D&D Dragonlance Review and GM Tips

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @TheGallantGoblin
    @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +3

    Sponsored by Hit Point Press's Black Friday Sale! (Use code BF2022 to get an additional 5% off your order of $50 or more!)
    $10 Non-Animated 5e Deck of Many Reference cards - (10% Off ) hitpointpress.com/the-deck-of-many/reference-decks/?aff=24
    Humblewood Products (10% Off ) - hitpointpress.com/humblewood/?aff=24
    Animated Spell Cards (10% Off ) - hitpointpress.com/animated-spells/?aff=24
    Griffon's Saddlebag (10% Off ) - hitpointpress.com/thegriffonssaddlebag/?aff=24
    Mini STL Files (10% Off ) - hitpointpress.com/mini-stls/?aff=24
    Fablemaker's Animated Tarot (16.7% Off) - hitpointpress.com/the-fablemakers-animated-tarot-box-set/?aff=24
    Pre-Order Kobold Plushies at: koboldplush.com

    • @cthrion_uroniziir
      @cthrion_uroniziir Рік тому +2

      where is the MCDM Kingdoms & Warfare link?

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for the reminder! I knew I forgot something! shop.mcdmproductions.com/products/kingdoms-and-warfare-pdf

    • @cthrion_uroniziir
      @cthrion_uroniziir Рік тому

      @@TheGallantGoblin thx

    • @josephskiles
      @josephskiles Рік тому

      Kender are halflings in Dragon lance BTW Theo, not gnomes...... Originally they were kleptomaniacs as well but I think Wizards changed that lore unfortunately because they felt it was problematic

    • @josephskiles
      @josephskiles Рік тому

      Would love to see you do a review on the boardgame, any day visiting the Gallant Goblin is a fine day indeed!

  • @Throgmoyd
    @Throgmoyd Рік тому +8

    A truly great review Theo - thank you so much! My original D&D playing days had paused when Dragonlance first came to prominence (yes, I am that old); sure I am aware of DL but never sought it out to play. In recent years I am back in the D&D saddle and am inspired by our video to pick up the adventure. Thank you!

  • @MrBrad9
    @MrBrad9 Рік тому +3

    I love Dragon lance. Pre-ordered all the goodies. Very thorough content as always. (Side note, just a personal opinion, would prefer if music wasn't playing while you were talking. If it works for you guys and your channel all the power to you. I'll still watch). Always enjoy your content keep up the great videos.

  • @Enlyss
    @Enlyss 10 місяців тому

    So happy UA-cam algorithms suggested this video. Fantastic review. Thanks a lot!

  • @kristofthedm231
    @kristofthedm231 Рік тому +1

    Not sure if its been mentioned here, but DMs Guild has a Dragonlance Companion book available, that has more lore and options. Just ordered my print copy today

  • @odinulveson9101
    @odinulveson9101 Рік тому +4

    Great video. I'll get the deluxe edition at leadt. But a heads up! Theres one detail not updated to D&D Beyond info. Just watched Nerd Immersions walkthrough of past and current arcana for say the Moon phases spell class distribution. On updated Beyond, the New moon have actually Enchantment and Necromancy, in physical books its Evocation and Necromancy. For Crescent moon phase its in the books Illusion and Divination but should be Illusion and Transmutation

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +2

      Hey thanks for the info! The nice thing about having access to the content digitally is getting all that errata baked in like that! -Theo

  • @Gravy65
    @Gravy65 Рік тому +1

    First off, thanks for the great review. I've been wishy-washy on what I want to do about this. In thinking about this comment, I realized it is almost exactly (couldn't tell you what month it was, but it was during the 92/93 school year) 30 years since my best friend in junior high was telling me about this dwarf trying to get into a boat while people shot arrows at the party in the book he found in the school library. He made it sound interesting, so when he returned it, I quickly grabbed it up, and began reading. (then when I had to return it unfinished, I bought my copy of all three Chronicle books. Starting a long time reading of almost exclusively DragonLance stuff.)
    I did not own any of the roleplaying stuff until they released it for 3rd edition, but I played the SSI goldbox games, and really just lost myself in the stories. By the time it was out for 3e, I had already found myself deep in a homebrew campaign with friends, so I've never actually played on Krynn.
    I very-likely will never run this adventure, though with the board game addition, it sounds fun, and I just may (especially being able to bring in your own character as the DM, that sounds like just the amount of playing I may need to keep me going sometimes) I could go on for far too long on why I was afraid I wont be happy with what they did to DragonLance....but your review makes it seem like I may enjoy it just enough, and I can always change a few things around to make it more traditional.

