Well when any modern musicians have the history, followers, hit songs, as these people get them together and sing a Taylor Swift song and see if anyone says things about them like these comments 🎸🎸🎸🎸🥁🥁🥁🎤🎤🎤🎤🎼🎼🎼
What is so great to see is that is just like ANY band practice I've ever participated in. Guitars noodling in the background, no one can get everyone's attention, etc . Even the masters are like the rest of us!
G.E. Smith!!! Can't really imagine anybody else with the personality and skill/talent to direct this powerhouse room/stage.... not to mention the personal credibility as a musician.
I love live music, I like the sound of guitars, it takes me back to the 70s, 80s, when I heard it for the first time. Thank you for sharing this beautiful memory!
Everybody having their say while his Bobness quietly sticks to himself most of the time. It's all about his song and he's blending in like it's no big deal!
Lots of history on this stand, Georges talking to Roger, Eric in the back ,Bob getting in tune, awsome sight, it,s the musical history of my past sixtie years, unforgettable moment, I,d like to freeze it in time for posterity.
@tenparab ~ At 1:48, talking to Clapton, is G.E. Smith who was the musical director of Dylan's 30th Anniversary Concert. Smith was, at one time, the lead gutiar player for Hall & Oates and also played lead gutiar in Dylan's 1988-1990 touring band. From 1980-82 he was married to the late Gilda Radner. Smith was also, at one time, the musical director for Saturday Night Live.
Thank God somebody was smart enough to film this. This many heroes In one room. Just being there self. Don't know what we would have done Without Them ?
During the Live performance, GE was hoping around like a cat on a tin roof. Pointing, nudging, reminding each performer when it was their turn to step up. Nerve wracking!!!
What a f***ing unbelievable cast of musical icons! G E Smith is my new hero - what magician he was to get that crew to perform to a T. How did I miss that concert?
Que maravilha tanta genialidade junta. Trata-se realmente de uma constelação primorosa e bela. Um dos meus sonhos, não possível mais, pois o nosso saudoso gênio GEORGE HARRISON, o mais agregador e brilhante compositor já não está entre nós, seria ve-los juntos novamente em memorável apresentação. CONCERT FOR GEORGE HARRISON foi uma emocionante e brilhante homenagem ao nosso saudoso ídolo, mas infelizmente por razões que desconheço alguns participantes deste show não estiveram presentes.
Soviele begnadete großartige Musiker. Ich kann es mir unglaublich oft anhören und meine Begeisterung wächst ständig! Einige sind viel zu früh gestorben!
Just a funny note, Rodger Mc Guinn was turned on to the Rick 12 when he and his Byrd mates went to see George Harrison in The Beatles movie A Hard Days Night. George was playing the Rick 12.
Everyone gives Clapton the "heads up" when it comes to THE gutiar player of the group but McGuinn can make that 12 string electric Rickenbacker come to life AND Neil Young is just outstanding as well. What I wouldn't give to have these guys sitting around in my living room, drinking brews and smoking a few while playing their musical instrument of choice. The landscape of my youth included every one of these guys and I'm hoping Dylan does it again in 2012 to celebrate 50 years.
Bob worked nonstop for four days & nights making it come together. It was his tribute concert so he could have just relaxed and done his set but no, he chased perfection as ever. The mark of the man.
But if you ever see an unedited version of the performance, you'll notice how slurred his singing truly was for this song. Almost all of the available versions are edited and his voice is dubbed and you can't see his lips move.on the rare occasions when his face is shown.
@@gr1629 . How did you come upon this info? Can you reference something? If this is so, that's something worth knowing those of us who are interested in Dylan.
Yes, but you left out Tom Petty & Eric. Add Roy Orbison & you've got The Traveling Wilbury's! How did I ever miss THEIR tour?!? Only Dylin lives on and plays now . . .
Could this be a vision of "rock star heaven"? Dylan's lyrics are so abstract that everyone needs to read off the page. Dylan's original recording of MBP was a waltz.
We've played this Song and others with our Band, I cry for this time. Many Songs: Mr. Tambourine Man, All I really want to do, Why, My Back Pages, Turn, Turn, Turn, Eight miles high, 😢😢😢😢
@ronatholl ~ Yes your correct, Tom Petty is playing a 12 string acoustic gutiar while Roger McGuinn (in black, leading off the singing @ 2:17) is playing the gutiar that created the trademark signature sound of the Byrds in the 1960's; his Rickenbacker 12 string electric gutiar.
