Video clip of the best passage of the film, for me, "Good bye, Lenin". A film by Wolfgang Becker, with music by Yann Tiersen ... Don't hesitate to follow me ! www.benoitbeal...
This movie isn't about just capitalism and socialism. It's about what a son can do for his mother. Create a fantasy just for protect who loves. Nothing can explain the love of a son for his mother. ❤️
All this people praising lenin didn't understand the true meaning of the movie. imo it's not about politics but how the strugle between the east and west affected the common people of germany.
Where are you from and how old are you? You don't know the shit about that terrible era. I am 46, I grew up in the USSR and I am happy that it's over. Lenin was a murderer.
Rivero Montara dito, auch wenn man hier und da kleine Patzer eingebaut hat (Der Abbau der Leninstatue, war erst im November 1991, im Film ist es aber 1990 als die Statue weggeflogen wird, siehe Video)
@@BenoitBeal GDR? The English acronym for DDR! Never heard that _Deutsche Demokratische Republik_ is simply _German Democratic Republic_ in English? And BRD is FRG (Federal Rep. ...🤷🏻♀️
@@meanE90 Forgive me, how is that possible?! Have you had family in the old GDR? Given that you were already born in 1989, all that changed for you after the GDR people overthrew a dictatorship with nothing but a candle in their hand was your postal code! Excuse me for using clichés, I'd be happy to hear you bear upon the old GDR and hopefully today's East as well, it's just that I've spent many vacations with both young and old West Germans, from Neufriesland, to the Schwarzwald and the Alpenvorland - it's been shocking to realize they usually can't even tell how many new Länder there are, yet alone what NVA means (the problem not being that they don't know but that they couldn't care less)! 🤷🏻♀️ FYI: To answer your question, some people tend to say Goodbye Lenin is nothing but a nostalgic sugarcoated version of GDR reality with all its rituals and symbols whereas I think the young protagonist displays more of an ironic GDR resumé. I mean, the history twist with FRG refugees deciding to abandon capitalism - As he sums up towards the end, the GDR he presents to his mother is a country that never existed but certainly one he would have liked to see grow. That comes with a sad undertone, yet this whole _Lenin waves Goodbye_ scene is so over the top that you'd laugh in tears if the score weren't so moving. So, that's just my point of view. 🤷🏻♀️ I'm far from saying GDR nostalgia is nonsense, I was born after 1989 and I feel it sometimes. Afterall, socialist brainwashing wasn't all the country brought about. In fact quite a few GDR concepts would be of great use for the old AND THE CURRENT FRG (children's daycare, training/apprenticeship system, ecological agriculture, systematic social integration of migrant workers, equal pay, sports/arts/science founding)!
even me, as a far right person I find this scene emotional, it's sure, the end of a tyrannical regime but ...it was a part of these people's lives that ends. It's a liberation, a turning of a page.
Lenin is hero of all workers even you should workshop Lenin because this is the man who had introduced 8hour work, pay for over work, pension, benifits, medical insurance for all workers....... I'm. Not a commie but I just love Lenin due to his equal rights and thus man had given equal rights to women too
Mr Leprechaun Compared to members of the Russian Orthodox Church, the Muslims of the Soviet Union were initially given more religious autonomy. This was in contrast to life under the Tsars, when Muslims were suppressed and the Eastern Orthodox Church was the official state religion. On 24 November 1917, weeks after the October revolution, the Bolsheviks issued an appeal to 'All the Muslim Workers of Russia and the East'.[4] Lenin declared; Muslims of Russia…all you whose mosques and prayer houses have been destroyed, whose beliefs and customs have been trampled upon by the tsars and oppressors of Russia: your beliefs and practices, your national and cultural institutions are forever free and inviolate. Know that your rights, like those of all the peoples of Russia, are under the mighty protection of the revolution.[5] Lenin even oversaw the return of certain religious artifacts such as the Uthman Quran.[5] Furthermore, some principles of Islamic law were instituted alongside the Communist legal system,[5] Jadids and other "Islamic socialists" were given positions of power within the government,[5] and an affirmative action system called "korenizatsiya" (nativisation) was implemented to help local Muslim populations.[5] Friday, the Muslim Sabbath, was declared a legal day of rest throughout Central Asia.[5] Hahahahahah lenin only had a problem with regressive fantasist christian cross worship along with death worship nonsensical and illogical communion and the veneration of dead saints and the attribution of miraculous powers to dead bodies and bones lol
This is the iconic scene. Lenin truncated floating in mid-air flying through the sky ! The end of that historic illusion of ...oh .. socialism ! OMG ! Noone uses that word anywhere now! What a F*** was old Lenin and his revolution. 😂 . I am glad that the worst century in human history is over( hopefully).
