@@verginithe I liked him for his effort level. He worked so hard to put on a show. When I pay 80 bucks for a ticket I expect you to leave it all on the stage, and he did.
@@jonbonzo9199 I really don't get the adulation that some people have for them. They have a couple of standout tracks but their output is so bland and homogenised I struggle to tell most of them apart.
A few decades ago, I saw a TV ad (I was in Australia at the time) for a Foo Fighters tour. The ad says they are the best band in the world. I was in a state of shock. I said: "The Foo Fighters are the world's best band? Aren't there any other bands left?"
Oh boy Barry, your broke my heart with the van Halen reference. Grew up in California back in the heyday of these guys . Love the DLR version of the band . However I do agree with you profusely concerning Foo fighters ( can't stand them ) . Great video sir 👍
Shocked! Van Halen!?!?! Of all the craptastic bands to truly despise.....Van freakin' Halen!?!? I literally felt sad/angry/confused/ empty upon hearing that. I mean, King Edwards brilliant tone, riffs, solos alone, are worth the price of admission!
Nine out of ten are great choices. But gotta part company with you on The Associates. And even if you don't care for Billy MacKenzie's voice it is simply inaccurate to call it non-singing. It is technically superb.
The band members of Motley Crue didn’t even care much for music. They were all about the cocaine, booze, heroin, hookers and money. They even admitted it.
Many good calls with a few shockers. Pills and Thrills is a classic album though the Mondays probably had a limited shelf life. Party Fears 2 is one of the greatest songs of all time and Billy McKenzie a top drawer vocalist. His live rendition of Wild is the Wind on the BBC is stonkingly good.
In lieu of their contemporaries at the time circa 1983 such as Dokken Judas Priest Iron Maiden their level of musical abilities place them as mere posers. Mannequins have more talent
Foo Fighters can't be despised enough. As for the Eagles, their music before Hotel California was much better. They try so hard to rock out but it just doesn't work.
I'm with you 110%. I saw the FF in the summer. I left way before the end to get some curry sauce and chips and avoid the crush for the final train home. I only went as I was on the guest list for the support act Wet Leg, who despite me usually disliking indie pop I really enjoyed.
Yeah that’s an odd one. Definitely one of the best bands I’ve seen live and good albums too. He should listen to 5150 (the track and the album) if he hasn’t heard it.
I'm a big VH fan and I think some of his criticisms are warranted. VHI was a masterful album, VHII was good, after that each album had too much scattered filler until 1984. From Women and Children First to Diver Down you can tell they had the mindset "we can just do whatever we want and people will buy it."
I keep hearing that the first album is good but ever since I saw the video to “Jump” when I was a kid I have considered them as the height of naffness.
I used to like the eagles but started to hate them about how they screwed Don Felder, man I loved that bloke and he is a very good guitarist. Don Henley and Joe Walsh can kiss my derriere. Joe Walsh can't sing for shiz.
The Eagles - bang on. Made the mistake of paying a lot of money to see them a few years ago. Two and a half hours of them standing like statues trotting out one long drone. A proper snore fest. The most boring band in the world.
I've found myself disagreeing with a few of these picks but I wholeheartedly agree with Foo Fighters. They are so mediocre. I did enjoy their cover of Down in the park though.
Well, Mick Mars came up with some superb riffs, but other than that I hated them with a vengeance, mainly because of the crass lyrics and that they were, apart from Mars, genuinely terrible people.
The worst band I have ever heard are the Foo fighters, what a load of rubbish...just a load of mush. Probably one of the most over-rated bands in history
The reason I love this channel, All these different opinions floating on an ocean of the realization that music is subjective. So refreshing. I personally love a lot of what the Foo Fighters do: My hero and Everlong I think are superb but if you don't like them, that's fine too.
@@Geraldo-ro9rc Pardon? You don't like "The Big Lebowski"? How could you not? Anyway, "The Dude will abide.".....with or without you.....did you see what I did there?
there's exceptions. I got free recordings at music stores and swap meets, so I have records by bands I don't like including Kiss, Crue, KC and the Sunshine Band, Kool and the Gang.
Another wonderful video. I love how our host earns the right to comment through commitment to listening and re-listening. I loved Happy Mondays; and have indeed been drawn to listening to Pills n thrills. I was 15, when it was released and perhaps understood them as related to me and being my rebels. I actually don’t get the Foo Fighters? Again, marvellous conversation starting video. Many thanks
Entertaining video, some of your observations and comparisons are very funny. Bit confusing though when you are listing bands you hate, but several of them released one or more records that you really enjoyed.
If you were an American in the mid to late 70’s I think it would sway your view of The Eagles. That California desert vibe was so fu**ing cool and laid back and they encapsulated it perfectly!!
Yes, they did encapsulate the California desert vibe perfectly. As a teenager in the 70s, they were good for one listen but then I just moved on, so I am in agreement with our host here. Just couldn't connect with the Eagles, even though their songs are brilliant.
Definitely ok to say "you had to be there" with The Eagles. That "desert vibe" was real for a time (see 'America' w/ "Ventura Highway" and "Horse With No Name." The disproportionate sales volume versus the "contribution to music, as a whole" works against them, as does the notorious personalities of band members, most notably "Nikon Don" Henley. "Hotel California" is George Washington on the "Mount Rushmore of Most Overplayed Songs in Radio History."
The Who worked because Pete Townsend was very sensitive to the barrage coming from and Entwistle and Moon, and played accordingly. And also, the songwriting was superb, and superbly tailored to the band. ~ "Huge Ballsack of Musical Mediocracy” is so poetic, I wept. Now get off my lawn!
The Who worked also because they wrote intelligent lyrics that still resonate with people today. That can't be said about Van Halen - a band that wrote lyrics like "ice cream man"
@@grantross2609 Don't know bout peer pressure,it becomes a warehouse and the least you can do is end up storeing what you don't like.Dont Buy what you don't like.
