How to Create a Language: Dothraki Inventor Explains | WIRED

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,7 тис.

  • @ambivalentllamas373
    @ambivalentllamas373 5 років тому +9755

    I have an applied linguistics exam in 5 days. watching this doesn’t feel like procrastinating

    • @ambivalentllamas373
      @ambivalentllamas373 5 років тому +42

      @El Vis i do too. thanks!

    • @ICarpeIDiemI
      @ICarpeIDiemI 5 років тому +30

      Sociolinguistics in 2 days for me :D

    • @rimbluebooks
      @rimbluebooks 5 років тому +1

      No not at all 👌😂

    • @rock3tcatU233
      @rock3tcatU233 5 років тому +84

      This is what I tell myself when I have a gynecology exam coming up and I'm stuck in a Pornhub™ loop.

    • @mercedesmartinezbruera9861
      @mercedesmartinezbruera9861 5 років тому +10

      Psicolinguistics next week. Good Luck!!!

  • @Shocktroll
    @Shocktroll 5 років тому +469

    Met this guy at a convention once, and basically learned he created at least two languages that never even got used. And one of them was for the White Walkers.

    • @ccorvid
      @ccorvid 6 місяців тому +7

      👀

    • @maggyfrog
      @maggyfrog 6 місяців тому +8

      they supposedly sound like cracking ice? did you ask?

  • @kerovibe
    @kerovibe 5 років тому +5990

    Meanwhile the guy making languages for guardians of the galaxy. " I am groot".

    • @sypwer
      @sypwer 5 років тому +48

      lmfao

    • @SubKoopa
      @SubKoopa 5 років тому +219

      Its purely tonal language

    • @kerovibe
      @kerovibe 5 років тому +73

      @@SubKoopa name one tonal language limited to one word.

    • @pinestraker4840
      @pinestraker4840 5 років тому +101

      @@kerovibe Game Theory did a video about this. There's a language with no words they posed as an example actially. It's made up of whistles.

    • @SubKoopa
      @SubKoopa 5 років тому +46

      @@kerovibe I posted that as a joke but sure lets get upset over a fake alien tree language

  • @cecin7042
    @cecin7042 5 років тому +1142

    I hope that David make the dothraki on duolingo. I can't believe that you can learn valyrian on duolingo is so amazing.

    • @gulsahfdn
      @gulsahfdn 5 років тому +51

      Ceci N OMG, you can learn valyrian on duolingo??!!! 😱

    • @ElizabethHanchett
      @ElizabethHanchett 5 років тому +108

      He did! Both Dothraki and High Valyrian courses on Duolingo were created and developed by him.

    • @guacamoshakrtveli4455
      @guacamoshakrtveli4455 5 років тому +3

      @@marissaurias5116 because it's only for English-speaking people

    • @guacamoshakrtveli4455
      @guacamoshakrtveli4455 5 років тому +3

      @@marissaurias5116 you were right, I've thought that I've seen it

    • @thewatcheronthewalls4809
      @thewatcheronthewalls4809 5 років тому +85

      Hey ok here’s a shock, some people might learn it for fun.

  • @girv98
    @girv98 5 років тому +1851

    Some good conlang and linguistics channels for those that are interested:
    - Artifexian
    - Biblaridion
    - Nativlang
    - Langfocus
    - jan Misali
    - Agma Schwa
    - Colin Gorrie
    - Worldbuilding Notes
    - Nakari Speardane
    - Xidnaf
    - Polymathy
    - Simon Roper
    - K Klein
    - Dr. Geoff Lindsey
    - Connor Quimby
    David Peterson also has his own channel, as well as the LangTime Studios channel; where he livestreams every Thursday creating conlangs with fellow conlanger Jessie Sams.

    • @RedHair651
      @RedHair651 5 років тому +18

      James Girven Xidnaf isn’t terrible, but saying he’s good is a stretch.

    • @Procrustinator52
      @Procrustinator52 5 років тому +6

      Thank you! I didn't know few of them. checking out soon

    • @girv98
      @girv98 5 років тому +25

      @@RedHair651 good as in a helpful resource

    • @Nae_Ayy
      @Nae_Ayy 5 років тому +6

      @@RedHair651 why?

    • @chanyeolswife5235
      @chanyeolswife5235 5 років тому +14

      Artificial is the best. He also teach how to create worlds

  • @mertensduplooy8870
    @mertensduplooy8870 5 років тому +506

    Butterfly in Afrikaans (my first language) is "skoenlapper", which directly translates to "shoe flapper".

    • @shariff6155
      @shariff6155 4 роки тому +9

      bruuuuuuuuh

    • @dollykumo2959
      @dollykumo2959 4 роки тому +17

      Okay , but why ? 😭

    • @CloveBunny
      @CloveBunny 4 роки тому +7

      Beautiful

    • @holdenfunk7411
      @holdenfunk7411 4 роки тому +43

      kumo narazi I mean, why is our butter flying?