Look at Eddie Vedder in the background @7:45 🤯 A room of incredible musicians!! Eddie did an incredible job singing "MASTERS OF WAR" THIS IS AWESOME VIDEO!! THANK YOU FOR SHARING THIS AWESOME VIDEO 😊 🩷 🤘✌️
Roger McGuinn, is the senior member of this group and can still teach all of them some lessons. Without that jangly Rick, and his arrangement of this song for the Byrds, it would never have sounded so good on stage for this group.
Coincido contigo, MrCostanica. George tenía un gran espíritu, un gran corazón, y eso le valió tener como amigos a muchos de los más grandes músicos de rock en la historia de este mundo. John era un rebelde, un inconforme con la sociedad, con lo establecido, y así lo plasmó en muchas de las letras de sus canciones. Paul siempre compuso más pensando en el bolsillo que en otra cosa. Y Ringo... bueno pues Ringo era Ringo.
@MsAnnestube Hi..here's a little background on the Wilburys...they formed in 1988, 5 years before this clip was shot. George Harrison, Bob Dylan, Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty and Roy Orbison comprised the band. Together with Jim Keltner, they recorded a song for the B side of a Harrison single. In May of 1988, they made their first album which was released in October 1988. Tragically, a few weeks after the albums release, Orbison died of a heart attack.
It's sooo sad to think that in today's music industry ... you put bieber gaga kesha katie perry and others on stage people would freak out saying omg this is amazing but no no ... THIS IS AMAZING!!!!!
Look at all my heroes... They kinda made me who I am. So many passed on- the rest are elderly men- they weren't immune to time. Wouldve loved to be in that room!
Both Eric and Neil riffed their hearts out in the concert. My theory is that we will have to make do with 'unofficial' clips for some time. As soon as 'Dylan's Nobel prize for literature 2016 wsa announced, all 'official' versions of his music disappeared like lightening. He's in a different place now, all gone to a higher place.
IALL of them were/are great musicians and all of them admired and respected eachother's work and secretly wished they'd written at least 1 song 1 of the others had written! Luckily they were all good friedns and able to put aside all their egos and fame to form one amazing tribute to Bob Dylan as well as participate in many other little get togethers/jamsover the years.
@azzaboi93 ~ Didn't I notice George Harrison? I was 17 years old when the Beatles made their 1st appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show in February of 1964. I owned every single Beatles' record album ever recorded, saw every Beatles' movie (Hard Day's Night, Help, Yellow Submarine, Magical Mystery Tour and Let It Be), attended their 1966 concert at Dodger Stadium in L.A., bought my 1st Beatles' 45 RPM record in early February '64 and grew up with them. Did I notice him? Kinda.
Me too, ditto to everything you said except I was 7 when They made their first appearance on Ed Sullivan..whole family glued to the tv. Hopefully you saw the clip of this at the real concert..George was very noticeable, he closed out the song doing the last verse and got the biggest ovation of all..It's here on UA-cam, I'm sure you've seen it. So incredible! I can watch it every day and not get tired of It! Cheers 😎
It's funny watching this because Clapton didn't look like he knew if he was suppose to sing at the rehearsal or at the event. Maybe Dylan just wanted to stand at the mic and confuse him twice.
The evolution of Claptons solo from this- to what was live... is remarkable. My second favorite solo of his after crossroads.
You'll never ever see that much talent in one room again.
Well when any modern musicians have the history, followers, hit songs, as these people get them together and sing a Taylor Swift song and see if anyone says things about them like these comments 🎸🎸🎸🎸🥁🥁🥁🎤🎤🎤🎤🎼🎼🎼
hug?@@artmchugh5644
Bob Dylan and Eric Clapton very talented the others just famous but average musicians.
never
Oh my God!!! My favorites Bob and George!!! Also Roger McGuinn and Tom Petty. Amazing!!!!
What is so great to see is that is just like ANY band practice I've ever participated in. Guitars noodling in the background, no one can get everyone's attention, etc . Even the masters are like the rest of us!
LOLROTF! Great description!
I've always loved Roger playing the Rickenbacker 😂🎉
Neil's solo is pure bliss.
G.E. Smith!!! Can't really imagine anybody else with the personality and skill/talent to direct this powerhouse room/stage.... not to mention the personal credibility as a musician.
So much talent on the stage, it,s a piece of history,
I love live music, I like the sound of guitars, it takes me back to the 70s, 80s, when I heard it for the first time. Thank you for sharing this beautiful memory!