Here are ten bands I hate : 10. Pearl Jam 9. King Diamond 8. Pulp 7. Muse 6. U2 5. Wasp 4. Guns N' Roses 3. the Flaming Lips 2. Mötley Crüe 1. Limp Bizkit
in my high school in Poland in 90's Limp Bizkit and Green Day were most hated band. People loved AC/DC, Motorhead, Metallica, Megadeth and Pearl Jam, Nirvana, Alice In Chains, Soundgarden and all that grunge rock.
Limp Bizkit were DESIGNED to be hated by the elitist crowd, that was their whole point. Even the name was designed to draw mockery. Personally I think they're loud stupid and obnoxious- and I kinda like it.
The Associates! No no no they are unique and inventive and Mckenzies voice its powerful moving and a the delivery can be as emotional as many a voice.Nothing quite like them in a good way.
Yes! I love them, I’m personally quite drawn to the drama and agony of his voice, I think he conveys a pretty unique mania and desperation. And musically as well, they touch on something immensely paranoid. Kitchen Person has to be one of the most intense and frightening songs I’ve ever heard.
I love the Associates and the Happy Mondays, but I understand your reasons for not liking them. Couldn't agree more about the Cranberries, though. Relatively new to this channel, but thoroughly enjoying catching up on your content. Rant on, sir!
Just subscribed because I just found your channel. We agree on much though your music/band knowledge is much deeper and broader than mine. Your descriptions both positive and negative have me alternately laughing myself ill and admiring your powers of description of good music. You have me listening to great and execrable music. I will tune in often and spread the word to music lovers.
Imagine Dragons, Creed, Disturbed, Metallica (yea I said it), Damn - there are way too many INCLUDING Foo Fighters, U2, Coldplay, Phish, 'maybe' Green Day,
Part Fears 2 is a masterpiece of the early 80s, it's the record I always look to as one of the last great individual uniques songs before the 80s gave us the first signs we were drifting into a corporate ice age and live aid confirmed it and now with this Taylor Swift, Sheeran and the like it feels like that compact perma-ice that even the reemergence of the sun into the musical hemisphere would have trouble melting. Mind you Party Fears 2 is that record you'd be careful not to play in the vicinity of most modern people because you just know it would get right under their skin but there remains a raw beauty to it that retains something mysterious that still seemed possible to a young man in 1982. And Martha Ladly on keyboards on Top of the Pops, what more can I say. Taylor Swift indeed!!
@@mcwulf25 That's one of the things I liked about it. It seemed deliberately designed to alienate mainstream listeners, perfectly combining a melodic pop sensibility with a punk ethos while confusing the hell out of everyone.
@@IamQuizPug One off pretentiousness, it couldn't last, the follow up Club Country was another classic but no 30 year career of tedium for the dullard masses, irritated by anything that deviates from expected vocal frequencies and rhythms. Beautiful!
@@matthewwoelfle5533I also like what Denis Leary said on a promo he did on MTV in the early 90s (which seem like an eternity ago), "I got three words for Don Henley, Joe F'n Walsh!"
Hah - the Eagles - indeed. They really, really lost me when, sometime in the 2000s, they signed an exclusive marketing deal with Walmart. The very ultimate in sell-out. Gag. You, me, and Jeffrey "The Dude" Lebowski happily hating on the Schmeagles.
"the reason the critics hate us and love Evis Costello is because they look like Elvis Costello!"DLR. in your case you'd give Costello a run for his money in the ugly department😅😂
O'Riordan's "yodeling schtick" always reiminded me of both Teena Marie and Alanis Morrisette. Both of them tended to add a little yelp at the end of most of their lyric phrases. Listen to "Hand In My Pocket" by Morrisette and you want to get her into throat surgery - the yelp is at the end of nearly every line in the chorus, every time.
I don't listen to any of these bands either. I can appreciate how good EVH was technically on guitar, but I dislike listening to their music. Like Motley Crue, it always felt, well, shallow and without a soul to me.
Matt belamy from muse sounds like mr burns, there's no difference whatsoever.. it's uncanny . He also takes a short breath between every vocal line. So he sounds like mr burns constantly catching his breath
It's all about opinions they say. I don't think it's necessarily negative to give honest opinions about the acts you don't love, if (as you do) you explain your reasons. I don't agree with all of your criticisms here, but because you explain them I understand them. And actually I feel the same way exactly, for exactly the same reasons, about some of them. Keep going mate, some lovely one-liners in there again 🙂
Really love to hear your opinions in these vids, Barry. You always manage to keep it sober when you describe your beefs with these bands which is how opinions should be omitted about music. Respect
The Associates were incredible! Billy was a one off who unfortunately took his own life. Very unkind critique I felt. In fact downright nasty and disrepectful.
Once I heard Gram Parsons, The Burritos etc I never had to listen to the Eagles again. Their two best songs for me are Bitter Creek and My Man (about Gram) and pretty much all Bernie both songs!
"Hysteria" is still miserable over cooked dirge, and the most disappointing follow up the great energetic pop metal of "High and Dry" and "Pyromania" albums. Too long, over produced, oddly joyless and weak limp material like "Dogs of war". Even though it was a massive album, it was the beginning of the end for the band that have limped along for the last 37 years but still make millions a year from touring the nostalgia market for superannuated late boomers and early Gen xers and their 20 to 30 yr old kids that get a free ticket to join their aging parents nostalgic whims.
Very harsh on the Associates. And when I criticise Pink Floyd or Metallica people like you throw your toys out of the pram. I always thought I was a music snob…
I agree Desperado was an excellent album, always gets overlooked. I love The Cranberries, and refuse to be swayed. I agree about Crue, Leppard, and Van Halen. Don't like my rock so well organized. Foo Fighters are over rated. I like to listen to Muse when I'm vacuuming the house. Great video as always.