  • @kyrnsword72
    @kyrnsword72 Рік тому +3

    Great review. Dragon Lance game looks and sounds fun. My beloved TTRPG is D100 Dungeon Mapping game with books by Martin Knight.

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      That's awesome! I'll look that up! Thanks, BhudaTao! -Theo

  • @joshuaregis4200
    @joshuaregis4200 Рік тому +3

    Please do a review of the warriors of krynn board game

  • @commanderbbshockwave8698
    @commanderbbshockwave8698 Рік тому +2

    Thanks for the extensive review of the book Theo! I am mostly familiar with Dragonlance from the Margaret T. Weis books and that not-so-great animated movie (if you ever feel like trying to review movies, it is a good choice for a bad one to start with! ;) ).
    I feel this new book has less setting than Ravenloft or Spelljammer did, and puts far more focus on the adventure, at least page-number-wise. The areas we visit are very well established and described, sure, but I feel the book puts little focus on the world as a whole. Important races of Krynn, like the Minotaur kingdoms or the Irda (High Ogres, basically blue-skinned intelligent and gentle noble creatures) are not even described or mentioned (at least from what I have seen in previews).
    My other main gripe is the really short Monster Manual entry, which barely has any unique Dragonlance creatures. The Anhkolox (a variant of the Gholor from 2E-3E) is really the only one, Istarian Drones and Death Dragons are a new 5E creation, and while I quite like them, wish we had gotten more. Dragonlance has a lot of unique Dragons, many water-themed, creepy undead elves who are just floating eyes and claws, adorable KoDragons (cute little furry big-eyed things), Eyewings that attack with acidic tears, gigantic flaming Skeletons, sand Crocodiles, Shadowperson (they were basically a pre-Spelljammer version of the Hadozee), Walrus people, and my favourite weirdest race ever, the Taylings/Taylands: binary bonded twin brothers/sisters, where the Taylings look like Elves, while the Taylands look like bestial animal-like humanoids. They are so attached to each other that should one die, the other would soon follow.
    Anyway, I am grateful that WotC brought back this setting at least for the new minis this gets us of important characters like Lord Soth and a lot of mounted Dragons.

  • @dennisbest4740
    @dennisbest4740 7 місяців тому +1

    Loved the tip about having PCs create their own NPCs and then merge them with actual NPCs in the campaign!

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  7 місяців тому +1

      I use that all the time! Players seem to enjoy seeing the NPCs they created take an important role in the story.

  • @DarkAutumnScribe
    @DarkAutumnScribe Рік тому +2

    Yes. Review of Kingdoms & Warfare please...

  • @chuckallerston9997
    @chuckallerston9997 Рік тому +5

    beadle and grims version's gonna be epic

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому

      Really excited to see it! -Theo

    • @kurtpearson2793
      @kurtpearson2793 Рік тому

      I’m really wishing that I could grab the Steel B&G DL , hard to wait!

  • @keithvanboskirk7327
    @keithvanboskirk7327 Рік тому +2

    would be great to see your take on K&W and how to dove tail into a campaign

  • @judemapp8804
    @judemapp8804 Рік тому +2

    Fantastic, thank you for the review Theo. I think D&D have been knocking it out of the park with their adventures in 5e, and I think this looks like a great continuation. Definitely will be picking up the version with the boardgame.
    Krynn was my favourite setting pre-5e and I even loved the Third Age edition with cards used instead of dice. It’s just such a lore rich environment and I found stories like the Sylvanesti shield and trapped dragon so enticing.
    I flip back and forth between wanting more D&D books (like lore books) and then remembering how awful it was in 3.5 and 4e being a fan of something that had Paizo levels of output. I’m loving the quality over quantity but… maybe moving from 4-5 books a year to 7-8 would be a happy medium.