Everybody having their say while his Bobness quietly sticks to himself most of the time. It's all about his song and he's blending in like it's no big deal!
Bob's a Gemini born on the cusp May 24 1941, that's who they are.😎
This is so cool, seeing American and British musical royalty getting together and having fun.
And Canadian royalty too...
Neil Young is Canadian eh! 🇨🇦
@@mrdave4714 right, I left out Neil, One of Canada's best...
Eric clean and sober drinking tea God bless him for getting clean and still being a badass guitar
Unfortunately, he messed up the lyrics in the live performance.
The heroes of my youth and my life, indescribable…
the sound quality but seeing all this legendary talent in one room singing one of my favorite dylan songs is simply amazing, incredible footage.
George still as cute as ever. I always think back to when he was that 15 year old kid auditioning for the Quarrymen.
How much talent together, my God.
Lots of history on this stand, Georges talking to Roger, Eric in the back ,Bob getting in tune, awsome sight, it,s the musical history of my past sixtie years, unforgettable moment, I,d like to freeze it in time for posterity.
Soo sorry, forgot Neal, Tom.
I know, amazing!!!
@tenparab ~ At 1:48, talking to Clapton, is G.E. Smith who was the musical director of Dylan's 30th Anniversary Concert. Smith was, at one time, the lead gutiar player for Hall & Oates and also played lead gutiar in Dylan's 1988-1990 touring band. From 1980-82 he was married to the late Gilda Radner. Smith was also, at one time, the musical director for Saturday Night Live.
Thanks. I had wondered who he was.
@@terrirozell9608 Ok thank you. i just wondered, Who this guy is.
Cool!cheers for the valued info!🌈🤗
Thank you for these details ~ knowing this stuff makes make life better! Ty!
Can anyone recognize what guitar he's playing here?
Hey Guys, don't forget Steve Cropper in the background carrying the rhythm as usual.
And Duck Dunn on bass
Always the folks you could count on. Saw them w Booker T w CSNY. “ Man, this the Blues Brothers!
Thank God somebody was smart enough to film this. This many heroes In one room. Just being there self. Don't know what we would have done Without Them ?
I love George!
so am i he is my spirit freind
Ever try to herd cats? GE Smith had his hands full. They did manage to pull it off!
Well put!
GE Smith is a legend! 👍🎸
😊😊😊 4:12 u😅i 4:12
During the Live performance, GE was hoping around like a cat on a tin roof. Pointing, nudging, reminding each performer when it was their turn to step up. Nerve wracking!!!
What a f***ing unbelievable cast of musical icons! G E Smith is my new hero - what magician he was to get that crew to perform to a T. How did I miss that concert?
Che meraviglia,da ascoltare ed immedesimarsi nella melodia e nel ritmo.!!
Que maravilha tanta genialidade junta. Trata-se realmente de uma constelação primorosa e bela. Um dos meus sonhos, não possível mais, pois o nosso saudoso gênio GEORGE HARRISON, o mais agregador e brilhante compositor já não está entre nós, seria ve-los juntos novamente em memorável apresentação. CONCERT FOR GEORGE HARRISON foi uma emocionante e brilhante homenagem ao nosso saudoso ídolo, mas infelizmente por razões que desconheço alguns participantes deste show não estiveram presentes.
Soviele begnadete großartige Musiker. Ich kann es mir unglaublich oft anhören und meine Begeisterung wächst ständig!
Einige sind viel zu früh gestorben!
Just a funny note, Rodger Mc Guinn was turned on to the Rick 12 when he and his Byrd mates went to see George Harrison in The Beatles movie A Hard Days Night. George was playing the Rick 12.
Jim drumming is just right. No silly fills just the beat.
Everyone gives Clapton the "heads up" when it comes to THE gutiar player of the group but McGuinn can make that 12 string electric Rickenbacker come to life AND Neil Young is just outstanding as well. What I wouldn't give to have these guys sitting around in my living room, drinking brews and smoking a few while playing their musical instrument of choice. The landscape of my youth included every one of these guys and I'm hoping Dylan does it again in 2012 to celebrate 50 years.
Just SO much talent there
Agree re Roger. Great My Back Pages was the. byrds version
@@blissy1 Not just talent...absolute legends.
Chi fa musica così,ha una marcia in più, c'è poco da fare. Wonderful.!
Bob worked nonstop for four days & nights making it come together. It was his tribute concert so he could have just relaxed and done his set but no, he chased perfection as ever. The mark of the man.