Right off the bat my favourite band at 10 bemused me a bit, but as much as I hate to admit it I can see where you’re coming from. Even I’ve thought their last two albums have been pretty dire, but I’ll defend almost anything they’ve done before that point. Always respect the no bullshit approach.
Agree with 50%. Subjective distain is always thought provoking whilst wearing a Miles Davis t-shirt which represents middle-aged Blue Note obsessed pretentious hazy jazzy horn parping boredom that sails through the musical note air journey mixed with my load snoring....zzzzz
'self esteem' is a good song. 'smash' was a huge album 30 FREEKIN' YEARS AGO & really made a fukkton of money for epitaph & is prob a reason why bad religion is still a going concern. hearing 'come out and play' on the radio those 30 years ago was not the worst thing either.
my brother-in-law fixed an appliance at Billy MacKenzie's home near Dundee shortly before his untimely death..... he was severely depressed by all accounts..... a genuine one-off tho for sure !
Another great video, as a fellow disc 4 Dad, your observations align eerily consistently with my own; it is obvious you are a chap that knows his stuff and I thoroughly enjoy your presenting style and the eloquence of your descriptors.... However as capital a fellow as you are, I found myself reeling (saving private Ryan style) at your scathing condemnation of The Cranberries with particular reference to the nails on chalk board accusation around Delores voice!... Happily there is enough good stuff in the bank laid down by your back catalogue of excellent views and insights to get passed this otherwise uncomfortable blip... I haven't worked my way through all your work so forgive me if you have already commented about my favourite Marillion album Clutching at Straws... would love to hear your thoughts on that one... Personally I love the sentiments behind Fish's (apologies for any errant apostrophefying) Swan song with the band. Also have you ever covered Fish's solo career I'd love to hear that :) Thanks for all your work, genuinely enjoy your narration and impressive knowledge of your subject matter! Jim.
Agree wholeheartedly with Elton. Maybe his early 70s output was ok, but I can't even bring myself to give a listen to one of those albums. I'm so put off by his 80s pap , Sacrifice and Blue Eyes and dross of that ilk. Queen post 70s I pretty much dismiss too. I can't stand 'It's a kind of magic' and I do feel Freddie's vocals are overrated.
Wow, quite an eclectic mix, but then as I've said before, your wide and knowledgeable grasp of historical music has always impressed me. I on the other hand, have been moved through the years by musicians who at a particular moment, reflected my life, at a critical life change. Bullet points if you will. My lists therefore, will always be shorter, my range less broad. Nonetheless, the fathom of those moments are just as important and central to my life. Just thought I'd pop that in 😁☯️🌱
agree there is zero punk about the offspring, and later fired their drummer for not complying with government medicine. Flush twice And hold the handle down
Let me highly recommend the band Versailles and their song Philia...this song has both immensely complex melodies as well a a massive number or complex chord.... while not prog whichh you like people who love prog tend to also like this band.... they are Melodic Symphonic Power Metal. And the singer has wm amazing voice.... they are a Japanese Band whose costumes are inspired by French Rococo fashion.
The Offspring are still one of my favorite bands (I'm fully aware it's more kind of a guilty pleasure) and regardless of context, I wasn't expecting them to ever even be mentioned on your channel ;-) keep up the great work!
How old is Barry Robinson? I can’t quite work it out, sometimes it sounds as if he was already old enough to know what’s what in the early 70s during the growth of program rock, next he seems to be talking about still being at school at the start of the 80s; bit of an enigma, really!
Oh my God. 💯 on The Cranberries. I really did enjoy the first album. Especially at the time it came out. It was quite refreshing when compared to everything else at the time. But by the second album I was done. That constant shrieking on Zombie had me ready to blow my brains out. And for some reason every cover band on the planet has that song in their repertoire. A sure fire way to get me to leave the joint. 😂
Agree, I thought Linger was good. In fact I heard it the other day and I enjoyed it, but Zombie always irritated me. But apparently we are not appreciating the ancient Celtic tradition in her vocals.
Hey, would you have a list of bands you revered at first but then got tired of (but maybe still revere)? Husker Du comes to mind. I still think they're genius as individuals and as a group, but I just have to admit I couldn't sustain my enthusiasm.
Lol!! On one of my list on this channel, I asked if I could put down the Eagles 10 times and someone questioned my taste in music. But here it is. Number one! In the immortal words of the man in the bathrobe, "I hate the f****ng Eagles, man!"
Agree with some, disagree with some. As it should be.
Same here. I've been a big fan of Van Halen and Def Leppard for 40 years.
I agree with just about all of those, especially Van Halen and Def Leppard
pour some sugar on me makes me wish i was def
@@kaned3570It is hilariously awful though. "Do you take sugar? ONE LUMP OR TWO?!!" How Joe Eliot sings that with a straight face is quite remarkable
@@kaned3570 Deaf Leppard
The you tube adds are out of control lately. Anyone else notice an uptick in frequency?
Yes absolutely ridiculous
The companies represented in these ads can be sure that I'll never buy any of their stuff
@peter-yy5qy I'm getting 4 to 6 adds on videos that are only 3 minutes long for goodness sakes ..not all but a lot
Yes, this little video alone had 4 ads 👹
I use the Brave browser & never see an ad !
As Half Man Half Biscuit sang:
"Oh help me Mrs Medlicott, i don't know what to do...
I've only got three bullets, and there's four of Mötley Crüe!"
Spare Mick Mars ! 🤣
@@DissTopia-o7p that would be the one I would spare too
This channel needs to feature 'Dikie Davis eyes'...
or as they also sang: ' I've only got 6 months to live but at least I'm not in JOURNEY!'
You can always rely on HMHB for accurate and amusing pop culture references..
We all hear things differently. A wise man once said "One man's Meatloaf is another man's Poison."
😂
Speaking of meatloaf, never understood why people like him so much
@@sanityclause-r8z Or one man's fish is another man's poisson. Agree, think Meatloaf overrated.