    • @dollykumo2959
      @dollykumo2959 4 роки тому +6

      @@holdenfunk7411 dude idk why you people do that . I speak Arabic & we just have a name for it like any other thing .

  • @12GabrielMacedo
    @12GabrielMacedo 5 років тому +2908

    Someone needs to teach the Dothraki how to say “I’m outta here this fight ain’t for me chief”. That’s my take

    • @noonecares616
      @noonecares616 5 років тому +164

      Dude where were you during the battle of winterfell

    • @anastasiyakozyrev9226
      @anastasiyakozyrev9226 5 років тому +10

      @@noonecares616 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @noonecares616
      @noonecares616 5 років тому +63

      @@anastasiyakozyrev9226 they hyped this dude for seven seasons and during the battle was nowhere to be found

    • @anastasiyakozyrev9226
      @anastasiyakozyrev9226 5 років тому +6

      @@noonecares616 True

    • @noonecares616
      @noonecares616 5 років тому +7

      @@anastasiyakozyrev9226 i was soo disappointed tbh

  • @ZHL242
    @ZHL242 5 років тому +2204

    Wired definitely needs another channel just devoted to linguistics lol

    • @armorsmith43
      @armorsmith43 5 років тому +8

      ZHL242 check out langfocus and xifmod

    • @eskipotato
      @eskipotato 5 років тому +9

      yuh didnt expect to see my favorite transcription boi here

    • @drago7466
      @drago7466 5 років тому +1

      eskipotato same 😂

    • @llarry2009
      @llarry2009 5 років тому +2

      @@eskipotato he has his own channel too

    • @melodyfussell829
      @melodyfussell829 4 роки тому +1

      Bring in Erik Singer. Please.

  • @Mysterialic
    @Mysterialic 5 років тому +2171

    How to say "lol you thought we were all gone pfft" in Dothraki?

    • @noonecares616
      @noonecares616 5 років тому +226

      Yer dirge kisha evoon gwe....
      There you go buddy

    • @jomouzio4443
      @jomouzio4443 5 років тому +78

      @@noonecares616 w8 for real? Can people actually speak the language, that must be an awesome party trick lmao

    • @Jacob-zc3ks
      @Jacob-zc3ks 5 років тому +71

      Joao Sr1l -_- It’s not, people just think you’re weird. Anha vos vindelat dranekh maisi yeri, zhey ifaki.

    • @jomouzio4443
      @jomouzio4443 5 років тому +51

      @@Jacob-zc3ks yo for real i think thats awesome, that mustve taken some dedication, kudos to you, although i have no idea what u just said

    • @noonecares616
      @noonecares616 5 років тому +57

      You know there is like a dictionary thing for dothraki right

  • @cyrusdastoor999
    @cyrusdastoor999 5 років тому +4917

    Anyone notice how his thumbs look like normal fingers?

    • @yoloswaggins2161
      @yoloswaggins2161 5 років тому +435

      dude WHAAAAAAT

    • @latenitebored
      @latenitebored 5 років тому +354

      Cyrus Dastoor lmao he just has long, skinny thumbs. Good eye though.

    • @pepsiforever1
      @pepsiforever1 5 років тому +207

      latenitebored
      NO WAY...he DEFINITELY has something wrong with his thumbs especially the left one. I think the position of the actual thumb is angled weird....like an ape

    • @hojdog
      @hojdog 5 років тому +271

      cannot unsee

    • @HappinessOrDeath
      @HappinessOrDeath 5 років тому +52

      Whoaaaaa wtffff

  • @zuko1569
    @zuko1569 5 років тому +6515

    The only Dothraki language i know is:
    _Alululululululu_

    • @mirza6399
      @mirza6399 5 років тому +58

      And A alululululululu to you to sir. Lets meet later at high tea.

    • @mohammedhisham4071
      @mohammedhisham4071 5 років тому +7

      Stop commenting everywhere

    • @Bangaly16kaba
      @Bangaly16kaba 5 років тому +3

      Lol

    • @TheSuperhoden
      @TheSuperhoden 5 років тому +2

      Lmao

    • @carkod
      @carkod 5 років тому +6

      He is totally right, most Western European can't pull off tone languages. It's awful how American actors speak Mandarin, even Chinese-Americans do it wrong...

  • @emilykolaja2816
    @emilykolaja2816 5 років тому +135

    As a linguistics student, I am loving all this language-related content lately. I've had the desire to create the basics of my own conlang for a while now, and this really motivated me to get started. I also loved hearing the basics of the subject explained to me again, but in terms of constructing a language rather than studying existing ones. Hoping to see more of David too!