2024 and I’m still here loving this
An epic scene of one of my favorite movies. Love this film and the actors.
This movie isn't about just capitalism and socialism.
It's about what a son can do for his mother.
Create a fantasy just for protect who loves.
Nothing can explain the love of a son for his mother. ❤️
You’re right, love is over all !
Exactly. Genau. A film about a son who wanted more than anything to do the right thing by his mother.
Thank you for uploading this video, it's by far the most strong and symbolic of the film. Simply amazing...
thank you !
To wake up one day and realize the world wasn't what you thought. Lot of people need this. Goodbye
there is a movie called :"Look Who's Back" it is Adolf H. returning in 2014 in Germany... Check out this ! bye
Great scene this. Love the floating Lenin. Funny, evocative and oddly touching.
my opinion too. I made this only for this memorial action
You love the thig this clip is about. Thanks for noticing. Take a Molotov out of petty cash.
Amazing
Very emotive 😢😢
Beste Szene! ;)
Damn. Damn. Damn. Lenin will be back.
Tony Smith no he won't
All this people praising lenin didn't understand the true meaning of the movie. imo it's not about politics but how the strugle between the east and west affected the common people of germany.
I cried about this scene. Lenin was such an amazing human, hope we had someone like him today
Carolina Silva thank you for your touching words !
@Michael VR well lenin was a good man but his ideology was used by terror stalin
What?? OMG you doesn’t know what you’re saying
@Abel Vermont No u
Where are you from and how old are you? You don't know the shit about that terrible era. I am 46, I grew up in the USSR and I am happy that it's over. Lenin was a murderer.
Ein großartiger Film.
Rivero Montara dito, auch wenn man hier und da kleine Patzer eingebaut hat (Der Abbau der Leninstatue, war erst im November 1991, im Film ist es aber 1990 als die Statue weggeflogen wird, siehe Video)
Let's not forget that this film and particularly this scene doesn't really romanticize GDR reality, this whole nostalgia is full of irony!
Vicky 12 What means GDR ?
@@BenoitBeal GDR? The English acronym for DDR! Never heard that _Deutsche Demokratische Republik_ is simply _German Democratic Republic_ in English? And BRD is FRG (Federal Rep. ...🤷🏻♀️
Vicky 12 thank ! Yes I know that but this vision is deeper without !
Vicky 12 Why would this scene be Ironic? I live in the south in Munich, and even I got nostalgia with the DDR.
@@meanE90 Forgive me, how is that possible?! Have you had family in the old GDR? Given that you were already born in 1989, all that changed for you after the GDR people overthrew a dictatorship with nothing but a candle in their hand was your postal code! Excuse me for using clichés, I'd be happy to hear you bear upon the old GDR and hopefully today's East as well, it's just that I've spent many vacations with both young and old West Germans, from Neufriesland, to the Schwarzwald and the Alpenvorland - it's been shocking to realize they usually can't even tell how many new Länder there are, yet alone what NVA means (the problem not being that they don't know but that they couldn't care less)! 🤷🏻♀️
FYI: To answer your question, some people tend to say Goodbye Lenin is nothing but a nostalgic sugarcoated version of GDR reality with all its rituals and symbols whereas I think the young protagonist displays more of an ironic GDR resumé. I mean, the history twist with FRG refugees deciding to abandon capitalism - As he sums up towards the end, the GDR he presents to his mother is a country that never existed but certainly one he would have liked to see grow. That comes with a sad undertone, yet this whole _Lenin waves Goodbye_ scene is so over the top that you'd laugh in tears if the score weren't so moving. So, that's just my point of view. 🤷🏻♀️ I'm far from saying GDR nostalgia is nonsense, I was born after 1989 and I feel it sometimes. Afterall, socialist brainwashing wasn't all the country brought about. In fact quite a few GDR concepts would be of great use for the old AND THE CURRENT FRG (children's daycare, training/apprenticeship system, ecological agriculture, systematic social integration of migrant workers, equal pay, sports/arts/science founding)!