That's a good one
@@verginithe I liked him for his effort level. He worked so hard to put on a show. When I pay 80 bucks for a ticket I expect you to leave it all on the stage, and he did.
I couldn't agree more about Foo Fighters. Best Of You might actually be the worst song I've ever heard.
And I've heard Coldplay.
Poo Fighters
@@jonbonzo9199 I really don't get the adulation that some people have for them. They have a couple of standout tracks but their output is so bland and homogenised I struggle to tell most of them apart.
Meat and potatoes rock band
A few decades ago, I saw a TV ad (I was in Australia at the time) for a Foo Fighters tour.
The ad says they are the best band in the world.
I was in a state of shock. I said: "The Foo Fighters are the world's best band? Aren't there any other bands left?"
Rock music for people who don't like rock music
My top ten worst bands 1 U2, 2 U2, 3 U2, 4 U2, 5 U2, 6 U2, 7, U2, 8, U2, 9, U2, 10, U2.
It’s Bono,he F ed it up,Jesus what a Tool..
They're just below Kiss for my worst bands!
And Kiss 😂
I’m the exact opposite.
I’m curious who do you have at number 11?
Me too
Oh boy Barry, your broke my heart with the van Halen reference. Grew up in California back in the heyday of these guys . Love the DLR version of the band . However I do agree with you profusely concerning Foo fighters ( can't stand them ) . Great video sir 👍
Shocked! Van Halen!?!?! Of all the craptastic bands to truly despise.....Van freakin' Halen!?!? I literally felt sad/angry/confused/ empty upon hearing that. I mean, King Edwards brilliant tone, riffs, solos alone, are worth the price of admission!
Agree with all except the Associates, who were an exceptional, original post punk band
Shame we lost both of them so early great band.
Nine out of ten are great choices. But gotta part company with you on The Associates. And even if you don't care for Billy MacKenzie's voice it is simply inaccurate to call it non-singing. It is technically superb.
Totally agree. Wasn’t even criticism- it was downright insulting
@@heff1964 Very unkind comments and totally unnecessary, Billy was awesome.. RIP
This channel is very conservative in taste though.
The band members of Motley Crue didn’t even care much for music. They were all about the cocaine, booze, heroin, hookers and money. They even admitted it.
Those 90s American 'skateboard' bands have singers that sound like they have a really bad cold...
Self Esteem by Offspring is a great tune. Other than that, well.....I listen to their entire albums when I'm working the leaf blower in the yard.
That’s a genre that Weird Al Yankovic’d itself
NOFX started that trend by my recollection
If I die before I wake...
awful, whoever that was.
Skate punk
Many good calls with a few shockers. Pills and Thrills is a classic album though the Mondays probably had a limited shelf life. Party Fears 2 is one of the greatest songs of all time and Billy McKenzie a top drawer vocalist. His live rendition of Wild is the Wind on the BBC is stonkingly good.
Apollo 440's "Pain in any language", his last recording, is truly mesmerising
I have to agree with you; Party Fears Two is a brilliantly insane slice of pop perfection. Forty years on I've still heard nothing like it.
Pseuds corner
Country club by the associates is another good one and Billy mckenzie is a brilliant singer.
Motley Clue is garbage.
They’re mostly attitude and very little talent, in my opinion
first two albums were good , after that they just became glam pop garbage
Tommy Lee - high on exposure- low on talent
In lieu of their contemporaries at the time circa 1983 such as Dokken Judas Priest Iron Maiden their level of musical abilities place them as mere posers. Mannequins have more talent
@@francovani393 Exactly!
Oasis is the worst band in the history of rock.
eh?
I agree
@@Brian_Boru to say Oasis are a rock band is an insult to real rock bands like The Who
No no no. I’m sure there’s another band er….westlife?
Oh yeah 666% correct ❤
The Associates were perhaps an acquired taste but undeserving of being 'hated' - that's a shocker!
Bit too close to Avant Garde for more Conservative tastes.
I love the Associates
Tragic what happened to Billy McKenzie!
Oh I dunno. Here in Scotland it's a band I was "supposed to like". But I simply can't stand his voice. Like a poor karaoke Freddie Mercury.
@@Titus9508 Sorry, I though you meant literal avant garde, not a band.
Foo Fighters can't be despised enough. As for the Eagles, their music before Hotel California was much better. They try so hard to rock out but it just doesn't work.
I'm with you 110%. I saw the FF in the summer. I left way before the end to get some curry sauce and chips and avoid the crush for the final train home. I only went as I was on the guest list for the support act Wet Leg, who despite me usually disliking indie pop I really enjoyed.
@@Walesktf .. Love Wet Leg
@@bizzjoe But do you love their name?
@@RAFchurchlawford4469 .. A good a name as any.
Victim of Love is their best had rock song and they did it very well
The opinion of VH reveals that the host deserves pity for having some seriously defective sensory equipment.
Yeah that’s an odd one. Definitely one of the best bands I’ve seen live and good albums too. He should listen to 5150 (the track and the album) if he hasn’t heard it.
I'm a big VH fan and I think some of his criticisms are warranted. VHI was a masterful album, VHII was good, after that each album had too much scattered filler until 1984. From Women and Children First to Diver Down you can tell they had the mindset "we can just do whatever we want and people will buy it."
if he had good sensory equipment, it would soon be ruined by listening to Van Halen.
...maybe that's what happened!
I keep hearing that the first album is good but ever since I saw the video to “Jump” when I was a kid I have considered them as the height of naffness.
Agree about all of them. Especially the Eagles. I've never understood the obsession over the Eagles.
Used to like the Eagles. Now, other than a few Glenn (RIP) Frey songs, no more
they were basically the maroon 5 of the 70s , played on the radio constantly being a very uninteresting band , plus Henley sucks
I used to like the eagles but started to hate them about how they screwed Don Felder, man I loved that bloke and he is a very good guitarist. Don Henley and Joe Walsh can kiss my derriere. Joe Walsh can't sing for shiz.
