DeWalt vs Hercules Circular Saw Exhaustive Comparison - E152
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
- Bryce gets a Hercules Saw from Harbor Freight and compares it to a FlexVolt DeWalt Circular Saw. Which is better? We show you all the angles in this video from price to cutting hardwood! The results were unsettling to me.
Tell us your results and expectations from either Hercules or DeWalt tools. Is one better than the other in your experience?
It’s a little long but here are chapters if you want to skip:
Introduction 00:00
Both Saws comparison 05:55
Cost 07:17
Batteries 07:54
Saw Weight 10:22
Battery Weight 12:13
Weight winner 13:03
Clarity of Marks 13:28
Blade Change 14:39
Features 16:56
Build Quality 20:59
Warranty 23:07
Hardwood Sawing 24:23
Accuracy of Marks to Blade 27:39
Accuracy of Angles 29:52
Braking 32:14
Final Scores 32:43
Ripping and Cutting 36:19
Conclusion 39:11
Final Note 42:11
Thanks for your comments and ideas! Take care and God Bless! - Навчання та стиль
![ПОЛНАЯ ИСТОРИЯ ЭКЗОРЦИЗМА [Топ Сикрет]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBySr6Bt0B8/mqdefault.jpg)
My only issue is that you're trying to compare a 60 volt saw to 20 volt saw. Of course 60 volt saw would be better power wise. Also the Dewalt battery would be heavier because it's a larger battery. So really it seems a waste to compare the two knowing that they are hugely different to begin with. A very detailed review though. I do appreciate that.
yeah. that's the "extremely biased" part of the review. You learn pretty quickly how to use the Hercules and it does cut better straighter as in it's less of a struggle to get it to cut straight.
Thank you for pointing this out!
@@PeaceIntheValley The power difference isn't really a bias though; the more powerful saw cuts more easily and is therefore "better" in that regard.
An example of bias might be claiming one saw is better due to already being invested in that saw's battery type -a preference based on something other than a fair comparison.
Your review is very informative and very helpful.
I agree
I used my friends Hercules when I was helping him with a project but he had a Diablo blade in it instead of Hercules. I don’t know who makes their blades. It also had an 8 amp battery in it. Ran great.
For a homeowner the Hercules deals are impossible to beat. Bought a 5Amp
Battery and charger for $99 with the latest Deal and got a $139 cordless grease gun for free. Father’s Day deals I will pick up the circular saw.
Let me know how the grease gun works. I have the DeWalt version, but real interested in the HF model.
I have never once thought about the slickness of the batteries lol.
I never did either until I got the Hercules and realized they don't slip near as much.
For me, the battery longevity and durability are a huge part of the equation. I very rarely notice the difference between the cordless tools. Most of the time, I don’t do precision work or work with hardwoods with my cordless tools. The batteries are very expensive and it is a hardship when they drop to little capacity or die.
I have the exact same Dewalt saw ,I am a contractor, this saw has revolutionised my work.
The saw ways less with the 6 amp battery than my blade right corded Skilsaw .A true professional never uses the marks on the base to align cuts ,the Dewalt has excellent views down the left and right sides of the blade ,you always look at the blade to do the cut ! The Hercules has bad sightlines down the blade and is only a handy man's saw .
Excellent review. The real world test was enlightening.
Thank you! Real world tests are what matters compared to the specs.
I have the Hercules saw as well as one from Bauer. I use and like both of them a lot. If you use the 4, 8, or 12ah Hercules batteries you will get greater performance from it. Dollars spent to value, it's hard to beat the Hercules stuff. Great review
Thank you for the great video. These saws are in two different classes. That being said the Hercules did everything you would need to do and more. And when you compare cost of tool cost of batteries and warranty. The Hercules is a clear winner. Only time will tell if it has the durability. And the best part is if you want to get their biggest battery, the 12 amp. It only cost $130.
Great video, I wonder if you use the 8 or 12 ah Hercules battery if it would make it through your stump
As far as the thumb safety having used both I think there’s is a definite advantage to the Hercules as it is much easier to depress the safety with gloved hands especially insulated gloves
Congratulations on on 1k subs!!!👍🏻🥳👍🏻
thanks for being one of the subscribers! ☺
Imo I don't think many cordless saws compare with the DeWalt 60V...its a beast like you said. 60V is usually for lawn equipment etc. The Hercules does match well with other 20v tools. The extreme Herc. batteries also use physically larger, higher quality cells so they do distribute more power.
For me the Circ Saw isnt the standout of the Hercules line (probably Impact Driver or Ultra Torque), I expect them to release a new version.
Also there is a Beam Cutter attachment for the Hercules that basically turns it into a chainsaw. That might help for what you were trying to do.