    • @the_doomcliff
      @the_doomcliff Рік тому

      How is it going with the conlang mate?

  • @mariostret
    @mariostret 5 років тому +3115

    "and the object is the woman"
    just like the Dothraki

  • @Lightologyy
    @Lightologyy 5 років тому +88

    Here you go guys ♥
    1. What is the point?
    2. Is it written, spoken, or signed?
    3. Sounds.
    A. Consonants and Vowels
    B. Syllables
    C. Stress and Intonation
    • Stress Language: English (You have to stress the word by the letters).
    • Tone Language: Chinese (The actual pitch that you speak the Vallot is important).
    4. Grammer.
    - Adjectives
    - Adverbs (thee main types)
    * Manner, Time, Place
    - Prepositions, Postpostitions
    - Determiners, Demonstratives
    Nouns:-
    • Singular vs Plural
    • dual or trail
    • nothing
    • Case
    • Gender
    • Masculine vs. Feminine
    • Big vs. Large
    • Living vs. Non-Living
    • Natural vs. Non-natural
    • Tool vs. Plant
    • High Valyrian Nouns
    • 4 Numbers
    • 8 Cases
    • 4 Genders
    Verbs
    5. Sentence Structure.
    “The man [Subject] sees [Verb] the woman [Object].”
    Subject + Verb + Object
    6. Derivation.
    Teach > Teacher
    Jelmio [wind] > Jelmazma [big wind]
    7. Miscellaneous.
    - Writing Systems:-
    • Alphabet: Characters for vowels and consonants. [English]
    • Abjad: Charactes for consonants only. [Arabic]
    • Abugida: Main glyph for a consonant and some sort of a little addition for a vowel. [Hindi]
    • Logography: Glyphs that stand for entire word or parts of words or maybe more than one word
    depending on how it works [Chinese]
    8. Lexicon
    The words of the language:-
    “Think about riding a horse, starting a fire, and think about what goes into that scenario, what’s happening,
    and what will speakers of this language have words for, with respect to that scenario.”
    9. Create a reference.
    • Grammer and dictionary.

  • @dilek92
    @dilek92 2 роки тому +21

    it was cool to see he recommended to study turkish along with japanese and french because i've realized that dothraki's grammar is similar to turkish. it was a great video!

  • @silentnitedeadlynite
    @silentnitedeadlynite 5 років тому +397

    This guy spent twice the amount of time creating languages used in maybe a couple hundred lines of dialogue, than did Weiss and Benioff creating the whole of season 6.

  • @rinhd1977
    @rinhd1977 5 років тому +4090

    Even after watching I still dont get it how language is made

    • @justblaze4707
      @justblaze4707 5 років тому +134

      It's a guide to make a cookie cutter, then when he wants to make a word to fit the situation, he puts it into his table and tests out the way it interacts with the surrounding lexicon

    • @petrino
      @petrino 5 років тому +13

      Chenza at court, the court of silence
      Darmok and Jalad on the ocean
      Darmok on the ocean
      Kadir beneath Mo Moteh
      Kira at Bashi
      Kiteo, his eyes closed
      Rai and Jiri at Lungha
      Shaka, when the walls fell
      Sokath, his eyes uncovered/opened
      Temba, at rest

    • @fabienlehenaff2742
      @fabienlehenaff2742 5 років тому +142

      you need to understand the rules of your own language first ( tenses, cases, vocabulary, grammar, etc...). Otherwise its like trying to write a song without even knowing what chords and rhythms are.

    • @ens0246
      @ens0246 5 років тому +3

      @@petrino Picard and Dathon at El-Adrel

    • @kuro13wolf
      @kuro13wolf 5 років тому +35

      ​@Eric Beller You okay there? Here, let me unscramble that for you.
      "This is more about syntax and grammar rather than philosophical considerations except in specific examples."

  • @TeagueChrystie
    @TeagueChrystie 5 років тому +70

    I was expecting this to be a good primer for conlangs. This was actually a *great* primer for conlangs. Well done, guy!

  • @saramiele4662
    @saramiele4662 5 років тому +29

    This dude will help me pass my linguistics exam he made me review all the program in just 13 minutes

  • @ayoubelamrani6920
    @ayoubelamrani6920 5 років тому +344

    Once you see his thumbs, you can't unsee them.

    • @nathanwilliams4005
      @nathanwilliams4005 5 років тому +29

      You mean his 2nd index finger?

    • @sinaimuse6562
      @sinaimuse6562 5 років тому +2

      Shut up !! LOLOL

    • @chrisp8458
      @chrisp8458 4 роки тому +3

      😹😹😹 he has the e.t ouuuchhhhee’s 💀💀💀

  • @robertschlesinger1342
    @robertschlesinger1342 5 років тому +75

    Fascinating video describing a logical set of procedures for creating a language. The presentation was clear, logical (almost algorithmic), and informative. I hope you prepare and post sequels to this great video.