I can’t figure any attraction to the Grateful Dead but someone does and that’s okay
@@giancarloabrahams Joe Walsh was fine solo and in James gang but probably should’ve stayed out of the eagles
The Eagles - bang on. Made the mistake of paying a lot of money to see them a few years ago. Two and a half hours of them standing like statues trotting out one long drone. A proper snore fest. The most boring band in the world.
Just imagine their tribute band Talon!
So, the lip syncing wasn’t also good then?
I've found myself disagreeing with a few of these picks but I wholeheartedly agree with Foo Fighters. They are so mediocre. I did enjoy their cover of Down in the park though.
yep a few days ago they were on a rerun sat.night live put on mute good guys and all but never liked the music
I never understood why Motley Crue was so popular. That goes for much of hair metal.
They glorified stupidity and showed disdain for their fans. I think that's why.
Well, Mick Mars came up with some superb riffs, but other than that I hated them with a vengeance, mainly because of the crass lyrics and that they were, apart from Mars, genuinely terrible people.
Vince Neil sounds like a cat being slowly disemboweled.
@@Darrylizer1never used to
@@user-qc7be1gs7j They never showed disdain for fans! They have always been super grateful.
The Eagles! YES! YES! YES! Finally someone agrees with how I have always felt about this band. Thank you.
Most Brits I know do not like the Eagles.
Used to like them. Now, other than a few of Glenn(RIP)Frey's songs, no more
No band can bore me more than the Eagles....ho hum.
I from California and I find this band to be just awful. There are more of us here, we just have to deal with snotty Eagle fans.
i like life in the fast lane, i never ever ever want to hear hotel california again
The worst band I have ever heard are the Foo fighters, what a load of rubbish...just a load of mush. Probably one of the most over-rated bands in history
Dave Grohl sings like an angry young mother raging at her children …
I hate them mostly because they insist their fans must prove they have had the vax upon presenting their ticket.
The reason I love this channel, All these different opinions floating on an ocean of the realization that music is subjective. So refreshing. I personally love a lot of what the Foo Fighters do: My hero and Everlong I think are superb but if you don't like them, that's fine too.
The Dude, "I had a rough night and I hate the f--in' Eagles, man!"
I dont like that movie but CCR is definitely better.
@@Geraldo-ro9rc
Pardon? You don't like "The Big Lebowski"? How could you not?
Anyway, "The Dude will abide.".....with or without you.....did you see what I did there?
@@noelmurray1 _That's just like, your opinion Man!_
you don't like the eagles? get outta my cab!!!!
@@noelmurray1 I just find the movie to be too silly. Theres plenty of other cohen bros movies that should be cult films like Lebowski but arent.
Great video, we love your remarks which leave us in stitches. Thanks for the videos, I'm happy to subscribe
Not really bands you hate if you have their albums 🙄
We music junkies sometimes can’t help ourselves…
oh yeah of course, that's logic for you.... narrow minded nonsense.
there's exceptions. I got free recordings at music stores and swap meets, so I have records by bands I don't like including Kiss, Crue, KC and the Sunshine Band, Kool and the Gang.
The Associates were ace, behave yerself.
Offspring look like guys that grew up saying ‘neat’
Another wonderful video.
I love how our host earns the right to comment through commitment to listening and re-listening.
I loved Happy Mondays; and have indeed been drawn to listening to Pills n thrills. I was 15, when it was released and perhaps understood them as related to me and being my rebels.
I actually don’t get the Foo Fighters?
Again, marvellous conversation starting video.
Many thanks
The first and second albums by Def Leppard are great because they are much more in line with the NWOBHM than glam/pop.
There is a hell of a lot of great music across all of their albums, certainly a lot more than many of their contemporaries.
What is NWOBHM ?
@@DissTopia-o7p ‘The New Wave of British Heavy Metal’.
They changed their sound to appeal to US radio. Their contemporaries, Iron Maiden, concentrated on quality.
Retro active was a darker amazing album from them that didn’t get enough love compared to hysteria or adrenalize IMO
Entertaining video, some of your observations and comparisons are very funny. Bit confusing though when you are listing bands you hate, but several of them released one or more records that you really enjoyed.
A blind squirrel finds an acorn once in a while.
A broken clock is correct twice a day.
etc......
Associates make the Smiths look like King crimson. Does this make sense? No. Oh well.
It makes sense to me. 💪🏼
Cranberries....Associates....Def Leppard...on THIS list....unbelievable...Mr Classic Review i will still subscribe but had to register my incredulity❤
Love the entire Cranberries discography, but to be fair, Def Leppard has some truly CRAPPY albums post-Hysteria!
Agree
If you were an American in the mid to late 70’s I think it would sway your view of The Eagles. That California desert vibe was so fu**ing cool and laid back and they encapsulated it perfectly!!
Yes, they did encapsulate the California desert vibe perfectly. As a teenager in the 70s, they were good for one listen but then I just moved on, so I am in agreement with our host here. Just couldn't connect with the Eagles, even though their songs are brilliant.
No,
Used to like them. Other than a few Glenn(RIP)Frey songs, no more
I survived the 70's Desert Vibe Massacre. 🤪
Definitely ok to say "you had to be there" with The Eagles. That "desert vibe" was real for a time (see 'America' w/ "Ventura Highway" and "Horse With No Name."
The disproportionate sales volume versus the "contribution to music, as a whole" works against them, as does the notorious personalities of band members, most notably "Nikon Don" Henley.
"Hotel California" is George Washington on the "Mount Rushmore of Most Overplayed Songs in Radio History."
The Who worked because Pete Townsend was very sensitive to the barrage coming from and Entwistle and Moon, and played accordingly. And also, the songwriting was superb, and superbly tailored to the band. ~ "Huge Ballsack of Musical Mediocracy” is so poetic, I wept. Now get off my lawn!
