get respect and attention as well when he's an annoying little shit in his debut episodes, he's a combination of spongebob (season 4 through 9) and jar jar binks.
I can assure you that Nia and Rebecca are not more popular with the fandom than Emily, and people haven't accused Emily of replacing engines 8-11 since around 2006 or so
Thomas does make cameos in the episode but he doesn’t have a role in it because he simply wasn’t needed. Don’t worry he does have a role if only small in the next episode though !
This is what I prefer over the modern T&F. Stories where Nia and Rebecca are main characters but not replacements for Edward and Henry. I hate how two of the oldest engines on Sodor got moved to different sheds and were kicked off the steam team, but I’m not like people who want to see the two new ones scrapped. Great work!
Thanks also I couldn't agree more! If I could I'd have them in an even bigger shed that they make bigger for the two newbies like in cae with emily
I agree with you too!!!!!!
@@BrendamProductions since James already messed the sheds up once, just repeat the story. Make it more dramatic, and use two episodes. One the crash, one rebuild
@@A.i.r_K I meeean maybe? But I think if I was gonna do it story wise I'd do something more along the lines of CAE
@@BrendamProductions what is CAE?
That was a superb story. Poor Rebecca getting tricked by Bill and Ben and then Diesel, Splatter and Dodge. You have to feel sorry for Rebecca, she really is a very soft and believable character. But I'm glad Nia helped her out in the end. I am still astonished with how you made the lips move on the characters :D .
Thanks dude hopefully I can make the lips even better someday!
A heartwarming, but also quite tearful and emotional episode to be honest! This, along with New Engines in Charge are tied to being my favorites from your series!
I really love how you gave Rebecca more character development (just like in her episodes in S22, as well as being relatable to anyone), being naive and worrisome (as well as still being new to Sodor), and I do feel sorry for her when she got tricked by Diesel, Splatter and Dodge, and the heart-to-heart relationship between her and Nia is beautifully written, along with the message the latter gave (which is a great moral). Liz Productions5784 and Yilin Zhou did spectacular with their roles respectively. Also, I like how you've added Boomer's theme from TUGS into that scene.
As for Diesel, Splatter and Dodge, the humor with them is great, especially the parts where Diesel gets annoyed with them and when he tries to pull the heavy express. Same would go for Splatter and Dodge when their funny lines crack me up. I only do have one question, (and I hope you don't mind me asking), but would Diesel 10 also be in your series as well?
Thanks for all this feedback it's great to know which parts people really enjoyed! I felt that rebecca being guilable was too obvious a trait for me to not make a story about it. You're absolutely right both vas did a great job! Also the biggest aim of splodge was to make them funny so I'm happy that worked! Also D10 will be in my series in the future (yes I have that much planned out).
Won’t rub rgbjnvg fghvn guys
Aw what a good emotional story, Brendam. I’m happy to have voiced Rebecca. :) Thanks and great job with your video!
You did a beautiful job voicing Rebecca :D .
Liz, you were excellent as Rebecca :)
Liz Productions5784 so am I lass
Thanks! Also thank you again for voicing rebecca you did a supurb job!
You did a great Rebecca voice.:)
S-SPLATTER AND DODGE???? And Molly in the background too. Amazing.
Rebecca is my general favourite dream character come true. You’ve done a great job with this! And Liz did a grand job voicing her.
A very nice story. Splatter and Dodge were hilarious! I see this as being "Diesel Do Right" done right.
I agree, this is a good emotional story. I feel bad for Rebecca for getting deceived by Bill & Ben and then the diesels. Thank you Nia for helping out Rebecca.
Thank you!
Nice work on this one, and I like the characterizations of Rebecca and Nia. Stupid Diesel, tricking the latter like that. Though Splatter & Dodge for once managed to pull off helping him with his trick, even if it sort of barely went as planned at first. I knew Diesel wasn't strong enough to pull the Express, but when he blew his motor out, I appreciated that he got Splodge (I like how even the narrator called them that, by the way) to help him. Also, I like how all the engines were worried about Rebecca and searching for her. Plus, James taking the Express instead of Diesel in that one part really provided a prelude to when Diesel would be in for it. As for The Fat Controller sending him to the waste dump, that was a perfect way to give him his comeuppance.
Serves Diesel right! He should not treat Rebecca or anyone like that! Anyways, splendid episode!
"Sir Rebecca jas disappeared somewhere to have a cry!" James puffed
"No one knows where she is" whistled percy
"And i miss her" peeped Emily
Thank you for giving Nia and Rebecca more likable.
This one episode has done them better than BWBA ever could.
If ya like them here just wait till series 2 is up and running ;)
@@BrendamProductions Can't wait 👍
Rebecca gets better characterization in fanmade episodes than BWBA...
This was really good mate! I quite like how you base your James voice on Top Hat. Makes a change from his scouse roots haha. So many good things I could list here: Nia and Rebecca's character personas, Diesel's character being Zorran-esque with Splatter & Dodge and that engine-belch when he's confronted by TFC was brilliant! Love it!