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому

      That's really awesome! I wish I had been in the hobby for the older editions! I would love to look at those older versions of Dragonlance one day! Yeah, I understand about the pain of keeping up with the books, though I appreciate Paizo indicating that all the current books are optional. And I like that they're region specific. If you're not interested in a certain region, you can skip those 3-4 books and wait until the next wave. -Theo

    • @judemapp8804
      @judemapp8804 Рік тому +1

      @@TheGallantGoblin Yeah, unfortunately I have a nasty case of collectivitis. I’m a completionist. I have all the Pathfinder 2e printed books to date, but I’m an adult with a good job and a partner who is *also* a gamer. I look back at my college-aged self though and think how frustrating it was to try and keep up with the D&D output. Even just the FR stuff. Anywhoo…
      I really, really recommend reading the Dragonlance trilogy. It suffers a little from it’s age but still tells a great story while filling in a lot of lore about the world.

  • @gabrielcardoso8732
    @gabrielcardoso8732 Рік тому +1

    I would like to hear your impressions on Kingdoms & Warfare!

  • @kurtoogle4576
    @kurtoogle4576 Рік тому

    Really appreciate the thorough review and your thoughts on play. Thank you!

  • @claymassingill9589
    @claymassingill9589 Рік тому +3

    Would love a video on Kingdoms, Organizations and Warfare. Curious to see what you think of it and how easy it is/isn't to teach to players.
    Edit: It's actually been a little bit since I watched a video from you, but your video production/presentation has gotten very professional, very good job on this one.

  • @markyerhardt
    @markyerhardt Рік тому

    thanks for this over all review

  • @YugiohPatternDuelist
    @YugiohPatternDuelist Рік тому +1

    Always love the content and really appreciate the review!

  • @bigH101
    @bigH101 Рік тому

    This is a great review Theo. I am not sure how I feel about the "board game". I bought this preorder and it seems to be lacking for the price. However, I do see how it will add another dimension in the game. Please do a full review of the board game.

  • @blodrush25
    @blodrush25 Рік тому +1

    i love the Dragon lance book i can only say read them before you start playing the game

  • @Angelfyre.
    @Angelfyre. Рік тому +1

    I hope Greyhawk is next

  • @redoctopusgames
    @redoctopusgames Рік тому

    thank you for these really great review and ideas how to play it.

  • @johnmhuizar
    @johnmhuizar Рік тому

    Am playing this campaign currently and am about 12 hours in. I avoided the spoiler sections so I don't know if these are things you addressed, but my preliminary thoughts are these (no story spoilers below but I do discuss encounter balance, enemy damage/abilities, and party composition). I should also preface this by saying that I am really enjoying the campaign so far! These are just things I wish I knew before I started.
    Early level combat can be a real mess if you are a melee-centric party. Nearly every single enemy you face even when you're at level 1 gets multiple melee attacks per turn, and the majority of them will also apply a status effect (and later, will do direct damage) in a radius when they die. So I hope you like rolling saving throws continously to see if you get to spend your turns doing nothing. Save yourself hours of headache and bring a bow/eldritch blast/etc.
    Speaking of saving throws, the battlefield random events each turn are neat on paper but irritating in practice because they just straight up override anything you've been doing to be careful on the battlefield. Worked really hard to get a defensible position, good sightlines, and map control? Too bad, a dice roll decided that somebody just staggers out of nowhere and stabs/shoots/blows up one of your randomly chosen characters.
    In a similar vein, there is one specific encounter in the early game where it is quite possible for a single high roll on the DM's part to do a TPK if you don't happen to be spread out enough. We were lucky and only lost one character--our level 3 barbarian was at full health but ate 5d10 to the face from 60 feet away. Balance-wise that seems a bit spicy to me (especially given it came late in a series of like 5-6 encounters with no ability to rest and restore spells/rages/etc). But, once again, a ranged party would not have even been in danger.