I’m just one minute in, and IF he says that he doesn’t like The Who, then I’m unsubscribed and out.
@@shizuokaBLUES He isn't mad!!
The Who worked also because they wrote intelligent lyrics that still resonate with people today. That can't be said about Van Halen - a band that wrote lyrics like "ice cream man"
Getting In Tune is my all time fav Who song that never gets talked about enough. Pete's magnum opus if you will.
@@Neodude991 Moonie goes nuts at the end of that one
I certainly wouldn’t own cds of those I don’t really care for.
Yeah, me too, but if you want to be a credible critic, then you have to put up the money.
.......peer pressure usually means you DO end up with music you could do without tho !
@@grantross2609 Don't know bout peer pressure,it becomes a warehouse and the least you can do is end up storeing what you don't like.Dont Buy what you don't like.
I was not expecting The Offspring to make an appearance. I mean, goes without saying.
Offspring are awful
Here are ten bands I hate :
10. Pearl Jam
9. King Diamond
8. Pulp
7. Muse
6. U2
5. Wasp
4. Guns N' Roses
3. the Flaming Lips
2. Mötley Crüe
1. Limp Bizkit
I agree with eight of those. I have a little time for Motley Crue and Pulp had a certain charm.
W.A.S.P. and King Diamond don't belong on that list, but I'm with you on the others.
in my high school in Poland in 90's Limp Bizkit and Green Day were most hated band. People loved AC/DC, Motorhead, Metallica, Megadeth and Pearl Jam, Nirvana, Alice In Chains, Soundgarden and all that grunge rock.
Limp Bizkit were DESIGNED to be hated by the elitist crowd, that was their whole point. Even the name was designed to draw mockery. Personally I think they're loud stupid and obnoxious- and I kinda like it.
Flaming lips are a good band the rest are poor.
The Associates! No no no they are unique and inventive and Mckenzies voice its powerful moving and a the delivery can be as emotional as many a voice.Nothing quite like them in a good way.
also, on a more shallow note, it was impossible not to crush on Martha Ladly 😍
@@donello430 I didn't think I would be the only one.
Yes! I love them, I’m personally quite drawn to the drama and agony of his voice, I think he conveys a pretty unique mania and desperation. And musically as well, they touch on something immensely paranoid. Kitchen Person has to be one of the most intense and frightening songs I’ve ever heard.
I love the Associates and the Happy Mondays, but I understand your reasons for not liking them. Couldn't agree more about the Cranberries, though. Relatively new to this channel, but thoroughly enjoying catching up on your content. Rant on, sir!
Just subscribed because I just found your channel. We agree on much though your music/band knowledge is much deeper and broader than mine. Your descriptions both positive and negative have me alternately laughing myself ill and admiring your powers of description of good music. You have me listening to great and execrable music. I will tune in often and spread the word to music lovers.
Imagine Dragons, Creed, Disturbed, Metallica (yea I said it), Damn - there are way too many INCLUDING Foo Fighters, U2, Coldplay, Phish, 'maybe' Green Day,
Nothing wrong with hating Metallica but their 1st 4 albums were world changing, after that, meh.
Cosidering later output of Metallica I can't blame anyone xD
I hate Green Day.
@@stephanieschwartz5214 They became just another 'Radio Rock' band, like the Foo Fighters.
@@stephanieschwartz5214They hate you too
Thanks for adding "knotty turd "to my armoury.
AKA a windjammer.😁
@@SheilaThompson-od5tr Glug!.
Thanks for writing this.
I heard "naughty turd" and thought "Well there's a new Britishism."😂
Part Fears 2 is a masterpiece of the early 80s, it's the record I always look to as one of the last great individual uniques songs before the 80s gave us the first signs we were drifting into a corporate ice age and live aid confirmed it and now with this Taylor Swift, Sheeran and the like it feels like that compact perma-ice that even the reemergence of the sun into the musical hemisphere would have trouble melting. Mind you Party Fears 2 is that record you'd be careful not to play in the vicinity of most modern people because you just know it would get right under their skin but there remains a raw beauty to it that retains something mysterious that still seemed possible to a young man in 1982. And Martha Ladly on keyboards on Top of the Pops, what more can I say. Taylor Swift indeed!!
I used to put in on the jukebox at my local - everyone hated it! Philistines
Clearly this song divides opinion. I hated it but most people I know liked it.
@@mcwulf25 That's one of the things I liked about it. It seemed deliberately designed to alienate mainstream listeners, perfectly combining a melodic pop sensibility with a punk ethos while confusing the hell out of everyone.
@@IamQuizPug One off pretentiousness, it couldn't last, the follow up Club Country was another classic but no 30 year career of tedium for the dullard masses, irritated by anything that deviates from expected vocal frequencies and rhythms. Beautiful!
Apologies if you've already answered this as I'm quite new to your channel but what do you think of Opeth? Or Porcupine Tree?
Mojo Nixon summed up the Eagles perfectly for me in his song "Don Henley must die" . I cannot stand them.
The late, great Mojo Nixon!
@@chuckm4540 Elvis is Everywhere! 😃
I think Jeff Lebowski had the best take on The Eagles.
@@matthewwoelfle5533I also like what Denis Leary said on a promo he did on MTV in the early 90s (which seem like an eternity ago), "I got three words for Don Henley, Joe F'n Walsh!"
There's a legend (donno if it's true) that Mojo and Don once shared a stage later in Mojo's life. And that they had a grand old time.
Tex Nugent, Styx, REO Speedwagon, molly hatchet, 38 special, to be continued
Oh man, your list could be mine. I had a room mate that played Pink Floyd's - The Wall 24/7. That was rough.
The Happy Mondays are wonderful!!!
Hah - the Eagles - indeed. They really, really lost me when, sometime in the 2000s, they signed an exclusive marketing deal with Walmart. The very ultimate in sell-out. Gag.