Haha did you remember the james thing from when I said at butterly! Also thank you for all the nice compliments!
@@BrendamProductions Oh wait yeah I do now! Haha lool! And yeah you're welcome :)
@@BrendamProductionstubb hhh Hugh
I love the use of sea rouges theme near the end! It was perfect
Thank you!
Man, this was a great episode! This was yet another good one of showing how evil Diesel can be.
And it was a good role for Rebecca!
Thank you!
@@BrendamProductions you're welcome, mate
This is Diesel Do Right but done right!👍
If I was the Fat Controller then I would've provided Diesel a worse punishment, which is working at the waste dump for 3 years.
I mean the Fat Controller doesn't want to send him away because he is sometimes helpful.
This was beautifully animated. Your best work yet!
Thanks I didn't know this was better animated than usual? haha!
That was amazing and a good episode Deisel was naughty playing a trick on Rebecca like that she was upset
I love how natural your dialogue feels xD Keep up the great work!!! 😃
Edit: also I love what you did with Rebecca and Nia here 😁
Thank you natural dialogue is something I always aim for in my scripts! Also thank you I tried to make them both a bit more fleshed out in this one!
@@BrendamProductions You did great! I officially accept these as canon over BWBA now xD It's pretty easy to forget all the characters are voiced by one or two actors sometimes, which is really great for immersion! In a world where Mattel is pretty much ruining Thomas you and people like you offer a breath of fresh air. :D
@@qui-gontimtherandomraptor1072 aww thank you people like you with your amazing feedback are a huge part of my inspiration, I’m glad I’ve managed to do what mattel can’t and I’m glad that you enjoy these videos. Having people say why they like my videos more than just yay blue train means a lot to me so again thank you!
Hi Brendam! Your Steam Team is awesome! But for my version of the Steam Team, it's:
Boys:Thomas, Edward, Henry, Gordon, James, Percy & Toby
Girls:Emily, Nia, Rebecca, Rosie, Molly, Gina & Mavis
That serves you right Diesel 😡.
This is very interesting, a very good way of interesting by the way. I want to see more of this.
There is no way on Earth Diesel can pull the express he's not as powerful as Rebbeca Gordon and Herny put together. They're more capable of pulling express trains while Diesel isn't. Heck even James can pull express trains.
Oh they can do it alright. It just wouldn't be at Express speed XD
Nice cameos of D199 and BoCo
Very Well Done
Thanks!
Hmm! Trouble ! Diesel is a mischief maker of the biggest kind. And she's going to find out the mischief doesn't work out. At all.
I hear Tobias and the half pariah music during Nia and Rebecca’s conversation.
SPLODGE ARE BAAAAAACK!!!!!!😁😁😁
YESSSSSH!!!😆😆😆
Those were some good words of wisdom Nia said to Rebecca
12:09
Diesel: I’LL GET YOU NEXT TIME PUFFBALL
New friend: 😤👊
That's more better than in the original series episode, Diesel Do Right.
Very well-written story! Nice to see Splatter and Dodge get a role in it, too!
If I may offer some constructive criticism: It's honestly distracting to see a character's face being animated and then the next shot it isn't. It's really inconsistent. Either have no animation or always have animation - if there are parts you can't be bothered to have a face animated, simply have the camera facing the speaking character's direction so their face isn't seen, despite clearly talking.
the reason that there sometimes was no face animation is because it would look weird usually because of the characters teeth. When I use my own models the problem will hopefully be gone! Also thank you for the feedback!
"Everyone at Tidmouth sheds is a trustworthy engine!"
*shows Nia at Tidmouth*
Pattin' yerself on the back there a little bit, ain't'cha -_-
hah thats a good one i would glady kill nia and cancel the season 25 reboot if i saw some one who worked at mattel
This is amazing Harry! Excellent work! :D
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
Sure thing! 👍
Very nice i wish i could see another of theses with dodge and splatter
Awesome video :)
Thanks!
This was a great video! I loved the facial animations, the story, I simply loved it! However, when the engines talk, why do sometimes their mouths move, whereas other times, they don't move their mouths at all.
11:13-11:15 Aww...Gordon
That's Amazing!☺
Thanks!
Great video keep it up mate but I know you will ;-)👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👍👍👍
Thanks!
@@BrendamProductions I'm a big fan
@@steamerfan2212 Thank youuu!
@@BrendamProductions no problem man hey I have a video idea
@@steamerfan2212 what is it? ;)
James: I will be very happy to keep Henry here, for one, When I dump Rebecca.
Rebecca: (sobbing)
Thomas: What?
Skarloey, Rheneas, Sir Handel, Falcon, Peter Sam, Stuart, Rusty, Duncan, Duke, Bertram, Mighty Mac, Fearless Freddie, Luke: (laughing)
New friend: No way James
0:23 Oh Fuck! Thought Gordon was gunna slam into the signalbox for a sec there.....
