I recently had the pleasure of sailing on board the Queen Mary II and Roger McGuinn was on board , a great talent and a nice person his story is forever apart of our rock and roll history, The Byrds are one of the many great groups that gave us so many great memories .
@@dianesaari3034 that's nice. I have been to new York so many years ago and it's very nice there, I will love to visit again. It's also very nice and beautiful here in Denver the mountains are full of snow. Have you been to Denver before?
They are so good do miss George and Tom but still pumping it out they were all so good very good looking forward to hearing more time gone through all the best regards to them all
Neil seems to always be full of the happies once he gets going. Check him flying while singing "Helpless" with The Band on Scorceses' The Last Waltz. So much joy. EAsy to find the track here on yt.
Especially right at the end, when everyone else forgets to come in on the last line so he's laughing, singing it on his own! This is the original audio - every other version I've seen has an edit there so that all appear to join in (Bob's vocal was also re-recorded to tone down the somewhat eccentric timing you can hear in this one).
Hola, hola. Realmente sensacional. Qué afortunados quienes pudieron presenciar este concierto y deleitarse con estos genios de la música. Ellos sí que son roqueros de corazón, con letras y música maravillosa y con sentido. Gracias al universo por poderlo apreciar aunque sea a la distancia y fuera de forma extemporánea. No importa, de igual manera se disfruta y se agradece semejante actuación. Qué maravilla! Gracias a dios por poderlo disfrutar Saludos desde la ciudad de México
Perfect use of the words Than and Then. And a fair enough premise when one is getting on in years. Like Nancy Reagan once remarked, "Ronnie is not getting older, he's getting better."
syedirfanahmed6320 Hi , i totally agree w/your comment; our R&R Royalty didn't get older, they got better! -But they were ALWAYS giants - all of them ! BTW, were 3 of them The Traveling Wilburys? WE all miss Tom & George & we cannot leave out Roy Orbison !!! Hey, maybe you can help me w/ this question : there's a guitarist behind the front musicians with blonde hair , sort of a mushroom cut , blonde on top but dark in the back. He smiles alot & moves around a bit. I recognize him but don't know his name . By any chance do you?? I'm not sure, but I think he was the guitarist band lead on Sat Night Live, many years ago. Could it be G.E. Smith? Much appreciation if you could respond - especially if you know who he is. ❤ from NYC
This is the version I’ve been looking for!! At 4:19, Neil sings the chorus by himself after the solo. In all the other rereleased versions, they overdubbed the others singing the chorus, but here you can see Neil’s spontaneity on full display. It’s great!
One of Eric's strings broke during his solo, quite early on. I believe Neil's solo at the end was impromtu quick-thinking obo Clapton. I like to think also that's the reason for Tom Petty's huge grin watching it - Neil absolutely nailed it. One of my favourite Neil moments of all time
@@CRyan71 Oh! Mister Dylan, (Ele é a razão principal de ser desse momento), ele só precisa criar, e isso ele faz como nenhum outro pode fazer até então, e, isso sim é ser genial!
Incrivel ver duas lendas da guitarra no mesmo palco que eu reverencio: Neil Young e Eric Clapton! A 1ª vez que vi foi Last Waltz com a The Band! Espetacular!
So happy to find the original recording where only Neil remembered to sing the final refrain, Bob was mostly unintelligible, and Clapton messed up the lines. Much better than the more polished version with the overdubs!
I'm not a Clapton fan - too dull - but to be fair, he lost a string early on in this performance. He does a nice live duet with Bob on Born In Time - check it out it's here on yt. Again though, he fluffs the lyrics. But hey, who cares really - it's live and it's real.
Maravilha, não canso de ver. Quem compôs esta obra-prima? Quem é este último guitarrista de costeleta? Toca muito e controle, sentindo o pulso da melodia. Sou Samuel, aqui de São Paulo, capital, no Brasil.Hoje é 2 de maio de 2023, terca-feira.
A canção é linda Bob é muito bom, mas a entrada de George com sua voz arrepia até os pentelhos , além de emocionar muito o coração, ele é realmente de um planeta superior…..
La gente no aprende. En todas las épocas y en todas partes son iguales: im-bé-ci-les. Por esto mismo dejaron de actuar en público The Beatles, por el ruido, por el griterío permanente del público histérico. No saben ir a disfrutar de un espectáculo genial, tienen que estar aplaudiendo y gritando para sacar afuera su histeria.