  • @BHNative
    @BHNative 5 років тому +29

    I envy this guy's brain. This was waaaay more interesting than I was expecting.

  • @mulanfrantic
    @mulanfrantic 5 років тому +463

    "I do syllable mostly because I am not convinced that actors will pull off a tone language correctly."
    HAHAHAHA

    • @baptistefaussat
      @baptistefaussat 5 років тому +67

      He's right, for instance the actors of Firefly speak terrible Mandarin.

    • @mulanfrantic
      @mulanfrantic 5 років тому +43

      @@baptistefaussat Very true, and I find it funny every time someone acknowledges it.

    • @MenloMarseilles
      @MenloMarseilles 3 роки тому +21

      in his book he mentions a bunch of other things like this... for example in English the p/t/k sounds are usually pronounced with a puff of air (the difference between the "t" in "talk" and the "t" in "stalk") - many languages don't do that, but native Engilsh speakers don't notice we're doing it & it's hard to stop doing it, so he had to make Dothraki allow it too

  • @scikick
    @scikick 5 років тому +97

    Butterfly in Nepali is called 'putali'. And the female genitalia is called 'puti'. Now I'm no expert, but I think the elders were on to something here.

    • @leeahh747
      @leeahh747 5 років тому +2

      scikick in my language puti means white

    • @oxigen85
      @oxigen85 5 років тому +1

      Butterfly in Hungarian is "pillangó". The same word is used as a slang for hookers.

    • @TheHarpyen
      @TheHarpyen 4 роки тому

      I once spontaneously used mariposa del carne (butterfly of flesh) talking to a Spanish native speaker. He totally got it . 🤣 nepali rocks.

  • @danis7070
    @danis7070 5 років тому +15

    As a speech and language pathologist, this was very interesting to watch!

  • @GeneraNothing
    @GeneraNothing 5 років тому +7

    I can’t believe I got to meet this guy and get a picture and conversation with him when he came down to my college, UAB. He’s an absolute genius

  • @anamo123456789
    @anamo123456789 5 років тому +47

    We need a meeting of him and the vocal coach dude

  • @sofiamanolakis8214
    @sofiamanolakis8214 5 років тому +8

    In my 4th year of linguisitics and you reignited my love for it! Thanks!

  • @LaydayEruanna
    @LaydayEruanna 5 років тому +9

    I could listen to this guy teach all day. Please have more videos with him.
    I like the editing you do, too.

  • @estherd.b.16
    @estherd.b.16 5 років тому +6

    Last year, Peterson was a speaker at an event in Belgium which I attended. His talk was so interesting and inspiring. Fascinating stuff, linguistics and conlanging!

  • @JazzyFlo15
    @JazzyFlo15 2 роки тому +381

    "My largest language, Dothraki, has 4,000 words"
    And yet there's no word for "thank you"
    I love it 🤣

    • @MinMinn192
      @MinMinn192 Рік тому +59

      So not only did he create a made-up, realistic language, he injected it with made-up, realistic cultural context. Pretty impressive if you ask me.

    • @LeReubzRic
      @LeReubzRic 11 місяців тому +1

      English has, like, 100,000 words

    • @tristensanz7058
      @tristensanz7058 10 місяців тому +5

      ​@@LeReubzRic Yes, but most of that is jargon and very obscure stuff. 4000 words is around 95 percent of word we actually use day to day

    • @LeReubzRic
      @LeReubzRic 10 місяців тому

      @@tristensanz7058 ok

  • @ghasos
    @ghasos 5 років тому +13

    this is absolutely the coolest video i have ever watched THANK YOU

  • @Sporacle
    @Sporacle 5 років тому +92

    DId he say, Dothraki suberts the expectations?.... this thing runs deep

  • @yulana990
    @yulana990 5 років тому +43

    Yes! I was so fascinated finding out the Dothraki language that reminded me of persian and arabian was a constructed language, and immediately wanted to know more about David. So cool to see someone that like JRR created a language, but in modern time so I can actually get some tips 😂 Thanks for this video. I hope someday I can create a language aswell for my future stories.

  • @Yuni009
    @Yuni009 5 років тому +105

    This is sooo interesting!! I kinda wanna know more about languages and be friends with this man

    • @veggiesupreme3556
      @veggiesupreme3556 5 років тому +14

      it's cool to see someone so passionate about their profession

    • @Yuni009
      @Yuni009 5 років тому +2

      @@veggiesupreme3556 ive subscribed to his channel. It was real cool to learn some more about that and very jmpressive that he can tell apart different sounds when (for many people) our brains kinda go 'deaf' on sounds that are not part if our native language in our adult lives. I stan this man!