Loved the comparison. I’m about to by the Hercules after your review. The stump cut test and others would have been interesting if both saws were running the same blade. Just a thought. I will probably go with the 8 ah battery at a minimum
i did actually swap blades to see if it would make any difference and it didn't seem to make any difference. Even though I have both and the DeWalt is more powerful, I do like the balance and the hook of the Hercules. i don't think you will be disappointed with Hercules.
I have the Hercules saw and I run it with the 4ah extreme performance batteries. The 21700 Samsung cells in those just has a better discharge rate. I am looking to get that flexvolt saw though. I have a ton of flexvolt batteries now and need things to use them with.
TorqueTest said in a Very Rare out right recommendation to go run and get the 60v flexvolt saw
Good insight. Bottom line is if your a regular home owner and use the saw for projects, is the lower cost the tie breaker.
I don't disagree with that. In fact for pretty much everything it would work great. I didn't mention this but Hercules is quieter.
Off topic but do you get any condensation issues on your tools being in an uninsulated garage? I do.
I have never had any problems with condensation in my garage. The most I'll get is on the concrete floor on high humid or rainy days.
I've recently bought two Hercules tools the multi-tool and the brushless recip saw. Hercules will get the job done and their batteries have a pretty good life but they're a bit underpowered. But honestly they offer such a wide variety of tools you could equip your entire shop with their 20 volt lineup. I see no need in getting their ported products though. I'm a new DIY but for some reason I keep wanting to invest in Makita 40 volt system
Woohoo. Finally made 1K subs. 🥳🥳🥳
Thanks for being one of the subscribers! ☺
Good video. I thought you would've tried to cut a post top about shoulder height or higher for a test. That would still be interesting.
You are right since that is what I was saying it was the reason for buying a new one! It will get used for that soon when we start the RV shelter in KY!
That is the exact reason I don't go to Lowe's anymore. I've had too many of those experiences.
I have a 20v 7 1/4 dewalt as well. DCS570. It also likes to stall out and flash the battery light at me. It has the same issues with the lines not being accurate on it. Think I'm going to get a hercules. Maybe also get a 6 1/2" saw.
if you get that, post your thoughts compared to the DeWalt
You may want to throw on a Makita Carbide-Tipped Max Efficiency blade on the Hercules. Might see some improvement in performance. I think the performance choke point is in the blade.
I switched blades with the DeWalt just to try and see if that was the difference but the Hercules is still under powered. It stops quite a bit. I still like it, especially the rafter hook! I may have to try that Makita blade! Thankyou for the suggestion!
@@PeaceIntheValley sure thing! Just saw some surprising test results on the Makita blade that made a difference in cutting.
I agree a better blade may help the Hercules, still would say for the heavier stuff I would just grab a corded saw because the flexvolt batteries cost as much as a corded saw.
I use converters for my 20v dewalt batteries in a HF tool i only need for occasional use.
where do you get those?
@@PeaceIntheValley Amazon has the Bauer ones, I believe Ebay may be the best place for Hercules.
@@PeaceIntheValley ua-cam.com/users/shortsPkfLRfjqRnE?si=pSsAAkRtCCXo7Aas
This guy's using the Bauer one I have.
I just purchased this saw, well saw, battery, charger combp yesterday. So I want to add a few things in the comments. One for $99.99 this is a hard to beat deal period, Second having not used the saw yet I don't know how long it will last. But I am just a handiman howmowner, so I dont think it is ever going to see job site professional work. On that note I am surprised on its construction, the Magnesium shoe and guards I did not expect and that the shoe is not just flat but has webbing in it for rigidity is also unexpected. But now to the discussed battery. 60 volt vs 20 volt is like it was said Apples to Oranges. Secondly the AHr rating and more so the peak discharge rate are the big determinaters here. It is not likely the saw shutting down but the battery. The batteries have a BMS and it determines the peak charge, discharge, and safe voltages. That said, the lesser battery likely has a lesser peak current till shutdown, also is it may also have a lesser avg current rate so the saw will not get the power it may want. I will be soon starting some summer projects and will repost my findings.
Good review! I am more of a corded person. I have the Milwaukee corded circular saw and the corded Skil Worm saw, but I looking at getting the Hercules cordless for quick easy jobs.
Well wasn't happy with at first you comparing a 60 to a 20 wasn't thrilled. But you did a real review I skimmed some tho. But the dewalt is a good brand won't lie but I'm harbor frieght guy I feel they can do same jobs. But there should be a way to fix the blade issue on the dewalt.
yeah. I figured it was better to do what I considered a real world test. It's not apples to apples, and there are other channels that do that. However, it is what I would do in real life, especially how I have so many DeWalt tools. I know some people, by the comments, don't like that i'm comparing that but that's okay. The average guy is going to compare them because they are both 7.25" circular saws doing the exact same job, not so much the voltage.