It brings back the memories...
Thank you for that.
In Memory of DDR
Why does lenin look like he bout to roast somebody
Krzyształ Błyszczący he gonna roast the tsar
Wonderful scene about the end of sovietc comunism.
This is what I call a motif for cognitive dissonance.
This is what I call a recipe for macaroni sauerkraut salad. Maybe we're both right.
Or just you.
World need a Lenin.
I agree Lenin is the best
Make that two!
May Karl Marx Lenin and Joseph Stalin all rot in hell
We got Putin and Emperor Xi, now you see what happens.
@@cykablyatifulscheisse Putin is not socialist.
even me, as a far right person I find this scene emotional, it's sure, the end of a tyrannical regime but ...it was a part of these people's lives that ends. It's a liberation, a turning of a page.
Silver Spoon you’re right !
Benoit Beal Badum Tss
Oh hay, Dark Doomer!
@@octaviondeminicolas1941 Yep, now you know what scene inspired me to draw this!~
"Far-right"
So 14 year old who browsed too much /pol/?
Lenin is hero of all workers even you should workshop Lenin because this is the man who had introduced 8hour work, pay for over work, pension, benifits, medical insurance for all workers....... I'm. Not a commie but I just love Lenin due to his equal rights and thus man had given equal rights to women too
@Michael VR I think the Soviet Union under Lenin was among the earliest countries which decriminalized homosexuality. Stalin criminalized it later.
Lenin was a dictator that tried to make his people happy
Stalin was a dictator that tried to make himself happy
Goodbye, Lenin. Hello, Alah. Germany is over.
Victor Lima it's not over until I say it's over
Mr Leprechaun there would be no need for terrorism as lenin approved of sharia law
Mr Leprechaun Compared to members of the Russian Orthodox Church, the Muslims of the Soviet Union were initially given more religious autonomy. This was in contrast to life under the Tsars, when Muslims were suppressed and the Eastern Orthodox Church was the official state religion. On 24 November 1917, weeks after the October revolution, the Bolsheviks issued an appeal to 'All the Muslim Workers of Russia and the East'.[4] Lenin declared;
Muslims of Russia…all you whose mosques and prayer houses have been destroyed, whose beliefs and customs have been trampled upon by the tsars and oppressors of Russia: your beliefs and practices, your national and cultural institutions are forever free and inviolate. Know that your rights, like those of all the peoples of Russia, are under the mighty protection of the revolution.[5]
Lenin even oversaw the return of certain religious artifacts such as the Uthman Quran.[5] Furthermore, some principles of Islamic law were instituted alongside the Communist legal system,[5] Jadids and other "Islamic socialists" were given positions of power within the government,[5] and an affirmative action system called "korenizatsiya" (nativisation) was implemented to help local Muslim populations.[5] Friday, the Muslim Sabbath, was declared a legal day of rest throughout Central Asia.[5]
Hahahahahah lenin only had a problem with regressive fantasist christian cross worship along with death worship nonsensical and illogical communion and the veneration of dead saints and the attribution of miraculous powers to dead bodies and bones lol
That E30 though lol
shingo's gumtape what means E30?
Benoit Beal Designer Image & Creation The chassis code of the silver BMW from 1:25
ESA NO ES LA MUSICO
Why you put this piano music here? That ruin the scene :/
This is the music from this movie. I have synchronized that in the perfect moment ! BR
This is the iconic scene. Lenin truncated floating in mid-air flying through the sky ! The end of that historic illusion of ...oh .. socialism ! OMG ! Noone uses that word anywhere now!
What a F*** was old Lenin and his revolution. 😂 . I am glad that the worst century in human history is over( hopefully).
Viva la libertad occidental... No más experimentos socialistas
Viva la occidental... viva Trump, Boris Johnson, Le Pen, Bolsonaro, Ucrânia nazi? Viva? Jajajaja