  • @RIVERSRPGChannel
    @RIVERSRPGChannel Рік тому +1

    Sounds like a good setting and setup
    I would like to get the deluxe edition for all the books and board game but it’s a bit pricey
    Thanks

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      Yeah, it certainly is. Curious how groups react to the board game. -Theo

  • @queerios9925
    @queerios9925 Рік тому

    Can't wait for mine to arrive

  • @snieves4
    @snieves4 Рік тому

    Yes please on watriors of krynn.

  • @josephskiles
    @josephskiles Рік тому +4

    Her name is pronounced " Tack-eye-sis", close enough though. You tube has the animated movie for the first heroes of the lance novel adaptation, it's passable with decent voice actors, Kieffer Sutherland is even one.
    I had a blast talking to you both about the lore of Krynn when you came to Indy!

    • @xczechr
      @xczechr Рік тому +1

      I have never heard it pronounced that way in my thirty+ years of playing.

    • @josephskiles
      @josephskiles Рік тому

      @@xczechr it's the way both Hickman and Weiss pronounce it so I reckon the people who named her and created her have some small clue how to pronounce her name, if you watch the animated movie it's how it's pronounced as well

    • @syd4890
      @syd4890 Рік тому

      It's actually pronounced Bob xD

  • @Zr0din
    @Zr0din Рік тому

    1. Good Review. 2. Can a Home Brewer use the boardgame scenarios / rules to make War based campaigns? Or do you believe it's too specific to the DragonLance situation?

    • @AbelMcTalisker
      @AbelMcTalisker Рік тому

      You would probably have to create a lot of homebrew cards and write your own scenarios. A lot of work but it COULD be done as the basic game mechanics have a lot of potential for expansions. Perhaps WOTc might get around to releasing some official expansions sometime. Unofficially, some of the old TSR Dragonlance modules have some content intended for the old Battlesystem wargame that could be mined for background information and scenario ideas.

  • @TheCreativeKobold
    @TheCreativeKobold Рік тому

    Very nice review! :D And yes, do review Kingdoms & Warfare! :D

  • @bestestfin2672
    @bestestfin2672 Рік тому

    I would love to see a video on Kingdoms and Warfare! I am a big fan of Matt Colville already so I may be a bit biased with my interest in it compared to the rest of your audience though

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      It seems to be pretty popular around here! I'm reading through it! -Theo

  • @danteviperbrandolini
    @danteviperbrandolini Рік тому

    Spectacular & Amazing Video Review by you Sir..... 👽👽👻😉

  • @starblaze27
    @starblaze27 Рік тому

    Got.a feeling if they make a lore book it may cause trouble, though one can easily find the lore online and with various books written during the 3.5 era. As to why I think it may cause trouble.. well there is the story on how the Kender and dwarves were created. Kender most will agree on but I am sure people will be getting their pitchforks and torches when they hear that the dwarves in Krynn were gnomes who got twisted by the greygem. Maybe people will like it like I did when I first knew of this back in the 90s and 2000s, but I do see some newer players seem to have their mind set to where things have to all be same and PC as well as saying it is ok to alter and change the lore to be agreeable to them.
    ...And then we had something like Rings of Power and the same people attacked because they "messed with the lore".

  • @sqoody7invegas625
    @sqoody7invegas625 Рік тому

    Does anyone know a good source to order the Kingdoms and warfare book featured in video?

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      You can get it directly from MCDM's shop at shop.mcdmproductions.com/collections/kingdoms-warfare/products/kingdoms-warfare-hardcover-book

  • @lancearmada
    @lancearmada Рік тому

    Im curious how the board game could influence things assuming you dont plan on getting it. Does it undermine the story at all not having it? Do i need the board game to maximize the story?

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому

      The board game pulls the camera back to show the greater context in which your heroes’ actions take place. As written, it doesn’t change the story in any significant way in my eyes. If the story of your heroes is your primary concern, the board game isn’t essential. -Theo

  • @EduFirenze
    @EduFirenze Рік тому

    Was hoping the board game would be like ravenloft

  • @ShadicXCIV
    @ShadicXCIV Рік тому +1

    Ayyyee MCDM plug!