    • @kuro13wolf
      @kuro13wolf 5 років тому +4

      ​@@Yuni009 If you liked this you're gonna love their accent critique series that man is just as passionate and it also teaches you a lot about language.

    • @Yuni009
      @Yuni009 5 років тому

      @@kuro13wolf sweet! Ill defo check it out, thanks!! Bring on the smart side of me which wants to learn stuff instead of drinking.. yay!! 😂

    • @Yuni009
      @Yuni009 5 років тому

      @@Lightologyy haha not sure ho thatd go!

  • @StewartFletcher
    @StewartFletcher 5 років тому +65

    "He throat rip.
    She throat rip.
    They throat it."

  • @MoliSuper
    @MoliSuper 5 років тому +40

    Butterfly in Icelandic is "Fiðrildi" which literally means "a Feathered Creature".....I think

  • @외로운_무민
    @외로운_무민 5 років тому +18

    I’m starting my first year at university in a few months and I’ll be studying linguistics, so this video was particularly interesting and enjoyable for me. I especially liked the advice about studying unrelated languages since as a native speaker of Russian who is also studying English and Korean I can assure you that this recommendation is really good. Being immersed into these three completely different languages has definitely broadened my horizons!

    • @bds8715
      @bds8715 Рік тому

      How did your degree go? 🤔

    • @외로운_무민
      @외로운_무민 Рік тому +2

      @@bds8715 What a throwback! haha
      I now have a bachelor’s degree in linguistics (with honours :P) and I’ve recently started my master’s degree - linguistics as well. Oh, and I’ve added Swedish to my roster of languages, so that's been fun!

    • @bds8715
      @bds8715 Рік тому

      @@외로운_무민 wow that’s awesome! Congrats 🥳 My curiosity got the best of me 😆 If I were to study linguistics I think I’d study how different languages approach word class/parts of speech

  • @Curlzyness
    @Curlzyness 5 років тому +17

    Phonetics lesson by David J Peterson, I wish this was posted back when I was a 1st year student of English.

  • @mr.knightthedetective7435
    @mr.knightthedetective7435 5 років тому +44

    0:35 I once actually used a similar idea on my fanfic aliens. They were called Y'hmma and they spoke in sign languages. But not in a normal way, they could morph their fingers into strange symbols. Another thing about their sign language is that they are telepathic in nature. You would literally know what they meant to say if they morphed their fingers.

  • @Aravzil
    @Aravzil 5 років тому +9

    That was really interesting. Good simple editing too.

  • @katiee9152
    @katiee9152 2 роки тому +5

    I love this guy for creating the beautiful language for game of thrones ♥️

  • @takeapil4568
    @takeapil4568 5 років тому +972

    I'm just as confused as I was after watching this video

    • @girv98
      @girv98 5 років тому +18

      I'd suggest Artifexian and biblaridion. They go into it a bit more

    • @bb-cc8hh
      @bb-cc8hh 5 років тому +29

      You need to have studied different sub disciplines in Linguistics to fully understand everything he mentions.

    • @cogithefool4284
      @cogithefool4284 5 років тому +3

      @@LauM he doesn't even make an exhaustive IPA consonants. He put approximant for everything else.

    • @Luis_Domingos
      @Luis_Domingos 5 років тому +3

      @@cogithefool4284 I'm still looking for someone to tell me how I can make a glottal stop at the start of a word, I don't think my glottis works that way 😭🤣 And at least he didn't scare anyone with cases in Finnish and Hungarian - that's something they need to find on their own :D

    • @matthuckabey007
      @matthuckabey007 5 років тому +6

      Well, your English sucks so you do not have much hope to begin with.

  • @tristantaylor5214
    @tristantaylor5214 5 років тому +33

    ....Tolkien: "Hold my beer"

  • @roncom4321
    @roncom4321 5 років тому +252

    UA-cam Algorithm: *Hey, I know you've never watched anything GOT related here on youtube, but hey! I'mma shove this in your recommended anyway :)*

    • @YunisRajab
      @YunisRajab 5 років тому +4

      You know it's not just based on things you watch, right?

    • @6ixlxrd
      @6ixlxrd 5 років тому +4

      @@YunisRajab It's geared towards recommending you things similar or in the same genre as what you've watched. I watched a cooking video and the next minute Gordon Ramsay, Babish, and a lot of other chefs were in my recommended.

  • @VMRVid
    @VMRVid 5 років тому +27

    Him: I never have a favorite word in any language.
    Me: Schmetterling
    Him: Look up the word for butterfly.