Wouldn't be the *first* time he slammed into something....
Did anyone else but me notice that Splatter and Dodge were off center from the tracks while talking to Rebecca on the bridge?
Awesome. Love it
Well Done. 👍🏻
love this episode
Thank you!
I love Nia & Rebecca
That was a very good story👍👍Thx for having me in it!!
Thanks and thank you for voicing nia you did a great job!
I like how there mouths move
Diesel now controls Splatter And Dodge
Nia: So you were the ones who cheated my Friend Rebecca
Diesel: Let's escapes Guys, they discovered Us
Splatter: yes Boss
Dodge: Run we follow Him
oh, THAT trainz 2019!
All them leave my 'Becca alone!
7:46 D199/Spamcan: Why am I here? >:(
Percy in the yards reminds me of Percy's Ploy (because the trucks are there)
Much better than Diesel Do Right!
If I remember correctly I finished writing this before the episode had even aired haha that does mean that this isn’t a rewrite though glad you enjoyed it either way !
Do you keep Edward, Henry and Toby in the Steam Team?
If Diesel keeps this bad behavior up Diesel should be kept at the waste dump working at the waste dump for ever more where Diesel belongs from here on in.
This was really good
Gave it a mention on my channel
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it that much!
Brendam Productions you’re very welcome
james was pulling the coaches like rebecca but he tried to find him🙁
Spatter and Dodge are actually sidekicks of diesel 10
I mean not all the time look at the end of tatmr
@@BrendamProductions because they were done with diesel 10 after that and not much is known about them after Thomas and the magic railroad
@@dylansmith5379 Right so what's to say they wouldn't work with diesel now ?
Could I reflect onto that in one of my videos? (It'll sound a bit like a documentary about it.)
I'm not sure what you mean sorry
I ment: Can I make a history styled version of it using footage from it as well? (Like giving it a date, going into details and stuff. I stick to the topic + you'll be credited.)@@BrendamProductions
Splatter and Dodge and Diesel is up to something.
I like this quite a bit, but the moving lips and faces are quite off putting. I get that this is supposed to be based on more modern cgi thomas, but I think making it in a purely classic style would still look and feel very good. I don’t think Rebecca’s lips have to move just because she is a cgi character.
This was very early days of doing this I think nowadays I've improved a lot on it (see the arthur saga) also when the series comes back it'll be fully cgi and therefore won't be as weird having mouth animations :)
@@BrendamProductions Ive watched alot of your newer videos and I enjoy them quite alot. You do fantastic work, this is the first video of your’s Ive seen with the moving mouths, which is probably why it stuck out to me. And tbh, the moving mouths have always been a bit unnerving for me going back to when HiT first introduced them. Keep up the great work!
@@trailduster6bt Aww thanks and ah ok yeah as I say when the series properly comes back it'll be in full CGI so it'll be more like watching the CGI series rather than s12
What's the name of the music at 3:22? I've been trying to find that theme for a while now.
i think is Dodge and Splatter theme
For what Diesel did to poor Rebecca Diesel should live at the waste dump for ever more and Diesel should live at the waste dump for a life time sentence if Diesel keeps causing trouble because it's about time Diesel should keep on working at the waste dump for ever without stopping all day Diesel should be working at the waste dump and Diesel should be working at the waste Dump for the rest of his life from here on in.
I found it interesting that in these fan made thomas series so many people give attention to characters from two different eras of thomas that no one likes/trusts more respect than characters from season 7 (the one season that wasn't completely corrupted with flanderization to the series as a whole).
Seriously, Emily gets hated on and shunned by fans for supposedly replacing duck, oliver, and the scottish twins (even though they weren't main characters at all so she didn't really replace them) yet characters like Nia and Rebecca, two characters that only exist to replace edward and henry (who was confirmed out right unlike the "controversy fans have with emily) for the sake of gaining NPC/feminist brownie points get respect and attention by fans, this makes no sense to me and feels like a double standard to me. Hell I also question why annoying characters like philip get respect and attention as well when he's an annoying little shit in his debut episodes, he's a combination of spongebob (season 4 through 9) and jar jar binks.
I can assure you that Nia and Rebecca are not more popular with the fandom than Emily, and people haven't accused Emily of replacing engines 8-11 since around 2006 or so
Where did you get the rebecca model from
With an attitude like that he will never never eeeeeever get what he wants
Like in the ending of "Diesel Do Right"
6:34 6:35 6:36
The three stooges
What game do you play to make this
Trainz Simulator 19
Nope! You get what you don't want!!! 😉
New Episode "Percy and the Haunted Florest"
0:47
How did you use their mouths?
Ok
Say wheres thomas?
Thomas does make cameos in the episode but he doesn’t have a role in it because he simply wasn’t needed. Don’t worry he does have a role if only small in the next episode though !
@@BrendamProductions Oke
EW THE MOUTH MOVMENTS
Meke the vídeo cald nia cry and go home for ever
Nooooooo nia no mor nia vídeos
6:21