  • @josephskiles
    @josephskiles Рік тому +4

    I'm going to explain my take on why the lore in so many settings is so light now compared to the rich and wonderful world building the settings were once known for. Im really really truly gonna try to not go on some grognard rant here I promise.
    Several settings are considered extremely problematic now and WOTC has made no secret that for every writer there are now 3 or 4 People hired to make sure there are no problematic content. Honestly if someone is extremely scared to push boundaries then you are going to get the most vanilla option possible , true art needs to challenge our perception and beliefs, this can't be done if your scared constantly that you will create something nobody in the world will be offended by (which is a losing battle before you even start). This is why we can't have nice things Theo.
    Dragonlance is a setting based partly with Mormon mythology integrated because both Hickman and Weiss are Mormons. The fact that the Gods of Krynn play such an integral part of the setting that many of the creative types working at current Wizards despise what the setting was so I have been extremely worried how the setting would be handled after what Jessica Price did to Ravenloft. Lord Soth is one of D&D's most tragic and iconic villains, I wanted so badly for his backstory to stay true to the wonderful lore he was originally given.
    Yes I'm a grognard, a dinosaur, a relic of the past but I wouldn't give up my love for the old lore for anything, I just wish I could share this beautiful setting with new players untouched by modernization of something I'm so passionate about!

    • @politenonparticipant4859
      @politenonparticipant4859 Рік тому +1

      I haven't been a fan of their more recent stuff, so it would really be a breath of fresh air if this module expanded on an existing setting, revitalizing and reintroducing the old familiar without removing the existing history or cultures. Instead finsing ways of making the conventions of the setting playable with the 5e rulebook and adapting out the modern take on the races and classes to better match what you would find in the DragonLance setting.
      I don't think there's anything particularly wrong with being a grognard. The new players in the hobby should be taking their lead of how to play from the veterans, because they are being adopted into an existing culture. Yes, the new generation helps decide what path the hobby takes to better fit their interests, but they shouldn't be getting into D&D if they don't already love it the way it is. They'd be better off building their own new settings, races, classes, or gaming systems if they don't like what was already in the game before they joined. Maybe then we'd see new settings get introduced which reflect the sentiments of some of those players and writers who have only joined tabletop roleplaying in the last five years while still having new adventures in older settings which retain the tone and sensabilities with which those settings were originally created.

  • @Gravy65
    @Gravy65 Рік тому

    So, I just went to buy it, and it's $154.98 on wizard's site for the deluxe edition. Did they up the price? Or do I need a coupon code?

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому

      Oh that’s strange. I’m honestly not sure. I may have pulled the price from Amazon or an older source when I made the video. I don’t fully remember anymore. It does look like $155 is the correct price from Wizards as I’m seeing it quoted in news articles. Apologies for the confusion. -Theo

  • @jancarlmatysiak4354
    @jancarlmatysiak4354 Рік тому

    Do you know about foreign language publications? Will this come in german for example?

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому +1

      I'm afraid I haven't received any information about the foreign language editions. If I hear something, I'll let you know! -Theo

  • @drivingavery
    @drivingavery Рік тому

    Would love some campaign books that start at level 10 and goes to 20. Progress characters through multiple stories.

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  Рік тому

      Yeah! Pathfinder (and even Starfinder) does this all the time. Not sure why we don't have a true high level D&D adventure that could pick up after the conclusion of other adventures. -Theo

  • @keeperofthefate
    @keeperofthefate Рік тому

    I'm upset, because WotC cancelled entire polish line of D&D. Not all of my players understand english and even if, we play in the same language as we speak. If I want to play this, I would need to sit down and translate ALL OF IT myself.

  • @scp53779-thebarber
    @scp53779-thebarber 3 місяці тому

    Id argue that dragonlance is a more iconic setting than faerun, and greyhawk ks the proper dnd setting. Faerun is rather basic and boring.

    • @TheGallantGoblin
      @TheGallantGoblin  3 місяці тому

      Fair. I guess it largely depends on when you came into the hobby.

  • @MS-lk2sk
    @MS-lk2sk Рік тому

    Got this to play, but this new artwork is generic crap.

  • @inverness1976
    @inverness1976 Рік тому

    This is a good review, but I am not a fan of your thumbnail.

  • @darksarcasmsvideodiaries6262

    Sorcerer is OP and broken!