  • @remis.4565
    @remis.4565 5 років тому +11

    I met this guy at UC Berkeley and he was amazing

  • @getcrafty8251
    @getcrafty8251 5 років тому +2

    He actually made this a lot easier for me to understand rather than the other YT videos I’ve watched. I shall go and continue my artlang :D

  • @caenieve
    @caenieve 4 роки тому +7

    This is basically a crash course in functional linguistics which I *love.*

  • @Yours_sincerely_thedreamer
    @Yours_sincerely_thedreamer 5 років тому +4

    I understood so much about languages listening to this! Thank you:)

  • @fb04
    @fb04 5 років тому +537

    When I saw the thumbnail I literally thought that that man was eating infinity stones... So yeah

    • @ronjayrose9706
      @ronjayrose9706 5 років тому +4

      😂😂😂😂

    • @RubikCJ
      @RubikCJ 5 років тому +18

      How else would a language be made?

    • @saraansari1394
      @saraansari1394 5 років тому +1

      Hahahahahah🤣🤣

    • @alisyed6809
      @alisyed6809 5 років тому

      This guy is also created the language of Valyrian

    • @lmaono8139
      @lmaono8139 5 років тому +1

      Evy stopppp omggggg😂😂😂😂

  • @sammy3212321
    @sammy3212321 5 років тому +37

    This guy took a hodgepodge of vocabulary and fabricated a rich and holistic conlang that remained true to the culture and tells a story of civilisation all on its own. Astounding dude.

  • @grex951
    @grex951 5 років тому +3

    This really did help alot. I've been so confused on how to make a language but this cleared up so much for me :)

  • @afrikasmith1049
    @afrikasmith1049 2 роки тому +2

    I recently read his book on creating a language. Didn't finish reading the book, but it was fascinating.

  • @m.coleman
    @m.coleman 5 років тому +18

    Speech-Language Pathologist, here! This was cool! 🥰 P.S. JUST found out about High Valyrian being on Duolingo! Off I go! 😁

  • @shyam8398
    @shyam8398 5 років тому +7

    I've see a few interviews with this guy I always find him fascinating I have absolutely no intentions of writing a language though

  • @dimaxbarnes6425
    @dimaxbarnes6425 4 роки тому +45

    The *r sound*
    David: I’m sorry for that one
    Spanish speakers: finally

    • @tommipeltovuori4869
      @tommipeltovuori4869 3 роки тому +5

      And finnish speakers

    • @Ignisan_66
      @Ignisan_66 3 роки тому +4

      And basically everyone else on the planet except native english speakers.

    • @cellularautomaton.
      @cellularautomaton. 2 роки тому +2

      @@Ignisan_66 actually, mandarin chinese doesn't have a trilled r either, and english and mandarin account for around a third of the earth's population

  • @pawprintz420
    @pawprintz420 3 роки тому +1

    i like this guy's face , he looks like he gives great hugs

  • @onem4040
    @onem4040 5 років тому +131

    More interesting than current season x)

    • @chelsey8737
      @chelsey8737 5 років тому

      Is it that bad? I dont watch got but all of the comments are saying stuff like this

    • @TBAYMenace
      @TBAYMenace 5 років тому

      @@chelsey8737 yeah the CGI was amazing but the writing was trash IMO

  • @syedimranali4429
    @syedimranali4429 5 років тому +13

    WOW. I was always wondering how did they created all of these languages e.g Avatar language or this Dothraki one. Amazingly creative process. No wonder why these sound so real.

  • @tyrant-den884
    @tyrant-den884 5 років тому +36

    In my D&D: goblins use a very basic Abjad, hobgoblins use a more comprehensive Abjad, and Bugbears have turned the goblin Abjad into an Abugida.

  • @ChelseaFCallday2
    @ChelseaFCallday2 5 років тому +1

    this stuff is so interesting, I love when you guys make videos like this

  • @stormblessed2321
    @stormblessed2321 5 років тому +92

    How do you say “the writers for Game of Thrones are incompetent morons” in Dothraki?

  • @dcphillips1991
    @dcphillips1991 5 років тому +2

    This is a really interesting video, you can tell the person knows there topic well and is passionate about it.

  • @omnitrix1992
    @omnitrix1992 5 років тому +9

    *gets casted in a Game of Thrones episode*
    "Hey casting director, who am i gonna be on the show?"
    "Oh, Head Dothraki ruler. Lots of speaking parts..."
    "... greaaaaat...."

  • @smallluigi3433
    @smallluigi3433 5 років тому +8

    3:10 that's the sound you make when somebody asks you a question you don't know the answer to

  • @michellestella7477
    @michellestella7477 5 років тому +16

    Wow this is a lot more complicated than I thought it would be 😶

  • @kirisuta8496
    @kirisuta8496 5 років тому +86

    Ah I’m glad I’m welsh - got brought up being able to make a lot of weird sounds. Like the rolling rs and the ch sounds and the ll sounds.
    It’s handy in that respect.

