Unraveling the Complex History of Hamas

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 кві 2024
  • Dr. Jonathan Schanzer is a terrorism finance expert, a Senior Vice President for Research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) and serves on the FDD's Center on Economic and Financial Power leadership team. Along with hundreds of articles on terrorism and the Middle East, he is the author of Gaza Conflict 2021: Hamas. Israel and Eleven Days of War, State of Failure: Yasser Arafat, Mahmoud Abbas, and the Unmaking of the Palestinian State, Hamas vs. Fatah: The Struggle for Palestine, and Al-Qaeda's Armies: Middle East Affiliate Groups & the Next Generation of Terror. Previously, Dr. Schanzer was a terrorism finance analyst in the U.S. Department of the Treasury. He also held think tank research positions at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy and the Middle East Forum.
    You can follow him on X @JSchanzer and on Instagram@jonathan.schanzer
    NOTE: This segment has been extracted from the full-length episode, which originally aired on November 10, 2023.
    SPONSORS:
    Red Sky Mourning - The 7th novel in the James Reece Terminal List series. Pre-order today! jackcarr.co/rsm
    Bravo Company Manufacturing: Visit us on the web at jackcarr.co/bcm and on Instagram @BravoCompanyUSA.com
    SIG: Celebrating the 40th Anniversary of the legendary SIG SAUER P226. Learn more here - https:/jackcarr.co/SIG40thP226
    Jack Carr Gear: Explore the gear here - jackcarr.co/gear
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 73

  • @sar4x474
    @sar4x474 2 місяці тому +10

    Thank Mr. Carr. Your interview provided a quick glimpse into the intricacies of this ongoing issue.

  • @luisacleaves9592
    @luisacleaves9592 2 місяці тому +20

    Hsmas-Palestinians did all mayhem by themselves; they have chosen one bad ‘leader’ after another. Arafat was a scoundrel and criminal

    • @channeldos
      @channeldos Місяць тому

      ^^ This is what dumb people sound like

  • @sharonconstan8234
    @sharonconstan8234 2 місяці тому +4

    Appreciate this channel. ❤

  • @geozeckful
    @geozeckful 2 місяці тому +1

    Great interview, great video, thanks.

  • @C.E.Thomas1952
    @C.E.Thomas1952 2 місяці тому +1

    A very good summary indeed. Thank you.

  • @JMADNICK
    @JMADNICK 2 місяці тому +6

    Actually it is more complex. America had an arms embargo in 1948 not selling weapons to Israel. The Hagana and then IDF bought weapons from communist Czechoslovakia for 48. I have read that first offensive arms sales by US to Israel was late July 1965, when the United States sold 210 M-48 Patton tanks to Israel. And of course, the Arab states, and Iran, had and have their allies too.

    • @ilana
      @ilana 2 місяці тому +7

      Israel is forever grateful to Czechia. Often cited as the greatest ally that paved the road for Israeli weapons independence later on. Israel gifted Czechia a Merkava tank as a gift for their trouble years later.
      When Isrsel fought Syria, Syrians were armed with soviet T tanks. You can find leftovers of those tanks in the Golan Heights to this day. Katyushas has been flying from Lebanon towards Israel on numerous occasions. A few months back, Syria threw a monster mossile s-200 at Israel for the lolz (the assumption is that it was a. A mild payback b. They wanted to dispose of it).

  • @channeldos
    @channeldos Місяць тому

    I doubt jack will see this but I hope you find better sources to talk about this issue.

  • @ikesteroma
    @ikesteroma 2 місяці тому +8

    I have noticed that when people rail against Israel, they almost never have a very good grasp of the history of this region of this part of the world. They routinely miss the forest because of all the trees in the way.

    • @marge3157
      @marge3157 Місяць тому +1

      That would be Krystal Ball on Breaking Points.

    • @trogdor8942
      @trogdor8942 Місяць тому

      ​@@marge3157stopped watching because of her obvious bias

    • @channeldos
      @channeldos Місяць тому

      Could say that about the other side as well. Hamas only exists because Mossad wanted it to but that fact is overlooked all the time.

    • @trogdor8942
      @trogdor8942 Місяць тому

      @@channeldos when Hamas was founded it was a religious charity organization that the Israeli authority in Gaza thought was doing good things. People didn't understand the dangers of Muslim Brotherhood organizations in the 70s, but now they do.

  • @HIAMHIGH
    @HIAMHIGH Місяць тому +1

    it’s crazy they had this history and still decided to fund hamas

  • @mariem6735
    @mariem6735 Місяць тому

    The complexity of it all roots in luminous simplicy.
    When they say there is no freedom, that all is God´s Will, that everyone has to Submit, Muslim means Submited,
    They chose the Fate, the Doom but eternally enraged to see others daring to feel happiness, daring to love their children more than their political agenda with God Hijacked to serve a a few cruel Mullahs, or Sheiks.
    If all is Allah´s Will, why do complain all the time but still depending on Israel medical system when it suits them.
    Problem is that God had enough to see the West appease what will never be appeased. The complexity of their Envy is also very simple. Hate pairs with Envy. That simple. I will listen to the video later to be honest. Just very very concerned. The War is now international. UK, France, US Navy.
    Also I wrote from the clairvoyants point of view. Convinced that Ukraine war was deliberate to allow Ukraine get weapons, ammunition, planes. And then October 7 came. The Timing is perfect. The West was beautifully played. Now depleted.