I recently had the pleasure of sailing on board the Queen Mary II and Roger McGuinn was on board , a great talent and a nice person his story is forever apart of our rock and roll history, The Byrds are one of the many great groups that gave us so many great memories .
Besser geht nicht, einfach unglaublich, dass nennt man Musik.
Love this ♥️ miss Tom and George ♥️💔♥️
Who else could of put this group of artis together. ❤It r. I. P who has gon e long lived the 69s
Its hard to beat perfection, but this version of the song does the trick. Neil Young singing the last line is something I'd do
Wow.. another bunch of sweet fun 🌸
“I was so much older then I’m younger than that now”
Magical times❤
Wow, a whole bunch of legends all together on one stage. Certainly my generation.
Truly!
vhh
I agree. This is one hellva band!
Which one is George Harrison?
Lol!!!!!!!! @@KR-on2ry
Those cheers for George 🥰 Guitar legends. We loved them all❤️
Hello 👋 Diane. How are you doing? Hope you are fine
@@markclifford1857 Hello Mark. I'm busy uncovering my patio furniture, getting ready for summer!
@@dianesaari3034 that's nice and am so sorry you're busy. Where you are from?
Originally from Buffalo but living in Indy.
@@dianesaari3034 that's nice. I have been to new York so many years ago and it's very nice there, I will love to visit again. It's also very nice and beautiful here in Denver the mountains are full of snow. Have you been to Denver before?
What an incredible collection of musicians. This will NEVER happen again, sigh.
Why not?
@@flemingcourt Creio que é por porque, 2 deles já dormem desconectados?
@@flemingcourt Because some of them dead.
I know. Good thing we're living in the end times. We'll all meet again.
They are so good do miss George and Tom but still pumping it out they were all so good very good looking forward to hearing more time gone through all the best regards to them all
The joy on Neil's face when he sings those lines is priceless ❤🎉😊
Neil seems to always be full of the happies once he gets going. Check him flying while singing "Helpless" with The Band on Scorceses' The Last Waltz. So much joy. EAsy to find the track here on yt.
Especially right at the end, when everyone else forgets to come in on the last line so he's laughing, singing it on his own! This is the original audio - every other version I've seen has an edit there so that all appear to join in (Bob's vocal was also re-recorded to tone down the somewhat eccentric timing you can hear in this one).
That is one huge stage full of the best talent possibly ever gathered!!
I remember this performance. Just stunned thinking of all the talent. One of my few remaining jobs is to pass this love to my grandchildren.
good luck!
It's a perfect way to transmit to other generations the talent of these eternal musicians!
my generation is wonderfuul...
❤
I really miss George and Tom.
No need they are immortal! 🕉
And Donald Duck Dunn
I'm with you on that.
Their absence has created a great void in music 😢
and roy, the wilburys were amazing
Love all the legends on that stage.❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😅They make me cry every time.😂😂😂😂😢😢😢😢😅😅😅
Happy Birthday Dhani,happy anniversary of the Concert for Bangladesh ,1971,Madison Square Garden.Rock n roll can change lives for the better.
Born in 1954. Lived these guys. How can I explain how much I relate to this. I can't.
There will never be collection of rock and folk royalty like this ever again. Iconic Dylan song.
It's surprising that the stage didn't collapse under the weight of all that talent.
So much talent on that stage. Love I'm all forever.❤😂😢😊😅😮🎉❤❤❤❤
Hola, hola. Realmente sensacional. Qué afortunados quienes pudieron presenciar este concierto y deleitarse con estos genios de la música. Ellos sí que son roqueros de corazón, con letras y música maravillosa y con sentido. Gracias al universo por poderlo apreciar aunque sea a la distancia y fuera de forma extemporánea. No importa, de igual manera se disfruta y se agradece semejante actuación. Qué maravilla! Gracias a dios por poderlo disfrutar
Saludos desde la ciudad de México
São muitas lendas reunidas para um palco só: fantástico!
Nie mehr werden wir so etwas Großartiges zu sehen bekommen !
The masters at work ,Bob has written some of the greatest songs of all time love this one!
is it 500 songs?
George Harrison is, for me, the most important guy on the stage
Dylan Man!!
They are playin Dylan...
Well, good for you
It's got to be Dylan..if he didn't write it they wouldn't be singing it
Steve Cropper at the back an extremely important park of rock
I sure wish I could have been there! Great performance!