You, me, and Jeffrey "The Dude" Lebowski happily hating on the Schmeagles.
My brother-in-law called them The Smeagols!
@@barbarakirk3064 hahahah - yeah!
Ironic because The Big Lebowski is hugely overrated.
@@AffectedAreadefinitely agree
I do agree with all your choices with the exception of The Associates. However I do understand your aversion to Billy's voice.
Do you have something against jewel cases?
"the reason the critics hate us and love Evis Costello is because they look like Elvis Costello!"DLR. in your case you'd give Costello a run for his money in the ugly department😅😂
O'Riordan's "yodeling schtick" always reiminded me of both Teena Marie and Alanis Morrisette. Both of them tended to add a little yelp at the end of most of their lyric phrases. Listen to "Hand In My Pocket" by Morrisette and you want to get her into throat surgery - the yelp is at the end of nearly every line in the chorus, every time.
I don't listen to any of these bands either. I can appreciate how good EVH was technically on guitar, but I dislike listening to their music. Like Motley Crue, it always felt, well, shallow and without a soul to me.
I love Billy Mackenzie's voice but as ever, even when I disagree with you I'm still entertained by your takes. Keep up the good work 👍
Matt belamy from muse sounds like mr burns, there's no difference whatsoever.. it's uncanny . He also takes a short breath between every vocal line.
So he sounds like mr burns constantly catching his breath
'Excellent!'
It's all about opinions they say. I don't think it's necessarily negative to give honest opinions about the acts you don't love, if (as you do) you explain your reasons. I don't agree with all of your criticisms here, but because you explain them I understand them. And actually I feel the same way exactly, for exactly the same reasons, about some of them. Keep going mate, some lovely one-liners in there again 🙂
Mid 80s had Dio, Sabbath, Dokken, Ratt. They were all great.
Don’t forget Judias priest and queensryche. 2 amazing live bands.
First two albums by The Cranberries are both 5 stars. RIP Delores.
"Number ten is Muse." I stood to applaud. That is a fantastic start.
Really love to hear your opinions in these vids, Barry. You always manage to keep it sober when you describe your beefs with these bands which is how opinions should be omitted about music. Respect
The Associates were incredible! Billy was a one off who unfortunately took his own life. Very unkind critique I felt. In fact downright nasty and disrepectful.
Surely the fact this band is unique and not for everyone is what makes them special.
Your daddy ?
Jim Kerr said Billy was a tough guy who would punch you if you weren’t careful.
@@alexbowman7582 he was a Dundonian lol
Totally agree Lorraine...billy was unique....he was a gift to all of us...
Once I heard Gram Parsons, The Burritos etc I never had to listen to the Eagles again. Their two best songs for me are Bitter Creek and My Man (about Gram) and pretty much all Bernie both songs!
Difficult one Muse, they were certainly a breath of fresh air when they started and are bloody good live.
MADNESS!
❤❤
I disagree with Van Halen and Motley Crue. I saw VH with DLR and SH and they were awesome live. Hysteria from Def Lepard is a great album.
"Hysteria" is still miserable over cooked dirge, and the most disappointing follow up the great energetic pop metal of "High and Dry" and "Pyromania" albums. Too long, over produced, oddly joyless and weak limp material like "Dogs of war". Even though it was a massive album, it was the beginning of the end for the band that have limped along for the last 37 years but still make millions a year from touring the nostalgia market for superannuated late boomers and early Gen xers and their 20 to 30 yr old kids that get a free ticket to join their aging parents nostalgic whims.
Saw them back in the day , they were really good. Worked a Van Hager show in the 80s , then Diamond Dave came through. He was pretty good too.
Very harsh on the Associates. And when I criticise Pink Floyd or Metallica people like you throw your toys out of the pram. I always thought I was a music snob…
Just bad taste 😂just a joke mate.
I agree Desperado was an excellent album, always gets overlooked. I love The Cranberries, and refuse to be swayed. I agree about Crue, Leppard, and Van Halen. Don't like my rock so well organized. Foo Fighters are over rated. I like to listen to Muse when I'm vacuuming the house. Great video as always.
I can't agree with you on the Cranberries but no disagreement on any of the others.
Great band. All the '90s albums are good, not just the first one. She was one of the best and most original singer -songwriter ever.
Same here.
“Dreams” is a really beautiful song. One of the best of the 90’s imo.
Right off the bat my favourite band at 10 bemused me a bit, but as much as I hate to admit it I can see where you’re coming from.
Even I’ve thought their last two albums have been pretty dire, but I’ll defend almost anything they’ve done before that point.
Always respect the no bullshit approach.
You should do a Ten Songs You Like from bands you hate…
Isn't that statement an Oxymoron?
@@spiritualarchitect4276 No. He specifically listed lots of stuff from these bands he "hates" but actually likes.
@@spiritualarchitect4276 I know plenty of tunes I like from bands I’m not fond of.
@@spiritualarchitect4276 not much of a fan of the rolling stones, but painted black is one of my favourite songs of all-time
yeah, that's a good idea
Agree with 50%. Subjective distain is always thought provoking whilst wearing a Miles Davis t-shirt which represents middle-aged Blue Note obsessed pretentious hazy jazzy horn parping boredom that sails through the musical note air journey mixed with my load snoring....zzzzz
10/10 for me there, Barry. But why hold on to those crap cd’s from bands who don’t grab you any more: the charity shop bin awaits your visit.
I don't agree on your views on the Associates but I do watch a lot of your videos and will continue to do so. That's life, tastes varies.
Eagles “Betrayal of the 60s ethos “ - as in “Deadhead sticker on a Cadillac “
The 60’s ethos were invented by a government office. Read “weird scenes in the canyon” and it will all make sense
I get the impression the word hate is pure clickbait! If you really hate them you certainly don't get their albums!!
'self esteem' is a good song.