But if you ever see an unedited version of the performance, you'll notice how slurred his singing truly was for this song. Almost all of the available versions are edited and his voice is dubbed and you can't see his lips move.on the rare occasions when his face is shown.
@@gr1629 . How did you come upon this info? Can you reference something? If this is so, that's something worth knowing those of us who are interested in Dylan.
Trust me ive watched the live version over and over for the last yearand my god he managed it soooooo well, this is the best song ive ever heard
Dylan...Harrison...old soulmates. Their relationship went back to the mid 60's.
There was lots of stuff on that in the press at that time. Before Rolling Stone mag. And Jan the wiener.
Yes, but you left out Tom Petty & Eric. Add Roy Orbison & you've got The Traveling Wilbury's! How did I ever miss THEIR tour?!? Only Dylin lives on and plays now . . .
@@Bullwhipseb7
The Traveling Wilburys never toured. Did you say Eric Clapton was in that supergroup? He wasn't.
Look at Neil! He's got those cool clothes on even for this rehearsal. Everybody's got sweatpants, etc. and Neil's all decked out.
No no no Eric looks like a distinguished geography teacher...
All decked out in his Canada clothes
@@karendurant4981 c'mon eric & niel are fabulous! no bullshittin'
Talented guys!
Neil young's fabulous!
SO fabulous to hear and see thx ❤❤❤
Wow!!!!! Thank you for posting this gem!!!!!
Dylan is the only musician in history to win the Nobel Prize for literature.
Hilarious! Roses smell great, so rose soup must be terrific. Needs more Steve Cropper.
They are rehearsing. Fabulous!!!!!!
Meu Deus, só a nata, esses solos de Eric Clapton e Neil Young não tem preço, demais...
yeah watching this theres so many awesome faces.. some long gone.. may they all rest in peace..
So many great artists there but Clapton is just the best
the reason he played so much with Mark.........even he can play second fiddle to Knopfler
Could this be a vision of "rock star heaven"? Dylan's lyrics are so abstract that everyone needs to read off the page. Dylan's original recording of MBP was a waltz.
We've played this Song and others with our Band, I cry for this time. Many Songs: Mr. Tambourine Man, All I really want to do, Why, My Back Pages, Turn, Turn, Turn, Eight miles high, 😢😢😢😢
Bob Dylan , George Harrison, Neil young, Eric Clapton y Tom Petty ensayando back pages ...gran video historico ! Amazing document
Saludos desde Peru
.... and Mr Steve Cropper for good measure...
@@jamesmeakin7673 and whose in green sitting drums stage right? On guitar.
@ronatholl ~ Yes your correct, Tom Petty is playing a 12 string acoustic gutiar while Roger McGuinn (in black, leading off the singing @ 2:17) is playing the gutiar that created the trademark signature sound of the Byrds in the 1960's; his Rickenbacker 12 string electric gutiar.
Love this SO much.
eric clapton a gentleman yields and smiles for acceptance from the great DYLAN
The best of the best. AWSOME!!!! It cant cant much better than that!
It all come together on the night…and it’s amazing
Great to see these 1st class artistes muddling into a perfect rehearsal.
Look at Eddie Vedder in the background @7:45 🤯 A room of incredible musicians!! Eddie did an incredible job singing "MASTERS OF WAR" THIS IS AWESOME VIDEO!! THANK YOU FOR SHARING THIS AWESOME VIDEO 😊 🩷 🤘✌️
Wow to see these guys like this is just fabulous, but can't hear them sing here.
solo los mejores, muy buena cancion.
Love it G.E bandleader
Legends in the room .
lo mejor de lo mejor....
Clapton is the world's best guitarist without a doubt!
He's my Guitar Hero of all time
Rodger McGuinn best ever and I'm a Clapton fan.
Roger McGuinn, is the senior member of this group and can still teach all of them some lessons. Without that jangly Rick, and his arrangement of this song for the Byrds, it would never have sounded so good on stage for this group.
One of them
Look omg wow so so wow, Nice too wow .
Wow awesome.....
Grandioso!!!!!!
Coincido contigo, MrCostanica. George tenía un gran espíritu, un gran corazón, y eso le valió tener como amigos a muchos de los más grandes músicos de rock en la historia de este mundo. John era un rebelde, un inconforme con la sociedad, con lo establecido, y así lo plasmó en muchas de las letras de sus canciones. Paul siempre compuso más pensando en el bolsillo que en otra cosa. Y Ringo... bueno pues Ringo era Ringo.