Perfect use of the words Than and Then. And a fair enough premise when one is getting on in years. Like Nancy Reagan once remarked, "Ronnie is not getting older, he's getting better."
syedirfanahmed6320 Hi , i totally agree w/your comment; our R&R Royalty didn't get older, they got better! -But they were ALWAYS giants - all of them ! BTW, were 3 of them The Traveling Wilburys? WE all miss Tom & George & we cannot leave out Roy Orbison !!! Hey, maybe you can help me w/ this question : there's a guitarist behind the front musicians with blonde hair , sort of a mushroom cut , blonde on top but dark in the back. He smiles alot & moves around a bit. I recognize him but don't know his name . By any chance do you?? I'm not sure, but I think he was the guitarist band lead on Sat Night Live, many years ago. Could it be G.E. Smith?
Much appreciation if you could respond - especially if you know who he is. ❤ from NYC
So sad that we have lost Tom and George 😥
Rock and roll royalty
Love them forever..
I have seen this a dozen times...still gives me chills when I see it...I would have given a lot to be the bass player behind this group of giants...
Who is the bass player? Thanks
This is the version I’ve been looking for!! At 4:19, Neil sings the chorus by himself after the solo. In all the other rereleased versions, they overdubbed the others singing the chorus, but here you can see Neil’s spontaneity on full display. It’s great!
I didnt know this version existed but had seen comments of people saying it did (without the overdub) - glad I found it too
I wondered about that.
An All-Star Band if ever there was one!
I love Roger, EC , & Neil playing great guitar 🎸 music ❤😂
Usually wait until after Midnight to appreciate this video.
If only we had this group back right now,,,😢😊
clapton, harrison to the left of him, young and petty to the right, oh what a sound they made, the world wonders, when will their glory fade !!!!!!!!
Surprisingly the stage didn't collapse under the weight of all that talent
So much talent~it still suspends me in AWE.😎♥
I really miss these guys, George,and Tom!!!!
@Greg Normal yes, I am a Hugh fan of theirs! I live in S C U.S.A ! I still love their music!!
Oh My! Lump in throat and tear in eye.
Awesome lineup of talent ! Great video.
They even had a Beatle 😊
Impresionante tal conjunto de genios en un escenario…bellísima interpretación de una de las mejores y más míticas canciones del maestro Dylan.
A band of ICONS
Ty for sharing😅❤
Cracking little pop song, absolutely brilliant!!😁😁🇬🇧
A Great bunch of all stars.
Harrison got the greatest applause...
As he should and should always.
WOW.....Amazing Every time I 🎶👂listen to my Back Pages....and all you Guys ❤🤲TOO....GOD BLESS 🙌you all....xxxx
The BEST!
❤ amazing combination
George, Tom eternos!!!!!!!
Best Boy Band EVER!!
Man band what a gig😊
Still loving this music xxxx
Roger McGuinn with his signature Rickenbacker 370-12. I don't think I've ever seen him play anything else.
I wish I could play guitar like these legends!
Love that Clapton guitar sound and Neil 💖
neil was terrible
Eric's brilliant guitar...the others all bow to him but he just chills at the back...
Maybe so, but he can't play a 12 string like Mcguinn.
All are special. No one rules over the others!
Exactly. All so talented, so (deservedly) loved, but all together in service of a great song. That's how art is made. @@alysiadriggers4966
Wish he hadn't flubbed his line :(
One of Eric's strings broke during his solo, quite early on. I believe Neil's solo at the end was impromtu quick-thinking obo Clapton. I like to think also that's the reason for Tom Petty's huge grin watching it - Neil absolutely nailed it. One of my favourite Neil moments of all time
The greatest generation of musicians in history. Sadly, likely to never be heard again.
Bob Dylan himself said, no one interprets my songs better than Jerry Garcia, including myself 🍄🌹🍄🇺🇲🍄🐟🍄🐟🍄🌍🍄
Love this music xxx
Mr. Smith un verdadero director en medio de estos monstruos de la música. Just leyends!!!!!!
Yayyy BABBBYY!!!!!❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😢😢😅😢😅
Magníficos ‼️👌
Exellent sir bob dylan;
I really miss Tom and George 😢
なんて贅沢な気分にさせてくれる演奏でしょうか。ヤングのあんな楽しそうな表情も珍しいと思いました。
Two greatest singers and songwriters
I agree.
