BORDER BREXIT BERWICK

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 лис 2016
  • Brexiteers aim to control and preferably prevent the movement of ‘outsiders’ to Britain, including those from mainland Europe. State borders are the principal foci imposing such control. However, the Scottish Government is opposed to Brexit and is campaigning for Scotland to remain in the European Union. That places a Brexit hard bordering spotlight on Berwick-upon-Tweed which is on the border between England and Scotland. It couldn’t happen here, could it?
    MUSIC: The Front - Conor Walsh
    conorwalsh.bandcamp.com/
    Produced and Directed: Gavin Turnbull
    www.gtmp.tv

КОМЕНТАРІ • 47

  • @brexitandbordering5671
    @brexitandbordering5671  4 роки тому

    In 2007 we made a film about the Irish Border, broadcast on RTE, here it is now available to view - ua-cam.com/video/UoWEJUSbMYE/v-deo.html

    • @no15minutecities
      @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

      you need to be more accurate instead of promoting woke rubbish Paddy. PS Northern Ireland is BRITISH!

  • @marmal320
    @marmal320 4 роки тому +22

    The accent really is a mix of Scottish and Geordie. Berwick looks like a Scottish town but it’s in England. Unique.

    • @220773
      @220773 3 роки тому +3

      It's much more Scottish. The only true English part is how they pronounce their 'r's.

    • @dvidclapperton
      @dvidclapperton 2 роки тому

      It's barely south of Glasgow.

    • @drrd4127
      @drrd4127 Рік тому

      Because it was actually a Scottish town but Scotland gave up the town as part of the Scottish independence treaty of Robert Bruce era.

  • @AL0129
    @AL0129 5 років тому +35

    Who’s here from jay foreman

  • @DrSpooglemon
    @DrSpooglemon 4 роки тому +9

    The Berwick accent sounds like they are half way between Edinburgh and Newcastle. In fact, they actually ARE half way between Edinburgh and Newcastle. National identity is just a fiction we tell ourselves. If the people of Berwick are English, indeed if Jordies are English, then so am I. I'm from Falkirk, BTW. And I do support Scottish independence but not out of nationalism but because I want to break away from Westminster rule. I think England needs independence too. From Westminster.

    • @karlosdeevs
      @karlosdeevs 3 роки тому

      do ya mean more autonomy for places in england beyond london, like say several parts of the north, cornwall-devon or east anglia

    • @220773
      @220773 3 роки тому

      It's much more Scottish. The only true English part is how they pronounce their 'r's.

    • @no15minutecities
      @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

      BRITISH

  • @kieranmowatt1952
    @kieranmowatt1952 5 років тому +5

    Strange place Berwick they are kind of in a state of limbo they don’t know what they are but no matter what it’s one of the nicest places in Britain

  • @Fernandwinnie
    @Fernandwinnie 3 роки тому +1

    There are people in Northern Ireland who describe them selves as British.

  • @Theodorus5
    @Theodorus5 4 роки тому

    Came here from Maximilien Robespierre‘a channel :) great video. Would like to see more interviews with Berwickers

  • @MrMikepresley
    @MrMikepresley 3 роки тому +1

    I have past relatives from Berwick, and I grew up confused as to what nationality they were, (last name Riley), some said they were Irish, some said Scottish, then I find out Berwick is in England, very confusing what to tell the outsider what it is.

  • @grahamfleming8139
    @grahamfleming8139 2 роки тому +1

    We are a Scottish toun in England ,its time tae gan hame.