Did the Dewalt come with dust collection?
No it did not but I think it has a port to hookup your vaccuum. Not sure though. i have to go and look.
Should have used the same blade for both.
When i started investing in power tools i lived right around the corner from a home depot. They sell ryobi, which has a great line of power tools. I went with them mostly due to proximity and convenience, but have never been let down and will continue to stick with them.
Absolutely. The batteries are costly and it's a chicken and egg conundrum. .
Note: Stores are obligated by law to Observe posted sales signs even if they've expired period it's on the store to remove the signage. Or be forced to honor the sale price... I think that's a federal rule and not state
I bought all the tools from Harbor freight, both Bauer and Hercules.If you want a pro grade tools buy DeWalt they are way better... but I don't have DeWalt money.the 25 cordless tools I bought from Harbor freight and the 12 batteries and 4 chargers would have cost me... Thousands of dollars more. So for me Harbor freight is the best choice. If my tools break down the road I'm not out much money. With the deals I got, might have paid 40. dollars a tool.campared to 100 bucks or more for DeWalt.
I have to agree with you. I think the DeWalt tools overall are built better. However, the newest Hercules Impact driver is better than my DeWalt. I suspect the next cordless circular saw will improve too.
I mean a felxvolt battery versus a standard 5ah battery should've used at least the 8 Ah Extreme Performance Battery on the hercules
agreed. Unfortunately HF wouldn't let me upgrade to the two 8AH batteries and pay them more for the same deal. I did recently get the 8AH battery, though, and will see if it makes a difference. If it does, I'll do a video update. Also, I don't think the warranty is 5 years as stated in the video. The paperwork that came with it said 90 days.
While I wouldn't expect any 20V saw to compare on performance to a 60V saw, I would say that the Hercules saw does very well in the 20V space. To be truly fair to Hercules, it would be best to compare with 20V saws of its competitors. I believe the Hercules will hold its own when compared with other 20V saws.
This video does well to illustrate the strengths of both saws, as well as their weaknesses. These saws target different segments of the customer pool, so I think this video will help people figure out which market segment they are most interested in, and thus, which saw would be better for that reason. While both are cordless saws, the DeWalt is the one I would say is most likely to perform on par with a corded tool. I believe that to obtain that level of performance from Hercules would require the use of the corded Hercules saw.
An s10 vs a full size Silverado in a towing challenge. Of course you know what has more power. At 60 volts it's 3x as much ad the harbor freight
I'm HEAVILY invested in dewalt. Im a homeowner thats pretty handy. I have a line of tools that'd outfit most professionals nicely. I tell ya.. if i had to start over, I'd be buying Hercules and Bauer. I did just pick up the Bauer brad nailer. Got it for 90 bucks with a 5 ah battery and charger. I think the DeWalt is like 250 bare tool.
That's kind of what got me started too. Buy a battery - get a tool. Can't complain about the impact driver at all. It's very powerful. Just built a building in Kentucky with it, and the DeWalt driver.
Flexvolt battery is not an equivalent comparison to the Hercules battery. Also is that an actual Flexvolt Saw as well, again not a fair comparison on power.
Great video can you do a video with the Hercules and the Craftsman 20 volt 7 1/4 inch battery-operated circular saw that would be awesome can you do a video like that please put this video was great great detail great content great job
Always buy tools on sell, like when you can get a free tool with purchase of a battery, etc. It took me about a year to get all the tools I wanted but I rarely bought anything until it was on sale.
Exactly right! Watch the HF fliers and you can get free batteries or tools with a battery purchase regularly!
Bauer is the lite , like the smaller circ saw it's 6 1/2 inch blade.
Bauer has the same 7 1/4" saw as this. The only difference is a few cosmetics.
I suspect the Hercules 5AH battery still using older 18600 cells. Their 4AH ("Extreme") use the newer 21700 (something like that) cells. Am DIYer and have been pretty much all Dewalt, until recently. The price for Hercules battery + charger + tool is less than price of Dewalt tool itself. I have both Dewalt and Hercules impact driver and feel the Hercules battery goes down faster. In terms of power/speed, Dewalt feel more powerful, but for me, not significantly enough for me to buy another Dewalt. On other hand, Dewalt tools have been very reliable so not expecting to need to replace any time soon. Not a pro so I'm not using the power tools daily or even weekly. If I were a pro, heck I may buy TWO Hercules, just in case one breaks because I know I can take broken one to HB and just replace it. Have never had a Dewalt break so not sure how the warranty work there.