Only two?
Which two do you mean?
Just wow! Musiciens !
One of the greatest ever assemblies of stars ever on stage together. Awesome.
OUTSTANDING!
This will go down in history, musical gods never to be replaced, all on one stage .
That was great miss them
The better of all times "my back pages "
Can you imagine seeing them all?
Seems they "cleaned up" the recording for release on record and video, - myself I really prefer this, - warts and all!
Can’t get any better than that.
Could if Dylan wasn't as stoned or sauced
@@CRyan71 Oh! Mister Dylan, (Ele é a razão principal de ser desse momento), ele só precisa criar, e isso ele faz como nenhum outro pode fazer até então, e, isso sim é ser genial!
@@CRyan71 Oh so what? Have you tried Peter Paul and Mary.
All great -- gives me goosebumps! Love that G.E. Smith (SNL band leader) is there directing them.
He looks in awe of Eric Clapton...😊
Loved that too!
There is mr Steve Cropper on that stage...and i wouldn't forget mr Duck Dunn
Incrivel ver duas lendas da guitarra no mesmo palco que eu reverencio: Neil Young e Eric Clapton!
A 1ª vez que vi foi Last Waltz com a The Band! Espetacular!
Too many of the GREATS are no longer with us...
So happy to find the original recording where only Neil remembered to sing the final refrain, Bob was mostly unintelligible, and Clapton messed up the lines. Much better than the more polished version with the overdubs!
Having so many people on stage will always be chaos.. but man is it glorious chaos
@@jnm92 That's why you play live. It's the only time you can have fun.
@@soaringvultureexactly!
I'm not a Clapton fan - too dull - but to be fair, he lost a string early on in this performance. He does a nice live duet with Bob on Born In Time - check it out it's here on yt. Again though, he fluffs the lyrics. But hey, who cares really - it's live and it's real.
Awesome!
GRANDIOSO, PUROS GENIOS Y HÉROES DE LA GUITARRA
Wow what could be better love it
Just the best Byrds song by a group of pretty good guitarists…..
Esse show de estrelas foi em homenagem aos 30 anos de carreira de Bob Dylan, no Madson Square Garden, em1992! Bobfest, segundo Neil Young!😅
Puras estrellas roqueras ,lo mejor de lo mejor 🎉🎉🎉🎉
The Best amazing wanderful
Maravilha, não canso de ver. Quem compôs esta obra-prima? Quem é este último guitarrista de costeleta? Toca muito e controle, sentindo o pulso da melodia. Sou Samuel, aqui de São Paulo, capital, no Brasil.Hoje é 2 de maio de 2023, terca-feira.
A música é do Bob Dylan. O último guitarrista é o Neil Young
Dylan escreveu isso no início de sua carreira. [usando o Google Tradutor, espero que [faça sentido!]
Quanta gente talentosa junta. Bons tempos.
Awesome
I miss Tom so much! ❤
Is that Steve Cropper ?
yes it is - thanks for mentioning him
Is that Steve Cropper in the wild shirt in the background as well..
Love!!
My god they are well missed
George es el número uno , que vos 😢
They all look up to Bob Dylan who wrote the song in 1964 - one song out of more than 500.
The young solo is fantastic
Agreed
I can't wait to get to that part. When I first heard 'Over and Over', I was floored.
what neil is and was terrible EC is god as they sat
@@bluetocopOh stoppit.. EC is a bore.
And deservedly so, G.E. Smith is playing with these Gods.
Love how Neil Young plays lead, he looks like he's wrestling with the guitar to get the good notes out. lol.
Wrestling. Good way to put it. Neal is one of a kind.
Great analogy. Yup, and check Tom looking on grinning. Love Neil.
A canção é linda Bob é muito bom, mas a entrada de George com sua voz arrepia até os pentelhos , além de emocionar muito o coração, ele é realmente de um planeta superior…..
Me too. George Harrison was and is far superior than we mere humans! I miss him so much. My Hero George! 💙 🙏🏽 💙
👏👏👍
La gente no aprende. En todas las épocas y en todas partes son iguales: im-bé-ci-les.
Por esto mismo dejaron de actuar en público The Beatles, por el ruido, por el griterío permanente del público histérico.
No saben ir a disfrutar de un espectáculo genial, tienen que estar aplaudiendo y gritando para sacar afuera su histeria.