    • @timmsattler3414
      @timmsattler3414 5 років тому +3

      Kiri Suta i bet you cant pronounce Brötchen, it’s German

    • @Luis_Domingos
      @Luis_Domingos 5 років тому +3

      @@timmsattler3414 I bet you won't pronounce the word "ci" or "afan" right the first time (that's Welsh for "dog" and "raspberries", by the way). I don't even get me started with "cŵn" (dogs), "cwm" (valley), or "ysgol" (school). And those are all without the infamous LL.

    • @Luis_Domingos
      @Luis_Domingos 5 років тому +1

      LL is a thing of beauty, I tried learning a bit of Welsh on Duolingo once and everytime I listen to a Welsh speaker, it's one of the things I love the most :)

    • @MickeyCuervo36
      @MickeyCuervo36 5 років тому

      Dw in dysgi siarad Cymraeg. Still a beginner, but I hope to get better.

    • @Y.M...
      @Y.M... 5 років тому +3

      Arabic does most of these sounds, but some native African languages have really interesting sounds unlike anywhere else in the world. They use clicking and some tongue-snapping sounds as letters or words.

  • @aaronmyers6686
    @aaronmyers6686 5 років тому +4

    Even thought it's a very "you are your own worst critic" art, I believe that fictional lanugage construction doesn't get enough traction as a hobby or a job. You learn a lot of things about logic, human behavior, aestheticism and categorization, among other things.

  • @luisasantana1827
    @luisasantana1827 5 років тому +2

    As a linguistic student and got fan, this is just fantastic.

  • @Rhasher
    @Rhasher 5 років тому +13

    As a Linguistics student, this video is awesome

  • @echo_8741
    @echo_8741 5 років тому +1

    I met him in real life. I went to the school and my principals son was him. It was so cool of him explaining everything. And I got his autograph. YAY

  • @balthasarrasahtlab8872
    @balthasarrasahtlab8872 5 років тому +4

    05:10 When he said "Subverting expectations" I flinched hard

  • @Noviosity
    @Noviosity 5 років тому +2

    Recently studied linguistics...and recently binged watched GOT.
    My prof told me how well paid a job working with/in the entertainment industry... Watching this makes sense. Much creative

  • @Peter_1986
    @Peter_1986 Рік тому +3

    I have been making up words for an own language for some time, but I have been extremely slow, and probably made up like 3-4 words per year, lol.
    I am quite content with a lot of the words though, and I feel that they capture the "spirit" of each meaning quite well;
    a few words are "linya" ("soft"), "hakka" ("hard"), "rayo" ("anger"), "lauro" ("fire"), "rasto" ("rope"), and "lóryo" ("circle"), and also a bunch of colours, such as "ranya" ("red"), "lilya" ("yellow"), "cagalya" ("green"), "lúnya" ("blue"), "lonya" ("purple"), and "ninya" ("pink").

  • @sho0oka
    @sho0oka 5 років тому +2

    love him! as a Japanese student I can tell his inspired by it very much これ それ あれ

  • @tomifamadewa7980
    @tomifamadewa7980 5 років тому +16

    Omg He mentioned Hausa! I’m Nigerian we speak it here

  • @rotem..
    @rotem.. 5 років тому +2

    Oh my this was incredibly interesting. This guy is amazing.

  • @x0xTHLover4Lifex0x
    @x0xTHLover4Lifex0x 5 років тому +3

    This man is brilliant. I've been working on my own language for about four years now and he has been inspiration

  • @oliverchannelle6919
    @oliverchannelle6919 5 років тому +2

    Oh hey, that's The Art of Language Invention on the table! That's kind of the book that got me into conlanging, it's essentially the contents of this video but more in depth so if anyone bere wanted to learn more I'd really recommend getting a copy.

  • @RobertShaverOfAustin
    @RobertShaverOfAustin 5 років тому +34

    The concepts in a society also shape the expression in the language ... or is it the other way around? Think of a society that has no concept of subjugation. Which of these sentences would fit that society?
    1. "I rode the horse across the stream."
    2. "The horse and I crossed the stream together."

    • @sergiosanchez7935
      @sergiosanchez7935 2 роки тому +2

      Possibly the first one as it seems clear to me that when one rides a horse the "agency of the act", so to say, belongs to the rider - as he is the one controlling the horse.
      The fact that their society has "no concept of subjugation" shouldn't really interfere with the fact that "riding a horse" essentially means that you, on the horse, command it to move in some direction. So saying "we moved together" would be ambiguous and transmit incomplete information as it is not specifying that you are actually riding the horse (it could mean for example that you found a friendly horse and you both went for a walk, using your own feet).
      And if you consider that their society is simply unable to understand subjugation to the point where they aren't able to ride horses or express that someone is riding a horse, then I guess there aren't many good arguments one can make about one of the sentences over the other.