All good points. I have the DeWalt Driver and Hercules Driver and the Hercules is quite a bit more powerful. Perhaps it's because my DeWalt is older?? The battery is not bad on either. I can go a half day of solid driving with the Hercules battery. Probably not quite as long as the DeWalt but I'm also driving more screws. It will get hot too putting in the 5" screws attaching the purlins to the trusses. I am a little disappointed in the circular saw power but I suspect they'll be updating it soon too like they did the impact driver.
Great video man.
I dont even bother with the 5ah on my hercules circ/recip saws, I use an 8ah. Those black 5ah batteries are worse than the old blue ones, they use cheaper no name cells vs the samsung cells on the blue batteries.
The 8ah battery doesnt heat up as much as the 5ah and you get a noticeable boost in power. I'm not sure if the comparison is exactly fair 60v vs 20v, also do the dewalt flex batteries have 21700 cells or 18650 cells. I know the hercules 5ah has 18650 cells, the 4ah/8ah/12ah do have 21700 cells.
Theres no doubt in my mind that dewalt makes a great saw and is more powerful but many times I'm up in the air and it's nice to have a rafter hook.
I'd swap the hercules 12v 2ah battery for a 4ah, there's enough of a difference in power that makes it worth upgrading for as little as $24.99 when on sale.
That's interesting to know the 5v are not quite up to the task because of the internals. I just saw a project farm video demonstrating that same thing with the no name batteries for Milwaukee. They would die much faster and didn't have the power. I'll get the 8AH and see how what difference it might make.
I'll take the Hercules with the 8ah battery because I don't plan on cutting through a log anytime soon 😅
I use both regularly. It lets me keep one on site and one in the shop! either way I've got something!
Dewalt was built for the professional (power & endurance). Hercules was built for the DiY (features & comfort).
Hercules is the more practical Purchase with the 8 or 12 amp hr.
I agree completely. It works well so far. and the marks are accurate. Time will tell on durability. It does cutout way more than it should though.
You are comparing apples to oranges with regard to cut speed. 60v saw versus a 20v? Of course the 20v saw did not cut as quickly. I’d be shocked if it did.
yeah. that's the "extremely biased" part of the review. Even so, I thought it would be able to cut through, just slower. It's still a decent saw.
@@PeaceIntheValley IMO that comes off as extremely disingenuous and intentionally misleading viewers. Due to your bias toward DeWalt you intentionally setup your "review" to purposely misrepresent the Hercules product by comparing it's 20v saw to DeWalt's 60v. You've admitted such in several of your replies. Your video here is why people can't trust youtube reviews anymore.
Just sayin u can easily make ur dewalt battery fit a harbor freight
I didn't know that. Can you go the other way too with HF batteries on DeWalt? I say because I think the Hercules batteries are better in many respects.
IMO dewalt wins easily I have a couple of Hercules 1/4 hex impact power tools which seem fine to me
it does when it comes to power. The Hercules does not have near the power when cutting, However, it does cut on the marks well and the DeWalt does not hit the marks. When cutting a 2x4 the other day the hercules stopped on me and I had to start again. Is that normal?
42:03 I have both i have not open the dewalt box yet. The hercules with a 8 ah cuts a lot of 2x4s and 3/4 plywood all day long and still have half the battery left at the end of the day. The dewalt i have is the flexvolt advantage. TTC showed it has 50% more power over the hercules. I have used the hercules every Saturday and Sunday for the last 6 months remodel 3 homes. I have worked the saw and myself hard. I am impressed by hercules. Note: my first hercules saw would stop and start, I never cut any wood. Went to HF and the gave me a new one that worked nice. The Sawzall is also impressive.
hercules is stronger with a 12a battery i test it out myself
I didn't know they had a 12AH battery. I'll have to check that out - though I'm not sure I really want the extra weight.
Hercules has a 5 yr warranty vs 3 year...and i know for a fact dewalt has severe issues with quality in tools and batteries...just go to lowes and read the amount of reviews that r horrible experiance not to mention mine
Dewalt has their share of problems for sure! I recently got the Hercules impact driver and it has quite a bit more power than my DeWalt. It also has a much brighter LED on it!
Don't buy the Hercules it sucks, And I love all my Hercules tools but not this one, the 6 1/2 inch saw is better for me
I took it on a work trip last week and it did fine for what I needed. i like that it effortlessly cuts straight, but it doesn't have the power of the DeWalt.
Hercules is a toy. Disappointed. Very warm battery=DeWalt TKO in the 3rd Rd.
Please take your gloves off when you're using spinning tools.