  • @noxiousdow
    @noxiousdow 4 місяці тому

    I'm from a few miles further south towards Alnwick, where the accent is not quite 'true' Geordie either but somewhere between Newcastle and Berwick. My dad is from the border so his accent is a bit more like the guy in the video. As commenters have pointed out, this guy's Berwick accent really is like a hybrid of Scottish and English. The best way I can describe it is what you'd get if a Geordie went to live for half his life up in Edinburgh. The Scottish comes out in his dark 'l's which you can hear in "I couldn't tell ye"; the tenser, shorter 'oo' in "soon/could/two/look/do" and 'ee' in "see/seem/mean/me"; and the grammar - Berwickers are more likely to say "a'm no..." and "a dinnae" whereas Alnwickers tend towards "a'm not" and "a divvent". The Geordie comes out in his glottalised p and k in "proPaganda" and "BerwicKer"; some of the wider diphthongs, especially the 'ua' in "purely" and the 'ai' and 'ow' in "Eyemouth" and "now"; and most noticeably the lack of rhotic 'r' in "border" and "Dunbar". When you are from this area, the border isn't that meaningful as many people have relatives on both sides of the Tweed and you're to-ing and fro-ing across the border all the time.

  • @Fernandwinnie
    @Fernandwinnie 3 роки тому +1

    Remember March 30th. 1296. 😩

  • @220773
    @220773 3 роки тому +1

    Ulsterman on tour in Berwick?

  • @Aritro77
    @Aritro77 2 роки тому

    The lady he interviewed first surely had a Scottish accent from living? Sounded a lot less Geordie-infused than the other guy interviewed

  • @220773
    @220773 3 роки тому

    This accent is a Scottish one on the whole, with the exception of 1) the 'ow' pronunciation (words like 'down') and 2) how they pronounce their 'r's: they don't pronounce them in front of consonants and at the end of words, just like they do down in Northumbria. I'm a Scot, by the way.

    • @MegaUsaname
      @MegaUsaname 2 роки тому

      Hmm I’m a Geordie and I can hear a lot more vowels that sound Northumbrian than just that, plus words from the dialect too

    • @220773
      @220773 2 роки тому

      @@MegaUsaname I still feel the 'music' of this accent is predominantly Scottish. The 'oo's are Scottish, not the typical North-eastern 'oo' sound. The 'L' sound is Scottish, not the 'hard L' of Geordieland. The 'r's are all Northumbrian, the 'ow' dipthong is Northumbrian.

  • @wonjubhoy
    @wonjubhoy 7 років тому +5

    I call it South Berwick.

    • @no15minutecities
      @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

      No, that's Tweedmouth....look at a map and learn.

  • @FAMEROB
    @FAMEROB 2 роки тому

    someone has to be on the border

  • @WizzardJC
    @WizzardJC 4 роки тому +6

    "Aye ah see Mahsel as Eynglish" -Random Berwicker 2016

    • @bjornhattan6026
      @bjornhattan6026 3 роки тому

      People sound like that in a lot of Northumberland to be fair, that guy sounded very much english to this Geordie

  • @gtmp4516
    @gtmp4516 4 роки тому

    In 2007 Cathal and I made a film about the Irish Border, it is now available to view here - ua-cam.com/video/UoWEJUSbMYE/v-deo.html

  • @douglaspotoksky1167
    @douglaspotoksky1167 6 років тому +3

    Thanks for this David! A lot of folks are really happy about this movie being made. I live in USA. But my soul is pure Scottish!!! I would tell you more. But you will not believe me!!!

  • @no15minutecities
    @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

    Britain must remain UNIFIED!

  • @craighobbs3708
    @craighobbs3708 4 роки тому +5

    It seems that you were stirring trouble when it wasn’t needed. Trying to stir anti Scottish- English sentiment when, quite frankly, it doesn’t exist

    • @daviddixon286
      @daviddixon286 4 роки тому +1

      Yes it does and I for one cannot wait for a war.

    • @hobbabobba7912
      @hobbabobba7912 3 роки тому +1

      @@daviddixon286 not even a contest

    • @no15minutecities
      @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

      Well said, Berwick is BRITISH.

    • @no15minutecities
      @no15minutecities 2 роки тому +1

      @@daviddixon286 wait forever

    • @daviddixon286
      @daviddixon286 2 роки тому

      @@no15minutecities always English. A proper country not a colony.