  • @rileydoolittle5324
    @rileydoolittle5324 5 років тому

    I have no clue what he is talking about but I can’t stop watching it

  • @ipwnyoudiehaha
    @ipwnyoudiehaha 5 років тому +3

    If only they put this much effort into season 8 * praying for tonight's finale *

  • @benwebster6563
    @benwebster6563 5 років тому

    This is the coolest video on UA-cam rn

  • @alexthomson6430
    @alexthomson6430 5 років тому +11

    I find this so amazing. We at once point could never have understood one another. And now google can translate your language into another and you can send that in an email to your friend in China and have a conversation. Technology is incredible

  • @Pretendship
    @Pretendship 5 років тому +1

    this was fascinating, get this guy on again! 10/10

  • @acediadekay3793
    @acediadekay3793 5 років тому +39

    A butterfly in Danish is "En Sommerfugl" => "A Summer Bird"

    • @littlemissdeel7231
      @littlemissdeel7231 5 років тому +4

      Same in Norwegian. And then Sweden goes and ruins this family again....

    • @olivier9751
      @olivier9751 5 років тому

      Spurgt

    • @freyjasvansdottir9904
      @freyjasvansdottir9904 5 років тому +2

      Acedia DeKay In icelandic a butterfly is Fiðrildi, a living feather!

    • @adamclark1972uk
      @adamclark1972uk 5 років тому +2

      The Russian for ladybird is God's little cow

    • @blacktesseract3798
      @blacktesseract3798 5 років тому +2

      In German it's "Schmetterling" literally "flutterling"

  • @Hoswendt
    @Hoswendt 5 років тому +1

    As a linguist, I find it fascinating and fresh.

  • @Jort419
    @Jort419 5 років тому +541

    How to create a language
    _Swollow all the infinity Stones_ (1:42)

    • @Robin-eq7uz
      @Robin-eq7uz 5 років тому +3

      😂😂😂

    • @multiversescriptutes8400
      @multiversescriptutes8400 5 років тому +4

      Infinity War and Endgame SUCK. Don't remind people of those abominal bastardization of Marvel comic's characters.

    • @multiversescriptutes8400
      @multiversescriptutes8400 5 років тому

      @Jamie Baxter Umm..... Wait what? Core muscles.... When did i ever mention anything about core muscles?

    • @Hapetiitti
      @Hapetiitti 5 років тому +5

      @@multiversescriptutes8400 you typoed "abominal" into "abdominal"

    • @multiversescriptutes8400
      @multiversescriptutes8400 5 років тому

      @@Hapetiitti Oops thanks for this.

  • @cameronthomas3398
    @cameronthomas3398 3 роки тому +1

    I dont know when that clip thing got added to UA-cam but that's madd smart

  • @NoseyNana
    @NoseyNana 5 років тому +37

    If you really want to study how languages are created, find sets of twins or triplets, etc. that are just beginning to talk. My twins took up a language of their own, as 'multiples' are known to do, commonly called twin talk. Trust me, they knew exactly what they were saying & their language took off at twice the speed compared to talking to others. I quickly put them into a pre-preschool, so their twin talk didn't hamper their actual language skills further. Otherwise, they'd be known all their life as Bunga & Wahgee :)

    • @Luis_Domingos
      @Luis_Domingos 5 років тому +4

      That's not really the point of this video: we are talking about artificial language creation, not child language acquisition (which would probably be more in the ballpark of a behavioral linguist or neurolinguist specialized in infant development). I can be just as interesting a topic - and one that can provide clues as to how languages emerge and evolve, which is fairly important for linguists of all stripes - but there's no need to choose one over the other. Knowledge doesn't take up space (or so my language says) :)

  • @anaismca
    @anaismca 5 років тому

    This is literally the coolest video I’ve ever seen

  • @spectrls
    @spectrls 5 років тому +62

    what's dothraki for "my expectations were subverted"

  • @ianthe.w
    @ianthe.w 5 років тому

    as a linguistics student, this was the best video I've had recommended to me in a while

  • @SlipFlip
    @SlipFlip 5 років тому +4

    I'd love to hear this guy analyse amd explain Greenlandic language!!

  • @DhavalShukla
    @DhavalShukla 5 років тому +2

    After you watch this video you get to learn it literally, "this guy's a genius."

  • @Mara-fh1gf
    @Mara-fh1gf 4 роки тому +3

    He also created Trig, the language of the grounders in the CW series, The 100❤️

  • @kingbrago
    @kingbrago 4 роки тому

    My head hurts more than a hangover after watching this video.
    I understood nothing but still feel kinda more sophisticated than before.

  • @rootednewt3262
    @rootednewt3262 5 років тому +8

    12:46 "Japanese and Turkish... completely unrelated" ALTAICISM INTENSIFIES

  • @stormking989
    @stormking989 5 років тому +1

    I'm writing down all the cliff notes. I actually made up my own language for a fantasy novel, I was working on. It was a magic language.