'smash' was a huge album 30 FREEKIN' YEARS AGO & really made a fukkton of money for epitaph & is prob a reason why bad religion is still a going concern.
hearing 'come out and play' on the radio those 30 years ago was not the worst thing either.
my brother-in-law fixed an appliance at Billy MacKenzie's home near Dundee shortly before his untimely death.....
he was severely depressed by all accounts.....
a genuine one-off tho for sure !
Absolutely agree with everything you said about the Eagles - my exact opinion.
Another great video, as a fellow disc 4 Dad, your observations align eerily consistently with my own; it is obvious you are a chap that knows his stuff and I thoroughly enjoy your presenting style and the eloquence of your descriptors.... However as capital a fellow as you are, I found myself reeling (saving private Ryan style) at your scathing condemnation of The Cranberries with particular reference to the nails on chalk board accusation around Delores voice!... Happily there is enough good stuff in the bank laid down by your back catalogue of excellent views and insights to get passed this otherwise uncomfortable blip... I haven't worked my way through all your work so forgive me if you have already commented about my favourite Marillion album Clutching at Straws... would love to hear your thoughts on that one... Personally I love the sentiments behind Fish's (apologies for any errant apostrophefying) Swan song with the band. Also have you ever covered Fish's solo career I'd love to hear that :) Thanks for all your work, genuinely enjoy your narration and impressive knowledge of your subject matter! Jim.
No1 Police, No2 Police No3 Police...............ad nauseum
Off-topic a bit (since I adore them), but any interest in covering Portishead or Beth Gibbins solo? Just a thought. Thank you
These lists are always fun. The three I cannot stand are Queen, Bowie and Elton John. Millions of people love them though. Funny old world.
Agree, Queen were a camp pantomime version of led zeppelin
@@stevem6963A camp pantomime Led Zeppelin sounds like fun though??
Ha! Queen makes my top 10. All ten slots actually!
@@StuartBenson-ih3dn Queen > Led Zeppelin. Yes, they were a fun band!
Agree wholeheartedly with Elton. Maybe his early 70s output was ok, but I can't even bring myself to give a listen to one of those albums. I'm so put off by his 80s pap , Sacrifice and Blue Eyes and dross of that ilk. Queen post 70s I pretty much dismiss too. I can't stand 'It's a kind of magic' and I do feel Freddie's vocals are overrated.
I really like what you do man. You know your stuff that's for sure. RESPECT!
I appreciate that!
The late great Mojo Nixon summed up the Eagles best with his song "Don Henley Must Die".
thanks for turning me on to the Jerry Lee Lewis live album from 1964. I never would have discovered it if it wasn't for you.
Agree with all but The Associates and Happy Mondays. Each to their own, eh?
Pretty much. If everyone was down with the same sound it would be as boring as hell by now
Wow, quite an eclectic mix, but then as I've said before, your wide and knowledgeable grasp of historical music has always impressed me.
I on the other hand, have been moved through the years by musicians who at a particular moment, reflected my life, at a critical life change.
Bullet points if you will.
My lists therefore, will always be shorter, my range less broad. Nonetheless, the fathom of those moments are just as important and central to my life.
Just thought I'd pop that in 😁☯️🌱
100% agree that Offspring were and are horrible fake punk rock. They made a bunch of money off the backs of the OG SoCal punk bands.
agree there is zero punk about the offspring, and later fired their drummer for not complying with government medicine. Flush twice And hold the handle down
@@michaelwills1926 Offspring suck!
They came from that same scene in the early 80s. Listen to the first album especially.
Let me highly recommend the band Versailles and their song Philia...this song has both immensely complex melodies as well a a massive number or complex chord.... while not prog whichh you like people who love prog tend to also like this band.... they are Melodic Symphonic Power Metal. And the singer has wm amazing voice.... they are a Japanese Band whose costumes are inspired by French Rococo fashion.
Alex Van Halen scares me. He reminds me of Ronnie Kray!
😂😂😂 ...I 'll never look at Alex the same way, again..ha,ha!
I love your list videos. I always try to find disagreement with them, but I haven't yet!
I with ' The Dude' in the Big Lebowski, who gets kicked out of a taxi for saying he hates The Eagles. Awful, awful band.
And he was thrown out by ... a black guy. Good one.
The Offspring are still one of my favorite bands (I'm fully aware it's more kind of a guilty pleasure) and regardless of context, I wasn't expecting them to ever even be mentioned on your channel ;-) keep up the great work!
Foo Fighters. Talking about overrated.
How old is Barry Robinson? I can’t quite work it out, sometimes it sounds as if he was already old enough to know what’s what in the early 70s during the growth of program rock, next he seems to be talking about still being at school at the start of the 80s; bit of an enigma, really!
Aaaargh! Prog rock, not program rock, curse you, autocorrect!
Oh my God. 💯 on The Cranberries. I really did enjoy the first album. Especially at the time it came out. It was quite refreshing when compared to everything else at the time. But by the second album I was done. That constant shrieking on Zombie had me ready to blow my brains out. And for some reason every cover band on the planet has that song in their repertoire. A sure fire way to get me to leave the joint. 😂
Agree, I thought Linger was good. In fact I heard it the other day and I enjoyed it, but Zombie always irritated me. But apparently we are not appreciating the ancient Celtic tradition in her vocals.
Dolores was half Canadian goose
Hey, would you have a list of bands you revered at first but then got tired of (but maybe still revere)? Husker Du comes to mind. I still think they're genius as individuals and as a group, but I just have to admit I couldn't sustain my enthusiasm.
Lol!! On one of my list on this channel, I asked if I could put down the Eagles 10 times and someone questioned my taste in music. But here it is. Number one! In the immortal words of the man in the bathrobe, "I hate the f****ng Eagles, man!"
1 on this list... 3rd list?
@FuturePast2019 On the first video of "Bands I Bleeping Hate."
At least VH had a lead guitarist unlike the Who !