BRILLIAN!!!!
Increíble, en los 60s cada uno construyendo su propia historia y unos eran ídolos de otros y hoy juntos cantando esta bella canción
La música no tiene fronteras
Tremendo todo esto .....🙏🎹🎼🎶🎸🔥♥️....abrazo grande querido GEORGE ...DONDE ESTES ♥️ DESDE ARGENTINA 🇦🇷✌️
@MsAnnestube Hi..here's a little background on the Wilburys...they formed in 1988, 5 years before this clip was shot. George Harrison, Bob Dylan, Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty and Roy Orbison comprised the band. Together with Jim Keltner, they recorded a song for the B side of a Harrison single. In May of 1988, they made their first album which was released in October 1988. Tragically, a few weeks after the albums release, Orbison died of a heart attack.
It's sooo sad to think that in today's music industry ... you put bieber gaga kesha katie perry and others on stage people would freak out saying omg this is amazing but no no ... THIS IS AMAZING!!!!!
Look at all my heroes...
They kinda made me who I am.
So many passed on- the rest are elderly men- they weren't immune to time.
Wouldve loved to be in that room!
FANTASTIC ......... Luji-TAMÁSI
i wish i was a fly on the wall
really awsm vid tnx 4 uploading it
Constelation of the stars!!!!!
Both Eric and Neil riffed their hearts out in the concert. My theory is that we will have to make do with 'unofficial' clips for some time. As soon as 'Dylan's Nobel prize for literature 2016 wsa announced, all 'official' versions of his music disappeared like lightening. He's in a different place now, all gone to a higher place.
You didn't need to worry. He is with "those who travelled with him".
IALL of them were/are great musicians and all of them admired and respected eachother's work and secretly wished they'd written at least 1 song 1 of the others had written! Luckily they were all good friedns and able to put aside all their egos and fame to form one amazing tribute to Bob Dylan as well as participate in many other little get togethers/jamsover the years.
cheers lad , yes turn turn turn was Mc Guiness classic 12 string really rang out
dude u are AWESOME, yes it's still there ..
I love them all
SO AWESOME!!!!!!
Watch how GE Smith organizes everyone
QUE MARAVILHA, TODOS ESSES CARAS JUNTOS,IMAGINA SE ESTIVESSE TBM, LENNON, MICK JAGGER,CHUC BERRY,QUE LOUCURA!!!!!!!!!
legends all of them
There's some really good not-so-humble rhythm guitar going on here
@azzaboi93 ~ Didn't I notice George Harrison? I was 17 years old when the Beatles made their 1st appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show in February of 1964. I owned every single Beatles' record album ever recorded, saw every Beatles' movie (Hard Day's Night, Help, Yellow Submarine, Magical Mystery Tour and Let It Be), attended their 1966 concert at Dodger Stadium in L.A., bought my 1st Beatles' 45 RPM record in early February '64 and grew up with them. Did I notice him? Kinda.
Me too, ditto to everything you said except I was 7 when They made their first appearance on Ed Sullivan..whole family glued to the tv. Hopefully you saw the clip of this at the real concert..George was very noticeable, he closed out the song doing the last verse and got the biggest ovation of all..It's here on UA-cam, I'm sure you've seen it. So incredible! I can watch it every day and not get tired of It! Cheers 😎
Gods walking amongst us
he just can't stand such direct adoration. give the man a beer, and i'll have some too
Amazing.
George Harrison,wow!
Man, this is priceless
Time is a blink of an eye 😩
Muiiiiiiiiit0 bom, dimais!
OMG... The best. ..
Sound of a generation
Love this
😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖 que no daria yo pero dare gracias gracias gracias por lo vivido en aquel lugar gracias DIOS mio asi lo hare hasta cerrar mis ojos
It's funny watching this because Clapton didn't look like he knew if he was suppose to sing at the rehearsal or at the event. Maybe Dylan just wanted to stand at the mic and confuse him twice.
hey, you do it live the way you did at rehearsal
Thank you!
Eric what speed precision power.the fuckin best all time can do anything.genetics.talent.
Great guy.humble.
haha, Bobby....good one!
Neil is the coolest!!!
Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton, Bob Dylan, George Harrison (em que a ordem).
Creo que Harrison fue el beatle que tuvo mas amigos musicos,talvez era el mas amigable y cercano a los demas
facinating