  • @scothighlander9864
    @scothighlander9864 2 місяці тому +9

    Their history is NOT really Complex at all.
    Let me explain it in two words;
    America & Israel !!

    • @g8keeper_breacher
      @g8keeper_breacher 2 місяці тому

      the agencies created them so they could manipulate the civilian populations and try to keep them living in fear.

    • @timbookedtwo2375
      @timbookedtwo2375 2 місяці тому +1

      that‘s three words

    • @mariem6735
      @mariem6735 Місяць тому

      Very True. The liberators and the Liberated helping each other with mutual ingenuity. Tiny Dot Israel and Giant Dot America.

  • @stephensipe5405
    @stephensipe5405 2 місяці тому +5

    You made my case. About 2.2 million Gaza Palestinians have to be expelled. Only a remnant, maybe 100,000 Christians, Bedouins, and select cooperating Gaza Muslims can stay. They will become Israeli citizens. They will get the 1ST rebuilt Israeli housing.

    • @anthonybernstein9698
      @anthonybernstein9698 2 місяці тому

      If 100,000 arabs remain it will soon be a problem.
      Hamas will put in a breeding programme.
      Just do the numbers, one man has four wives, as they get to old to breed he dumps one and replaces it for a younger one. This man can recycle his wives and have more than sixty kids.
      Sixty boys and girls get married if only half are male then the numbers get repeated.
      Thirty men at least four wives thats one hundred and twenty breeding female wives.
      The numbers start to go crazy, one hundred and twenty wives multiply a conservative number of five kids its six hundred.
      One man four wives plus replacements, twenty or thirty kids, how many grandchildren?
      In 1945 with a slow the arabs were not forced to breed and numbered 600.000 throughout all the various refugee camps. Gaza is an exception, the population has grown faster than other refugees camps. Refugees are now spread all over the place and we now have over 8 million "palastinian refugees" being supported for generations to come.

    • @stephensipe5405
      @stephensipe5405 2 місяці тому

      @@stickshaker4262 Read Zechariah 9:5-7. It’s not BS, it’s prophecy.

    • @user-dg1ho4tj2g
      @user-dg1ho4tj2g 2 місяці тому

      the 2.2M unwanted Pales can go to Australia, Malaysia, Spain, Italy, UK, Ireland, Norway, China, Nicaragua, Russia, and other pro-Hamas/ Pales countries.

    • @eli-kathrinknudsen3644
      @eli-kathrinknudsen3644 2 місяці тому

      And people keep claiming muslims are The problem…

    • @mariem6735
      @mariem6735 Місяць тому

      Reading this after my comment. They can't do that without the risk to be invaded by all Muslim world. America will do it nevertheless. How do I know? I dreamed about it November 2012. I can see the resolve on the emaciated faces of 2 agents backs against walls in a corridor. One was consulting his notes and told me We Know you Warned us. I did. 2012 connected to 2003.. Warnings being mostly about Islam + Communism.
      Also I warned Israel about an invasion in 2021. Pride is our worst enemy. I would have not blinked when telling them a million ways to invade any country no matter the technology. Go to Switzerland. They are everywhere. Aggressive and condescending. The Swiss are nevertheless wiser than Israeli. They don't grant citizenship like chocolates.

  • @laurenglass4514
    @laurenglass4514 2 місяці тому +1

    Didn’t they make the Palestinians permanent refugees in name and behavior and that is that they are not “citizens”, I wish he would comment on that

  • @user-yg7fv3jo8v
    @user-yg7fv3jo8v 2 місяці тому

    If every sane person in the world had watched the terrible and barbaric scenes of October 7th and listened to what happened to the captives who have already been released from Hamas, they would have Join the IDF.

    • @channeldos
      @channeldos Місяць тому

      You pretending it started oct 7 is all I need to know about you

    • @user-yg7fv3jo8v
      @user-yg7fv3jo8v Місяць тому

      @@channeldos Just so I understand you correctly, are you saying that October 7th is justified?

  • @eli-kathrinknudsen3644
    @eli-kathrinknudsen3644 2 місяці тому +2

    Poorly balanced summary. Meaning no credibility. Do americans believe this is The truth?

  • @ayanda6862
    @ayanda6862 2 місяці тому +4

    Love your propaganda show.you should become isreal spokesperson

  • @saabajoe
    @saabajoe 2 місяці тому +9

    Disingenous and false. But great propaganda for the uneducated. 👍🏻

    • @anitamwd
      @anitamwd 2 місяці тому +3

      We can say the same towards your believes.

    • @saabajoe
      @saabajoe 2 місяці тому

      @@anitamwd And what are my "believes" (sic) according to you?

    • @laverdad2022
      @laverdad2022 2 місяці тому

      Be more precise otherwise you sound like a woke and or a leftit that never makes sense of their saying...throw some facts and tell us your sources to at least perhaps learn something we do not know...please enlighten us with facts

    • @boofclouds199
      @boofclouds199 2 місяці тому +6

      I would like you to point out what was disingenuous and false. Please educate us.

    • @johnf.1969
      @johnf.1969 2 місяці тому +4

      "This conflict is not merely a Palestinian-Israeli conflict but rather a Muslim-Jewish conflict. The Islamic sources, the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Sira show that the Islamic deep seated enmity towards the Jews and Israel, is profoundly Qur'anic, inspired by Allah as claimed by Muhammad."